10/17/2002 - Minutes (2) PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 17 , 2002
The City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah met in Work Session on Thursday, October 17,
2002, at 5:30 p.m. in Room 326, Committee Room, City County Building, 451 South State
Street.
In Attendance: Council Members Carlton Christensen, Van Turner, Eric Jergensen, Nancy
Saxton, Jill Remington Love, Dave Buhler, and Dale Lambert.
Also In Attendance: Cindy Gust-Jenson, Executive Council Director; Rocky Fluhart,
Chief Administrative Officer; Gary Mumford, Council Deputy Director/Senior Legislative
Auditor; Lehua Weaver, Council Staff Assistant; Janet Wolf, Director of Youth Programs;
D. J. Baxter, Mayor' s Senior Advisor; Alison McFarlane, Economic Development Manager;
Alison Weyher, Community and Economic Development Director; Steve Fawcett, Management
Services Deputy Director; Gordon Hoskins, Accounting Controller; Valda Tarbet,
Redevelopment Agency Deputy Director; Danny Walz, Redevelopment Agency Project Manager;
Bob Farrington, Downtown Alliance; Prescott Muir, Downtown Alliance; and Scott
Crandall, Deputy Recorder.
Councilmember Buhler presided at and conducted the meeting.
The meeting was called to order at 5:42 p.m.
AGENDA ITEMS
#1. REPORT OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, INCLUDING REVIEW OF COUNCIL INFORMATION
ITEMS AND ANNOUNCEMENTS.
See file M 02-5 for announcements.
#2. COUNCIL WILL CONTINUE THEIR DISCUSSION REGARDING BUDGET AMENDMENT NO. 10,
INITIATIVE RELATING TO DOWNTOWN LIGHTING, DECORATION AND ENTERTAINMENT PROGRAM. View
Attachment
Alison Weyher, Alison McFarlane, Bob Farrington, and Prescott Muir briefed the Council
with the attached handout. Ms. Weyher said nine of the ten responses to the Request
for Proposal (RFP) were considered responsive. She said proposals were reviewed by a
committee consisting of representatives from the City, Downtown Alliance, and Council.
She said sales tax revenues were down and one goal was to encourage more people
to visit and shop in the downtown area during the holiday season.
Ms. Weyher said the proposal tied traditional Christmas activities with new activities
and provided a focus on the Main Street Corridor. She said the proposal would be
pedestrian friendly and provide transportation links between Main Street malls and
Gateway. She said the RFP would provide three additional events throughout the year.
She said one of the main components was the long-range marketing plan. She said the
consultant wanted to market Main Street as an outdoor mall. Councilmember Christensen
said a number of reasons existed to treat Main Street as a mall. He said he felt the
short and long-term coordinating and marketing needs for Main Street would be addressed
by the proposal.
Councilmember Buhler asked how the Downtown Alliance felt about the proposal.
Mr. Farrington said they felt it would add another level of enhancement. He said they
welcomed the chance to participate and wanted to integrate their ideas and experiences
into the project. Mr. Muir said he felt the contract needed to contain an evaluation
period and a termination clause.
Councilmember Saxton asked what the City' s goals were regarding downtown
02 - 1
PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 17 , 2002
programming and decorations. Ms. Weyher said the goal was to provide a long-range
marketing strategy. She said the City needed to capitalize on the investment and bring
more residents and visitors downtown. Councilmember Saxton asked what portion of the
sales tax generated by Salt Lake City was given to other municipalities. Mr. Fluhart
said a small percentage was distributed to other cities.
Councilmember Saxton asked if the $600, 000 could be given to the Downtown Alliance
instead of going through the RFP. Ms. Gust-Jenson said legal advice was needed about
appropriating money to a specific organization. She said the same results could be
achieved by appropriating money for a specific purpose with specific stipulations.
Councilmember Jergensen asked if the vendor would work to bring other groups together.
Ms. Weyher said she felt the vendor understood a collaborative effort was needed by
all parties involved to make the project successful. Mr. Muir suggested creating a
Steering Committee comprised of representatives from mall and retail merchants,
Downtown Alliance, Chamber of Commerce, the City Council and the Administration.
Councilmember Love asked if the additional events proposed in the RFP included
the Winter Festival. Ms. Weyher said no. Councilmember Love said for future events,
she felt the Downtown Alliance needed to be responsible for coordination.
Councilmember Lambert asked what funding source was being used for the $600, 000.
Mr. Fluhart said the general fund. Councilmember Lambert said he wanted to receive
comments from people attending the meeting. Councilmember Buhler said a comment period
could be added to the formal agenda.
Councilmember Buhler asked if the proposal fit the Downtown Alliance's plans.
Ms. Weyher said the bid contained elements which would complement traditional lighting
in the downtown area. Councilmember Buhler said at an earlier meeting, the Council
requested the Downtown Alliance move forward with their plans and not wait for the
RFP. Mr. Farrington said the Downtown Alliance was following the Council's request to
proceed with their annual plans. Councilmember Buhler asked how long the contract
would be in place. Ms. Weyher said until December 2003. Councilmember Buhler said
the Council would consider action during the formal meeting.
#3. COUNCIL WILL CONTINUE THEIR DISCUSSION REGARDING ONE-TIME MONEY. View Attachment
Gary Mumford and Rocky Fluhart briefed the Council with the attached handout. Mr.
Mumford said $1, 626,000 was available from the general fund in one-time money.
Discussion was held on appropriating the funding. All Council Members were in favor
of allocating $800,000 to the Housing Trust Fund. All Council Members were in favor
of allocating $75, 000 for the Police Memorial with a community match. Mr. Fluhart
said Police Chief Dinse estimated the cost of the memorial at $100, 000.
Discussion was held on the advantages or disadvantages of allocating $100,000 per
Council district. Some Council Members wanted to keep the money together for larger
projects or put in the Open Space fund. A straw poll was taken. All Council Members
were in favor of $100,000 per district, except Council Members Lambert and Love.
Councilmember Jergensen asked about receiving $1.8 million of Utah Transit Authority
(UTA) money. Mr. Fluhart said the money was in a State account. He said the City
could receive the money through an interlocal agreement or directly from the State.
He said both options were being explored. He said he was confident the City would
receive the money but timing was an unknown factor. Councilmember Jergensen asked how
the $1.8 million would be handled. Councilmember Buhler said the money would come in
through a budget amendment. He said it could go to fund balance or be allocated.
02 - 2
PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 17 , 2002
Mr. Mumford said approximately $50, 000 remained to be allocated. The majority of the
Council was in favor of allocating the money to the Leonardo Endowment Fund for cultural
events designed to celebrate Olympic ideals and diversity. Councilmember Buhler said
the money would be set aside with the understanding more details would be given to the
Council prior to the November budget opening. He said a community match needed to be
included.
The meeting adjourned at 7:59 p.m.
sc
02 - 3
EF Downtown Alliance
SALT LAKE CITY
238 South Main Street
Salt Lake City,Utah 84ioi
t:801.359.5118
f:801.359.5136
www.downtownslc.org
October 16, 2002
Mr. David Buhler
Chairman
Salt Lake City Council
451 South State Street
Salt Lake City, Utah 84101
Dear Chairman Buhler;
The Downtown Alliance supports Salt Lake City's efforts to provide an additional level
of funding for Main Street enhancements that helps drive retail sales and bring customers,
visitors, and business to downtown Salt Lake City.
Given the current slowdown in the economy, and the lack of funds from traditional
private sector sources, the enhancement program, if done properly, can be a bridge to
more important permanent changes for the Main Street core area.
For the program to be successful the Downtown Alliance, as the representative of
downtown businesses and property owners for the past ten years, believes it is imperative
that we provide oversight and coordination of the enhancement services that you may
contract for, and do so in a way that is consistent with the plans and objectives of the
City, and the downtown businesses and property owners that the proposal intends to
assist.
Our organization has been providing many of the services requested in the Main Street
enhancement proposal for 10 years, and those services have been funded almost
exclusively by businesses and property owners through a special assessment on their
property or other business contributions.
Now that Salt Lake City is ready to make a financial contribution to marketing, events,
decor and other improvements to Main Street, we believe it is imperative to utilize the
Downtown Alliance, and our Board and Committee structure, to oversee and provide
guidance to the services you are looking to contract.
The Downtown Alliance has the expertise,business leadership, and community
connections to help direct and manage this effort in conjunction with the City Council
and the City administration.
business vision :m w
•
Page 2
In any future efforts of a similar nature, it would be a more productive process to involve
our organization in the early stages of deliberation, and we could be helpful in providing
meaningful input on the best course of action. We are also in a position, given enough
notice, to be a direct contractor for the types of service you now are considering, and
would like an opportunity to do so in the future.
While new ideas and initiatives for improving our downtown are always welcome, it is
important to build upon current successes. We should leverage our existing projects and
programs that are successful with additional funding from Salt Lake City, and partner
with other successful programs and organizations to extend their work downtown as well.
We appreciate the willingness of Salt Lake City to help provide funding for
improvements to our Main Street core, and ask that you consider our involvement as a
necessary ingredient to its success.
S' erely,
, `
Robert Farrington Jr.
Executive Director
cc. Mayor Rocky Anderson
Salt Lake City Council
Budget Amendments
wr.*m.*m.*wu
. �nun�/
'` `� �^ Adopted
REVENUE
One-Time Money
Reimbursement m1x64m sales tax(received inFvu1eu appropriated mm.F.Fund Balance) $ *20e137
Reimbursement m,oanLake opoxnuom�ox(eoeiveui"Fvo1'ouoppmpnat*mmo.F.Fund Balance) o'o��'1eo
Emmosveoanein the oamuemi000va�meeFund ' '
ou«umouemnemive savings onmmia»uemm ue 77.e57
567,591
uTA reimbursement of back sales tax for light rail operation and maintenance Total One-Time Received $ o'o»o'oua
1.80O.00O
Total Projected Revenue $ 8,683,853
, .
. �������
One-Time Money
Use of one-time$for Houser Sculpture(private donations for matching)(BA#7' $ 200000
U����me$�xE��e��emu�|��mP��3�(B�� '
Use ofone� �
ime�«vreq^i;�en�fundinUfo,JRPo,k�, Cwoonwnod(BA#7) 121'1S4
Use ufnne�ime*for aUooaUontoC|P(BA#7) 1,383,806
47'ODU
Use mone�ime$for Open Space oeve|onmematuura�Square(a*#y) n'
Use ofone�ime*for 2no East Mid-Block Cmou,a|k(B*#9) '°"�'=�
148,609
Tpta|One'T|me Money Expenditures from Received Revenue $ 5.257.563
Total Available One-Time Money contained|n General Fund Balance $ 1.62e.290
Total p,u]ectpu 4vai|omeone'nme Money contained In General Fund Balance $ a/uon.uoo
� .....
...................................
..... ...... ........ .
. ... ... ----
. ... ... .......... .....
""'|F One-Time Money
Use of one-time$for Winter Festival(8A#10) $ o00[�
Use of one-time for� ,Downtown Enhancements(BA#10) ao'UOO
Use v[one-time$for Youth Endowment Fund '
anoo
Use ofone�ime$h,r Neighborhood Legacy Pv� �e 'oon'
700000
Use o/one-time$for Housing Trust Fund '
Use m one-time$for Milestone Apartments oeonu' 'ouo
000
Use n[vne� for
for 'nou'
250mm
Use ofnne�ime*for mnuw�ionof Library Building(cultural o,gan��ionnponion> 35O'00}
Use v[vne�ime$for open�ionand moina"onoom,The Leo"a�v 1000'0�
Use ofon*�me$for enovaoonvvLiu,a�Building o'oou'000
Use ofune�/me$for The Leonardo Endowmem 3
Funu ' '
0OOOOO
Use vfonr�me$for Annual Co|ehmgionn[the Legacy nf the 2O02VVinte,Olympics Endow�`entFund 4'OUO'OOo
Use ofone�ime$for|mpmvememom Pioneer Park ' '
??
Use of one-time$for Section 8 Housing Purchases ??
Use of one-time$for Capital Improvement Program Pn4enm ??
Use m one-time o for Police Memorial
??
Tvtu|One'Time Money Proposed Expenditures from Received Revenue $ 19'880.000
MEMORANDUM
DATE: October 11, 2002
TO: Salt Lake City Council Members
FROM: Michael Sears, Budget & Policy Analyst
RE: Salt Lake City One-Time Revenue Appropriation request / Salt Lake City Fiscal
Year 2002-2003 Budget
The Salt Lake City Council considered appropriation of one-time revenue during the
May and June fiscal year 2002-2003 budget adoption process. The Council also
discussed proposed use of one-time revenue during a briefing on September 5, 2002.
Several projects were funded with one-time revenue in budget amendments 7, 8, 9 and
10. The attached sheet shows the sources and uses of the funds. This attachment also
contains a listing of all of the requests for one-time revenue that the Council Office has
received.
Of the original budget requests contained in the Mayor's Recommended Budget, only
the Neighborhood Legacy Project and Youth Endowment Fund have not been funded.
The Council is considering an appropriation for Downtown Enhancements ($500,000)
and a Winter Festival ($80,000) as part of budget amendment #10. Additional items
that the Council may wish to fund could be included in future budget amendments.
cc: Cindy Gust-Jenson,Rocky Fluhart, David Nimkin, Steve Fawcett and Gordon Hoskins
OCT
1 t, ?00?
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: DAVE BUHLER, CITY COUNCIL CHAIR
FROM: ROCKY FLUHART, CHIEF ADMINLSTRATIVE OFFICER
CC: MAYOR ROCKY ANDERSON
SUBJECT: FIRST QUARTER REVENUE INFORMATION
DATE: OCTOBER 15,2002
Our analysis of FY2003 budgeted revenue and current economic trends indicates
substantial potential shortfalls.
When the Utah State Legislature met in special session to deal with the State's budget
deficit they eliminated our liquor law enforcement funding. That decision will result in a
shortfall of approximately$222,000.
Although we still expect to receive the 1/64th cent sales tax distribution being withheld by
the State Tax Commission,we do not know when the funds will be distributed. These
funds,as you know,were part of the original funding plan for the Airport and University
light rail line.
Motor vehicle registration funds are projected to be approximately$365,000 less than
projected. This trend reflects an ongoing adjustment in the division of motor vehicle fees
by the County to correct past errors,and an overall reduction in the number of vehicles
registered in Salt Lake City.
Sales taxes are estimated to be between$730,000 and$1,530,000 less than projected. A
conservative estimate puts the impact at$1,131,500.
Ongoing Shortfall source Projected Amount _
Liquor Law funds $221,500
Sale Tax going to UTA $600,000
Motor Vehicle fees $365,000
Retail Sales Tax receipts $1,131,500
Total $2,318,000
We are currently exploring options for closing this gap, and will keep you apprised.