The URL can be used to link to this page

03/22/2011 - Work Session - Minutes PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH WORK SESSION TUESDAY, MARCH 22, 2011 The City Council met in Work Session on Tuesday, March 22, 2011, at 3 : 00 p.m. in Room 326, City Council Office, City County Building, 451 South State Street . In Attendance : Council Members Carlton Christensen, Stan Penfold, Soren Simonsen, JT Martin, Luke Garrott, Jill Remington Love and Van Turner. Also In Attendance: Cindy Gust-Jenson, Executive Council Director; John LaPlante, Professional Traffic Operations Engineer and Director of Traffic Engineering for T.Y. Lin International; Michael Ronkin, Principal Designing Streets for Pedestrians and Bicyclists; Frank Gray, Community and Economic Development Director; Doug Dansie; Senior Planner; Wilford Sommerkorn, Planning Division Director; Russell Weeks, Council Policy Analyst; Dan Bergenthal, Trails Coordinator; Gina Chamness, Budget Director; Vicki Bennett, Director of the Office of Sustainability and Environment; Rick Graham, Public Services Director; Lehua Weaver, Council Research and Policy Analyst; Debbie Lyons, Recycling Programs Manager; and Beverly Jones, Deputy City Recorder. Councilmember Love presided at and conducted the meeting. The meeting was called to order at 3 : 09 p.m. AGENDA ITEMS #1. REPORT OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, INCLUDING A REVIEW OF COUNCIL INFORMATION ITEMS AND 3 : 09 : 11 PM ANNOUNCEMENTS. See File M 11-5 for announcements. #2 . 3 : 23 : 00 PM RECEIVE A PRESENTATION FROM JOHN N. LAPLANTE, P.E. (PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER) , P.T.O.E. (PROFESSIONAL TRAFFIC OPERATIONS ENGINEER) , DIRECTOR OF TRAFFIC ENGINEERING FOR T.Y. LIN INTERNATIONAL, ON BEHALF OF SALT LAKE COUNTY IN PARTNERSHIP WITH SALT LAKE CITY' S TRANSPORTATION DIVISION REGARDING COMPLETE STREETS EFFORTS IN SALT LAKE CITY. THE PRESENTATION WILL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: • COMMENTARY ON THE COMPLETE STREETS ORDINANCE ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL • WHAT ELECTED LEADERSHIP SHOULD CONSIDER DOING TO MAXIMIZE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE COMPLETE STREETS PHILOSOPHY • HOW BEST TO INCORPORATE/VIEW FUNDING PRIORITIES THROUGH A COMPLETE STREETS LENS • CITIES THAT IMPLEMENT COMPLETE STREETS PARTICULARLY WELL THAT SALT LAKE CITY CAN EMULATE 11 - 1 PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH WORK SESSION TUESDAY, MARCH 22, 2011 • BEST PRACTICES FOR SETTING OF GOALS/USE OF INDICATORS FOR COMPLETE STREETS/METRICS USED ELSEWHERE THAT CAN BE APPLIED TO SALT LAKE CITY • BENEFIT/COST INFORMATION PERTAINING TO COMPLETE STREETS • DISCUSSION OF THE VARIOUS STEPS NEEDED TO IMPLEMENT COMPLETE STREETS John LaPlante and Michael Ronkin briefed the Council with a power point presentation. #3 . 4 : 52 :46 PM RECEIVE A BRIEFING REGARDING AN ORDINANCE CHANGING THE CITY' S ZONING REGULATIONS TO PROHIBIT NEW ELECTRONIC BILLBOARDS AND REGULATE CHANGING EXISTING BILLBOARDS TO AN ELECTRONIC FORMAT PURSUANT TO PETITION NO. PLNPCM2010-000717 . (RELATED PROVISIONS OF TITLE 21A - ZONING MAY ALSO BE AMENDED AS PART OF THIS PETITION. MAYOR RALPH BECKER) View Attachments Frank Gray, Doug Dansie and Wilf Sommerkorn briefed the Council from the attached handouts. Councilmember Love said the Council should hold a discussion with the School Board on electronic signs . She said the Council would hold a hearing on April 5, 2011 . #4 . 5: 17 : 00 PM RECEIVE A BRIEFING REGARDING AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTIONS 12 . 56.205 AND 12 .56.550, SALT LAKE CITY CODE, DEFINING ELECTRIC VEHICLES CHARGING STATIONS, LIMITING THEIR USE TO ELECTRIC VEHICLES BEING ACTIVELY CHARGED, IMPOSING A LIMIT FOR USE AND ESTABLISHING A CIVIL PENALTY FOR VIOLATIONS. View Attachments Russell Weeks and Dan Bergenthal briefed the Council from the attached handouts . Councilmember Love said this item would be placed on Unfinished Business on the agenda. She said no public hearing would be held. #5. 5: 29 : 36 PM RECEIVE A BUDGET PRESENTATION FROM THE ADMINISTRATION, INCLUDING A REPORT ON REVENUES FOR THE CURRENT FISCAL YEAR AND A PREVIEW OF REVENUES AND THE OVERALL BUDGET FOR FISCAL YEAR 2011-12 . Gina Chamness briefed the Council from a power point presentation and the attached handout . #6. 5 : 54 :20 PM A BRIEFING REGARDING THE STATUS OF THE REFUSE FUND BUDGET, RECYCLING PROGRAM CHANGES AND OTHER RELATED UPDATES. View Attachments Vicki Bennett, Rick Graham, Lehua Weaver and Debbie Lyons briefed 11 - 2 PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH WORK SESSION TUESDAY, MARCH 22, 2011 the Council from the attached handouts . #7 . DISCUSS PRIORITIES FOR 2011 AS A FOLLOW-UP TO THEIR RETREAT. DISCUSSION COULD INCLUDE ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING: View Attachments • SUSTAINABILITY • 9:27 :27 PM MAXIMIZING CITY RESOURCES • CITY'S BENEFITS PLAN DEFICIT AND FUTURE PLANNING • COUNCIL COMMUNICATION EFFORTS AND PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT • HISTORIC PRESERVATION • STREET LIGHTING - POLICY AND FUNDING (This item was discussed in the Council Chambers) Karen Halladay briefed the Council from the attached handouts . Councilmember Love asked if the Council supported the three items that were discussed. She said there would additional items in the future. Council Members were in favor. #8. CONSIDER A MOTION TO ENTER INTO CLOSED SESSION, IN KEEPING WITH UTAH CODE § 52-4-204, FOR ANY OF THE FOLLOWING PURPOSES: a) A STRATEGY SESSION TO DISCUSS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE § 52-4-205 (1) (b) ; b) A STRATEGY SESSION TO DISCUSS THE PURCHASE, EXCHANGE OR LEASE OF REAL PROPERTY (INCLUDING ANY FORM OF WATER RIGHT OR WATER SHARES) WHEN PUBLIC DISCUSSION OF THE TRANSACTION WOULD DISCLOSE THE APPRAISAL OR ESTIMATED VALUE OF THE PROPERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION OR PREVENT THE CITY FROM COMPLETING THE TRANSACTION ON THE BEST POSSIBLE TERMS PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE § 52-4-205 (1) (d) ; c) A STRATEGY SESSION TO DISCUSS PENDING OR REASONABLY IMMINENT LITIGATION PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE § 52-4-205 (1) (c) ; d) A STRATEGY SESSION TO DISCUSS THE SALE OF REAL PROPERTY (INCLUDING ANY FORM OF WATER RIGHT OR WATER SHARES) IF (1) PUBLIC DISCUSSION OF THE TRANSACTION WOULD DISCLOSE THE APPRAISAL OR ESTIMATED VALUE OF THE PROPERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION OR PREVENT THE CITY FROM COMPLETING THE TRANSACTION ON THE BEST POSSIBLE TERMS, (2) THE CITY PREVIOUSLY GAVE NOTICE THAT THE PROPERTY WOULD BE OFFERED FOR SALE, AND (3) THE TERMS OF THE SALE ARE PUBLICLY DISCLOSED BEFORE THE CITY APPROVES THE SALE; e) FOR ATTORNEY- CLIENT MATTERS THAT ARE PRIVILEGED PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE § 78B-1-137, AND f) A STRATEGY SESSION TO DISCUSS DEPLOYMENT OF SECURITY PERSONNEL, DEVICES OR SYSTEMS PURSUANT TO UTAH CODE SECTION 52-4-205 (1) (f) . This item was not held. The meeting adjourned at 9 : 32 p.m. 11 - 3 PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH WORK SESSION TUESDAY, MARCH 22, 2011 LeKA-C ti i� /n(� COUNCIL CHAIR i 3x `ay, 1 -4 CITY RECORDER This document along with the digital recording constitute the official minutes of the City Council Work Session meeting held March 22, 2011 . bj 11 - 4 I - C, OM'WI COMMON' kikN �i G��t TO SG FRANK B. GRAY ` DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY& ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SCANNET M YT7 R .RY DE LA MARE-SCHAEFER OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR DATE: 1410 n DEPUTY DIRECTOR ` ROBERT FARRINGTON, JR. DEPUTY DIRECTOR CITY COUNCIL TRANSMITTAL Date Received: MAR 15 2011 David E ritt, Chie of Staff By Date Sent to City Council: 031/S/Le)/( TO: Salt Lake City Council DATE: March 10, 2010 Jill Remington-Love, Chair FROM: Frank Gray, Community &Ec omic Development Department Directo RE: PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards - A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. STAFF CONTACTS: Doug Dansie, Senior Planner, at 535-6182 or doug.dansie@slcgov.com RECOMMENDATION: That the City Council hold a briefing and schedule a Public Hearing DOCUMENT TYPE: Ordinance BUDGET IMPACT: None DISCUSSION: Issue Origin: Mayor Ralph Becker has initiated a request to amend the Salt Lake City Zoning Ordinance to include regulations for electronic billboards. The petition requests that existing City ordinances are updated to reflect industry changes and to define and regulate the conversion of existing billboards to an electronic format. 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 404 P.O. BOX 145486, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84114-5486 TELEPHONE: BO1-535.6230 FAX: B01-535-6005 WWW.SLCGOV.COM/CED is �� nccvcco rwPce Analysis: In October 2010, Mayor Becker initiated a petition for the purpose of amending the ''"" Salt Lake City Zoning Ordinance to address the conversion of traditional billboards to an electronic format. There are two associated petitions: Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment, Transit Shelter Advertising - A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment, Billboards - A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with State law. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. The Planning Commission has not yet taken action on either of these petitions. The petition regarding electronic billboards has been forward ahead of action regarding the other associated petitions because the issuance of building permits for electronic billboards have been withheld since October 21, 2011, under the Pending Ordinance Doctrine. This doctrine allows the City to withhold the issuance of building permits for a period of 180 days as the City reviews and potentially adopts proposed regulations. At the end of 180 days (April 19, 2011), the City can no longer withhold permits under this doctrine and if no new legislation has been passed, permits must be issued based on current Zoning Ordinance standards. Regulation of electronic billboards is the most pressing of the billboard issues being reviewed. For this reason, a recommendation to prohibit electronic billboards is being transmitted to the . City Council by the Planning Commission, at this time,to provide specific regulation of electronic billboards prior to the end of the 180 Pending Ordinance Doctrine deadline. The proposed text amendment defines and prohibits electronic billboards, which are considered to be an intensification of existing billboards. The Planning Commission.is recommending that the City Council adopt an ordinance which prohibits electronic billboards in Salt Lake City at least until such time that the broader issues surrounding billboards in general are reviewed and potential amendments to the City's billboard regulations are forwarded to the Council for consideration. The Planning Commission has already scheduled further discussion on the broader issues of billboards. Because of the approaching deadline imposed by the Pending Ordinance Doctrine, this transmittal is being forwarded to the City Council without ratified minutes of the March 9, 2011 Planning Commission meeting. The minutes will be forwarded to the City Council upon adoption(tentatively scheduled for March 23, 2011). Master Plan Considerations: The following master plans have been reviewed: • Urban Design Element: This plan calls for the prohibition of billboards on gateway streets. Gateway streets are the major entrances into the City and include interstate highways I-15, I-80, I-215; 300 West, Main Street, State Street, 5600 West, Foothill Drive, 600 North, North Temple, 400 South, 500 South and 600 South. ' RE: Petition PLNPCM2010-00717-Electronic Billboards • Page2of3 • North Temple Boulevard Plan: This plan calls for the prohibition of billboards on North Temple. • Downtown Master: This plan calls for the prohibition of billboards on entry streets to downtown and cleaning up their general appearance. PUBLIC PROCESS: • An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 18, 2010. • There was an initial briefing with the Planning Commission at the December 9, 2010 meeting. • The Business Advisory Board was briefed on January 5, 2011. • Several Planning Commissioners met with YESCO representatives on January 5, 2011 to discuss technical aspects of electronic billboards. • The Planning Commission received a briefing and held a work session on January 12, 2011 and set up a subcommittee to review the proposals. • The Planning Commission held an "issues only" hearing on January 26, 2011. • The Planning Commission held a hearing on February 23, 2011 and voted to continue the item as other business. • The Planning Commission made a decision on March 9, 2011 and voted to forward a positive recommendation to the City Council for the text change to the billboard ordinance that would define electronic billboards, prohibit electronic billboards and provide criteria for any existing electronic billboards. The Planning Commission vote was four in favor; two opposed; one abstention. The discussion included statements that the prohibition was to prevent the mass construction of electronic billboard at the end of the "pending legislation" period. No building permits have been issued within 180 days of initiating the petition. The Planning- Commission also set a date for ongoing discussion of billboards, with the understanding that the discussion may include proposing new regulations for electronic billboards. RELEVANT ORDINANCES: Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance and Maps are authorized under Section 21A.50 of the Salt Lake City Zoning Ordinance, as detailed in Section 21 A.50.050: "A decision to amend the text of this title or the zoning map by general amendment is a matter committed to the legislative discretion of the City Council and is not controlled by any one standard." It does, however, list five standards, which should be analyzed prior to rezoning property (Section 21A.50.050 A-E). The five standards are discussed in detail in the Planning Commission Staff Report. RE: Petition PLNPCM2010-00717-Electronic Billboards Page 3 of 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. PROJECT CHRONOLOGY 2. PROPOSED ORDINANCE 3. NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL HEARING 4. MAILING LABELS 5. PLANING COMMISSION A) ORIGINAL NOTICE AND POSTMARK January 15, 2011 newspaper February 12, 2011 newspaper B) STAFF REPORT 1) February 23, 2011 STAFF REPORT (Primary staff report) 2) December 2,2010 Briefing memo for December 9 meeting 3) January 12,2011 Briefing memo 4) January 20, 2011 Briefing memo for January 26 hearing 5) Report of information provided to the subcommittee 6) Continuation of February 23, 2011 public hearing to March 9,2011 C) AGENDA AND MINUTES January 26, 2011 February 23, 2011 March 9, 2011 6. ORIGINAL PETITION PROJECT CHRONOLOGY Petition No. PLNPCM2009-01048 October 21, 2010 Petition submitted to City for consideration and processing. October 21, 2010 Petition assigned to Doug Dansie, Senior Planner, for staff analysis and processing. November 18, 2010 Open House. November 24, 2011 Routed petition for review to applicable Departments and Divisions of Salt Lake City. December 9, 2010 Initial Briefing with the Salt Lake City Planning Commission. January 5, 2011 The Business Advisory Board was briefed January 5, 2011 Several Planning Commissioners met with YESCO representatives to discuss technical aspects of electronic billboards January 12,' 2011 The Planning Commission received a briefing and held a work session and set up a subcommittee to review the proposals. January 13, 2011 Mailed public hearing notice for the January 26, 2011 Planning Commission meeting. January 15, 2011 Published public hearing notice for the January 26, 201 1 Planning Commission meeting in the Salt Lake Tribune. January 26, 2011 The Planning Commission held an "issues only" hearing January 31, and February 7, 2011 A Planning Commission subcommittee met with industry February 10, 2011 Mailed public hearing notice for the February 23, 2011 Planning Commission meeting. February 12. 2011 Published public hearing notice for the February 23, 201 l Planning Commission meeting in the Salt Lake Tribune. February 18, 2011 Published Planning Commission Staff Report. February 23, 2011 Planning Commission conducted public hearing and voted postpone action. March 9, 2011 Planning voted to forward a positive recommendation to the City Council for the text change to the Billboard ordinance that would define electronic billboards, prohibit electronic billboards and provide criteria for any electronic billboard that may be constructed for any external reason. March --. 2010 Planning Commission ratified meeting minutes for March 9. 2011. SALT LAKE CITY ORDINANCE No. of 2011 (An ordinance amending section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code pertaining to billboards) An ordinance amending section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code pursuant to Petition No. PLNPCM2010-00717 regarding the regulation of billboards. WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Planning Commission ("Planning Commission") held a public hearings on January 26, 2011 and February 23, 2011 to consider a request made by Mayor Ralph Becker ("Applicant") (Petition No. PLNPCM2010-00717) to amend the text of section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Signs: Billboards) regarding the regulation of electronic billboards; and WHEREAS, at its March 9, 2011 public meeting, the Planning Commission voted in favor of recommending to the Salt Lake City Council("City Council")that the City Council amend section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code as specified herein; and WHEREAS, after a public hearing on this matter the City Council has determined that adopting this ordinance is in the City's best interests. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah: SECTION 1. Amending text of Salt Lake City Code section 21A.46.160. That section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Signs: Billboards), shall be, and hereby is, amended to read as follows: 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement: This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number. This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways, views, vistas and related urban design elements of the city's , master plans. B. Definitions: BILLBOARD: A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK: An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconforming billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT: An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER: The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. DWELL TIME: The length of time that elapses between text, images, or graphics on an electronic sign. EXISTING BILLBOARD: A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use AMMO* or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD: Any off-premise sign, video display, projected image, or similar device with text, images, or graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include, but are not limited to, signs that use light emitting diodes (LED), plasma displays, fiber optics, or other technology that results in bright, high-resolution text, images, and graphics. FOOT CANDLE: the English unit of measurement for luminance, which is equal to one lumen, incident upon an area of one square foot. GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4. 4000 West; 5. 5600 West; 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7. The 2100 South Expressway from I-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD: An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. ILLUMINENCE: The intensity of light falling on a subsurface at a defined distance from the source. MOTION: The depiction of movement or change of position of text, images, or graphics. Motion shall include, but not be limited to, visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images, running sequential text, graphic bursts, lighting that resembles zooming, twinkling, or sparkling, changes in light or color, transitory bursts of light intensity, moving patterns or bands of light, expanding or contracting shapes, and similar actions. TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT: An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text, images, and graphics on an electronic sign to change to a different text, images, or graphics on a subsequent sign face. C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred ,nrk, eleven dollars ($111.00). E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D1 of this section, or its successor, the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; and 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however, the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor, priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section,the two (2) higher priority billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. G. Life Of Billboard Credits: Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty (60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable: A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six (36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may be constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Permits: 1. Application: Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building /Oak code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: 1. A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2. When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued, the zoning administrator shall deduct from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a. The square footage of the new billboard; and b. The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3. If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage, any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N. New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet (600') of the right of way of any gateway. O. Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway, the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P, Q, R and S of this section, provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2. The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits within the general billboard bank. Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway. A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six (36) months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15') in height and fifty feet (50') in width. Q. Temporary Embellishments: 1. Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent (10%) of the advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet (5') in height above the billboard structure. 2. No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve (12) months. R. Height: The highest point of any new billboard, excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: 1. Forty five feet (45') above the existing grade; or 2. If a street within one hundred feet (100') of the billboard, measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street, is on a different grade than the new billboard, twenty five feet (25') above the pavement elevation of the street. 3. If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section, or its successor subsection, apply to more than one street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. S. Minimum Setback Requirements: All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet (5') from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300) square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet (800') from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. 3. Electronic billboards shall not be located closer than sixteen hundred (1600) Amok linear feet from any other electronic billboard on the same or opposite side of the street U. Electronic Billboards: 1. New Electronic Billboards are prohibited: Electronic billboards constructed or reconstructed for any reason after the date of adoption of this ordinance are limited to the following: a. Motion Any motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face. Electronic billboards shall have only static text, images, and graphics. b. Dwell time The text, image, or display on an electronic sign may not change more than once every twenty four (24) hours. Twirl time between subsequent text, images, or display shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. c. Brightness The illumination of any Electronic Billboard shall not increase the ambient lighting level more than 0.3 foot candles when measured by a foot candle meter perpendicular to the electronic Billboard face at: i. 150 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface are of not more than 242 square feet ii. 200 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 242 square feet but not more than 378 square feet iii. 250 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 378 square feet but not more than 672 square feet iv. 350 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 672 square feet. d. Display period Electronic billboards may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight. and 6 a.m if they are located in, or within 600 Feet of, a residential, mixed-use, downtown, Sugar House Business District, gateway, Neighborhood Commercial, Community Business, or Community Shopping Center zoning district, e. Controls i. All electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer control or other mechanism that automatically controls the sign's brightness and display period as provided above. ii. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sign, the applicant shall certify that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion, dwell time, brightness, and other requirements herein. iii. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sign shall submit an annual report to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion, dwell time, brightness, and other requirements herein. UV. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. VW. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection US of this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty (50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. WX. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property, the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. XY. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. Z. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance. ZAA. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land Amok, for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary, such subdivision. AABB. Special Provisions: 1. Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: a. Four (4) existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the west side of Interstate 15; and b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. ,, mok 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection VW of this section, or its successor subsection. BBCC. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. SECTION 2. Effective Date. This ordinance shall become effective on the date of its first publication. Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah, this day of 2011. SALT LAKE CITY ORDINANCE No. of 2011 (An ordinance amending section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code pertaining to billboards) An ordinance amending section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code pursuant to Petition No. PLNPCM2010-00717 regarding the regulation of billboards. WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Planning Commission ("Planning Commission") held a public hearings on January 26, 2011 and February 23, 2011 to consider a request made by Mayor Ralph Becker("Applicant") (Petition No. PLNPCM2010-00717) to amend the text of section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Signs: Billboards) regarding the regulation of electronic billboards; and WHEREAS, at its March 9, 2011 public meeting, the Planning Commission voted in favor of recommending to the Salt Lake City Council ("City Council") that the City Council amend section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code as specified herein; and WHEREAS, after a public hearing on this matter the City Council has determined that adopting this ordinance is in the City's best interests. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah: SECTION 1. Amending text of Salt Lake City Code section 21A.46.160. That section 21A.46.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Signs: Billboards), shall be, and hereby is, amended to read as follows: 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement: This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number. This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways, views, vistas and related urban design elements of the city's .... master plans. B. Definitions: BILLBOARD: A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK: An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconfoiniing billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT: An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER: The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. DWELL TIME: The length of time that elapses between text, images, or graphics on an electronic sign. EXISTING BILLBOARD: A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use ,m,, or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD: Any off-premise sign, video display, projected image, or similar device with text, images, or graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include, but are not limited to, signs that use light emitting diodes (LED), plasma displays, fiber optics, or other technology that results in bright, high-resolution text, images, and graphics. FOOT CANDLE: the English unit of measurement for luminance, which is equal to one lumen, incident upon an area of one square foot. GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4. 4000 West; 5. 5600 West; ., 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7. The 2100 South Expressway from I-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD: An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. ILLUMINENCE: The intensity of light falling on a subsurface at a defined distance from the source. MOTION: The depiction of movement or change of position of text, images, or graphics. Motion shall include, but not be limited to, visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images, running sequential text, graphic bursts, lighting that resembles zooming, twinkling, or sparkling, changes in light or color, transitory bursts of light intensity, moving patterns or bands of light, expanding or contracting shapes, and similar actions. TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT: An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text, images, and graphics on an electronic sign to change to a different text, images, or graphics on a subsequent sign face. C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred - eleven dollars ($111.00). E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D 1 of this section, or its successor, the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; and 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however, the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor,priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section, the two (2) higher priority billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. G. Life Of Billboard Credits: Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty(60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable: A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six (36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code, the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may be constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Pennits: 1. Application: Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building Amok code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: 1. A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2. When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued, the zoning administrator shall deduct from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a. The square footage of the new billboard; and b. The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3. If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage, any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N. New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet (600') of the right of way of any gateway. O. Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway, the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P, Q, R and S of this section, provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2. The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits within the general billboard bank. Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway. A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six (36) months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet (15') in height and fifty feet (50') in width. Q. Temporary Embellishments: 1. Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent (10%) of the advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet (5') in height above the billboard structure. 2. No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve (12) months. R. Height: The highest point of any new billboard, excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: 1. Forty five feet (45') above the existing grade; or 2. If a street within one hundred feet (100') of the billboard, measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street, is on a different grade than the new billboard, twenty five feet (25') above the pavement elevation of the street. 3. If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section, or its successor subsection, apply to more than one street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. S. Minimum Setback Requirements: All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet (5') from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300) square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet (800') from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred(800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. 3. Electronic billboards shall not be located closer than sixteen hundred (1600) Amok linear feet from any other electronic billboard on the same or opposite side of the street U. Electronic Billboards: 1. New Electronic Billboards are prohibited: Electronic billboards constructed or reconstructed for any reason after the date of adoption of this ordinance are limited to the following: a. Motion Any motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face. Electronic billboards shall have only static text, images, and graphics. b. Dwell time The text, image, or display on an electronic sign may not change more than once every twenty four (24) hours. Twirl time between subsequent text, images, or display shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. c. Brightness The illumination of any Electronic Billboard shall not increase the ambient lighting level more than 0.3 foot candles when measured by a foot candle meter perpendicular to the electronic Billboard face at: i. 150 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface are of not more than 242 square feet ii. 200 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 242 square feet but not more than 378 square feet iii. 250 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 378 square feet but not more than 672 square feet iv. 350 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater than 672 square feet. d. Display period Electronic billboards may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight. and 6 a.m if they are located in, or within 600 Feet of, a residential, mixed-use, downtown, Sugar House Business District, gateway, Neighborhood Commercial, Community Business, or Community Shopping Center zoning district, e. Controls i. All electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer control or other mechanism that automatically controls the sign's brightness and display period as provided above. ii. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sign, the applicant shall certify that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion, dwell time, brightness, and other requirements herein. iii. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sign shall submit an annual report to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion, dwell time, brightness, and other requirements herein. V. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. W. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection S of this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. X. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property, the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. Y. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. Z. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance. AA. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary, such subdivision. BB. Special Provisions: 1. Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: a. Four(4) existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the west side of Interstate 15; and b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection W of this section, or its successor subsection. CC. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. f, SECTION 2. Effective Date. This ordinance shall become effective on the date of its first publication. Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah, this day of 2011. CHAIRPERSON ATTEST AND COUNTERSIGN: CITY RECORDER Transmitted to Mayor on Mayor's Action: Approved. Vetoed. MAYOR CITY RECORDER APPROVED AS TO FORM (SEAL) Salt Lake City Attorney's Office Date: 2/I Bill No. of 2011. By: Published: P d C.Niels , enior City Attorney HB ATTY-#17129-v2-Ordinance- Billboard amendments- electronrc billboards.DOC NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The Salt Lake City Council will hold a public hearing regarding Petition PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards - A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. As part of its study, the City Council is holding an advertised public hearing to receive comments regarding the petition. During this hearing, anyone desiring to address the City Council concerning this issue will be given an opportunity to speak. The hearing will be held: Date: Time: 7:00 p.m. Place: Room 315 (City Council Chambers)* Salt Lake City and County Building 451 S. State Street Salt Lake City, UT *Please enter building from east side. If you have any questions relating to this proposal or would like to review the petition on file, please call Doug Dansie, Senior Planner, at 535-6182 between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday or via e-mail at doug.dansie .slcgov.com. People with disabilities may make requests for reasonable accommodations no later than 48 hours in advance in order to attend this public hearing. Accommodations may include alternate formats, interpreters, and other auxiliary aids. The City R County Building is an accessible facility. For questions, requests, or additional information, please contact the ADA Coordinator at (801) 535-7971; TDD 535-6021. Saunders Outdoor Advertising High Impact Billboards Alex Waller ";3 Lincoln Avenue 808 N. Hwy 89 545 S 700E Jen, Utah 84401-3837 Ogden, Utah 84404 Salt Lake City, Utah 84102 Reagan Outdoor Advertising Fusion Imaging Inc. Jared Johnson 1775 Warm Springs Road 601 Boro St. 1065 S Gramercy Rd Salt Lake City, Utah 84116-2353 Kaysville, Utah 84037-3122 Salt Lake City, Utah 84109 Simmons Media Group Young Electric Sign Company Ryan Young 515 S. 7`" E. #IC 2401 S. Foothill Drive 2401 Foothill Drive Salt Lake City, Utah 84102-2802 Salt Lake City, Utah 84109 Salt Lake City, Utah 845109 Card Sign Inc. COAMAX Sign Company Inc. Mike Helm 960 W. 2100 S. 2180 N. 1089 W. 1505 S Gramercy Rd Salt Lake City, Utah 84119-1530 Salt Lake City, Utah 84116 Salt Lake City, Utah 64104 Utah Logos Inc. Millennium Sign Company Daniel (Dewey) Reagan 5278 Pinemont Dr. 4A150 2150 S. 1300 E. Suite 500 1775 North Warm Springs ,1t Lake City, Utah 84123-2711 Salt Lake City, Utah 84106 Salt Lake City, Utah 84116 Lamar Transit Advertising John Evans Co. Digital Imaging Randy Horiuchi 754 S. 200 W. 3815 Parkway Boulevard 1785 Michigan Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Salt Lake City, Utah 84120 Salt Lake City, Utah 84108 CBS Outdoor Republic Outdoor Advertising Collin Simonson PO BOX 2455 1675 Beck Street 50 West 300 South #1200 Salt Lake City, Utah 84110-2455 Salt Lake City, Utah 84116-1214 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 JLC Signs Vision International Kim Spring 6605 Sunflower Dr. 3030 Directors Row 1011 S West Temple APT 305 I-Iighland, Utah 84003-9483 Salt Lake City, Utah 84104-4551 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Lockridge Outdoor Advertising Mike Zuhl 4460 Wallace Lane 1063 Douglas Street Highland, Utah 84124 Salt Lake City, Utah84105 Outdoor Promotions Guy Larson 9500 S. 500 W. 4106 1775 North Warm Springs Sandy, Utah 84070-6654 Salt Lake City, Utah 84116 Terry Thomas Elke Phillips Cabot Nelson 1848 Stallion Lane 839 S Washington Street 984 Simpson Ave % Salt Lake City UT 84116 Salt Lake City UT 84101 Salt Lake City UT 84106 Brad Bartholomew Thomas Mutter 871 N. Poinsettia Dr. 228 EAST 500 SOUTH Salt Lake City UT 84116 Salt Lake City UT 84111 Angie Vorher Esther Hunter, 1988 Sir James Dr. East Central & Univ. CC Salt Lake City UT 84116 1049 Norris Place Salt Lake City UT 84152-1809 Gordon Storrs DeWitt Smith 223 North 800 West 328 E. Hollywood Ave. Salt Lake City UT 84116 Salt Lake City UT 84115 Mike Harman por&& DA)U5 (la 1044 West 300 South 51,7 N MA-/N Salt Lake City UT 84104 Icr-I/0 3 imok Randy Sorenson George Kelner 1184 S. Redwood Dr. 1000 Military Drive Salt Lake City UT 84104-3325 Salt Lake City UT 84105 Katherine Gardner Mark Brinton 606 De Soto St 1869 Logan Ave Salt Lake City UT 84103 Salt Lake City UT 84108 Jim Jenkin Pete Taylor 212 5th Ave 933 S. 2300 E. Salt Lake City UT 84103 Salt Lake City UT 84108 Gene Fitzgerald Ellen Reddick 1385 Butler Ave 2177 Roosevelt Ave Salt Lake City, UT 84102 Salt Lake City UT 84108 ,004004, -4004 D. Christian Harrison R. Gene Moffitt Community Council Chaii 336 W. Broadway,#308 1410 Chancellor Way Last update from CC website 12.1.1 Salt Lake City UT 84101 Salt Lake City UT 84108 Ii`I`tI'`I`IIttlImirti"I"i# i -t% i'-fia=;C)S-0-SCE;0* tr 1 T G :Z)O G11VMa03 0131evNn a3ss3daav 06'1 ('l`c4C:,-.1 01 '3--1t:l Nt t buis ivis kr SV 318V113A113010N VI ""- to 17MSm11N1 SS3k100V1N313133fSNI❑ tCIL12C1td�4 01 t,mflZ:t t3WfNHonSON❑ o„o, a3SndkiO3d1s HOns ON❑ MYY10r "r 2_;/TO 00 T :.,i T V a :-i is"K I i4 • •03WWNW NMONN 10N-031dW31LV ❑ SS31:10OVON.L 1'03AOW❑ 4001‘0„6 ,i,I . .1 ONIUV21--.V..d0 DOLLON ', •duc►,,,ut! limo �' 9 O8t✓9-t7L',vein 1A110 3>IV1 rIVS `l 9.0V W2t 19]�JIS L1d1S H1fOS 1,9 , r O r+-�'iv/iota ,.4 :i-L^f ',;11 O0tr9�k XOa Od 9 L bb9 3OOOdIZ WOdd 0dlIVL1 r,. a' 'v''1€s/ v p NOI Oet' JNINN did W661 6 L G00 t '`0 ra Z O , ..1.1, '. -3 '" •g a m t S '.O9 h3n311d tr - N f ').. cO •.;dr'. .. r�:�L.^ �-••• _ i• }:_c./• / . _ m_ ,. . ... .. ._-_•--- .-4SOy c„1''' • GUIDELINES 1. Fill out registration card and indicate if you wish to speak and which agenda item you will address. 2. After the staff and petitioner presentations, hearings will be opened for public comment. Community Councils will present their comments at the beginning of the hearing. -- 3. In'order to be considerate of everyone attending the meeting,public comments are limited to two(2)minutes per person, per item.A spokesperson who has already been asked by a group to summarize their concerns will be allowed five (5) minutes to speak. Written comments are welcome and will be provided to staff and the Hearing Officer in advance of the meeting if they are submitted prior to noon the day before the meeting.Written comments should be sent to: Salt Lake City Planning Commission 451 South State Street, Room 406 Salt Lake City UT 84111 4. Speakers wiiil be called by the Chair. 5. Please state your name and your affiliation to the petition or whom you represent at the beginning of your comments. S eakers should focus their comments on the agenda item.Extre ' repetitive comments should be avoided. .__ f-- _ - ' - • ui I. e . Vies may make requests for reasonable accommodation no-titer aril van _ this meeting.Accommodations may include alternate formats,interpreters,and other auxiliary aids. This _ ..,t accessi_ 1ity. For questions, requests,or additional information, please contact the Planning Office at 535-7757;TDD 535-6220. . der SALT LAKE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA In Room 326 of the City&County Building at 451 South State Street Wednesday,January 26,2011 at 7:00 p.m.or immediately following the Work Session The field trip is scheduled to leave at 4:00 p.m. Dinner will be served to the Planning Commissioners and Staff at 5:00p.m:in Room 126. • a Work Session: 5:30 in Room 326. The Planning Commission will hold a work session from approximately 5:30-6:30. During the Work Session the Planning Staff will brief the Planning Commission on pending projects, discuss project updates and minor administrative matters. This portion of the meeting is open to the public for observation, PLNPCM2011-00015: Yalecrest Local Historic District Designation—A request by the Historic Landmark Commission, pursuant to a request from the Yalecrest Yes Heritage Preservation Committee,to amend the Salt Lake City Zoning Map,in accordance with the standards of chapter 21A.34.020 and chapter 21A.50.050 of the City Ordinance,and establish an H Historic Preservation Overlay District for the Yalecrest neighborhood which is located generally between 800 South/Sunnyside Avenue and 1300 South,from 1300 East to 1900 East.The area is located in City Council District 5 represented by Jill Remington Love and District 6 represented by JT Martin.(Staff contact:Carl Leith at(801)535-7758 or carl.leith@slcgov.corn.) PLNPCM2010-00665: Yalecrest Compatible Infill Overlay(YCI)and Historic Preservation Overlay(H)Amendment—A request by Jodi Howick in behalf of the Yalecrest Preservationists for Property Rights for amendment of the Salt Lake City Code to establish a voluntary development review process and modify certain provisions of the YCI District,and amend the procedure to establish an H District. The amendment will affect sections 21A.34.120 and 21A.34.020 of the zoning ordinance. Related provisions of Title 21A-Zoning may also be amended as part of this petition. (Staff contact:Michael Maloy at(801)535-7118 or michael.malov@slcgov.com). o Approval of Minutes o Report of the Chair and Vice Chair o Report of the Director o Public Hearings 7:00 or immediately following the work session Public Hearing(Administrative Petition) 1. PLNPCM2010-00760: Deseret First Credit Union Conditional Use—A request by Gary Gower for conditional use approval for an expansion of the office building located at 147 North 200 West in the R-MU(Residential Mixed Use)and RMF-35(Moderate Density Multi-Family Residential) zoning districts and in Council District 3,represented by Stan Penfold.(Staff contact:Katia Pace at 801-535-6354 or katia.pace@slcgov.com) issues Only(Legislative Petitions) 2. Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts.(Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.densie@slcgov.com) 3. PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards.The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts.(Staff contact:Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie@slcgov.ccm) 4. PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Teat Amendment,Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards.Currently,the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact:Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie@slcgov.com) The files for the above items are available in the Planning Division offices,room gob of the City and Courrti/Building. Please contact the staff planner for information,Visit the Planning Division's website at www.slcgov.coni/CTD/planning for copies of the Planning Commission agendas,staff reports,and minutes.Staff Reports will be posted the Friday prior to the meeting and minutes will he posted two days after they are rat fled,which usually occurs at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Planning Commission.Planning Conursissiorr Meetings may be watched live on SLCTV Channel 17;past meetings arc recorded and archived,and nray be viewed at rtavw.sletv.conr 4770 S.5600\V. P.O-BOX 704005 Ow gait gatiaribune MEDIA9ae Deseret News WEST VALLEY CITY.UTAH 84170 FED.TAX I.D.# 87-0217663 PROOF OF PUBLICATION CUSTOMER'S COPY ERN -.:'CUSTOMA IvIEAND AIJDRESS�- w'DATE.., _. PLANNING DIVISION, 9001394298 2/14/2011 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 406 SALT LAKE CITY UT 84111 w��':�x'c'j'.{x��`:?a+�'� PLANNING DIVISION, 8015356184 0000662998 / ss �F n l':_ i.-t> '�: '"-,•�% _5��.��LE�; Tyr ,•st,'#��^- :� '��a�.� i ' n`-��. y� w's Start 02/12/2011 End 02/12/2011 Zoning Ordinance ` _ .'�i_-..__ =<s. _- _- -- -..y.fig_ •.�. Lake Ci Salt Lake City Zoning Ordinance Amendment On Wednesday February 23, 2011 at 7:00 pm ii ,Zoning Orrdtinance Amendment On Wednesday February 23, -a." -r - .rT -` - - �� =` `• Fes'-- :•f-fi` '� -"s:.�. _ —' '. ";'�.r" 2011 at 7:00 pm in Room 3`=„�` _ _ =� _ - --. ;' . . ,- ,�"`t'SiZ� - &-`ca=.r f _ - sr it~•, :i1 ^�k1- _-,Fs!=✓? -_ 326 of the Salt Lake City/County Building, 451' South State, the Salt Lake 31 Lines 1.00 COLUMN City Planning Commission will hold a public hearing to con- ,sider zoning text amendments - TIMES - _'- ''.'RATE'-" regarding transit shelter ad- . - - c - _ - - - -ti _ _ .- •- .. ad- vertising, billboard reguic- lions end electronic bill- boards. Staff Contact: Doug 3 Dansie(801)535-6182 doug .dansie@slcgov.com • i Troom ne publ 32 ic of t hearing Cry willCauat be iny MISC:CHARGES . - ._ , 6 Building, 451 South State Street,Solt lake City,UT.For more information or for spe- •cial ADO acccmmcdations, I which may include alternate formats, interpreters, and _ other auxiliary aids or addi- - - _ :-TOTAL CO STr;•a` _ tional information, please - - - - contact Ccug Dansie at 535- 61 82 cr colt ISO 535-6220. 662998 UPAxLP 43.75 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION AS NEWSPAPER AGENCY COMPANY,LLC dba MEDIAONE OF UTAH LEGAL BOOKER,I CERTIFY TI IAT THE ATTACHED ADVERTISEMENT OF Salt Lake City Zoninu Ordinance Amendment On Wednesday February 23.2011 at 7:00 pm ill Room 326 of the Salt Lake City/County Builclina.451 South State, the S FOR PLANNING DIVISION.WAS PUBLISHED BY THE NEWSPAPER AGENCY COMPANY,LLC dba MEDIAONE OF UTAH,AGENT FOR THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE AND DESERET NEWS,DAILY NE\VSPAPERS PRINTED IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE\V1TH GENERAL CIRCULATION IN UTAH,AND PUBLISHED IN SALT LAKE CITY,SALT LAKE COUNTY IN THE STATE OF UTAH.NOTICE IS ALSO POSTED ON UTAI ILEGALS.COM ON THE SAME DAY AS THE FIRST NEWSPAPER PUBLICATION DATE AND REMAINS ON UTAHLEGALS CO\1 INDEFINATELY. PUBLISHED ON Start 02/12/2011 End 02/12/2011 C tt `l - is i • .. \ ._ � � 4 . I)',. , ,';,. — I \ DATE 2/14/2011 Tl IIS 1S NOT A STATEMENT BUT A"PROOF OF PUBLICATION" '' 1 PLEASE PAY FROM BILLING STATEMENT Remit to:P.O.Box 704005 Mrgntt tkrZrabunr MEDIA. ge Deseret News West Valley City, UT 84170 Order Confirmation for Ad #0000655815-01 Client PLANNING DIVISION Payor Customer PLANNING DIVISION Ad Content Proof Actual Size On Wednesday January Client Phone 801-535-7930 Payor Phone 801-535-7930 26 at 7:00 pet In Pace, 326 of the Salt Lake City/County Building, 451 South tare,S the Sult Account# 1001472101 PayorAccount 1001472101 Lake City Planning Com- mission will hold a public hearing to consider z on- Add ress P.O.Box 145460,451 South State Street,Rm 40E Payor Address P.O.Box 145480,451 South State Stree ing text c reenchnents in- SALT LAKE CITY UT 84114-5480 USA SALT LAKE CITY UT 84114-5480 garcling tionsit shelters aclveuising bi!Iboaicl ieculatlons and elernon- Iccillboardss. Sta`1 Ordered n- Ordered By Acct.Exec tact,Doug)Dunsie Fax (801)535-61 82 EMail doug.dansieaslcyotwom everett.joyce@slcgov.com Angela jvaldez Total Amount $109.00 Payment Amt $0.00 Tear Sheets Proofs Affidavits Amount Due $109.00 0 0 0 Payment Method PO Number Confirmation Notes: Text: Ad Type Ad Size Color CLS Liner 1.0 X 16 Li <NONE> tduct Placement Position .t Lake Tribune:: General Classified 010-Special Notices 0010 Scheduled Date(s): 01/15/2011 Product Placement Position Deseret News:: General Classified 010-Special Notices 0010 Scheduled Date(s): 01/15/2011 Product Placement Position sltrib.com:: General Classified 010-Special Notices 0010 Scheduled Date(s): 01/15/2011 Product Placement Position deseretnews.com:: General Classified 010-Special Notices 0010 Scheduled Date(s): 01/15/2011 01/13/2011 2:45:42PM 1 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMOS 1) February 23,2011 STAFF REPORT(Primary staff report) 2) December 2,2010 Briefing memo for December 9 meeting 3) January 12,2011 Briefing memo 4) January 20,2011 Briefing memo for January 26 hearing 5) Report of information provided to the subcommittee 6) February 18 memo 7) Continuation of February 23, 2011 public hearing to March 9, 2011 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT ttttt 41, ,,,,, "1 , Off-premise advertising = ' ` Petitions: 400-06-51 PLNPCM2010-00032, PLNPCM2010-00717 _!'�' `^�y)� Zoning Text Amendment -c I l"T '`�� tt,tt Citywide Planning and Zoning Division February 23, 2011 Department of Community and Economic Development Applicant: Mayor Ralph Becker Request Staff: There are three separate petitions regarding the regulation of off-premise Doug Dansie,535-6182 Doug.Dansie r slcgov.con, advertising in Salt Lake City. Tax ID: Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment, Transit Shelter Advertising - city\\idc A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. Current Zone: The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. Citywide Master Plan Designation: PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment, Billboards - A request by NA Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for Council District: outdoor billboards to make them consistent with State law. The text amendment Citywide would affect all zoning districts. Community Council: Citywide PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards - A Lot Size: request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to Citywide address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not Current Use: address electronic billboards. The text amendment would affect all zoning NA districts. Applicable Land Use Regulations: Staff Recommendation 21A.50.050: Standards for general amendments Based on the findings listed in the staff report, it is the Planning Staffs opinion 21A.46.160: Billboards that overall the proposal generally meets the applicable standards and therefore, Notification (hearing) recommends the Planning Commission forward a positive recommendation to • Notice: January 22. the City Council to approve the requested zoning text amendments associated Feb 12.2011 with petitions PLNPCM2010-00032 and PLNPCM2010-00717 as outlined in • Web: January 22. Feb 11,201 1 the summary and not take action on petition 400-06-51 and hold it for further review. Attachments: A. Department Comments B. Proposed ordinance C. Map of affected geography Petitions•400-06-51,PLNPCN120I0-00032,PLNPCp12010-00717 Published Date. Februaryl 8,2011 17 ommok Background The current billboard ordinance was adopted in 1993. It was based upon the premise of capping the overall number of billboards and allowing the remaining billboards to move to more acceptable locations away from residential and historical areas. Since then, State legislation has changed allowing billboard companies to relocate billboards to non-residential zoning districts adjacent to existing billboard locations. In many cases, billboard companies have purchased the land or easement on sites to insure the permanence of their board, therefore eliminating the incentive for movement. The industry has also expressed a desire to maintain its present coverage; therefore the billboard bank contained in the original ordinance has been rendered mute. The industry is now considering converting many billboards to billboards with electronic faces, which have a differing set of impacts (such as changing images) and effectively increase the non-conformity of many billboards. The current ordinance is silent regarding electronic billboards: Meaning there is no prohibition or rules regarding conversion. Project Description There are three separate petitions, all involving off-premise advertising. Off-premise advertising differs from on-premise advertising in that on-premise is generally necessary for an individual business to exist or survive, Off—premise advertising generally promotes activity not associated with the location of the sign, therefore th''''"k nexus between the business and the sign is not as critical. Court cases have generally allowed local communities to regulate off-premise advertising more stringently than on-premise advertising. The Supreme Court has ruled that billboards may be banned as long as other forms of advertising exist in the community. The petitions and issues are as follows: Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment, Transit Shelter Advertising - A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. Request: The present ordinance has banned bus bench advertising and most other advertising in the public right-of- way since the 1970's. This proposal is to allow limited advertising on bus shelters or other public furniture (as is done in numerous suburban communities)to allow advertising to pay for those public amenities. Issues: • Off-premise signage in the public right-of-way, including bus benches, was prohibited in the 1970's. • Previous use of signage in the right-of-way resulted in complaints of clutter. • Previous signage in the right-of-way resulted in complaints of businesses putting signage directly in front of competitors, etc. • Salt Lake City has liberalized some signage regulations since the 1970's: Specifically banners and A-frame directional signs • UTA (and Lamar Advertising) approached the City regarding the potential for advertising to pay for transit shelters. • Using advertising to pay for other potential public furniture and services has also been considered (restrooms, bike rental, etc.) PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards -A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for ate. zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations outdoor billboards to make them consistent with State law. Petitions 400-06-51,PLNPCM12010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 Published Date. February!S,2011 18 Request: The existing law regarding billboards was adopted in 1993. State law has changed considerably since that time leaving portions of current City law to be inneffective. The purpose of this petition is to update City law to be consistent with State law and to simplify City processes. Issues: • The current ordinance was adopted in 1993 and was intended to be a cap and reduce program, allowing billboards to relocate to more appropriate locations while prohibiting an increase in the overall number of billboards in the City and allowing for a decrease. • A billboard bank was set up to accommodate movement and to prioritize areas of acceptable relocation. • State law has changed considerably since 1993. • State law allows billboards to move to any non-residential property within a variable distance from the original location for multiple reasons, if the City does not allow the movement; the City is obligated to purchase the billboard. The City may negotiate alternative locations with the Billboard company. • State law requires the purchase of a billboard to include damages to the"package". Billboards are often sold in groups to one advertiser; that group constitutes a package. • Changes in State law have left the SLC billboard bank largely irrelevant. • Many billboards in the City were erected before there were any sign regulations and they remain in areas where they have long been non-conforming. • Billboards are amortized for tax value and pay taxes on 8% of their original value after 19 years. • By State law, billboards are the only non-conforming use that cannot be removed through the use of amortization. • There are numerous scenarios in Salt Lake City where the presence of a billboard suppresses the redevelopment potential of the underlying land, as well as examples of redevelopment with billboards. PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards- A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently. the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. Request: The petition is to update existing City law to reflect industry changes and to define and regulate the conversion of existing billboards to an electronic format. Issues: • The current ordinance is silent regarding electronic billboards. • Six electronic billboards exist in Salt Lake City. Three are under dispute. • Numerous electronic on-premise signs exist. • State law allows electronic billboards but does not require local government to allow the conversion of old billboards to an electronic format. • Electronic billboards are the emerging format for billboards. • Electronic billboards require a greater investment and offer an increased potential revenue source for the owner; therefore their removal costs are also higher. Comments Public Comments • An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 1S, 2010. • There was an initial briefing with the Planning Commission at the December 9, 2010 meeting. • The Business Advisory' Board was briefed on January 5, 2011. • Several Planning Commissioners met with YESCO representatives on January 5, 2011 to discuss technical aspects of electronic billboards. Petitions -100-06-51,PLNPC\12010-0002,PLNPCM2010-00717 Published Date February IS,2011 19 • The Planning Commission received a briefing and held a work session on January 12,' 2011 and set up a subcommittee to review the proposals. Al • The Planning Commission held an "issues only" hearing on January 26, 2011. City Department Comments Department comments are attached. There were generally no significant issues raised. Project Review A Planning Commission subcommittee met with industry members on January 31, and February 7, 2011. The subcommittee discussion included the following issues: • Comparison of Salt Lake City's ordinance with Salt Lake County • Relocation potential of existing billboards • Geography of existing billboards and potential geography for allowing them • Power requirements and sustainability of electronic billboards • Impacts of electronic billboards vs. impacts of electronic on-premise signs • Lighting, timing and luminance of electronic billboards • Spacing and geographical concerns regarding electronic boards • Master plan policies regarding billboards; including the concept of Gateway streets. • The Administration's opinion on billboards Aimmik .00011110, Petitions.400-06-51.PLNPC\12010-00032,PLNPC\12010-00717 Published Date: February)S,2011 20 Analysis and Findings Jptions The City presently has a sign ordinance regulating off-premise advertising. Failure to grant zoning changes outlined by Petition 400-06-51 would keep the present prohibition of bus bench advertising. Failure to grant zoning changes suggested by petition PLNPCM2010-00032 would result in a situation where State law would still supersede City ordinance and allow movement into areas currently prohibited by City ordinance, regardless of the City billboard banking process. Failure to grant zoning changes requested by petition PLNPCM2010- 00717 would allow conversion of static billboards to electronic billboards by not providing any prohibition against their conversion or providing any standards to do so. Findings A decision to amend the text of this title or the zoning map by general amendment is a matter committed to the legislative discretion of the city council and is not controlled by any one standard. However, In making its decision concerning a proposed text amendment, the city council should consider the following factors: A. 1. Whether a proposed text amendment is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives, and policies of the city as stated through its various adopted planning documents; Analysis: The Urban Design Element calls for the prohibition of billboards on gateway streets. The North Temple Master Plan calls for the prohibition of billboards on North Temple. The Downtown Master Plan and Downtown Rising Plan (not formally adopted by Salt Lake City) call for prohibiting billboards on entry streets to downtown and cleaning up their general appearance. The proposed amendment outlines general areas where billboards are allowed and defines gateway streets where they are not allowed. The billboard ordinance is not the only ordinance affecting gateway streets. Other sections of City code require landscaping on street frontages, including freeways. full architecture on all sides of the building and regulation of on-premise signage. Sexually oriented businesses are also prohibited on gateway streets. Finding: The proposed zoning text amendments arc supported by general policy of the City 2. Whether a proposed text amendment furthers the specific purpose statements of the zoning ordinance; Analysis: The proposed zoning amendments bring the City ordinance into conformity with State law while still allowing for local flexibility in relocation and discouraging new impacts; such as the lighting emanating from electronic billboards in residential areas. State law allows for billboards to move in the immediate vicinity of their existing location or as negotiated with the City. The proposed City ordinance would also allow the City to move billboards to Manufacturing and General Commercial areas of the City, away from existing residential and gateway areas. The proposed geography for relocation opens up much of the industrial area on the west side of 1-215. Finding: The proposed zoning text amendments are designed to be consistent with City master plan goals while also remaining consistent with State law. Petitions 400-06-51,PLNPCN12010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 Published Date: FebruarylS,2011 21 3. Whether a proposed text amendment is consistent with the purposes and provisions of any applicable overlay zoning districts which may impose additional standards; and Amok Analysis: The current and newly proposed ordinance encourages the relocation of billboards onto locations outside of historical preservation overlay districts. The new ordinance would allow billboards within the approach area of the Airport (Airport Influence Overlay), but billboards would be no more impactful than allowable buildings or on-premise signs in that overlay district. One of the provisions of the proposed ordinance is to limit height of new billboards to the same height of on-premise signage. There is a provision to subject billboard lighting in Airport Influence Overlay Zones to Airport lighting restrictions. The ordinance has little or no effect on other overlay districts (transitional, groundwater, etc.). Finding: The proposed zoning map amendment is consistent with overlay districts. 4. The extent to which a proposed text amendment implements best current, professional practices of urban planning and design. Analysis: Changes in State law over the last fifteen years, along with the industry practice of acquiring permanent easement for billboards and the adoption of taxing billboards as personal property as tax policy, has created a situation where non-conforming billboards, which generate little tax revenue, are suppressing development that is in conformity with master plan policies and which also generates housing, employment and tax revenue. Billboard laws vary from State to State and City to City. Fig iiak states outlaw the construction of new billboards, conversely some cities, such as New York have use off-premise signage to create lively and bright sections of their community (Times Square). The regulation of off-premise advertising can play an important role in defining the character of a city. For example: Las Vegas, a desert resort, allows for numerous electronic billboards to create a bright and lively atmosphere. Conversely Palm Springs, also a desert resort, prohibits billboards in the City to create more formal resort feel. The proposed ordinance is part of an overall effort to accentuate Salt Lake City's physical environment by protecting views of the mountains and the eliminating unnecessary visual clutter. The proposed ordinance codifies a Salt Lake City policy closer to that of Palm Springs. Locations that ban electronic billboards (as reported by USA Today) include; Hawaii, San Francisco, Montana, Denver, Gilbert AZ, Pima County AZ, Amarillo TX, Ft. Worth, Dallas, Galveston, Houston, Austin, St Petersburg FL, Knoxville TN, Durham NC, Vermont, and Maine. Other cities in Utah that prohibit the construction of new billboards include Provo, Kaysville, Lehi and Park City, as well as newly incorporated cities such as Holladay and Cottonwood Heights. Finding: The proposed zoning text amendment is supported by general policy of increasing housing employment and tax revenue by discouraging the suppression of development on lots occupied by billboards. The proposed ordinance codifies a desire to eliminate visual clutter and to accentuate the physical characteristic of Salt Lake City's physical setting. Amok Petitions 400-06-51,PLNPCM2010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 Published Date FebruarylS,2011 22 Summary Staff is recommending the postponement of a decision regarding Petition 400-06-51, transit shelter advertising, in order to allow further analysis of the issues. Staff is recommending that the Planning Commission forward a positive recommendation to the City Council regarding the adoption of an ordinance that codifies petitions PLNPCM2010-00032 and PLNPCM2010-00717 and accomplishes the following: Eliminates the billboard bank: • State Law allows billboards to move within the general vicinity of their existing sites and billboard companies often own the land or easements on many of the sites that are conflicting with neighborhoods. • Billboard companies have expressed an interest in maintaining existing distribution throughout the City (which means maintaining them east of I-215 where all residential areas are located), • Therefore the premise of encouraging the movement of billboards out of neighborhoods into manufacturing area has been undermined and the Billboard Bank is no longer effective for its original intended purpose of moving billboards out of residential areas into less conflicting areas of the City. The three year banking period has been eliminated o Billboards will be expected to be relocated to a new area when they are removed from an old area, with no time lapse, otherwise they are deemed removed. Still allows for relocation. • The ordinance allows for relocation to Manufacturing and select General Commercial zoning districts (but not on gateways streets or within 600 feet of residential zoning) for those instances where billboards may wish to move. o The proposed ordinance actually increases the geography of where billboards may move by opening the entire west side Manufacturing areas (west of I-215) to billboard relocation (excluding gateway streets). Acids several new gateway streets: o 5600 West, 7200 West and the proposed Mountain View Corridor freeway were added as gateways because the general area was opened for billboards. Billboards have not been allowed on these streets in the past. They are now classified as Gateway Streets because the new ordinance would allow billboards in adjacent Manufacturing zoning districts. • The 900 South off-ramp was added for clarification (I-15 is already a gateway) Eliminates special gateways: e Special Gateways previously allowed for limited billboard movement on several select streets. o Policy changes, such as prohibiting billboards as part of the North Temple Plan, have altered the concept of special gateways. Defines electronic billboards; • The ordinance includes a definition and detailed requirements for electronic billboards in the event that existing boards are relocated or new ones are authorized for external reasons. Petitions 400-06-51,P1.NPCM2010-00032,PLNPCM12010-00717 Published Date. Febi uarvt 8,2011 2J Prohibits electronic billboards: • The proposed ordinance prohibits the construction of new electronic billboards (the City presentlywm,, has 6 electronic billboards—three of which are in dispute) Options for the Planning Commission to consider: Recommending adoption of the ordinance with a statement to the City Council that the Planning Commission will continue with further review of the issue. Recommend expanding or reducing the zoning districts where billboards are allowed to move. Recommend that billboards be allowed to convert to electronic billboards in those zoning districts where billboards are allowed to relocate. Recommend that static billboards may be converted to electronic billboards with the removal of equal or greater square footage of the static billboard being converted (or provide cash in lieu of removal in the event that there are no static billboards available for removal). Amok Petitions 400-06-51,PLNPC\12010-00032,PLNPCM2010-007 17 Published Date. February!8,2011 24 Public Utilities Justin Stoker We have no comment on the proposed text amendments. 0 1111 1 4 " Justin D. Stoker, PE, LEED®AP, CFM Building review Larry Butcher Engineering Randy Drummond Doug, after reviewing the proposed text amendments listed above, we find no concerns with the proposed amendments. Randy Transportation Barry Walsh . The division of transportation review comments are as follows: The text addresses transportation safety issues with references to sec 21A.46.060 sign prohibited - "E" portable (locations) "G" Unsafe, hazardous. & "H" confuse traffic. and does not change compliance with remaining section of 21A.46 with primary attention to sec 21A.46.070 "D" Traffic hazards, which are reviewed on a case by case basis. Sincerely, Barry Walsh • Proposed Ordinance Proposal which eliminates billboard bank, eliminates Special Gateway Streets and modifies Gateway Streets, establishes lighting policies, expands the relocation area for billboards to all Manufacturing zones, defines electronic billboards and prohibits electronic billboards. 21A.46.16O: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to.areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. B. Definitions: _ BILLBOARD: A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. t^__ __ ___ ^ ^ramno _n r _---^`--_rC,�=c,:_t—r--� DII I n Into, ;II;., _vI `.h2 BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard iii Salt Lake City. ,DWELL TIME The length of time that era!}o_cs_between to t, imoues. or ornohicS on ormatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sign., dornatad:Indent:Rr;tline: 0" For er e I:Font:Cold EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction v./as issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:Any off-premise sign,video display, proiected image,or similar device with text.images,or graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include, but are not limited to,signs that use light emitting diodes (LED), plasma displays,fiber optics.or other technology that results in bright, high-resolution text. images,and graphics. FOOT CANDLE: the English unit of measurement for luminance.which is equal to < (Formaetad:Indent:First line: 0' one lumen, incident upon an area of one square foot. GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.33" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5.5600 West; 6.2100 South Street/Parleys Way from Interstate 15 to;200E�=Foothill Boulevard 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 3. Foothill Drive/500 South from G--=dam;an Nay1000 East to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from-1eta-zt :3==-Redvioccl Road to 39O-Eao-t 1000 East 10.500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16.600 North from 800 West to 300 West. 17. 7200 West ANN 18. Mountain View/5600 West Highway corridor(as identified and to be constructed according to UDOT plans) 19. 900 South 1-15 off-ramp to West Temple NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPEC AI atr"motc.. ce � Salt Cit y: (.:300A-le-st and t Formatted:Indent:Le`. 0.96" 2. 't nn Sc b 3v 200 Ea `.?::d Q00 East- 2. Mate—S4rco: ',.as^ 21n2Sa.,. n4 S!Feat 600 C-cu ?and 2100 Said._ LUMINENCE: The intensity of light falling on a subsurface at a defined distance from / mok the source. MOTION The depiction of movement or change of position of text, images.or Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab graphics. Motion shall include, but not be limited to.visual effects such as dissolving �Formatted:Font:Not Bold and fading text and images. running sequential text. graphic bursts. lighting that resembles zooming,twinkling. or sparkling,changes in light or color, transitory bursts of light intensity. moving patterns or bands of light, expanding or contracting_ shapes.and similar actions., —i Formatted:Font:Bold TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: 0.25",List tab or advertisement. -- TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text, images,and graphics on an electronic 4-, —c matted:Font:Helvetica,12pt j sien to change to a different text. images, or graphics on a subsequent sign face. Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab C. "..,C n vF l h!ambo. :`E J nl = ^' — F-'rc : in s2,-1_a4 c( I than the ox:so-ti., t,111;, rc1a Bil boards.y Prohibited: Ne,',Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. D. Relocation of Billboards: Existing billboards may be relocated as required and (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0",Hanging: 0.25 authorized by the requirements of Utah state law. Relocation shall follow the general priority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F and only be allowed in areas (Formatted:Font:Not Bold outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.1 of this ordinance,unless otherwise negotiated with the Mayor or designee. OE. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner - (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2.Application:Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars ($111.00). E. r'.- ---Fo_.I.._ =`,=�-. illb ,d- -eva!:A -a nc000n c:-i =-^ 4'ri1-:tee d ...r._;,t to-n..2 nit�.,:u-a� ....:,�.^.. `::bcootio .D1 of this coctio , J.. cumoo. �i,o .,.j`,^.=.!!orZ:.ie-a-b Q-erd bank e�ooun- fe th-e✓i�!.^,carc ".v r o-41-E. ref!oct billboard cre`?::c far to Do s t- -o F. Priority For Removal OF Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; I o.ss",Lei: 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or any gateway zoning district "U-O - ';-or on gateway streets shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; ns h lib - Iv. I. h ., h-G _ -;i;y,-rho ,.,� :j; .,.�... , - `! °ha!!a-et b000.— f; ottis ---- =---- - ,s,'n;,--=-as- =!!two p.-) c,;r,`„ • • Fl of this os ea-e$4ts s ^SS (�:",':f jet lS^, =o footage ey!a!to or greater than the lower priority-oi-144ev'-a.e^cfei�d in the-k,illboard ew S s b-it Bard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection Fl of this section,or its oLea sor,nonconforming billboards,two (2)subset on F2 of this :ectinr succpriority ln the, ., .. ,cr its .,�.,or, billboards may be cr�+�i,. b44bee-rd owner's-billboard Lan,e'count to effete •wt the S;i, c subsoctian F3 of this section, cr its successor,billboard tc allow:the ccr:St.nct,cr of a new billboa d.F Tr purposes of thic c et:^ ,the ti,o (2) dig e Fr!,sty bill a do or-edited in the billboard bank accou n be ' e-y-n-nce-te-e e* etuata the-billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. c_Liifo Of B:;ib o:rd-C—F—& An-y biilbo.-d—credits n=-t use=S'-w- n-t-14ctL J2e) ,.n-n4hh-c of thoi roa n S ! nd b-r---Ero f4rthez va4u or except' -!��__ n ran r;t i n. d e p _.ant t"suboec FA, o--t io ~t.. h c-of;r?-f_rthcrxa.k're er .t,?,r H. �;!;:'-?-;z c`t rr` =:s--r;ter ..�.-�.!�-��-a-:�! .,...;:� .,,... ma other sfa o c1-14- '".-re-..:`'-,=cr bi-Ilb__rd credits.Trancferrod �-nerd .,e-d4e .. �-hr-oh are -?� -. bc ^..use of the prioxity.. ouie ^e-s=c '.c-s.e- tiara F this action or_t ` - u-ntt-IP.: rey-'o have-become h ecome efta__- -the - . . .—%raj .• �.;.,/ -,-, ..- ; o.,-..�--i'L'-� vti`'�t... -- ..c... , �-., S^_ G Double Faced Billboards:Q:>.s!ttien-Relocation of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall recoiv= i!!bew=d�se4 eY- Y of on?bli:-ea;bbe allowed to relocate as a two faced billboard or combined as a single face billboard, provided that the relocated advertising square footage is no greater than the square footage of the original billboard and does not --- exceed the size requirements outlined in 21A.46.160.L . riFl. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. • • !'.f. Permitted Zoning Districts:N-c-=Relocated billboards may be constructed only in the arc-2;dor,tifiod on the bitboerd map.-Manufacturing and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.or located within 600 feet of a gateway street or residential zoning district. Billboards are not to be relocated to the CG General Commercial zoning district that is mooned and located between Interstate-15,300 West. 200 South and the 900 South 1-15 off- ramp., > J." '.� Billboard relocation or remodeling Permits: 1.Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees:The fees for a new btiboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96",Tab stops: code as adopted by the city;and 1.13",Left b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. ��_ ., h111vea-ct p choi1LTi„h�n��.�_�tl the o�C -+._t-h-a h'll YI 1 • -. `�" f - . .. .-rr..��., ,,..� if-Sc; [Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" of 7.,.E e foot M�.a 1�=��uCwr`t=-'L414w ecoot notion of the ee,..-ci1-'9e4-,. 7 1T.t the .- - . ......,. . T ,,.,.., ;-;gih n.,....�.,�.,:..,,, .,, w��:.v,,.,�ti�•�:��'�=-L��-�,� +Tr_hlhbha.=rd o. r.o. ., =r�V fo rvt_' h:ll:. -,�. of ,�-��5� ..,�"----• ��".- ,— Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.05",Tab stops: 1 .. --- --- 1.25",Left J b.Tho nt mbo of—b14 a-cd-a :,ho-ce c '1 h.::Ik??-r-:t c,r stsuc l now-L;'bcnrd' 0 5� ''; .rid !r 1 ',. h"I t ti c3-1•:-:=. �c'�-a' �`�}E,t-t-c; .., .,.. [Formatted:Indert:Left: 0.71" _tk I k r.-,. c.n.J Formatted:Irdent:First line: 0.25" • NK.Ns—Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection Q-D of this section,or its successor, no paw-billboard may be constructed or relocated within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway street. Special Gateway 1 If a nonconforming llh^ rd demolished within a spe�!al gateway, h.e bt!b".:'r—'� ' . nenecnfor,,,i ,� b, „�� .:,demolished c within. .,r,c ,y..,., 1a`y,t„ .,.. ,.. Formatted:Indent:Left: 0",Hanging: 0.25" ewncr may construct a new billboard a!^ g4—se-me- ! gnte"w-ay!„ a ^-g' di°tr.ct eg;.c-I-to or sacs restrictive than that from which th in, 1=Il ea,4' we S renewed and s4..=hj::t to Et'bseGt nd Softh;s S gilon, provided that the cis-of the now billboard does net mmee+tho amount of billboard credits i.n the `!ti f a cm,' g h Ilh rl pursuant +hi I �: 2. .. ......,,. ,.,.,., C' ,.cn„ .a!',^,';��y ..I 2-ar rLrS' w to , .� :;.,.,"✓{ Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: -cl_cc,ue-bilbca,d 4e `,h!„tham-Fa!billboard b ti-k.Credits fo-a 0.8S",Left 1-4: aLI7-t-:1. a!i5.1.af4 o c..„`r"c'G whh;n a op vial gateway shall be t� 22;:rthin a separate bbn. .-1 ccoun,for-each special atov.'a .A permit fc �G2-nr.:;...ction ^a-nrc1.1 .,1-1 l-cnc.? cJcl-2P.-+b + cer4 n m #he+•,lc-ort 2-the of the Clan oh-ic-i of the nonconfo„i TJ -aSmNy °L. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any n-e::billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15') in height and fifty feet(50') in width. OM.Temporary Embellishments: to-ori p n,(1 eo,,,) C<<r._.. Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71", stops: Tab.� r 3F� ,-mo `aInier Ine- -fa-cc of a't':!I=a-c.pd--en1 ti_! + .��o t(G'� I :. l--?ram= ca :o_,gi__ -'— I 0.58",Left c.t-C .,t �h�lir-'��,.i-'J Wit;..c� . 2. Ho to o(i:j chz!! be_f,-2into-1n-e_d-cn w:aTIiaac::d Temporary Embellishments are prohibited (Formatted:Indent:First line: 0.25" INJ. Height:The highest point of any new ,:t-h-!!n^;mi4s shall not be more than: • • • 1—Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or the maximum height for a r-o;maseri Indent:Left: 0.63",Hanging: pole sign in the applicable zoning district,whichever is less, unless 0.25" otherwise authorized by State law. 2. If a street within cr eet-(100')of the billbo^-rd-T^er red-i,em- (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" street at the point at-which the billboard is perpend cola tc the ctrcet, is on a different grade th^n the nevi billboard,t'venty fit -poet .'e the ;p�,,me t-st a n of the s :-tcaet 0. If the provisions-cf-su-beeo:'^ .-R2 c -this section,or its succeescr s-bsection apply to more than one-street,the now bilt a;r_'r ay ho the #e, of the two (2) ho hts. ig �O. Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district,freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line.This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T-P. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred(300)square CFormaenc.:Indent Left: 0.71",Tab stops: feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) Loss",Leo linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large,on the same side of the street. 3. Electronic billboards shall not be located closer than sixteen hundred (1600) linear feet from any other electronic billboard on the same or oonosite side ., of the street O Lighting: Nighttime illumination of billboards may not Clare directly onto the roadway or sidewalk or across orcoelty lines. Billboards located within Residential, Mixed-Use, CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit bob seen the hours of midnight and 6 am. Billboards located in en Airport Influence Overlay Zone are subject to Airport restrictions regarding_lighting, • AIN R: Electronic Billboards: 1. New Electronic Billboards are prohibited: Electronic billboards constructed or Formatted:List Paragraph,Numbered+Level: reconstructed for any reason after the date of adoption of this ordinance are 1+Numbering Style:1,2,3,...+Start at:1+ Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 0.25"+Indent limited to the following: at: 0.5" Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.5", No bullets or a. Motion numbering Any motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face\(Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Electronic billboards,shall have only static text. images.and Graphics. Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start b. Dwell time, at 1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ Indent at: 2.5" The text,image. or display on an electronic sign may not change mores, Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 t Not Bold than once every twenty four 241 hours. Twirl time between \ p' subsequent text, images. or display shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" c. Brightness Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 1 The illumination of arty Electronic Billboard shall not increase the'-\ Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ ambient liahtina level more than 0.3 foot candles when measured by a ' �1 Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+start I I at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned et: 2.25'+ r foot candle meter perpendicular to the electronic Billboard face at: Indent 1\ Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold i. 150 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface are of not- ' - 1 Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt more than 242 square feet Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" -_-__-15" ] I ii. 200 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area greater Formatted:For (Default)Helvetica,12 than 242 square feet but not more than 378 square feet I•, Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",lumbered " Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start III_ 250 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area ore-^.ter hi at: i;2.5" Left+Ali,nc-riot: 2.25"+ I Indent at: 2.5" than 378 square feet but not more than 672 square feet I, ---1 Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold i'i. 350 feet for an electronic billboard with a surface area oreater Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" Formatted:Indent:Hanging: 0.19", than 672 square feet., • Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:i,ii, I i,...+Start at: 1+Alignment:Right+Aligned d. Display period at: 1.5"+Indent at: 1.75" ,Electronic billboards.may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of, Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12pt �) •midnight. and 6 a.m if they are located within 600 Feet of a residential. •',, Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ mixed-use. downtown. Sugar House Business District. Gateway. Level 5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,..+Start at:1-:-Alignment:Len •Aliened at 25-i--� Neighborhood Commercial. Community Business, or Community ` I Indent at: 2.5" Shopping Center z onlna district., Fmatted:Font Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold• For ormatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt • Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt _) • • e. Controls, Formatted:Indent:Left: I",Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start i. All electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ control or other mechanism that automatically controls the sign's Indent at: 2.5",Tab stops: 1.25",Left brightness and display period as provided above. (Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold (Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt ii. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sign. the applicant shall certify that the sign has been tested and • complies with the motion, dwell time.brightness,and other requirements herein. i:i. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sign shall submit an annual report-to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion.dwell time,brightness,and other requirements herein. (Formatted:List Paragraph US. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. VT. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection '!S of this section,or its successor subsection,upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. 1P1U.Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for — - _ _- ___irrigation_does.not.exist on_the property_ar in_thestreet_ight_cf way-adjacent-to_such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. {V. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. WU. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance:Construction,demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance and the Tree Protection ordinance-_ -Z--X.Subdivision Registration:To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary,such subdivision. • -(1) _;'_r^ '.24W cs i 3 v,e-en 1500 Ncr<I; North cc--.4F.cont.:o the t'c... '- `p,r,-:x:ct. b-`ram. -`!„n, /�..__=�6^^-;.ram,—:I:-.• C, ^-S ;-'.•��h ^_-''O.:.., .,II nthTI_ _-- - - LAIh-9w ds- (6)C�rCcf-cd bili oordY-I o-tl- c-^c-^v�r�i�€ as-g covio 4zt '` ov -;G C -G =C;t C£ G, ,^: .• h'hi.,_ r-of-r.:-n- ._"V of ths0004to , .t.. ..c,..,.-..c-� r1 �-�� C::o , p•rat J :....c:rdn .,,:v-ncr �'al^c-wed e�L2p�Tm-aar.r'4otod by .cc,,,H-Y.v s.n o J oh (Ord. 72-08§2, 2008: Ord.42-08§ 12,2008: Ord. 13-04§§25,26, 27,2004: Ord. 25-00§§ 1-3,2000: Ord.83-98§§ 12-14, 1998:Ord.88-95§ 1 (Exh. A), 19951 Billboards Permitted within the CG. M-1 and M-2 Zones (with exclusions) in Salt Lake City C --- 1 I t. , = I 1" ill , _ _..„...., .. •• . " N '�l'_j1� 51 , FT L ..- I-1• ,—; ��T7 i, ' ll�S ; r ... • ; • 1. fl•t _L Jill_ I1. I 1— TEMPLE-11 � I1i T � J s` J ' NORTH ._ _ 1 r I _ �11� Is.— --- � ` coos „ I I CI 1 T soo s r' / Ai�l Aif1 1 a L1t. fall 1 600 S 1 � • ,ITi I I -13-11.77:7E7:::::=it' I I {� ie i ' M ' II�f 1-L. '1 - Q I �II1-` ,'T'!--j.1=liC---1-: (11--Tr 1-1-11 yT . . , ilk ."I L ir3:=1,--__.--1-Firi--b:-L-F1 'le- I---"L F---1-2,5:;-.=-1— __F.- H i Legend --- ZONING II I so .- ' `1 �LI1 �� 1IL_ M-11 frl r M-2MI Gateway I - Map created by SLC Planning Division 2011 NORTH • • 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMO © 2) December 2,2010 Briefing memo for December 9 meeting L.9 Briefing for =f' !!! , ; Planning Commission Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: December 2,2010 Re: Billboard Ordinance: December 9d'briefing on proposed code amendments regarding billboards and public transit(public amenity)advertising. Petitions:400-06-51, PLNPCM2010-00032, PLNPCM2010-00717 Background There are presently three separate petitions regarding the regulation of off-premise advertising in Salt Lake City. Petition 400-06-51:Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. PLNPCM2010-00032:Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards.The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. PLNPCM2010-00717:Zoning Text Amendment,Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards.Currently,the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 18,2010. There will be a briefing at the December 9,2010 meeting in preparation for a more formal staff report and public hearing not yet scheduled. Because of the complicated nature of these petitions,the Staff is requesting that the Planning Commission hold an extensive working session prior to a public hearing. A working session has been tentatively scheduled for January 12, 2011. A working subcommittee may also be advantageous. O Attached are two working drafts illustrating potential changes.These drafts are provided to begin the discussion only. No comments from other departments or the industry have yet been integrated into the discussion drafts. The Planning Commission will be expected to address major policy issues prior to finalizing a draft. Young Electric Sign Company has offered to provide a seminar regarding the technical details of electronic signage. They have invited staff and Planning Commission members to view their presentation; as early as December, in order to provide background for the proposed January working session.. Any Planning Commissioner who is interested in attending should let staff know. Issues Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. Issues: • This is a potential method of paying for public amenities. • Other communities along the Wasatch Front are presently using advertising as a method of paying for transit shelters. Advertising has been used to pay for other public amenities such as public toilettes or kiosks for news racks etc. Questions: • • How much advertising in the public way is appropriate? How much advertising creates clutter? • Should it be limited to transit shelter advertising or are other forms acceptable? • Is this unfair competition? PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards -A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. Issues: • The original billboard bank was instigated in 1993. Changes in State Law have made the Salt Lake billboard bank ineffective. • Billboards impact City revenues and have a negative effect on development(they are taxed as personal property, providing minimal tax generation after 16 years—yet they often occupy high-profile locations, effectively preventing higher tax generating development). Questions: • What relocation is acceptable? • Are there methods of decreasing billboard impacts? • Are there methods of reducing the negative tax impact on the community? • Are there methods of reducing visual or physical impacts on the city? • Are there more appropriate methods of spacing billboards (i.e. concentration-similar to Time Square vs. dispersal-spaced every 500 feet). PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment,Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning CI Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. Issues: • The Federal Government has not completed studies regarding highway safety. • Electronic billboards are undefined by City Ordinances. Questions: • Are electronic billboards appropriate in the city? If so,where? • Can conversion be used to reduce overall numbers of billboards? • Can billboards effectively be integrated into building architecture(rather than free standing signs)? • What are the traffic impacts? • What are the impacts on adjacent landowners? • What are appropriate levels of illumination and timing? • 0 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMO O 3) January 12,2011 Briefing memo Utah State Tax Commission 2011 Recommended Personal Property Valuation Schedule for Class 16 Long Life Property • Examples of Property Include: Burled Cable Bulk Storage Tanks,Underground&Surface Billboards Oil and Gas Gathering Systems Pipelines Sign Towers Grain Elevators,Non Farm Skl Lift&Tram Towers Broadcast and Cell Towers Storage and Shipping Containers Truck Scales The following schedule Is recommended for valuing Class 16 property for the , 2011 assessment year: i Percent Good i' Year of Acquisition of Acquisition Cost 2010- 1st Year 92% 2009-2nd Year 86% 2008- 3rd Year 85% '• 2007-4th Year 84% • ' 2006- 5th Year 83% 2005-6th Year 82% 2004-7th Year 81% • 2003-8th Year 76% 2002- 9th Year 71% 2001-10th Year 64% 2000-11th Year 59% I 1999-12th Year 63% 1998-13th Year 46% • 1997-14th Year 40% ' • 1996-16th Year 34% r 1995-16th Year 28% 1994-17th Year 22% , • 1993-18th Year 15% 1992-19th Year 8% and prior i • Class 16,Long Life Property Is Defined as: Property having a long physical life,subject to little obsolescence. • i, 16. • I. _. .. — . w 0 �°,s, , I€ L �4, Briefing for • �' �a ",,- �t `� Planning Commission ...... '',i e OHM II`\\.mil Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie, Senior Planner Date: December 2,2010 0 Re: Billboard Ordinance: December 9th briefing on proposed code amendments regarding billboards and public transit(public amenity)advertising. Petitions: 400-06-51, PLNPCM2010-00032, PLNPCM2010-00717 Background There are presently three separate petitions regarding the regulation of off-premise advertising in Salt Lake City. Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards -A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently,the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 18, 2010. Q There will be a briefing at the December 9, 2010 meeting in preparation for a more formal staff report and public hearing not yet scheduled. Because of the complicated nature of these petitions,the Staff is requesting that the Planning Commission hold an extensive working session prior to a public hearing. A working session has been tentatively scheduled for January 12, 2011. A working subcommittee may also be advantageous. CO Attached are two wOrkingdrafts illustrating potential-changes. These drafts are provided to-begin The discussion only. No comments from other departments or the industry have yet been integrated into the discussion drafts. The Planning Commission will be expected to address major policy issues prior to finalizing a draft. Young Electric Sign Company has offered to provide a seminar regarding the technical details of electronic signage. They have invited staff and Planning Commission members to view their presentation; as early as December, in order to provide background for the proposed January working session.. Any Planning Commissioner who is interested in attending should let staff know. Issues Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. Issues: • This is a potential method of paying for public amenities. • Other communities along the Wasatch Front are presently using advertising as a method of paying for transit shelters. Advertising has been used to pay for other public amenities such as public toilettes or kiosks for news racks etc. Questions: S • How much advertising in the public way is appropriate?How much advertising creates clutter? • Should it be limited to transit shelter advertising or are other forms acceptable? • Is this unfair competition? PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. Issues: • The original billboard bank was instigated in 1993. Changes in State Law have made the Salt Lake billboard bank ineffective. • Billboards impact City revenues and have a negative effect on development(they are taxed as personal property, providing minimal tax generation after 16 years—yet they often occupy high-profile locations, effectively preventing higher tax generating development). Questions: • What relocation is acceptable? • Are there methods of decreasing billboard impacts? • Are there methods of reducing the negative tax impact on the community? • Are there methods of reducing visual or physical impacts on the city? • Are there more appropriate methods of spacing billboards (i.e. concentration-similar to Time Square vs. dispersal-spaced every 500 feet). PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment,Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. Issues. • The Federal Government has not completed studies regarding highway safety. • Electronic billboards are undefined by City Ordinances. CQuestions: • Are electronic billboards appropriate in the city? If so,where? • Can conversion be used to reduce overall numbers of billboards? • Can billboards effectively be integrated into building architecture(rather than free standing signs)? • What are the traffic impacts? • What are the impacts on adjacent landowners? • What are appropriate levels of illumination and timing? O 0 0 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMO 3) January 12,2011 0 Briefing memo O ��- 't Briefing for Planning Commission Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: January 12,2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: January 12th briefing on proposed code amendments regarding billboards and public transit(public amenity)advertising. O Petitions:400-06-51, PLNPCM2010-00032, PLNPCM2010-00717 Background There are presently three separate petitions regarding the regulation of off-premise advertising in Salt Lake City. An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 18, 2010. There was an initial briefing in December 9,2010 meeting in preparation for a work session on January 12,2012. Some Planning Commissioners met with YESCO representatives on January 5 to discuss technical aspects of electronic billboards. Petition 400-06-51:Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. Issues: • Off-premise signage in the public right-of-way,including bus benches,was prohibited in the 1970's. • Previous use of signage in the right-of way resulted in complaints of clutter. • Previous signage in the right-of-way resulted in complaints of businesses putting signage directly in front of competitors,etc. • Salt Lake City has liberalized some signage since the 1970's:Specifically banners and A-frame directional signs O • UTA(and Lamar Advertising)approached the City regarding the potential for advertising to pay for transit shelters. • Using advertising to pay for other potential public furniture and services has also been considered (restrooms,bike rental,etc.) Questions: • Are the original concerns that led to SLC prohibiting signage in the right-or-way still valid? • Is this a legitimate method of paying for public amenities? • How much advertising in the public way is appropriate?How much advertising creates clutter? • Should it be limited to transit shelter advertising or are other forms acceptable? • Is this unfair competition? • Is there any need to change at all? Is the status quo acceptable? PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment,Billboards -A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. Issues: • The current ordinance was adopted in 1993 and was intended to be a cap and reduce program, allowing billboards to relocate to more appropriate locations while prohibiting an increase in the overall number of billboards in the City and allowing for a decrease. • A billboard bank was set up to accommodate movement and to prioritize areas of acceptable relocation. • State law has changed considerably since 1993. • State law allows billboards to move to any non-residential property within a variable distance from the original location for multiple reasons, if the City does not allow the movement; the City is obligated to purchase the billboard. • State law requires the purchase of a billboard to include damages to the"package". Billboards are often sold in groups to one advertiser;that group constitutes a package. • Changes in State law have left the SLC billboard bank largely irrelevant. • Many billboards in the City were erected before there were any sign regulations and they remain in areas where they have long been non-conforming. • Billboards are amortized for tax value and pay taxes on 8% of their original value after 19 years. • • By State law, billboards are the only non-conforming use that cannot be removed through the use of amortization. • There are numerous scenarios in Salt Lake City where the presence of a billboard suppresses the redevelopment potential of the underlying land, as well as examples of redevelopment with billboards. Questions: • Should the billboard bank be eliminated? • What relocation is acceptable? • Are there methods of decreasing billboard impacts? • Are there methods of reducing the negative tax impact on the community? • Are there methods of reducing visual or physical impacts on the city? • Are there more appropriate methods of spacing billboards (i.e. concentration-similar to Time Square vs. dispersal-spaced every 500 feet). PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. Issues: • The current ordinance is silent regarding electronic billboards. • Three electronic billboards exist in Salt Lake City. Numerous electronic on-premise sings exist. • State law allows electronic billboards but does not require local government to allow the conversion of old billboards to an electronic format. • Electronic billboards are the emerging format for billboards. • Electronic billboards require a greater investment and offer an increased potential revenue source for the owner, therefore their removal costs are also higher. Questions: • How should the City define and regulate electronic billboards? • Are electronic billboards appropriate in the city? If so,where? C • Can conversion be used to reduce overall numbers of billboards? • Can billboards effectively be integrated into building architecture(rather than free standing signs)? • Are there safety concerns • What are the traffic impacts? • What are the impacts on adjacent landowners? • What are appropriate levels of illumination and timing? • Should spacing rules for electronic billboards be modified to allow for a Time Square type area? Draft ordinances The draft ordinances provided to the Planning Commission are to begin a dialogue and contain the following assumptions: Both drafts allows the Administration to determine the level of off-premise advertising allowed on transit shelters or other public furniture: THIS IS NOT A RECCOMENDATION, but merely a starting point for discussion. The Planning Commission may choose to maintain current conditions or define a multitude of options. Both drafts eliminate the billboard bank and allow relocation only according to State Law or as negotiated on a case-by-case basis with the City(the draft provides guidance for relocation negotiation). One draft prohibits the allowance of electronic billboards. The other draft allows the conversion of static billboards to electronic billboards only if multiple signs are removed. This draft also allows the Planning Q Commission to waive spacing requirements in order to consolidate electronic billboards(rather than disperse), in order to create a"Time Square"type district. There are numerous other alternatives: including simply defining where billboards would be allowed to be converted to electronic. Next steps It is suggested that the Planning Commission discuss whether a subcommittee is necessary to research the issue. It is suggested that an "issues only" hearing be held on January 26 , 2010 so that the full scope of issues may be considered in advance of making a decision. Because the conversion of static billboards to electronic is being held for 180 days following the initiation of the petition (October 21, 2010), it is suggested that any changes regarding electronic billboards be made by the Planning Commission AND City Council prior to the mid-April 2011. All three petitions are interconnected, but the electronic billboard petition has a time frame associated with it and may need to be expedited if necessary. • • Discussion Draft Proposal which allows transit advertising, eliminates billboard bank, defines electronic billboards and allows limited conversion to electronic billboards when accompanied by a reduction in overall number of billboards. 21A.46.058 TRANSIT SHELTER AND PUBLIC AMENITY ADVERTISING Transit shelter and public amenity advertising shall be allowed only as part of a shelter at a bus stop or public transit stop or station,or a public amenity,pursuant to an approved and executed agreement between the City and a provider of transit shelters or public amenities,which sets forth the regulation of size,content.placement.design and materials used in the construction of said advertising and shelters and oublic amentity. For purposes of this section."public amenity"means an item generally located in the • public way to provide a public service.which may include, but is not limited to,a kiosk displaying way finding signage or accommodating news racks or other public • information,public restrooms,public furniture such as benches or trash receptacles or public services such as bike sharing. The common element is that they are offered for public consumption and provided as contract services to the City. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising shall in no case be larger than 48"by 72" and shall be limited to no more than three panels per shelter or kiosk.unless otherwise restricted further by contract. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising is only authorized when located adjacent to non-residential. RB. RMU.or RO zoning districts. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising display may not contain nudity. pornography,or indecent or vulgar pictures.graphics or language or advertising of illegal products. 21A.46.060: SIGNS SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITED IN ALL ZONING DISTRICTS: The following exterior signs, in addition to all other signs not expressly permitted by this chapter, are prohibited in all zoning districts and shall not be erected: • A.Animated signs excluding public service signs; B.Any snipe sign; C.Balloons; D.Bench signs'exceot transit shelter and public amenity advertisina specifically 'horized by section 21AA6.58 E.Portable signs,except where specifically permitted by district sign regulations; F.Signs overhanging the property line other than signs that are permitted under the sign regulations applicable to each zoning district; G.Signs which are structurally unsafe,hazardous or violate the uniform building code or the uniform fire code; H.Signs located near streets which imitate or are easily confused with official traffic signs and use words such as"stop","look","danger","go slow","caution"or"warning", except where such words are part of the name of a business or are accessory to Coparking lots;and I.Painted signs which do not meet the definition of wall signs.(Ord.53-00§3,2000: Ord.88-95§1(Exh.A),1995) • 21A.46.160:BILLBOARDS: A.Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. • B. Definitions: BILLBOARD:A freestanding ground sign located on industrial,commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold,offered or existing on the property where the sign is located.A billboard does not include transit shelter and public amenity advertising specifically authorized by Section 21A.46.058 BILLBOARD BANK:An acclunt:rg oyster!estabfshcd by the-city to kecp track of the-.3r l e d-squa.e-feeotage-of-noncen#erming-bil;bia ds-removcd pursuant-to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT:An-en-tag-into a b reea:d-c,wr cr's billboard-bank-account-tat shone tha number ard sq.icre fcctag2 of dcrr c!chcd nonconforming billboards- BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. DWELL TIME The length of time that elapses between text. images.or graphics on Formatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sign, rF«matted:Indentt First line: 0"�_ A� (Formatted:Font:Bold EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use • or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:Any off-premise sign.video display.orofected image.or similar device with text. images.or Graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include. but are not limited to.signs that use light emitting diodes(LED).plasma displays.fiber optics.or other technology that results in bright. high-resolution text. images,and graohics. • (Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" --� GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; (For • matted:Indent:Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5. 5600 West; • e 6.2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10.500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11.600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12.300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South;and 16.600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after ` December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96" 2.400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3.State Street between 600 South and 2100 South;and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. LUMINANCE The photometric cuantity most closely associated with the perception Formatted:Font:Not Bold of brightness. Luminance is measured in candelas per square meters or"nits"for r Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25',Usttab purposes of this ordinance, Formatted:Font:Bold`— MOTION The depiction of movement or chance of cosition of text. images.or -Formatted_Font:Not Bad graphics. Motion shall include. but not be limited to.visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images. runnino sequential text. graphic bursts. lighting that C 3 resembles zooming.twinkling.or sparkling.chances in light or color. transitory bursts of light intensity. moving patterns or bands of light.expanding or contracting � shapes.and similar actions. rormatted:Font:Bold NITS A unit of measure of brightness or luminance. One nit is equal to one Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", candela/square meter. Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: l 0.25",List tab TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. TWiRL TIME The time it takes for static text. images.and graphics on an electronic - Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt sign to change to a different text, images.or graphics on a subsequent sign face. I�or Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab C.Limit On The Total m f ili rds: No-g-reate i' allow_ ' umber of existieg-billbeards,Billboards Prohibited: New Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. D Relocation of Billboards: Existing billboards may be relocated as mandated by the - [Formatted:Indent:Left: 0-;Hanging: 0.25" ) requirements of Utah state law. Additionally. billboards may be relocated from any • zoning district to Manufacturing. Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards, or located within 600 feet of a gateway or special gateway street cr residential zoning district. Voluntary relocation shall follow the priority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F of Formatted:Font:Not Bold this ordinance, unless otherwise negotiated with the City. DE. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner - (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2.Application:Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee:The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars($111.00). E--Gred:ts or-iNgnoonformi-ng-6illbeafd-RemovalAfter-a-nenc©nferm;og-billloard is demolished pursuant-to-a- env-rit i;sued' =s.' sectien D 1 of this section,or its sueo,seer,the city-shall create a billboer -bank- ccouat-for ha billboard-ewner.The aGGGL1Fishall—snoow the-date-of-the.row-revel-and ti?ionfng--distHCt the-defimo144ed • nt^hatl.�^t b b _ and-its-squat'o footage.Ds • - -' r th„bibc#rcw't in any billboard-credit, F.Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards:Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1.Billboards in districts zoned residential,historic,residential R-MU or •---i rammed:Indent:Left:a.nt,Tel)O s: downtown D-1,D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; o.se•,Left 2.Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB,or aiw_gateway; district G t:'. •or on gateway streets shall be removed second; 3.Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last;end 4.A billboa•it owner-rray-demelish-nonocnferrning-bil boan{-of-a-lo pr+ority be • • r prisrityhewevecrthebillboardcredifs for-removing-the4ower-prior4tybillboard shalinot-becomeeffective-for-use-in • constructing-anew-billboard unkl-tva(2 • F1 of this section,or its successor,with a totalsguare-feetage-equal to« greaterth00the;cwer_ffcrty,illbeard-a_ nafs billboardbarkacccurt.If a billboard-o ri has-no-subsection Fl of this section,cr£c successor,nonconforming-billbsard F2 of siaaybe-ereditedan-the • billboard-owner's billboardbank-account-to-effectua:ethebillboard-credits-ef fib,^ i cctcna^.. ^ram •.. - Vow the can rthe-purposes ef-this-section-ihe-two(2) hig itecfin-the billboard ban aesauntean seused onlyonce-taeffecfuate4hebillbcardcredits-ora-lower-priority-billboard, G ife-0t.Billboard-GreditarAnybillboardcredi:s-nct-usedwithin-thiriysix-(3Ci)+rwn,hs of their craatieashalt-expirrandbeof-no;liaber-value-or-use-exeept4hat owes priority credits-effectuated-purnuont to cu shall-expireandbe-of-no-further valuesr-use+r+ithin-sixly-value -months cr -inifial creation: kl-Billboard-SradilcTronc bif,wbifbo-.1cwr2r-nroyrell-srskzavisekaac°.:ra billboa - s.Transferred-billboard credits which arc not effecGiw because of the priority-provisiansufsubseefione-o€4his section Brits-successes; 0 • • • their thirty-xix-(36)-mer ;en-G-ef this-seotion-0c-iis state-sser. • I! Double Faced Billboards:Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two(2) advertising faces shall receive bil4 evwi-credit for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J;I.New Billboard Construction:It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter.In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. Kl.Permitted Zoning Districts:New-Relocated billboards may be constructed only in the area'identified-oo-the-of ieiat-biflbeard-map_Manufacturing.Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not • oriented towards,or located within 600 feet of a gateway or special gateway street or residential zoning district. • U.New-Billboard relocation or remodeling Permits: 1.Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an - (wrreatted:Indent:Left:0.71• application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2.Fees:The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a.Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building Fererlted:Indent Lett osc,rebstops: code as adopted by the city;and Liar,Left b.Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. til-Use Qf Billboar4 Geed s: ',-;-net�'" :;'shall crly-be-Lsucd if th appliEanttras-billboard For n.ro.d:rent:Let 0.71' credits of a cufticicnt number cf cquarc fcc chd-billboaais4o-alfhv constntction the.wew-billboard • • 2.\•:'hcn the,.pc- '` h. r;:.tiv ti,lbcard is issued;the zoning cdmin'stra` . al ct r. 1- :' a-Thess-quare-sootag?of-o-new-b+{{oafs;cr d Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.08",Tab stops: 1.25",Left I, Tr,,... , ber of billb arils.,_cse -q a;e-`ootoge-was u:,cd to allow t`-1a new-bitlboar4ce,nstrucntio V 3-if-the new--billboard uses loss than-he-en•',;re-available-billboard-oredits i Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" biltbeardc and square footago,any rennaini^^ uc,ti-lo^tage shell rainand bank -1 Formatted:Indent:First line: 0.25" Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection O-0_of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway street. . Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway,the I Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special °_68" LeftJ gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to other subsections l?;O7 f,d-S of this section,provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the-an a�p°e+a billboard-banksize of the billboard being relocated.Billboards may not be relocated from other areas onto a special gateway 2.-The deroliticn c-€a-foriscalorr.-.''r,y billbr.Yard-pursuant-ta-this-sestien-shall not accrue inboard-credits-within-he-e,ereral billboard bank-Credits-for--a billboard-den hed-or-oonstfueted-within-a-special gateway-shall-be trc.ckcd within a soparate-lbank ace 14e ecc-i-opee+al gateway.A permit far-the construction-of-a-new billboard-pursuant to this-scctior must ba taken out-within-thlrty-six(36)-nlonths-of-the-demolition-of the noneonforming billboard . Maximum Size:The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard • shall not exceed fifteen feet(15') in height and fifty feet(50') in width. • Temporary Embellishments: Temperer,cmbei!ishcnte sha!1 rot cxcecd ten percent(10',S)cf the Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: advertising face of any-bittboard, ar hatl--n©t-exceed-Eva feet(-5)-41-height l 0.88",Left -- above4;e-blttboard-structure. 2.No-tomporery-embeltt-sh-ment-sha'.l be n1a4ttairae4-o L-a-biltboard-more-than r,,eli,e (,2)mernths- Temporary Embellishments are prohibited • (Formatted:Indent:First line: 0.25" Rn. Height:The highest point of any new t_;l:cerd:hillbo?rd excluding-temporacr embeltiehrrcnt:-shall not be more than: --Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or the maximum height for a • (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.63",Hanging: pole sign in the applicable zoning district.whichever is less. Unless 10.2s otherwise authorized by State law. 2. If a street‘ it`I;n cr•e hundred-feet-(-1- he-billboard, measured frorn-the' ,Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" streettiz «�t;e-point-at-wh;ch the biltbea-d endic•4tar--te-the-street,Icon a-cif#erent-grede4han4he-now billboard,'wenty-€eve-feet-(25')above-the pavemcntflevet!on of the str et. • 3-If-the prcvicic -of-s13bsection R2 cf thin sscr subsection,epp;y to rare then-one ctreat,the new blltboerd tie the higher of the two(2) haichts Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district,freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line.This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred(300)square Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred(300) 0.88",Left linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2.Large Signs:Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300)square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800)linear feet from any other billboard,small or large,on the same side of the street. 3.Spacing for electronic billboards fully integrated into the architecture of a building and not free standing.may be modified by the Planning Commission as a Conditional Building and Site Design Review as outlined in section 21A.59,as lona as such modifications are consistent with State Law R Lighting:Nighttime illumination of billboards may not glare directly onto the roadway or sidewalk nor across property lines. Billboards located within Residential,Mixed-Use. Formatted:Indent:First line:CO CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight -Formatted:Font:(Default)Helveto,-12 a and 6 am. Formatted:Lint Paragraph,beam[:Left: Num6erNumbered+Level: 0 N 1+Numbering Stylee:a,,tat q S:Electronic Billboards: o•..+start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned • 1. Electronic Billboard are prohibited except when converting an existing billboard to at oas+indent at:os electronic as follows: o7 Firstls[st line: Paragraph,Indent:Left: _'-.iv— Fenoettedt list Paragraph,Indent:Left:0.5•, • a Billboard ma, be converted to an electronic billboard in Manufacturin • Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:a,b. Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the o mberedrt at l:1+Nuent:Left+Aligned restriction that they are not oriented towards,or located within 600 feet of a at 0.25'+Indent at:Ds gateway or special gateway sti et or residential zoning district. Provided that FO1w1°"d_Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 p four times the non-electronic square footage of the new electronic billboard is Formate`Fax:(Default)He 112p removed elsewhere in the City. Formatted:Font:(Default)Hel vti a,12 p Formatted:Font:(Defeat)Hei etlm,12 p b Billboards ma be converted to electronic billboards on Gatewaystreets Formatted:Four co a�cj Mee ,1z p provided the five times the non-electronic s uare foots a of the new Formatted:Imem:left:0.75•,First line:0' electronic billboard is removed along the same Gateway.or removed from rmmatt.s.use ParagaPn,meld t tort:0.51, another gateway only if sufficient square footage is not available on the host Numbered+Level' +Numbed q Style:a,b, gateway. c,...+start at:1+Alignment:felt+Angled at:0.25"+Indent at:0.5• Formatted:Font:(Default)Hel tica,12 p el Billboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Special Gateways Formatted:Fart:(Default)ndNeno,12 p provided that four times the non-electronic square footage of the new Formatted:Fax:(cerandt)Heleara,12 p electronic billboard is removed on the same Special Gateway or removed - -- - - fromanother special gateway only if sufficient square footage is not available Formatted:Fong(Default)Helvetica,12 p on the host special gateway and the new electronic billboard is fully integrated Formatted:list Paragraph,Indent:Leon 0.75",First line:0• into the architecture of a building and is not free standing., n- -_----•- /Formatted:list Paragraph,Indent:Left:0S, d) Billboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Downtown or Sugar J c.2+Sea Level: m°Style:a'Aligned grment:ten+ House Business District zoning districts provided that five times the non- at:0.25+Indent at:0.5• electronic square footage of the new electronic billboard is removed in any \ Formatted:Font:(Default)Helm,jz R Downtown.Sugar House Business District.residential,neighborhood l Formatted:For (Default)Heloenea,12 ge commercial.Community Business.Community Shopping Center,gateway.or Formatted:Font:(Default)Helveara,12 pt Formatted:Font:(Default)Hel.eeca,12 Pt d. 0 mixed-use zoning district and the new electronic billboard is fully integrated �Farrrntt.d_r t:(Default)Melveuu,12 a ) into the architecture of a building and is not free standing. • )formatted:FUN:ioogeAt)HtlM1o,12 Lit ) Formatted:laded:Left 0.5',Space Ater: 2. Motion, 10 Lit,nne spacing:Multiple 1.151i,No billets j Any motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face. Electronic 111° mt" g billboards shall have only static text.images.and graphics. Formatted:Font:Hewn.,12 a Not Bold Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvena,12 pt 3. Dwell time • Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetic a,12 Pt . The text.image.or display on an electronic sign may not change more than once F.rm,tve:Font Hevetiaa,12 pt,Not we every sixty(60)seconds. Twirl time between subsequent text.images.or display . F„nts. ;Font:(Default) „ ,12 a shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. — — 4. Brightness F.rmattoad:Font.Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold During daylight hours between sunrise and sunset,luminance shall be no greater F.etr.tt.dt Font:(Default)t um,12 pt than 2.500 nits.At all other times-luminance shall be no greater than 500 nits. 5. Size Formatted:Font:Helvetia,12 pt,Not Bold The maximum size of an electronic sign shall be no larger than the billboard it Crwmatted:Font(Default)Velvena,12 pt_� replaced or shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50')in width whichever is less, (Formatted:Font Helrtto,12 It 6. Displayperiod Formatted:Font(Default),el et,Not Boid Electronic b billboards may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight. Pm-matted:Font(Default)F1eh4tica,12 x and 6 a.m if they are located within 600 Feet of a residential. mixed-use, (Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetia,12 a downtown,Sugar House Business District.gateway,Neighborhood Commercial (Formatted:Font.(Default)HeM1etia,12 p Community Business.or Community Shopping Center zoning district (Formatted:Font:Helvetia,(apt 7. Controls [Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 Lit,Not Bold • a.Alt electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer control or (wrnaned:Font(Default)Web.,lz a-� other mechanism that automatically controls the sign's brightness and disolay period as provided above. h. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sign,the applicant shall certify that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion,dwell time,brightness.and other requirements herein. c. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sign shall submit an annual report to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion.dwell time brightness,and other requirements herein. • i_Formatted:List Paragraph UT.Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CO zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title,or its successor chapter.No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. • IVU.Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts:Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of this section,or its successor subsection,upon which a billboard is the only structure,shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50)linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible,evenly on each side of the billboard. WV.Xeriscape Alternative:If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection,are not developed or,if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. IXW.Existing Billboard Landscaping:Existing billboards shall comply with the 0 landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1,1996. aFX.Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance:Construction,demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree Istewardship ordinance and the Tree Protection ordinance. IZY.Subdivision Registration:To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve,make minor subsequent amendments to,and record as necessary,such subdivision. AA-Spocict Pravisiorer. plicability #ra-provlsio;c cf'his c__'ia;r-sl;a;1-2pp.y4xpesir; iA✓r 's-le. t . eur(4)ex<sting-bitltboardmhe haen4500-Nerth-and-3l?13North-odjcccnt-t i;evvest sided:;rrterstatrl5;-end .Qae-existing billboard cc the...act side of Victory Road-at-agproxinaa?ety 11C01da441r- 0 • • may:Except as modified by this section,c . _ _. ehaptershati apply• _ s: I-P-riority h ve-(5)-sco-cified-b441boards-shallbe-considered-asyeteway bitlboardsfier-the-purposes-of-the-priority-proyisionc of subsection F of this-sectionrecits b _.tion: . -n4eoap4ig:Tha-f v (5)sp:ciGcd biltbocrds-shah b a-lse4s ped-pursuant-to-he cfft-i . , .,c'_e-.:en: R .f dRelocat:on Of 6i'tboarde ep aeother.•'c_a thorn= -a herein exist ng-billboards-may-notbe-retooatedexcEpt as mandatedby-the-requirements c' Utah state-law.(Ord.72-08§2,2008:Ord.42-08§12,2008:Ord.13-04§§25,26, 27,2004:Ord.25-00§§1-3,2000:Ord.83-98§§12-14,1998:Ord.88-95§1(Exh. A),1995) CO) O Discussion Draft Proposal which allows transit advertising, eliminates billboard bank, defines electronic billboards and prohibits electronic billboards. • 21A.46.058 TRANSIT SHELTER AND PUBLIC AMENITY ADVERTISING Transit shelter and public amenity advertising shall be allowed only as part of a shelter at a bus stop or public transit stop or station.or a public amenity,pursuant to an approved and executed agreement between the City and a provider of transit shelters or public amenities,which sets forth the regulation of size.content.placement.design and materials used in the construction of said advertising and shelters and public amentity. For purposes of this section."public amenity"means an item generally located in the public way to provide a public service.which may include,but is not limited to,a kiosk displaying way finding sianaae or accommodating news racks or other public information.public restrooms.public furniture such as benches or trash receptacles or public services such as bike sharing. The common element is that they are offered for public consumption and provided as contract services to the City. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising shall in no case be larger than 48"by 72" and shall be limited to no more than three panels per shelter or kiosk,unless otherwise restricted further by contract. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising is only authorized when located adjacent to non-residential. RB.RMU.or RO zonina districts. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising display may not contain nudity, pornography.or indecent crv_u!ner nictures.graphics or tanauage or adyertis?n9 of illegal products. 21A.46.060: SIGNS SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITED IN ALL ZONING DISTRICTS: The following exterior signs, in addition to all other signs not expressly permitted by this chapter,are prohibited in all zoning districts and shall not be erected: A.Animated signs excluding public service signs; B.Any snipe sign; C.Balloons; D.Bench signs-except transit shelter and amenity advertising specifically authorized by section 21A e6.58 E.Portable signs,except where specifically permitted by district sign regulations; F.Signs overhanging the property line other than signs that are permitted under the sign regulations applicable to each zoning district; G.Signs which are structurally unsafe,hazardous or violate the uniform building code or the uniform fire code; H.Signs located near streets which imitate or are easily confused with official traffic signs and use words such as"stop","look","danger","go slow","caution"or"warning", except where such words are part of the name of a business or are accessory to parking lots;and I.Painted signs which do not meet the definition of wall signs.(Ord.53-00§3,2000: Ord.88-95§1(Exh.A),1995)- 21A.46.160:BILLBOARDS: A.Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the citys master plans. O • B. Definitions: BILLBOARD:A freestanding ground sign located on industrial,commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business,product or service that is not sold,offered or existing on the property where the sign is located.A billboard does not include transit shelter and public amenity advertising specifically authorized by Section 21A.46.058 • BILLBOARD BANK:An acccunting system established by the city to keep*sack of the rumber--ar dseaace-foetaee-0f ,senfer ing-billboards-rernoved-pur ant-to this chopt: . BII=L-BOARI REDIT ,A,n{ntn}Ito-a-bill rd-owners billboard-bankaoEsuat- t chcv<s-the -mbc;4r,d lface foc,a of d..,m-o'.ished r,efoor'fccr;ing bitivosr4s BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. • DWELL TIME The length of time that elapses between text. images, or graphics on Formatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sian � ::ttedIndent:First line: Ermatte ::Font_Bold O EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:Any off-oremise sign.video display.projected image,or similar device with text.images.or graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include. but are not limited to.signs that use light emitting diodes(LED).plasma displays.fiber optics.or other technology that results in bright.high-resolution text. images.and graphics. • CFormatted:Indent:First line: 0" GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; • [Formatted:Indent Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5.5600 West; 6.2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8.Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10.500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11.600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12.300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13.North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14.Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15.State Street from South Temple to 2100 South;and 16.600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after • December 31,1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1.North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; —Formatted:indent:Lett:0.96. 2.400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3.State Street between 600 South and 2100 South;and 4.Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. LUMINANCE The photometric quantity most closely associated with the perception •y rormaned:Fat rateaa of brightness. Luminance is measured in candelas per sauare meters or"nits"for \\Formatted:TTab gore:o.:r,List tab purposes of this ordinance. _Fornwtted•tort Bold MOTION The depiction of movement or change of position of text,images.or Formatted:Font Not Bold graphics. Motion shall include but not be limited to.visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images.runnipo sequential text.craohic bursts.lighting that • IMMENa L • resembles zoomina.twinkling. cr sparkling.chanaes in liaht or color.transitory bursts of liaht intensity.moving patterns or bands of light.exoandingor contracting shapes.and similar actions. [Formatted:Font:Bold NITS A unit of measure of brightness or luminance. One nit is equal to one • Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", candela/sauare meter. Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: 0.25",Ust tab TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text.images.and craohics on an electronic Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt sian to chance to a different text. images.or graphics on a subsequent sian face. Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab C.Um' 'a' 'umber Of- l;boards:-i o-gr a:_r-Rumbc-of billboardsshall-b.° aticwcd in Salt L3!;e-Si`: tl-ian-the ouimber-of-exist+hg-bitiboards.Billboards Prohibited:Nevi Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. D. Relocation of Billboards: Existing billboards may be relocated as mandated by the • Formatted:Indent:Left: 0",Hanging: 0.25" requirements of Utah state law. Additionally.billboards may be relocated from any zoning district to Manufacturing. Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.or located within 600 feet of a oateway or special gateway street or residential zoning district. _ Voluntary relocation shall follow the priority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F of (Formatted:Font:Not Bold this ordinance. unless otherwise negotiated with the City. DE. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner • Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2.Application:Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee:The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars($111.00). €—Gradits-For-None-entermirg£illboard-Removal ,`tar-a-noncenferrningbftibsard is demolished-pursuant-ta-affirm:'.iss „d ubsec!; -D-a-cif-ibis-seEtior}-oats succc:sor,tlhc city shall cr.,ate a billboard bank,c—nt 4he-tAlt oard-owner.The acc t-s;a;l-show the data-of their sval-en- the zoning-district of the+'cr !fished • is fsr4he—b44b,....a andks-serua any billboard-credit F.Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards:Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1.Billboards in districts zoned residential,historic,residential R-MU or • Fon,ra.d:Indent:Left:0.71•,Tab stops: downtown D-1,D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 0.88'telt 2.Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB,or any gateway zonina district G-MIJ—G C-er-C,4 or on gateway streets shall be removed second; • 3.Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last;and 4-Abii board-owner may dernslishmorcan;em;ng-billboerds 4r.,4.a4e.er-riority be oreremovi • i'y however_4he-biliboard-credits for-removing4heGower-pricrity-biUboerd-shall-not-beson eefeetivefor-usein .,•il-two-(2-)-billboarde epeci:cd in cubccc:icn • Ft of this section,cr is successor,with a tcXml-square-footageequattoer greater-hen the lower priority bilit-,aardrare ed-imthe-billboardewne,'-e billboard-bane ac,ountAf-a4;illboardowner hasmo-oubseotion-FI-O€ihis section,or its sucoe rd , this sect itybiitboards may be credited in the billboard-owne4billboarelbankacsount4o effectuate-he-bi lboardered ts-of eanstmstientlaaew-billboard.For the purposes-o`th`s session,the-two(:-) rdsereditedin-tie-biliboardka . c-nly-cnce-to-effecluatethe-bil boardcredits-fora-lower-prioritybiUbnard, G-LifeOf-Billboard-Creditsi-Anybillboard-cedits-notusedwithin-Urirty-six-( )geode n of their erectionurther vet fewer priority-credi s-effee uated pursuant tosubsection-F-4-ef..,, • r shaltexpireandbeof-rw-further-vatueowse-within sixly{50)months-of-their-inilial ereaticn: H-Billboerd-CroatsTrncfera ' y-seise-iransfera bi tbeard-andicr till-bead credits.Transferred bil board credits whit-h re ' fee.hoe beeaus of4he.pr sr:y-prcvisiens o b�,�^^^han-P-eft:.issection,or its sue:aesc • r £hall not bcccm ef:cct:vc for their ,.rtiI thoy would have become cf`zctiva for the originc!owner.The trorsf:r of zny billb.and crodits do nc emend their thi4y-six(36)mon':€i 1+f2 .rovirlsd--in-wbecctior}G-of-this tion,or-its £uccez.ccr. _ Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two(2) advertising faces shall receive bi!;hcc44-'J-credit- for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. Kl.Permitted Zoning Districts:New-Relocated billboards may be constructed only in the area;dentified-cnzhe—c.t cial-billboard-map_c Manufaciurinu. Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.cr located within 600 feet of a aateway or special gateway street or residential zoning district. L:J.Ne::Billboard relocation cr remodeling Permits: 1.Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees:The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: • a. Building permit and pla evie•s_fees requir h2�jj�et[f0 6 ma's'.' Fdrmaltea.Indent:Left 0.96',Tab stops: code as adopted by the cl ;a i _ _ "='� " 1.13•,left �� l b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. Use^� eecd Crcd de. l ,a+; :kiiibEard pzrrri`.sh-il cn l-b—iseucd 4-tho a{ licant-Ins-bitlbaar:t • CFO-matted:Indent:Left 0.71" credits.cf a su`iciant numba cf s, re`c ct aad 34:b•sardc to allow cnstruc ion of-the-new-biliboard- • admi ' . a.The squa Fdm.tled:Indent left IOC,Tab stops: I.a•,Left h Th•... . der of billb ardc•.hole f�..1�.a•. n.!In+II.....the new-billboardconstwsfion. 3-if-tha-new-billboard illboa.•.�.- Jesse 'han the entire-available-billboard-credits �rwsn.ead:Indent Left a.n• y remaining-equate-f . • [Fono.eed:Indent we We:0.25' J Ni<.New-Billboards Prohibited On Gateways:Except as provided in subsection O-D of this section,or its successor,no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway street. Gt.Special Gateway Provisions: 1.If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway,the • Fam.tadi Indent Left 0.71•,Tab stops: billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special nor,Left gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to other subsections P,Q,R andSof this section,provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amcuntof-billbaardciedi zS special gateway billboardbanksize of the billboard being relocated.Billboards may not be relocated from other areas onto a special gateway 2 The _ lninin-afa-nenconfem ing ion shall notaesrue-billboard eneratkiubeard bank.Credits fee-a billboerd-dernolishedor-r.onsirusied withina-epecial.gatewayshalfbe tracked within a separate ban it fern • want to thiisoestion meetbe-taken out-within-thirty-six )-monthsof-the-demoG;ien-cf-the-nonconforming billboard, PM.Maximum Size:The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50')in width. • • QN.Temporary Embellishments: 1.Tarrpora^ eTsc''nhm • ^h ^ •execed ten perscnt(10','.)of the - (rr«.omr:Indent:Let 0.71•,Tab stops: advertising-face-ofany-billboard,and-shal not-ex dive feet(5')in height (°�AV,telt J above-the-billboard-structure: 2-14o-tomperaryfmhellishrnent shall-be.rnaintained+tn-abil4bearda;sre-than t::c've(12)months Temperer/Embellishments are prohibited - (_rws.etra:Went Fin Noe:s.zs RO.Height:The highest point of any new b4lheardbillboard exstuding tempera=} embetishmen:a-shall not be more than: -1-,.Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or the maximum height for a • Tenoned: tem o.w•,wnenp: pole sign in the applicable zoning district,whichever is less. Unless o.zs__ __ 1 otherwise authorized by State law. —, etTrit rd,measure"fr-sm-tlr_• L►en..ad:Indent Left sir street at the pointat-which-t ieutar o-the-streetris-on a-differant-grade4hanthe-newbillbeard,1wenty-five-faet(251)above-tho O pavement eleva 3-1 the-provis;cr ,vits-eGGess_r subsection,apply to more thewonesirc^•,the-newbilrboard nay-be-the higher-of the'.no-(2)-#eights. SP.Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located.In the absence of setback standards for a particular district,freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line.This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard,not just the sign support structure. TO.Spacing: 1.Small Signs:Billboards with an advertising face three hundred(300)square. (rer.umad:t de,b ten:0.71•,Tab stops: feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred(300) t° ,Left linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; O • 2.Large Signs:Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300)square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800)linear feet from any other billboard,small or large,on the same side of the street. Formatted:uu Paragraph,Numbered+Lem:: I+Numtedrq Style:1,2,3,...+Start at 1+ algnment:Left+Allred at:0.25•+Indent 3.Spacing for billboards fully integrated into the architecture of a building and at:os' not free standing.may be modified by the Planning Commission as a Formatted:Indent Left or,No bullets or Conditional Building and Site Design Review as outlined in section 21A.59 numbering as long as such modifications are consistent with State Law Formatted:Font:(Default)Hebetice,12 pi Formatted:Indent:Left 1",Numbered+ Level:5+Nunberi g Sryk:a,D,t....+SLrt at 1+Alignment left+Aligned at 2,25+ R Lighting:Nighttime illumination of billboards may not glare directly onto the roadway Indent et:2.5. or sidewalk nor across property lines. Billboards located within Residential.Mixed-Use Formatted:Fort Ielvetica,12 pt,Not Bold CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight Formatted:Font(Default)HenRbca,12 a and 6 am. Formatted:Indent.Left:1.25" S Electronic Billboards: /Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 1. New Electronic Billboard are prohibited.Electronic billboard existing as of the • Formatted:Indent Left:1',Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering 5+e:a,b,c,...+Start date of adoption of this ordinance are limited to the following: at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:z.zs•+ Indent at.2.5" a. Motion . Formatted:Font.Helvetica,12 Pt.Not Bold Any motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face. Formatted:Font:(Default)Heiveaca,12 Pt Electronic billboards shall have only static text,images,and graphics. r Formatted:Indent Left:125" / Formatted:Indent:Left:1',NumbNed+ b. Dwell time Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start The text.image.or display on an electronic sign may not change mor- at:l+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:2.25'+ Indent at 2.5. than once every sixty(60)seconds. Twirl time between subsequentFormatted:Font.Helvetica,12 a,Not Bold text.images.or display shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,Iz p c. Brightness Formatted:Indent Left:1.25' During daylight hours between sunrise and sunset,luminance shall b- Formatted:Indent:Left:,',Numbered+ no greater than 2,500 nits. At all other times,luminance shalt be no Level:s+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start z.z greater than500nits. Indent Alignment: tg nt. 2.5• 4R+agreed,r. s+ Formatted:Font:Helveaca,12 pt,Not Bold d. Size Formatted:Font(Default)Helvet col,12 pt The maximum size of an electronic si.n shall be no lar.er than th- billboard as it exists as of the date of the adoption of this ordinance, Formatted:Indent:Left:t.zs• ,J . Formatted:Font Heivetca,12 pt e.. Display period, Formatted:Indent:Left:1',Numbered+ Electronic billboards may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of Level:5+Numberingment Style:a,b,at:2.Start Electronic Le l+Ali Left+Aligned a[: +St+ midnight.and 6 am if the are located within 600 Feet of a residential. indent at 2.5' mixed-use. downtown, Sugar House Business District. gateway Fartaedt Font:Helvetica, 12 pt,Not d 3 Neighborhood Commercial, Community Business. or Community � nFmmattd:Foot(Default)Helvetica,12 p1 _3 Shopping Center zoning district, Formatted:Indent:Left:1.25' ) Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font:Hetoetks,12 pt -_ 411 • f. Controls - Formatted:Indent:Left:1",Numbered+ • Level:5+Numberep style:a,b,c,...+Start i. All electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer at 1+Alignment:Left+feigned at 2.25"+ control or other mechanism that automatically controls the sian's Indent at:2.5",Tab stops:1.25",Lek briahtness and display period as provided above. I Formatted,Font:Nelvetca,12 Pt,Not Bold ii. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sicn. -Fornatted:Font(Default)Hclvetica,12 pt the applicant shall certify that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion.dwell time.brightness.and other recuirements herein. • iii. The owner and/or operator of art electronic sign shall submit an annual report to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion.dwell time.brightness.and other requirements herein. " �Farmattad_Ust Paragraph UT.Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title,or its successor chapter.No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. © I VU.Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts:Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of this section,or its successor subsection,upon which a billboard is the only structure,shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50)linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible,evenly on each side of the billboard. Xeriscape Alternative:If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection,are not developed or,if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. IXV/.Existing Billboard Landscaping:Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1,1996. • Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction,demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance and the Tree Protection ordinance.. -'r. Subdivision Registration:To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to,and record as necessary,such subdivision. M.Spccicl-Previsio^e ^!cab y:Then cf th;c,.e }; i1 - .P.^ „^,on shall-apply _ c located: -ter()a billbo^rds be ..ecn ,h00;vsrh-and-1-800 Nc west adjacent to the west side cf Interstate 15;and v le. One exist-i,g-bil+boe d cn+. e e�:.-t side of Victory Road at appraxirnately 1100 North-, .l.Gcnercl Applicability: Except as-n ostified-by this section,all other previsions cf this III shapter-shall-appt + e-five(5)specified billboards. 2especial-Priority:The five(5)-spe�ied-billboafds-shall-be-consideredd-as-gateway billboards-for-the-rposcs-of-the-priority-provisions of subsection-€of-this-section-ro its success, ticn. ->randscaping:The five(5) specified billboards-shall be landscaped pu,...s.mat-to-the orsvisiens cf hre^+;, \/.f h'^ }ion,or-its-suocecsfi ub&eotiea: BR--State Mandate ovation-015illboards xcept-as-o hefwiee authorized-hereif . existing-billboards- y-net-be-aJonated cept—n-rnnn atad by-the-requirements-cf Utah state law. (Ord.72-08§2,2008: Ord.42-08§ 12,2008: Ord. 13-04§§25,26, 27,2004: Ord.25-00§§ 1-3,2000: Ord.83-98§§ 12-14, 1998:Ord.88-95§ 1 (Exh. A), 1995) 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMOS O 4) January 20,2011 January 24,2011 Briefing memos for January 26 hearing ,n_,N Briefing for „ r z Planning Commission Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: January 20,2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: January 26th`issue only hearing'on proposed code amendments regarding billboards and public transit(public amenity)advertising. Petitions:400-06-51, PLNPCM2010-00032, PLNPCM2010-00717 Background There are presently three separate petitions regarding the regulation of off-premise advertising in Salt Lake City. An Open House introducing these petitions and potential regulations was held on November 18, 2010. There was an initial briefing in December 9,2010 meeting in preparation for a work session on January 12,2012. Some Planning Commissioners met with YESCO representatives on January 5 to discuss technical aspects of electronic billboards. The Planning Commission received a briefing on January 12th 2011 and set up a subcommittee to review the proposals. Hearing: This January 26"'hearing is`issues only'. No decision is recommended or expected. The hearing provides an opportunity to hear from the community and industry representatives in order to provide information to guide the creation of a final product. After the hearing,the Planning Commission should discuss the next steps with staff. Previous staff memos may be re-read at:littp://www.slcgov.com/boards/plancom/plancom.htm _v : t; Briefing for D z�' �'= Planning Commission Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: January 24,2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: Policy discussion. Petitions:400-06-51,PLNPCM2010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 In considering the three petitions,the Planning Commission should focus on general policy issues and allow the Attorneys to develop specific language. The following is a bullet point outline of the general policies codified by the existing ordinance,the policies included in the two draft ordinances provided and potential alternative policies. Policy reversals and/or significant changes offered in • the draft ordinances are highlighted with an asterisk*. Transit shelters Existing policy • Adverting in the public way is prohibited with exceptions for A-frame signs and logos on banners. Draft ordinance policy • Allows advertising in the public way when associated with a contract for street furniture.* • Allows the Administration to determine all details. Alternative policies • Allow transit shelter advertising only associated with City contract. • Allow transit shelter advertising and logos on other furniture only associated with City contract. • Place ordinance limits on the size of advertising. • Place ordinance limits on the size of logos. • Limit the number of shelters and/or furniture allowed to be negotiated by the administration. • Billboard ordinance Existing policy • Cap and reduce program. • Allows banking of billboards for three years. • Encourages movement away from residential, historic,downtown,gateway districts. • Allows relocation to general commercial and industrial(non-gateway)districts generally located west of 300 West. Draft ordinance policy • Eliminates bank. • Allows movement according to state law. • Allow negotiated movement with the City and provides policy guidance directing negotiated movement. Alternative policies • No change(State law still supersedes). • Increase the number of boards allowed. Electronic Billboards Existing policy • Silent:does not prohibit or define. Draft ordinance policy • First draft prohibits electronic billboard conversion. • Second draft • Creates definitions. • Sets lighting and brightness definitions for electronic billboards. • Allows for conversions to freestanding boards on gateway streets*. • Allows conversion to electronic on special gateways as part of the architecture*. • Allows electronic billboards in downtown districts as part of the architecture*. • Requires general reduction in boards when converting*. • Allows Planning Commission to modify spacing requirements*. Alternative policies • Allow conversion only on particular streets or in specific zoning districts. • Increase or decrease the numbers of billboards required for conversion(from the second draft). • • Define standards and allow all conversions. • 5.B PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS/MEMOS • 5) Report of information provided to the subcommittee iS?; L9�- Briefing for Planning Commission c i •r ,,, Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: February 3,2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: Subcommittee. Petitions:400-06-51,PLNPCM2010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 Attached is the information provided to the Subcommittee for their January 31,2011 meeting: Agenda • Policy Discussion Salt Lake County ordinance Salt Lake City Ordinance. Excerpts from the Urban Design Element Excerpts from the Downtown Plan Excerpts from Downtown Rising YESCO suggestions Discussion draft prohibiting electronic billboards Discussion draft allowing some movement of electronic billboards Information being provided for the February 7,2011 subcommittee meeting: Initial inventory of neighborhood billboards(not field checked) USA today article List of cities and states indicated in the USA today graphics Comparison of land values adjacent to residentially zone billboards(spread sheet done in 2002) Map of Salt Lake County Map of Salt Lake County Townships(Salt Lake County ordinance applies to unincorporated County and Millcreek,Emigration,Kearns,Copperton,White City and Magna townships) Official Billboard and Gateway map Salt Lake City zoning maps Information being acquired,but not yet available for February 7,2011 meeting: • Salt Lake County zoning maps Consolidated map of billboard locations in Salt Lake City January 31. 2011 1 Planning Commission Subcommittee agenda Review of policies and existing map Comparison of Salt Lake City to Salt Lake County Is the subcommittee ok with YESCOs suggested criteria for electronic? What more info is needed? Where to? • 0 ti ' PL-7•- Briefing for �_ f _�- =N TL. it Planning Commission Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie,Senior Planner Date: January 24,2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: Policy discussion. Petitions:400-06-51,PLNPCM2010-00032,PLNPCM2010-00717 • In considering the three petitions,the Planning Commission should focus on general policy issues and allow the Attorneys to develop specific language. The following is a bullet point outline of the general policies ® codified by the existing ordinance,the policies included in the two draft ordinances provided and potential alternative policies. Policy reversals and/or significant changes offered in the draft ordinances are highlighted with an asterisk*. Transit shelters Existing policy • Adverting in the public way is prohibited with exceptions for A-frame signs and logos on banners. Draft ordinance policy • Allows advertising in the public way when associated with a contract for street furniture.* • Allows the Administration to determine all details. Alternative policies • Allow transit shelter advertising only associated with City contract. • Allow transit shelter advertising and logos on other furniture only associated with City contract. • Place ordinance limits on the size of advertising. • Place ordinance limits on the size of logos. • Limit the number of shelters and/or furniture allowed to be negotiated by the administration. Billboard ordinance Existing policy • Cap and reduce program. • Allows banking of billboards for three years. • Encourages movement away from residential, historic, downtown, gateway districts. • Allows relocation to general commercial and industrial (non-gateway) districts generally located west of 300 West. Draft ordinance policy • Eliminates bank. • Allows movement according to state law. • Allow negotiated movement with the City and provides policy guidance directing negotiated movement. Alternative policies • No change (State law still supersedes). • Increase the number of boards allowed. Electronic Billboards llboards Existing policy • Silent: does not prohibit or define. Draft ordinance policy • First draft prohibits electronic billboard conversion. • Second draft • Creates definitions. • Sets lighting and brightness definitions for electronic billboards. • Allows for conversions to freestanding boards on gateway streets*. • Allows conversion to electronic on special gateways as part of the architecture*. • Allows electronic billboards in downtown districts as part of the architecture*. • Requires general reduction in boards when converting*. • Allows Planning Commission to modify spacing requirements*. Alternative policies • Allow conversion only on particular streets or in specific zoning districts. • Increase or decrease the numbers of billboards required for conversion (from the second draft). • Define standards and allow all conversions. O Municode Page 1 of 2 f=I- L..Ak. ' tl • 19.82.185-Off-premises signs—Billboards. A. Purpose.This section provides for the reasonable regulation of off-premises signs with the intent of enhancing the aesthetics of existing and future billboards,mitigating negative impacts,promoting safety and protecting property values that further the goals and planning policies of Salt Lake County. B. Cap on Number of Off-Premises Signs.The number of off-premises signs allowed in unincorporated Salt Lake County and established or future townships shall be limited to the number of off-premises signs that are existing as defined herein as of May 18',2004.This cap shall automatically decrease as off-premises signs are annexed into a municipal jurisdiction or removed and not relocated. C. Location.Off-premises signs shall be allowed in the C-1 zone as a conditional use.Off-premises signs shall be allowed in the C-2,C-3,M-1 and M-2 zones as a permitted use. D. Size.Off-premises signs shall not exceed six hundred seventy-two square feet in the C-2,C-3,M-1 and M-2 zones.Off-premises signs located in a C-1 zone shall not exceed three hundred square feet in size. E. Height.The maximum height of an off-premises sign shall be thirty-five feet in a C-1 zone.The maximum height of an off-premises sign shall be forty-five feet above the grade level of the road in the C-2,C-3,M-1 and M-2 zones or,when oriented for freeway viewing only and located within three hundred feet of the nearest freeway lane,twenty-five feet above freeway grade level or fifty feet overall,whichever is greater. F. Separation.The minimum distance between off-premises signs larger than three hundred square feet shall be five hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections.The minimum distance between off-premises signs three hundred square feet or less in size shall be three hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections.All off-premises signs must be at least one hundred fifty radial feet from any other off-premises sign. G. Setbacks.The minimum setback shall be eighteen inches for off-premises signs.The sign's front-yard setback shall be measured from the future right-of-way line(see Transportation Improvement Plan).The closest edge of an off-premises sign shall not project into any required setback area.The minimum setback between an off- premises sign and any residential zone boundary shall be one hundred fifty feet. • H. Lighting.Lighting shall be confined to the sign face,and the lighting source shall not be directly visible. I. Design.Off-premises signs shall utilize either the"mono-pole"or the"bi-pole"design and shall be continually maintained structurally and on the copy face.The back of the sign and the structure behind the sign shall be painted a dark color.Tri-vision sign faces shall be permitted and,if illuminated,must be externally illuminated. Internally illuminated off-premises signs,electronic display(outdoor video advertising)and electronic message centers are only allowed adjacent to the interstate freeway system and limited to no more than one change to the copy face In a twenty-four hour period.Two-decked off-premises signs are prohibited in all zones. J. Credits for Removal.Prior to the removal of any off-premises sign,the owner shall obtain a permit for the demolition of the off-premises sign.Permits may be provided following application to the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division.The Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall by letter inform the affected community council chairman and affected planning commission chairman that a permit for demolition of an off-premises sign has been issued.After any off-premises sign is demolished,the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall create a"billboard bank account"for the sign owner.The account shall reflect credits for the off-premises sign square footage as well as the date of removal.Any off-premises sign credits not used within thirty-six months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use.An off-premises sign owner may sell or otherwise transfer off- premises signs and/or billboard bank account credits.The transfer of any billboard bank account credits does not extend their thirty-six-month life as provided in this section.Demolition of an off-premises sign that has two advertising faces shall receive billboard bank account credits for the square footage of each sign face. K. Relocation.The owner of an existing off-premises sign may remove an existing off-premises sign from any site to an approved location only after a permit for relocation is obtained upon substantiation of compliance with this chapter.Prior to approval of a permit for relocation,the sign owner(applicant)shall submit to the county a notarized affidavit signed by the property owner,a copy of the lease agreement or other document to be signed by the property owner,indicating at a minimum the duration of the lease and renewal provisions. Additionally,prior to approval of a permit for relocation,Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall by letter inform the affected community council chairman and affected planning commission chairman that application for an off-premises sign permit has been received.Off-premises signs moved to approved locations shall conform to all off-premises sign requirements of the new location.Off-premises signs moved from one location to another must be installed in the new approved location within the period allotted by the International Building Code(IBC).A new off-premises sign permit shall only be issued if the applicant has O billboard bank account credits of a sufficient number of square feet.When the permit for construction of a new off-premises sign is issued,the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall deduct from the sign owner's billboard bank account the square footage of the new off-premises sign.If the new off- premises sign uses less than the entire available square footage credits,any remaining square footage credits shall remain in the sign owner's billboard bank account. L. County Council Review and Monitoring.The county council shall,on a regular six-month schedule be updated Municode Page 2 of 2 at a regular public meeting to changes in status and effectiveness of the provisions related to off-premises signs in unincorporated Salt Lake County. M. Severability and Conflict.This section and its various parts are hereby declared to be severable if a court of competent jurisdiction declares any subsection,clause,provision or portion of this section invalid or unconstitutional.No court decision will affect the validity of either this section as a whole or any parts not declared invalid or unconstitutional by that decision.If any part of this section is found to be in conflict with any other provision of the county,the most restrictive or highest standard will apply,prevail and govern. (Ord.0532§4,2004) • • • Sterling Codifiers,Inc. Page 1 of 6 21A.46.160:BILLBOARDS: O A.Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. B.Definitions: BILLBOARD:A freestanding ground sign located on industrial,commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business,product or service that is not sold,offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK:An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconforming billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT:An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed,maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13,1993. • GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1.Interstate 80; 2.Interstate 215; 3.Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5.5600 West; 6.2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8.Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10.500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11.600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12.300 West from 900 North to 900 South; • 13.North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14.Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 2 of 6 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. 0 NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD: An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT: An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: • 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars ($111.00). • E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D1 of this section, or its successor, the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways • shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; and httr //-anxnu cterlinarnrlifierc rnm/rnrlehnnlr/aetRnnl:flata nhn9certinn ir1=Fi517R4 1/;1/')nl Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 3 of 6 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however,the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor, priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section, the two (2) higher priority billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. • G. Life Of Billboard Credits: Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty (60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable: A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six (36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. • J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code, the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may be constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Permits: 1. Application: Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: 1. A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number Sterling Codifiers,Inc. Page 4 of 6 of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2.When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued,the zoning administrator shall deduct© from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a.The square footage of the new billboard;and b.The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3.If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage,any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N.New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways:Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section,or its successor,no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway. O.Special Gateway Provisions: 1.If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway,the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P,Q,R and.S of this section,provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2.The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits • within the general billboard bank.Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway.A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six(36)months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P.Maximum Size:The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50')in width. Q.Temporary Embellishments: 1.Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent(10%)of the advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet(5')in height above the billboard structure. 2.No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve(12)months. R.Height:The highest point of any new billboard,excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: 1.Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or 2.If a street within one hundred feet(100')of the billboard,measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street,is on a different grade than the new billboard,twenty five feet(25')above the pavement elevation of the street. 3.If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section,or its successor subsection,apply to more than one Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 5 of 6 street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. S. Minimum Setback Requirements: All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet (5') from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300) square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet (800') from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. U. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. V. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of . this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped •• from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty (50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. W. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property, the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. X. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. Y. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance. Z. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, © and record as necessary, such subdivision. AA. Special Provisions: 1. Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 6 of 6 a. Four(4) existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the west side of Interstate 15; and 0 b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection. BB. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. (Ord. 72- 08 § 2, 2008: Ord. 42-08 § 12, 2008: Ord. 13-04 §§ 25, 26, 27, 2004: Ord. 25-00 §§ 1-3, 2000: Ord. 83-98 §§ 12-14, 1998: Ord. 88-95 § 1 (Exh. A), 1995) • • h++.,.//.,.,.,, �+0.•1:., , .1:F o. ,.,,/ ,101,. .1./.o+T� ..l,Tl,+ .,h.,��o +: ., 1-4S 1'7QA 1 /Z 1 /�nl VIEW CORRIDORS AND VISTAS A view is a visual image having aesthetic beauty worth preserving. A"view corridor"frames a view of a building or natural feature from either a short or a long distance. View corridors are most often associated with streets or pedestrian walkways. The buildings adjacent to the street often frame a view of a prominent feature of the city. A vista,on the other hand, suggests a wider perspective or panoramic view. It may encompass an entire city,a sunset over the Great Salt Lake,or the Wasatch Mountain backdrop. While views are an important part of a dty's urban form,their value is often overlooked. They can easily be destroyed before the loss is realized leaving an environment of monoto- nous development and further damaging the city's identity. Salt Lake City has many view corridors which influence both the urban form of the city and the development character of its districts and communities. The most prominent indude the following(see Vista Protection Map). (Figure 8) - State Street corridor of the State Capitol Building and surrounding foothills - Exchange Place terminating at the Post Office Building - Main Street to The Daughters of Utah Pioneers Museum - 200 South east to the University of Utah Park Building - 300 South Street terminating at the D&RGW Railroad depot - South Temple,from Union Pacific Depot to Federal Heights Foothills - First Avenue terminating at the LDS Temple Square . , • - Ensign Peak ;x.:; *��irr Oquirrh Vista fir;. :'k .',_ - :. -, - Wasatch foothills tr,V , . 2 ° OTO6as88� ��°°aa ° °s /r/ f/,/ &; sss°° °ssso a °O8s K9 soo R. a8 as a o s o s s ° °� ° r8sasg § ' " o ° r.o� °ssasN °°s°°ss °° s°° �° ?, s : s� i�° a °°°°° psogo � °°'o00 ms ° 8° r- '•i ;'•' o oe� °se°o oRoo?. :aosros°°o°... :` � o ooS °° a 80 08° � %/./, : is NJo °.8g 8s°a8g008 7 0°0880,,. �8°° r<::::iS: r: .2#s r: .J5, td 08°-_..o °000. ,go° /j/ A,,, �. y�. .or.isozzv iQvzanp, dfb ��,,/ //lid --swY.:`,cozznir.6i�� c'991oo�0°88€8 GATEWAYS & VISTAS / "00m ° "' GATEWAYS ./////��%.l,//��/s„i. '�� ') VISTAS � / eo e88°° MAJOR VISTA TERMINUS j/ f:'74 i �ysi!!i _o°e°°a8Ae8 STREET VIEW CORRIDOR // /� °00g$g°00 O VIEW OR VISTA OBSERVATIQN'PFy1 TS • MOUNTAIN BACKDROP °82g I LAKE/DESERT VISTA fI ure. 8 9 ,•.i.‘. MAJOR STREETS ----- - • 21 Gateways Gateways refer to the entrances in and out of a city,but may also refer to the entrances into districts or neighborhoods. They are an important part of an area's image because they provide visitors and residents with their first visual impression of the city. A gateway often frames a principal view,providing a point of identity from which the viewer begins to evalu- ate the form and scale of an area. A gateway may occur as an auxiliary function to an area's main purpose. For example, airport and railroad terminals,bus depots,or freeway off-ramps may function as gateways since they are the point at which a visitor gets his first impression of a city. Changes in transportation modes,speed of travel,street pattern,or topography are often gateways because they signal"the entrance"into a district of the city. • • - - ., ,�x .�;r'�/... .• %- Jam.. .. Z-V''t��'t� F90eFi � 1� '•r Y �pT • • i , `^` , d 7t eY� No slops!?Per tlond Ore. - r . \\* Gateways into the City can be a road,or transit terminal. 7 24 • POLICY CONCEPTS • o Develop Salt Lake City's gateways to provide a good first impression of the city. o Develop gateways in a fashion which strengthens the identity of the city. Gateway streets should be visually uncluttered,their views unobstructed. o Preserve the City's major gateways. They are as follows: - Beck Street entrance - Parleys'Way(Parley's Canyon entrance) - South State Street entrance (2100 South at State Street) - Interstate 15(north and south entrances) - Union Pacific Railroad Depot • - Denver and Rio Grand Railroad Depot - Salt Lake City International Airport - Western city entrances(1-80 West and 2100 South) - Foothill Drive - 7th East - All I-15 and 1-80 Interchanges Strategies - Improve gateway vistas and the immediate environment of the major gateway roads. - Rehabilitate the areas immediately around gateways by providing landscaping, special streetscapes or district improvements. Rehabilitation may require modifying the zoning and allowed land use activities. Street improvements must go beyond 25 111 0 0 • MIMINENNIMMli simple replacement of hazardous or worn out equipment,sidewalks,or street fumi ture. If thoughtfully installed,such improvements announce to visitors that they have arrived. One such technique is the use of pylons or community identification markers to denote entrance into a neighborhood or district. - Prohibit by ordinance,sky-bridges and skyways over streets identified as significant view corridors on the Vista Protection Map. • - Remove overhead power transmission lines along streets in gateway and vista • areas. - Unify street light fixtures and equipment into a consistent design theme. - Encourage development which takes advantage of natural features such as topo- graphy,vegetation,water elements,etc - Amend Salt Lake City's sign ordinance to prohibit billboards along roadways that serve as gateways into the city and along view and vista corridors.(Figure 9) In addition,the following ordinances should be initiated for gateway districts.(For additional recommendations on sign regulations see"Signs"below.) Beck Street Vista/Gateway ' n:3 - I'7v• •• -#:: .:1 iiMMOIVEMOI • 26 +� E- stablish legislation allowing the city to amortize the useful life of existing bill L , boards as a method to remove signs in areas identified as city and community gate ways,principle city streets,and view corridors. .. - Reduce the allowable billboard sign height in vista areas zoned C-3,M-1,M-2 and M-3 from the present 65 feet to 40 feet. (Figure 9) - Require a minimum distance of 400 feet from freeway"no access lines"or right- of-way lines in sign free corridor. (Figure 9) - Require a minimum 1,200 foot spacing between billboards located in areas outside of sign free corridors. - Establish sign-free zones beyond the minimum distances proposed. The ac- companying map illustrates the areas where this is important. - Survey existing billboards to determine whether they were constructed legally. Those erected without permits should be removed. If legally constructed,signs need to be moved. - Require that signs located within a vista be low profile and preferably mounted parallel to building surfaces. - Require yard areas of properties adjacent to gateways or principle streets be treated as front yard space with landscaped setbacks and screening of unsightly uses.In conjunction with this,rooftop equipment such as air conditioning equip ment,satellite dishes,etc.,should be well organized and painted a neutral color or screened to minimize the visual distraction they often create. - Re-analyze allowed land uses adjacent to principle gateways. Prohibit open stor age,auto wrecking,junk yards,and open air refuse recycling processes within view corridors. ® V 02& l O Signs Signs are an integral and expected part of the city landscape. Signs contribute to the char- acter of different areas of downtown and are often a major identifying feature.Most signs in j .,e O� Salt Lake City are oriented to the street level environment as a result of the city's sign ordi- I(��+ nance. This has helped to make buildings and land features the landmarks instead of signs. This not only helps to maintain the individuality and quality of buildings,it enhances views of the mountain setting. Unfortunately,however,signs are still a dominate feature of the eiu landscape along our city's major boulevards and gateways. • �>_ L: /. • Signs sponsored by city,county,and state governments often set a poor example.Too often, little attention is paid to the impact directional and informational signs,such as street name signs have on the city's image. Our present lack of clear policy helps to create haphazardly • located,confusing,and often poorly designed signs. + . "�-� t IS r POLICY CONCEPTS D EseL z l FUEL o Provide ample opportunities for business to advertise products and service with p1• a°'.V." •f' ' out having a detrimental effect on the community. o Consider sign design and location as an integral part of all development,not as an after thought. o Ensure that government sponsored signage sets a positive example. o Regulate the size and location of billboards so they do not detract from the city's positive environment. Strategies - Initiate the following billboard sign ordinance amendments and legislation: 36 • • - Establish State enabling legislation allowing the city to amortize the useful life of existing billboard signs. - Reduce allowable billboard sign height in vista areas. (Presently the C-3,M-1, M-2,and M-3 zones allow 65 feet of height.) - Require a minimum distance of 400 feet from freeway"no access lines"or right-of-way lines in sign free corridors. In some cases protecting prominent views may require establishing sign-free zones beyond the minimum distances proposed. - Initiate a minimum 1,200 foot spacing between billboard signs located in areas outside of sign free corridors. (Figure 9) - Survey existing billboards to determine whether existing off-premise signs were constructed legally. Those which have been erected without building permits should be removed. If illegally constructed,signs need to be removed. - Require the review and approval of all signs in conservation districts,view corri- dors and vistas as part of the construction permit process. The following guidelines should be considered in granting sign approval: * Require signs located within a view corridor to be low profile and preferably mounted parallel to the building surface. Encourage sign design as an integral part of the design of buildings and developments. * Increase enforcement of the sign ordinance. 37 • N 'I E 0 m Q P 1 W - : L I i 1: //h a, . cm :U111i.1 - 410 �i_ :` ! = e la- _ \ _ 1111 we, t Al ,Rn mu smslmitm CO W Qa n C41.1 Inn "'VI" 7 0 tIn rum ci mgtm I -1 I.I i - . 1 •` tvut iLu-_ut-ut E IEEE neutt 'maw CC —Ilk, 4 t to mg t- u 11 uta 1M1Juu nn- nu **I - ; CItt ttttt t}ttr,t tall tttt t_-IR t I ttmmt„MI!1 t�--tnt If ttta,m,tt,1„ - - u. •oIi �, 5 O. .i* J(''�+•�• .1/Antutu saetz tn,p,SlruSnt'Zeta J ,4 IE Li °•i '' III ptnSnn Ti -- � I f'1 * Mixed-use zoning should be applied to the area adjacent to Pioneer Park. Previous plans have called for the enhancement of existing residen- tial and the introduction of new residential populations into this ' 1____J L____-1 li L- underutilized area. This zoning does not need to require residential as 1 the host use, but it should retain a residential component. J •.:� p ..2;:;;;satn••*11 Iii:::!: ■ * Warehouse Historic District The historical survey for the area sur- rounding the Rio Grande Depot and Pierpont areas has been done and I E indicates a for an im ortant Historic District. Such desi ation l potentialP � •��1115 °• �ooswcn would enhance the existing character of the area,providing architectural 1 ■ C protection and insuring compatibility of new development. Importantly, J L historical designation provides a "theme" for the area, inviting reinvest- , 'WAREHOUSE ment capital and providing an "Avant-Garde" area for the arts to thrive. HISTORIC DISTRICT *Temple Square/City-County Building/Cathedral of the Madeleine/ State Capitol View Corridors: These buildings represent the most archi- tecturally and historically significant buildings in the City. They provide an immediately recognizable image to residents and tourists. A view corridor would "red flag" new construction that interferes with signifi- cant g � cant views and subject it to design review. This will insure the continued f.- - - Vriti , 9 t view amenity of these important buildings. fl'? N 1 *View Corridors: Views from Downtown to the mountains and major • e l l I landmarks should also be preserved. Skywalks or other obstructions ,- , that would block view corridors are prohibited on Main Street, State 1 Street, South Temple, 200 South and 300 South and are discouraged on _=__-J�=�_ other streets except in extenuating circumstances. Historic Social Hall / *Gateways: Changes in zoning should be made to enhance the entry into i Downtown on major streets. These changes include landscaped setbacks, r land use controls and prohibition of billboards. 30 o 0 -DCA,Lit(pAltn, K1(;I,-,"") (_ NO47--avi ., ci let5z iiiii Ill Downtown Rising supports Street character © Plant more shade trees, install more wayfinding the designation of streets Each of downtown's streets serves a slightly different role signs,repurpose turning lanes to create pedestrian as either"boulevards," -some are key walking routes,others are vital regional refuges, public art or landscaping, and explore traffic arteries and some serve an important role for public reconfiguring on-street parking to provide more "transit corridors,"or transportation. Despite their role for moving traffic, all parking opportunities. ```-----�� "promenades."Here's downtown streets, regardless of their primary function, must be beautiful and convenient for pedestrians. GRAND BOULEVARDS(500 SOUTH AND 600 into the distinction: These two streets are the principal auto gateways into BOULEVARD. The following streets are recommended for priority and out of the city. Both streets should be grand ` Quality design action to improve their beauty and walkability. expressions of a capital city;they should provide a more 1 on these key dignified entrance and exit. More-stately and urban a4Y 200 EAST has the potential to be the focus of a revived boulevards can be accomplished byaddingmonumental ...• traffic arteries P `' _ urban neighborhood. While automobile traffic would L imbues all of trees and distinctive lighting to form a canopy over the �, downtown with the feeling of still be a primary use of the street,200 East could spur streets,reducing the number of large signs that visually development by providing active open space in a"Park conflict with the concept of agrand gateway,building , vibrancy.These are the main entry P and exit points for people traveling Avenue"concept similar to the center park blocks on multi-story structures to the edge of the sidewalk,and by automobile.A pedestrian would 500 West or 600 East.Turning 200 East into a dynamic preventing visible surface parking lots. l___. feel comfortable on these decidedly urban street is a signature project of Downtown Rising. 100 SOUTH east of the Salt Palace Convention Center urban,landscaped streets. WEST TEMPLE plays a key role in moving automobiles is a prime opportunity to create a new gathering space. through downtown. Nonetheless, West Temple has a ' ' r TRANSIT Traffic demands on this section are low.A pedestrian- CORRIDOR. tremendous opportunity to be transformed into a oriented street could showcase the Salt Palace tower III 1 Downtown pedestrian-friendly boulevard, linking together major and a growing restaurant scene.First South could thus �� t—� relies on hotels on the south to the Salt Palace,Symphony Hall, become a linear park filled with people,but still open r�?J City Creek Center and Temple Square complex to the to auto movement and on-street parking,not unlike Rio transit.These corridors put priority on the north. Modifications suggested through the Downtown Grande Street in the center of The Gateway. convenient movement of buses and Rising process include: 200 SOUTH provides a major link for bus and trains yet cars continue to be El Retail uses that greet the street and feature automobile traffic travelling east to west through the welcome. All trips start and prominent entrances for pedestrians. city.It also serves as a critical corridor linking the core end with walking,so these streets must be walkable. © Changes to the Salt Palace facade to provide downtown area with Salt Lake Central Station. purposeful pedestrian destinations along the west ?,"+ PROMENADE. side of West Temple. These could include a "City 'r',,. ; -' While cars are History"walk,a linear sculpture garden,kiosks and •• i- • LA still welcome, food carts,and outdoor dining. • -'QW ..,� the pedestrian gets priority on these beautiful walking routes. ' ,t r , 4 s F_ , tit F— F• , _ - Lu W RY ‘,F,e u ' + 1 . 1.- , ' 'P k + r k'f n jt Imo... +!1 '� A .. 0''',.• 4; i it'i.r r.,i-,:.'"1''','w.'."'*t00'','•4.1674,4!•.',4,•./.t 1;0,., t x to • $ y r F, , 4.7/'/if,-.0.t.oie, ,-,, .,k , W ' i I ri .1.... . . , - , I : ' .• F ` {. T • i sv f, I n i '. i 1 ubf,j�,.'1 ' ••*— ,„ + P. v `14 hppyl_�. "� .0.,,,;,...,....• ---e . k flMP • a �' .,., a'LV6i".....0...�T ,,,lie 4e .. . ., _- , ."'w'Y S ,j fF ca Illustration:Paul crown Grand Boulevards District The Grand Boulevards welcome the world to downtown Salt Lake. leading to the doorstep of the Grand America Hotel. Buildings This district includes the foremost entry corridor from the Salt Lake here clearly have the strongest presence on the street— creating an International Airport and is also home to many of Downtown's urban ambience — while stately landscaping hints at the beauty hotels. With many hotels,it is truly a hospitality neighborhood. As further within downtown. The urban design is monumental, such, the Grand Boulevards offer an outstanding first impression. befitting the width and character of these Grand Boulevards. The dominant features of this district are 500 South and 600 South 0 U 0 • • • .. Street Character • � I '.� .. - ...... 1 +1 - .II Re: .. o Y : I 4 South Tem•le - I _I .I 0/ - aaY�Y .. ia� I• 1 • I i I . . 1 '.IA lac:t ^ ;. ap` .. I 4g;1 4 R't I — . If' .. no ■• ••••• •■ 200 South ■■ . ■•••:� ■•■ ■•.• I 1 0 k. t'--174 t' 300 South 1' ■ 9 aa:; c• _ .W s I Mil__ a It n 1._ -, . ,..i- 1 ▪ g9. i f .4 i V 2 x 5 i wi. . t . .. _ v. 3 _, yy - - } r caa V. 1 _. . - 3 y • a._. L :::: : y' 2. �q. 1 .� 3 Ji N .. _ t t f:;y t .q.. .z Map lax couMny -aaaa • TRAX --- TRAX ■■■I Commuter Transit Boulevard Promenade Commerce DIG (existing) (proposed) Rail Corridor City of Salt Lake Digital Billboard Presentation • YESCO Electronics We recognize the importance of establishing effective sign codes. We appreciate the good and hard work done on the ordinance to date. We suggest the following revisions to the proposed digital ordinance: Use the following provisions for brightness: Illuminance:The intensity of light falling on a surface at a defined distance from the light source. Foot Candle: The English unit of measurement for Illuminance,which is equal to one lumen,incident upon an area of one square foot. The illumination of an Electronic Billboard shall not increase the ambient lighting level by more than 0,3 foot candles when measured by a foot candle meter perpendicular to the Electronic Billboard face at: (A)150 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area of not more than 242 square • (B)200 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area greater than 242 square feet but not more than 378 square feet; (C)250 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area greater than 378 square feet but not more than 672 square feet;and (D)350 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area greater than 672 square feet. [Keep the provision relating to"controls"] Change Dwell Time to Eight Seconds This is standard recommended by the Federal Highway Administration and is consistent with state law. Eliminate Electronic Billboard Curfew The signs are needed by business owners,stakeholders,and public service organizations 24/hrs/day. Eliminate trade-for-upgrade provisions This is a legal concern. • 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7. The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and • 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD: An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; t Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96" 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. �1tG� ANG TE e ehete }i�t#c cu ntity-fr'',ezt c esely-=?:;seslot-erd-wih-thee-oer£?otiof_-- _ -{Formatted:Font:Not Bold,Strikethrough of-brtel-ltnesS--Lum-inanee-iS-tileasuceE -in-eendet=S-oer=squarC mcter-s-or"flits'-fec ;'{Formatted:Strikethrough et3foc-3es f t T ocd Re Ge .{Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab Illuminance: The intensity of light falling on a surface at a defined distance from the --{Formatted:Not Strikethrough light source L • • {• Formatted:Font:Bold MOTION, The depiction of movement or chance of position of text. images. or --i, Formatted:Font:Not Bold graphics. Motion shall include. but not be limited to. visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images. runnina sequential text. graphic bursts, lighting that resembles zooming. twinkling, or soarklina. chances in liaht or color, transitory bursts of light intensity. movina patterns or bands of light, expanding or contracting shapes, and similar actions, . - Formatted:Font:Bold J ,NITS-A-unit-of-rneasure-off-brightness or luminance.--Gne c t-is-egual-to—ne • ---{Formatted:Strikethrough eandei Lset-are n TeterI Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: Foot Candle: The English unit of measurement for illuminance, which is equal to one', 0.25",List tab t Formatted:Font:Bold,Strikethrough lumen, incident upon an area of one square foot. {Formatted:Strikethrough TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT: An extension of the billboard resulting in Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", increased square footage aspart of an artistic design to conveya specific message Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: q 9 9 p g '•, o.zs',List tab or advertisement. { Formatted:Font:Bold• —_ Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", 1�1•'.JIRL TIME The time it takes for static text. images, and graphics on an electronic • Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: ,TWIRL to change to a different text, images. or graphics on a subseouent sign face. 0.25",List tab I Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt • t Formatted:Tab stops 0.25",List C. it -Tt?e Total-Nun;ber Of-Bill Jess als -4 k--treat -number s€bill-boards-shall-be allowed-in-Sett Lak: City-:,ha-n-the-number-of-ex-Isting-filth-ads-Billboards Prohibited: New Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. D. Relocation of Billboards: Existing billboards may be relocated as mandated by the • {Formatted:indent:Left: 0",Hanging: 0.25" requirements of Utah state law. Additionally, billboards may be relocated from any zonina district to Manufacturing, Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards, or located within 600 feet of a gateway or special aateway street or residential zoning district. ----------- --- Voluntary relocation shall follow the priority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F of Formatted:Font:Not Bold this ordinance, unless otherwise negotiated with the City. DE. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: • 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner • Formattedi_Indent_Left: 0.71" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. • • • • TC . Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300)square- (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: Left feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) °�", - J linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; Formatted:Strikethrough 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred rmatted:Indent:First line: 0" (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt --, Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left: 0.5", the Street. Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:a,b, • c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned 3. Soacina for electronic billboards fully intearated into the architecture of a at: 0.25"+Indent at: 0.5" building and not free standing, may he modified by the Planning Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Commission as a Conditional Building and Site Desian Review as outlined ; Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, in section 21A.59. as long as such modifications are consistent with State Strikethrough Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica, Law12 pt I- ::(Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left: 10.75",First line: 0" • Formatted: Paragraph,Nighttimme Illumioatien-ef-bin�rcs-rnav-not-eland-di;ee:lj-eato-the-readwav is Nbre +Level:1ist +NnberingStyle:a,b; cr_idcwalk-ocracr s- rcccrty-tires—Billboards located within Residential, Mixed-Use, :;: c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned i CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight at: 0.25"+Indent at: 0.5"_ _ and 6 am. • Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Strikethrough S: Electronic Billboards: Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, 'S 1. Electronic Billboard are prohibited except when converting an existing billboard to !? ii' Strikethrough electronic as follows: Formatted:Strikethrough • Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, a) P Billboard may be converted to an electronic billboard in 1Vlanufacturina, • .:; Strikethrough Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts.;vith--t#;e Formatted:Strikethrough r-ostricticn that-they-are-ntot--arierlted-t wafds. or-located-within-600 fo.?tLef Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, Strikethrough J gateway-ee-s-caei=t-gatev aystreet-er-reside.ntist-zoning-aistrictAarevi d-t#ai four times-the-nor^r-elertren;s-sguare-footage-o#-tie-new e!eetuonia-bltiboacd-IS ;,'j Formatted:Strikethrough ) Formatted:re- Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt ;axed c,se:yh;re in the Git __ ) • Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.75",First line: 0" tWi B• illboards may be converted to electronic billboards on Gateway streets, Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left: 0.5", ravided-thatve-tulles-the-non-elecirani he �:aucre feo-ag:c`tn ;, ::: Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:a,b, • c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned cl ctrogie-billbeard-i erneved-aleno ti e-Same-Gateway.c.r-c-ernGved-frem1:,:::: at: 0.25"+Indent at: 0.5" anot er-gatewe,y-enl',--if-stlf icient-square-foota€e-is-not-avait-able-on-the-host //. , Formatted:Strikethrough g ek . If. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, • Strikethrough o} B• illboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Special Gateways ,. Formatted:Strikethrough_ 3VIEt2d tilatOl?f tinl2S-tF1?nEn Zl2GifE3nl6sg4k7re?f00t4'£f ibS+la4'J Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, . eteetionic-billboard,is-remooved-on-the-sameSSo€cial-Gatew a:or-removed Strikethrough IC {Formatted:Strikethrough • 0 • from cno'er-cecciel gate•.,_'^^ly-if su`ficient-seuare-fea£aae-is-notavaileb'e ( tted For Font:(Default)Hevetoo,12 pt, on-the-hest-speeial-gateway-and4he-ne�rd-is fully-inteoreted ;' Form through • ir,o the architect« .ate^`a bu£ding.and-is-not free s:andinct Formatted:Strkewough Formatted:Font:(Default)HeNetica,12 pt d) Billboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Downtown or Sugar Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left: House Business District zoning jistrietsprevided-that-fwe-times-thc nor. 0.75",First Inc:0'• eJectreniwsgunre-footage-of-the-flew-eiec1roniG-billbaard-isiemoved-n nY -Formatted:List paragraph,Indent:Left 0.5', Downtown,Sugar-Hause-Business-District-fesidentialr-neiohoerhood Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:a,b, •commercial-community-B mess_onmunit'hSheoemg-6ent_ccle(eway-or C,...+Sortat:l+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:0.25"+Indent at:0.5" mixed uee^e an t e ne: eles#enicbillbeardis-fully-in£earated : intothe-arehiteohiFe of_1 e, st_ndi.., ..�o.v9.�IldiR(}andi5-Rot-f£.,c�:m.v�-m. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, St,ikethraugh • - Formatted:striketivotgh 2. Motion •Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt ,Anv motion of any kind is prohibited on an electronic sign face Electronic'fti;'r` sbaeerough billboards shall have only static text,images,and graphics. rrormatted:so-keewugn 3. Dwell time The text,image,or display on an electronic sign may not change more than once " Formatted:so-kedaougn everyt-ixtv460-)eight181seconds. Twirl time between subsequent text.images_ ro.nattea � or display shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. Formatted:smkettaough 'Formatted• 4. Brightness, • Formatted:Font:(Default)Helveti• j During-daylight-hours between eunriseand-aunset-luminance-shall-be-no.gceate' • Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica, pt than-2 500-rite At-elfethectimes74uminanee-shell-beao{,reater hae-500fits Formatted 9 The illumination of and Electronic Billboard shall not increase the ambient lighting Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold 1 level more than 0.3 foot candles when measured by a foot candle meter Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 1 perpendicular to the Electronic Billboard face at: Formatted:Foot(Default)Helvetica,a pt J Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold j (A)150 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area of not more than 242-. Formatted:Font:(1efoult)Helvetica,12 pt square feet .,;'.�FarmattrA ‘III (8)200 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface area greater than 242 '•,• I For"a 'tted•rmt.(DFlault)Helvetica,lz pt i Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt square feet but not more than 378 square feet •;'.Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold (C1250 feet for an electronic Billboard with a surface area greater than 378 ':•+ rorerettraf ...e square feet but not more than 672 square feet t','. Formatted:Not Snikethrough Formatted l...f71 (D1350 feet for an Electronic Billboard with a surface are greater than 672 square ` Formatted:Not Strikettrough feet. •`, Formatted:Not strketlrggh 5. Size Formatted:Not Strketl'mrgt' The maximum size of en electronic sign shall be no larger than the billboard It Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt replaced or shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50')in width, Formatted:Foot:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt whichever is less, ,.Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold 'Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt • • • s�:spl3y Per od F rmatted:Font Would xetem,12 a, €leotronis-killboards-may-netbe illuminated or-litbepveen-the-hours-o€midniah tO dr and-6-a fi--if-the'/ arclooated-within600 Feet of a rosidentiat-mixed-use-t,,. Formettee Font Helvetica,12 a•Not Bold, doµwADWA—Skigaf-HOLIse-Business-9istriot-gateway-Netehberhood-Gommefelal: Formatted:Fort(Dnfaun)Helvetica,12 et, Common ty Business oF-Community-Shopping-Center-zenin9-district a ap yt I Formatted:strkdleotgr 7. Controls - 'Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, a. All electronic signs shall be equipped with an automatic dimmer control or str,kethrooph other mechanism that automatically controls the sian's brightness and display Formatted:strlxmmugh .period as provided above. Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt, b. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sign,the aoolicant stnkethrough shall certify that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion,dwell Formatted:smYenragh time,brightness,and other requirements herein. Formatted:Font Helvetica,12 pr • Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold c. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sian shall submit an annual report Formatted:Font(oNault)HeNeem,12 a to the city certifying that the sign complies with the motion,dwell time brightness,and other requirements herein. -"'I Formatted:tht Paragraph UT.Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: ® Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections • 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title,or its successor chapter.No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. V U.Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts:Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of this section,or its successor subsection,upon which a billboard is the only structure,shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50)linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible,evenly on each side of the billboard. 4'W-Xeriscape Alternative:If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection,are not developed or,if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. O Discussion Draft Proposal which allows transit advertising, eliminates billboard bank, defines electronic billboards and prohibits electronic billboards. 21A.46.4 3 TRANSIT SHELTER AND PUBLIC AMENITY ADVERTISING Transit sheiter and oub!ic amenity advertising shall be allowed only as cart of a shelter at a bus stop or public transit stop or station. or a public amenity.pursuant to an accroved and executed acrreerne,nt between the City and a provider of transit shelters or public amenities.which sets forth the regulation of size,content.Placement.design and materials used in the construction of said advertisinc and shelters and public arnentit✓. For purposes of this section. "public amenity"means an item Generally Iccated in the public way to provide a public service.which may include.but is not limited to. a kiosk displaying way finding sicnace or accommodating news racks or other public • information.public restrooms, public furniture such as benches cr trash receptacles or public services such as bike sharing. The common element is that they are offered for public consumption and Provided as contract services to the City. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising shall in no case be larger than 43'by 72" and shall be limited to no more than three panels per shelter cr kiosk,unless otherwise restricted further by contract. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising is only authorized when located adjacent to non-residential. RB. RNIU.or RO zoning districts. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising display may not contain nudity. pornography.or indecent or vulgar Pictures,Graphics or lancuace or advertising of illegal products. 21A.46.060: SIGNS SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITED IN ALL ZONING DISTRICTS: The following exterior signs, in addition to all other signs not expressly permitted by this chapter,are prohibited in all zoning districts and shall not be erected: • A.Animated signs excluding public service signs; • ter' • • B.Any snipe sign; C. Balloons; D. Bench signs; except transit shelter and amenity advertising soeci ically authorized by • E. Portable signs,except where specifically permitted by district sign regulations; F. Signs overhanging the property line other than signs that are permitted under the sign regulations applicable to each zoning district; G. Signs which are structurally unsafe, hazardous or violate the uniform building code or the uniform fire code; 111 H. Signs located near streets which imitate or are easily confused with official traffic signs and use words such as"stop","look","danger", "go slow","caution"or"warning", except where such words are part of the name of a business or are accessory to parking lots;and I. Painted signs which do not meet the definition of wall signs. (Ord. 53-00§3,2000: Ord.88-95§ 1 (Exh.A), 1995) 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. • B. Definitions: BILLBOARD:A free.,standing ground sign located on industrial,commercial or 44getErifial property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located.A billboard does r,ct i; c. ,; transit shelter and public amenity advertising specifically authorized by Section 21A.45.058 E,44 EOA.P.D, BANK:An __cou'in;: 'n cs-tottched-t-‘frtko city to kcop•.:ock of t $frrrzk 2� sq are footage£•f-Fi-.r-:sonfor,r g iii�t ci s re ved p;:rai =rt-te chor B4i L8 ARD-ram EDIT:A. -p.::7 into _ -ewr, -sbiitse=rd-t .,;'. ss t-that chews the + !era.nd c9uc.c f:f::a-go o``x` !:st's..1--r,_,.—.,`c:a':ng bi cor` s BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. ,DWELL TIME The Icncth of time that elapses between text.images,or Graphics on • Formatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sign. I Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" _� I Formatted:Font:Bold EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use • or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:P.ny off-premise sign.video display.protected image.or similar device with text, images.or araohics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include.but are not limited to.signs that use licht emitting diodes(LED).plasma displays.fiber octics.or other technology that'results in bricht.hich-resolution text. imaces.and craohics. • [Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; • (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5.5600 West; • 6.2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8.Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10.500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11.600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12.300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13.North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14.Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15.State Street from South Temple to 2100 South;and 16.600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31,1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1.North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; ----1 Formatted:Indent:Left:OW 2.400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3.State Street between 600 South and 2100 South;and 4.Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. LUMINANCE The photometric euentity most c:os by associated with the cerception --Formatted:Wit:Not sad— ---- _) of brightness. Luminance is measured in cardn!an cur sgaare meters or"nits"for Formatted:Tab stops:o._zs,List tab 1 ourocses of this ordinance -Formatted:Font Bold MOTION The deeicticn of m;vement cr chenee of position of text.imaees,or Formatted:Font:Not Odd - 1 crachics. Moticn shall include.but not be limited to.visual effects such as dissolving and fadina text and imaees.running seeuentiat text.crraohic bursts,lighting that 0 • 0 resembles zooming.twinkling.or sca_rk!ina.chances in Iioht or color.transitory bursts of light intensity. movina patterns or bands of lioht.expanding or contractina shapes.and similar actions., [Formatted:Font:Bold _ ) NITS A unit of measure of brightness or luminance. One nit is equal to one - Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25°, Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: rande!c!S(;U3r�m?` r. 0.25',List tab TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. ,TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text. images.and orachics on en electronic - Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt sign to chance to a different text. imag:•S.or r]raohics on a subsequent sian face. (Formatted:Tab stops: 0.254,List tab I a C. 9T,. ;Teat r number of sh 4ll-b e 2I9r'vcr—=t— I+t fk3-G'f-'.'f-tha-?-the nm°e—^f axicti.^.y--oil o:rds.Billboards Prohibited: Nevi Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. D.Relocation of Billboards: Existing billboards may be relocated as mandated by the - (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0',Hanging: 0.25" ) reauirements of Utah state law. Additionally,billboards may be relocated from any • zoning district to'Manufacturina.Extractive industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards. or located within 600 feet of a gateway or special gateway street cr residential zonirta district. Voluntary relocation shall fellow the criority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F of [ormatted:Font:Not Bold this ordinance. unless otherwise necotiated with the City. • ;_. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner - [Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2.Application:Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee:The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars($111.00). avert:Aft::-: -a on5ofg-.Sra;-ia-y-brilbca d• ic, derr.clichod: u an:to-a—pe:ice:-ibseL—L?r:4'£r cu`5s.cti n 01 of-th s s c-cticn,or its SL:c_:seor the.e..y she s;:aatc a-t-ita r-'j-t !i--acs :zt-ta le bilibccsd ov:n£r.Tha aa'::;=s" 1-s-h, :; "e'�o.te cf th-e- ,: ,ev-_Lc=.4-#1-e zca-i g-di rict of the dc?agichcJ • S • rc..__^`cr.... ^t.'llit a h account:h€'! b!ftc^:u cradlt:fcr the billboard c 1 sure o tage. rd:hall net res.;fl=i-n-. y b llama;i cr.4 F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: • 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic,residential R-MU or (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71',Tab stops: downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; l 0.88"'Left 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB,or env gateway caning distrct C- M -1 G-:F-O i-or on gateway `s shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; 1.A biliteard.c'.vrcrFresj-4ecrt .~ rcrtenfo..mla—g billboards of a 1^' . ,ra, t.far a rame'Jing billb '� in a hi^hz e 1 n credits .�,. �.r s'• ..,.. :,;rrtii`y;hswcJ;.r,'h .1.� rd -.r-realevin -t ?Lower--p:-iefity-b4 1b -ard Sidi-rst-teeo{;,e- eciive-f r-use-ifs cCit=inisiir ':2%.lf£ilt?s=;J- ^t.�-':c(2)billscafsl:cscc!iled ss4ts°e`:iei Fl ^t this .s`.`.?r -cr' es-se i-w-ch-e-te`aii--s-q'61-ar-e-fo a equal to sF greetar ut::.,th I:wc.rr ,.ier4V- ., =r'. e atited in`he'a.:l:heard c4'rre4s b'.l'.bca.. beh aaa nt: l-a-,i�ll-ntea d--c-ne has-r—subsn2�.tton-F-1 of.this ^ ..:� r its c..ccesc4 r,'. eex4-l:FP•r.l� g bllitcards,two( St-&Cct en F'Y of crcditcd in the 1=::ICe��3 jTT,i�Ys�i}Ib ear-d--t ::-eT.o::11t-t>-ef ectuata-tae-bitltear redits-ef a-&v-sect:cn F3 of tie s:ct:cn,or its v ie .:,bl!ibc r4 to ei'ovi the c_net.'_t.c t'=r c c�J b: e-zr .For the icurt^nces of this coction,the two(2} 4.:ghc. 't t, r a.tathe``illyowrrrli '••r.:c-rr.Vc-s�--�..-c^�^—'c-'-it,..3,..,:,:r:ar�; .�ll•Aat s C`e�i:- d in�,.,... .. 1 e tr, [t.. t ti. 1 .1 .s f ..�. I @i,:}i-:�f?c.. ._c.rstklar2-n9-b{r1I36ti-r CFCL�- r,Cr 8-IrsV.,, priority-bill-beard: bi:1139$rfl: �',�=fe.Of�3+I'.beard C;`di`s-:->;;i}-b;-:-beard-sr-Vdits-rs±-Used-within-t,;;ny-six{36}finent#s of the'r _tien S'G!l . and be of r.e sr-usesxsept that!cv.cF 2cicrit'credits is cf astuata' of-t;-':o section,or its si cccsT.C;, hall cr.=ir_a: -t-:e-of-ro-kW-thtc-r-value- ;-use-wi4'^,in sixty(`;r3ymo—nths of their initial ere-t:t o.:rd Cr'.c.i�r:n:t.ra.!::A i:!: -IIY.'n:r r"r ',..!{er cth:r'r}o.transfer a Ir:!It`.^,a r-r- �LT-f.:lt t•,V ar''crrdi.s.Tr_.starred bTheord Ci itt�."4i4 h n et e{l:^hhvo i �rs2of—t i=ci ^ns�ct bsac io- f- sect!.cr its c..cc_SS-o L • • �'�r t Frf�Ceccr: gffcctiv::or t!-..0 -s-sw-ew have b ccr:n • €Tee°-fcFfr.a_'ig`F'.at C'.Vrre..'.Ttie-p=8r-sfe {';t: .�..^..,:`.., th-eif-Th rty '.x;36)mcnt it`e prcvicr-ia cubce6t; h-G-g--{this scst:oTh-GF-ito • 1-G Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two(2) advertising faces shall receive credit for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. JH.New Billboard Construction: it is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. 141. Permitted Zoning Districts:New-Relocated billboards may be constructed only in the area-;dent;,fed-en-`he-efficial-billbeG;d-map_:,Manufacturing,Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.or located within 600 feet of a oateway or special gateway street • or residential zoning district. 1_J,ev,-Billboard relocation or remodeling Permits: 1.Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an [Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees:The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building - Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96",Tab stops: code as adopted by the city; and 1.13•,Left b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. Of-2-1411.:_crd CFe'&: :-E-r--1.Ln._:tL er, ,t-s;1,n! `ormatted:Indent: Left: 0.71" Ert?Nits--cc a s-'-`-rent n rn1i_c rf-s cua re-`+.a=t en4-Lilo emit. -to-a'-'r-.mow ce stri=;6f#-er`4 e-Frew- 4lii Lc:'d: • 2.`4the the per;,--lit for the cerst ushor.of a row bi"boerd re booed,the z-ning edr..Inistreter ohe&deduct ern t e bi9bc_rd cv:ner'e b?ll,aeri benk -^^•ct a.The oq.Iere fctegee!-tke-n-c'v billboard;end Fogleman':Indent:Left r.0s^,Tab stops: 1.25',Left b- ke-e +he -f-bit t:oaress whose s,uere`rootage wee uocd to allow-he aevthiltbaarot r7structice. 3-If-the nevr-b iiho.-d ins-I ssi;an4kafafire_-avaitabta billboards:ediy (Formatted:Indent Lit:sir ccnc)Cer;ntht.:.h th num o cf billbeerds end equate footage,any remaining square*=age. re fs.he b`.fboerd bank. �rwmatbad:Indent:flnt 5,e:0.25' NK.New-Billboards Prohibited On Gateways:Except as provided in subsection 0-D of this section,or its successor,no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway s treet.. O).Special Gateway Provisions: IC) 1.If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway,the • Fmm.tted:Indent:left:0.7r,Tab.mp.: billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special °88 gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to other subsections P,0,'i-and S-of this section,provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the ass e d'e in tipzeia!gateway bil'teerd tonksize of the billboard being relocated.Billboards may not be relocated from other areas onto a special eateway 2.The demcl:on cf c ne:,saafnirg bi"boc:d porcuent to this s_c:ien ckali rot ecer e bil:bc.rd ere_'?e-v.•zk n-e—eneratbiiiheardkaak.Credits for e ki;taeerd dce-c i'skeed cr ccrf'n;c,e-d-w=kia-a speeial-gateway shall-be track_"wit:n a fa?a3 rh c t e eech cpcct l gate-lay. Pee ter the ccnotr•cticn of e eew->z'i sPant?-i fete acctien must bc te:r- cut vrithin41-. 'I—..�'6).-w-- tkss,`-t e d_r.,st3,. z.��_nnnoenferzling bil'bcard- RM.Maximum Size:The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50')in width. • • 0• l'>I.Temporary Embellishments: J—Terpercr/ -ct_z^_ce44en porr_nt(10%)cf t`.^ • Formatted:Indent Left:0.71•,Tab slops: l advec5eing-£ec_c`any b lltrvc"� n, 'pa"exceed five fee.-(a"'}tn-keig;t oar,Left arc the tilibca d str ctu e 2-No-tempeFary=mbeilis4merit,sh?!l-te-wa nie'ncd on a bulbeer-drr:erc then twelve-(:2)rncrrths, Temoorary Embellishments are prohibited • (Formatter Indent First me:0.25" RO.Height:The highest point of any new bi ree;4billboard ezcladln;'crpcarf errtbetiicb:n^nfe-shall not be more than: • 4-Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or the maximum height for a • (Formatted:Went:Left o.sa•,Hanging:—I pole sian in the applicable zanina district,whichever is less. Unless l 0.25• otherwise authorized by State law. 2-1f, r xFwi?frame•haedred-f=,—Y^-0'}cf t;a t:i!'hcard,moti:.:urod from::F• (Fonm.teed:Indent:Left:0.71• s,z«-the.-pert-at-+4tish the bil!bocrc4s-perpendicular to Sic street,is cn a-di{erel-grade4han-he-n?v.i9✓nar44wenty Eno feet(25')cbeve4 e • 3--1`the prcvisiorx c£culseetiee-R2^".�,-th v^^^lion,or Ito secrr_ssor sa=ssefan,apply to meFe-thcr coo street, h:3ticr of t`o two(2)he ghts; P.Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located.In the absence of setback standards for a particular district,freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line.This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard,not just the sign support structure. • TO.Spacing: 1.Small Signs:Billboards with an advertising face three hundred(300)square. Formated:Indent Len:o.n•,Tabstops: feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred(300) oar,LeftJ linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; • • . 2.Large Signs:Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300)square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800)linear feet from any other billboard,small or large,on the same side of the street. 'Formatted:List Paragraph,Numbered*Level: • 1+Numbering Style:1,2,3,...+Start at:I+ Alignment:Left+Aligned at:0.25"+Indent 3.Scacino for billboards icily intecrated into the architecture of a building and at:0.5" • not free standing,-may be modified by the Planning Commission as a Formatted:Indent:Left:0.5",No bullets or Conditional Building and Site Dalian Review as outlined in section 21A.50, numbering as long as such modifications are consistent with State Law •Formatted:Font:(Default)Henenca,12 pt Formatted:Indent:Left:1",Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering SMe:a,0,c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:2.25"+ R Liohting:Nighttime illumination of billboards may not axle directly onto the roadway Indent at:2.5" or sidewalk nor across property lines. Biliboards located within Residential.Mixed-Use. Formatted:Font.Helvetia,12 p4 Not Bold CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt cud E ram. Formatted:Indent:Left:1.25" S:Electronic Billboards: Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 1. New Electronic Billboard are Prohibited.Electronic billboard existing as of the Formatted:Indent:Left:r,Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start date of adoption of this ordinance.are limited to the followino: at:1+Alignment:Lett+Aligned at:2.2s"+ • Indent at 2.5" a. Motion Formatted:Font:Helvetia,12 pt,Not Bold 1 • Any motion of any kind is prohibited on en electronic sion face. Formattea:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 Pt Electronic billboards shall have only static text.images.and graphics. Formatted:Indent:Left:1.25' Formatted:Indent:Left:1",Numbered+ b. Dwell time • ''i,Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start The text.image,or display an an electronic sign may not chance more at eI+Alignment Left+Aligned at:2.25'+ than once every sixty(60)seconds. Twirl time between subse❑uent mdernat zs^ .�Formatted:Font Helvetiap4 N , Not Bok text.images.or diselay shall not exceed 0.25 seconds. - - — -----12 pt, Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetia,12 pt C. Brightness Formatted:Indent:Left:1.25- During daylight hours between sunrise and sunset.luminance shall be+ Formatted:Indent:Left:1',Numbered+ no creator than 2.500 nits. At all other times.luminance shall be no/Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:2.25"+ abater than 500 nits. Indent at:2.5" Formatted:Font:Helvetia,12 pt,Not Bold d. Size Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt -. The maximum size of an electronic sion shall be no larger than tne•-formatted:Indent Len:1.25" billboard as it exists as of the date of the adoption of this ordinance 'Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt e. D'cslr',r cried -'Formatted:Indent.Left:I',Numbered+ •_ - Level:5 Numbering Style a,b,c, +Start t:1 a Alignment:Left+Aligned at:2.25'+ nixuduse. doi.i.intc,iiiii. Scour House Besn_ss District. catewav Formatted:Font:Helvetia,12 Pt,Not Bold Neighborhood•Commercial, Community Business. or Community Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Shoosine Center zoning district. Formatted:Indent:Left:1.25" \Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt 0 0 f. Con„roil Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start i. All electronic signs shall be ecuipped with an automatic dimmer at:1+Alignment:left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ control or other mechanism that automatically controls the sign's Indent at: 2_5",Tab stops: 1.25",Left briohtness and display period as provided above. � Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold 3 Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 9 ii. Prior to approval of any cermit for to ocerate an electronic sign. - the applicant shall certify that the sian has been tested and complies with the motion,dwell time.briohtness.and other requirements herein. ill. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sign shall submit an annual report to the city certifying that the sicn complies with the motion.dwell time.briohtness.and other recuirements herein. • Lormatted:List Paragraph . Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. VUJ.. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as • specified in subsection U of this section,or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure,shall he landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible,evenly on each side of the billboard. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection,are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. '. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. • • • YX.Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance:Construction,demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance and the Tree Pro'eceion ordinance.. ZY.Subdivision Registration:To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve,make minor subsequent amendments to,and record as necessary,such subdivision. PA.Spccici Provic!or- pp rcci!!y:TFc p ovtsiecta-ef4h-e-eec;orr-shc;!apply to:postficd t:illbea.-da!:coat: - -- -- - -_aae''F.'a0 North crdl8nn•crr:djceattot.cwee' lido of!r.!^rc.ct:15;::.d ._ .. - - _:-sf side of V!ctcry Poo::ct:pprcxkeatc'y 110')Clcr'r. • Ccr.cr_I f rl cb;::y:E--,crept-au rcd:`ed by till:sec'::,:,all ct cr p v aisa:_...,._ cl-cp'er chaltapp-ly.to tl s Sve{S)spes+!led bill5r_rds • .cpeeicl Priesity:The-€ve-(5)-speuified-billbr ard;-shallbe-esa;idesedas-gateway bilksarde-fes-the-puticeses-of-the-pdaaty-prov ste s of subsection F of this ce on,-^ ; • c.:ccccscesubeeoction. . -n.cccpi The vc(5)s-pecifod billbea-dc shell be 4eeey d-percacr:._ prcv'cieee cf eubs_stie -Vs`-''.is saeiien;6Fii.eecce:ccr BB,Stale endatedRe...o_.. a ;rs:E.__ .cri_<d``_, axis-i-S-litlbc r - r Lll-b s:cte4u:•::(Ord.72-08§2,2008:Ord.42-08§12,2008:Ord.13-04§§25,26, 27,2004:Ord.25-00§§1-3,2000:Ord.83-98§§12-14,1998:Ord.88-95§1(Exh. A),1995) C Discussion Draft Proposal which allows transit advertising,eliminates billboard bank, defines electronic billboards and allows limited conversion to electronic billboards when accompanied by a reduction in overall number of billboards. 21A.46.058 TRANSIT SHELTER AND PUBLIC AMENITY ADVERTISING Transit shelter and oublic amenity advertising sha'1 be allowed only as part of a shelter at a bus stop or public transit stop or station.or a public amenity.pursuant to an approved and executed agreement between the City and a provider of transit shelters or public amenities,which sets forth the regulation of size.content.placement.design and materials used in the construction of said advertising and shelters and public amentity. For purposes of this section.'public amenity"means an item generally located in the • oublic way to provide a public service.which may include,but is not limited to.a kiosk displaying way finding sionage or accommodatina news racks or other public information.public restrooms.public furniture such as benches or trash receptacles or public services such as bike sharino. The common element is that they are offered for public consumption and provided as contract services to the City. Transit shelter and oublic amenity advertising shall in no case be larger than 48'by 72" and shall be limited to no more than three panels per shelter or kiosk,unless otherwise restricted further by contract. Transit shelter and public amenity advertising is only authorized when located adjacent to non-residential.RB,RNU,or RO zoning districts. Transit shelter and oublic amenity advertising disolav may not contain nudity. pornoeraohy,cr indecent or vulezr pichures,graphics or language or advertising of iilesal products. 21A.46.060:SIGNS SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITED IN ALL ZONING DISTRICTS: The following exterior signs,in addition to all other signs not expressly permitted by this chapter,are prohibited in all zoning districts and shall not be erected: • 0 A.Animated signs excluding public service signs; B.Any snipe sign; C.Balloons; D.Bench signs;excerpt transit shelter and public amenity advertisina soecitcally authorized by section 21A,46.58 E.Portable signs,except where specifically permitted by district sign regulations; F.Signs overhanging the property line other than signs that are permitted under the sign regulations applicable to each zoning district; G.Signs which are structurally unsafe,hazardous or violate the uniform building code or the uniform fire code; H.Signs located near streets which imitate or are easily confused with official traffic signs and use words such as"stop","look","danger","go slow","caution"or"warning", except where such words are part of the name of a business or are accessory to ® parking lots;and I.Painted signs which do not meet the definition of wall signs.(Ord.53-00§3,2000: Ord.88-95§1(Exh.A),1995) 21A.46.160:BILLBOARDS: A.Purpose Statement:This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number.This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways,views,vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. 0 • B. Definitions: BILLBOARD:A freestanding ground sign located on industrial,commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business,product or service that is not sold,offered or existing on the property where the sign is located.A billboard does not include transit shelter and public amenity advertising specifically authorized by Section 21A.46.058 3'-LLB-CARD 9.N4c—i,r..accounting syorta.n1 estcti!;ch:d c.,,f a city to?.cop trcck-ef 4. -n Wtb€4-and sq..* re`D-rag-e-of•-g9:toonfe:fFii:3-b-4i--oaf's rCT,C€4 r-uarit to te7;4c cho;:te-. E SQ�RD CREDIT =,-4-ec tcy inte z billboard owner's billboard ban%account that :how-P.-to .._:'.'.hc -.an cqu:e fco imago. ..a:r.c"cs .ed r o.r_c .fora.n; BILLBOARD OWNER:The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. DWELL TIME I ha length of time that elapses between text. images.cr graphics on " I Formatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sign. I Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" Formatted:Font:Bold z EXISTING BILLBOARD:A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use • or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. • ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:Any off-premise sign.video display.orolected image.or similar device with text. images.or graphics generated by solid state electronic comoonents. Electronic signs include, but are not limited to.signs that use Tight emitting diodes(LED). plasma displays,fiber optics,or other technology that results in bright. high-resolution text.images.and graphics. • Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; • (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4.4000 West; 5. 5600 West; • = C 6.2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7.The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9.400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11.600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12.300 West from 000 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16.600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY:The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96" 2.400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. LUMINANCE The oh i i':nl itic CU_:nNu✓most CI059i`✓a55cc:ated with the oerceotion Formatted:Font:Not Bold of brightness. Luminance is measured in candelas per square meters or"nits"for Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab purposes of this Ordinance. Formatted:Font Bold MOTION The depiction of movement or chance of position of text.images,or /l formatted:Font:Not Bold grohics. Motion shall include. but not be limited to.visual effects such as dissolving and fading text and images. running seouential text, craohic bursts. lighting that • resembles zooming.twinkling,or sparkling,chances in light or color.transitory bursts of light intensity,moving patterns or bands of light,expanding or contracting shapes,and similar actions, I Formatad:Fan:Bold 1 • NITS A unit of measure of brightness or luminance. One nit is easel to one (Formeted:Normal,Went:terb candela/square meter. IlSpace Berate:Auto,After Auto,Tab : 0.2F,nst bb TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text.images,and graphics on an electronic - [Fe—matted:Fad:ekhetlo,12 a sign to change to a different text,images,or oraohics on a subsequent sign face. Lnnnatted:Tab stops:01r,nsttab C.Limit On Tho Tctol tlrmi'cr Cf Biltbnorce:No grn to curnbcr of billboard:choll be thcn tho rumbcr cf cxicting billboards Billboards Prohibited:New Billboards are prohibited in Salt Lake City. • D.Relocation of Billboards:Existing billboards may be relocated as mandated by the :Indent:ten:0•,!Sensing:0.zr requirements of Utah state law. Additionally.billboards may be relocated from any •' zoning district to Manufacturing,Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.or located within 600 feet of a gateway or special gateway street or residential zoning district. Voluntary relocation shall follow the priority outlined in subsection 21A.46.160.F of• f.ormatted:Font:Not Bold this ordinance,unless otherwise negotiated with the City. OS.Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1.Permit:Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner • (rorrn.tind:Indent Loft 0.71 only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2.Application:Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3.Fee:The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars($111.00). E.Credits-Fes-0-oveuafcwr..: g Sillbeec4.Rernevs-i-Atar.—nawennferming da s-s=ad-prr :.t to a pcw'ticcuc 4cr cutozcticr. of tt is tno city oho.'crac:ea biltbo:rd boat;acoo::nt for the billtoa•" a__:t#=Y_nc.w-he-da'.aaf-1`.cromova!;.;:'"h...zoning diot:ictcft odcr..^lT4 0 0 • Rcr.Csnf:r:rts!f g bil�C^...f1.Th2 eC::.,...^,t sh ll cc:c+bi!lboa:d Ord itc cquere footago D,^.:;'c!:t:o of a conformity + :+IbC?: -h}aY;notroo....ilt t,+iibo .rd credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or Formatted:Indent:Left:.0.71",Tab stops: downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 0.88",Left 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or env gateway-enina district G AID ti=rS c-G-4or on gateway s shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; ..:,bil!boerd:,;.'f+'sr`Ttr^.. s'-i+.`,i:c`1 :'oonfo:ruing b i:`..':,c--c'cf-c^.!c'.ver Wore rof'rnv-ir:^ .,oa d in r.i;i?^_'priority;t.cwc':r,the t_7,+_Co..rd c.eet:ts- #oF-removing-the--to ec-f 4 y billtoord shall- stkaseme-e feL ve-fo :e i F c--a,ctrif`ing 3 W-4-bcord u4,`r-i--t,'.c(2) b:irboo opeeinc.''.. F1 of this section,or itss:.ccesx.r,with tctcl c:,ue;_fcetege cal to Cr gr',~tF-#*cT—! e—1IT.•T FT !ti biUIho:f{, c P C:�ico In the bi'!5c "f o .n:ra • hittboccdamnk aor-curt. if a-trii;tcc cv:^ has-sosubsec4i-on F, of this rcction,or its cucsesscr,r..nccnfe..'* a-b are- two(2) this cecti cr it'.cucce—ss:fiority bi!{boa,'Gts may be croditec'in the b-itiboacd-Fiwnor'o <crc:.';,t-to-e#footua_te th b'0i ee 4credito cf 3 cubscctien F3 cf thio c cti:f ,cr Ito s::5ce or,b!llbcord to e!icYi4 e conetri;ctior:cf a nerd-vitib£ac4-For 41 e tpu po ec of ti-ic saoioR-r tha4 :c(2) 41 t:ighor priority bi!lbserds credited ti:c ni:cord '<^ account co;,,,� did only ono3 tt'3-a-cott1ate-the-trithoard--crd,;3-#c--a-wer pr:^rFiif ail=^---o r-'4: • • r— Of 3ltafd--C4--editrAn'billboard-credits no sed-withi;-th f`;&in(33)-msnths can cho!i-ex--i a-af'rd cf,^,`J fu th&va'!..--or e c.`:coj:.t that',owe; priority c,cd:ts-^`footoctod pun.^,..nt to cvtrs:ction FS of this section,cr its-suooerc^ , s l-e-xo e-arnci.-bavf no f:H'_i ar-v al oo or U-24 af=_'-Sierd4 ;;s-f^fcv!e:A hiltha: -t ILC ctthe t'_-s4an-a bIf .I h 1 .Jito Tinno� .J h Ilion d .hi rt rt n :�afd-?f�..Jc�!:�rd cre..E..,. ._.,.,,aFa—i...,_eru ...e�'.�`t-s�r..,.ci cr...,.,... ..,o the priority:,revisi_..:{=f- c - !-:f tip:., • • •-?..!-Prot beC{3cnc h:v.:bccc;`.;e e-frcti c for the origin'.!cw e .Tt'c tranzfor f any billboard`'rodit:do not oxtien:' ei�:' rty s�Es c•,h Tito- vi�e44n_4t o_�t a rf ;;s ^�tio cr is Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two(2) advertising faces shall receive •' credit for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. • New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code,the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K1. Permitted Zoning Districts:New-Relocated billboards may be constructed only in the ar a id-2a:+t ed on the-o-ffieiat and map_Manufacturing. Extractive Industry and CG General Commercial zoning districts with the restriction that they are not oriented towards.or located within 6C0 feet of a gateway or special oatewav street 1111 or residential zoning district. Billboard ialocaticn or remodeling Permits: 1.Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an • [Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees:The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building " Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.96",Tab stops: 1 code as adopted by the city; and 1.13",Left • b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Us-e^f Bidaced+ 4—A-?aw billboard per Fr^t droll a;41--t-e-= ad .h e-cp mar t ha bi! C_:d ' (Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71" � • ' cr its of a sufficient num5cr of cyu ce-faa- d billboards to allow ao4s-tr-L-Lati-an-ef,t;o new-b-gaaacd.r • 0 • 2.When.the p(^.;:t f;r the the__... g adrninist,'3tt. C all .1tt-f rn tiY_ c1- ?e-tquace-f 2ge•- cf-z^-e—ne' nd Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.08",Tab stops: 1.25",Left b. Tire-nu'nha'o,bl!lboard-s- o-c _ new-biliboerd serlstrustior,. 1f t!'v.-,-Revo-b-i4lbear4-uses-les£ fan th anti-re--at,Lallabla bi!-;cca d.cr` tdits to matted:Indent:Left: 0.71" J cr..r.s!derIng Loth the-n-u-F-ber-ef-bit!Lcards ar.d ;ua._`cc`.z;o,any re ;- +xce foot. e-�trall rern „-in4he-b!tbaard bank ' ! Formatted:Indent:First line: 0.25" ' Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection(?-D of this section,or its successor, no new b;l!board may be constructed within six hundred feet(600')of the right of way of any gateway street. • Special Gateway Provisions: Q 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway,the • Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.71",Tab stops: • billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special 0•88"•left ! gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to other subsections P,O, R G 4-SS-of this section,provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the z-rne ~-ef-i!:-osa-7! b boar benksize of the billboard being relocated. Billboards may not be relocated from other areas onto a special gateway 2.The a.amo-":`.,c..c`-a-seA a� :rre-.' ' car j r5_ent to this sect or shag not u a a :itii t 1 IIyc 'd C `v^orti2-�'-i1�.".��.rr''�i-:rti'rsrr?-t� bill-beacd--de-ma;ished-er ccng rrusfe<'.rty t a- -s eo =teway shall-be trcc4ed within a scpc._t:.b nk 'ant for each c.rec e!get v.ay.A for-he c-cns-talct!c -ef rurtuant to th:&s-eot an mt..at be tal-ce-r cut within demelit; e-acnccn`a4miag Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50') in width. C • -:?_.Temporary Embellishments: ..Tempe:cry am. ,,00tc lf_�ecd ton;,erne;*tc1444vrGe Formatted:Indent:tat:0.71%Tab stops: advertising face-of any-tailibeaf^_, -'d sha .. _•mend-Eve`ea'(5)is:e gbi o.sr,Left aheve-thebillko=_rd structure. 2tva-ternpaaq entee:ucbrn t-shams -nta .alne-d-on-a-biq ;9-ms-e than twelve(12)menthe.- Temporary Embellishments are prohibited (r«m.tted:Indent:Rrst aye:0.25" P.O.Height:The highest point of any new b!4 hear=billboard exciedi; rm p_rvr, e mbelliehmenfs-shall not be more than: i—Forty five feet(45')above the existing grade;or the maximum height for a Formatted:Indent:Left:o.sa•,nanoaq: pole sign in the applicable zoning district.whichever is less. Unless l o.zs• __ J otherwise authorized by State law. 2.Ifcst: hhie-..=; n;a1`ct(1C0)c`.,ctiL"_•c4a,oleoured`:petthe• `Fommtted:Indent:Let on' sect et the-point at-which the biilboc•h;s perpendloe1er to the street,::co adiSecent-grada4bee-the-new biibsaue'4 en;i-fveteet-f2S)-aheve-the pescrneat-elevaGanefihc cf ee=. • 3--4-the provici�.c cf-:bscc eoee-i22 cf this coctioe.Crar its cucs_= subsection,opp;y to •orcthen � c---en e'rth ,e -eill _ar d:any bethe higher cf the two(2)heights."^ SP.Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located.In the absence of setback standards for a particular district,freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line.This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard,not just the sign support structure. TO.Spacing: 1.Small Signs:Billboards with an advertising face three hundred(300)square• :Formatted Indent:Len:O.n•,Tab stops: -_l feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred(300) o.ea•,Left J linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; • 0 2.Large Signs:Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300)square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800)linear feet from any ether billboard,small or large,on the same side of the street. 3.Spacing for electronic billboards fully integrated into the architecture of a building and not free standing.may be modified by the Planning Commission as a Conditional Building and Site Design Review as outlined in section 21A.59,as long as such modifications are consistent with State Law R Lighting:Nighttime illumination of bilibeards may not glare directly onto the roadway • or sidewalk nor across orooerl,LIMes. Billboards located within Residential,Mixed-Use Formatted:Indent:First lme:o^ CN or CB zoning districts may not be illuminated or lit between the hours of midnight Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvenca,12 pt and 6 am. Formatted:on Paragraph,Indent Left:0.S., Numbered+Level:I+Numbering Style:a,b, S:Electronic Billboards: c,.....Start at:I+Alignment:Left+Mgred at:0.25•+Indent at:0.51 1. Electronic Billboard are prohibited excerpt when converting an existing billboard to Formatted;List Paragraph,Indent Left: electronic as follow_: 0.25•,First line:0• • Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Lee:0S, © a)A Billboard may be converted to en electronic billboard in Manufacturina. Numbered+Level:1+Numcedng Style:a,Extractive Industry and CG general Commercial zoning districts with the G..+Start at 1+Allgnmeot Left+Aligned restriction that they are not oriented towards,or located within 600 feet of a at o 2s•+Indent at:os gateway or special Gateway street or residential zoning district. Provided that F°"°anew:Font(Deramn velveuea,lz pt four times the non-electronic square footage of the new electronic billboard is Formatted.Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt removed elsewhere in the City. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 Pt Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt bl Billboards may be cerrserted to electronic billboards on Gateway streets, Formanea:Font(Default)Heroeu e,12 pt provided that five times the non-electronic square footage of the new Formatted:Indent:Left:0.75,First line:0'' electronic billboard is removed along,the same Gateway.or removed from Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left:0.51, another gateway only if sufficient square footage is not available on the host J Numbered+Level:1+Numbedng Style:a,la, c,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned gateway. Iat:0.25•+Indent at 0.51 //A Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt c) Billboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Special Gateways /;Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt provided that four times the non-electronic souare footage of the new j Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetlra,12 pt electronjillboard is removed on the same Special Gateway or removed from another special gateway only if sufficient square footage is not available Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt on the host special gateway and the new electronic billboard is fully integrated Fortte'lrsdt o• :ust paragraph,Indent:Left: .D.�sma�,F Imo: into the architecture of a building and is not free standina_ 7.1 Formatted:List Paragraph,Indent:Left:0.5•, Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:a,b, ell Billboards may be converted to electronic billboards in Downtown or Sugar +Start at 1+Alignment:Left+Aligned House Business District zonina districts provided that five times the non- at.o.2s+mdentat os electronic souare footage of the new electronic billboard is removed in any l Formatted:Font(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Downtown.Sugar House Business District,residential,neighborhood Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt commercial.Community Business.Community Shopping Center.aateway.or Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt -71 Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 • • • • • mixed-use zoning district and the new electronic billboard is fully integrated Formatted:Font:(Default)WWI.,12 pt J into the architecture of a buildino and is not free standing. . • • Formatted:Font(Dorgan)Helvetlo,]z pt Formatted:Indent:Leg:0.5',Space After: 2. Motion 18 pt,tine spadrp:Multiple 1.151i,No bullets Any malice of any kind is crohibited on an electronic sign face. Electronic or nonibe""9 billboards shall have only static text,images.and araohics. Formatted_Font:Helvetica,12 pt.Not Bold 1 Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetira,12 pt 3. Dwell time Formatted_:Font:(Default)Hemetica,12 pt The text.image.or display on an electronic sign may not chance more than once Formatted Font:Hevetica,12 pt.Not Bold every sixty(60)seconds. Tv:irt time between subsequent text.images.or display Fomuned:Font:(Default)eeloenca,12 pt 1 shall not exceed 0.25 seconaa. --_--- 4. Brightness Formanea:Fprd:Helvetica,12 pt,not Bold During daylight hours between sunrise and sunset.luminance shall be no greater Fonnaned:Fyne(Default)HeIontica,12 pt than 2.500 nits. At all other times,luminance shall be no greater than 500 nits. -.-.- 5. Size 'Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Odd 1 The maximum size of an electronic sian shall be no larger than the billboard it Formatted:Font:(Default)Helveuw,laps_J replaced or shalt not exceed fifteen feet(15'1 in height and fifty feet(50')in width. whichever is less, Formatted:Font Helvetica,12 pt 6. Display period Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 Pt,Not Sold Electronic billboards may not be iiluminated or lit between the hours of midnight. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt and 6 a.m if then are located within 600 Feet of a residential. mixed-use. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt downtown,Sugar House Business District.oatewa',Neiahborhood Commercial. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 Pt Community Business.or Community Shopping Center zonina district. Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt 7. Controls Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold 1 a. All electronic signs shall be ecuioped with an automatic dimmer control or • !Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt _! ether mecherti;,n that automatically controls the sian•s brightness and display period as provided above. b. Prior to approval of any permit for to operate an electronic sion,the acolicant shall certitl that the sign has been tested and complies with the motion.dwell time,brightness.and other reouirements herein. c. The owner and/or operator of an electronic sion shall submit an annual raoort to the city certifying that the sign complies with the,motion,dwell time. brightness.and other requirements herein. • Formatted:Set Paragraph UT.Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title,or its successor chapter.No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. • • VU.Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts:Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of this section,or its successor subsection,upon which a billboard is the only structure,shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50)linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible,evenly on each side of the billboard. IWV.Xeriscape Alternative:If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section,or its successor subsection,are not developed or,if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property,or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. XY/.Existing Billboard Landscaping:Existing billboards shall comply with the © landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1,1996. IxX.Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance:Construction,demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree Istewardship ordinance and the Tree Protection ordinance_ Y.Subdivision Registration:To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve,make minor subsequent amendments to,and record as necessary,such subdivision. AA,-Spec-gal Previ=isrv_- pp eab"ty:The previcic =-of-ir:c c n :lz_r s. ed bil'.tcaeT,oti. Four-(4}e)deting bi lMxdc between 1500 t:or -ae44900 P's# _cnt to tt',c wc- sfde of Intersta'c 15 ad One cx s&,tin:0:rd on::.pact c:'e cfN;c'ary ricer,ct cpprc i eta y-i 100 1'er: 0 • • [evr;.2..:. c,r,:,..ic.,`,.:•,. .`..-4,—::::4:tEt,(f::',..c,;..-÷-:,,,:cdzi,:ci_f,t,y !,..:23,....:tio.. .'i.. s.---:er-,-:r.i-,-:•g-:ei--:r•s o f I!:i: .qssoi-cl-P-r-ireiT-he-five;5)cpssifsd-biWosis4o-s4ail-be-,-r-:asidsred-as-gatieway . biiilboarrl:fostbep4r-p-ose-s-of4Se-priarity-Koria c.cob:co:ion F cf tbis-sssitisn,cr it: ouccesccr cut-ses, Lrir,docap-istj:Th..:fae-(4)-od-biiii1L-,::::•:'s r.h:This-a-k-:h.4.zoop:d purzo:nt t-c-tire proktrichs cf cut:2ctirrl-,'of this occt.on,cr it:----,-:-•'---'jci. Egii-Stato f.lasdi,..ted-Reilosatian Of Eillbonr4 Ex:sot=other.vi:e cothcrizcal-h-sr:i.r, exis#og boards-rosy-sat bc rcloeated-exc-F-.;ka:mcndctcd by th2 rco ;recnestssf litch statc Iow.(Ord.72-08§2,2008:Ord.42-08§12,2008:Ord.13-04§§25,26, 27,2004:Ord.25-00§§1-3,2000:Ord.83-98§§12-14,1998:Ord.88-95§1(Exh. A),1995) 0 1110 • Information being provided for the February 7,2011 subcommittee meeting: 0 C February 7.2011 Planning Commission Subcommittee agenda 0 Review of Administration position—Frank Gray Comparison of Salt Lake City to Salt Lake County—zoning maps Review of Gateway concept. Discussion • • OInitial Inventory of neighborhood billboards 2/3/11—not field checked—not all inclusive Type Board owner Land owner Residentially zoned billboards 1290 East 700 South Reagan Reagan 760 South 1300 East Reagan Joseph Snore 2708 south 900 East Reagan Reagan 300 North 900 West Reagan Reagan 1040 West 200 South(freeway)Reagan Reagan RB Residential Business billboards 380 E 900 South Reagan Three Eighty LLC CN Neighborhood Commercial billboards 432 S 900 East Reagan Janda 1314 S 500 E Reagan Hogle O314E 1300 South Reagan Reagan 1706 s 900 East Reagan Robinson CB Community Business billboards 2348 E Parleys Reagan Neerings 2320 E Parleys Reagan Cochrane 252 S 1300 E(University HD) Reagan Penelope 227E 2100 S Reagan 21 and Roberta Ilc 2219 South 700 East Reagan North Building Ilc 2191 S 700 East Reagan Miller 2208 S 900 East Reagan McDonald 912 North 900 West(freeway) Reagan Shree Historic District 276 W 700 North(Capitol Hill) Reagan NTS investments O More cities ban digital billboards-USATODAY.com Page I of 2 •Cars•Auto Financing•Event Tickets•Jobs•Real Estate On'ire Degrees•Business Opportunities•Shopping Search Now do I and k? Subscribe to paper O • IAlNi7. Home News Travel Money Sports Life Tech Weather News Nation Census Troops at Risk Lotteries More cities ban digital billboards Videos you may be interested in updated Y2a12010 532 PM I comment I Recommend sm.!save'Print I Reprints a Remissions Ica • By Larry Copeland,USA TODAY Share As the USA cracks down on testing while Yahoo!Burs driving,more than a dozen cities around the ..a nation have banned what some consider a Add ss Mba I growing external driving distraction:digital tmatsr Yi ,r,tyr billboards. Facebook preparations in.. Named WTI _ Digital billboards change images every four to' Twitter More sudedl 10 seconds,flashing multiple messages from ' one or ore advertisers an the same sign. More Opponents such as John Regenbogen of ba Scenic Missouri deride them as"television on s Most Popular E-mail Newsletter a stick." myYahn TSpnep to teget: Several communities have banned digital IDPpgle ®Enlarge By Tim A Puker,1:USA TODAY gi gap viiwand comm p8 y Y_�_ billboards outright,rhis the most recent being More galleries and community ILIUM sr Louie a among a growing number al cries Denver earlier this month.Other places have tl_;3 r.1"h P insisumg a moratorium on digital and other electronics put a moratorium on them pending a federal MOST the ahead untilnse<s an enensive review Cy study on whether they distract drivers.Al least two other cities e Federal Highwry Admimseaton, and bee states are studying moratoriums. POPULAR MAP:Digital billboard laws across the USA /'Y4 sign up gm USA TODAY E.n'ail newsletters DIGITAL BILLBOARDS HIT DISTRACTIONS:States go after testing drivers ROADBLOCK LAHOOD:FecusDriven combats distracted driving • Digital billboards along public roadways face 'The digital billboards area distraction;says Fred Wessels,an Phone cone,C orpes miam Cont pas by Good!= t Amon the state and alderman in St.Louis,which just a roved a one-a n has for PF le aam a Today! oga Vour • local 900e regulations is(mirin them: m 1 thata one-year L dl Bill?ClClaimTod yI govemmen g oratorium on new such signs in city. Avow lad'-±ClascACn cam "I/they weren't distracting,they wouldn't be doing their job,"says Max Ashburn,spokesman for Scenic Arne-c3,a national non- CLICK HERE fora larger map. profit group that seeks to limit billboards. Research on the issue is mixed.A Virginia Tech Transportation Institute study in 2007,financed by the billboard industry,found that they aren't distracting.A review of studies completed last year for the American Association of State Highway • and Transportation Officials,however,concluded that they"attract drivers'eyes away from the road for extended, demonstrably unsafe periods of time." "There's no doubt in my mind that they are not a dining distraction;says Bryan Parker,en executive vice president for Clear Chancel Ct.''u:,r,which owns about 100 digital billboards.He cites industry-sponsored studies of collis!one before and after digital bi.l'oards were installed in Albuquerque.Cleveland,and Rochester,Minn.,that found no correlation. "We've looked at bet very carefully,"says Bill Ripp,vice president of Lamar Advertising,which owns 159,000 billboards,1,150 of them digital."We don't want to cause any unsafe conditions for drivers." Digital billboards area fast-growing segment of the outdoor advertising market.Since a federal rule against them was eased in 2007,the number of digital billboards has more than doubled to about 1,800 of 450,000 total billboards.At least 39 states allow them.They cost en average 3200,000 to$300,000 apiece,according to the industry group Oct iocr Ad.er.s;rig Aosccia'en Cl Are,:is. In 2007,the Federal Highway Administration relaxed a rule against digital billboards,saying they don't violate the 1965 Highway Beautification Act's ban on"intermittent,""flashing"or"moving'fights.FHWA is researching the signs,using eye-trackers inside volunteers vehicles to determine whether drivers look at the billboards and for how long.The study Is to be completed this summer. There is little current data on whether greater distractions fur drivers come from in-vehicle or eolemal factors.The Department of Transportation,which is leading the national push against testing while driving,says that 5,870 people were kilted in distracted driving crashes in 2008.But the agency has not determined how many of those deaths involved en electronic device,another distraction such as eating or tuning the radio,or something outside the vehicle. You might also be interested in: Are cholesterol drugs OK for healthy people? (USATODAYmm in Mews) Lake Superior's great mystery (USATODAYmm in hews) Is focus on distracted driving going down the wrong road?(USATODAYrom in Money) Car navigation,radio touch'screens can distract drivers(USATODAYmm in Money) .....n con con ♦.T s.o__nTllT`—„1:..1._..0_ "TH1/")f111 OCities and States that restrict electronic billboards(as reported by USA today 3/24/10) Ban Hawaii ' San Francisco Montana Denver Gilbert AZ Pima County AZ Amarillo TX Ft.Worth Dallas Galveston Houston Austin St Petersburg FL Knoxville TN © Durham NC Vermont Maine Moratorium Los Angeles El Paso San Antonio St Louis Minnetonka MN Considering Atlanta Minnesota Michigan O Residentially Zoned Billboards. • Billboard Adjacent Sidwell Zone Lot size Lot Improve- Tax on land Tax on Bill- Tax on Total tax Owner- Notes location property number in acres value8 ment value,/ and IandS board billboards on land ship (sq ft) (total) improve- (billboard values and menlss sites) billboard. 1290 East - 16-8-231- R-2 0.07 $3,900 - - $56.' $105 81° $57" Reagan, Substandard lot.. 700 South 014 (3,049.2) William+ Potential park. 1280 East 16-8-231- R-2 0.05 and $26,400 - $208." - - - - Bastow, Multi-family 700 South 013 and 0.16 $62,200 $89,400 $1,199.59 Jeffery and 704 015 (9,147.6) ($178,000) ($1,408.") South 1300 East 760 South - 16-8-231- RMF- 0.14 $51,800 - - $745" $35 $0." $745.'5 Shore, Lot capable of 1300 East 032 30 (6098) Joseph accommodating one housing unit. 766/776/ 16-8-231- RMF- 0.10/ $54,000 - $776.1° - - - - Shore, 7-11/ 780 South 025/026 30 0.14/0.16 S72,600 - $1,044." Joseph commercially 1300 East /027 (17,424) S124,500 $36,100 $2,310.55 used residential ($287,200) ($4,131.95) land. 756 South 16-8-231- RMF- 0.14 S55,700 $215,100 $2,142'' - - - - Felsted, Multi-family/ 1300 East 023 30 (6098.4) ($270,800) Raymond non-conforming units. 2708 South - 16-20- R-1- 0.11 $35,700 - - $282." $315 $4." $2$7•' Reagan, Substandard lot• 900 East 381-007 7000 (4791.6) William+ 2712 South 16-20- R-1- 0.21 $40,300 $215,500. $2,024." - - - - Abassi, Duplex to the 900 East 381-017 7000 (9147.6) ($255,800) Masoud south/non- conforming unit 300 North - 8-35-404- R-I- 0.17 $25,500 - - $366." $224 $3." S370." Reagan, Lot capable of 900 West 001 7000 (7405.2) - William+ accommodating one housing unit 868 West 8-35-004- R-I- 0.09 $18,100 $91,000. $863." - - - - Zovkovic, Home to east/ 300 North 002 7000 (3920.4) ($109,100) Ginna substandard lot• 334 North 8-35-258- R-l- 0.09 S20,100 $58,800 $624." - - - - Mendez, Home to north/ 900 West 001 7000 (3920.4) (S78,900) Sapai substandard lot' 1040 West - 15-02- RMF- 0.25 $19,200 - - $250." No No tax 5250.g1 Price,Edith Lot capable of 200 South 178-021 35 (10,890) value listed accommodating a listed triplex 1044 West 15-02- RMF-' 0.19 $40,000 $19,300 S0.' - - - - LD Church Church 200 South 178-020 35 (8276.4) (lax exempt) of Christ 1030 West 15-02- RMF- 0.12 $16,200 $41,500 S0.' - - - - Kohart, 200 South 178-022 35 (5227.2) ($57,700) Francine N •A single housing unit may be built on substandard lots if they were legally subdivided. • +Owner of both billboard and land s Values provided by Salt Lake County Assessor and Treasurer 1111 0 Billboards Go Interactive With Help of WiFi-WSJ.com#printMode Page 1 of 2 CMExecot6roConfwenee;.,•TIITIPLI fSITIIlRGI- THE FUTURE OF BUSINESS• Request an ECOy�nyy� n c Q ■nom1cs MARCH 2-4.2011 Invitation ■■CREATING S Invitation C EcCc.'3 n's _ c .;E t_r3. . Dow Jones Reprints:This copy Is for your personal,non-come-motel use only.To order presentation-ready copes for distribution to your colleagues,Clients or customers,use the Order Reprints tool at the bottom of any amide or visit ecew dreprirds.cca, See samplesseAIL print inPDFfoorrett.minimum. Order arepnet el maamide new t� 1(11RIm� TECHNOLOGY I FEBRUARY 4.2011 Billboards Join Wired Age Wi-Fi Lets Once-Static Posters Interact With Smartphones and Their Owners By SPENCER E.ANTE Billboards and posters are one of world's oldest forms of advertising.Now,some marketers and start-ups say wireless technology could revamp outdoor advertising by bringing interactivity and pay-for-performance models. - - x • Over the last few months,Google Inc.,Nokia Corp.and France WW1 ii Telecom SA's Orange have run pilot advertising campaigns that let a t't- tartd [ \ person interact with posters in bus stops,phone booths,train stations , rw ' % t and airports in cites including New York and London. © y = tiw .,%•. I'1;r: `!. -3 So far,companies are using the posters as a way to distribute wireless —' '` .� applications or ringtones for Smartphones.But outdoor advertisers 477, and marketers say the ads could also be used to distribute games, video ads,coupons and even as a way to sell physical or digital goods Antobee and services. An interactive ad for Nokia in a London phone booth urges passers-by to download an app on the spot. "You have to wait here.You don't have to be bored,"read the poster for a Google campaign,which ran in Boston-area bus stops.The poster let a person download Google's mobile app through a free Wi-Fi router installed in the location. "It's an old-school media that has been around for hundreds of years but we've dressed it up and made it fresh,"said Zohar Levkovitz,chief executive and co-founder of Amobee,Inc.,a start-up based in Redwood City,Calif.,that has developed the technology and begun selling it to advertisers. The billboard also gives users free Internet access at the bus stop.People can download the advertised app through their cellular connection as well,but Amobee says using the Wi-Fi connection allows people to avoid any data charges. Interactive outdoor advertising is still unproven on a large scale and the business model is in an early stage of development,but Amobee says it is in discussions with other large multinational companies to roll out new campaigns. EXPERIENCE WSJ PROFESSIONAL • Starting March 1,European wireless operator Orange will spend several hundred thousand dollars to run an advertising campaign Editors'Deep Dive:New Tech,Analytics Yield across 30o sites in London and New York City for its ON wireless O Targeted Ads application that runs on Google's Android wireless operating system. NEDwPosT.cotn A consumer waiting at a bus stop can hold his or her smartphone near How Media Multitasking Fuels'Brand Response'Advertising the poster and download the app over Wi-Fi technology or by sending ADVERTISING AGE a text message to the company. Marketers Suit Up With Twitter and Facebook for Billboards Go Interactive With Help of WiFi-WSJ.com#printMode Page 2 of 2 The interactive ads have allowed the company"to more accurately measure the effectiveness of our marketing spend"and made the "campaign experience more personal and engaging for our customers,"said Jean Donadieu de Lavit,chief marketing officer of an 'Social Bowl' Orange subsidiary that develops wireless hardware and software. STRATEGY New Analytics Tools Help Businesses Nigel Emery,director of marketing and business development for Understand Foursquare Cemusa North America,a large outdoor advertising company that has • worked with Amobee to place ads in New York City bus stops,said Access thousands of business sources not available on the free web.Learn More traditionally outdoor ads are sold for a lump sum covering a certain time frame.In New York City,Mr.Emery said the company charges $5,000 to$8,000 per bus shelter for a month. The interactive ads,however,are built around a performance-based model.Advertisers pay only when a customer interacts with the ad,much like Internet search advertising works.The cost per download can range from$1 to$3 depending on the client,the budget,the offer and the location of the posters,said Harry Dewhirst,an advertising executive at Amobee.The ads run until a set number of downloads are reached. Cemusa has yet to fully embrace the model,however.Instead it sold the outdoor ad spaces to Amobee,which is reselling them in a performance-based model to advertisers.But Mr.Emery said the idea holds a lot of promise."If advertisers have positive results they will do more of it,"said Mr.Emery."I love the idea and think it will attract more money into the outdoor medium." Over the last few months,Nokia said it got a good return on its$1 million interactive poster campaign that ran in the U.S.,U.K.,South Africa and Australia promoting the app for its Ovi app store. "Get apps and much more for your Nokia,turn on your Bluetooth now,"read the poster,which displayed a Nokia smartphone and icons of apps for Facebook,Foursquare,Angry Birds and other programs. A consumer could download the app through Bluetooth technology or by sending a text message.During the 10 weeks that the campaign ran,Craig Hepburn,global director of digital for Nokia,said 1.5 million people interacted with the poster and tens of millions of people saw it. Mr.Hepburn said the campaign helped drive registrations for the Nokia Ovi app store and was relatively cheap compared with the cost of display and search ads on the Internet.And in an age when advertisers are facing tight ad budgets,the campaign was welcomed because it helped him show that Nokia was getting results for its money. "We've been really impressed with the kind of performance and the engagement,"said Mr.Hepburn.As a result,he is already mulling new campaigns and plans to move more of his ad budget into this area. Copyright 2011 Dow Jones&Company,Inc.All Rights Reserved This copy is for your personal,non-commercial use only.Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law.For non-personal use or to order multiple copies,please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com • . ._— ---- ..1flflflfl ncnc.ccc ti.._.io__ fin1nn11 R3V/ R 2 W RIW R 1 E R 2 E R3E 0 / Legend Salt Lake County P.N.i Jordan River - ` ,`.14, �� i Freeways �s '..^ / 4100 NORTH\ -t• L_f� Townships / ��C c.=. 7 /Ai. ` 1 3100 NORTH � 11 i r —__ _r .._._ \ "4 2700 NORTH / � � ` r� 1 I rao NORTH t �: i• 1300 NORTH I j Emigration Salt Lake City I Canyon :, 1 700 NORTH -� / Y / / BASE \\ -. _ ,( -�: ` LINE 7 / /,/- 700 SOUTH i -__.,_.` j 13O0 SOUTH v- , ~ \ I `12100 S0U7H 1 Magna West J h — /"'�:'•_/ 2700 SOUTH ' \ �, Valley h Salt ' "-` ') 3500 SOUTH City • e City tl "L 1 L Millcreek ' ' 4100 SOUTH 0I ii — 1 - 4700 SOUTH i I t'----- -Talo tL Holladay - `..i�_.�..��- -C l F{-!!Kearns YCi % Murray�\ City : -y i ,` \ saoo SOUTH ff 1 r1 l 6200 SOUTH Cottonwood Midvale 7000 SOUTH _ I �1,LT,, Heights Jordan �+ ';City-\ law SOUTH City ._j"''4iei �j �^'r�'r� / 9600 SOUTH Copperton — 'Sandy .5J Alta 9400 SOUTH fil CItyS �i, cirk' TOvm/ti, �-.- ._ 10200 SOUTH South Jordan City °f� �� `� r i.Whit. I ' �r'+�- 1100o SOUTH j' -_ ------ ) .fl I_I-'—' 11 a00 SOUTH J ( , ` J? IL Riverton City .r v 12600 SOUTH f !(,'] �_� Draper 13400 SOUTH i. -- �'� Bluffdale L_ ��•J 14200 SOUTH t` City �; N \ Herriman City 15000 SOUTH ~ \'1 ^`� I. ` n 15800 SOUTH t-1-.------11 I. / .-\, 'l , • 1aao0 SOUTH N r t L.,.. 17400 SOUTH ` 1 1 O LE 18200 SOUTH W _ _ sc. 1 S . L m S e n 3 h a $ S 1 S n S n I n I S a . .. 6 I n m I /I•n,d/M•TA nrrwerr REID J.DF,MaL N P.L.S. May 2010 CO / •,' 4. R1► s....L../ 4_ — / I 44 1 Salt Lake City i i�ilel_ ro.nanb lit eI, MI 101111.1mir 'moms' -----.111111111k11111 _ r111■1 ,�south salt '� 'z' West Valley,�.■i■� La Cit �1 _ _ I • IIIIII ;1-1:117,7,1111:57y 0416 O .'... , \ "'n'h'a I�T.aylorsvffle ; day Imili Cityi t[ Is 111 III idvafe ei Cottonwoo it 44 `� it City' 1 , s West Jordan City _..... II - /n ■■■■ �ardyCity _ P A. rower. Him rim 1 Town South Jo•an City .y •v,� ik 2:7- . Riverton II _. ced'.aey D H<pona ' � [ �1'i cit City -lbpr Fna4 TOWNSHIPS COLNCIIS El-rrinun Bluffdale ��1'P""°" Qnw�nem.00a�, City I Oilyl] D ...c lc. ®craw. „ / o-- �-Sadf 140. CO) / Q HLh.«l cep,„, f CgwPw U7.�7nu, ��: oWeo.al ®awn c; F` .'2 t ,.„. Cog.NM Wants n . SALT LAKE COUNTY d"t 4 Townships and Community Councils �r ,.. , 1 e i [ SALT LAKE CITY t tb211.: rW"f-l /1 ..\:'\. 20 OFFICIAL BILLBOARD 1I__ F 1.14 - .. AND GATEWAY MAP 111IIII-.I10,—■'' `,41 -` Aiiiiiiinluuminimum eft„ . ; y I�..i.,lltli c, I�_= 1 i 11'iii l�`i�te, i�'3_ _stliPlii. `= III IIl V, ��'� �t '4,�� 1 'Ill 1�� V tom-_ �_�,, iii111_ mammon e I • ., 2,..11 i .. r_Nol2oo■ !!! + B®m811 Y:EG 1: I 11\L�, N�•ms.e�em®� �7 -- ____7 ��'- :„!Ill4II®�.L�:�uNtlll '+i� � ae�8 'MINI /. � N1ER5 AlEE,, • ill. �_..._ I�I�Y_ T r�.CQ p li•! �� L Nrie'I III1,141. ' �;�'' uv !irippOO■a O�OC3000.44l O I - , ' �. _,� rn�- Bm/d©■0■ .,■!! ©©©®❑❑81. f: _ � �� _ �w�- ill 1❑❑❑r; 1�li^❑©®❑❑m®®®®®❑IP �_ f��119111��Cuw_ :!_ ❑ 1 Ed.11 11�©©®®8:11®G' a ` l.i' `14:7. QIim�4 iiIIIIiih,LL�■ i MILT t. f�i]E1! �1ClP©❑©® sa q �. i iTJA \ IMO J � `�IIIIII taw■MET■■171M-.T�1■I■❑®e© M s ;iiiiiijui;i� °' J 1� ♦ IIIIX� iJawEIl1•Clw■■Ic�C71113111 ■®©®r®®® . rMil i � �p��y, 1 7III`�!]�E�1�]®�I 'A!�I 1m❑®®®m®B�m � )111 H_ 1 ��1 �- ~ 1. 'n�1111111■ Idle 111 aro" Illy 7. ". :4 1 ■■1.1MNl�t is il �.1�1 ��i I i . .L� E __ 31; Ili i`'�w.. l G� / 1 - I��r s .� '� urni A.,,I - , �,,MI=t r: Illlllll"IIIIIIU Y • L. • ` t( `- rl _ .J, , 11,. `,;r �y.,�{ � ! � �� ur r �! n;;lll�__ �.��'�_ _�■� 11��1 • �� f 1 t�� ; II��j1 Ip _ 11 •I'i �� IIIIIII IIIr1 ��+n rl� 1_1 cu.,rORNURVE ULIFORH0IR ' _ %It 1 �� 11�" t - _�i ,- 4 1-� i ,1i o. # 1,1 a .R �i IIIt?1i1�L, ��.�.� \ �1111 t 'N I 1I '■ I.I IIII 1%111i ■=.-,IIl!r 1 1�� J ' `� I �I�a�it.'-. � —r II 11111114=� In 1� n "�'' 14ia 3 , 11111 !.e B I i ,Ail I --i-I,�I0171 u Y _ !I _ 0.vF _ a S _ u�� \'�tlfFIM i1itifU ■� IFHI jolii .` P100Y 'II �V 1 v Legend �� 1'Innn i1 t ;;1■;.;tip ."---'—'"!'IA'-' lERS AlE EO N 'IIi1ir 3't I Fait. .■� . — Gateway 10.1111. , _Iilr(IIII.I_IIIIIIy - _� 0sir �_�_— (J -- Special GatewayW—t9� E tm -A�a �, June 2001 Billboards Permitted S 2200 SOUTH MAP LEGEND .=,Historic Preservation . :. .- ...- , . ,IIIIII CN,Neighborhood Commercial ,: _: MI ,CS,Community Shopping , III FP,Foothills Protection I FR-2,FR-2/21,780 Foothills Residential I I FR-3,FR-3/12,000 Foothills Residential '.. , -,. • OS It i 1,Institutional / ,. ,i,;.,:-,,11,-.;f-;-' S.... .• :,.-.1 OS,Open Space I I MI /'PL,Public Lands . -)R-1-12000,Single Family Residential ,,,'R-1-5000,Single Family Residential ,(/,'` . r 1 R-1-7000,Single Family Residential '-.,::::Y-::::CT, IIIIII R-MU,Residential/Mixed Use ,1 ,-' ... -r• : ME RMF-35,Moderate Density Multifamily Residential ,., I . . , [04 1 =RMF-45,Moderate/High Density Multifamily Residential .3 '. •••• ---,A =RMF-75,High Density Multifamily Residential / ) IOU I deigil WARN le.. ja., 4 .PA•..f.' 41"2'5.111 1111 51 If**** a' At • 114:64::4 isitacaltam„. . .....:"411*A4.14:47'' v.44.:-:-'' 11111111114_ 411001, 1111112 INMIIIIININIptititivallaitilltilts 1,0. V,.7;1 RO,Residential/Office 67000114111s4 illursii::: 11,MEM 4811111• -z., - al 11.:•Bsimmure'l,g4.111.91- 11111,4v1"4 NE SR-1,Special Development Pattem Residential 1 vs Igh m Ul,Urban Institutional 7/''.. \ \ ' &VA1111111,WV yourf.'1.41mININFA.,,t U1 al -c, ..\_= t Iiiii. ill'404., 7,4iTtie.,/eassimeeii-206, al ,.... , ' LI .,,.„...,,_ _-,),... 17.4•.fftlioirnatio,Lity—.A...•••%1Iti , ,,,,,,,NA '----,-._ -, a4p..,4" #. . !MIMI """011M."."'. ,,,,,,, . — 51.P.„,,I -MN .- wit,y,ta,41/44 „,,,,,,„,„ 11,,,,..--te g. winwiii ri _ma w. 466ivenues „, , „,,______,„ ,„. ...,. ...,_ ,............ „,„,. i ,,,,,,, , ..,c,b Mtn JIM -1,11 1111 mins um .4 -lid Y "4**I/ i =;i+4.1,,,,),.= --, - es= ... ---i-- — ..__ _ '7-4,14.:Flq,,_ .4. e'-'11q-,- *4 *.lialli;-- __ ';,-....._, .,_,/, „,-- mil ii. "TNT TT' HETI E___ —. _....... .., , : ..• ,:k--..., - . ,,, . ,,..,.... c Ern lulu Hum buili ii_i_L j j ji nin Hiss , , 4 , ,,,. .„.. . „ 8,,141:4P. km......_•ammi—vesi.jrilip.....4%r4 _ ... . . _ . Zoning81111 IlliE Mil tit i I err -Ft illii Si . , , Y „„ / e= Lum MIMI pH! 'um gm gips I mu inn ITT i 'Fill! II - C--; 4(4., . '.. Nokr,„,,As, wrA, a. . , , Iliil MIL Elul rail FM ill illir Mill Rik] hi ii TrtF1 SI M ,„T. wasommion_iworits=x211I mr _N. ill LI. 1, , -gti ppapT &Tg. KIN RE WILI ELI. ILLI N.R7 mill : ____,--_ oidommraiviibramikw. I =Nii l ..,- , gau: mil MUM MUT ME MN K.11-1 tmlie i '41. 11111/d/11)1114:11 .......A0A-,7- Map ii. iu.----, ,, EOM MN WE SHE- =Intl OM aim gq MIPE n 1 L'Ili- MN 01111f illifi frail Mkiii IIP wiii .0.1T B eat e---------- -,.... . , ---- - - Eli F -1 Erg E_.-1.3 Lii slim mil.= ii,11- aLE H.L.411 MO At fill os . .__ _ ._ ilid mai :lie iTIT nig/ iiin int. --F, nun os -• .,. - - All _°. 1.• ilffl Eft IELE IIIM -mQ - , _ Wilii,El wIlat - r m EMI iml amm .7[G . ---'1 m1111 NM - CEMETERY /brim Lib'- allE =—3 MR 1M illla TIE 1.c.W NIN MC=. rill Ella mil - filliiirPi, 414-i siis ill/441 ri--: him in:: rin Him = FEN In iill His iiii aul! mim Jim, -tote: . 0•sogino.,.. R- , /..._ rlp az = .-__--,- 'ail =Li: a am -LIM --ga It a aum mil 12 • - ik,,, 0 St •• llt itg I 1101M11111 41' IS '0 .. . .RI Ali h ini 1 Iff Till-r oda I= olIM NIP Illi Ella -1J-frri iiiiii Elm _ ., 1M111 romini..1 c;AT,.,0,.,!,. A.• I.is. *AO* Or -‘, or am os = l; 11111g mi" -2-Z;71 -.` r-- ini.„La ga,2 Elien..7--- :7, -=, '---t1 BAP ..'. ME To.2 IIIIIIIk: akor_ie4 At,I. ,- 1i Itik,,141: LT= ME inhi 7.401. Inii II r It TTI-V ion on ail gal I. if Fr , Ritii: (Er mil iiiiii 1111, ffiliil Ma .2111.2 Inol.Irtiot os 1111 Ai Ram MI -1-i_.1 PAH WIIII QV Mr2; tug' attlA 0 EREJJ 211111 111 1, 43 allo Ea' mini'1-11,1`v4751114:%v `%. i I i': ow 1.11fi sol -..iv oil ma Iii Oki ma lila RFE olio Erni ii a HDIfi -iri ma illhili Ellri Ell aumrd 111" 0 : 1 I I I or 111118" IMIII. '' Inv Salt Lake City Planning Division ,Iit Geographic Information System V.:a, ___J iii-44 il- -Lilt- 1111 1.112 L 441 gum 4 EMI IM= A 11117.: ilia: KM Ell, 011:11 Eli ..1,„*"-` , NOT TO SCALE April 2003 IA M11111111111 Ili ,. Ina :,_..i. miii I loil 1 Mil mf_s kill Lich all MIIJ Eli 11 02 MI mi. NA" E ,,„ .... Capitol Hill Community Zoning Map / /,• 4 /�� Il,o fir,+ cm \ m \ M1 . a° l , , Ii QI \ a11 ....Jos , . k # ci .. , . . 4 ., I �%, ' \\ MIMI El '.4e' / 4.,,..111-1 �\ 1 J ja-0011641 ,, - .1� AID j 1 ipV. . ,r_ Imo- it ___j5- tp v 6.,4,4:1 V IMO / \ '�\\\, .'.,.. -'''' •. • • • rA. «tea m. 4._ ! 1 l dGr ir0.4 �\ i \ vas ��l'a2i ��,��g�„.4el .-.) E °0 , 4. \\ •n Area \ \ �I kt IL• E.BP.Business Park `, IIII M� ��1�{ \ F Ii. r .II1e,cmamyeaameaa �� \ 11.n 1 n11 lil6 II� Y�' IIIIII�CC.Commercial Corridor Al•• 1 . r.: I1OI'1IIL ,''*' Rif \ '' .,,' , ! Ruuw 1111. .4 n gim a�,� s mil LG,General Commercial ,\ e: 11111 CS,Community Shopping 11, ,a II D 1 Central Business District �_ 1.1 El,Extractive Industry �� 1'IIIIIIM -1 i ,W \a 'I-FP,Foothills Protection \ l1 it II I'"_ ill laIE idi I „`r® m II: =FR-a.FR-221.500 FoothillslBal Residential I,II■ 11 •II: I !IN 01 ii' \ Fft-2.FR-22110g Foothills Residential g 910I['� 1117,'�lll .. 1 I -yyJ FR-3,FR.3112 000 Foothals Resident., �IIIIIII7_ EMI, ,. a �$ P�.FSEF I.Institutional -•IIII_ IIIIIIIIIII%' " 61 L M-1,Light Manufacturing n sue_ •� Ar = 1111 .4.4,i (2° M2.Heavy Manufacturing ^I 71 ®MU.Mixed Use e 1}�• - \ .- r; ��GS,Gpee Space �a ' I�: 1111 \ I.PL,Public Lands I l I R-2.Single Single Family Residential I � 1:-' ' ill II . ' lR-2.Sirgle and Two-Family Residential .L1� R-MU,ResidentiaVMlxed Use / ........... n.v ' tfAig RMF-35,Moderate Density Multifamily Residential !1/ ■�I MIRMF-45,Moderate/High Density Multifamily Residential 1)-] =� -I• Salt Lakc City Planning Division �� Geographic Information$yslcma _RMF-75,High Density Multifamily Residential _ SR-1.Special Development Pattern Residential I. l SR-3,Spec; elopment Pattern Residential -UI.Urban Cenal 0 3 Central Communityg a ZoningMapIII OHM ' killigin gni I.E I ,1ILE9F4U � I �Gir� a ,lillritt /r 1...��®.r: `�Q1 I- III II�'2 ` y Walla i y �111 C ,�1 '� • 111 1� 1,ale MIII I rl el _ 1, I _I - ..I,tJY AIBI�l a 15i:'1j� Es. 'Nov 11.41.pcj I ' _ - i ,,IL :tog111�17�r1r-- 1-1'It I'7.11' I cll II•I�'- ®In ■ • �ilr- �t..a1= _ \ r _ us`. t=1, tin JI1Dkt= �llrl. 1.111014rA . AIM t u� r ��[-vg��@ i r � III If 111F, ' .__ g..1..i I.n"1" ��I� 1 c .ems 1W � �,JII�1 r "i.-j ]R Irnr.a e1' -- IIP�1 Map Legend Al . r 1 li- YI -T- = VI ®. ?�.- o.ri •� fam • - s1 E.grir.,- ti n1 �. 1 I11_ II1� '�1 DUI ■_rl�� ,Iti? 3 �l i� Igl;ly =1 TI Historic Preservation Overlay Distract 1,Institutional r _ nrI. Transitional Overlay District ro OS,Open Space .,,e; I trm, _ ull II n South State Street Corridor Overlay District-PL,Public Lands `„ '1 I,q 1[ Apr ■3Al14e,-L P, yrmM. 1 „; E�'[ ��{{{ggg :m n F.D.Field Sign Overlay District PL-2,Public Lands ma li!"_dhIl I. l Illl I 1'= Maw LJ '; j...- ' alga till. -I T :, li _.:� LLB JJJ ��11 n Delta Center Sign Overlay District I I R-1-5000,Single Family Residential \ L u a Ink; -I;r.11 tl' I` ,telly I�1 h YI II S�f�t -BP,Business Park I I R-2,Single and Two-Family Residential r it/_ I,;2 y ig =L _idl,L--1 i r�JR. �d., �n € 7PLT.;) CIIIh '1'I.0 ..Ilt uuuuuu" -RAT.; 0:CB,Community Business I -=1 R-MU,Residential/Mixed Use r -'_� j%�; I (� �- i E1�' W :_�I y CC,Commercial Corridor 7kii Hi 1[`a - ((``,, -x I RB,Residential/Business ,_ r1_ � , '. 1F� l4 � ns Mal } ?„�,�y 'ES f -CG,General Commercial -RMF-30,Low Density Multifamily Residential '� a —� "�w9M1 r. r e �r�G`, -CN,Neighborhood Commercial RMF-35,Moderate DensityMultifamilyResidential , - r'+� ®'-'-' -t_ ,� .� L® y l!t""a -CS,Community Shopping I'RMF-45,Moderate/High DensityMultifamilyResidential - � , M.Mffl_ & - `�; �'9 1 3 r--� Pne c € { l�' 1 D-1,Central Business District -RMF-75,High Density Multifamily Residential \ ® w i1 AM nr:AT-. r[tl e- .F I m s tl"- 4.. D-2,Downtown Support District IMEN E�� i= u9f ¢ 7nni.,.� PP I IRO,Residential/Office '_ rI �- f 1.`�GJ C t -v lIIF^!91fIX I xlcz®D-3,Downtown Warehouse/Residential SR-1,Special Development Pattern Residential 1 IF I— r �t t g t[y�i1' -D-4,Secondary Central Business District _sc} SR-3,Special Development Pattern Residential L°9 - ''!'!!9iiii !!t IltlS al u e fit.r ull+iit Zl • II �1:. -.1,.Y.Nlielliin -GMU,Gateway Mixed Use -UI,Urban Institutional II ' =, _ �®® 1 try i " " ` T Enlimill 11q�,rrI li 1.;t1 EN it .I t,&,R. n RI_ I -u n t5 �' I - u L 11 IIt,� tlwnta 051,1 iii ® �l�n {+u� i P, I II 11® rmn. =cumin ,Ilnta Ai ® ti ;,t1 M - —ins®®e[r ail O ILI ■S u NEE Salt Lake City Planning Divisionf / �^ , . - 11111 ME ®®®� Geographic Information Systems _III" III III HIE Ry m IIII TI IIIIIIII� { II II II 1 l r RIIII!!DPP L I 1 I Le 1as: I L_ "p/II,_1_ 111 _ ( — 1 /� �111QA111 :IIIIIIIII� ( II i.lTT'' ��fII111I1_ ■■ aryl a1111U� m IIIIII I 1_- 111 I :Inn m u Irsnalln 1_=J �IW+1 �11l�I _non m_, Blhhllh6l- =1181!. �!I!JIIIIITi IIIIIIIIIIIII� ' ►t��Rlb ✓ 111°Illlll 11=1 n�yiiniini is nIIIIIIIIIII,` I- i l l I If 1111111111111111 M . - utintna= ® �/I r �!,, nnunnn -IIIIIIIIIII f 1 I'I I I _.ri, ,111,�f■=■__I ■;33C . I. EE7E115 u1111111111t / W 'Mfl�W tYF9�N�� " ��muffle:*-�=1a+_.111�' - =nlEnnnll= nnun■nnnnl nnnnne=111111111a-- - win nnnml 1 Sugar House e .1n F r-t11. ime E„• 1' =nnnnns=_nnmum illt�¢EEu111 C1111111'11y•11111111111 ..-1.3¢1111 ` IF:¢¢IIIII �d-I=IlIf10ft1 i- I� IIII l.1+u+ L-1.E 98dII RnTF-30 =1111111111E IIIIII ff''11II11 r i �111111P 4 1111111111 E.*9,5 1 v.!lll li11ir:Ilai 111E alai■ =� '° �III11111� F I�In[r- _ -�� IIi II II II �I NM III 1111111111 = Orr- l- _ 1111I 5 II — I�r111111l, -��p 1 t,� me on ■ 11 um IIti1S-111 1 Its= B I 1 11111111 I•I:.•"UJU■- • • = 1■Il,t...1>t _+_ .1+ � - --• II 1 1L::'a"Him_IIII 11:. �'I I11{III II 1 111 1 -.13,@2,111 Community ommun�t J Zoning �'u mlr.m1II1N 111 JII. II IIII - nnc.n ==�f+win iilil�ai; n I I I OPINE°iiiiiiiiiiii I nl 1 n u I Is minima n1e a l«J// _ � _. 448 Illtiti E gnu emu nu Him •1••= 1 nuurul�L�� ---}{ L rljNnum111=nnmmn(I 1 III ID ----..s s( �. .=a_-'-__ = II E7TI"S�IIII`.�LllllLLLLI _IIIII 3W II I''11*,111: 11 4 I�1 Map /� -�i .:Fr __,, a 1.IN111111111R -I9a `� ' 1■IISS"''''''num ,=1'1 8111 l J ! t �II-. G I Cwtn 1 nnnnue }{} _=1n1-anon n1 IIII IIIIII. ,c,,, Iia a■ °rim:,gill HMI 111.1 :111:1171 ill �9111'1i111111un i!!11111�1'■ l .'� Ir! � �0 7 .11 7i I nla , '�a 1 1 ® - /11 Ill I L-1p1 ME -1�� I f== kho,II �a CB I. i; mil,n__,��1, * SUGARHOUSE /� =-5 -�� -era I�• f• �, __a JE= IIRI !i $ �u atlll ��1� ~1♦� PARK _ -.t1' ..=_-_,- =._ _--: , , li t n,.� 1 - Tn FIIIII II tll �_ \ s� —.: __ _ _Ali milli r.l:¢E. 1 I ■6 .F stint•._ I 1 �■ 11= C.= 1� - S'. E �IIIQIIIIt , �t �s / ��gad film IAWN1.11(16 OS f IWI1 NMr41■l�— N..ar I�l�,..I. , s a xisE.In.....una1 i .. - _ _ _ _ :::5 ni• ! _ 11111111111111 1 Mr_ :_ . —a1... 1aI:I7171(1 IIIII\+� OS .l - fEL.:E9S]OII17.� =IIIII, ! C.- PARK FAIRMO ® 3� i0♦O c y:!& 11 mo � Cas'� _ \ . q 1�� p�771 �� imil'olli 111IE1 IQ Z 1 E.� IIIII MN �_ • • _ h 1 ®� a � �,� _uunnni_ os ■im l'zi1!nulmm W ►Is ere I. 4Will" C I.n11 411 a ig-!_d1111111111111� ==q11 _III!IIIII= FOREST DALE 11==IIIIII �p `b ♦11 ��a �t Aff - ►I llll�l Sj: GOLF COURSE !!!�IIIII: - :� . .. •� ��Q'l� �� OS ��L��I H 111 r� �� =i�� -_ T p 1 Ie��Q IT mono aim �/plitII 111� E � '��i� pl Imo; �4I!111 in=pl1111= OS _ - x= E _'Iu1 ��_� `', COUNTRY CLUB _ `I� � I�♦ -126 : _: Nil nI = v. s ._u IC 711 r uu nti ila Hi ilil iW Ho r� rp�,4`.,a 11t k4•14 _ PEW _. a _ - 2 GOLF COURSE �I L n _ nr% _I1imu =J111 1lli m: �„4\ ;::`�I/111��I rt\ III emu, . . ... !!111 _unn: -- :: „�plp,-��`��\ --- IN --_r —i _■■ur♦pwq_e1Ela _ r Mir — g II _uE1l111111 ndmn!!Im\ � 1 .__ - . -___wrs re;u aw:6►'=__' =_r.=is ©!1 11' _ E. 1 nuirmri 9iYlrim;l* -- / J a 7'0 : :y=- _n I ��S=1111t - __ =$ _mac i11 ■r ��r�f�a. Q rim ' =1fiF,EL jt -5fi1■11.1E ;Ph."Mull 1111 LE El I•i Mit=MO .� _■: =u T , g�Ell� IIIIII :�u�.i i1111111►. -_ �� NIBLEY - - _==�li-°T'�': t� '1�i -t- re.....=,...„,i 11;. I,___-y�-.L. .L--1 -r1�1 u: HII;.-4 ' 11�:IIIIII I-I�III`311HI11,11, llILllLUlll _ SE' `f' ti -�GAOLF OS 1t`1113 =�i,1ino_;4 ,L•`•_' ZE_ Eirz .a ( +'F.ad i. V4 l'I 3 - 'a �11 IIIII-_ 5C i�11111 ■ } �1 r T MI 1�1 ., COURSE C1o..,.■. . .It9ImI!mammy ,t - — =.s"lll� :;IIIIiiOIii"a�i1 _" 1=es!11111n1nI t T 111''!:IIIIIIIII911®® "_ ' 1:1111I111!111 (i) — a, _— � , I il111!!�1uu11 Pam` ---_ __ —" I 1=11►/F`,; o■■ mullion! lllla c =ES = E' L Li E11►� -� e 1111111J EMI- Pa wiTT IN amnia t -r•°• IPiltl 1 -Ill McMinn�/j `��F�[II Ill. 'a111111i]c'�!9111 i/'�'i'i '�'��'i i11111►1■ 1's1.1.1111= III I ,1 I■i um mu 111 /N_a e141111u wrl 1:11111111_=I1;0.111IIIII�=uum a=rums Fin iti.7. : _ Wm.. .1111 E ma..o au ®maim 1°31�""" 13 Map Legend M1111J11111 sai r 3 saw I C-SHBD,Sugar House Business G, :1 OS,Open Space Q �u a `.�� 11311 CB,Community Business -PL,Public Lands RMF-30,Low Density Multifamily Residential fl, J a� i CC,Commercial Corridor I R-1-12000,Single Family Residential -RMF-35,Moderate Density Multifamily Residential Ai CN,Neighborhood Commercial I j R-1-5000,Single Family Residential -RMF-45,Moderate/High Density Multifamily Residential -CS,Community Shopping I R-1-7000,Single Family Residential [ I RO,Residential/Office Salt Lake City Planning Division a 1=� !I1 ]I,Institutional I I RB,Residential/Business I I SR-1,Special Development Pattern Residential Geographic Information Systems West Salt Lake Zoning Map Map Legend r-1 Transitional Overlay District BP,Business Park i �� u 1 ®CB,Community Business .II 1 _CC,Commercial Corridor /� -j irw i_ ® rIkraik III ) � �- Il �.-�� _, %'/�l I.Institutional �- - _ r ,_ ---•� - a M 1,LightManufacturing %- -II'----------'----- - '=-- � ��1— .10, ,;� � ._ iimu t I / -M-2,Heavy Manufacturing I,,• - OLI0 it ii I" �� •'IO�O��r li= lf"h► inunn■1 /(J ' ®ell=-� 1 �� tltllllllllllllhk I�I1t 111 _. pilll;uµll WOp _ -�P r'p"' -MH,Mobile Home Park / H Il)kl I�t�IIII175131 III _ 1 0- All ,. -, - �114114 I vin= 1 y, _1 =OS.Open Space atllll _ y�'Y � .� ,%� _.._ 1r.P. 1.....,, wpm _ PL,Public Lands up d-1 i `a�. _Zmimi; IF ' 1- I R-1-5000,Single Family Residential ", - r ��` \ Q11I11 I',r% 0 tl - 'I IT tilld ) n.- ;a 1 �R-1-7000,Single FamilyResidentialI ®- I'. �� II 'n■ -r R-2,SinE$2' EE::enhal yRdential� � � - Y13w ! çi p'� � _ „eu -- I!, - t ® ` ®RMF-30, Residential■ is Ill n 111 9pBil�iLI ( \\ -RMF-35, amily Residential a - _ --' - - r _ ( '`'r [ ��"9 if:hi, , _RMF�5,Moderate/High Density Multifamily Residential IIIr� - II :' �,m'' IWY41 = I11I■ - LI LI— _� � J ,�;�, _� r ILi fr I I i.1 y gm�;rt'�y7�^..7�.�1 �Inn/%/I um Im f n1- r �Gf,�.mi ®\ .; SR-3,Special Development Pattern Residential Ni9 If" VaiEJ ll.. iF, wmi ,--► IUI: t 1111�Ii_R, wWi -Efd 1�- nt III NILEI - ,— _ w - Ill IIII1Illt!■I ` f1011 _ Can 1I111wiN1 .i] w L rill■ [ I .I III y�p■� +[ �aa]r�J�l�r�] }�. MS101111111 .. lijili ul If 2-l__-- -f E 11I I1 .__.: - L millin 'I Ill I AM II faA mil �� I I �II. Illllli�1 '■i III fit _ „_ �� :,.,. brl In�aR , 1...4:f /4';':,t- 1 :,...31 ''.7 -1 rii'LE ritim rill \\ __ Imo• �:rnl.;'miMilt . . �I 69 . il mint ., -.rr"'' t., _ _ ��yyp�!....it sill]1 oa,,,.,. f�j�� 21r. .. _02 .n■ " —PO.4M 1 =till- I.ii 1_mil- i • ' Y s�'vee ��, 1W. L' lf mow%,vi 11llllllllll!IHi II(- ,lint �� 1{l1' r'�1,'■011 -,I _` { i I _�� y f (i) =1t .�-.tll ,':It r/I��l'Illlllll Ili II :c. �_, � . r' ,■ Is�I „t i a� ■ ■■c III 1.I rw�lll�IIIIIII-2121 �LW�- iii\\ ---imiimiffir ll A.• --1' -=- jam_ I1 1\ , . 5\ I M1 1 1- of�; ICSR-�._t""YI- 1_I,t1_ i , �.. �!\\ r ____ NI-1 ( ®®111111.11 i I i I — , k jEl II l'ill. ; iE=��=I � E.[ mmorp. __......_...... . IIuI.nhII !i i E OS o©t�el7n: 11 - -______________Fin ""- EIDE _z'-a17-3----- _i. IN l _ — - „6. �' _JIB /' _ � I(�III Sall Lake City Planning Mission ,,1 I ir i''w"'pv �/� \`,\�J�I I Geographic Information systems Billboards Permitted within C-2, C-3, M-1 , M-2 & Conditional Uses within C-i 14.1 ri Salt lake City Milicreek Township - Salt Lake County s �, T 73 vout\my --117-_-___:-...!____.-' A g IlMiallb 'F'V...:' '-',,, 3300 S 1-" - OX- I �V f ' [_"Gr , s c= _ ..i I_ yWILL IMINII 0. ,. .j__ C T. ---d 1H irdiaLriril „„ . ) c„ .... i.iii,i____}._- - South Salt Lake ' i.✓ ,� Yr��I,-,l , _ -rrii � pre --,,,--4.—:.-4— : -11.4101 i'm sb_, .-,. , \ , , I" l c W_- � � ` w ,Murray - — 'III �rgre eirOwillitap © A. Legend - 1 t7`- j _ e : ,. . . SLCO_ ®zoning2011 �__ FA-5 I�FR-20 ®R-1 3 ®R 2 10 I r 1 �A / I A-1 f I FM-10 I I FR-5 R-1-4 "R-2-10/zc \ t, i � in A-1/zc FM-10/zc-M-1;M-1/zc sigR-1-43 151 R-2-6.5 !-: •-` « — — 1'A-2 I 1 FM-20 -M-2 R-1-5 [_-1 R 2 8 ''''_(NM -`1. t 1 A-20 I I FM-20/zc 1111MD-3/zc ®R-1-5/zc Lj R-4-8.5 y�� I _J A-5 ®FR-0.5 R-1-10 ®R-1-6 I I R-M i`�.J F i C-1;C-1/zc IIIFR-1 �•'„t R-1-10/zc R-1-6/zc L,I R-M/zc �1 ' s I- C-2;C-2/zc IIFR-1/zc Ell R-1-15 /', 1J I R-1-7 RMH ,�1 C-3;C-3/zc ®FR-10 '';`! R-1-15/zc R-1-7/zc L-J S-1-G in -. C-V hr1t FR-10/zc IJ R-1-21Holladay R-1-8 ® - �-� ri FA-2.5 Q3::.1 FR-2.5 -R-1-21/zc R-1-8/zc / M ip createdtby SLC Planning Division 2011 NORTH Billboards Permitted within C-2, C-3, M-1 , M-2 & Conditional Uses within C-1 Northwest - Salt Lake Count Y Salt Lake City � =T } AIRPORT 1141 K l / � 1-80 vY>r "s r N o-1 zt',~ i C c O xt..:} y co — CALIFORNIA AVE D z 1 1 0 xi --1 70 1 SR-201 West Valley City 1 ..1 in, liri /I I: _ Legend "1� ��n I H YY 71111,14Ei1.11 SLCO_zoning2011 kg FA-5 E;FR-20 ", > R-1-3 I---1 LJ A .FM-10 r -FR-5 ail R-1-4 E-1 R-2-10/zc _uff - 1-1 . filli 71 A-1/zc ®FM-10/zc.M-1;M-1/zc R-1-43em R-2-6.5 F L , L-_J A-2 r I FM-20 -M-2 i R 1 5 I I R 2 8 :—'I�� . Uv��E- ,__i A-20 I I FM 20/zc®MD-3/zc ®R-1 5/zc( l R-4-8.5 r; Q a� ii' [—)A-5 ®FR-0.5 yij R-1-10 ®R-1 6 j 1 R-M a -111lf�[ },7� TT ttl `m r i C-1;C-1/zc NIFR-1 Ll R-1-10/zc MIR-1-6/zc,_1 R-M/zc --"' %f,lit,ri` Y i C-2;C-2/zc .FR-1/zc ( _ R-1-15 Es R-1-7 4 1 RMH Um C 3;C 3/zc S FR 10 ®R-1-15/zc ®R-1-7/zc I I S-1-G 1,- El C-V ®FR-10/zc M R-1-21 ®R-1-8 I FA-2.5 Mg FR-2.5 ®R-1-21/zc gn R-1-8/zc 4,-•34 , 1 A; „ . .,,, I Map created by SLC Planning Division 2011 NORTH • ( 0 . .... .. . East Bench • . - Community Zoning os ,07,-, Map \ .... • b ........ , i os I UNIVERSITY ,..•\ OF UTAH , S' F, ‘. litirtI OummNa ip,A,'VA:IAWp__7_w_i_n.,__u_nI tuIii;P .VHm.pri. imuurmi 7o>4.„sw,7m i.r1.:i1.i thn1.1•i 1nt2.ii.nc.:nPa...um.t.Mo.INiAlTlAI Cl II,•• • _IrIE,Aii.5 S Nos . . 1 El r.!,-;,./ 3 m = „ c! P WMP IV ,n ,; .._..c._,o. o___ I11.1 1.1.4..1.,...a. .... • 7.0,0.•,:altiilyt\> liR...,;- :IP,..04sAmitomp slum guipinph v u 0J.1 filh''.1..'g M 5',4.' . -' ,.. .. . .. ,011111111e....„.. .enuoftwituunud e ' 4, m117!EffEtillil IIIIIIIII ult!Intlima'71111H . , 7.1.41111,1,31•111111111::Hiwim gil> S. FT,FlT,,,FF.'11111111111111 — -g, .. .... .p :.-... -13 -"%yizatIgn-,,F1,!ra ,. Hail 4.,..,...0 EU imam •••'. ..r, Ili ...,....t4 if • :11 ,.--i 2 NOTED! mill1114,,4,111,04 RE@ . f•N,., OS •,,,,12-.., IIIIIPUMITIVE- IlUtuumuniu pR.Rp mum!!giullw,..i:4:1 ‘. I;1 1111 ..-0.,,,- v.i...ttttt unit,:a;:autuuti u= g ..1-is 0.0111 tttttt 11 141:1,'\ .4...:.,.L'..,...,.- ir;".6111Z;;EM•116."15 VIIIMI15. ig.:;i1ArilltirilS:r415117r;t5jUmil''''14.5:11."9751:5T!':11'5,,,,,,,,Fr419.10“e PN‘,0,77.'P.II ll '51, i..A jo N I • Mk r•MUIT:I.E.M...1.44.ti,Essidc Viri5 min:Efhias 17.4m.1.4%.'I ti';--zumir • c,,,,,....1,...p.s.:...............uss •Nror.=11110111111111111111:31111111= -_., sr.:-.4p:r,...,23-Olk ....ti,ilkii. OA ..--ftga1112 41P41:gem E 4 1J,_ro.-.it ami%F- :AI:,t Vilm"`-v2 r 1:te4..,--...:tn.f:..-Are I:11 wet • E4.......-igremi ri. , .z. „ 1E11.&,At`Tritseet,_!ILJ..:atiliwil! ,,,it 11,,,,., IN pilSr...... ,E El,j3:,:leyZ 47+1 ilk at .:I MAIM=.,1 1 4ii '''.:i0115-- 'symotr,gp,,-. • m==. ,,-.14.1.141!...,:froars...211,1111 FA:.:411:41,11//dijii= =ginuurg.agsgumgz E.9tiumun4 Etiruz.u,MUM=11515551.19 111/43,551115ir reltp;oViter.:!!".., NAME EllIP.:421P IG,;;;; '.7,71.4 . '1 ill Fi ri.........11....,''ri::4,11.4!•4 ,;'1;11,1"-ZiDT,s,fat,pm 572155511511a..4111VMU.S! -IIIIIIJIIII:2=Dittaurs1 I 'tri:,• ST•1111111/1111111111.1: ha nzimmi-=5.55.53 ,,.gpi, moo IT:It.,..t.-111 •ITS 17t.,1 .„tp:4,1:4,,,Is'ft zu-:NIA' 1-'-""— -,.....-mow., i.e.0511110Rn •.. ... ' El-,• A II I 1 1 -.DIM r ,, Il.11,-4'ATP r'„akt.r,,,,e,vor,c,-,,,,,MI '3 ilimm...En mu,,winin= .03,„,,,"', - .1.111,11M,'t=11.111110.11,i•4 Vt•41.-4'411)174.liV•C3 • - 7-911Pligig?-11,yri RWW alai. .... ',.°01, all -.e --, --':.'":.'"'""'•-k" - .t ,,letw57.;:".1....ttto"".0 "''''"u'll 444%11 0110111a p.-1110101110" II"!RIM-1....05'aldLiF101 7lig"Pl:,t r MAUI II?r .7:111111110.MD1064111014.-Siiilltilit---4' I. 111 RI I 4I-1_1-u 179M ErrET ME- --,lilitam1111111111 Lll1111U.""'"CF"."'Pullu°ANinit., Mk I ,-, L litArai At Zar gg--11""eirAx 11% / ' I Map Legend 1 1-:..• r--77 M 32 i--.ite 6:4.'1--:',4"''' / ! Zoning Districts .— 1 mit1.1111 Els - 4E: '''',4154.4--•:-kl,....-1455 gr.y.',.5=5,11..mir -L...,15W OS 1/ .•FP 1 '7 1.4 7.5:.e, MN 1 L.7,,j CS,Community Business ITI CN,Neighborhood Commercial gi rg??-4 — 1111 CS,Community Shopping 7"-•Fri`‘'r*a'''':-t.-,,-E 4,1, .w.gg Elie.042 ygg., .... ": '-,•;-,.: vr110 .•- \‘\ V isi E.,.7 Wig ilftgoi.:11U :.;,k,... nrt.,..7.71F,..4 •,A:,, I IIII FP,Foothills Protection -f t MIFR-1,FR-1/43,580 Foothills Estates Residential *1 :::: .11:::41..,ft.t:+e•054,,i --- -PA.-4.ei4Vtlf6Ati.Vt MEFR-2.FR-2/21,780 FoothilM Residential •• F., t -,,• , ,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,, ,,,, FR-S.FR-3/12,000 Foothills Residential „ ,, ,, 0 il r—iri I,Institutional NIIILlis,,;4‘ Wili 74 els II i 7,:.I OS,Open Space . 414111iiit.'ilivl..Ai* 11111 PL,Public Lands Is 1 a 1 1 R-1-12000,Single Family Residential R-1-5000,Single Family Residential 4.4,• 1 1 R-1-7000,Single Family Residential ,... •'Ids• -• ",-...,..,4 • RMF-30.Low Density Multifamily Residential ranRMF-35.Moderate Density Multifamily Residential 11111 RMF-45,Moderatea-ligh Density Multifamily Residential .• RO,ResidentiaBOffice Sell Lake City Planning Division NMOcagro,hic Information Systems RP,Research Park IngSR-1,Special Development Pattern Residential I. 0 0 it oS Northwest os . � ,i9 fF �..,_ Quadrant r Community x 1 , .i. ,_:, F i os Zoning Map • �� i / ____cv ,,, . _ . 1 Q.../)� - t L ‘ i ..j . . , e ,,,z:z M1 h—� 1 M-1 I • �:. �1 1 Y �� i I g,'. �— — 11 / :7 -.--__4:;.•com.-- • IN_ _. .. , . i _ _ .1 ,,, . ,, ', A ff_ . , __ _ „, _ ____ L ,.._... Ei1E:.- _-3--r---f T - ! i1 .; os7::_ 11-1i � ,,iir `„ `..,...., 1 _I- I N II11 i @ �.nl�1 � I � _IL Jy:. (i Map Legend Lowland Conservancy Overlay District Transitional Overlay District Landfill Overlay District IIE AG.Agriculture (i) - CG,General Commercial M-1,Light Manufacturing Salt Lake City Planning Division OS, Open Space Geographic Information Systems I • T, Northwest Community - e1 Zoning• „, Map 4' Map Legend)I -IT V-_ .. r=_ I AG-2,Agriculture-2 Acre Minimum IIIII _7 ` f/ Li r ®AG 5,Agriculture-5 Acre Minimum - - -- -®® + t�1 b 1 1 Airport iY L.-_�__�_ -BP,Business Park I 'L y) cm CB,Community Business d _ ,,,.]ft E71 I �'/j' ®CC,Commercial Corridor I t,1 �� n -CG,General Commercial isCN,Neighborhood Commercial „ ,le?_ III -_ - t , II -CS,Community Shopping Ai Ine - k,,,, L-- I I,Institutional Baron G�*�m''"@H ....- 1 ,t \�`1 I _.1 M-1,Light Manufacturing t..i ,d tri F EB ` I-M-2,Heavy Manufacturing ; .,\\ O 11 J I 3, F_'1 MH,Mobile Home Park Il l�ll II I"�--III _ A.� F.a=n~ f.,:., .... ,�7 ,,: PROS,Open Space J`[C1t�1 TT1�_IIJIIIIIr� �� r 0..1g.11 Gt` -PL,Public Lands ,WS.�IrI-[DII. __ _ t•1,r-'^'+-r.,,(_--.��_ U �� 1R-1-5000,Single Family Residential IIIIIIM- II. 11I IT ff \\ IR-1-7000,Single FamilyResidential ill I _ aF i I I R-1-Single and Two-Family a Residential ; T ' s'a§-Iv t`',.� RMF-30,Low Density Multifamily Residential -- _ -_- � �""ON t. Lk'\ ®RMF-35,Moderate Density Multifamily Residential �� E HHH 1 {I I,,.m=-{ER 'irrkl p IL➢G�,t I-EE'EEE0 °tm' F-45,Moderate/ y Mumily Reside �Hl I--iC 6yI '�� \Zi;k GAR ® tial NFL -* WWI M � yE niia �nmc,� ill2 e,,. L P • ^ ," ' 41 .,1lKaverl ! iiM® ,. 0 \� \.� N -,—� S, , SiVe_ _, f � Geographic i monla..Systems : �� ...._ R ._—jai- ( \, .12 S, _ 9g • /J 2.449:1;04 } _• ., , ci a r1 • Sf'• • b «r y a •¢t4 yp;3y f'•^r.••4, •r.;Z. k. • 1 .... F 0,tor.r...e •"� }� r? ❑ m 1 yt , .:;n r , Z.❑ In - r ip , � r �'7-"tom CI rh r� t �+.. ., El b L In , . _ ,_._. ` W f �, .r tl?., �., ,.it r. ,u• tom`•si" • , r • i yx M� •e '',yam"'"''- p c J .4 „ A , ., ' % ''" a�X[ .., @ it 1 1.1 ,,, II ' A�' d • ai II❑ m ta Ill ' tID f m^ sF1 i• i m ,fir _, m 411,l ilrrtl 1 ll/.Q.,,.•:. ! 1. RG, a:^ k #1,i 4»yiilllifrt to m' ,m ��° •! «4.17 '' 4.".r r 1 t1, 4 y 411di" m , '- mdm m rad m •4 ri b �,,1r r •.,,,mo t« i+l! ai maim h7' ' +t w1iL.=wr 1 A itlllrYarm m • ]. 1-•rL• w',rlt TAnoil Z ••„'►may twin 1 �,I, GU m P L m y .• 'ty ai i! 'n .., n �� 1//441 Briefing for = =hire4 RO Planning Commission z � sd. Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie, Senior Planner Date: February 18, 2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: Comparison of Salt Lake City and Salt Lake County ordinances The Planning Commission subcommittee asked for a comparison of Salt Lake City and Salt Lake County ordinances regarding billboards. Please find attached the following: Salt Lake City ordinance Salt Lake County ordinance Outline of comparable zoning districts between Salt Lake City and County Map of zoning districts where billboards are allowed in Salt Lake County (Millcreek Township and west of Salt Lake City) Map of comparable zoning districts in Salt Lake City Map of area where the current Salt Lake City ordinance allows billboards • Sterling Codifiers, Inc. - ; - ,% Page 1 of 6 • i' • 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: inoolk A. Purpose Statement: This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number. This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways, views, vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. B. Definitions: BILLBOARD: A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK: An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconforming billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT: An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER: The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. • EXISTING BILLBOARD: A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. Amok GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4. 4000 West; 5. 5500 West; 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7. The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. G00 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; '12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; omokt 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 2 of 6 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD: An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT: An extension of the billboard resulting in increased square footage as pad of an artistic design to convey a specific message or advertisement. C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars ($111.00). E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D1 of this section, or its successor, the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; and Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 3 of 6 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however, the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor, priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section, the two (2) higher priority billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. G. Life Of Billboard Credits: Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty (60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable: A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six (36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall Auk receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code, the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may he constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Permits: '1. Application: Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: 1. A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 4 of 6 of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2. When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued, the zoning administrator shall deduct from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a. The square footage of the new billboard; and b. The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3. If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage, any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N. New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet (600') of the right of way of any gateway. O. Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway, the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P, 0, R and S of this section, provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2. The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits within the general billboard bank. Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway.A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six (36) months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet (15') in height and fifty feet (50') in width. 0.-Temporary mbe lis imenis 1. Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent (10%) of the advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet (5') in height above the billboard structure. 2. No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve (12) months. R. Height: The highest point of any new billboard, excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: '1. Forty five feet (45') above the existing grade; or 2. If a street within one hundred feet (100') of the billboard, measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street, is on a different grade than the new billboard, twenty five feet (25') above the pavement elevation of the street. 3. If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section, or its successor subsection, apply to more than one Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 5 of 6 street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. Aimik S. Minimum Setback Requirements: All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet (5') from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300) square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet (800') from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. U. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. V. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection U of „„ ' this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty (50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. W. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property, the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the-required-landscaping.-- X. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. Y. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance. Z. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary, such subdivision. .tea. AA. Special Provisions: 1. Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: Sterling Codifiers, Inc. Page 6 of 6 a. Four (4) existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the west side of Interstate 15; and b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection. BB. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. (Ord. 72- 08 § 2, 2008: Ord. 42-08 § 12, 2008: Ord. 13-04 §§ 25, 26, 27, 2004: Ord. 25-00 §§ 1-3, 2000: Ord. 83-98 §§ 12-14, 1998: Ord. 88-95 § 1 (Exh. A), 1995) Municode Page 1 of 2 • • 19.82.185 -Off-premises signs—Billboards. A. Purpose.This section provides for the reasonable regulation of off-premises signs with the intent of enhancing the aesthetics of existing and future billboards, mitigating negative impacts, promoting safety and protecting property values that further the goals and planning policies of Salt Lake County. B. Cap on Number of Off-Premises Signs.The number of off-premises signs allowed in unincorporated Salt Lake County and established or future townships shall be limited to the number of off-premises signs that are existing as defined herein as of May 18; 2004. This cap shall automatically decrease as off-premises signs are annexed into a municipal jurisdiction or removed and not relocated. C. Location. Off-premises signs shall be allowed in the C-1 zone as a conditional use. Off-premises signs shall be allowed in the C-2,C-3, M-1 and M-2 zones as a permitted use. D. Size. Off-premises signs shall not exceed six hundred seventy-two square feet in the C-2, C-3, M-1 and M-2 zones. Off-premises signs located in a C-1 zone shall not exceed three hundred square feet in size. E. Height.The maximum height of an off-premises sign shall be thirty-five feet in a C-1 zone.The maximum height of an off-premises sign shall be forty-five feet above the grade level of the road ill the C-2, C-3, M-1 and M-2 zones or,when oriented for freeway viewing only and located within three hundred feet of the nearest freeway lane, twenty-five feet above freeway grade level or fifty feet overall, whichever is greater. F. Separation.The minimum distance between off-premises signs larger than three hundred square feet shall be five hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections. The minimum distance between off-premises signs three hundred square feet or less in size shall be three hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections.All off-premises signs must be at least one hundred fifty radial feet from any other off-premises sign. G. Setbacks. The minimum setback shall be eighteen inches for off-premises signs.The sign's front-yard setback shall he measured from the future right-of-way line (see Transportation Improvement Plan).The closest edge of an off-premises sign shall not project into any required setback area.The minimum setback between an off- premises sign and any residential zone boundary shall be one hundred fifty feet. I-1. Light-g. Lighting shall be confined to the sign face, and the lighting source shall not be directly visible. Design. Off-premises signs shall utilize either the"mono-pole" or the"bi-pole" design and shall be continually maintained structurally and on the copy face.The back of the sign and the structure behind the sign shall be painted a dark color.Tri-vision sign faces shall be permitted and, if illuminated, must be externally illuminated. Internally illuminated off-premises signs, electronic display(outdoor video advertising) and electronic message centers are only allowed adjacent to the interstate freeway system and limited to no more than one change to the copy face in a twenty-four hour period. Two-decked off-premises signs are prohibited in all zones. J. Credits for Removal. Prior to the removal of any off-premises sign,the owner shall obtain a permit for the demolition of the off-premises sign. Permits may be provided following application to the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division. The Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall by letter inform the affected community council chairman and affected planning commission chairman that a permit for demolition of an off-premises sign has been issued.After any off-premises sign is demolished,the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall create a"billboard bank account"for the sign owner.The account shall reflect credits for the off-premises sign square footage as well as the date of removal. Any off-premises sign credits not used within thirty=srx months oftheir creation shall expire and be of no further value or use. An off-premises sign owner may sell or otherwise transfer off- premises signs and/or billboard bank account credits.The transfer of any billboard bank account credits does not extend their thirty-six-month life as provided in this section. Demolition of an off-premises sign that has two advertising faces shall receive billboard bank account credits for the square footage of each sign face. IC. Relocation.The owner of an existing off-premises sign may remove an existing off-premises sign from any site to an approved location only after a permit for relocation is obtained upon substantiation of compliance with this chapter. Prior to approval of a permit for relocation, the sign owner(applicant) shall submit to the county a notarized affidavit signed by the property owner, a copy of the lease agreement or other document to be signed by the property owner, indicating at a minimum the duration of the lease and renewal provisions. Additionally, prior to approval of a permit for relocation, Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall by letter inform the affected community council chairman and affected planning commission chairman that application for an off-premises sign permit has been received. Off-premises signs moved to approved locations shall conform to all off-premises sign requirements of the new location. Off-premises signs moved from one location to another must be installed in the new approved location within the period allotted by the International Building Code (IBC).A new off-premises sign permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard bank account credits of a sufficient number of square feet. When the permit for construction of a new off-premises sign is issued,the Salt Lake County Planning and Development Services Division shall deduct from the sign owner's billboard bank account the square footage of the new off-premises sign. If the new off- - — premises sign uses less than the entire available square footage credits, any remaining square footage credits shall remain in the sign owner's billboard bank account. L. County Council Review and Monitoring. The county council shall, on a regular six-month schedule be updated n•, '- ---__i__- -. ----n_i:_._ TTl—Y LLnn o_TTTA /nn1 Municode Page 2 of 2 at a regular public meeting to changes in status and effectiveness of the provisions related to off-premises signs in unincorporated Salt Lake County. M. Severability and Conflict.This section and its various parts are hereby declared to be severable if a court of competent jurisdiction declares any subsection,clause, provision or portion of this section invalid or unconstitutional. No court decision will affect the validity of either this section as a whole or any parts not declared invalid or unconstitutional by that decision. If any part of this section is found to be in conflict with any other provision of the county, the most restrictive or highest standard will apply, prevail and govern. (Ord. 1532§4,2004) Dansie, Doug As From: Norris, Nick '" Sent: Monday, February 07, 2011 4:49 PM To: Dansie, Doug Subject: Bookl.xlsx Attachments: Bookl.xlsx Categories: Other Doug, I quickly put together a summary of the counties C-1, C-2 and C-3 zones and which zones they are the most similar to in SLC. Both C-1 and C-2 are most similar to the City's CC zoning district. The CB district listed in the table is primarily used for those areas that are adjacent to residential uses. The main difference is SLC has a max building size of 20,000 square feet, while the C-1 zone in the county allows buildings larger than 20,000 square feet with a conditional use. Based on that, C-1 is kind of between our CB and CC. C-2 and C-3 are more similar to CC and CG, respectively. Amok Amok Purpose Front yard side yard rear yard min lot size Max height Uses Uses max height min lot size rear yard side yard front yard Purpose District District j' provide areas in the 20 0;except 0;except 35 feet general commercial, general 30 none, 10 feet None None; provide for the CB The C-1 zone is most county for 10 10 required typically. commerci over 4 maximum close integration similar to the CB zone in neighborhood required when next Development over al and acres setback of of moderately SLC. The key difference is commercial when next to 20,000 square feet is a office,size requires a 15 for at sized the CB zone is intended to development to residential conditional use. esidential limted by conditiona least 75% commercial be closely integrated into rbuilding I use. of building areas with adjacent neighborhoods. size. Building facade. adjacent Examples of where the CB size reisdnetil zone is include the limited neighborhoods. Univeristy business 20,000 district,most stand along square grocery stores,and feet corners of City collector streets C-1 Provide areas in the 20 feet for 0;except 0;except none 6 stories or general commercial. general 30 feet; 10,000 10 none 15 provide an CC The C-2 and CC zones are county for commercial 10 10 required 75 feet Uses over one acre commerci up to an square enviornment for fairly similar,with the community uses required when next require conditional al, additional feet efficient and City's CC zone being more commercial when next to use. development to esidential 15 feet attractive auto restrictive in terms of esidential may be oriented building intensity. rapproved commercial as a development conditiona along arterial I use and major collector streets c-2 Provide areas in the none 0;except 0;except none 75 feet general commercial, Most 60 feet, 10,000 10 none 10 Provide an CG The CG and C-3 are the county for 10 10 required fairly land intensive. intense up to 90 squarefee environment for most intensive commercial commercial uses, required when next Uses over one acre commerci with a t a variety of zones in SLC as well as SL warehouding and when next to require conditional al zone,conditiona commercial CO. They allow similar wholesale - to ------- residential- - - ---------- use -- - - -- - businesses residential includes I use uses,some of uses and similar big box, which involve intensities. warehous the outdoor e stores as display of permitted merchandise or uses materials. c-3 Conditional in C- Billboard size: limited Separation: over 300 1;permitted in C- to 300 sq.ft in C-1; sq ft requires 500 ft Billboard r 2,C-3,M-1 and M-672 in C-2,C-3,M-1 separation;less than Billboards Permitted within C-2, C-3, M-1, M-2 & Conditional Uses within C-1 0 1 :iali lake City n Millcreek Township - Salt Lake County 1 ; � _ . _� -� try, Lb t .�L111 3300 S ^i�� ` - .r_� �fit.: ..ten Ii 1-� �s 01 cn ..1 Or ,:.. ..,..'-. Willi diiii : „: n _. r _-___f -`�+ m i'�C �t - _:! '-�f it r ` '' l .- T .''I.-+ - -cam _ South Salt Lake - —� — � s 1 < ,- _,---..-- South 1- 3900 S t� p1 - �"�N • , —LR UJ biz i1 / ,\ r J q i -n M ' I' a7 -, 0 —_ - . L ' ii1 � -I - m — r t I Wm\ ' . . [[-- ( �r t T� �I� '�4 l is 7-- i I—irI ,ILL_' �- :;a - I .I_ 4500 S 411 I J - / J_ �� '�' �� F = f �/ / / ///- ' Legend — ' l L „. --- -:i l' ' ,, SLCO_zoning2011 L___I FA-5 L i FR-20 R-1-3 EL R-2-10 I k'..; r _, 6 - -' i 1 Jb L� r Y ' I' i 1 A-1 h_J FM-10 I-1 FR-5 EU R-1-4 I__ -I R• -2-10/zc AI•JI L dZ F '1 A-1/zc FM-10/zc i M-1;M 1/zc "I R-1-43 L i R-2-6.5 \, ��, ^�� `` ...... kiN,i( !- a1, qqI J A 2 [ I FM 20 .M-2 I R-1-5 I _I R• -2-8 __ T c= t r , L_ I A-20 I 1 FM-20/zc IN MD-3/zc ®R-1-5/zc I--I R• -4-8.5 ` i ,_i[ ,I -i� 1':./1 Li A-5 FR-0.5 :� R-1-10 R-1-6 �1 R-M � S��' 7` r J!. I i C-1;C-1/zc FR-1 R-1-10/zc R-1-6/zc L';'I R-M/zc _ ( i� I I C-2;C-2/zc ®FR-1/zc R-1-15 I::_ I R-1-7 Li RMH I Vl C-3;C-3lzc FR-10 i Rt, R-1-15/zc is R-1-7/zc 1 I S-1-G eti C-V Li FR-10/zc n R-1-21 • R-1-8 Holladay - r 1 FA-2.5 _J FR-2.5 es R-1-21/zc R-1-8/zc M p created by SLC Planning Division 2011 NORTH Billboards Permitted within C-2, C-3, M-1 , M-2 & Conditional Uses within C-1 Salt Lake City Northwest - Salt Lake County - _._ AIRPORT ,,. ,.....,;., N. V hi 0 0 cm * er ,f. o -...-tcy.;• '-,,,...., ." . CALIFORNIA AVE w m III .-- p3 * a -1 m x)..---- . ..,----- —_ SR-201 West Valley City T-- ,_,, ,,,- „ ia_ ,-- ,±. Legend • ' H 41 4' 4 re.,0--TE.1/11,7 SLCO_zoning2011 11..,:71 FA-5 I I FR-20 tal R-1-3 ERI R-2-10 . L F 1 Al rj FM-10 I- -I FR-5 am R-1-4 t I R-2-10/zc 1L,t,-3 _, + .. r I . V) '.L.I.,A-1/zc In FM-10/zc 1.1 M-1,M-1/zc gl R-1-43 E23 R-2-6 5 '- ,2r -' ''' rr,t' 1 -2 IF--;-L ' Lii--- l vij A-2 t I FM-20 IIII M-2 CL R-1-5 I I R-2 " a11 El -8 _, ,— ,. -,I A-20 Li FM-20/zc at MD Mt R-1-5/zc I I R-4-8 5 '''' \ . -44 -''. 'IL I ' ' P , - ro x5 Nui FR-0 5 MI R-1-10 gm R-1-6 I I R-M pi Cl c_liz. El FR-1 ri R-1-10/n NE R-1-6/ze I -I R-M/zc , t4 RE , .-C-2,C-2/zc II FR-1/zc r..j R-1-15 pi R-1-7 [ 1 RMH , _.7, SI C-3;C-3/ze 1111 FR-10 Euil R-1-15/zc ati R-1-7/zc I I S-1-G .,, :- ",...;: IIII CV p:4 FR-10/zc ,-1 R-1-21 ;4;,-. R-1-8 --;: 4,i7 :a El FA-25 E]FR-2 5 III R-1-21/ze t i',:! R-1-8/zc Map created by SLC Planning Division 2011 NORTH Salt Lake City CB, CC, CG, M-1 and M-2 Zones lk ■ . 1111 - ' .i 1 raj . • -7 1II 1 Nilit:, ii Illipitr1-1 k 111117 IIIIIP, IL k - .no.\\ 46.„,,, , ._ \ 1. ) MEI l-C. 1 i-commil. -__Pi-- . 'NMI -,_. \-1-A- LI__ 1211111111111-.;a11111IN NI,t 1 si_i um- ii -7 -- 1211111M11111 :, 11111,W . slimmunidis i. ql) -,1: Ill 11111111 fit 4 111111111111' --.:. , inff_111111 I— :nal= gils - -7 1,•f+ -,07-.k7exii \- _. _ - - .__ • r .„, _ ::: 1.\..r_.......„„,_,. ................. NOITTIVEMP: it". •--...:5-_- - -• ___I• ___ • , 1111±114::::Ro. .11111 ti..11 ._. .., '''''' -7-----'•---4011pr"-, -71:4"%/>411111iitiliiiiiil i III I .. " I 1=11111 _-- ',, '11.• NI:. 11111 i. III I "' --Imolai' °all! , ,-I/ 111111111111 ' IalLi.„„,„ i II iitilijr '_4Afist-• - . - ._..-t-il _ , iniiii t:1011X11 LID a •--= iii 1011 nErmi j_--- ---.-,- -7-- -__,_ _s_s_r_._ ' 0 , ..sen T.- gw ___., ....I ,.____ --sy7-_-:22-_,42 tit-bs„,?- ___ .____A•-- ' F ."11 ill: ll'• . U1_, _-- ii-:- -- N LINI ir; . zi -:._L--7--.‘_-_-•"„:...-=-:...„....:2,2-: ___1,1;' ._, i i —__-/I-i , • t i 7-7177 _,::::: ::::----±-17 1-.-_..1 t- . -4- •.,..,..: — • ., .. i ,_, ,..1:41,_ . „ 0 ....,,,it 66, i _ _______ _ = ..{,-rn. •,..: _ -2.,:,,„., / . ; __, _•••,_ _• i . iir • _::::::;--• +,—_,-_,___ A.__,:ijr.i..-... H... ,_-_Ku_ 1 ! . II '._2:;',. -- _ • I -1' DM .,. •--_, - ...-.7.•=:!_ = - _ _...7__=.±.7:::,.. _ L'_'.,...,._::. • i ‘ ------ --f! :.; i I • 1 141111111.• IBM ,i ----L, -:-1 -- 7 --:-..1 _ I_• I.7._' - --- .7-7..---.7 [ 74 .-..! -1; Legend _r, , I -ano-..w:-. ININ"uli -1--1:--7-=• -• ,,,-1-1- \ ZONING A. vomim Mimm... .14 2. . - -'.1 1 1----1 CB -Mi E.1‘, NE ...., — - ve CG 1 r Ii I. sow --- , Division 2011 NORTH :- , „e • 1 I p I. SALT LAKE CITY -----, mill 11 iiNATI,:i .. : \\ 1 II .. 1 E iallir 1 1 1 1 nilillimilli 11 itit glig tAl i ::_11J:;111!,0.1111itMMEI . A .74-: pm , . --, . A N., ;1111411111111411.11.1M.1 11,4:71 '1:1: 'Llu....1p..1, " .— -3,• OFFICIAL BILLBOARD AND GATEWAY MAP .. ___ I }Y.11.111111.1111111111 •-----E MI1111111111111111 ff'i..f;;. : 011 ,Iliffillifral,. _:11 .r.E---„... 1.-,.... 41. --------ivErt,..._ .. ., :. . 1..1.1..... 1...v ‘,.. ' ...L....."ii-:"45 IIII 'rEIZ j..111 111.riEil VI"AO- eata4R, . I i I I • NN,..11 i ,- i - VI'.. del \ 11113 ...- '..4:5)_•zi -ion , ••., 1/4, . -. ....., z',:ii k"11111.1-111 'rthat 1 -7. S. ;', . -.7.1%-#-..1- ' ;1201.6114 --Ilaill II tk‘11111 ..w.112B°94:- Ok, ‘ tv(ft, '',----•Ellin '—...., , 111 lifillii- 11M1111411M131214ini:1 NIU27'!" '!LI-171110i- 111FIIII ‘t- --03,,..., [11=3, .11.!LIAII ED i PIN N •Itti, :;o0cooragArc ill _II - _ill M" , ( • 1 . c-'EI . .. . -.-, INEMITERIU ilill--T,. RHRR e..opauunoo••e.•v.k,,...,..- --- --. _. finnOCDOLi_uultu ctu•,...'.--,J•1•*. --.- ..,.„/,,s'•.' g mum•••inELIOSECIO•a vutsiu uttAtc•11,..!. ' 4. ----._ ,.., '-',111.prii -----mi,...,„•minim. k _ , prz_orti.=a.atitt_• _. .. ,.., u. .„...., 0 _ - 10.T - I 0E1 1 Mall. 4'._) •.:„..____ 11--- (4,-4, ..Iiipli-ti H=1,_L, irt tilt J.11 EiDENHEairsivig IMI r:...........-4,,,N.ci-oz-a-imia_VE--(1,WIIHIElt.i:IWI: Ill'-in:, , TIPQM1F71171R NI DEEM i, '',s,„, AffiNI111-__.I.-.,..1M, ' 11111.7A1p2r.77::g.:t;011,1111IgNVIBAEE MINIUM•WM A? _ IEI small 0 :.-,, • pionou-v-ii----.._11 feu,.w.Az, :-..z,,-...4-,sjoinix omminii mon•;mums Is ma]Fri ... ___ —I ' 0"Illiela .P, ,,,,...miLugurgroHNk• mi •E.. ;;w..,..M NI tr NigmEDWIE "Mk_ . * kii-lisal. 11,%;Pliat4lifEli to DM i aDQIA'ER MI; ,AGODOMMEMOTIMOO ---- lig 1 '11.*11 II% rilt M-74-kiVOC E n,U110 M DM ONO I I: 'NOME MI Oil EIZITEEEk.i.:4,.-..17...........0 11MMM NirlrININOINirisT 1.....A B-1,111:-gul,,E1-, ,.7,. ''!':;k2"1111111WIIII lil="911 mum die.,nmor,..enf-I"ka=•;,, .- I - , I 1.11111; immilirmil 111 rip - '''.101g=) OT,5 . \'."- -:,Tiitii 1 ( =L' F'11114 111111011.=li eg:::effElEik Mtn! 1111 2Fir•" I -11 = N =`, -- i• t ik--....f=i, . .-111.-•• nu ini-,--.-• . 10111:=—.., t. , hum •at..' 4444i ,,et&''fe-, , n t, , 7.,71F....-91; ..,,,zam ,...it,;,..=4,:m.fl.,,,,.,....,_.=41.,,,,0,, 1,••••••• I • itillAntiiiila lirai,7 ,611111111101 ill V;'''AIIIIIIi p,411:11-,--I.J4-:' X aaIIIIL,r'.I;aRIE,IE:a7P111jfiW.E.::g;::SS,___k_-*— , •i .rd 11 -h RIM' ...It...1 ..E.,7-.1emir,.....•0. Ems,1=.....:acIM,mi . , . I IIMIgh ' ill \, I Mr..• .'-T'w-l'2C,c,griiiiit "1:1114'711:11.0,11111111..,E' llnr...3.7.1M IMP% ,-----. 11 • I • I I I 0 1 I onj ir riii It 0 nri . ,,-pi Il ,110-inscp, I : w)111.70.er.' - ilitrEit:fly,EN.,,,tviti:=ERE=.=INE,A1 li,,•.- - 111. imimpil-4 le . -__u.i Lotman '1 z,.".q.,;=,,..z.,--- ...ov_ou 1 a P31 I l'.=. 1.5.7.,M.7..L1.IWIACIPIC•A t._-_,.. . y__ ‘11111IMP TA v-.7,--- Legend Y./ ..., ,, ._. -r -,,,,...,, --atifr-mr!..:711 it111.11ungiptIR. .. - ....1 IM-11111111111161kra N 12 HI ['`A 1010111Micatiik; 'I ,.. ON0100 — Gateway ,I .... 1 w-.710,-- E la , V 1:1,1 1111 11 111011191111.15 MI U ------ Special Gateway June 2001 r Ir•••1-..,-.:(7.=...101" `MI •Billboards Permitted s 1.300 SOUTH_ um . { • Pif I Briefing for ia1�*iai.r,�c • ' il Planning Commission `` rT ` III,. ,,,,, Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Planning Commission Members From: Doug Dansie, Senior Planner Date: March 9, 2011 Re: Billboard Ordinance: Continuation of February 23, 2011 discussion At the February 23, 201 1 meeting. the Planning Commission asked that the two petitions regarding rewriting the billboard ordinance PLNPCM2010-00032,�and electronic billboards PLNPCM2010-00717 be separated; with expected action regarding electronic billboard to take place at the March 9, 20] 1 meeting and the other items be continued for discussion. Please find attached the following: A proposed ordinance defining and banning electronic billboards 0 A proposed ordinance defining electronic billboards, banning them and then providing criteria for them in the event that they are moved, rebuilt or otherwise constructed for external reasons. The Planning Commission should discuss and choose which route (either those provided or another alternative) they wish to pursue. The proposed ordinances are Planning Staff drafts reflecting policy and may be modified by the Attorneys office to insure legality and compatibility with existing code. The Planning Commission raised questions regarding outstanding balances in the billboard bank. The only company with an outstanding balance is Salt Lake Community College. Reagan has 604 square feet in the general account but is overdrawn by 660 square feet in the North Temple account. Therefore Reagan is presently in a negative overall scenario with the bank. Salt Lake Community College has S40 square feet worth of credit that expires in December 2013. Proposed Ordinance Proposal which defines and prohibits electronic billboards. 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement: This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number. This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways, views, vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. B. Definitions: BILLBOARD: A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK:An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconforming billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT: An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER: The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. (3WE_LL TIME The length of time that elapses between text. Images, or grrphi s on {Formatted:Font:Not Bold an electronic sign. {Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" f Formatted:Font:Bold EXISTING BILLBOARD: A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ELECTRONIC BILLBOARD:Any of-premise sign, video display, projected image, or similar device with text. images, or graphics generated by solid state electronic components. Electronic signs include but are not limited to, signs that use light emitting diodes (LED), plasma displays, fiber optics, or other technology that results in bright, high-resolution text, images, and graphics. FOOT CANDLE: the English unit of measurement for luminance, which is equal to -- {Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" one lumen. incident upon an area of one square foot. GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; {Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4. 4000 West; 5. 5600 West; 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; 7. The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; ,- 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 30; -"" odooll 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD:A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; -- {Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.58" 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. ILLUMINENCE: The intensity of light falling on a subsurface at a defined distance from the source. MOTION, The depiction of movement or change of position of text, images,or -{Formatted:Font:Not Bold J graphics. Motion shall include, but not be limited to, visual effects such as dissolving '{Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab and fading text and images. running sequential text. graphic bursts, lighting that resembles zooming, twinkling, or sparkling, changes in light or color, transitory bursts of light intensity, moving patterns or bands of light, expanding or contracting shapes, and similar actions., {Formatted:Font:Bold TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message Space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: or advertisement. o.zs",List tab ,TWIRL TIME The time it takes for static text, images, and graphics on an electronic _ {Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt sign to change to a different text. images. or graphics on a subsequent sign face. {Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner - {Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.58" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars ($111.00). Aimilk E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D1 of this section, or its successor,the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. • F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways shall be removed second; 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed �r last; and *moo' 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however, the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection Fl of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor, priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section, the two (2) higher priority billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. G. Life Of Billboard Credits: Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty (60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable:A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six(36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code, the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may be constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Permits: 1. Application: Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: ems. 1. A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2. When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued, the zoning administrator shall deduct from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a. The square footage of the new billboard; and b.The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3. If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage, any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N. New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet (600') of the right of way of any gateway. O. Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway, the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P, 0, R and S of this section, provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2. The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits within the general billboard bank. Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway. A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six (36) months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15') in height and fifty feet (50') in width. • Q. Temporary Embellishments: 1. Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent(10%) of the advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet (5') in height above the billboard structure. 2. No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve (12) months. R. Height: The highest point of any new billboard, excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: 1. Forty five feet(45') above the existing grade; or 2. If a street within one hundred feet (100') of the billboard, measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street, is on a different grade than the new billboard, twenty five feet(25') above the pavement elevation of the street. 3. If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section, or its successor subsection, apply to more than one street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. S. Minimum Setback Requirements:All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet (5')from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300)square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. U: Electronic Billboards: 1. Electronic Billboards are prohibited:, r Formatted:List Paragraph,Numbered+ Level:1+Numbering Style:1,2,3,...+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 0.25"+ UV. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: indent at: 0.5" Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a 'f Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21A.26.020 and 21A.26.030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. VW. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as • specified in subsection U-S of this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed,to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. • W ,. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property,the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. XY. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. Z. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or maintenance of billboards shall comply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance.-_ ZAA. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the site of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary, such subdivision. MBB. Special Provisions: 1. Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: a. Four(4)existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the west side of Interstate 15; and b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection-W of this section, or its successor subsection. &BCC. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. (Ord. 72-08§2, 2008: Ord. 42-08 § 12, 2008: Ord. 13-04 §§25, 26, 27, 2004: Ord. 25-00§§ 1-3,2000: Ord. 83-98 §§ 12-14, 1998: Ord. 88-95 § 1 (Exh.A), 1995) Proposed Ordinance Proposal which defines and prohibits electronic billboards and provides criteria if they are built for external reasons. 21A.46.160: BILLBOARDS: A. Purpose Statement: This chapter is intended to limit the maximum number of billboards in Salt Lake City to no greater than the current number. This chapter further provides reasonable processes and methods for the replacement or relocation of existing nonconforming billboards to areas of the city where they will have less negative impact on the goals and policies of the city which promote the enhancement of the city's gateways, views, vistas and related urban design elements of the city's master plans. B. Definitions: BILLBOARD:A freestanding ground sign located on industrial, commercial or residential property if the sign is designed or intended to direct attention to a business, product or service that is not sold, offered or existing on the property where the sign is located. BILLBOARD BANK:An accounting system established by the city to keep track of the number and square footage of nonconforming billboards removed pursuant to this chapter. BILLBOARD CREDIT: An entry into a billboard owner's billboard bank account that shows the number and square footage of demolished nonconforming billboards. BILLBOARD OWNER: The owner of a billboard in Salt Lake City. Sp'./.EI _ iI: = li�;_. i=• ,l �t -ti? i;l_ - _ - - - is �i lii'�i:� �i C.f-�:f'i�' C• l iFormatted:Font: = -C'F: n'' Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" Formatted:Font:Bold EXISTING BILLBOARD: A billboard which was constructed, maintained and in use or for which a permit for construction was issued as of July 13, 1993. ls'r d'v: ✓1 = c; c cn==t• comcon nts. Hectronic s;gns Inc'ude. but are not limited to. signs that use lhcht emittino h ode.-ilLED). plasma disclays, fiber optics. or other tschnolcav that results In braht, hinh-resolution text. imeaes. and oraohics. FOOT CANDLE: the Er.c':sh unit of measurement for luminance.. \ii;Irh IS enu_I to • Formatted:Indent:First line: 0" one lumen. incldent'unon an area of one sauar_foot_ GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. Interstate 80; - Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.83" 2. Interstate 215; 3. Interstate 15; 4. 4000 West; 5. 5600 West; 6. 2100 South Street from Interstate 15 to 1300 East; AIN 7. The 2100 South Expressway from 1-15 west to the city limit; ' 8. Foothill Drive from Guardsman Way to Interstate 80; 9. 400 South from Interstate 15 to 800 East; 10. 500 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 11. 600 South from Interstate 15 to 700 East; 12. 300 West from 900 North to 900 South; 13. North Temple from Main Street to Interstate 80; 14. Main Street from North Temple to 2100 South Street; 15. State Street from South Temple to 2100 South; and 16. 600 North from 800 West to 300 West. NEW BILLBOARD: A billboard for which a permit to construct is issued after December 31, 1993. NONCONFORMING BILLBOARD:An existing billboard which is located in a zoning district or otherwise situated in a way which would not be permitted by the provisions of this chapter. SPECIAL GATEWAY: The following streets or highways within Salt Lake City: 1. North Temple between 600 West and 2200 West; • I Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.58" 2. 400 South between 200 East and 800 East; 3. State Street between 600 South and 2100 South; and 4. Main Street between 600 South and 2100 South. c.`rno ef1''_t cr chance of .r.osition of text irn.a.ces. or I Formatted:Font:Not Bold • ( ,n} �__-.�.n :inaiI irrJ Id_ C� t.not be llrr:-d to. `iist)al effects Swat aS f� _.so;'1;� � "` � '' Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab d f^cir- to•xf and is _ ,,,_ running_q ucntial text. gr_cnic bursts~L(1htinn taa zCi;f" L:Q_t,':'n!Khna. or soarkl'n!�_clan:es in llaht cr color. transitar'/ ` burst3U I_r' lotenS`v. mo _r..1 c=_eriss or bxnclk cf Il cni. excanding or ccntr=ct'i, —----_ actions, - Formatted:Font:Bold TEMPORARY EMBELLISHMENT:An extension of the billboard resulting in Formatted:Normal,Indent:Left: 0.25", increased square footage as part of an artistic design to convey a specific message space Before: Auto,After: Auto,Tab stops: or advertisement. 0.25",List tab 1 Pd^ l it t for at, t xt irnan End crachics Cn an ctrcr_�; • i Formatted:' � � � �,� 5 3� � . �• �! Font:Helvetia,12pt tO Ch11r -,J a d ter nt text. imaac;. or crachics cn a subsecuen skkn feca ' Formatted:Tab stops: 0.25",List tab C. Limit On The Total Number Of Billboards: No greater number of billboards shall be allowed in Salt Lake City than the number of existing billboards. D. Permit Required For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: 1. Permit: Nonconforming billboards may be removed by the billboard owner • Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.55" only after obtaining a permit for the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. - 2. Application: Application for demolition shall be on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 3. Fee: The fee for demolishing a nonconforming billboard shall be one hundred eleven dollars ($111.00). E. Credits For Nonconforming Billboard Removal: After a nonconforming billboard is demolished pursuant to a permit issued under subsection D1 of this section, or its successor,the city shall create a billboard bank account for the billboard owner. The account shall show the date of the removal and the zoning district of the demolished nonconforming billboard. The account shall reflect billboard credits for the billboard and its square footage. Demolition of a conforming billboard shall not result in any billboard credit. F. Priority For Removal Of Nonconforming Billboards: Nonconforming billboards shall be removed subject to the following priority schedule: 1. Billboards in districts zoned residential, historic, residential R-MU or downtown D-1, D-3 and D-4 shall be removed first; 2. Billboards in districts zoned commercial CN or CB, or gateway G-MU, GGC or GH or on gateways shall be removed second; Nogoe 3. Billboards which are nonconforming for any other reason shall be removed last; and 4. A billboard owner may demolish nonconforming billboards of a lower priority before removing billboards in a higher priority; however, the billboard credits for removing the lower priority billboard shall not become effective for use in constructing a new billboard until two (2) billboards specified in subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, with a total square footage equal to or greater than the lower priority billboard, are credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account. If a billboard owner has no subsection F1 of this section, or its successor, nonconforming billboards, two (2) subsection F2 of this section, or its successor, priority billboards may be credited in the billboard owner's billboard bank account to effectuate the billboard credits of a subsection F3 of this section, or its successor, billboard to allow the construction of a new billboard. For the purposes of this section, the two (2) higher priority.billboards credited in the billboard bank account can be used only once to effectuate the billboard credits for a lower priority billboard. G. Life Of Billboard Credits:Any billboard credits not used within thirty six (36) months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value or use except that lower • priority credits effectuated pursuant to subsection F4 of this section, or its successor, shall expire and be of no further value or use within sixty(60) months of their initial creation. H. Billboard Credits Transferable: A billboard owner may sell or otherwise transfer a billboard and/or billboard credits. Transferred billboard credits which are not effective because of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor, shall not become effective for their new owner until they would have become effective for the original owner. The transfer of any billboard credits do not extend their thirty six (36) month life provided in subsection G of this section, or its successor. I. Double Faced Billboards: Demolition of a nonconforming billboard that has two (2) advertising faces shall receive billboard credits for the square footage on each face, but only as one billboard. J. New Billboard Construction: It is unlawful to construct a new billboard other than pursuant to the terms of this chapter. In the event of a conflict between this chapter and any other provision in this code, the provisions of this chapter shall prevail. K. Permitted Zoning Districts: New billboards may be constructed only in the area identified on the official billboard map. L. New Billboard Permits: 1. Application:Anyone desiring to construct a new billboard shall file an application on a form provided by the zoning administrator. 2. Fees: The fees for a new billboard construction permit shall be: a. Building permit and plan review fees required by the uniform building code as adopted by the city; and b. Inspection tag fees according to the fee schedule or its successor. M. Use Of Billboard Credits: 1.A new billboard permit shall only be issued if the applicant has billboard credits of a sufficient number of square feet and billboards to allow construction of the new billboard. 2.When the permit for the construction of a new billboard is issued,the zoning administrator shall deduct from the billboard owner's billboard bank account: a. The square footage of the new billboard; and b. The number of billboards whose square footage was used to allow the new billboard construction. 3. If the new billboard uses less than the entire available billboard credits considering both the number of billboards and square footage, any remaining square footage shall remain in the billboard bank. N. New Billboards Prohibited On Gateways: Except as provided in subsection 0 of this section, or its successor, no new billboard may be constructed within six hundred feet(600') of the right of way of any gateway. O. Special Gateway Provisions: 1. If a nonconforming billboard is demolished within a special gateway, the billboard owner may construct a new billboard along the same special gateway in a zoning district equal to or less restrictive than that from which the nonconforming billboard was removed and subject to subsections P, Q, R and S of this section, provided that the size of the new billboard does not exceed the amount of billboard credits in the special gateway billboard bank. 2. The demolition of a nonconforming billboard pursuant to this section shall not accrue billboard credits within the general billboard bank. Credits for a billboard demolished or constructed within a special gateway shall be tracked within a separate bank account for each special gateway. A permit for the construction of a new billboard pursuant to this section must be taken out within thirty six(36) months of the demolition of the nonconforming billboard. P. Maximum Size: The maximum size of the advertising area of any new billboard shall not exceed fifteen feet(15')in height and fifty feet(50') in width. Q. Temporary Embellishments: 1. Temporary embellishments shall not exceed ten percent (10%)of the• advertising face of any billboard, and shall not exceed five feet (5') in height above the billboard structure. 2. No temporary embellishment shall be maintained on a billboard more than twelve (12) months. R. Height: The highest point of any new billboard, excluding temporary embellishments shall not be more than: 1. Forty five feet(45') above the existing grade; or 2. If a street within one hundred feet(100') of the billboard, measured from the street at the point at which the billboard is perpendicular to the street, is on a different grade than the new billboard, twenty five feet(25') above the pavement elevation of the street. 3. If the provisions of subsection R2 of this section, or its successor subsection, apply to more than one street, the new billboard may be the higher of the two (2) heights. S. Minimum Setback Requirements: All freestanding billboards shall be subject to pole sign setback requirements listed for the district in which the billboard is located. In the absence of setback standards for a particular district, freestanding billboards shall maintain a setback of not less than five feet(5')from the front or corner side lot line. This setback requirement shall be applied to all parts of the billboard, not just the sign support structure. T. Spacing: 1. Small Signs: Billboards with an advertising face three hundred (300) square feet or less in size shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) linear feet from any other small billboard or eight hundred feet(800')from a large billboard on the same side of the street; 2. Large Signs: Billboards with an advertising face greater than three hundred (300) square feet in size shall not be located closer than eight hundred (800) linear feet from any other billboard, small or large, on the same side of the street. 3. F! f_trcn c h iibc_rd� snail not be loco`sd closer than si,teen hundred (1E0011 fnct from an:!('.t_•er electronic b`Ili;cord nn the., same or opposite side Ci tli e street Formatted:Space Before: Auto,After: Auto I U 'ectrcniC E'I CO rds: 1. No':/ ElectrcnioEiiiCO_.r':i5 ce c chibited: Electronic billbosri s constiu:t:J C Formatted:List Paragraph,Numbered+ Level:1+Numbering Style:1,2,3,...+Start reconstructed forantr Fson a:c foe date of adoption Of this ofdina:nceare at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 0.25"+ linl!ted to the fCllOw!nc_ - — Indent at: 0.5" Formatted:Indent:Left: 0.5", No bullets or ,; - numbering motion of En'i <.nCI is prohibited cn an eleCtrOi?„ sicn i C _' ' Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,l2pt Electronic biilboai'Us si?Il have cni'i static text. Iflla2__ 2fdI Cr_a_r?U-_s_ Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numb, 111140) . Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c, rt at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at:`*00+ t ii_ - • Indent at: 2.5" The text. Imape c.r cl,scl '✓ cn oil electronic S'.riniii�'/ fiat chance rilt:`c --- • Formatted:Font:Hel etica,12 pt,Not Bold ti10 ri Circe eveiw t' ent/ four (24) hours Twirl time between - --- m_ seconds. Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt c l_Iizseou2nt .�`:i. :i it=.� Ci ul_Hol shall not exceed--__ 5 — — Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" c Hri:h tr_s Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt The i;Iu ?inat::oil of a 1V Cie ctrcr Billboard shall not If Cr' z. to: Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ ;in;Dili !ICiitinU I e-I more titan 0.3 foot candle) 1'%oot1 nlea3ur:;:I !'( Level 5+Numbering Style:a,b, '✓ _---__ __-- - at:1+Aignment:Left+Aligned cCt candle meter cerc_'ndic.flar to the electronic _IIico=rd fact at Indent at: 2.5" ' Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold i 1 . f I• r 'n �! circa_Ic i.i,ico rd -h suifsce ai� cf act --_--____— Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt .=i_3 a_ 1=i 212 sciwere ie i ' Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" f�:i i'r =:i �l�_IrCn.0 l;!IIIiCid %11 n :' zrt_ICC, are, Qf�_-,r Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 7'12 r11!are feet ii'Jt not more th=;l 3l8sduare feet ' Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ i , �.a (. Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,.. +Start i =i _ '_l __rG it i',_QJ=f 1. ?l u ri at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ ail '3 3 iCTL_!in _I7•rreti'_'.ili I `_l!'(efe- Indent at: 2.5" Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" 3='9 f`_• i r :' l "oc'tic1.:• oc rcl - Formatted:Indent:Hanging: 0.19", t;-!^n 6;. Numbered+Level:1+Numbering Style:i,ii, +Start at: 1+Alignment:Right+Aligned at: 1.5"+Indent at: 1.75" ' Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt • U_ D l o C i c'/ C e i:C U Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold ' Electronic bliiboar_ds Tray not be illuminated or l,t, c?t:', an the incurs cf' I Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ midnight and 6 ant if the./ are located in. Cr within 600 eel of. a , Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,...+Start'" ,_ at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ residential, rn xed-U= 'l+d0 'nt0':'ill, SUC_i { :Us ine isti;e- Dus - D - Indent at: 2.5" Gateway. Neighborhood Commercial. on-rni..nii'/ EusTess, C" - - , ' Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt Ccmmun' / ''Shorina Cienter zoning district, — Formatted:Indent:Left: 1.25" • Controls Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt 1- Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt I. i'iI .'. ..C=rn.i,isicr's sn?.l be eduioc�U- --iil c1;1_.'- ;'ri.ai,� :i.iriimer - - - =_ -- - --- • -- Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt control cr other mechanism that euto aitic2','1 C;ntrcls tin?, _ n'_ - Cfirli;tn'_ and i_ ,, Formatted:Indent:Left: 1",Numbered+ s d s c'a'/ !period as provided._d _ , _ Level:5+Numbering Style:a,b,c,..+Start at:1+Alignment:Left+Aligned at: 2.25"+ Prior t0 a r,Crc',i or env C erm i for t0 ,eera.'. an e'se-troci,o _ ,pl Indent at: 2.5",Tab stops: 1.25" Left, the 2CC!'Cant shall certif./that the 5 on h'0S been t estc'i aril — -- Formatted:Font:Helvetica,12 pt,Not Bold complies%' tt. the motion. c;, ='I fir.> r :r= rind „I Formatted:Font:(Default)Helvetica,12 pt rsc'-i;rernerlts h I. i h_ er an j!nr cf�,n n -n e.n:n'lc l rercrt to the city certifying theih ' s. corciti.es motion C'. =_I time, b;i-ih'iness.--_' .j i. _f I _ = her:: Formatted:List Paragraph • !.:V. Landscaping In Residential And Commercial CN And CB Zoning Districts: Properties in any residential zone and commercial CN or CB zones on which a billboard is the only structure shall be landscaped as required by sections 21 A 26 020 and 21A.23 030 and chapter 21A.48 of this title, or its successor chapter. No portion of such property shall be hard or gravel surfaced. Landscaping In Other Zoning Districts: Property in all districts other than as specified in subsection ':!-S of this section, or its successor subsection, upon which a billboard is the only structure, shall be landscaped from the front of the property to the deepest interior point of the billboard for fifty(50) linear feet along the street frontage distributed, to the maximum extent possible, evenly on each side of the billboard. Xeriscape Alternative: If all the properties adjacent to and across any street from the property for which billboard landscaping is required pursuant to subsection V of this section, or its successor subsection, are not developed or, if a water line for irrigation does not exist on the property or in the street right of way adjacent to such property, the zoning administrator may authorize Xeriscaping as an alternative for the required landscaping. "Y. Existing Billboard Landscaping: Existing billboards shall comply with the landscaping provisions of this section on or before January 1, 1996. %. Compliance With Tree Stewardship Ordinance: Construction, demolition or . maintenance of billboards shall corn ply with the provisions of the Salt Lake City tree stewardship ordinance-_ ZAA. Subdivision Registration: To the extent that the lease or other acquisition of land for the sjte•of a new billboard may be determined to be a subdivision pursuant to state statute no subdivision plat shall be required and the zoning administrator is authorized to approve, make minor subsequent amendments to, and record as necessary, such subdivision. __D. Special Provisions: 1.Applicability: The provisions of this section shall apply to specified billboards located: a. Four(4) existing billboards between 1500 North and 1800 North adjacent to the APIs west side of Interstate 15; and b. One existing billboard on the east side of Victory Road at approximately 1100 North. 2. General Applicability: Except as modified by this section, all other provisions of this chapter shall apply to the five (5) specified billboards. 3. Special Priority: The five (5) specified billboards shall be considered as gateway billboards for the purposes of the priority provisions of subsection F of this section, or its successor subsection. 4. Landscaping: The five (5) specified billboards shall be landscaped pursuant to the provisions of subsection ^: of this section, or its successor subsection. -2ECC. State Mandated Relocation Of Billboards: Except as otherwise authorized herein, existing billboards may not be relocated except as mandated by the requirements of Utah state law. (Ord. 72-08 § 2, 2008: Ord. 42-08 § 12, 2008: Ord. 13-04 §§25, 26, 27, 2004: Ord. 25-00 §§ 1-3, 2000: Ord. 83-98 §§ 12-14, 1998: Ord. 88-95§ 1 (Exh.A), 1995) March 3. '_01 1 Salt lake City Planning Commission Michelle Poland Dear members oldie Salt Lake City Planning Commission: (Inclosed you v"ill find a first draft of the lndustry's proposal for a new Off-Premises Sign Ordinance. I-his draft will be a starting point for discussions on this very complicated issue. I he Industry would like to discuss this drab and a(ioogle Earth interactive map that the Industry has created to study this issue with the Planning Committee at another Off-Premises Sign Subcommittee meeting. 1 he Industry feels that another Subcommittee nteetina ould be the best platform to do this given the complexities at the issue and the amount tat time it t\ill take to review the map. I have not enclosed the map herein due to the fact it is impossible to explain hog: it works in \\riling and. instead. needs to be reviewed in person, The lndustr' uill brine this draft and the map to the Planning Commission meeting \\"ednesday. March and if the Planning Commission desires. the Industry can present both items at that time as an alternati.c. I lowever. it sill take approximately one hour at a minimum to do so. In closing.as you review the provisions of this first draft regarding Placement. I leis lit and Spacing. please be conscious of the fact that it is only a first drabI and it is probable the Industry has failed to consider all of the issues related to the elements described above, Consequently.the Industry understands the need for additional discussions and.in all likelihood. changes to this :iocunie ra. \'cry truly \ours. i I / Dewey A. Reagan 1),'\R Idc Off-premises signs.--Billboards. INDUSTRY DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES. A. Purpose This section provides for the reasonable regulation of off-premises signs v.ith the intent of enhancing the aesthetics of existing and future billboards B. Cap on the amount of Off-Premises Sign square footage The amount of oft-premises sign square footage allowed in Sall Lake City shall be limited to the amount of off-premises sign square footage existing on Salt Lake City streets and or any square footage deposited in the Sall Lake City Off-Premises Sign Bank as defined herein as of March 2,2011 C. Location Off-premises Signs shall be allowed in the CS.CC,CD,GMU.M•1 and M-2 zones as a permitted use irrespective of overlay zoning,and the CB zone as a conditional use Size Off-premises signs that not exceed six hundred seventy-two square feet in the CS,CC.CG GMU-M-1 and M-2 zones Off-premises signs located in a CB zone shall not exceed three hundred square feet in size E. Height The maximum height of an off-prerises sign shall be forty-five feet above the grade of the street in a CE,CS.CC,CG,GMU M-1 and M-2 zone.unless oriented for freeway viewing only and located within three hundred feet of the nearest freeway lane of 1-15,I.215 1.80 west of 1.15 or the 21st South Expressway west of 1.15 When oriented to the afore mentioned routes the ntaxinium height of an off-premises sign shall be twenty-five feel above freeway grade level or sixty-five feet overall,whichever is greater Which height shall be extended by the overall height measured at the highest point of any sound wall.traffic or pedestrian safety barrier erected ay a mun•cipality county or agency of the state F. Separation The minimum distance between off-premises signs larger than three hundred square feet shall be five hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections The minimum distance between off-premises signs three hundred square feet or less in size shall be three hundred lineal feet as measured along the same side of the street including intersections All off-premises signs must be at least one hundred fifty radial feast trcrn any other off ,ry premises sign G. Setbacks l he minimum setback shalt be eighteen inches for oft-premises signs The sign's front- yard and side yard setback shall be measured from the right-of-way line The closest edge of an off-premises sign shall not protect into any required setback area 1 he minimum setback between an off-premises sign and any residential zone boundary shall be one hundred fifty fee! H. Lighting Lighting shall he confined to the ago face.and the ti_iht.nq source shall not he directly visible Design Off.premrsrrs signs shale utilize either the"mono-pole' or tlr "hi•pole"design and sr,si;tic continually maintained structurally and on the copy face inc back of the sign and the structure behind the sign shall be painted a care.color J. Credits for Removal Firm to the removal el any offLpremrses sign the owner snail cbta'n r;:rn-•it for the demolition of the off premises sign Permits may be provided following app'ication to the S;a" Lake Cray Planning Division After any off premises sign is deniotishod the Salt Lake City Relining Division shall create a'bikboard bank account`for the sign owner Tile account shad reflect meets for the off premises sign square footage as well as the date of removal Any off iPleln,Ses sign credits not used within forty-eight months of their creation shall expire and be of no further value Or use An oft-premises sign owner may sell or otherwise transfer off-premises signs andlor billboard bank account credits The transfer of any billboard bank account credits does not extend their thirty-six-month life as provided in this section Demolition of an off•piemises sign that has t�vc: advertising faces shall receive billboard baa account credits for the equine footage of each sign face AtilltAk . .. • / ) SALT LAKE CITY -\\\_--•- II 1.1111,111.117. 1 I 1. !L..,,. ... IP I 11 1111116. \1 1 111.11 \ke F7rill 1 1 OFFICIAL BILLBOARD _ I1COSORTH 4 3. E V al fad,' 11 r Il 1 Artt ..• 1 1 1 y im „,...ii ,,,.... .0 • AND GATEWAY MAP IND ailing NM=EN . • U--I-- -,-,- Aill.11111111111111 ..,g ( !:-.r.,, lk .‘ , friptiRit ,77:5;--.;c,r, ,I ,.,,,.1 lid iiilifflo, :: ,,z.A., ,_17.1 :41Li 11,1iniii. \it, _..• L i L-..--if,2 _ A .11:"Iil= III I lVII-l -; ';(1111r1111,5)17_7*iiitill'al":, ,, ii , •' 1:,:bem It .....10.F.ro Oka!! ...m. .,s.,..., , — . . Ha . 1.11-1M111.1111,1111SIBEREM Mari I I IN It. 0.,:in r,f,m r 7A'F V.:11 461/4-001 )-- - iii. --lumen-nen Irataieslatir kii7A;t1:1;N• ' . .,, I ,edier-1 IIMISTATE BOIMIIIIrrit: lim . ( am , 1 , .NEM CIL •IIRIUP,.:• 11 n,.. ...... ..,.. „ Itill.". j. ;--"RP ;;;; - rr- - ,,AOMaidil ...lifi-I !.,.72.,.III 2.1 r ENE• a L' 1t.11:114.:A.14 :;:" -; 0 - ,„_,(14 ' -41,11P AmmEggiwo--, 200,011ME EMprOrmismammtm‘l. ,s0a,/, • ztil-- -' 311 10E1E1E11 WIliiielip,11Filiiilliiir.;1111, 1 2.57.1llunifir ,, opt-:.,itimmigmEniNimaniii rm ANNINE- iiiiiih, Ills - z ei liniaintEmzito al , -,,,, . i . 4. il r75..4111.7. IIL_ !k- ,% li_ t4)4E;E:24:10!!!!Avigaso rum•a rflii..m. -t_zi s-_0•Y., liftr-!---" 1 It:1 - „1,11,16litrigi&-.-,a,- MIL_ ,11,1.=:-4,=__1, Ulla. 411111C1111 EOM II MiCall!,11111111.,,1.1. la rlD Ili_go - .3 . ,H ne,:SPINV. 11.1..._.,.211__Itgli. _•Eiki commons' .0MI.V. FA li,111111d ,, , \''-.111 _. -MAL2i1.:41 d ir EON a 111,11 ER..III 71 I AI gil L T i HMO 311111111 7. 't t .- Ill '_ Alinli41 .1. --i,t,_;'4 6174" ;i17-"gre"'E-T4 qD0iifinlliiil g H11111114 II!I II ff_41,IIIIPM111* ..., -.....1.,1•1''''"'' c, i 'Ir cilt.11...[MINIIiii ti Jan bfk,ittaiallif-'1 -..,,!R MN. Liigzil a BILK!!ji,q,nmal 11_1 _•%urc.0:-.A4.,:A•hi.!7:1 _ r [ 1 iimmimourNAF.1 41"kl. liflimot Tr \--,...i.-01=iii.il . 4,7-4;1;1 lloilinio.r.aw.F--zimies. . la, - . 1,_•1*-4., il,kr .:Jriti,„%lin- , 1 :4::_4-=-416, .!=mfreilg. nii.11i-i-1_=,70.m=ir...t . 1 iii .m_._ ..,....„ -1,1A- iii -°'' --4-. l - ?Ill i170iiil .111•116-0iit'=1.4111111111411i-E-.z.-izia:gfEzi11111..ig"6-17-31.‘=„,. Wid - MI 6 1111111:11A 4'3..1'2'611 il 11111-11 I[IS I • y . . .... 1 , - -;,,:' „,1- ...1,-,.........=„7,1.--. ......- .—.rtracm=r,--t-z-vor p 11"411 61 , gir.. - 41...N.L Y . _---- I - "mm. - I 11.11511 1 11 III W 1,101_, 1 411'47 Ir.; T, I Ha-WM 2dd •iim... -:- -"-•--- " . / , -,„. .0. s\ . ii -,-- .--- ------ . . _ ...- - ..1,......merm.. .74,-.14------ 4 Legend ,,_...._ v, ..1 1 __:7711inglimR_Till_ ..,L_ '71.11.1.101104, -1-s--.4\, ref, imnpirjrialikil r-,u, II 1 i .__,1,‘ . . .11 N litilivoi;11 1 1;14,:%vi II 1 n _ . -4, 04010 — Gateway I iiiJR, -: iillIlIl 1111.1111111 - ----, meinniviomitirma4 W—50—E ,ip .1,...,..411......-. u -- Special Gateway .... 1,1111 MI pbril,11\!:1;1=.11111 '''" June 2001 S '0 Billboards Permitted 3300 SOUTH r 14: i I r , ..,---i-t 1_,I :,4J ti i_r-t jl1.l r / - r 71..7� I F!G (O,_ - 1-4 —. 5 , 'Tr'"- I LN II T ' I` r ,t .--a ,- , I s_ -i ,: :-1----,!:1-÷ftii-i:-:-;,--'• '4:1:- • ! .I2.4.L._i_.-27.-nl-frit:L-q'Tri ' -14 1 ' I- •-r-7-'--t :-1 III 1 :-,I_- µ=.T! -r! .. r { �e I RIM I _ ,,,i. a, pi t i ii 1" V i - " 1.. _�.J• an -II I 4'O i ' i Ir..� Hi ' —I r ..� n-i I _ -I i T, Tci— I t . II 7'-o I r � v -t' t P ^O I L { r -~--'I -; —j 1 1 I t•i f'T -1 c "+LLL � t"rr . I I 10 ,,iri i, S:ft1.X�- I _C_ - I I rJ T 1,-. w` 1. _I ,I / O i ' - i of ) j, _ ni ____. ,::,, — , . _ ,..„__, , 1 , ..._ _ — o N ' I O^ i' _ .__.. ._.._..l_. !n S I _ I I C - r a iY,if 1— r J a a 7. __ U G m •I = 4CC 0 Z -�y — .. 03 N- N C Z O �O1 O V ( 2 2 U' 1 J s I RiI_II I 0 0 SALT LAKE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA In Room 326 of the City&County Building at 451 South State Street Wednesday,January 26,2011 at 7:00 p.m.or immediately following the Work Session The field trip is scheduled to leave at 4:00 p.m. Dinner will be served to the Planning Commissioners and Staff at 5:00p.m. in Room 126. Work Session: 5:30 in Room 326. The Planning Commission will hold a work session from approximately 5:30- 6:30. During the Work Session the Planning Staff will brief the Planning Commission on pending projects, discuss project updates and minor administrative matters. This portion of the meeting is open to the public for observation. PLNPCM2011-00015: Yalecrest Local Historic District Designation—A request by the Historic Landmark Commission, pursuant to a request from the Yalecrest Yes Heritage Preservation Committee,to amend the Salt Lake City Zoning Map, in accordance with the standards of chapter 21A.34.020 and chapter 21A.50.050 of the City Ordinance, and establish an H Historic Preservation Overlay District for the Yalecrest neighborhood which is located generally between 800 South/Sunnyside Avenue and 1300 South,from 1300 East to 1900 East. The area is located in City Council District 5 represented by Jill Remington Love and District 6 represented by JT Martin. (Staff contact:Carl Leith at(801)535-7758 or carl.leith@slcgov.com.) PLNPCM2010-00665: Yalecrest Compatible Infill Overlay(YCI) and Historic Preservation Overlay(H)Amendment —A request by Jodi Howick in behalf of the Yalecrest Preservationists for Property Rights for amendment of the Salt Lake City Code to establish a voluntary development review process and modify certain provisions of the YCI District, and amend the procedure to establish an H District. The amendment will affect sections 21A.34.120 and 21A.34.020 of the zoning ordinance. Related provisions of Title 21A-Zoning may also be amended as part of this petition. (Staff contact: Michael Maloy at (801)535-7118 or michael.maloy@slcgov.com). • Approval of Minutes • Report of the Chair and Vice Chair • Report of the Director • Public Hearings 7:00 or immediately following the work session Public Hearing(Administrative Petition) 1. PLNPCM2010-00760: Deseret First Credit Union Conditional Use—A request by Gary Gower for conditional use approval for an expansion of the office building located at 147 North 200 West in the R-MU (Residential Mixed Use)and RMF-35 (Moderate Density Multi-Family Residential) zoning districts and in Council District 3, represented by Stan Penfold. (Staff contact: Katia Pace at 801-535-6354 or katia.paceCaslcg ov.com) Issues Only(Legislative Petitions) 2. Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment,Transit Shelter Advertising-A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie@slcgov.com) 3. PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment, Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards.The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie@slcgov.com) 4. PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards-A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently,the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards.The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie@slcgov.com) The files for the above items are available in the Planning Division offices, room 406 of the City and County Building. Please contact the staff planner for information, Visit the Planning Division's website at www.slcgov.com/CED/planning for copies of the Planning Commission agendas,staff reports, and minutes. Staff Reports will be posted the Friday prior to the meeting and minutes will be posted two days after they are ratified, which usually occurs at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Planning Commission. Planning Commission Meetings may be watched live on SLCTV Channel 17;past meetings are recorded and archived, and may be viewed at www.slctv.com SALT LAKE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA In Room 326 of the City & County Building at 451 South State Street Wednesday, February 23, 2011 at 6:00 p.m. or immediately following the Work Session The field trip is scheduled to leave at 4:00 p.m. Dinner will be served to the Planning Commissioners and Staff at 5:00p.m. in Room 126. Work Session: 5:30 in Room 326. The Planning Commission will hold a work session from approximately 5:30-6:00. During the Work Session the Planning Staff will brief the Planning Commission on pending projects, discuss project updates and minor administrative matters. This portion of the meeting is open to the public for observation. Briefing O PLNPCM2010-00612 Accessory Dwelling Unit - A request by Mayor Ralph Becker for a zoning text amendment to allow accessory dwelling units within single-family and multi-family residential districts. This request is part of the Sustainability Code Amendment Project. (Staff contact: Michael Maloy at 801-535-7118 or michael.maloy@slcgov.com.) • Approval of Minutes • Report of the Chair and Vice Chair ▪ Report of the Director • Public Hearings 6:00 or immediately following the work session Public Hearing Legislative Petitions 1. PLNSUB2009-01424 Public Safety Building Zoning Amendment: a request by Salt Lake City Corporation to amend the zoning of the properties associated with the new Public Safety Building project. The zoning map would be amended to show zoning of Transit Corridor (TC-75) along 400 South and Public Lands (PL-2) for the southern portion of the property. Also, an amendment to the text of the Public Lands districts (PL, PL-2) would allow for a communication tower to exceed building height only when it is government owned and operated for public safety purposes. This request applies to various properties within the block bounded by 400 South and 500 south, 300 East and 400 East, in Council District 4 represented by Luke Garrott. (Staff contact: Casey Stewart at 801-535-6260 or casey.si.ewar , slcgov.com) 2. Petition 400-06-51: Zoning Text Amendment, Transit Shelter Advertising - A request for a zoning text amendment to address advertising on Bus Shelters. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie @slcgov.com) 3. PLNPCM2010-00032: Zoning Text Amendment, Billboards - A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address outdoor billboards. The proposed amendment would update current regulations for outdoor billboards to make them consistent with state law. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie @slcgov.com) 4. PLNPCM2010-00717: Zoning Text Amendment, Electronic Billboards - A request by Salt Lake City Mayor Becker for a zoning text amendment to address electronic billboards. Currently, the City Zoning Ordinance does not address electronic billboards. The text amendment would affect all zoning districts. (Staff contact: Doug Dansie at 801-535-6107 or doug.dansie @slcgov.com) The files for the above items are available in the Planning Division offices, room 406 of the City and County Building. Please contact the staff planner for information, Visit the Planning Division's website at www.slcgov.com/CED/planning for copies of the Planning Commission agendas,staff reports, and minutes.Staff Reports will be posted the Friday prior to the meeting and minutes will be posted two days after they are ratified, which usually occurs at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Planning Commission. Planning Commission Meetings may be watched live on SLCTV Channel 17;past meetings are recorded and archived, and may be viewed at www.slctv.com Remarks: Petition No: PLNPCM2010-00717 By: Salt Lake City Planning Zoning Text Amendment for Electronic Billboards Date Filed: October 21, 2010 Address: Citywide rLCvti'► zip 0c-,,,,,, ,,,, Petition Initiation --.4*\ -.`". u�'��, Re u e s t "-�1S/illl�il"`� �,"iI nm ,,,,, Planning Division Community&Economic Development Department To: Mayor Becker From: Wilf Sommerkorn, Planning Director y/ Date: October 21, 2010 CC: Frank Gray, Community and Economic Development Director; Mary De La Mare-Schaefer, Community & Economic Development Department Deputy Director; Cheri Coffey, Assistant Planning Director; file Re: Initiate Petition to amend the Sign Ordinance relating to Electronic Billboards This memo is to request that you initiate a petition requesting the Planning Division to analyze the appropriateness of amending various sections of the City's Sign Ordinance, Chapter 21A.46, relating to Electronic Billboards. The purpose of the request is to the revise the ordinance to address electronic billboards, which the ordinance is currently silent on and to analyze issue and impacts relating to electronic billboards, which may include a prohibition of electronic billboards in the City. As part of the process, the Planning Division will follow the City adoption process for zoning text amendments which includes citizen input and public hearings with the Planning Commission and City Council. If you have any questions, please contact me. Thank you. Concurrence to initiate the zoning text amendment petition as noted above. 3,6-o M/Z,91/0 Ralph Becker, Mayor Date © Page 1 MEMORANDUM DATE: March 16,2011 TO: City Council Members FROM: Russell Weeks RE: Proposed Ordinance Amendment: Providing On-Street Parking Spaces to Charge Electric Vehicles, Authorizing the Transportation Division to Set Time Limits for Charging Electric Vehicles,and Establishing Fines for Violations CC: Cindy Gust-Jenson,David Everitt,Frank Gray,Tim Harpst,Jennifer Bruno,Dan Bergenthal, Gordon Hoskins,Gina Chamness,Karen Halladay This memorandum pertains to proposed amendments to Salt Lake City Code sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550. The amendments would provide parking spaces for charging vehicles powered by electric batteries, restrict use of the spaces to"electric vehicles actively charging their battery at the provided electrical outlet,"and authorize the Transportation Division to set time limits for using the charging stations.Another amendment would establish fmes for motorists using the parking spaces designated as charging stations without actively charging their electric vehicles and for motorists that exceed designated time limits for using the spaces. The City Council is scheduled to hear a briefing on the proposed amendments at its March 22 work session. OPTIONS o Adopt the proposed amendments. o Do not adopt the proposed amendments. o Change the proposed amendments or adopt additional amendments. POTENTIAL MOTIONS o I move that the City Council adopt the ordinance amending Salt Lake City Code Section 12.56.205 and 12.56.550 that define electric vehicle charging stations,limit the use of charging stations to electric vehicles actually being charged, impose time limits for use of the stations,and establish a civil penalty for violations. o I move that the City Council consider the next item on the agenda. o I move that the City Council adopt the ordinance amending Salt Lake City Code Section 12.56.205 and 12.56.550 that define electric vehicle charging stations, limit the use of charging stations to electric vehicles actually being charged, impose time limits for use of the stations, and establish a civil penalty for violations with the following amendments: (Council Members may propose amendments they deem appropriate). 1 KEY POINTS o The proposed amendments would be added to Salt Lake City Code section 12.56.205 titled Parking Meters;No Charge for Alternative Fuel,Fuel Efficient,and Low Polluting Vehicles and City Code section 12.56.550 titled,Unauthorized Use of Streets,Parking Lots and Other Areas;Penalties. o The electrical charging stations already have been installed. o Installing the electrical charging stations is a pilot program funded by a federal grant.' o The Administration appears to be addressing points raised in an April 21,2009 Legislative Action Item pertaining to promoting the use of electric vehicles. o The proposed civil fine for violating the amendments would be$160--$50 if paid within 10 days.The fines appear to be consistent with the fine schedule listed in City Code section 15.56.550. ISSUES/QUESTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION If the City installs electrical charging stations at electronic parking pay stations,would the ordinance have to be amended again? BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION Earlier this year the Transportation Division installed charging stations for electric vehicles at five locations: • The Salt Lake City Main Library Parking Garage(Level P2) • 50 East 300 South(north side of road) • 135 South Main Street(east side of road) • Forest Dale Golf Course • Liberty Park(west side)2 The charging stations are equipped with 110/120-volt alternate current power outlets.However,the Main Library parking garage has a second charging station that carries a 220/240-volt power outlet.3 Independent of the City's program,Smith's grocery store at 876 East 800 South Street has installed an electrical charging station at its new gasoline fueling station.4 The Administration also forwarded to the City Council proposed amendments to Salt Lake City Code section 12.56.205 titled Parking Meters;No Charge for Alternative Fuel,Fuel Efficient,and Low Polluting Vehicles and City Code section 12.56.550 titled,Unauthorized Use of Streets,Parking Lots and Other Areas; Penalties.The amendments would limit designated electrical vehicle charging parking spaces to electric vehicles with batteries that are actively being charged.They also would allow the Transportation Division to impose time • limits on the use of the charging stations.According to the Administration transmittal letter,the Transportation Division is contemplating a two-hour limit at the parking spaces on public streets to allow the charging stations "to be utilized by multiple vehicles throughout the day." As noted earlier,the charging stations are a pilot program funded by a federal grant.The Administration also is exploring adding more charging stations.The City's request for proposals to provide electronic parking pay stations includes asking companies for proposals to provide the ability to install electric car charging stations in up to a fourth of the roughly 340 pay stations the City would acquire,according to Transportation Director Tim Harpst. The charging stations would be one of several options the City could add to an electronic pay station unit. A selection committee is reviewing the proposals received from the private sector. 2 The option raises one question: If the City installs more charging stations as part of installing electronic pay stations,would the proposed amendment restricting the use of a parking space to electrical vehicles that are being actively charged have to be revised to allow vehicles operating on different fuel to locate at a parking meter? It should be noted that a Legislative Action Item adopted by the City Council in April 2009 included three items in Part 1 of the Legislative Action: 1. Identify the location of available electric plug-in charging stations and include those locations on the alternative fueling stations database on the City website. 2. Look at the use of small grants/incentives to encourage business owners and or public entities to install electric vehicles outlets and signage for reserved parking available for electric vehicle use. 3. Investigate the possibility of incorporating plug in and/or pay per use systems when purchasing credit-card-reading parking meters. It appears that the pilot program and the request for proposals aim to fulfill the requests Nos.2 and 3 in the Legislative Action. In addition,the Transportation Division researching establishing a link to the U.S. Department of Energy's Internet web site to show alternative fuel fueling stations,including the electric charging stations.The link would be like the one provided on the Utah Clean Cities web site. 1 SLC gives a jolt to electric-vehicle push,The Salt Lake Tribune,February 9,2011,Derek P.Jensen. 2 E-mail,Dan Bergenthal,March 15,2011. 3 SLC gives a jolt to electric-vehicle push,The Salt Lake Tribune,February 9,2011,Derek P.Jensen. 4 E-mail,Dan Bergenthal,March 15,2011. 3 SLC gives a jolt to electric-vehicle push I The Salt Lake Tribune Page 1 of 6 - Blog a Prep Sports T �, —— i I. I2 5$ t ,i,ne,r,_ .,east x,S; I z ,ft.�:i ,, l)t,t butt`.,Wit't 1' 64UP 1 s= a ., g _-Ax Get Breaking Alerts via E-mail t•\ K " i > .. _ '� Sign up for Breaking News e-mail alerts from the Tribune. Y 4 our daily newsletter,or the latest updates from BYU,the Jazz,the Utah Utes and more.J Manage Exishno Settings 1 'a¢ 0 Breaking News(Jazz rtUtes lab ,,e„- ri ,t, In Top Stories 0 Cougars 0 Political Cornflakes„»_ .«s . st' Email:1 ( Up ! .' was _.....___._._.__._.___ .— *I LIVE PAIN FREE! �+ Click NOW for 2 Free Treatments f v, 7 ' lit •_ �.. _. , \.0 ,,, 17(ki4 . a . s -. �.r - e _..'t: 1. y a firi; . ... '.^,,I� 1 '4 w i f ' ! naueLtpe Y•reea{r/eM44 ! ► '� - - ,yrr 111SE13 CI: HTIAIS ' 800-PA'N-FR' S.,! "" "i <, ---- --..,1 - ". (Chris Detrick I The Salt Lake Tribune)Hans Jorgensen Irons on his electric 1950 Volkswagen Rabbit truck at Liberty Most Popular Stories Par 1. Mysterious meeting follows Jazz loss to Boozer& Bulls SLC gives a jolt to electric- 2. BTU's rock show still rolling 3. West Jordan teen found dead In field over weekend push 4. Discussion between Sloan,O'Connor explained as ve •aleheat-of-the-moment occurrence 5. SLC planners reject planned Wal-Mart on Parleys Way 6. Grand Canyon may see more'grand flushes' Six free charging BY ThB Salt°EREKe TJribune 7. Parents want compensation after student slices off fingers at school stations Come First published Feb 07 2011 03:56PM 6. Cougars crush Air Force at sold-out Clune Arena online,along with Updated Feb 9,2011 07:01PM 9. Utah's undocume streak v driver cards targeted 10.Aggles'win streak over more energy- Plug-ins may still reference household air fresheners,but across Salt Lake City efficient streetlights. they represent a new opportunity to keep the outside air a little more fresh. K, Article Tools Tire city has added six free charging stations for electric vehicles—stretching :k. from Liberty Park to Forest Dale Golf Course to downtown's showcase Main °.. � ' )•'•`- i-t T=: 1i 4, i e 1 Si,?t't ie t5 i l `arn library.All but one are the lower,no-volt plugs,which won't quickly juice a �'f,`'it C U I'b'=S P a Comments(13) modern electric vehicle.Most take at least six hours to power.But the stations are a E-mail this story perfect for"topping off,"perhaps while drivers are visiting the library,golfing or Printer-friendly version doing a little downtown shopping. Photos The portals are timed for the arrival of newly manufactured electric cars,expected , LIRA to hit the area market in the next six months1011 "As more residents commit to purchasing alternative vehicles,we feel compelled to support them,'says Lisa Harrison Smith,spokeswoman for Mayor Ralph Becker."Adding charging stations around town was a sensible step to making it easier for owners of EVs." th area gets a The grant-funded pilot program allows each station to be metered separately so tt §lance electricity use can be tracked.Smith notes the electricity charge to the city is Besides the citys six new "nominal,'and transportation officials say the stations themselves cost only$Soo charging stations,Smith's apiece. has added a free electric- car outlet at its new fuel Besides Liberty and the library(which also has a stronger,240-volt outlet), station at 876 iet seo owners of. stations are available at Forest Dale,r S.Main and at o E. oo South. The Idea is to owners of 35 S 3 electric cars"top off'at the courtesy station while they The idea was floated two years ago by City Councilman Soren Simonsen,who took shop.Smith's also has his cue from a devoted u of electric-car owners. Installed equipment at the group new station to harness solar http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/neighborhoodcity/51193304-135/electric-statio... 2/10/2011 SLC gives a jolt to electric-vehicle push I The Salt Lake Tribune Page 2 of 6 power and to distribute "They really helped put together this proposal,"Simonsen says. natural gas Find us on Facebook Story oonbnun6 below ttil Latest In Utah News The Salt Lake Tribune a Reams bookkeeper =- _ • Like e Gun-permit change charged With passes Utah Legislature g _ - H Posted 17 minutes ago stealing about$44K i 2,399 people like The Salt Lake Tribune. si e New Broadway-style Published Feb 8,2011 `' ,. theater opens In 11:51 s12AM�l 10 Comments - Costed 1lle Latter-day , , ` Posted hour ago -- - `< .K-'1 lampooner helps Brrky Cathy Mart, Adam Maggie a Grand Canyon may see M laugh - more'grand Mormons flushes' g "` Posted 1 hour ago themselves - - In s SLC planners reject Published Feb a,2011 _k_ _ ..- ]E planned Wal-Mart on 11:21:30AM n 218 Comments Way Friends mourn Mary v Parleys _ - Sarah Mn Dann Knitlln left Posted 1 hour ago _ passing of pianist, f y ' v. 46"4 ,4 ' a West Jordan teen found ;.r dead In field over LDS youth leader , -,,, =�,;;. -".-� weekend Published Feb 7,2011 ^?jm'" ;i. Recent Activity Posted 1 hour ago 10:09:38PM or 1 Comments e Feds end mobster's Sign Up Create an account or log in to see what rural southern Idaho your friends are doing. escape At the same time,the new stations have limits.Simonsen notes they are akin to Posted 1 hour ago most wall"plug-ins,"saying they best serve home-conversion vehicles and older .. `w..e, SIC planners reject planned Walmart on e Ogden makes plea for plug-in hybrids.State-of-the-industry EVs would use the stations mainly to top ,a4RF,. Parleys Way I The Salt Lake Tribune RAMP funds for Field off - - 22 people shared this. House Posted 1 hour ago Feds end mobster's rural southern Idaho +Show all Utah News "This will kind of be yesterday's technology,"says Simonsen,who sometimes escape I The Salt Lake Tribune stories rides a scooter and admired the transit systems spanning Northern Europe while 8 people shared this. serving a Mormon mission there."It's kind of a modest start." House committee skins Ode's feral cat bill Besides addressing electric cars,city officials have been busy swapping out traffic- I The Salt Lake Tribune 52 people shared this. light bulbs and many streetlights with more energy-efficient LED lights.The upgrade was funded with federal stimulus,awarded through the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant program. ©Facebook soda)plugln J The move will reduce the city's electricity use by 8O6,O0o kilowatts a year, according to transportation executives,and will save$123,Ooo annually.In recent years,the city has made similar LED upgrades on traffic signals,saving taxpayers about$140,000 a year. Renee Zollinger,the city's environmental program manager,notes 1,337 meek, streetlights have been replaced,and all of the traffic signals are now done.The conversion,she says,will be noticeable to drivers. "They give a much better light,"Zollinger says,"a much crisper light.People will t3et a't►uote' definitely notice the difference.We use about a third of the energy we used so years ago;the difference is phenomenal." There are no plans for additional charging stations as yet,but that may change The right c a r depending on the success of the pilot program. insurance can Energy-conscious consumers have balked at the high prices of electric cars.The i save you more hyped Chevrolet Volt is expected to retail at$41,000.Still,buyers are eligible for than you think, $7,50o in federal tax credits,while a handful of states offer additional rebates up to$5,000. l � Next Page a including an average of Copyright 2011 The Salt Lake Tribune.All rights reserved.This material may not be published, broadcast,rewritten or redistributed. jQ' 53._ JazzPublic Safety Utah News West Jordan SLC planners teen found dead reject planned in field over Wal-Mart on TRAVELERS) weeke... Parle ys... 4 32 Comments et 70 Comments 3 people liked this. II Add New Comment L J Required:Please login below to comment. i Top Jobs O Salt Lake Tribune r— — — —— — Aiiik 1 http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/neighborhoodcity/51193304-13 5/electric-statio... 2/10/2011 (`�1 SLC COVNc, C „ FRANK B. GRAY vr� ' ,�1`�aJl��l �~I�`'_ ' �" � DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPME CEfVED � OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR NNt^:�Y DE LA MARE-SCHAEFER O NOV �1U DEPUTY DIRECTOR �I ROBERT FARR JR. Salt Lake Ci Mayor DEPUTY DIRECTORECTOR CITY COUNCIL TRANSMITTAL SCANNED! TO: .1bY. SCANNED BY:lc Date ReceQEl t ' lD David E rift, Chief Staff Date sent to Council: l l C, ',Q 1 D TO: Salt Lake City Council DATE: November 1, 2010 JT Martin, Chair _ FROM: Frank Gray, Director Community &Economic De ment SUBJECT: An Ordinance Amending Sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550 Salt Lake City Code, defining electric vehicle charging stations, limiting their use to electric vehicles being actively charged, and establishing a civil penalty for violations. STAFF CONTACT: Tim Harpst, Transportation Director, 801-535-7148 Dan Bergenthal, Transportation Engineer, 801-535-7106 DOCUMENT TYPE: Ordinance RECOMMENDATION: That the City Council schedule a briefing and hold a public hearing BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: In 2005, Salt Lake City passed ordinance 12.56.205 to encourage the use of"Green Vehicles." This ordinance allows alternative fuel, fuel efficient and low polluting vehicles to park for free at Salt Lake City parking meters. The use of these types of vehicles helps the City to reduce our dependence on foreign oil and improve air quality which is consistent with the City's goal of creating a greener, more sustainable, and environmentally friendly city. In a further effort to promote the use of"Green Vehicles",the City is installing electric vehicle charging stations at five parking stalls within the City. These stalls will provide a standard 120 volt, 20 amp outlet to recharge many models of electric vehicles. Parking in the stalls will be restricted to electric vehicles actively charging their battery by use of the provided electrical outlet. The five electric vehicle parking stalls are located as follows: 1. Salt Lake City Main Library Parking Garage 2. 50 East 300 South(north side of road) 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 404 P.O. BOX 1454E16, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 04114-5466 TELEPHONE: B01-535.6230 FAX: B01.535-6005 WWW.SLCGOV.COM/CED ♦ ncerceo vnrcn 3. 135 South Main Street(east side of road)— - - , 4. Forest Dale Golf Course 5. Liberty Park(west side) The on-street stalls will have a two-hour time limit allowing them to be utilized by multiple vehicles throughout the day. The City envisions these charging station parking stalls to be the first of many installed to support new models of electric vehicles being produced by auto manufacturers. Salt Lake City ordinances allow the Transportation Division to create restricted parking zones/spaces and to place specific time limits on parking. However, restricting the use of a parking space to vehicles that are actively charging their battery by use of a provided electrical outlet is currently not addressed. The ordinance additions in Attachment A are proposed to allow the City to enforce this new parking provision. The fine for parking in an electrical vehicle charging station parking stall for more than two hours,parking without actively charging, parking by a non-electric powered vehicle or a vehicle not capable of being charged by a standard 120 volt outlet, is proposed as $50 if paid within ten days. As a comparison, other similar city parking penalties include: Action Penalty Allowing a parking meter to expire while parked $15 Parking unlawfully in a freight or loading zone $30 Parking unlawfully in a handicapped parking stall $150 Parking unlawfully within an electrical vehicle charging station parking stall $50 (Proposed) Ordinance No. of 2010 (Amending Sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550, Salt Lake City Code, defining electric vehicle charging stations, limiting their use to electric vehicles being actively charged, and establishing a civil penalty for violations.) An ordinance amending Sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550,Salt Lake City Code, defining electric vehicle charging stations, limiting their use to electric vehicles being actively charged, imposing a two hour limit for use, and establishing a civil penalty for violations. WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Council approved Ordinance No. 82 of 2005, enacting Section 12.56.205 of the Salt Lake City Code to encourage the use of alternative fuel, fuel efficient, and low polluting vehicles by permitting such vehicles to park for free at Salt Lake City parking meters. WHEREAS,the use of these types of vehicles helps to improve air quality within the City and to reduce dependence on foreign oil,which is consistent with the City's goal of creating a greener, more sustainable, and environmentally friendly city. WHEREAS, certain electric vehicles must be recharged regularly, and lack of charging stations outside of the vehicle owner's home limit the range over which the vehicle may be used. WHEREAS, the City wishes to encourage the use of electric vehicles by providing charging stations within the City that may be used by multiple vehicles each day. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah, as follows: SECTION 1. That the following sections of the Salt Lake City Code be amended as follows: 12.56.205: PARKING METERS; NO CHARGE FOR ALTERNATIVE FUEL, FUEL EFFICIENT AND LOW POLLUTING VEHICLES: i;L l ( 1 kit- V"I.i i I( I T. ( i t \Etc s'l .t"i ltly,,: A. The following definitions shall apply to this section: ALTERNATIVE FUEL: Propane, compressed natural gas, electricity, or any motor or special fuel that meets the clean fuel vehicle standards in the federal clean air act amendments of 1990, title II, as amended. ALTERNATIVE FUEL VEHICLE: A vehicle with an engine powered full or part time by an alternative fuel. CLEAN FUEL LICENSE PLATE: A special group license plate issued by the Utah department of motor vehicles as authorized by Utah code 41-1a-418, or its successor. DIVISION: The city's transportation division. li \ i t k t t ; � ,. I•,f ` h 1 nin. \\im iill �l:'•_tii ii FUEL EFFICIENT VEHICLE: A vehicle that is powered by gasoline or diesel that achieves a city driving fuel efficiency of forty one(41) or more miles per gallon. LOW POLLUTING VEHICLE: A vehicle that achieves an environmental protection agency (EPA)air pollution score of at least eight(8)on the EPA vehicle rating scale of zero to ten (10). B. 1. The division shall issue a vehicle windshield sticker to all persons applying for such sticker who provide evidence acceptable to the division that the vehicle for which the sticker is desired is a "fuel efficient vehicle" or a "low polluting vehicle" as defined in subsection A of this section. Motorcycles and other vehicles that are not automobiles shall not be issued a sticker pursuant to this section. 2. The recipient of the sticker shall affix it only to the bottom of the driver's side of the rear window of the vehicle for which it is issued so that it is readily visible. C. Parking meter spaces may be used without charge on all days of the week at all hours by vehicles properly displaying the sticker referred to in subsection B of this section or vehicles displaying a clean fuel license plate. D.No person parking a vehicle without charge pursuant to this section shall park or permit such vehicle to remain parked in any parking meter space adjacent to a meter for a continuous period longer than that designated on the meter, nor shall they park in restricted spaces pursuant to section 12.56.180 of this chapter. E. In assessing the evidence provided by an applicant for such sticker as set forth in subsection B 1 of this section,the division may consider: 1. The fuel efficiency information for particular years and models of vehicles determined by the department of energy and the environmental protection agency as shown on their website at www.fueleconomy.gov or its successor website; and 2. The EPA's annual "Green Vehicle Guide" as found at the website www.epa.gov/greenvehicles or its successor website. of electric vchicle ciiat'_liL' station-, Is restricted to electric vehicles activel`: cliitplint! their hattei\ at the provided electrical outlet. I he di+,ision ma\ establish time limits for use of " itictilar electric chaiaainl stations. No person shall use an electric \chicle clitirctne' station for I0th Cr than the tithe period specified for that station. Failure to coinpl', ith this result in a cix it r;enalty as set forth in Section f 2.56.550 of this code. 2 12.56.550: UNAUTHORIZED USE OF STREETS,PARKING LOTS AND OTHER AREAS; PENALTIES: A. Violation: 1. Any person engaging in the unauthorized use of streets,parking lots or other areas as provided under this chapter, within the city, shall be liable for a civil penalty. Any penalty assessed in subsection B of this section may be in addition to such other penalties as may be provided in this title. 2. "Unauthorized use of streets" means a violation of any restriction or prohibition contained in this chapter or its successor. B. Civil Penalties: Civil penalties shall be imposed as follows: Section Of This Chapter Penalty 12.56.040 $140 .00 12.56.050 135 .00 12.56.080 150 .00 12.56.100 135 .00 12.56.110 135 .00 12.56.120 260 .00 12.56.130 260 .00 12.56.150 125 .00 12.56.180 135 .00 12.56.190 125 .00 12.56.210 135 .00 3 12.56.235 135 .00 12.56.240 140 .00 12.56.250 135 .00 12.56.290 135 .00 12.56.300 140 .00 12.56.302 125 .00 12.56.303 125 .00 12.56.304 125 .00 12.56.310 140 .00 12.56.330 140 .00 ,044, 12.56.350 135 .00 12.56.360 140 .00 12.56.380 140 .00 12.56.390 135 .00 12.56.400 135 .00 12.56.410 135 .00 12.56.420 140 .00 12.56.430 135 .00 12.56.4401 135 .00 AiNk 4 12.56.440A5 147 .00 12.56.440A19 260 .00 12.56.450 125 .00 12.56.460 140 .00 12.56.465 192 .00 12.56.470 140 .00 12.56.480 140 .00 12.56.490 140 .00 12.56.500 140 .00 12.56.515 135 .00 12.56.520 135 .00 12.56.525 135 .00 Note: 1.With the exception of subsections 12.56.440A5 and A19. C. Reduction Of Penalties: The civil penalties specified in subsection B of this section shall be subject to the following: 1. Any penalty that is paid within ten (10) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of one hundred ten dollars($110.00). 2. Any penalty that is paid within twenty (20) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of seventy dollars ($70.00). 3. Any penalty that is paid within thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of forty dollars ($40.00). 5 D. Receipt Of Notice: As used in this section, "receipt of notice" means the affixing of a notice to the vehicle alleged to have been employed in such unauthorized use, or by delivery of such notice to the owner or driver thereof. E. Other Fees And Assessments: A forty five dollar($45.00) administrative fee shall be assessed for the city's cost of collecting past due debts. SECTION 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon first publication. Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah this day of 2010. CHAIRPERSON ATTEST: CITY RECORDER Transmitted to Mayor on Mayor's Action: Approved. Vetoed. MAYOR CITY RECORDER (SEAL) Bill No. of 2010. Published: HB_ATTY-#15210-v1-amending_12_56_205_and 12_56_550 electric_vehicle_charging_stations.DOC 6 Ordinance No. of 2010 (Amending Sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550,Salt Lake City Code, defining electric vehicle charging stations, limiting their use to electric vehicles being actively charged, and establishing a civil penalty for violations.) An ordinance amending Sections 12.56.205 and 12.56.550, Salt Lake City Code, defining electric vehicle charging stations, limiting their use to electric vehicles being actively charged, imposing a two hour limit for use, and establishing a civil penalty for violations. WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Council approved Ordinance No. 82 of 2005, enacting Section 12.56.205 of the Salt Lake City Code to encourage the use of alternative fuel, fuel efficient, and low polluting vehicles by permitting such vehicles to park for free at Salt Lake City parking meters. WHEREAS, the use of these types of vehicles helps to improve air quality within the City and to reduce dependence on foreign oil, which is consistent with the City's goal of creating a greener, more sustainable, and environmentally friendly city. WHEREAS. certain electric vehicles must be recharged regularly, and lack of charging stations outside of the vehicle owner's home limit the range over which the vehicle may be used. WHEREAS. the City wishes to encourage the use of electric vehicles by providing charging stations within the City that may be used by multiple vehicles each day. NOW. THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah. as follows: SECTION 1. That the following sections of the Salt Lake City Code be amended as follows: 12.56.205: PARKING METERS; NO CHARGE FOR ALTERNATIVE FUEL, FUEL EFFICIEiNT AND LOW POLLUTING VEHICLES; ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATIONS: A. The following definitions shall apply to this section: ALTERNATIVE FUEL: Propane. compressed natural gas, electricity, or any motor or special fuel that meets the clean fuel vehicle standards in the federal clean air act amendments of 1990, title II. as amended. ALTERNATIVE FUEL VEHICLE: A vehicle with an engine powered full or part time by an alternative fuel. CLEAN FUEL LICENSE PLATE: A special group license plate issued by the Utah department of motor vehicles as authorized by Utah code 41-1 a-418, or its successor. DIVISION: The city's transportation division. ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATION: A parking stall equiped with an electrical outlet to charge electric vehicles. FUEL EFFICIENT VEHICLE: A vehicle that is powered by gasoline or diesel that achieves a city driving fuel efficiency of forty one (41) or more miles per gallon. LOW POLLUTING VEHICLE: A vehicle that achieves an environmental protection agency (EPA) air pollution score of at least eight (8) on the EPA vehicle rating scale of zero to ten (10). B. 1. The division shall issue a vehicle windshield sticker to all persons applying for such sticker who provide evidence acceptable to the division that the vehicle for which the sticker is desired is a "fuel efficient vehicle" or a "low polluting vehicle" as defined in subsection A of this section. Motorcycles and other vehicles that are not automobiles shall not be issued a sticker pursuant to this section. 2. The recipient of the sticker shall affix it only to the bottom of the driver's side of the rear window of the vehicle for which it is issued so that it is readily visible. C. Parking meter spaces may be used without charge on all days of the week at all hours by vehicles properly displaying the sticker referred to in subsection B of this section or vehicles displaying a clean fuel license plate. D. No person parking a vehicle without charge pursuant to this section shall park or permit such vehicle to remain parked in any parking meter space adjacent to a meter for a continuous period longer than that designated on the meter, nor shall they park in restricted spaces pursuant to section 12.56.180 of this chapter. E. In assessing the evidence provided by an applicant for such sticker as set forth in subsection B 1 of this section, the division may consider: 1. The fuel efficiency information for particular years and models of vehicles determined by the department of energy and the environmental protection agency as shown on their website at www.fueleconomy.gov or its successor website; and 2. The EPA's annual "Green Vehicle Guide" as found at the website www.epa.govkreenvehicles or its successor website. F. Use of electric vehicle charging stations is restricted to electric vehicles actively charging their battery at the provided electrical outlet. The division may establish time limits for use of particular electric vehicle charging stations. No person shall use an electric vehicle charging station for longer than the time period specified for that station. Failure to comply with this provision will result in a civil penalty as set forth in Section 12.56.550 of this code. Amok 12.56.550: UNAUTHORIZED USE OF STREETS, PARKING LOTS AND OTHER AREAS; PENALTIES: A. Violation: 1. Any person engaging in the unauthorized use of streets, parking lots or other areas as provided under this chapter, within the city, shall be liable for a civil penalty. Any penalty assessed in subsection B of this section may be in addition to such other penalties as may be provided in this title. 2. "Unauthorized use of streets" means a violation of any restriction or prohibition contained in this chapter or its successor. B. Civil Penalties: Civil penalties shall be imposed as follows: Section Of This Chapter Penalty 12.56.040 $140 .00 12.56.050 135 .00 12.56.080 150 .00 12.56.100 135 .00 12.56.110 135 .00 12.56.120 260 .00 12.56.130 260 .00 12.56.150 125 .00 12.56.180 135 .00 12.56.190 125 .00 12.56.205F 160.00 12.56.210 135 .00 3 12.56.440A5 147 .00 12.56.440A19 260 .00 12.56.450 125 .00 12.56.460 140 .00 12.56.465 192 .00 12.56.470 140 .00 12.56.480 140 .00 12.56.490 140 .00 12.56.500 140 .00 12.56.515 135 .00 12.56.520 135 .00 12.56.525 135 .00 Note: 1.With the exception of subsections 12.56.440A5 and A19. C. Reduction Of Penalties: The civil penalties specified in subsection B of this section shall be subject to the following: 1. Any penalty that is paid within ten (10) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of one hundred ten dollars ($110.00). 2. Any penalty that is paid within twenty (20) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of seventy dollars ($70.00). 3. Any penalty that is paid within thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of notice shall be reduced by the sum of forty dollars ($40.00). 5 D. Receipt Of Notice: As used in this section, "receipt of notice" means the affixing of a notice to the vehicle alleged to have been employed in such unauthorized use, or by delivery of such notice to the owner or driver thereof. E. Other Fees And Assessments: A forty five dollar ($45.00) administrative fee shall be assessed • for the city's cost of collecting past due debts. SECTION 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon first publication. Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah this day of 2010. CHAIRPERSON ATTEST: CITY RECORDER Transmitted to Mayor on Mayor's Action: Approved. Vetoed. MAYOR APPROVED AS TO FORM CITY RECORDER Salt Lake ity ttorne 's Office Da e 2 6 (c) (SEAL) By Bill No. of 2010. Published: I 13 ,<\1T1'-=152I0-v1-amending_12_56_205_and_12_56_550_electric_vehicle_chareine_stations.DOC 6 m -< O P N P N CO C 0- lQ rD (D _< • fD Budget Overview City Budget is $750 Million ■ Enterprise funds — including airport and public utilities funds, make up more than half of the overall budget. General Fund is 25 percent, or approximately $189 million. Discussion focused on General Fund — the same general trends affect Enterprise and Internal Service Funds. Pension increases, health insurance changes, and any compensation adjustments would also impact other funds. Where We've Been • FY 2009-10 • Mid-year reductions in FY zoo8-o9 continued in FY 2009-10. • Reduced about 2%of our positions in the General Fund. • No General Fund department immune. • Reduced contribution to CIP from 7.95%of General Fund revenue to 7%. • Employees absorbed health insurance increase,moving from 95/5%premium split to 9o/io split. • Employees absorbed pay suspension of 2.5%of their salaries. • Merit and career ladder increases suspended. • FY 2010-11 • All General Fund Departments took some reductions. • Reorganized City functions to improve efficiency. • Continued CIP funding at 7%. • Restored 2.5%pay suspension,while employees assumed greater share of health insurance costs moving to 85/25%split. • Eliminated an additional 3%of our positions in the General Fund. • Funded foregone FY io merits and career ladders. • Did not fund merit increases for FY 11. • Used approximately$4 million in one-time revenue to balance budget,offset with approximately $2.5 million in one-time expenses. lJ �) ( ) General Fund FY 2008-09 DISTRIBUTION FY 2010-11 DISTRIBUTION BETWEEN CATEGORIES BETWEEN CATEGORIES 0 General Fund by Department FY 2008-09 FY 2010-11 .11 1111 •1I 0 u • • 0 rcs • -• • o r I I I - • 0) ets • - 4 N M O C GO to M Ill O M iiif M V / O C n M • cn 40k IH O o n 0) LC rD tn rD O a) X rD rD C rD • m. • t CD X rD a) Wood• • PS 1 Changes In Key Sources of Revenue ill Sales Tax Interest Income Permits 0 i i FY 2011-12 Preview FY 2012 Budget Building • FY 2011 issues: fewer one-time expenses than one-time revenue — $2.5 million. ■ Stabilized revenue sources ■ Possible increases in some areas, including sales tax, interest, and permits. ■ Modest increases in some revenue categories still leave us far short of previous levels. V FY 2011 - 12 Preview Expense Side Must Adds ze Pension Contribution • Municipal Elections ■ Fuel ■ Health Insurance — address both premium increases and deficit ■ Compensation ■ Pent up demand 0 � � FY 2011 - 12 Budget Preview Mayor has asked each department head to submit budget reduction plans based on a reduction target of 2%. ■ Mayor will review the plans and make decisions about what is included in his overall recommendations . Compensation and health insurance issues are central to budget discussions this year. Options Available for FY 2011 - 12 • Continue to Seek Efficiencies • Changing how we do the work of the City Slimming or Eliminating Programs ▪ Reducing service levels, and/or • Eliminating programs • Holding vacancies (on a dept. by dept. basis) Revenue Enhancements • Recovering our costs • Raising or generating new fees • Raising property taxes 1 I � RECEIVED RICHARD GRAHAM ,+w\, y' 1 u �rl� RAREAMON\ •• .,• RA L�FI �ECKER MAYOR JBLIC SERVICES DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICES SLC COUNCIL OFFICE DIRECTORS OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Jill Remington-Love, Chair DATE: March 17, 2011 Salt Lake City Council FROM: Rick Graham 535-7774 14( Director of Public Services Vicki Bennett 535-6540 Sustainability Director SUBJECT: Refuse Program Update The following is a status update on the Administration's efforts to resolve the issues on recycling and refuse collection. 1. Status of CNG trucks: a. It is the opinion of the City Attorney that the City is obligated to purchase the trucks. b. Sixteen cab and chassis have been built; without bringing recycling in-house this year, we have a need for three now and will be proposing to purchase three additional trucks in FY 2011-12 as part of our ongoing replacement plan. c. These trucks will be purchased using a lease-purchase agreement. d. The Administration has not made a decision as to if it will purchase the additional ten cab and chassis alone, or have the packer bodies added to them. Options are being considered. 2. Current status of refuse operations: a. Yard waste and recycling services are now being provided to all residents. b. One combination fee for all services, depending upon the size of refuse can, is in place. c. A waste stream audit is being completed to help us to determine future actions that will increase our diversion rate, and will be completed in the spring of 2012. d. Additional glass recycling locations have been put throughout the city. e. Leaf pick-up increased from 24,000 tons to 33,000 tons this year, and residents were able to request an additional free yard waste can for large quantities of leaves during November and December. LOCATION: 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 138 SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH B41 1 1-3104 MAILING ADDRESS: PO BOX 145469, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 841 14.5469 TELEPHONE: 801-535-7775 FAX: BO 1-535.7963 W W W.BLCOO V.COM vcc.cco c.acR f. 3,575 Christmas trees were collected in a special one-week curb-side pick-up. g. The slow-fill CNG station contract is in place and will be installed soon. 3. Plan for Refuse: a. As requested by Council, we have delayed the process of bringing the recycling collection in-house. Allied has verbally agreed to extend its contract for up to one year. b. We are about to issue an RFP for the sorting of the materials,which will give us direct control over this process,plus a revenue stream for the recycled material. This should be completed and awarded in June 2011. c. Once we have chosen a sorting facility,we will issue a RFP for the collection of the material,to get a firm bid from vendors. This bid process will be completed in the fall of 2011. d. The detailed analysis of our internal costs for recycling services will be refined and completed by the end of the summer. We have met with Council staff and will continue to include them in this analysis. e. We will then be able to compare our internal costs to the bids to determine if we bring recycling in-house or not. f. While we wait for these decisions, next year's budget will be based on a"steady- state" of services, with no changes from this year. 4. Status of$7.0 MM from landfill: a. The money has been received. 1.5 MM has been placed in the operating fund to support ongoing expenses, and $5.5 MM is being reserved for future sustainability projects. b. Potential projects will be determined as we complete the waste audit and community food assessment, and as we investigate alternative energy options for the Public Safety Building. c. Any input on this from the Council will be welcomed. Cc: David Everitt Cindy Gust-Jensen Lehua Weaver Outline of Expectations Salt Lake City Council Priority - Maximize Existing City Resources Goal: To assure that City resources are spent wisely, protected properly and managed in the most efficient way possible by: • collaborating with the Administration, • reducing duplication of efforts, • clarifying and updating ordinances, • investing in resources to make City processes more efficient, and effectively exercising the Council's oversight role. 54t 'o#91i'i'itiative: 2011 Retreat iltiE3id; On-going Karen Halladay- Lead, Jennifer Bruno, Quin Card, Neil Lindberg, Sylvia $400t a Richards, Lehua Weaver 1 1. Collaboration with Administrative Staff and, 2. Budget appropriations, as identified by project. A. Consolidate all City fees into one schedule before the budget process in order to save approximately 100 hours in staff time(citywide)and over 10 cases of paper. sSili;t :. B. Update business license ordinances prior to consideration of the Pifi Ei ion of small business neighborhood zoning issue to assure that 004%0; enforcement is effective. - C. Support efforts to evaluate and update the City's Financial Management software. This Council priority will include much more detail about potential projects, options, and ways to work collaboratively with the Administration. The Council staff is working with the Administration to review that detail and prepare it for the Council's review. Staff will bring the more comprehensive document to the Council as soon as it is ready. Council Priority Items ("Umbrellas") Items confirmed at the Jan.2011 retreat. V • 0 • Council Communication Efforts: Council Website in progress;Council interviews for Channel 17;Weeklies; aeli weekly Council meeting reports; 0 v y at • Public Engagement: Increased contact with community and stakeholders through mailing lists and listsery emails CU to provide notifications/updates on topics,requests for comment,notification of meeting 0000 times,etc. fLk rS al • Small Neighborhood business zones, location of alcohol establishments: waiting for transmittal O ,'" • Parley's Historic Nature Park: Walking tours scheduled for end of January with the Mayor 0 fr..47 • tiati: Council staff putting recommended edits into document in revision format for Zj w Council review O0 • New Libraries: Library progress,and Council involvement,needs additional community input o • Conditional Use text amendments: Council staff to revise the Administration's proposal N • Pan-handling: Council closed hearing and direction needed for further work ^ham • Demolition Ordinance: Needs Council review of changes to the ordinance,then community input needed •� • Resident donations for Quality of Life projects: Council staff prepared to draft ordinance,further Z discussion from Council needed. • Street Lighting - Policy d4 ` , +.# • 10-year CIP Plan: Administration working with consultant to do updates .1.4gli • Impact Fee Study: Administration working with consultant to do updates 1I� • North Temple: Construction moving forward,budget steps in progress U '8 • Regional Sports Complex: Pending litigation • Public Safety Building: Planning/design moving forward,budget steps in progress 4.1� • Open Space Policy: Pending information from the Administration on Golf projects er-► •• Emergency Preparation - Budget ordinances / practices, Work Plan: Council staff preparing work plan, g.1 discussions with Administration on budget pieces • City's Benefits Plan deficit Z • Council Oversight & Internal Controls 01 O • Street Cars / Trolleys: Planning,budgeting,staffing in progress • Bicycle & Transportation projects: .r▪ j • Traffic Calming - including speed limits, stop signs, pedestrian safety: policy discussion held with k Administration,further discussion needed on next steps and action items spi 4Q • Sidewalk snow removal: COMPLETE a • Electric vehicles: Council staff prepared to draft revisions to the Administration's proposal in order to complete 1/ Nri the intent of the Council's Legislative Action • Ground Transportation: NEARLY COMPLETE til t • Concrete / Sidewalk standards:Council staff working with Administration on audit scope Printed Feb.3,2011 Project updates as of January 20,2011