Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout12/03/2024 - Work Session - Meeting MaterialsSALT LAKE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA WORK SESSION   December 3, 2024 Tuesday 2:00 PM Council meetings are held in a hybrid meeting format. Hybrid meetings allow people to join online or in person at the City & County Building. Learn more at www.slc.gov/council/agendas. Council Work Room 451 South State Street, Room 326 Salt Lake City, UT 84111 SLCCouncil.com 7:00 pm Formal Meeting Room 315 (See separate agenda) Welcome and public meeting rules In accordance with State Statute and City Ordinance, the meeting may be held electronically. After 5:00 p.m., please enter the City & County Building through the main east entrance. The Work Session is a discussion among Council Members and select presenters. The public is welcome to listen. Items scheduled on the Work Session or Formal Meeting may be moved and / or discussed during a different portion of the Meeting based on circumstance or availability of speakers. The Website addresses listed on the agenda may not be available after the Council votes on the item. Not all agenda items will have a webpage for additional information read associated agenda paperwork. Generated: 10:48:27 Note: Dates not identified in the project timeline are either not applicable or not yet determined. Item start times and durations are approximate and are subject to change. Work Session Items   1.Informational: Updates from the Administration ~ 2:00 p.m.  15 min. The Council will receive information from the Administration on major items or projects in progress. Topics may relate to major events or emergencies (if needed), services and resources related to people experiencing homelessness, active public engagement efforts, and projects or staffing updates from City Departments, or other items as appropriate. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Recurring Briefing Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - n/a   2.Ordinance: Title 18 Text Amendments Follow-up ~ 2:15 p.m.  20 min. The Council will receive a follow-up briefing about a proposal that would amend the text of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code to update references to state adopted code, modify building code enforcement appeal process, add and increase building enforcement fines and penalties to match zoning enforcement and cost of operations. The changes are necessary to bring the City's building regulations into compliance with state law. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Thursday, May 30, 2024 and Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - Tuesday, May 21, 2024 Hold hearing to accept public comment - Tuesday, June 4, 2024 at 7 p.m. TENTATIVE Council Action - TBD   3.Resolution: Americans with Disabilities Act Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan ~ 2:35 p.m.  20 min. The Council will receive a briefing about the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Self- Evaluation and Transition Plan. The proposal assesses the City’s compliance with the ADA and identifies steps to eliminate accessibility barriers in City programs, facilities, and public spaces. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, December 10, 2024   4.Ordinance: Jordan River Fairpark District Zoning Map & Text Amendment Follow-up ~ 2:55 p.m.  25 min. The Council will receive a follow-up briefing about a proposal that would amend the City's zoning ordinance by creating a new zoning district known as the Jordan River Fairpark (JRF) District at approximately 1500 West North Temple and bounded by the Jordan River, Redwood Road, North Temple, and Interstate 15. The proposal would rezone approximately 93 acres across 32 parcels into a single zone to support the area's redevelopment. The project is located within Council District 2. Petitioner: Snell & Wilmer, representing Larry H. Miller Development. 1.Zoning Map & Text Amendment: The JRF district would allow buildings up to 400 feet tall. No minimum lot size, setbacks, or open space requirements are proposed, and developments would be exempt from meeting the City's general plans. 2.Development Agreement: The proposed Development Agreement addresses access to the Jordan River, open space, roads, and infrastructure improvements and establishes review processes for development applications. Under new state law, an agreement must be reached by December 31, 2024, for expedited land use reviews related to a qualified stadium and related uses. If no agreement is made, the JRF District will not be subject to the City's zoning regulations. For more information visit https://tinyurl.com/JRFDistrict. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, November 12, 2024; Tuesday, November 19, 2024; and Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - Tuesday, November 12, 2024 Hold hearing to accept public comment - Tuesday, November 19, 2024 and Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 7 p.m. TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, December 3, 2024   5.Municipal Services Interlocal Agreement between Salt Lake City and the Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District ~ 3:20 p.m.  20 min. The Council will receive a briefing on an interlocal agreement between Salt Lake City and the Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District to provide municipal services, such as water, sewer, police, fire, and homelessness assistance to the Fairpark District boundary. In 2024, the Utah State legislature passed House Bill 562, the Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District (the Act), which created the Fairpark District and, among other things, requires the City and the District enter into an agreement by December 31, 2024. This interlocal agreement provides that the District reimburse the City for the cost of municipal services. This reimbursement would be in addition to the City receiving the base taxable value and 25% of the enhanced property tax from the Fairpark District Boundary. The Council may consider approving the interlocal agreement at the December 10, 2024 Council meeting. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, December 10, 2024   6.Ordinance: Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning Text Amendment Follow-up ~ 3:40 p.m.  20 min. The Council will receive a follow-up briefing about a proposal that would amend various sections of Title 21A of the Salt Lake City Code creating a new section 21A.28.040 Northpoint Light Industrial (M-1A) Zoning District that aligns with the goals, policies and future land use recommendations established in the Northpoint Small Area Plan. The proposal would include providing an environment for light industrial, office, and research uses, while reducing the impact on adjacent agricultural and residential properties and native habitats. This is a City Council-initiated petition. Other sections of Title 21A – Zoning may also be amended as part of this petition. This project is within Council District 1. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, September 3, 2024; Tuesday, October 15, 2024; and Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - Tuesday, September 3, 2024 Hold hearing to accept public comment - Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 7 p.m. TENTATIVE Council Action - TBD   7.Tentative Break ~ 4:00 p.m.  20 min. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Set Public Hearing Date - Hold hearing to accept public comment - TENTATIVE Council Action -   8.Ordinance: Sugar House Master Plan, Zoning Map, and Text Amendment at Approximately 1095 East 2100 South (Formerly Wells Fargo Bank) ~ 4:20 p.m.  30 min. The Council will receive a briefing about a proposal that would amend the City's zoning ordinance by creating a new zoning district known as MU-15 (Form Based Mixed-Use 15 Subdistrict) that would apply to the property at approximately 1095 East 2100 South. The proposal would also amend the Sugar House Master Plan to support the proposed rezone. The proposal intends to redevelop the current two-story building (formerly a Wells Fargo bank branch) on the 1.22-acre property into a mixed-use residential project. The Planning Commission forwarded a negative recommendation, therefore the ordinances have not been drafted. If the Council decides to approve the amendments, the ordinances would be drafted and considered for approval. The project is located within Council District 7. Petitioner: Snell & Wilmer, representing the property owner Harbor Bay Ventures. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - Tuesday, December 10, 2024 Hold hearing to accept public comment - Tuesday, January 7, 2025 at 7 p.m. TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, January 21, 2025   9.Ordinance: Budget Amendment No.2 for Fiscal Year 2024- 25 Follow-up ~ 4:50 p.m.  30 min. The Council will receive a follow-up briefing about Budget Amendment No. 2 for the Fiscal Year 2024-25 Budget. Budget amendments happen several times each year to reflect adjustments to the City’s budgets, including proposed project additions and modifications. The proposed amendment includes creating a new fund dedicated to the Capital City Downtown Revitalization Zone sales tax, 12 new police officers partially funded by a Community Oriented Policing Services or COPS program grant from the U.S. Department of Justice, a donation from the University of Utah related to the construction of a baseball stadium at Sunnyside Park, and funding for the City’s vehicle fleet among other projects. The Council will also receive a presentation about the State Transit Transportation Investment Fund or TTIF and four capital projects receiving TTIF grants, including a multiuse trail on 400 South to better connect Poplar Grove and Downtown, among other projects. For more information visit tinyurl.com/SLCFY25. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, November 19, 2024 and Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - Tuesday, November 19, 2024 Hold hearing to accept public comment - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 7 p.m. TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, December 10, 2024   10.Informational: Council/Board Leadership Structural Changes ~ 5:20 p.m.  20 min. The Council will have an internal discussion about a proposal to adjust Council/Board leadership positions. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - n/a   11.Resolution: Ranked Choice Voting for 2025 Municipal Election ~ 5:40 p.m.  15 min. The Council will have an internal discussion about an option for the 2025 municipal election to participate in the State-authorized Municipal Alternative Voting Method Pilot Program project, otherwise known as ranked choice voting or instant runoff voting. Under ranked choice voting, voters rank the candidates in order of preference. Election equipment counts the preference numbers for each ballot. If none of the candidates receive more than 50% of the overall vote after the first round, the candidate with the least number of votes is eliminated. The voters who had selected the eliminated candidate as their first choice would then have their votes counted for their second- choice candidate. This process of elimination continues until a candidate crosses the 50% threshold and is declared the winner. For more information on this item visit https://tinyurl.com/RankedChoiceSLC. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - Tuesday, December 10, 2024   12.Informational: Council Policy Manual - Travel Section Update ~ 5:55 p.m.  20 min. The Council will have a discussion about possible amendments to their internal Council Policy regarding Travel, Training, and Capacity Building. FYI – Project Timeline: (subject to change per Chair direction or Council discussion) Briefing - Tuesday, December 3, 2024 Set Public Hearing Date - n/a Hold hearing to accept public comment - n/a TENTATIVE Council Action - n/a   Standing Items   13.Report of the Chair and Vice Chair -  - Report of Chair and Vice Chair.    14.Report and Announcements from the Executive Director -  - Report of the Executive Director, including a review of Council information items and announcements. The Council may give feedback or staff direction on any item related to City Council business, including but not limited to: •Housing Programs and Loan Deferment; and •Scheduling Items.    15.Tentative Closed Session -  - The Council will consider a motion to enter into Closed Session. A closed meeting described under Section 52-4-205 may be held for specific purposes including, but not limited to: a. discussion of the character, professional competence, or physical or mental health of an individual; b. strategy sessions to discuss collective bargaining; c. strategy sessions to discuss pending or reasonably imminent litigation; d. strategy sessions to discuss the purchase, exchange, or lease of real property, including any form of a water right or water shares, if public discussion of the transaction would: (i) disclose the appraisal or estimated value of the property under consideration; or (ii) prevent the public body from completing the transaction on the best possible terms; e. strategy sessions to discuss the sale of real property, including any form of a water right or water shares, if: (i) public discussion of the transaction would: (A) disclose the appraisal or estimated value of the property under consideration; or (B) prevent the public body from completing the transaction on the best possible terms; (ii) the public body previously gave public notice that the property would be offered for sale; and (iii) the terms of the sale are publicly disclosed before the public body approves the sale; f. discussion regarding deployment of security personnel, devices, or systems; and g. investigative proceedings regarding allegations of criminal misconduct. A closed meeting may also be held for attorney-client matters that are privileged pursuant to Utah Code § 78B-1-137, and for other lawful purposes that satisfy the pertinent requirements of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act.    CERTIFICATE OF POSTING On or before 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday, November 26, 2024, the undersigned, duly appointed City Recorder, does hereby certify that the above notice and agenda was (1) posted on the Utah Public Notice Website created under Utah Code Section 63F-1-701, and (2) a copy of the foregoing provided to The Salt Lake Tribune and/or the Deseret News and to a local media correspondent and any others who have indicated interest. CINDY LOU TRISHMAN SALT LAKE CITY RECORDER Final action may be taken in relation to any topic listed on the agenda, including but not limited to adoption, rejection, amendment, addition of conditions and variations of options discussed. The City & County Building is an accessible facility. People with disabilities may make requests for reasonable accommodation, which may include alternate formats, interpreters, and other auxiliary aids and services. Please make requests at least two business days in advance. To make a request, please contact the City Council Office at council.comments@slc.gov, 801-535-7600, or relay service 711. COUNCIL STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY TO:City Council Members FROM: Nick Tarbet, Policy Analyst DATE: Dec. 3, 2024 RE:Title 18 Text Amendment: Building Code, Boarded Buildings Administration and Fee Updates. PROJECT TIMELINE: Briefing 1: May 30, 2024 Briefing 2: Dec. 3, 2024 Set Date: May 21, 2024 Public Hearing: June 4, 2024 Potential Action: Dec. 10, 2024 NEW INFORMATION During the May 30 briefing, the Council asked the administration to come back with recommendations that could be included in the final ordinance regarding the following concepts: Increase the fines for building code violations Increase the annual fee for boarded buildings Create a separate fee for commercial vs. residential buildings and charging commercial buildings a higher fee Consider an escalating fee for the annual fee o Charging the maximum amount allowed after a certain year (3 or 5 years were both mentioned) Establish a better definition of compliance after violating a building code. o Consider requiring any damage that occurred to adjacent properties to be made whole before the work permit is reissued. Clarify that the timeclock on a boarded building does not restart due to a transfer of ownership. The Public hearing was held on June 4. The Council closed the public hearing and deferred action. The administration has updated the ordinance based on the Council's feedback. The outline below shows how the Council’s policy direction was incorporated and where it is in the draft ordinance. Administrative staff feel these changes, in conjunction with their updated administrative enforcement policies, put them in a much stronger position to enforce building code violations successfully. One example is the Building Code Enforcement Team (BCE Team), which Building Services recently created. Page | 2 This team will ensure better coordination and enforcement between the building inspectors and the enforcement staff. This will help improve the enforcement of building code and zoning violations in the following ways: Review with permit processors any properties with multiple pending permits Monitor cases more closely so that issues are identified as early as possible. Handle complaints and assign senior staff to address and help follow up on any issues. Funnel permits cases through fewer staff so that multiple people are not involved in one case, creating ineffective awareness and/or enforcement. Increase focus on expiring permits when allowed by code, organize multiple permit issues, and begin fines immediately. Permits can expire if they have not progressed for 180 days. o Written documentation will also be required and reviewed to reinstate any expired permit. Fines for violations have been increased and will be applied to properties, o Multiple fines can be applied to a property – Each for $100/day. o When fines accrue to $14,000, the City will take the case to small claims court, which requires the contractor and/or permit holder to appear. This can repeat as long as fines accrue, at each $14,000 mark. o All staff is receiving biannual training on survey protocol to follow up on any potential issues. Made clear that surveys will be required (at the permit holder's expense) as deemed necessary by City inspectors/enforcement. Issue Change Ordinance Citation Increase the fines for building code violations Violation of Title 18 $100 (except Ch. 18.50 or Stop Work Order) Violation of Stop Work Order: $250 Exhibit A Line 6378 Increase the annual fee for boarded buildings Create a separate fee for commercial vs. residential buildings and charging commercial buildings a higher fee Consider an escalating fee for the annual fee. Charging the maximum amount allowed after a certain year (3 or 5 years were both mentioned) Boarding registration fee Residential Years 1&2: $3,000 Non-Residential Years 1 & 2: $6,000 Residential Years 3-5 $6,000 Non-Residential Years 3-5 $9,000 Residential Years 6 or more $,9000 Non-Residential Years 6 or more $14,000 Boarding registration fee for a contributing structure or landmark site $14,000 Exhibit A Line 6378 Page | 3 Clarify that the timeclock on a boarded building does not restart due to a transfer of ownership. 18.48.215: Yearly Registration Fees: A change in ownership shall not restart the yearly amount of registration fees, but such fees shall increase as set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule in accordance with the amount of time that the property has been registered. Lines 2736-2738 Establish a better definition of compliance after violating a building code. Include language that clearly states permits issued do not allow a permit holder to negatively impact an adjacent property. 18.04.070: LIABILITY LIMITATIONS: Nothing in this title shall be construed to relieve or lessen the responsibility of any contractor, owner, or any other persons involved, for apparatus, construction or equipment installed by or for them, for damages to anyone injured or damaged either in person or property by any defect therein, nor shall the city or any employee thereof be held to assume any liability by reason of the inspections authorized herein, or the certificate of occupancy issued by the building official of the division of building and housing services. The provisions of this title are not intended to interfere with, abrogate, or require enforcement by the city of any legally enforceable easements, covenants, or other agreements between private parties that may restrict the use of the land. Permits or other approvals issued pursuant to this title provide no right to encroach or interfere with the private property of third parties. Lines 110-114 If supportive of these changes, the Council may wish to direct staff to put this on the December 10 agenda for potential adoption. The following information was provided for the May 30 work session briefing. It is provided again for background purposes. ISSUE AT-A-GLANCE The Council will receive a briefing on a proposed ordinance that would amend the text of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code, regarding Boarded Building Fees and enforcement of building code violations. If adopted, the Code would be amended in the following ways: This proposal increases fees associated with the boarded building program to reflect the City’s actual cost of regulation. Eliminate code that is duplicative or irreconcilable with state-wide adopted building codes Creates an administrative enforcement mechanism for building code violations. Page | 4 Updates existing residential housing standards based on precedent from the Housing Advisory Appeals Board and creates one standard appeal process to a streamlined Board of Appeals and Examiners for any violation of Title 18. Updates portions of Title 21A related to zoning enforcement to reflect existing City Administrative practices and increases daily fines associated with uncorrected zoning violations. The changes were requested during previous Council conversations. In 2022, the City Council requested that the Administration review and propose a change in boarded building fees to capture the full City cost of both monitoring/boarding and emergency services of dangerous/boarded buildings. The majority of these recommended changes in this petition resulted from that request. Additionally, when the Council adopted the Housing Incentives in December of 2023, the Council officially requested the Administration forward a transmittal that would make recommendations for code changes to safeguard that construction work may not damage adjacent properties, establish a process to help remedy situations when damage has occurred, and include penalties that will discourage damage from being done. Changes pertaining to this request are included in Section 2 Building Code Enforcement Process, of the information below (pages 2- 3). Please note, the majority of the Consolidated Fee Schedule (CFS) will be discussed by the Council on June 4, 2024. If the Council is supportive of adopting both of these items, staff will prepare motions to ensure there are not conflicts between the two ordinances. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 1. Boarded Building Amendments Proposed Fee o The City’s Finance Department conducted a cost analysis and found that each boarded building permit costs the City $15,551 annually. This was updated in March 2024 based on additional review by the Finance Department. The original estimate noted in the Planning Commission staff report was $22,537. The cost to the City includes zoning enforcement for weeds and other maintenance issues, public safety calls & responses (due to trespassing or fires), permit review for boarding, and monitoring for building requirements, etc. o The Fee Study recommended a maximum proposed fee increase to be $14,000 due to small claims collections requirements. o The current renewal fee is $1,546. o Building services is recommending potential boarding registration fee increases up to $14,000 per year. ($14,850 for a contributing structure or landmark site) o This fee will be listed in the Consolidated Fee Schedule. (CFS) Program Changes o Changing the program from an annual boarding permit to an annual registration. A registry more accurately reflects the nature of the City’s monitoring and regulation, since boarding does not necessarily occur every year (as a permit suggests). o Recording notices against the title for properties on the registry to let any interested buyer know that (1) the property is subject to the registry with annual registration fees, Page | 5 and (2) that boarding costs actually incurred by the City may be outstanding (which fees could be a lien against the title once sent to the Salt Lake County Treasurer). o Incorporates a standard citation and appeal process if the registration is not current, which will be the same for any Title 18 violation (found in Chapters 18.24 and 18.12). 2. Building Code Enforcement Process (Chapters 18.12, 18.24, and 2.21, and Section 5.14.125) Based on several factors ranging from updated state building code, process streamlining and improvements as well as staffing needs, significant updates to this section of the City code were needed. The proposed changes include the following: o The Board of Appeals and Examiners has been streamlined to require only one appeal hearing officer, along with the building official as an ex-officio member (this building official status on the board is consistent with state-adopted building code). o The Housing Advisory Appeals Board is being eliminated in favor of one appeal body – the Board of Appeals and Examiners (which the City must have according to state-adopted building code) – to reduce administrative burden and keep appeal processes consistent. o A standard appeal process for any violation of Title 18 has been added to Chapter 18.12. This process is nearly identical to an appeal of an administrative decision made pursuant to Title 21A. o A fines-only appeal process for any violation of Title 18 has been added to Chapter 18.12. This process is identical to the fines-only appeal process for a zoning code violation. The following changes address the council’s request to “safeguard that construction work may not damage adjacent properties” o Significant changes to Chapter 18.24 were made to describe the City’s remedies in the event of a violation of Title 18, which will now include a civil citation and civil fines process. This process is nearly identical to the process for citing and fining individuals and businesses for zoning violations. o New fines are being adopted now that a civil citation process has been created within Title 18. General violations will be $100 per day; violation of a stop work order will be $250 per day; housing code (Chapter 18.50) violations will be between $50 and $200 per day depending on the severity of the violation. o Currently Title 18 only permits enforcement by stop work order and criminal proceedings. o With these new standardized enforcement and appeal processes, in addition to the criminal proceedings, the City will have a more effective tool to get properties and construction projects into compliance. The current cost for criminal violations of the building code is a $1,000 fine, double permit fees, a stop work order, or a re-inspection fee of $75.00. Implementation of the assessment of daily fines for civil violations will make the fines high enough that they will not be ignored by the property owner or contractor. This will give us a better enforcement tool for future construction violations and decrease the number of violations not rectified. 3. Housing Code Updates (Chapters 18.50 and 18.96) Page | 6 These proposed changes will update code references in Chapter 18.50 to conform with the Utah adopted International Construction Codes (ICC). They also incorporate the standard citation appeal process for Title 18 violations. Residential rental housing owners will receive a warning notice before a citation is issued. 4. Removal of Duplicative or Overlapping Code Since it’s been decades since Title 18 was comprehensively updated, old and outdated sections have been removed. 5. Zoning Code Enforcement  Parts of the zoning enforcement chapter (Chapter 21A.20) are necessary to reflect Building Services updated civil citation and fine process for Title 18. o Building Services’ current citation process is now reflected, including when a notice and order can be issued, what it needs to include, how it needs to be sent, and a recipient’s ability to appeal the notice and order. o Zoning violations fines are being increased from $25 to $50 per day for residential properties and from $100 to $200 per day for commercial properties. o A new fine amount for failing to have a certificate of appropriateness for work on the exterior of historic district properties is proposed at $50 per day, but if the work that was done is a full or partial demolition of a contributing or landmark structure, then the fine would be $250 per day. (The enforcement process and fines for work done without a certificate of appropriateness was recently updated and approved by the Council when they adopted the amendments related to enforcement of work done without a Certificate of Appropriateness. The fine is $250 per day for full or partial demolition of a contributing structure without a certificate of appropriateness and $500 per day for full or partial demolition of a landmark site without a certificate of appropriateness. CAN Staff will send an updated ordinance that matches the recent changes made by the Council) o Clarifying that citation notices can be sent by any reputable mail tracking service that confirms delivery, as opposed to just by “certified mail” or “commercial courier service.” POLICY QUESTIONS 1. Amendments proposed based on the Council’s request to “safeguard that construction work may not damage adjacent properties” include creating civil citations and fine process. (section 2 above) Do these changes address the concerns raised by the Council? What additional remedies could be available if there is a property line dispute between adjacent property owners? Could a provision be added that would require immediate repairs if any damage is done? 2. The Administration had proposed a preferred fee for the boarded building registration. Page 4 of the transmittal letter says notes Building Services is recommending potential boarding registration fee increases in the range of $3,000, $6,000, or $14,000 per year. The table at the end of the draft ordinance has the fee listed as $14,000. This fee will be listed in the CFS. The Council may wish to ask the Administration what their recommended fee is. 3. In previous discussions the potential of having a different fee for residential vs. commercial boarded/dangerous buildings was raised. The intent of the higher fee is to discourage property Page | 8 owners from keeping buildings that attract nuisance issues. Staff time that goes into enforcement for residential and commercial basically is the same. The Council may wish to ask the administration to explain if one fee is recommended or if it makes sense to have a different fee for commercial vs. residential. If a building is not boarded for a full year, is there a discount or pro-rated refund of fees paid? 4. Building Services is recommending a potential boarding registration fee of $14,850 for a contributing structure or landmark site. $850 more than a typical building. The Council may want to ask the Administration why the fee for a contributing structure or landmark site has a higher proposed fee. 1 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1 SALT LAKE CITY ORDINANCE 2 No. _____ of 202___ 3 4 (An ordinance amending the text of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code to 5 modernize the administration, enforcement, and appeals procedures applicable to the state 6 construction codes) 7 8 An ordinance amending the text of Titles 2, 5, 18, and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code to 9 modernize the administration, enforcement, and appeals procedures applicable to the state 10 construction codes pursuant to Petition No. PLNPM2023-00868. 11 WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Planning Commission (“Planning Commission”) held a 12 public hearing on January 24, 2024 to consider a petition by the Salt Lake City Council (“City 13 Council”) to amend various provisions of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code 14 pursuant to Petition No. PLNPM2023-00868; and 15 WHEREAS, at its January 24, 2024 meeting, the Planning Commission voted in favor of 16 transmitting a positive recommendation to the City Council on said petition; and 17 WHEREAS, after a public hearing on this matter the City Council has determined that 18 adopting this ordinance is in the city’s best interests. 19 NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah: 20 SECTION 1. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.04. That Chapter 21 18.04 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Administration and General 22 Provisions) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 23 CHAPTER 18.04 24 ADMINISTRATION AND GENERAL PROVISIONS 25 26 18.04.010: DIVISION OF BUILDING AND HOUSING SERVICES; ADMINISTRATIVE 27 DUTIES: 28 This title establishes the duties of the division of building and housing services. 2 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 29 30 18.04.020: DEFINITIONS: 31 A. Where undefined terms are used in this title, the definitions of "Webster's 32 Unabridged Collegiate Dictionary" shall apply. 33 B. In addition thereto, aAll words and phrases defined in this section chapter shall be 34 given such defined meanings wherever used in this title, including the following: 35 BUILDING OFFICIAL: Means and refers to the director of the division of building and housing 36 services, or his/her designee. 37 DEVELOPMENT: any building activity or clearing of land as an adjunct of construction. 38 DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY: shall have the same meaning as defined in Utah Code §10-9a- 39 103 or its successor provisions. 40 DIVISION: Means and refers to the division of building and housing services of the city. 41 ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL: any person employed by and authorized by the city to enforce 42 violations of state law or this title, including, but not limited to, building inspectors, the building 43 official, fire marshals, and civil enforcement officers. 44 NONCOMPLIANT PROPERTY: property where one or more violations of this title have 45 occurred or are currently occurring. 46 NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE: a document, in any form, giving notice to interested parties 47 that one or more violations of city code exist on the noncompliant property. 48 PERSON: any individual, receiver, assignee, trustee in bankruptcy, trust, estate firm, co- 49 partnership, joint venture, club, company, joint stock company, business trust, limited liability 50 company, corporation, association, legal entity, society or other group of individuals acting as a 51 unit, whether mutual, cooperative, fraternal, nonprofit or otherwise. 52 RESPONSIBLE PARTY: means the person(s) determined by the city who is responsible for 53 causing, maintaining, or allowing the continuation of a violation of this title. This may include, 54 but is not limited to, a property owner, agent, tenant, lessee, occupant, architect, builder, 55 contractor, business owner, or other person who individually or together with another person is 56 responsible for causing, maintaining, or allowing the continuation or a violation of any provision 57 of the code. 58 59 18.04.030: APPLICATION OF PROVISIONS: RESERVED 60 This title applies to the construction, alteration, moving, demolition, repair and use of any 61 building or structure and the equipment therein within Salt Lake City's jurisdiction, including 62 portable dwellings, mobile homes, trailers, and mobile home parks. 3 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 63 18.04.040: TECHNICAL CONSTRUCTION CODES; ADOPTION, ADMINISTRATION 64 AND ENFORCEMENT BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION CODES ADOPTED: 65 The following codes, as adopted by the State of Utah, along with any adopted appendices are 66 hereby adopted as part of the code of Salt Lake City: 67 The International Building Code, as promulgated by Title 15A of the Utah State Code; 68 The International Residential Code, as promulgated by Title 15A of the Utah State Code; 69 The International Fire Code; 70 International Existing Building Code; 71 International Energy Conservation Code; 72 International Fuel Gas Code; 73 National Electrical Code; 74 The International Mechanical Code; 75 The International Plumbing Code; 76 The International Swimming Pool and Spa Code; 77 Rule R156-56 of the Utah Administrative Code; 78 ICC/MBI 1205-2021 Standard for Off-Site Construction: Inspection and Regulatory 79 Compliance, or its successor, and 80 1997 Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings 81 This title provides for the adoption, administration, and enforcement of the technical construction 82 codes referenced herein. Each of the referenced technical codes bears a legal influence over 83 details of the design, construction, alteration, occupancy, use, repair and maintenance of 84 buildings, structures, and certain equipment therein. Each of the referenced technical codes 85 provides minimum standards and practical safeguards and provisions against threats to life and 86 limb, health, safety, property, and public welfare. Wherever in these codes reference is made to 87 an appendix, the provisions of the appendix shall apply. 88 89 18.04.050: EQUIPMENT INSTALLATION SPECIFICATIONS: RESERVED 90 This title establishes minimum requirements for the installation and maintenance of electrical 91 conductors, fittings, devices and fixtures, herein referred to as "electrical equipment"; for the 92 installation and maintenance of plumbing, heating, cooling, ventilation and refrigeration systems; 93 for the installation and maintenance of fuel piping and energy using equipment; fire protection or 94 fire prevention piping within the corporate limits of the city, and to provide for the enforcement 95 thereof. 96 97 18.04.060: RESOLUTION OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS: 98 Wherever conflicting provisions or requirements of the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040 or 99 the provision of this title occur, the most restrictive provisions or requirements shall govern. In 100 the event a provision of this title conflicts with the codes adopted in Utah Code Title 15A, the 101 provisions of Title 15A shall govern. 4 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 102 18.04.070: LIABILITY LIMITATIONS: 103 Nothing in this title shall be construed to relieve or lessen the responsibility of any contractor, 104 owner, or any other persons involved, for apparatus, construction or equipment installed by or 105 for them, for damages to anyone injured or damaged either in person or property by any defect 106 therein, nor shall the city or any employee thereof be held to assume any liability by reason of 107 the inspections authorized herein, or the certificate of occupancy issued by the building official 108 of the division of building and housing services. The provisions of this title are not intended to 109 interfere with, abrogate, or require enforcement by the city of any legally enforceable easements, 110 covenants, or other agreements between private parties that may restrict the use of the land. 111 Permits or other approvals issued pursuant to this title provide no right to encroach or interfere 112 with the private property of third parties. 113 114 SECTION 2. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.08. That Chapter 115 18.08 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Organization) shall be, and 116 hereby is amended as follows: 117 CHAPTER 18.08 118 ORGANIZATION 119 18.08.010: DIVISION ESTABLISHED; SECTIONS DESIGNATED: 120 There is established, in the department of community and neighborhoods development services, 121 a subordinate division of building and housing services, to be under the supervision of the 122 building official, which division shall be divided into the following sections: . The function of 123 the division shall be the implementation, administration and enforcement of the provisions of this 124 title. 125 A. Construction compliance; 126 B. Zoning compliance; 127 C. Housing preservation. 128 129 18.08.020: POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE DIVISION: 130 The functions of the division of building and housing services shall be: 131 A. To enforce the zoning laws of Salt Lake City and to inspect, or cause to be 132 inspected, all buildings and structures erected, or proposed to be erected in the city; 133 B. To carry out, enforce and perform all duties, provisions and mandates designated, 134 made and set forth in the ordinances of the city concerning zoning, building, plumbing, electrical 5 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 135 and mechanical construction, and construction related fire suppressionrepair, including uniform 136 housing code regulations; 137 C. To examine and approve all plans and specifications before building permits shall 138 be issued, and to execute all permits, certificates and notices required to be issued inspect or 139 cause to be inspected all buildings and structures erected in the city; and 140 D. To examine all applicants for licensing and registration in accordance with 141 requirements of chapter 18.16 of this title, and issue same in accordance with the requirements of 142 this title; and 143 E. To perform all of the functions and have all of the powers required of and 144 conferred on the building official by the ordinances of the city. 145 146 18.08.030: BUILDING OFFICIAL; EMPLOYMENT: 147 The mayor of the city shall employ a qualified building official, construction official, housing 148 official, zoning official, plans examiner, inspector, and such other assistants and clerks as the 149 exigencies of the work employees of the division that may from time to time be required to 150 perform the functions of this title, at such compensation and for such periods of time as the 151 mayor may deem proper. 152 153 18.08.040: BUILDING OFFICIAL; POWERS AND DUTIES: 154 The building official shall maintain public office hours necessary to efficiently administer the 155 provisions of this title and related titles and amendments thereto, and shall perform the following 156 duties: 157 A. Maintain an official register of all persons, firms or corporations lawfully entitled 158 to carry on or engage in the businesses regulated by this title to whom a current license has been 159 issued by the department of contractors of the state; 160 B. Issue building permits to properly licensed, bonded and registered persons, firms 161 or corporations for work to be done within the scope of this title; 162 C. Administer and enforce the provisions of this title in a manner consistent with the 163 intent thereof, and inspect all work authorized by any permit, to assure compliance with 164 provisions of this title or amendments thereto, approving or condemning such work in whole or 165 in part, as conditions require; 166 D. Issue a certificate of approval or certificate of occupancy for all work approved by 167 him/her; 168 E. CondemnRequire correction or and reject all work done or being done, or 169 materials used or being used which do not in all respects comply with the provisions of this title 170 and amendments thereto; 6 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 171 F. Order changes in workmanship and/or materials essential to obtain compliance 172 with all provisions of this title; 173 G. Investigate any construction or work regulated by this title and issue such notices 174 and/or stop work orders which are necessary to prevent or to correct dangerous or unsanitary 175 conditions; 176 H. Recommend revocation of contractor licenses to the state department of business 177 regulation for cause; 178 I. Authorize any utility to make necessary connections for power, water or gas to all 179 applicants for such power or water in the city, when the installation and all facets of the 180 construction or remodel project conform to this title; and 181 J. Verify that buildings not built on site in Salt Lake City (Factory Built Buildings) 182 are built, inspected, and installed in accordance with the "ICC/MBI Standard for Off-Site 183 Construction: Planning, Design, Fabrication and Assembly", or its successor document. In order 184 for the building official to allow occupancy of qualifying structures, units delivered on site must 185 be provided with a permanently affixed tag identifying the technical code versions, with Utah 186 State Amendments, under which they were built. Individuals making the inspections must be 187 certified and licensed Bbuilding Iinspectors in the State of Utah.; and 188 K. The building official may render interpretations of this title and adopt and enforce 189 rules and supplemental regulations pursuant to adopted state construction codes to clarify the 190 application of its provisions. Such interpretations, rules and regulations shall conform to the 191 intent and purpose of this title, and shall be made available in writing for public inspection upon 192 request. 193 194 18.08.050: BUILDING OFFICIAL; DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY: 195 The building official may delegate any of his/her powers and duties to the construction official, 196 housing official, zoning official, plans examiner, inspectors and assistants, who shall enforce all 197 of the provisions of this title. 198 199 18.08.060: BUILDING OFFICIAL; UTILITY DISCONNECTION AUTHORITY: 200 The building official, or the building official's authorized representative, shall have the authority 201 to disconnect or order discontinuance of any utility service or energy supply to buildings, 202 structures or equipment therein regulated by this code, in cases of emergency or where necessary 203 for safety to protect life and property. Such utility service shall be discontinued until the 204 equipment, appliances, devices, piping or wiring found to be defective, or defectively installed, 205 are removed or restored to a safe conditionemergency or threat to life or property has ceased. 206 207 18.08.070: DEVIATION FROM REGULATIONS AUTHORIZED WHEN: 7 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 208 Where conditions are extremely adverse to full compliance with the regulations of this title, the 209 building official may grant special permission in writing to deviate from the regulations, 210 provided that in the judgment of the building official such deviation does not create an 211 unsanitary or unsafe condition, and further provided the request for deviation is submitted for 212 approval in writing in advance of the construction or installation. 213 214 18.08.080: DIVISION; RECORD KEEPING AND ACCOUNTING: 215 An itemized account of the business and transactions of the division, the expenses thereof, and 216 the income therefrom for the preceding month shall be made and filed with the mayor each 217 month. Annual reports shall be made and filed with the mayor each year, in the same manner as 218 monthly reports. 219 220 18.08.090: DIVISION; BOOKS, PAPERS AND EQUIPMENT: 221 The city shall provide such instruments, books, papers and equipment as shall be necessary for 222 the proper performance of the duties of the members of the division. The building official shall 223 have charge and control of the books, instruments, papers and equipment used and employed in 224 the division, and shall deliver the same to his/her successor in office. 225 226 18.08.100070: BUILDING OFFICIAL; LIABILITY LIMITATIONS: 227 The building official, or his/her assistantsappeals hearing officer, fines hearing officer, or 228 enforcement officials, when acting for the city in good faith and without malice in the discharge 229 of his/her duties, shall not thereby render himself/herself liable personally, and the building 230 official is same are hereby relieved from all personal liability for any damage that may accrue to 231 persons or property as a result of any act required or by reason of any act or omission in the 232 discharge of such official's duties. 233 234 18.08.110080: BUILDING OFFICIAL; RIGHT OF ENTRY FOR INSPECTIONS: 235 The building official and any enforcement official, or his/her authorized assistants, shall have the 236 right of entry, within reasonable hours, to any building or premises for the purpose of inspection, 237 or to investigate any work or conditions governed by this title. 238 239 18.08.120090: BUILDING OFFICIAL; CONFLICT OF INTEREST PROHIBITED: 240 The building official and his/her assistants shall not in any way engage in the sale or installation 241 of equipment or supplies upon which they are required to make inspection under this code. 8 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 242 SECTION 3. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.12. That Chapter 243 18.12 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Board of Appeals and 244 Examiners) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 245 246 CHAPTER 18.12 247 BOARD OF APPEALS AND EXAMINERS 248 18.12.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: 249 The provisions of chapter 2.07 of this title shall apply to the board of appeals and examiners 250 except as otherwise set forth in this chapter. 251 252 18.12.020: BOARD OF APPEALS CREATED; PURPOSE AND AUTHORITY: 253 In order to (1) hear and decide appeals of orders, decisions or determinations made by the 254 building official relative to the application and interpretation of this title, including any state 255 construction code adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040, or (2) hear and decide appeals of 256 orders by enforcement officials, there shall be and is hereby created a board of appeals and 257 examiners comprised of an appeals hearing officer and the building official. The building official 258 shall be an ex officio member of said board but shall not have a vote on any matter before the 259 board. The mayor may appoint more than one appeals hearing officer, but only one appeals 260 hearing officer shall consider and decide upon any matter before the board. The appeals hearing 261 officer may serve consecutive four year terms upon the advice of the mayor and consent of the 262 city council. The appeals hearing officer need not be a resident of Salt Lake City. The board shall 263 provide for reasonable interpretations of the provisions of this title and the appeals hearing 264 officer shall be, and to determine the suitability of alternates, there shall be created a board of 265 appeals and examiners, hereinafter called "board", consisting of five (5) members who are 266 qualified by experience and training to pass upon matters pertaining to building construction, 267 housing, and abatement codes and technical disciplines set forth in this titletherein. One board 268 member shall be a LEED accredited professional. The board shall hear and decide appeals where 269 it is alleged there is an error in any order, requirement, decision or determination made by an 270 administrative official in the enforcement of this title. The board may also recommend new 271 ordinances to the city council. 272 273 18.12.030: MEMBERSHIP; TERMPROCEDURE FOR APPEALS TO THE BOARD OF 274 APPEALS & EXAMINERS: 275 Appeals of decisions by the building official or enforcement officials shall be taken in 276 accordance with the following procedures: 9 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 277 A. Form: The appeal shall be filed using an application form provided by the 278 building official. To be considered complete, the application must include all information 279 required on the application, including but not limited to identification of the order, decision or 280 determination being appealed, the alleged error made by stating each fact and every theory of 281 relief on appeal and one or more reasons the appellant claims the administrative decision is in 282 error. Incomplete applications will not be accepted. 283 B. Filing: The application must be submitted as indicated on the form by the 284 applicable deadline, together with all applicable fees as set forth in the Salt Lake City 285 consolidated fee schedule. The applicant shall also be responsible for payment of 286 all fees established for providing the public notice required by the Utah Open and Public 287 Meetings Act, in accordance with the consolidated fee schedule, including costs of mailing, 288 preparation of mailing labels and all other costs relating to notification. All fees are due at the 289 time of filing the appeal. An appeal will not be considered complete until all applicable fees are 290 paid. 291 C. Parties Entitled to Appeal. An applicant, a board or officer of the city, or an 292 adversely affected party, as that term is defined by Utah Code 10-9a-103, or its successor, may 293 appeal. 294 D. Time for Filing an Appeal; Time for Hearing: The deadline for filing a complete 295 application for appeal is 10 days from the date of the decision, determination or order. Each 296 appeal shall be reviewed informally by the board no later than 45 days from the date of filing of 297 a written appeal, unless a later date is agreed to by the parties. Failure of any person to file an 298 appeal in accordance with the provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's 299 right to an appeal. 300 E. Notice Required. Upon receipt of an appeal the board of appeals and examiners 301 shall schedule and hold a public hearing in accordance with the standards and procedures for 302 conducting public hearings set forth in Chapter 21A.10. 303 F. Standard of Review. The board shall conduct each appeal de novo. The 304 appellant has the burden of proving the decision appealed is incorrect. The board shall render a 305 decision based upon the applicable law. The board shall afford due process to the parties on 306 appeal. Each party may call such witnesses and present such evidence as it deems appropriate, 307 provided such evidence is not unduly cumulative or irrelevant as determined by the board. 308 Hearings shall be conducted informally. After hearing all evidence and legal arguments 309 presented by the parties, the board shall apply the plain language of the applicable law and 310 issue a written decision on the merits of all theories of relief the appellant raised in the appeal. 311 G. Effect of Decision. The decision of the board is a final decision of the city, 312 appealable to district court. No person may challenge in district court any order, decision, or 313 enforcement action taken pursuant to this title unless and until that person has exhausted the 314 administrative remedies provided by this chapter. 315 H. Procedures. The proceedings of each appeal hearing shall be recorded and such 316 recordings shall be retained for a period that is consistent with city retention policies and any 317 applicable retention requirements set forth in state law. The building official shall adopt 10 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 318 policies and procedures, consistent with the provisions of this chapter, for processing appeals, 319 the conduct of an appeal hearing, and for any other purpose considered necessary to properly 320 consider an appeal. 321 I. No Automatic Stay: Filing an appeal does not stay the decision appealed, unless a 322 provision of this title specifically states otherwise. 323 J. Requesting a Stay: The board may grant a request submitted by any party to the 324 appeal to stay a decision of the building official or enforcement official for a specified period of 325 time or until the board issues a decision, if the requesting party can show a stay is necessary to 326 prevent substantial harm to the requesting party. No request is required if a provision of this title 327 imposes an automatic stay upon the filing of an appeal with the board. If a stay is requested, the 328 board shall make reasonable efforts to determine whether a stay is appropriate within 10 days of 329 the appeal being deemed complete. If the board does not decide a request for a stay within 10 330 days of the appeal being deemed complete, the request shall be presumed denied. No stay will be 331 authorized for incomplete appeals or appeals filed after the appeal deadline. 332 Members of the board shall hold office for five (5) years. The building official shall be an ex 333 officio member of the board, and shall act as secretary. 334 335 18.12.040: BOARD DECISIONS: 336 The board of appeals shall render all decisions and findings in writing to the parties within 14 337 days of the hearing on the appealbuilding official and appellants. 338 339 18.12.050: APPEALS OF CIVIL FINES & ABATEMENT COSTS: 340 341 A. Powers and Duties of Fines Hearing Officer: The fines hearing officer, appointed 342 pursuant to Section 21A.06.090, may hear and decide appeals of civil fines and abatement costs 343 imposed pursuant to this title. As set forth in this section, the fines hearing officer may affirm 344 civil fines, reduce civil fines, and approve civil fine payment schedules. The fines hearing officer 345 may affirm or reduce an abatement statement of costs and may approve abatement cost payment 346 schedules. 347 B. Right to Appear: Any responsible party receiving a notice and order or statement 348 of abatement costs may appear before a fines hearing officer to appeal the amount of the civil 349 fine or abatement cost imposed by submitting a statement of appeal on a form provided by the 350 division of building services. However, in the case of civil fines, no party may appear before a 351 fines hearing officer until violations identified have been corrected. Appeals to a fines hearing 352 officer contesting the amount of the civil fine imposed must be filed within 30 days from the date 353 of compliance. Appeals to a fines hearing officer contesting the statement of abatement costs 354 must be filed within 20 days from the date the statement of costs is delivered, but the only issue 355 on such appeal is the amount of such costs and not the city’s determination to incur abatement 356 costs. Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the provisions of this section 357 shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. 11 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 358 C. Responsibility: Commencement of any action to remove or reduce civil fines shall 359 not relieve the responsibility of any responsible party to correct the violation or make payment of 360 accrued civil fines nor shall it require the city to reissue any of the notices required by this 361 chapter. 362 D. Reduction of Civil Fine: Civil fines may be reduced at the discretion of the fines 363 hearing officer after the violation is corrected and if any of the following conditions exist: 364 1. Strict compliance with the notice and order would have caused an 365 imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property; 366 2. The violation and inability to correct the same were both caused by a force 367 majeure event such as war, act of nature, strike or civil disturbance; 368 3. A change in the actual ownership of the property was recorded with the 369 Salt Lake County Recorder's Office after a notice of violation was issued and the new 370 property owner is not related by blood, marriage or common ownership to the prior 371 owner; or 372 4. Such other mitigating circumstances as determined by the fines hearing 373 officer. 374 E. Notice Required. Upon receipt of an appeal of a statement of abatement costs the 375 fines hearing officer shall schedule and hold a public hearing in accordance with the standards 376 and procedures for conducting public hearings set forth in Chapter 21A.10. 377 F. Payment Schedule: At the request of a responsible party subject to civil fines or 378 abatement costs governed by this title, the fines hearing officer may approve a payment schedule 379 for the delayed or periodic payment of the applicable civil fine or abatement costs to 380 accommodate the person's unique circumstances or ability to pay. 381 G. Failure to Comply with Payment Schedule: If a payment schedule has been 382 developed by the fines hearing officer, the failure by a person to submit any 2 payments as 383 scheduled shall cause the entire amount of the original civil fine or abatement cost to become 384 immediately due, less any payments actually made. 385 18.12.060: JUDICIAL REVIEW OF BOARD'S DECISIONS: 386 The city, or any person aggrieved by any decision of the board or fines hearing officer as to 387 abatement costs, may appeal to district courthave and maintain an action for relief therefrom in a 388 court of competent jurisdiction, provided a so long as the petition for such relief is filed 389 withpresented to the court within thirty (30) days of the board’s or fines hearing officer’s 390 decisionafter the filing of such decision in the office of the board. 12 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 391 SECTION 4. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.16. That Chapter 392 18.16 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Registration and Licenses) 393 shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 394 395 CHAPTER 18.16 396 REGISTRATION AND LICENSES 397 398 ARTICLE I. CONTRACTOR REGISTRATION 399 400 18.16.010: REGISTRATION; PREREQUISITE TO BUILDING WORK: 401 It is unlawful for any person, firm or corporation to perform any work requiring a permit from 402 the city division of building and housing services without first having registered with the 403 building official. 404 405 18.16.0210: STATE CONTRACTOR LICENSE REQUIRED: 406 Except as provided in Section 18.20.070, eEvery applicant for registration a permit issued 407 pursuant to this title shall furnish evidence that such applicant is currently licensed under the 408 provisions of the Utah contractor's license law as it presently exists or hereafter may be 409 amended, giving the classification and number of the license, and shall have secured all licenses 410 required by the ordinances of Salt Lake City. 411 412 18.16.0240: EXCAVATION BOND REQUIRED: 413 Any person, firm or corporation properly licensed to do business in accordance with this title 414 who in the course of their work has occasion to excavate in the city streets, alleys or rights of 415 way shall file an additional bond with the city in the amount of ten thousand dollars 416 ($10,000.00), or such larger amount as the city engineermayor may require. 417 418 18.16.050: FEE FOR REGISTRATION: 419 Each person, firm or corporation required to register in accordance with this chapter shall pay a 420 registration fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule for each fiscal year, or 421 part thereof. 13 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 422 18.16.0360: LICENSE AND REGISTRATION NOT TRANSFERABLE: 423 It is unlawful for any contractor to use such contractor's license or registration or to allow his/her 424 license to be used in any way for the purpose of procuring a license bond, registration or permit 425 for any person other than such contractor. 426 427 18.16.0470: SALE OF UNAPPROVED MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT PROHIBITED: 428 It is unlawful for any dealer or person to sell, deliver or offer for sale any mechanical equipment 429 or apparatus that has not been approved by a recognized listing agency. 430 431 SECTION 5. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.20. That Chapter 432 18.20 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Permits and Inspections) 433 shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 434 435 CHAPTER 18.20 436 PERMITS AND INSPECTIONS 437 438 18.20.010: WORK REQUIRING PERMIT: 439 No person, firm or corporation shall erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, improve, 440 remove, convert or demolish any building, structure or premises, or make any installation, 441 alteration or improvement to the electrical, fire, plumbing or mechanical system in a building, 442 structure or premises, or cause the same to be done, without first obtaining the prescribed permits 443 for each such building or structure or premises from the building official. 444 445 18.20.020: EXEMPT WORK DESIGNATED FEES: 446 A. A building permit shall not be required for the following: 447 1. Playhouses and similar uses; 448 2. Oil derricks; 449 3. Movable cases, counters and partitions not over five feet (5') high; 450 4. Retaining walls which are not over two feet (2') in height measured from the bottom of 451 the footing to the top of the wall, unless supporting a surcharge or impounding flammable 452 liquids; 14 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 453 5. Water tanks supported directly upon grade if the capacity does not exceed five thousand 454 (5,000) gallons and the ratio of height to diameter or width does not exceed two to one (2:1); 455 6. Painting, papering and similar finish work; 456 7. Temporary motion picture, television and theater stage sets and scenery; 457 8. Window awnings supported by an exterior wall of group R, division 3, and group M 458 occupancies, when projecting not more than fifty four inches (54"). 459 B. Unless otherwise exempted, separate plumbing, electrical and mechanical permits shall be 460 required for the above exempted items. 461 C. Exemption from the permit requirements of this code shall not be deemed to grant 462 authorization for any work to be done in any manner in violation of the provisions of this code or 463 any other laws or ordinances of this jurisdiction. 464 465 A. Building permit fees shall be based on the total valuation of the proposed project 466 as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 467 B. Plan review fees shall be 65% of the building permit fees. 468 C. Fees to expedite building plan review as governed by Section 18.20.050 shall be 2 469 times the standard building plan review fee. 470 D. Penalties for not obtaining permanent certificate of occupancy will be $300.00 for 471 each month, after the initial 30 day temporary certificate of occupancy, which has no additional 472 cost associated with it; due before the first of the month and only allowed for up to 3 renewals 473 after the initial free 30 day period. Partial months will not be refunded. 474 E. Fees for renewing expired plan review after 180 days as governed by Section 475 18.20.110 shall be shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 476 F. A fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be charged for 477 each permit for fencing. 478 G. Other fees shall consist of electrical, mechanical and plumbing, and fire 479 suppression and monitoring equipment inspection fees as shown on the Salt Lake City 480 consolidated fee schedule. 481 482 18.20.030: APPLICATION; FORM AND FILING: 483 To apply forobtain a building permit the applicant shall first file an application on a form 484 furnished by the building official and pay the requisite fee therefor as established in the Salt Lake 485 City consolidated fee schedule, in writing, on a form furnished for that purpose. 486 487 18.20.040: APPLICATION; PLANS AND OTHER DATA: 488 Each application for a permit shall be accompanied by all required plans, diagrams and other 489 data, in duplicate, unless otherwise required by the building official. The building official may 15 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 490 require the plans and other data to be prepared and designed by an engineer or architect licensed 491 by the state to practice as such. 492 493 18.20.050: APPLICATION; REVIEW; PERMIT ISSUANCE CONDITIONS: 494 A. Application Review: Except as provided in subsection B of this section, the 495 application plans and data filed by an applicant for a building permit shall be checked by the 496 building official. Said application may be reviewed by other government agencies or 497 departments to check compliance with the laws and ordinances under their jurisdiction. If the 498 building official is satisfied that the work described in an application for a building permit and 499 plans filed therewith conform to the requirements of this title and other pertinent ordinances and 500 laws and that the required fees have been paid, the building official shall issue a permit therefor 501 to the applicant. No building permit shall be issued unless and until the plans and specifications 502 comply with all applicable land use regulations, including but not limited to Title 21A. The 503 building official may issue a permit for the construction of part of a building or structure before 504 the entire plans and specifications for the whole building or structure have been submitted or 505 approved, provided adequate information and detailed statements have been filed complying 506 with all pertinent requirements of this title. The holder of such permit shall proceed at his or her 507 own risk without assurance that the permit for the entire building or structure will be granted. 508 B. Expedited Plan Review: A building permit applicant may seek an expedited 509 building plan review, provided that the applicant pay the expedited plan review fee set forth in 510 sSection 18.2032.02035 of this title. The expedited building plan review may be conducted by a 511 qualified third party with significant experience conducting building plan reviews, as selected 512 and approved by the building official. The person(s) assigned to conduct the expedited building 513 plan review shall provide initial comments, including corrections to be made to the building 514 plans, within ten (10) business days of the date the application was filed and all fees paid. 515 C. Plan Review Expiration: If a building permit applicant fails to submit corrected 516 building plans in accordance with the comments and requirements of the building services 517 division or its authorized representative within one hundred eighty (180) days of the division 518 transmitting such comments and requirements to the applicant, or if the applicant fails to pay the 519 required building permit fee within one hundred eighty (180) days of the division informing the 520 applicant that its building plans are approved and the building permit fee is due, the plan review 521 shall expire at the end of such period and the review become null and void. An expired plan 522 review may be renewed, provided that the applicant pay the plan review renewal fee established 523 in sSection 18.2032.020035 of this title, however, no plan review may be renewed after three (3) 524 years from the original submission date or if new versions of the codes adopted pursuant to 525 Section 18.04.040 have come into effect since the prior plan review was conducted. 526 527 18.20.060: PERMIT; ISSUED TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS ONLY: 528 Except as otherwise provided by this title, it is unlawful to issue a permit no building permit shall 529 be issued to any person other than a duly registered licensed contractor licensed to do business 16 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 530 by the state department of business regulation, and registered by the city division of building and 531 housing services by the State of Utah Division of Professional Licensing or its successor. 532 533 18.20.070: HOMEOWNER PERMITS: 534 Any permit required by this title may be issued to any person to do any work regulated by this 535 title in a single-family dwelling used exclusively for such person's living purposes, including the 536 usual accessory buildings and quarters in connection with such buildings, provided that any such 537 person is a bona fide owner of any such dwelling and accessory buildings and quarters, and that 538 the same are occupied or designed to be occupied by such owner, and further provided that the 539 owner shall furnish the building official with a complete layout drawing of the proposed work, 540 satisfy the building official that he or she has a working knowledge of the code requirements, 541 performs the work himself or herself, pays the necessary inspection fees, and calls for all 542 inspections required by this title. 543 544 18.20.080: PERMIT; EFFECT OF ISSUANCE: 545 The issuance of a permit or approval of plans or other data shall not be construed to be a permit 546 for or an approval of any violation of any of the provisions of this title, Title 21A, or any rights 547 of third parties. The issuance of a permit based upon plans and other data shall not prevent the 548 building official from thereafter requiring the correction of errors in said plans and data or from 549 stopping construction activitybuilding operations being carried on thereunder when in violation 550 of this title or any other ordinancelaw. The city shall have no obligation to enforce the rights of 551 third parties or recover damages to third parties due to the acts or omissions of permit holders. 552 553 18.20.090: START OF WORK WITHOUT PERMIT; PENALTY FEES; 554 EMERGENCIES: 555 A. Whenever any work requiring a permit under this title is commenced without a 556 permit first having been obtained the building official may pursue enforcement of this title 557 pursuant to Chapter 18.24. 558 B. Fee Increase When: Whenever any construction or work for which a permit is 559 required by this title is started or commenced without obtaining the prescribed permit, the fees 560 specified in this title may be increased by the building official up to a fee of ten percent (10%) of 561 the valuation of the proposed construction as determined by the building official, or one 562 thousand dollars ($1,000.00), whichever is greater, but the payment of such increased fees shall 563 not relieve any persons from fully complying with the requirements of this title in the execution 564 of the work nor from any other penalties prescribed herein. 565 B. C. Exception; Emergency Work: This provision section shall not apply to 566 emergency work when it shall be proved to the satisfaction of the building official that such work 567 was urgently necessary and that it was not practical to obtain a permit therefor before the 568 commencement of the work. In all such cases, a permit must be obtained as soon as it is practical 17 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 569 to do so, and if there be an unreasonable delay in obtaining a permit, a double fee, as herein 570 provided, shall be charged. 571 572 18.20.100: PERMIT; DENIAL CONDITIONS: 573 The building official may refuse to issue any permit for work governed by this title to any person 574 who has a permit revoked in accordance with this title, or during such time as such person fails 575 to comply with any provision of this title or Title 21A. No permit shall be issued to the 576 responsible party for a property actively subject to enforcement proceedings by the city for 577 violations of this title or Title 21A, except for permits required to correct the violations. 578 579 18.20.110: PERMIT; EXPIRATION AND RENEWAL: 580 Every permit issued by the building official under the provisions of this title shall expire by 581 limitation and become null and void if the building or work authorized by such permit is not 582 commenced within one hundred eighty (180) days from the date of such permit or if the building 583 or work authorized by such permit is suspended or abandoned at any time after the work is 584 commenced for a period of one hundred eighty (180) days. Before such work can be 585 recommenced, the permittee must request that the permit shall first be renewed by the building 586 official and the fee therefor shall be one-half (1/2) the amount required for a new permit for such 587 work. Such renewal may be granted if such request is made prior to the permit expiring upon the 588 permittee demonstrating justifiable cause for the renewal, and provided no changes have been 589 made or will be made in the original plans or scope of such work. Such renewal shall be denied if 590 such request is made after the permit has expired and (1), and provided no changes have 591 occurred relative to other municipal regulations impacting the use, size, yard, space or other 592 requirements concerning the proposed structure or development have changed since the permit 593 was issued, (2) material changes have been made or will be made in the original plans or scope 594 of work, or (3) justifiable cause does not exist to allow the project to be renewed. In connection 595 with renewing a permit that pertains to construction of a new structure or substantial exterior 596 alteration of a site the building official may impose reasonable conditions regarding a deadline to 597 complete the work, posting of a bond, erection of fences, securing methods, and similar 598 conditions to mitigate the hazards of and limit the nuisances of ongoing construction. Whenever 599 a construction permit is taken out in order to resolve the violation(s) specified in a notice and 600 order, the expiration date for the permit shall coincide with the time limit for resolution of the 601 violation(s) contained in the notice and order. 602 603 18.20.120: PERMIT; NOT TRANSFERABLE: 604 Building permits are non-transferable without completion of a permit transfer document 605 approved by the building official. When any work construction activity regulated by this title is 606 not completed by the permittee identified inunder the permit and is insteadissued to him or her 607 for the work and the work in question is added to or completed by any other personone or more 608 contractors, such personeach contractor shall procure a permit to cover the work he or she 609 performs. 18 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 610 611 18.20.130: PERMIT; SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION: 612 The building official may, in writing, suspend or revoke a permit issued under provisions of this 613 title whenever the permit is issued in error, or on the basis of incorrect inaccurate information 614 supplied, or upon a finding of ain violation of any ordinance or regulation of any of the 615 provisions of this title or Title 21A. 616 617 18.20.140: HEARING ON DENIAL OR REVOCATION OF PERMIT: 618 Any person adversely affected by the action of the building official made pursuant to Section 619 18.20.130in accordance with the preceding sections may appeal pursuant to Chapter 18.12to the 620 board of appeals and examiners for a hearing upon such revocation or denial, except that an 621 appeal of a revocation or suspension of a building permit based upon a finding of a violation of 622 Title 21A shall be made to the appeals hearing officer as set forth in Chapter 21A.16. 623 624 18.20.150: INSPECTION OF WORK: 625 A. All construction, work and equipment for which a permit is required shall be 626 subject to inspections by the building official. The building official may make or require any 627 inspection of any construction work to ascertain compliance with the provisions of this title and 628 other laws which are enforced by the division. 629 B. No construction, work or equipment regulated by this title shall be connected to 630 any energy, fuel or power supply or water system or sewer system until authorized by the 631 building official. 632 C. Prior to issuance of a building permit or during construction aA survey of any lot 633 or parcel may be required by the building official to verify compliance of structures with 634 approved plans. 635 D. The building official shall not be liable for any expense entailed in the removal or 636 replacement of any material required to allow an inspection. 637 E. If a property subject to a building permit is open and unattended, such that 638 unauthorized persons are accessing the property, or the open nature of the work poses a risk to 639 the health, safety, and welfare of the public, the building official shall order the owner of the 640 property to immediately secure the property, including by fencing and boarding, by issuing a 641 notice and order in accordance with Section 18.24.040. If the property is not secured within the 642 cure period set forth in the notice and order, which shall not be less than 10 days, then the city 643 may secure the property and recover its costs in accordance with Section 18.48.100. 644 645 18.20.160: APPROVALS REQUIRED FOR ONGOING CONSTRUCTION: 19 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 646 No work shall be done on any part of the building or structure beyond the point indicated in each 647 successive inspection without first obtaining the written approval of the building official. Such 648 written approval shall be given only after an inspection shall have been made of each successive 649 step in the construction as indicated by each of the inspections required by the building official. 650 651 18.20.170: REQUESTS FOR INSPECTIONS: 652 The building official may require that every request for the inspection be madefiled at least one 653 day before such inspection is required and in such method as prescribed by the building official. 654 Such request may be in writing or by telephone. It shall be the duty of the person requesting any 655 inspections required by this title to provide access to and means for proper inspection of such 656 work. Nothing in this section shall be construed to require the building official to perform an 657 inspection within the notice period provided herein. 658 659 18.20.180: INSPECTION RECORD CARD:RESERVED 660 Work requiring a permit shall not be commenced until the permit holder or his or her agent shall 661 have posted an inspection record card in a conspicuous place on the front premises, or on an 662 electrical service panel, and in such position as to allow the director conveniently to make the 663 required entries thereon regarding inspection of the work. This card shall be maintained in such 664 position by the permit holder until the building or structure is completed and ready for 665 occupancy. 666 667 18.20.190: FINAL INSPECTION AND CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: 668 There shall be aA final inspection and building official approval are required on all buildings and 669 structures requiring a building permit prior towhen completed and ready for occupancy. A fFinal 670 inspection approval shall be issued in the form of a certificate of occupancy. A building or 671 structure shall not be used or occupied in whole or in part, and a change in occupancy of a 672 building or structure or portion thereof shall not be, until the building official has issued a 673 certificate of occupancy therefor. A certificate of occupancy may, upon notice, be revoked by the 674 building official if the building official finds that any construction, work or equipment fails in 675 any respect to comply with the requirements of this title, or that the installation is unsafe, 676 dangerous, or a hazard to life or propertyelements of the property for which a certificate was 677 issued have been changed or modified, including a change in occupancy classification, without 678 obtaining the requisite permits required by this title. A certificate of occupancy shall be issued as 679 specified in the adopted uniform building code, as amended. 680 681 18.20.200: REINSPECTIONS AND FEES: 682 A. A reinspection fee may be assessed: 683 1. When the approved plans are not readily available to the inspector; 20 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 684 2. For failure to provide access on the date for which the inspection is 685 required; 686 3. For deviating from plans requiring the approval of the building official. 687 B. In instances where reinspection fees have been assessed or reinspection is 688 necessary, no additional inspection of the work will be performed until the required fees have 689 been paid and the permittee calls for a reinspection. The reinspection charge shall be shown on 690 the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule and not exceed the amount shown on the Salt Lake 691 City consolidated fee schedule for each additional inspection required. 692 693 18.20.210: CLEANUP AND PROTECTION OF PUBLIC RIGHTS OF WAY: 694 A. Each permit holder shall be responsible to see that vehicles used in the process of 695 carrying out the work authorized by the permit shall not track any mud, dirt or debris of any kind 696 upon any streets or sidewalks within the corporate limits of Salt Lake City Corporation unless a 697 permit has been obtained from the city engineer for use of a designated portion of the right of 698 way with provisions made to keep that portion of the right of way and adjacent areas cleared of 699 mud, dirt or debris of any kind. The permittee shall install a suitable process to clean the wheels 700 of the equipment prior to its leaving the job site and entering the streets of Salt Lake City 701 Corporation. The suitable process shall consist of: 702 1. A cleaning area and crew to clean mud and dirt off the wheels and exterior 703 body surface of the trucks, or its equivalent; 704 2. The cleaning area shall be arranged to furnish adequate draining to prevent 705 puddling; the cleaning area shall be kept mud free and may be on a macadam or concrete 706 slab; 707 3. The cleaning area shall be located on private property and arranged in 708 such a way that there is no blocking of vehicular or pedestrian traffic on city rights of 709 way except where permission has been granted by the city engineer; 710 4. The cleaning water or solution used for cleaning shall not be allowed to 711 enter the city streets, gutter, or storm drain or sanitary sewer system. 712 B. All trucks and equipment leaving the site with earthen materials or loose debris 713 shall be loaded and/or covered in such a manner as to prevent dropping of materials on city 714 streets and/or sidewalks. 715 C. Ramps constructed over curbs and gutters shall not interfere with or block the 716 passage of water along the gutter and shall be constructed of asphalt material that will not erode 717 or deteriorate under adverse weather conditions. 718 D. The permit holder shall install erosion and water runoff controls sufficient to 719 ensure that no stormwater, surface water, sediments or debris from the construction site shall 720 drain or wash or be tracked into any public right of way or other adjacent properties, including 721 curb and gutter, unless permission has been granted through the erosion control plan. These 722 controls shall be sufficient to cover any contingency, including, but not limited to, seasonal 21 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 723 storms, unseasonal storms, or methods of construction. The director of building and housing 724 servicesbuilding official or the city engineer may require, when in his/her discretion he/she 725 deems necessary, an erosion control plan to be submitted for approval. Such plan may be 726 required any time during construction and must be submitted within five (5) days of the request. 727 The director of building and housingbuilding official or the city engineer may suspend all work 728 until the plan requested is approved. The permit holder will maintain all erosion control facilities 729 throughout the life of the construction project. He/she will monitor their effectiveness after 730 storms and make the necessary adjustments to ensure they function correctly. 731 E. The sidewalk and/or curb and gutter shall not be used for storage of debris, dirt or 732 excavated materials. In addition, the sidewalks shall not be removed, blocked or otherwise 733 rendered unusable by either the storage of construction equipment or materials or the 734 construction procedures used, unless a safe, usable alternate walkway along the same side of the 735 street is provided by the contractor unless a permit has been issued by the city engineer's office. 736 All alternate walkways shall be ramped in accordance with handicap ramp requirements and so 737 constructed as to provide an all weather walking surface 4four feet (4') wide as sound and 738 smooth as the normal concrete sidewalk. 739 F. The permit holder shall be responsible for the immediate removal of mud, dirt or 740 debris deposited on city streets, sidewalks and/or curb and gutters by equipment leaving the site 741 or by the permit holder's construction procedures. 742 G. If it becomes necessary for the city street crews to remove any mud, dirt, or debris 743 which has been deposited upon a street or sidewalk of Salt Lake City Corporation, the total cost 744 to the city of such removal will be charged to the property owner or contractor (permit holder), 745 including legal fees, if any. Payment of such charges will be made to the city prior to 746 certification of final inspections, utility clearances, and issuance of a certificate of occupancy. 747 H. The director of building and housing servicesbuilding official or the city engineer 748 is empowered to suspend any permit until the permit holder installs the necessary cleaning 749 equipment and/or erosion control facilities to ensure that no dust or debris is deposited upon the 750 streets and sidewalks of Salt Lake City Corporation. Such device shall operate in a manner 751 satisfactory to the director of building and housing servicesbuilding official or the city engineer. 752 I. A violation of this chapter shall be punished as a class B misdemeanor, and the 753 issuance of a criminal complaint shall not excuse the permit holder of his or her responsibilities 754 to abate the problem. Each day the violation exists shall be a separate offense. 755 756 18.20.220: WAIVER OR DEFERRAL OF FEES: 757 Nonprofit organizations may petition the city for the waiver or deferral of any or all fees required 758 by this title on an annual or project by project basis as provided below: 759 A. Petitions shall be filed with the division of housing stabilityappeals and advisory 760 board ("HAAB"). 761 B. Waivers shall not be granted for projects that are receiving seventy five percent 762 (75%) or more of their funding directly or indirectly from state or federal agencies, except for 22 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 763 projects that upgrade or construct owner occupied housing or multiple dwelling units used for 764 very low income housing as provided by the guidelines established by the United States 765 department of housing and urban development. 766 C. Waivers under five hundred dollars ($500.00) may be granted by the director of 767 community and neighborhoods. 768 D. Waiver requests over five hundred dollars ($500.00), and director denials of 769 waivers under five hundred dollars ($500.00) shall be heard informally before the director of the 770 department of community and neighborhoodsHAAB after notice of the hearing has been posted 771 for seven (7) days in the office of the city recorder. 772 ED. HAABThe director of the department of community and neighborhoods may 773 recommend granting the waiver or deferral if ithe/she finds that the project or projects, and the 774 sponsoring nonprofit organization furthers the city's established low income housing goals to 775 provide housing for persons or families under eighty percent (80%) of the city's median income, 776 as defined by the United States department of housing and urban development, and also meets all 777 applicable guidelines established for any such programs by the United States department of 778 housing and urban development. HAAB The director may recommend that waivers may be 779 granted for remodeling or construction of offices for nonprofit housing corporations if ithe/she 780 finds that such remodeling or construction will save the corporation money and that such savings 781 will be applied to a specific housing project. 782 FE. The HAABdirector’s recommendation will be made to the director of community 783 and neighborhoodscity council and considered at a public meeting, who shall issue the decision 784 of the department. The property owner of any project(s) for which a waiver or deferral of fees is 785 granted shall enter into, as applicable, (1) a restrictive covenant, in a form approved by the city 786 attorney, against the applicable property pertaining to the affordable housing that shall be 787 provided at the property, or (2) a binding agreement regarding the method in which the fee 788 savings shall be applied to a specific housing project. 789 G. Any person or entity dissatisfied with the decision of the director may appeal such 790 decision to the mayor or the mayor's designee, whose decision shall be final. 791 HF. HAAB Fee waivers or deferrals shall not be granted may not grant a waiver or 792 deferral to any organization which owns, operates, manages or is related by common ownership 793 or management to any other such organization which owns, operates or manages buildings for 794 which existing notices of code violations have not been curedcorrected. 795 796 SECTION 6. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.24. That Chapter 797 18.24 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Enforcement and Penalties) 798 shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 799 CHAPTER 18.24 800 ENFORCEMENT AND PENALTIES 23 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 801 802 18.24.010: MANDATORY AND PROHIBITIONARY NATURE OF 803 PROVISIONSENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY: 804 A. It is unlawful for any person, firm or corporation to perform any act prohibited by 805 this title, specifically chapters 18.04 through this chapter, 18.32 through 18.44, 18.48 through 806 18.64, 18.72, 18.76, 18.84 and 18.88 of this title, or to fail or to refuse to perform any act 807 required by this title and said chapters, or to aid or abet therein, or to fail or refuse to comply 808 with any valid order issued by the building official or his or her designee pursuant to the 809 provisions of this title. 810 B. No permits shall be issued to any applicant during the time such applicant fails to 811 correct any defective work or noncomplying installation of equipment after written notice by the 812 building official of the division of building and housing services or his or her designee. 813 C. Any person, firm or corporation violating any of the provisions of this title shall 814 be guilty of a misdemeanor. 815 Unless otherwise provided by this title, the building official is authorized and responsible for 816 enforcement of this title. The fire marshal or designee shall be the principal enforcement 817 officer on post construction activity with respect to the fire codes. Whenever one or more 818 violations of this title exist, any enforcement official has the authority to obtain compliance 819 subject to the provisions of this code. Unless otherwise provided, any violation of this title 820 shall be subject to the enforcement processes and penalties as set forth in this chapter. 821 822 18.24.020: CONTINUING OFFENSES DEEMED DAILY VIOLATIONSCRIMINAL 823 PENALTIES: 824 Where no other penalty is prescribed, any person convicted of violating any provision of this title 825 shall be punished as provided by section 1.12.050 of this code, or its successor section, and each 826 day that any violation of this title is permitted to continue shall constitute a separate offense. 827 Unless otherwise provided, it shall be a misdemeanor for any person, firm, or corporation to 828 violate the provisions of this title, either by failing to do those acts required or by doing an act 829 prohibited by this title or the codes referred to herein, or by aiding or abetting in a violation of 830 this title or the codes referred to herein. Each day that any violation of this title is permitted to 831 continue shall constitute a separate offense. The class of misdemeanor shall be as dictated by 832 state law. 833 834 18.24.030: CHOICE OF REMEDIES: 835 A. In addition to any criminal prosecution, this title may be enforced through 836 administrative or civil actions. The city may pursue any legal remedy to ensure compliance 837 with this title including, but not limited to, injunctive relief. The city has sole discretion over 838 which remedy or combination of remedies it may choose to pursue. 24 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 839 B. If the city elects to pursue through administrative or civil actions one or more 840 violations of the provisions of this title, a civil penalty shall be assessed for each violation in 841 the amount set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. Each day a violation 842 continues after notice of the same shall give rise to a separate civil fine. 843 C. The possibility of an administrative or civil remedy does not interfere with the 844 city’s right to prosecute violations of this title as criminal offenses. If the city chooses to file 845 both civil and criminal actions for the same violation, no civil penalties in the form of fines shall 846 be assessed, but other remedies, such as orders to correct the violations or other declaratory or 847 injunctive relief, is available to the city. 848 849 D. The city may use such lawful means as are available to obtain compliance with 850 the provisions of this title and to collect the civil fines that accrue as a result of the violation of 851 the provisions of this title, including but not limited to a legal action to obtain one or more of the 852 following: an injunction, an order of mandamus, an order requiring the property owner or 853 occupant or permittee to abate the violations, an order permitting the city to enter the property 854 and abate the violations, and a judgment in the amount of the civil fines accrued for the violation, 855 including costs and attorney fees, and a judgment in the amount of any actual costs incurred by 856 the city. 857 858 E. In addition to the other remedies provided by this title, upon the finding of a 859 violation of this title the building official may evacuate or close a building to occupancy when 860 necessary to protect the public or neighboring property from a risk to health or safety. The 861 building shall thereafter remain unoccupied until the appropriate certificate of occupancy has 862 been issued. 863 864 F. Recurring Violations: In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, 865 reoccurs at the same property within 6 months of the initial correction and is due the actions or 866 inactions of the same responsible party as the prior violation, the city may begin enforcement of 867 said recurring violation and impose fines after a 10 day warning period. 868 869 18.24.040: NOTICE & ORDER; STOP WORK ORDER: 870 A. Notice and Order. 871 1. Upon a determination that there is a violation of this title an enforcement 872 official may provide a written notice and order to any responsible party. The written 873 notice and order shall state: 874 a. The name and address, if known, of the responsible party; 875 b. the date and location of each violation; 876 c. the code sections violated; 877 d. that the violations must be corrected; 878 e. provide a specific date by which the enforcement official orders that 879 the violations be corrected by; 25 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 880 a. the amount of the civil fine to accrue for each violation, or other 881 enforcement action that the enforcement official intends to pursue, if 882 the violation is not corrected by the date specified; 883 b. identification of the right to and procedure to appeal; and 884 c. the signature of the enforcement official. 885 2. The enforcement official shall serve the notice and order on the 886 responsible party by: 887 a. Posting a copy of the written notice and order on the noncompliant 888 property, and 889 b. By mailing the notice and order through certified mail or reputable 890 mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery. If the 891 responsible party is the property owner of record, then mailing shall be 892 to the last known address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake 893 County Recorder. If the responsible party is any other person or entity 894 other than the owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known 895 address of the responsible party on file with the city. 896 c. Notwithstanding the foregoing, personal service upon the responsible 897 party shall be sufficient to meet the notice and order mailing 898 requirements of Subsection 18.24.040.A.2.b. 899 3. Following the issuance of a notice and order, any responsible party shall 900 correct the violations specified in the notice and order. Upon correction of the violations 901 specified in the notice and order, the responsible party shall request an inspection of the 902 property. 903 4. Following a request for an inspection as set forth in Subsection 904 18.24.040.A.3, an enforcement official shall conduct an inspection of the property to 905 determine whether the violations alleged in the notice and order have been corrected, 906 including, if applicable, all necessary permits have been issued and all final inspections 907 have been performed as required by applicable city codes. 908 5. If one or more violations are not corrected by the deadline specified in the 909 notice and order, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set forth in Subsection 18.24.030.B. 910 Accumulation of civil fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of civil 911 fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed 912 through an inspection requested pursuant to Subsection 18.24.040.A.3. 913 6. The responsible party shall have the right to contest the notice and order at 914 an administrative hearing in accordance with Chapter 18.12. Failure to timely request an 915 administrative hearing and pay the administrative hearing fee set forth in the Salt Lake 916 City consolidated fee schedule shall constitute a waiver of the right to a hearing and a 917 waiver of the right to appeal. 918 919 B. Stop Work Order. Upon a determination that there is a violation of this title an 920 enforcement official may issue a stop work order prior to issuance of a notice and order. If, after 921 issuance of a notice and order pursuant to subsection A, the violations cited remain uncorrected 922 after the correction period set forth in the notice and order, then a daily civil fine in the amount 923 set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be imposed. 26 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 924 925 18.24.050: NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE; ABATEMENT LIEN: 926 A. Upon expiration of the correction period set forth in a notice and order or stop 927 work order, and where the violation(s) remain uncorrected, the city may record on the 928 noncompliant property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of noncompliance. 929 930 B. The recordation of a notice of noncompliance shall not be deemed an 931 encumbrance on the noncompliant property but shall merely place interested parties on notice of 932 any continuing violation of this title at the noncompliant property. 933 934 C. If a notice of noncompliance has been recorded pursuant to Section A and the 935 enforcement official determines that all violations have been corrected, the enforcement official 936 shall issue a notice of compliance by recording the notice of compliance on the property with the 937 Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office. Recordation of the notice of compliance shall have the 938 effect of canceling the recorded notice of noncompliance. 939 940 D. If the city files an action for injunctive relief seeking abatement of one or more 941 violations and the district court authorizes the abatement of one or more violations and the city 942 incurs costs and the costs are not paid, a lien or garnishment may be placed to recover the costs 943 and may be considered an encumbrance on the property. 944 945 SECTION 7. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.28. That Chapter 946 18.28 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Site Development 947 Regulations) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 948 CHAPTER 18.28 949 SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS 950 951 18.28.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: 952 A. Authority: This chapter is enacted pursuant to title 10 of the, Utah Code 953 Annotated, 1953, as amended. This chapter is further enacted as an element of the Salt Lake City 954 master plan. 955 B. Applicability: The provisions of this chapter shall apply to all site development 956 within Salt Lake City; however, a permit shall be required only for those types of developments 957 set forth in subsections 18.28.040A, "General Application", and 18.28.050A, "General 958 Application", of this chapter. 27 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 959 C. Purpose: This title chapter is adopted: to promote public safety and the general 960 public welfare; to protect property against loss from erosion, earth movement, earthquake 961 hazard, and flooding; to maintain a superior community environment; to provide for the 962 continued orderly growth of the city to ensure maximum preservation of the natural scenic 963 character of major portions of the city by establishing minimum standards and requirements 964 relating to land grading, excavations, and fills; and to establish procedures by which these 965 standards and requirements may be enforced. It is intended that this chapter be administered with 966 the foregoing purposes in mind and specifically to: 967 1. Ensure that the development of each site occurs in a manner harmonious 968 with adjacent lands so as to minimize problems of drainage, erosion, earth movement, 969 and similar hazards; 970 2. Ensure that public lands and places, watercourses, streets, and all other 971 lands in the city are protected from erosion, earth movement, and drainage hazards; 972 3. Ensure that the planning, design, and construction of all development will 973 be done in a manner which provides maximum safety and human enjoyment, and, except 974 where specifically intended otherwise, makes it as unobtrusive in the natural terrain as 975 possible; 976 4. Ensure, insofar as practicable, the retention of natural vegetation to aid in 977 protection against erosion, earth movement, and other hazards and to aid in preservation 978 of the natural scenic qualities of the city; and 979 5. Ensure, insofar as Salt Lake City is located in an active seismic zone, that 980 appropriate earthquake hazard mitigation measures are incorporated into the planning and 981 execution of site development. 982 D. Identification Oof Fault Hazards: Pending the completion by the Utah geological 983 survey (UGS) of a fault hazard map for Salt Lake City, the planning director may rely upon the 984 existing information available from UGS or other publicly or privately prepared geological 985 reports to identify fault hazards. 986 E. Format: This chapter is designed to establish administrative and enforcement 987 procedures and minimum standards applicable to site development activities according to the 988 following categories: 989 1. Section 18.28.040 of this chapter governs site development associated 990 with construction of individual buildings under authorized building permits; 991 2. Section 18.28.050 of this chapter governs site development not requiring 992 permits under subsection E1 of this section. 993 994 18.28.020: DEFINITIONS: 995 A. Definition Of Terms: For the purposes of this chapter, certain terms used herein 996 are defined as set forth below: 28 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 997 AS GRADED: The surface conditions existent upon completion of grading. 998 BEDROCK: In place, solid, rock. 999 BENCH: A relatively level step excavated into earth material on which fill is to be placed. 1000 BORROW: Earth material acquired from an off site location for use in grading a site. 1001 BUILDING OFFICIAL: The director of the building and housing services department of Salt 1002 Lake City. 1003 BUILDING PERMIT: A permit issued by Salt Lake City for the construction, erection, or 1004 alteration of a structure or building. 1005 CERTIFY OR CERTIFICATION: Means that the specific reports, inspections, and tests that are 1006 required have been performed by the person or under their supervision, and that the results of 1007 such reports, inspections, and tests comply with the applicable requirements of this chapter. 1008 CITY ENGINEER: The city engineer of Salt Lake City. 1009 CIVIL ENGINEER: A professional engineer registered in the state of Utah to practice in the 1010 field of civil works. 1011 CIVIL ENGINEERING: The application of the knowledge to the forces of nature, principals of 1012 mechanics, and the properties of materials to the evaluation, design, and construction of civil 1013 works for the beneficial uses of mankind. 1014 COMPACTION: The densification of fill by mechanical means. 1015 CUBIC YARDS: The volume of material in an excavation and/or fill. 1016 CUL-DE-SAC: A street closed at one end. 1017 CUT: See definition of Excavation. 1018 DRIVEWAY: A way or route for use by vehicle traffic leading from a parking area or from a 1019 house, garage, or other structure, to a road or street. 1020 EARTH MATERIAL: Any rock, natural soil, or any combination thereof. 1021 ENGINEERING GEOLOGIST: A graduate in geology or engineering geology of an accredited 1022 university, with five (5) or more full years of professional postgraduate experience in the 1023 application of the geological sciences, of which three (3) full years shall be in the field of 1024 engineering geology that has required the application of geological data, techniques, and 1025 principles to engineering problems dealing with groundwater, naturally occurring rock and soil, 1026 and geologic hazards for the purpose of assuring that geological factors are recognized and 1027 adequately interpreted and presented. 1028 EROSION: The wearing away of the ground surface as a result of the movement of wind, water, 1029 and/or ice. 29 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1030 EXCAVATION: Any act by which vegetation, earth, sand, gravel, rock, or any other similar 1031 material is cut into, dug, quarried, uncovered, removed, displaced, relocated, or bulldozed, and 1032 shall include the conditions resulting therefrom. 1033 EXISTING GRADE: The actual elevation (in relation to mean sea level) of the ground surface 1034 before excavation or filling. 1035 FILL: Any earth, sand, gravel, rock, or any other material which is deposited, placed, replaced, 1036 pushed, dumped, pulled, transported, or moved by man to a new location and shall include the 1037 conditions resulting therefrom. 1038 FILL MATERIAL: Earth material free from rock or similar irreducible material exceeding 1039 twelve12 inches (12") in diameter, metal, and organic material except that topsoil spread on cut 1040 and fill surfaces may incorporate humus for desirable moisture retention properties. 1041 FUEL BREAK: A strategically located strip or block of land, varying in width, on which 1042 vegetation has been modified to provide a safer place for firefighters to work and to help reduce 1043 the rate of fire spread. 1044 GRADING: Excavation or fill or any combination thereof that alters the elevation of the terrain 1045 and shall include the conditions resulting from any excavation or fill. 1046 LICENSED ARCHITECT: An architect who is registered with the division of occupational and 1047 professional licensing of the state of Utah. 1048 NATURAL DRAINAGE: Water which flows by gravity in channels formed by the surface 1049 topography of the earth prior to changes made by the efforts of man. 1050 ONE STREET ACCESS: A street that provides the sole access to one or more other streets. 1051 PARCEL: All contiguous land in one ownership, provided, however, each lot conforming to the 1052 zoning ordinances of Salt Lake City in a subdivision may be considered to be a separate parcel. 1053 PERCENT OF SLOPE: The slope of a designated area of land determined by dividing the 1054 horizontal run of the slope into the vertical rise of the same slope, measured between contour 1055 lines on the referenced contour map and converting the resulting figure into a percentage value. 1056 This calculation is described by the following formula: 1057 1058 S = V/H 1059 Where 1060 "S" is the percent of slope; 1061 1062 "V" is the vertical distance; and 1063 1064 "H" is the horizontal distance. 30 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1065 1066 PERMITTEE: Any person to which a site development permit has been issued. 1067 PERSON: Any person, firm or corporation (either public or private), the state of Utah and its 1068 agencies or political subdivisions, the United States Of America and its agencies and 1069 instrumentalities, and any agent, servant, office, or employee of any of the foregoing. 1070 PLANNING DIRECTOR: The planning director of Salt Lake City. 1071 QUARRY: An open excavation for the extraction of resources. 1072 REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER: A civil engineer who is registered with the 1073 division of occupational and professional licensing of the state of Utah. 1074 REMOVAL: Killing vegetation by spraying, complete extraction, or excavation, or cutting 1075 vegetation to the ground, trunks, or stumps. 1076 SEISMIC: Characteristic of, or produced by, earthquakes or earth vibration. 1077 SITE: A lot or parcel of land, or a contiguous combination thereof, where grading work is 1078 performed as a single unified operation. 1079 SITE DEVELOPMENT (Also Known As SITE PREPARATION): Grading and underground 1080 utility installation in preparation for an approved, pending development or use for the subject 1081 site. 1082 SLOPE CLASSIFICATION MAP: A map prepared as a colored exhibit by a registered 1083 professional engineer or land surveyor based upon a contour map of the specified scale and 1084 contour interval, upon which the measured and calculated percent of slope (measured between 1085 every contour interval on the map) is classified or grouped into percentage of slope data in ten 1086 percent (10%) slope groupings as follows: 1087 Slope Classification Percent Of Slope Mapped Color Level 0 - 9.9%Uncolored Slight 10 - 19.9%Yellow Moderate 20 - 29.9%Orange Severe 30% and greater Red 1088 1089 SOILS ENGINEER: A registered civil engineer of the state of Utah, specializing in soil 1090 mechanics and foundation engineering, familiar with the application of principles of soil 1091 mechanics in the investigation and analysis of the engineering properties of earth materials. 1092 SURCHARGE: The temporary placement of fill material on a site in order to compress or 1093 compact the natural soil mass. 31 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1094 TESTING LABORATORY: A testing laboratory that requires supervisory personnel to be 1095 professional engineers registered with the division of occupational and professional licensing of 1096 the state of Utah. 1097 VACANT: Land on which there are no structures or only structures which are secondary to the 1098 use or maintenance of the land itself. 1099 1100 18.28.030: RESERVED: 1101 1102 18.28.040: LAND DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS (BUILDING SITES): 1103 A. General Application: No person or party shall cause any excavation or grading to 1104 be done on a building sitein excess of the limits set forth below without first having obtained a 1105 site development permitapproval in conjunction with the building permit process or a permit 1106 from the building official except as specified below. 1107 1. Work Requiring Separate Approval/Permit: A site development approval 1108 and/or permit shall be required in all cases where development comes under any one or 1109 more of the following provisions: 1110 a. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding one 1111 thousand (1,000) cubic yards; 1112 b. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding five5 feet 1113 (5') in vertical depth at its deepest point measured from the adjacent, undisturbed, 1114 ground surface; 1115 c. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding an area of 1116 aone-half (1/2) acre; 1117 d. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof ofexceeding seventy 1118 five percent (7510%) or more of a building site including the excavation for 1119 foundations and footings; 1120 e. Removal of vegetation from an area in excess of aone-half (1/2) 1121 acre for purposes other than agricultural; 1122 f. Engineered interior fills or surcharges. 1123 g. Commercial quarries or mining activities operating in permitted 1124 zoning districts as provided in Title 21A. 1125 2. Work Not Requiring Separate Approval/Permit: A separate site 1126 development permit shall not be required in the following cases, for issuance of a 1127 building permit shall specify approval of the required grading plan: 1128 a. Excavation below finished grade for basements and footings of 1129 buildings or other structures authorized by a valid building permit. This shall not 32 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1130 exempt any fill made with material from such excavation, or exempt any 1131 excavation having an unsupported height greater than five5 feet (5') after the 1132 completion of such structure. 1133 b. Removal of vegetation as part of work authorized by a valid 1134 building permit. 1135 3. Waiver: The following requirements and standards shall apply to all 1136 building sites unless deemed unwarranted by the written recommendation of the building 1137 official. 1138 B. Permits Required: Except as exempted in sSubsection A of this section, no person 1139 or party shall do or cause any grading to be done on a building site without first obtaining site 1140 development approval, or permit from the building official. A a separate approval or permit shall 1141 be required for each site, and may cover both excavation and fill. 1142 1. Application: To obtain a permit or approval the applicant shall first file an 1143 application therefor in writing on a form furnished by the building department for that 1144 purpose. Every such application shall: 1145 a. Identify and describe the work to be covered by the permit or 1146 approval for which application is made; 1147 b. Describe the land on which the proposed work is to be done by 1148 legal description, street address, or similar description that will readily identify 1149 and definitely locate the proposed work and identify lots of any platted 1150 subdivision included within the proposed building site; 1151 c. Indicate the use or occupancy for which the proposed work is 1152 intended; 1153 d. Be accompanied by plans, diagrams, computations, and 1154 specifications and other data as required; 1155 e. Be signed by property owner or permittee, or his authorized agent, 1156 who may be required to submit evidence to indicate such authority; 1157 f. Show the location of existing and proposed buildings or structures 1158 on the applicant's property, and the location of buildings or structures on adjacent 1159 properties which are within fifteen15 feet (15') of the applicant's property, or 1160 which may be affected by the proposed site development activities; 1161 g. Show the location of property lines and all existing and proposed 1162 streets, roadways, driveways, easements, and rights of way on, contiguous, or 1163 adjacent to the proposed development site; 1164 h. Show the present contours of the site in dashed lines and the 1165 proposed contours in solid lines. Contour intervals shall be not greater than two2 1166 feet (2') where slopes are predominately five percent (5%) or less, and five5 feet 1167 (5') where slopes are predominately steeper than five percent (5%). The source of 1168 all topographical information shall be indicated; 33 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1169 i. Show the location of all drainage to, from, and across the site, the 1170 location of intermittent and permanent streams, springs, culverts, and other 1171 drainage structures, and size and location of any precipitation catchment areas in, 1172 above, or within one hundred100 feet (100') of the site; 1173 j. IncludeShow detailed plans and location of all surface and 1174 subsurface drainage devices, walls, dams, sediment basins, storage reservoirs, and 1175 other protective devices to be constructed with, or as a part of, the proposed work, 1176 together with a map showing drainage areas, and the complete drainage network 1177 including outfall lines and natural drainageways which may be affected by the 1178 proposed project. Include the estimated runoff of the areas served by the proposed 1179 drainage system; 1180 k. Present a plan showing temporary erosion control measures to 1181 prevent erosion during the course of construction; 1182 l. All grading in excess of five thousand (5,000) cubic yards shall 1183 require professional engineering and shall be designated as "engineered grading". 1184 Any application including engineered grading shall contain a grading plan 1185 prepared by a registered professional engineer or licensed architect; 1186 m. IncludeShow a revegetation plan including: 1187 (1) A survey of existing trees, shrubs, and ground covers, 1188 (2) A plan for the proposed revegetation of the site detailing 1189 existing vegetation to be preserved, new vegetation to be planned and any 1190 modification to existing vegetation, and 1191 (3) A plan for the preservation of existing vegetation during 1192 construction activity; 1193 n. Make a statement of the estimated starting and completion dates 1194 for the grading work proposed and any revegetation work that may be required; 1195 o. Identify the type of surcharging fill material to be used on the 1196 building site; 1197 p. Estimate the amount of time surcharging fill material will be in 1198 place, and show consideration by a soils engineer of the potential for vertical and 1199 lateral soil movements on properties adjacent to the surcharge; 1200 q. Submit a copy of the recorded subdivision plat showing 1201 developable area limitations, if applicable; 1202 r. Describe the method to be employed in disposing of soil and other 1203 material that is removed from the site, including the location of the disposal site; 1204 s. Describe the method to be used in obtaining fill to be used on the 1205 site and the site of acquisition of such fill; 34 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1206 t. Include an engineering geology report described in Section 1207 18.28.040.C.2 if the proposed development lies within 500 feet of an identified 1208 fault. Said report may be submitted for review to the Utah geological survey by 1209 the building official. 1210 u. Applications related to commercial quarriers shall contain an 1211 acceptable plan for the eventual rehabilitation and use of the quarry site after the 1212 resources have been removed. Such a plan, at a scale of not less than one inch 1213 equals 100 feet with contour intervals not greater than 5 feet, shall be compatible 1214 with its surroundings and in general agreement with the city’s master plan. The 1215 plan shall show the proposed treatment of any stream channel adjacent to the 1216 resource deposits during extraction operations. Limits of excavation shall be 1217 determined to protect any natural or improved channel and any nearby wooded 1218 areas considered vital to the function of the rehabilitated area. Included the 1219 estimated time period during which quarrying and land rehabilitation operations 1220 will be conducted. 1221 v. Such other information as may be required by the building official 1222 or city engineer such as slope classification map and analysis, profiles or cross 1223 sections, additional drainage calculations, soils data including a report from a 1224 registered soils engineer or other qualified person. 1225 C. Soil Engineering Report Oor Engineering Geology Required: 1226 1. Soil Engineering Report: The soil engineering report required shall 1227 include data regarding the nature, distribution, and strength of existing soils, conclusions 1228 and recommendations for grading procedures, design criteria for corrective measures 1229 when necessary, and opinions and recommendations addressing the adequacy of the site 1230 under the proposed grading plan to support the proposed development. 1231 2. Engineering Geology Report: The engineering geology report required 1232 shall include an adequate description of the geology of the site, conclusions and 1233 recommendations regarding the effect of geologic conditions on the proposed 1234 development, and opinions and recommendations addressing the adequacy of the site 1235 under the proposed grading plan to support the proposed development. This requirement 1236 may be waived by written recommendation of the building official if it is deemed 1237 unwarranted. 1238 D. Issuance: The application, plans, specifications, and other data submitted by an 1239 applicant for permit shall be reviewed by the building official. Such plans may be reviewed by 1240 other departments or agencies to verify compliance with any applicable laws under their 1241 jurisdiction. If the building official finds that the work described in an application for a permit 1242 and the plans, specifications, and other data filed therewith conform to the requirements of this 1243 title and other pertinent laws and ordinances, and that the fees specified have been paid, he shall 1244 issue a permit therefor to the property owner or his authorized agent. When the building official 1245 issues the permit where plans are required, he shall endorse in writing or stamp the plans and 1246 specifications "APPROVED". Such approved plans and specifications shall not be changed, 1247 modified, or altered without authorization from the building official, and all work shall be done 1248 in accordance with the approved plans. The building official may require that the site 35 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1249 development activities and project designs or specifications be modified if delays occur which 1250 may create weather generated problems not considered at the time the permit was issued. No site 1251 alteration shall occur during the months of November through March and no applications 1252 proposing such work during that time shall be approved. 1253 E. Fees: City fees associated with reviewing and processing site development (a.k.a. 1254 "preparation") permits shall be those listed on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 1255 F. Grading Aand Erosion Control Standards Aand Regulations: All site development 1256 work shall be accomplished in conformance to the following grading and erosion control design 1257 standards and regulations: 1258 1. Hours Oof Operation: All grading operations in or within 660 feet 1259 ofcontiguous to residential land usesneighborhoods shall be carried on between the hours 1260 of seven o'clock (7:00) A.M. and five thirty o'clock (5:30) P.M. The building official may 1261 waive this requirement if it is shown that by restricting the hours of operation it would 1262 unduly interfere with the development of the property and it is shown that the 1263 neighboring properties would not be adversely affected. 1264 2. Dust Aand Dirt Control: All graded surfaces of any nature shall be 1265 dampened or suitably contained to prevent dust or spillage on city streets or adjacent 1266 properties. Equipment, materials, and roadways on the site shall be used or treated so as 1267 to cause the least possible annoyance due to dirt, mud, or dust conditions. 1268 3. Undevelopable Slopes: Any (1) slope identified on a subdivision plat as 1269 undevelopable, (2) slope that has been altered without permits or prior approval to 30% 1270 or greater, or (3) natural slopes identified on a slope classification map of thirty percent 1271 (30%) or greater (as measured pursuant to a “ten-foot averaging” method as defined in 1272 Section 20.50.020), shall be designated undevelopable area. In no event shall streets 1273 traverse such slopes. 1274 4. Finished Cuts Aand Slopes: Limitations shall be applied to the extent of 1275 cut and fill slopes to minimize the amount of excavated surface or ground area exposed to 1276 potential erosion and settlement. 1277 a. The exposed or finished cuts or slopes of any fill or excavation 1278 shall be smoothly graded. 1279 b. All cut and fill slopes shall be recontoured and revegetated by the 1280 permittee in accordance with an approved plan. 1281 c. Cut or fill slopes shall normally be limited to fifteen15 feet (15') in 1282 vertical height. However, upon review and favorable recommendation of the city 1283 engineer and public utilities director the building official may approve cut and fill 1284 slopes exceeding fifteen15 feet (15') provided that such variations be allowed on a 1285 limited basis after thorough review of each request and only when balanced by 1286 offsetting improvements to the overall aesthetic, environmental, and engineering 1287 quality of the development. 36 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1288 d. No excavation creating a cut face and no fill creating an exposed 1289 surface shall have a slope ratio exceeding one and one- half horizontal to one 1290 vertical (11/2:1). 1291 e. Exceptions: 1292 (1) No slopes shall cut steeper than the bedding plane, fracture, 1293 fault, or joint in any formation where the cut slope will lie on the dip of 1294 the strike line of the bedding plane, fracture, fault, or joint. 1295 (2) No slopes shall be cut in an existing landslide, mudflow, or 1296 other form of naturally unstable slope except as recommended by a 1297 qualified geological engineer. 1298 (3) Where the formation is exposed above the top of the cut 1299 which will permit the entry of water along bedding planes, this area shall 1300 be sealed with a compacted soil blanket having a minimum thickness of 1301 two2 feet (2'). The soil for this blanket shall be relatively impervious and 1302 shall be approved by the soils engineer or engineering geologist. 1303 f. If the material of a slope is of such composition and character as to 1304 be unstable under the anticipated maximum moisture content, the slope angle 1305 shall be reduced to a stable value or retained by a method approved by the city 1306 engineer and certified as to its stability by a soils engineer or geologist. Said 1307 retaining method shall include design provisions which are: 1308 (1) Conducive to revegetation for soil stability and visual 1309 impact; 1310 (2) Used for selected areas of the site and not as a general 1311 application; and 1312 (3) Limited to tiers each of which is no higher than six6 feet 1313 (6'), separated by plantable terraces a minimum of two2 feet (2') in width; 1314 g. Any retaining system shall remain and be maintained on the lots 1315 until plans for construction are approved and a building permit is issued. The 1316 plans shall include provisions to integrate driveway access to the lot while 1317 maintaining the structural integrity of the retaining system. 1318 h. The building officialcity engineer may require the slope of a cut or 1319 fill to be made more level if at any time it is found that the material being, or the 1320 fill, is unusually subject to erosion, static or dynamic instability, or if other 1321 conditions make such requirements necessary for stability. 1322 i. Driveways leaving public rights of way shall not exceed a 1323 maximum change in grade angle of six percent (6%) transition over an eleven11 1324 foot (11') run. The slope should be transitioned beyond property line no more than 1325 an average sixteen percent (16%) grade. Parking structures may allow a maximum 1326 change in grade angle of ten percent (10%) with a minimum ten10 foot (10') run. 37 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1327 Maximum sight distance should be encouraged with blind entrances or other sight 1328 obstructions complying with the Sight Distance Triangle Requirements as defined 1329 and illustrated in Chapter 21A.62transportation division's standard E2.c1 "clear 1330 site zone area" or its successor. 1331 5. Abatement Oof Hazardous Conditions: 1332 a. If, at any stage of grading, the building official or city engineer 1333 determines by inspection that the nature of the formation is such that further work 1334 as authorized by an existing permit is likely to imperil any property, public way, 1335 watercourse, or drainage structure, the building official or city engineer shall 1336 require, as condition to allowing the work to proceed, that reasonable safety 1337 precautions be taken as are considered advisable to avoid likelihood of such peril. 1338 Such precautions may include, but shall not be limited to, any of the following: 1339 (1) Specification of a more level exposed slope; 1340 (2) Construction of additional drainage facilities, berms, or 1341 terraces; 1342 (3) Compaction or cribbing; 1343 (4) Installation of plants for erosion control; and/or 1344 (5) Reports from a registered soils engineer and/or engineering 1345 geologist whose recommendations may be made requirements for further 1346 work. 1347 Such requirements by the building officialplanning director or city engineer shall 1348 constitute a required change order in the work to be performed under permit. Said 1349 changes may be required to be reflected in amended plans. 1350 b. Where it appears that damage from storm drainage may result from 1351 work performed hereunder, such work may be stopped and the permittee required 1352 to take such measures as may be necessary to protect adjoining property or the 1353 public safety. On large operations, or where unusual site conditions exist, the 1354 building official or city engineer may specify the time at which grading may 1355 proceed and the time of completion or may require that the operation be 1356 conducted in specific stages so as to ensure completion of protective measures or 1357 devices prior to the advent of seasonal rains. 1358 6. Fill Material Aand Compaction: 1359 a. Fill Material: All fill shall be earth, rock, or inert material free 1360 from organic material and free of metal, except that topsoil spread on cut and fill 1361 surfaces may incorporate humus for desirable moisture retention properties. Fill 1362 not meeting the definition above shall be placed only in an approved public or 1363 private landfill or other approved deposit site. 38 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1364 b. Backfillings: Any pipe trench or trenching, or excavation made in 1365 any slope of any excavated or filled site, shall be backfilled and compacted to the 1366 level of the surrounding grade. 1367 c. Compaction Oof Fills: Unless otherwise directed by the building 1368 official, all fills governed by this title, intended to support building, structures, or 1369 where otherwise required to be compacted for stability, shall be compacted, 1370 inspected, and tested in accordance with the following provisions: 1371 (1) The natural ground surface shall be prepared by removal of 1372 topsoil and vegetation, and, if necessary, shall be graded to a series of 1373 terraces. If fill material unacceptable under subsection F6a of this section 1374 is placed on the site, or the fill is not placed according to procedures of 1375 this title, then it must be removed. 1376 (2) The fill shall be spread and compacted in accordance with 1377 the city engineer's approved standards. 1378 (3) The moisture content of the fill material shall be controlled 1379 at the time of spreading and compaction to obtain required maximum 1380 density. 1381 (4) A written report of the completed compaction, showing 1382 location and depth of test holes, materials used, moisture conditions, 1383 recommended soil bearing pressures, and relative density obtained from 1384 all tests, prepared by a civil engineer or soils engineer licensed by the state 1385 of Utah, or testing laboratory shall be submitted to the building official, 1386 who shall rely on the expertise of the city engineer for review. 1387 (5) The building official or city engineer may require 1388 additional tests or information if, in his opinion, the conditions or 1389 materials are such that additional information is necessary, and may 1390 modify or delete any of the above listed requirements that, in his opinion, 1391 are unnecessary to further the purpose of this title. 1392 7. Surcharging: Surcharges shall consist of earth material and shall be 1393 applied in such a manner as to have no effect on soil stability on adjacent or neighboring 1394 properties. 1395 G. Erosion Control Aand Revegetation: All cut and fill surfaces created by grading 1396 shall be planted with a ground cover that is a drought resistant variety. Topsoils are to be 1397 stockpiled during rough grading and used on cut and fill slopes. Cuts and fills along public roads 1398 are required to be landscaped according to a revegetation plan approved by the city. All plant 1399 selections must be approved by the parks department and building official prior to approval. 1400 H. Drainage: 1401 1. Adequate provisions shall be made to prevent any surface waters from 1402 damaging the cut face of an excavation or any portion of a fill. All drainage ways and 1403 structures shall carry surface waters, without producing erosion, to the nearest practical 39 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1404 street, storm drain, or natural watercourse as approved by the city engineer. The city 1405 engineer may also require drainage structures to be constructed, or installed as necessary 1406 to prevent erosion damage or to prevent saturation of the fill or material behind cut 1407 slopes. 1408 2. An excess stormwater passage shall be provided for all stormwater storage 1409 areas. Such passage shall have capacity to convey through the proposed development the 1410 excess stormwater from the tributary watershed. The capacity of such excess stormwater 1411 passages shall be constructed in such a manner as to transport the peak rate of runoff 1412 from a 100-year return frequency storm assuming all storm sewers are inoperative, all 1413 upstream areas are fully developed in accordance with the city's current land use plan, 1414 and that antecedent rainfall has saturated the tributary watershed. 1415 3. No buildings or structures shall be constructed within such passage, 1416 however, streets, parking lots, playgrounds, park areas, pedestrian walkways, utility 1417 easements, and other open space uses shall be considered compatible uses. In the event 1418 such passageway is reshaped or its capacity to transport excess stormwater is otherwise 1419 restricted during or after construction, the building official or city engineer shall notify 1420 the agency, party, or parties causing said restriction to remove the same and set a 1421 reasonable time for its removal. If said parties refuse to, or are unable to, comply with 1422 said order, the building official or city engineer shall cause said restrictions to be 1423 removed at the expense of said parties. Where a proposed development contains existing 1424 natural drainage, appropriate planning measures shall be undertaken or required to 1425 preserve and maintain said natural drainage as part of the excess stormwater passage. 1426 4. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this title, whenever, in the 1427 judgment of the building official or city engineer, a condition occurs in a stormwater 1428 storage area or passageway that creates a dangerous and imminent health and safety 1429 hazard, the building official or city engineer shall order such action as shall be effective 1430 immediately or in the time manner prescribed in the order itself. 1431 I. Setbacks: The setback and other restrictions specified in this section are minimum 1432 and may be increased by the building official or by the recommendation of a civil engineer, soils 1433 engineer, or engineering geologist, if necessary for safety and stability, to prevent damage of 1434 adjacent properties from deposition or erosion, or to provide access for slope maintenance and 1435 drainage. Setbacks deal with distance from property lines, structures, or faults, and must satisfy 1436 the requirements of subsections I1 through I3 of this section. Retaining walls may be used to 1437 reduce the required setbacks when approved by the building official. 1438 1. Setbacks Ffrom Property Lines: The toes and tops of cut and fill slopes 1439 where no structures are located shall be set back from the outer boundaries of a "permit 1440 area" (PA = lot area excluding any undevelopable areas) including yard setbacks, slope- 1441 right areas, and easements, in accordance with the table and figure 2 of this section. 1442 SETBACKS FROM PERMIT AREA BOUNDARY 1443 a =Setback distance at toe 40 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT b =Setback at top H =Height from toe to top of cut/fill slope 1445 H a b1 Less than 5'0 1' 5' to 30'H/2 H/5 Over 30'15'6' 1446 1447 Note: 1448 1. Additional width may be required for interceptor drain. 1449 FIGURE 2 1450 1451 2. Setback Ffrom Structures: Setback from cut or fill slopes and structures 1452 shall be provided in accordance with figure 3 of this section. 1453 FIGURE 3 41 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1454 1455 3. Setbacks Ffrom Faults: No structure shall be located over a fault. Determinations 1456 of the appropriate setback distance from the fault shall be made based on recommendations 1457 contained in the geological report required by subsection C of this section. 1458 J. Site Development Inspections: 1459 1. Special Inspections: All site development activities for which a permit or 1460 approval is required shall be subject to inspection by the building official. Special 1461 inspections of grading operations and special testing shall be performed to ensure 1462 conformity with approved plans and specifications. The following special inspections and 1463 testing are required: 1464 a. Fills: 1465 (1) The site is to be inspected prior to placement of fill 1466 material. 1467 (2) The fill material is to be inspected prior to placement on the 1468 site. 1469 (3) Final compaction of fill is to be tested. 1470 (4) The final grade is to be inspected. 1471 (5) Revegetation will be inspected during planting, upon 1472 planting completion, and again prior to bond release where applicable. 1473 b. Cuts: 1474 (1) The site is to be inspected prior to cutting or removing 1475 material. 1476 (2) The grade is to be inspected after cutting. 1477 (3) Revegetation will be inspected during planting, upon 1478 planting completion, and again prior to bond release where applicable. 42 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1479 2. Inspection Schedule Aand Enforcement: At the time the site development 1480 permit or approval is issued, the building official shall establish the stage of development 1481 at which required inspections shall be made. In order to obtain inspections, the permittee 1482 shall notify the city of readiness at least twenty four (24) hours before said inspection is 1483 to be made. Where it is found by inspection that conditions are not substantially as stated 1484 or shown on the approved plans, the building official or his inspectors shall may stop 1485 further work until approval is obtained for amended plans. 1486 K. Completion Oof Work: 1487 1. Final Reports: Upon completion of the rough grading work and again at 1488 the final completion of the work, reports, drawings, and supplements thereto will be 1489 required as follows: 1490 a. An "as graded" grading plan, prepared by a civil engineer, 1491 including original ground surface elevations, lot drainage patterns, and locations 1492 and elevations of all surface and subsurface drainage facilities. The engineer shall 1493 verify that the work was done in accordance with the final approved site 1494 development plan. 1495 b. A soil grading report, prepared by a soils engineer, including 1496 location and elevations of field density tests, summaries of field and laboratory 1497 tests and other substantiating data, and comments on any changes made during 1498 grading and their effect on the recommendations made in the soil engineering 1499 investigation report. The soils engineer shall verify the adequacy of the site for the 1500 intended use. 1501 c. A geologic grading report, prepared by an engineering geologist, 1502 including a final description of the geology of the site including any new 1503 information disclosed during the grading and the effect of the same on 1504 recommendations incorporated in the approved site development plan. The 1505 engineering geologist shall verify the adequacy of the site for the intended use as 1506 affected by geologic factors. This requirement may be modified or waived in 1507 writing by the building official if circumstances warrant. 1508 2. Notification Oof Completion: The permittee, or his authorized agent, shall 1509 notify the building official when the grading operation is ready for final inspection. Final 1510 approval shall not be given until all work, including installation of all drainage facilities 1511 and their protective devices and all erosion control measures including revegetation, have 1512 been completed in accordance with the final approved site development plan and the 1513 required reports have been submitted. 1514 1515 18.28.050: RESERVEDINDEPENDENT SITE DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES: 1516 A. General Application: No person shall commence, perform, or cause any grading 1517 to be done in excess of the limits specified below without first obtaining a site development 1518 permit. A separate independent site development permit not otherwise required under section 43 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1519 10.28.040 of this chapter shall be required for each site on which grading is to be done as 1520 specified in subsection A1 of this section. 1521 1. General: A site development permit shall be required in all cases where 1522 development comes under any one or more of the following provisions: 1523 a. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding one thousand 1524 (1,000) cubic yards; 1525 b. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding five feet (5') in 1526 vertical depth at its deepest point measured from the adjacent, undisturbed, ground 1527 surface; 1528 c. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding an area of one-half 1529 (1/2) acre; 1530 d. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding seventy five 1531 percent (75%) of a building site including the excavation for foundations and footings; 1532 e. Removal of vegetation from an area in excess of one-half (1/2) acre for 1533 purposes other than agricultural; 1534 f. Engineered interior fills or surcharges; 1535 g. Fuel break for fire protection purposes; 1536 h. Commercial quarries or mining activities operating in appropriate 1537 industrial zone as provided in the Salt Lake City zoning ordinance; 1538 2. Waiver: All of the following requirements and standards shall apply unless 1539 deemed unwarranted by the building official and waived in writing. 1540 B. Permit Application: Each application for an independent site development permit 1541 shall be made by the owner of the property, or the owner's authorized agent, to the building 1542 official on a form furnished for that purpose. The application shall include: 1543 1. Required Information: Three (3) copies of plot plans of the property, 1544 drawn to scale, which: 1545 a. Identify and describe the work to be covered by the permit for which 1546 application is made; 1547 b. Describe the land on which the proposed work is to be done by legal 1548 description, street address, or similar description that will readily identify and definitely 1549 locate the proposed work and identify lots of any platted subdivision included within the 1550 proposed building site; 1551 c. Indicate the use or occupancy for which the proposed work is intended; 1552 d. Be accompanied by plans, diagrams, computations, and specifications and 1553 other data as required; 44 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1554 e. Be signed by property owner or permittee, or his authorized agent, who 1555 may be required to submit evidence to indicate such authority; 1556 f. Location of existing and proposed buildings or structures on the 1557 applicant's property, and the location of buildings or structures on adjacent properties 1558 which are within fifteen feet (15') of the applicant's property, or which may be affected 1559 by the proposed site development activities; 1560 g. Location of property lines and all existing and proposed streets, roadways, 1561 driveways, easements, and rights of way on, contiguous, or adjacent to the proposed 1562 development site; 1563 h. The present contours of the site in dashed lines and the proposed contours 1564 in solid lines. Contour intervals shall be not greater than two feet (2') where slopes are 1565 predominately five percent (5%) or less, and five feet (5') where slopes are predominately 1566 steeper than five percent (5%). The source of all topographical information shall be 1567 indicated; 1568 i. The location of all drainage to, from, and across the site, the location of 1569 intermittent and permanent streams, springs, culverts, and other drainage structures, and 1570 size and location of any precipitation catchment areas in, above, or within one hundred 1571 feet (100') of the site; 1572 j. Detailed plans and location of all surface and subsurface drainage devices, 1573 walls, dams, sediment basins, storage reservoirs, and other protective devices to be 1574 constructed with, or as a part of, the proposed work, together with a map showing 1575 drainage areas, and the complete drainage network including outfall lines and natural 1576 drainageways which may be affected by the proposed project. Include the estimated 1577 runoff of the areas served by the proposed drainage system; 1578 k. Plan showing temporary erosion control measures to prevent erosion 1579 during the course of construction; 1580 l. All grading in excess of five thousand (5,000) cubic yards shall require 1581 professional engineering and shall be designated as "engineered grading". Any 1582 application including engineered grading shall contain a grading plan prepared by a 1583 registered professional engineer or licensed architect; 1584 m. A revegetation plan including: 1585 (1) A survey of existing trees, shrubs, and ground covers, 1586 (2) A plan for the proposed revegetation of the site detailing existing 1587 vegetation to be preserved, new vegetation to be planned and any modification to 1588 existing vegetation, and 1589 (3) A plan for the preservation of existing vegetation during 1590 construction activity; 1591 n. Statement of the estimated starting and completion dates for the grading 1592 work proposed and any revegetation work that may be required; 45 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1593 o. Identify the type of surcharging fill material to be used on the building 1594 site; 1595 p. Estimate the amount of time surcharging fill material will be in place, and 1596 show consideration by a soils engineer of the potential for vertical and lateral soil 1597 movements on properties adjacent to the surcharge; 1598 q. A description of the method to be employed in disposing of soil and other 1599 material that is removed from the site, including the location of the disposal site; 1600 r. A description of the method to be used in obtaining fill to be used on the 1601 site and the site of acquisition of such fill; 1602 s. If the proposed development lies within five hundred feet (500') of an 1603 identified fault, a geological report and verification as per subsection 18.28.040C2 of this 1604 chapter will be required. Said report may be submitted for review to the Utah geological 1605 survey by the building official; 1606 t. If applicable, submit a copy of the recorded subdivision plat showing 1607 developable area limitations; 1608 u. Application for commercial quarries shall contain an acceptable plan for 1609 the eventual rehabilitation and use of the quarry site after the resources have been 1610 removed. Such a plan, at a scale of not less than one inch equals one hundred feet (1" = 1611 100') with contour intervals not greater than five feet (5'), shall be compatible with its 1612 surroundings and in general agreement with the city's master plan. The plan shall show 1613 the proposed treatment of any stream channel adjacent to the resource deposits during 1614 extraction operations. Limits of excavation shall be determined to protect any natural or 1615 improved channel and any nearby wooded areas considered vital to the function of the 1616 rehabilitated area. Include the estimated time period during which quarrying and land 1617 rehabilitation operations will be conducted. 1618 2. Additional Information Which May Be Required: The following 1619 information shall be provided in triplicate if requested by the building official or city 1620 engineer: 1621 a. Slope classification map and analysis; 1622 b. Profiles or cross sections; 1623 c. Additional drainage calculations; 1624 d. Soils data including a report from a registered soils engineer, 1625 engineering geologist, or other qualified person; 1626 e. Statement of the estimated starting and completion dates for the 1627 grading work proposed and any revegetation work that may be required. 1628 f. Detailed revegetation plans for the site and, if appropriate, 1629 information relating to the landscaping on adjacent or surrounding areas affected 1630 by the proposed development. Such revegetation plans shall be prepared by a 46 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1631 licensed engineer, architect, landscape architect, or other qualified person. These 1632 plans shall show: 1633 (1) Distribution of plants, existing trees, and work involved as 1634 related to slope control and/or physical environment; 1635 (2) A plan describing the methods of planting the areas to be 1636 landscaped with special emphasis on soil preparation, plant selection, 1637 methods of planting, and initial maintenance of plants and slopes until a 1638 specified percentage of plant coverage is uniformly established on cut and 1639 fill slopes; 1640 (3) Such other and further details as may be specified by the 1641 building official or city engineer to carry out the purpose of this title. All 1642 such plans shall bear the name of the person responsible for the 1643 preparation of the plan; 1644 (4) The revegetation plan will be submitted by the building 1645 official to the Salt Lake City parks department's landscape architect for 1646 review. 1647 g. Such other information as shall be required by the building official 1648 or city engineer. 1649 3. Fee: Each site development application made independent and separate from a 1650 building permit application shall be accompanied by payment of an application fee 1651 pursuant to the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 1652 C. Granting Permit: To further the specific purposes of this title as set forth in 1653 subsection 18.28.010C of this chapter, the following procedures are established: 1654 1. Referrals: The application shall be referred by the building official to the 1655 city engineer and planning director for review. Further, applications may also be referred 1656 to the Utah geological survey and other appropriate advisors for comments and 1657 recommendations as deemed necessary or appropriate. 1658 2. Conformity To Plans: The building official shall be responsible to arrange 1659 for required inspections by appropriate inspectors who shall either approve that portion of 1660 the work completed or shall notify the permittee wherein the same fails to comply with 1661 this title. Where it is found by inspection that conditions are not substantially as stated or 1662 shown in the site development permit applications, the inspector shall stop further work 1663 until the work conforms to the approved plan or approval is obtained for revised plans. 1664 3. Abatement Of Hazardous Conditions: If, at any stage of site development, 1665 the building official determines by inspection that the work is creating hazardous 1666 conditions, he may suspend the work until provisions for abatement and/or correction are 1667 completed as set forth in subsection E of this section. 1668 D. Inspections: 47 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1669 1. Inspection Schedule: At the time a site development permit is issued, the 1670 building official shall establish the stages of development at which inspections required 1671 by subsection 18.28.040J of this chapter shall be made. In order to obtain inspections, the 1672 permittee shall notify the city of readiness at least twenty four (24) hours before said 1673 inspection is to be made. 1674 2. Conformity To Plans: The building official shall be responsible to arrange 1675 for required inspections by appropriate inspectors who shall either approve that portion of 1676 the work completed or shall notify the permittee wherein the same fails to comply with 1677 this title. Where it is found by inspection that conditions are not substantially as stated or 1678 shown in the site development permit applications, the inspector shall stop further work 1679 until the work conforms to the approved plan or approval is obtained for revised plans. 1680 3. Abatement Of Hazardous Conditions: If, at any stage of site development, 1681 the building official determines by inspection that the work is creating hazardous 1682 conditions, he may suspend the work until provisions for abatement and/or correction are 1683 completed as set forth in subsection E of this section. 1684 E. Grading And Erosion Control Design Standards And Regulations: All site 1685 development work shall be accomplished in conformance to the following provisions: 1686 1. Hours Of Operation: All grading operations in or contiguous to residential 1687 neighborhoods shall be carried on between the hours of seven o'clock (7:00) A.M. and 1688 five thirty o'clock (5:30) P.M. The city engineer may waive this requirement if it is 1689 shown that by restricting the hours of operation it would unduly interfere with the 1690 development of the property and it is shown that the neighboring properties would not be 1691 adversely affected. 1692 2. Dust And Dirt Control: All graded surfaces of any nature shall be 1693 dampened or suitably contained to prevent dust or spillage on city streets or adjacent 1694 properties. Equipment, materials, and roadways on the site shall be used or treated so as 1695 to cause the least possible annoyance due to dirt, mud, or dust conditions. 1696 3. Undevelopable Slopes: Any natural slopes identified on a slope 1697 classification map of thirty percent (30%) or greater, shall be designated undevelopable 1698 area. Said slope, if retained within the subdivision, may be designated and maintained as 1699 common area. In no event shall streets traverse such slopes. 1700 4. Finished Cuts And Slopes: Limitations shall be applied to the extent of cut 1701 and fill slopes to minimize the amount of excavated surface or ground area exposed to 1702 potential erosion and settlement. 1703 a. The exposed or finished cuts or slopes of any fill or excavation 1704 shall be smoothly graded. 1705 b. All cut and fill slopes shall be recontoured and revegetated by the 1706 subdivider in accordance with an approved plan. 1707 c. Cut or fill slopes shall normally be limited to fifteen feet (15') in 1708 vertical height. However, upon review and favorable recommendation of the city 48 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1709 engineer and public utilities director the building official may approve cut and fill 1710 slopes exceeding fifteen feet (15') provided that such variations be allowed on a 1711 limited basis after thorough review of each request and only when balanced by 1712 offsetting improvements to the overall aesthetic, environmental, and engineering 1713 quality of the development. 1714 d. No excavation creating a cut face and no fill creating an exposed 1715 surface shall have a slope ratio exceeding one and one- half horizontal to one 1716 vertical (11/2:1). 1717 e. Exceptions: 1718 (1) No slopes shall cut steeper than the bedding plane, fracture, 1719 fault, or joint in any formation where the cut slope will lie on the dip of 1720 the strike line of the bedding plane, fracture, fault, or joint. 1721 (2) No slopes shall be cut in an existing landslide, mudflow, or 1722 other form of naturally unstable slope except as recommended by a 1723 qualified geological engineer. 1724 (3) Where the formation is exposed above the top of the cut 1725 which will permit the entry of water along bedding planes, this area shall 1726 be sealed with a compacted soil blanket having a minimum thickness of 1727 two feet (2'). The soil for this blanket shall be relatively impervious and 1728 shall be approved by the soils engineer or engineering geologist. 1729 f. If the material of a slope is of such composition and character as to 1730 be unstable under the anticipated maximum moisture content, the slope angle 1731 shall be reduced to a stable value or retained by a method approved by the city 1732 engineer and certified as to its stability by a soils engineer or geologist. Said 1733 retaining method shall include design provisions which are: 1734 (1) Conducive to revegetation for soil stability and visual 1735 impact; 1736 (2) Used for selected areas of the site and not as a general 1737 application; and 1738 (3) Limited to tiers each of which is no higher than six feet (6'), 1739 separated by plantable terraces a minimum of two feet (2') in width; 1740 g. Any retaining system shall remain and be maintained on the lots 1741 until plans for construction are approved and a building permit is issued. The 1742 plans shall include provisions to integrate driveway access to the lot while 1743 maintaining the structural integrity of the retaining system. 1744 h. The building official may require the slope of a cut or fill to be 1745 made more level if at any time it is found that the material being, or the fill, is 1746 unusually subject to erosion, static or dynamic instability, or if other conditions 1747 make such requirements necessary for stability. 49 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1748 5. Abatement Of Hazardous Conditions: 1749 a. If, at any stage of grading, the planning director or city engineer 1750 determines by inspection that the nature of the formation is such that further work 1751 as authorized by an existing permit is likely to imperil any property, public way, 1752 watercourse, or drainage structure, the planning director or city engineer shall 1753 require, as condition to allowing the work to proceed, that reasonable safety 1754 precautions be taken as are considered advisable to avoid likelihood of such peril. 1755 Such precautions may include, but shall not be limited to, any of the following: 1756 (1) Specification of a more level exposed slope; 1757 (2) Construction of additional drainage facilities, berms, or 1758 terraces; 1759 (3) Compaction or cribbing; 1760 (4) Installation of plants for erosion control; and/or 1761 (5) Reports from a registered soils engineer and/or engineering 1762 geologist whose recommendations may be made requirements for further 1763 work. 1764 Such requirements by the planning director or city engineer shall constitute a 1765 required change order in the work to be performed under permit. Said changes 1766 may be required to be reflected in amended plans. 1767 b. Where it appears that damage from storm drainage may result from 1768 work performed hereunder, such work may be stopped and the permittee required 1769 to take such measures as may be necessary to protect adjoining property or the 1770 public safety. On large operations, or where unusual site conditions exist, the 1771 planning director or city engineer may specify the time at which grading may 1772 proceed and the time of completion or may require that the operation be 1773 conducted in specific stages so as to ensure completion of protective measures or 1774 devices prior to the advent of seasonal rains. 1775 6. Fill Material And Compaction: 1776 a. Fill Material: All fill shall be earth, rock, or inert material free 1777 from organic material and free of metal, except that topsoil spread on cut and fill 1778 surfaces may incorporate humus for desirable moisture retention properties. Fill 1779 not meeting the definition above shall be placed only on approved public or 1780 private landfills or other approved deposit sites. 1781 b. Backfillings: Any pipe trench or trenching, or excavation made in 1782 any slope of any excavated or filled site, shall be backfilled and compacted to the 1783 level of the surrounding grade. 1784 c. Compaction Of Fills: Unless otherwise directed by the building 1785 official or city engineer, all fills governed by this title, intended to support 1786 building structures, or where otherwise required to be compacted for stability, 50 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1787 shall be compacted, inspected, and tested in accordance with the following 1788 provisions: 1789 (1) The natural ground surface shall be prepared by removal of 1790 topsoil and vegetation, and if necessary shall be graded to a series of 1791 terraces. If fill material unacceptable under subsection E6a of this section 1792 is placed on the site, or the fill is not placed according to procedures of 1793 this title, then it must be removed. 1794 (2) The fill shall be spread and compacted in accordance with 1795 the city engineer's approved standards. 1796 (3) The moisture content of the fill material shall be controlled 1797 at the time of spreading and compaction to obtain required maximum 1798 density. 1799 (4) A written report of the completed compaction, showing 1800 location and depth of test holes, materials used, moisture conditions, 1801 recommended soil bearing pressures, and relative density obtained from 1802 all tests, prepared by a civil engineer or soils engineer licensed by the state 1803 of Utah, or testing laboratory shall be submitted to the building official, 1804 who will submit it to the city engineer for review. 1805 (5) The building official or city engineer may require 1806 additional tests or information if, in his opinion, the conditions or 1807 materials are such that additional information is necessary, and may 1808 modify or delete any of the above listed requirements that, in his opinion, 1809 are unnecessary to further the purpose of this title. 1810 7. Erosion Control And Revegetation: All cut and fill surfaces created by 1811 grading shall be planted with a ground cover that is a drought resistant variety. Topsoils 1812 are to be stockpiled during rough grading and used on cut and fill slopes. Cuts and fills 1813 along public roads are required to be landscaped according to a revegetation plan 1814 approved by the city. All plant selections must be approved by the parks department and 1815 building official prior to subdivision approval. 1816 8. Drainage: 1817 a. Adequate provisions shall be made to prevent any surface waters 1818 from damaging the cut face of an excavation or any portion of a fill. All drainage 1819 ways and structures shall carry surface waters, without producing erosion, to the 1820 nearest practical street, storm drain, or natural watercourse as approved by the city 1821 engineer. The city engineer may also require drainage structures to be 1822 constructed, or installed as necessary to prevent erosion damage or to prevent 1823 saturation of the fill or material behind cut slopes. 1824 b. An excess stormwater passage shall be provided for all stormwater 1825 storage areas. Such passage shall have capacity to convey through the proposed 1826 development the excess stormwater from the tributary watershed. The capacity of 1827 such excess stormwater passages shall be constructed in such a manner as to 51 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1828 transport the peak rate of runoff from a 100-year return frequency storm assuming 1829 all storm sewers are inoperative, all upstream areas are fully developed in 1830 accordance with the city's current land use plan, and that antecedent rainfall has 1831 saturated the tributary watershed. 1832 c. No buildings or structures shall be constructed within such 1833 passage, however, streets, parking lots, playgrounds, park areas, pedestrian 1834 walkways, utility easements, and other open space uses shall be considered 1835 compatible uses. In the event such passageway is reshaped or its capacity to 1836 transport excess stormwater is otherwise restricted during or after construction, 1837 the city engineer shall notify the agency, party, or parties causing said restriction 1838 to remove the same and set a reasonable time for its removal. If said parties refuse 1839 to, or are unable to, comply with said order, the city engineer shall cause said 1840 restrictions to be removed at the expense of said parties. Where a proposed 1841 development contains existing natural drainage, appropriate planning measures 1842 shall be undertaken or required to preserve and maintain said natural drainage as 1843 part of the excess stormwater passage. 1844 d. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this title, whenever, in the 1845 judgment of the city engineer, a condition occurs in a stormwater storage area or 1846 passageway that creates a dangerous and imminent health and safety hazard, the 1847 city engineer shall order such action as shall be effective immediately or in the 1848 time manner prescribed in the order itself. 1849 9. Surcharging: Surcharges shall consist of earth material and shall be 1850 applied in such a manner as to have no effect on soil stability on adjacent or neighboring 1851 properties. 1852 10. No Structure Shall Be Located Over A Fault: Determinations of the 1853 appropriate setback distance from the fault shall be made based on recommendations 1854 contained in the geological report as per subsection 18.28.040C2 of this chapter. 1855 1856 18.28.060: INTERPRETATION, PERMIT PROCEDURE, APPEALS, GROUNDS FOR 1857 DENIAL, AND ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS: 1858 A. Interpretation; Conflicts: 1859 1. Minimum Requirements: In their interpretation and application, provisions 1860 of this chapter shall be held to be minimum requirements, except where expressly stated 1861 to be maximum requirements. No intent is made to impair, or interfere with, any private 1862 restrictions placed upon any property by covenant or deed; provided, however, that where 1863 this chapter imposes higher standards or greater restrictions the provisions of this chapter 1864 shall govern. 1865 2. Application Oof Most Restrictive Standard: Whenever any provision of 1866 this chapter or any other provision of law, whether set forth in this chapter or in any other 1867 law, ordinance, or resolution of any kind, imposes overlapping or contradictory 52 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1868 regulations over the development of land, the most restrictive standards or requirements 1869 shall govern. 1870 B. Retention Oof Plans: Plans, specifications, and reports for all site development 1871 submitted to Salt Lake City for approval shall be retained by Salt Lake City. 1872 C. Expiration, Renewals, Aand Extensions Oof Permit: Every site development 1873 permit or approval shall expire by limitation and become null and void if the work authorized by 1874 such permit or approvals has not been commenced within one hundred eighty (180) days, or if 1875 the work is suspended or abandoned for a period of one hundred eighty (180) days at any time 1876 after the work is commenced. Before such work can recommence, the permit shall first be 1877 renewed by the building official and the renewal fee shall be one-half (1/2) the amount required 1878 for a new permit for such work, provided no changes have been made or will be made in the 1879 original plans or scope of such work, otherwise a full fee may be required as determined by the 1880 building official. Any modifications to the original approved work that is related to a 1881 development for which the Salt Lake City planning commission granted approval, may require 1882 subsequent review and decision by the planning commission as determined by the planning 1883 director. 1884 D. Appeals: 1885 1. Filing: Any applicant aggrieved by a determination of any administrative official 1886 in relation to this chapter may appeal such determination to the appeals hearing officerboard of 1887 appeals and examiners pursuant to Chapter 18.12section 21A.16.030 of this code. 1888 2. Effect Oof Administrative Appeal: In the event of an appeal pursuant to the 1889 provisions above, the effect of such filing shall act to stay any and all further action and work 1890 pending the determination of the matter on appeal. 1891 E. General Grounds Ffor Denial: Factors, in addition to deviation from provisions of 1892 this chapter, which may be grounds for denial of a site development permit or approval shall 1893 include, but not be limited to: 1894 1. Possible or potential saturation of fill and/or unsupported cuts by water 1895 (both natural and/or domestic); 1896 2. Runoff surface waters that produce unreasonable erosion and/or silting of 1897 drainageways; 1898 3. Subsurface conditions (such as rock strata and faults, soil or rock 1899 materials, types of formations, etc.) which when disturbed by the proposed site 1900 development activity, may create earth movement and/or produce slopes that cannot be 1901 landscaped; 1902 4. Result in excessive and unnecessary scarring of the natural landscape 1903 through grading or removal of vegetation. 1904 F. Prohibited Activities: 1905 1. Removal Oof Topsoil: It shall be unlawful to remove topsoil for purposes 1906 of resale when unrelated to a bona fide purpose of site development contemplated under 53 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1907 this chapter. The provisions of this chapter shall not be construed as permitting the 1908 removal of topsoil solely for resale. 1909 2. Nuisance: It shall be unlawful to create or maintain a condition which 1910 creates a public or private nuisance. After notice by the city, owners shall be strictly 1911 responsible to take any necessary action to correct or abate such nuisance. Further, this 1912 chapter shall not be construed to authorize any person or owner to create or maintain a 1913 private or public nuisance upon real property and compliance with the provisions of this 1914 chapter shall not be a defense in any action to abate such nuisance. 1915 G. Permit Oor Approval Revocation: In the event the building official or city 1916 engineer requests that a site development permit or approval be permanently suspended or 1917 revokesd a site development permit any aggrieved party may appeal such decision pursuant to 1918 Chapter 18.12., they shall formally request a revocation hearing before the planning commission 1919 in compliance with the following procedures: 1920 1. Request: The request shall specify the grounds for complaint or details of 1921 deviation with terms and conditions of the approval that justify the proposed permit or 1922 approval revocation or suspension. 1923 2. Public Hearing: The planning commission shall hold a formal hearing to 1924 consider requests and recommendations for permanent revocation or suspension of 1925 permits at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the planning commission, at which 1926 service of the required notice can be satisfied. 1927 3. Notice: The planning commission shall cause notice of the time and place 1928 of the scheduled hearing to be prepared. Such notice shall be delivered by certified mail 1929 or personal service upon the permittee at least five (5) days prior to the date set for the 1930 hearing. At any such hearing, the permittee shall be given an opportunity to be heard and 1931 may call witnesses and present evidence. Upon conclusion of such hearing, the planning 1932 commission shall determine whether or not the permit shall be suspended or revoked, and 1933 any necessary or appropriate conditions which must be satisfied prior to the renewal or 1934 extension of said permit, including any necessary corrective measures to be completed as 1935 provided in subsection G4a of this section. 1936 4. Planning Commission Determination: Upon the conclusion of the required 1937 hearing and its deliberations thereon, should the planning commission find that the 1938 permittee, or authorized agent(s), have violated the terms of the permit or provisions of 1939 this chapter, have conducted or desire to carry out such site development activity in such 1940 a manner which unreasonably adversely affects the health, welfare, or safety of persons 1941 residing or working in the vicinity of the site, or have caused the same to be done, the 1942 planning commission may, as it deems appropriate: 1943 a. Require necessary corrective measures to be undertaken and 1944 completed at permittee's expense; 1945 b. Require reimbursement to the city for unusual costs incurred by the 1946 necessitation of enforcement action including costs of inspections, mailings, 1947 expert technical assistance, etc.; 54 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1948 c. Continue suspension of all work contemplated or associated with 1949 the permit permanently until corrective requirements and/or original conditions 1950 are satisfied; 1951 d. If circumstances of work conducted have resulted in factors which 1952 would have been grounds for denial of the permit, the planning commission may 1953 order such necessary actions as required to restore the site, insofar as possible, to 1954 the preexisting conditions, and revoke the site development permit. If so evoked, 1955 and where appropriate, the planning commission may preclude acceptance of any 1956 site development application for the same site for a period not to exceed twelve 1957 (12) months. 1958 5. Appeal: The decision of the planning commission on a request for 1959 permanent suspension or revocation of a site development permit or approval under this 1960 chapter may be appealed by the permittee, building official, or city engineer to the 1961 appeals hearing officer pursuant to section 21A.16.030 of this code. 1962 H. Property Owner Responsibility: Property owners are responsible to maintain their 1963 property in a safe, nonhazardous, condition and to otherwise comply with the provisions of this 1964 chapter and other applicable ordinances. Failure of city officials to observe or to recognize 1965 hazardous or unsightly conditions, or to recommend denial of the site development permit, shall 1966 not relieve the permittee, or property owner, from responsibility for the condition or damages 1967 resulting therefrom. Nor shall such action result in the city, its officers, or agents, becoming 1968 responsible or liable for conditions and damages resulting therefrom. 1969 I. Obstruction Prohibited: It shall be unlawful for any person to willfully or 1970 carelessly obstruct or injure any public right of way by causing or permitting earth or rock to 1971 slump, slough, or erode off private property onto the public right of way. 1972 J. Flooding: It shall be unlawful for any person to willfully or carelessly obstruct or 1973 injure any public right of way by causing or permitting flow or seepage of water, or by willfully 1974 or carelessly causing or permitting water under his/her control, possession, or supervision to 1975 escape in any manner so as to injure any street or public improvement. 1976 K. Violation And Penalties: 1977 1. Violation Of Chapter: It shall be unlawful for any person to construct, 1978 enlarge, alter, repair, or maintain any grading, excavation or fill or cause the same to be 1979 done, contrary to or in violation of any provision of this chapter. 1980 2. Obstruction Prohibited: It shall be unlawful for any person to wilfully or 1981 carelessly obstruct or injure any public right of way by causing or permitting earth or 1982 rock to slump, slough, or erode off private property onto the public right of way. 1983 3. Flooding: It shall be unlawful for any person to wilfully or carelessly 1984 obstruct or injure any public right of way by causing or permitting flow or seepage of 1985 water, or by wilfully or carelessly causing or permitting water under his/her control, 1986 possession, or supervision to escape in any manner so as to injure any street or public 1987 improvement. 55 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 1988 4. Misdemeanor Penalty: Any person violating any of the provisions of this 1989 chapter shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and each such person shall be deemed 1990 guilty of a separate offense for each and every day or portion thereof during which any 1991 violation of any of the provisions of this chapter is committed, continued, permitted, or 1992 maintained. Upon conviction of any such violation, such person may be imprisoned for a 1993 period not exceeding six (6) months or be fined in the amount not exceeding two hundred 1994 ninety nine dollars ($299.00) if the person is an individual, or the greater amount of two 1995 thousand dollars ($2,000.00) in the event the person is a corporation, association, or 1996 partnership, or both so imprisoned or fined. 1997 J. Severability: 1998 1. Severability: If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase of this 1999 chapter is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision of any 2000 court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the 2001 remaining portions of this chapter. The city council hereby declares that it would have 2002 passed this chapter and each section, subsection, sentence, clause, and phrase thereof, 2003 irrespective of the fact that one or more of the sections, subsections, sentences, clauses, or 2004 phrases hereof may be declared invalid or unconstitutional. 2005 2. Limitation To Applied Facts: If the application of any provision or 2006 provisions of this chapter to any person, property, or circumstance is found to be 2007 unconstitutional, invalid, or ineffective, in whole or in part, by any court of competent 2008 jurisdiction, or other competent agency, the effect of such provision shall be limited to 2009 the person, property, or circumstance immediately involved in the controversy and the 2010 application of such provision to other persons, properties, or circumstances shall be 2011 unaffected unless the court specifically rules otherwise. 2012 2013 18.28.070: RESERVED: 2014 2015 SECTION 8. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.32. That Chapter 2016 18.32 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Building Regulations) is 2017 hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: 2018 CHAPTER 18.32 2019 BUILDING REGULATIONS 2020 18.32.020: BUILDING CODE AND STANDARDS ADOPTED: 2021 The edition of the uniform building code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code 2022 commission as the construction standard to be adhered to by subdivisions of the state (section 2023 58-56-4, Utah Code Annotated, or its successor section) is adopted by Salt Lake City, together 2024 with the following chapters of the appendix to the uniform building code: 56 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2025 Chapter 3 Division IV - Requirements For Group R, Division 4 Occupancies; 2026 Chapter 11 Division I - Site Accessibility; 2027 Chapter 11 Division II - Accessibility For Existing Buildings; 2028 Chapter 15 Reroofing; 2029 Chapter 16 Division I - Snow Load Design; 2030 Chapter 16 Division III - Earthquake Regulations For Seismic Isolated Structures; 2031 Chapter 31 Division II - Membrane Structure; 2032 Chapter 33 Excavation And Grading. 2033 ICC/MBI Standard for Off-Site Construction: Planning, Design, Fabrication and Assembly, or its 2034 successor document. 2035 Hereafter, all references in this code to the uniform building code shall mean the said edition 2036 adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. One copy of the uniform building code 2037 shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. 2038 2039 18.32.035: FEES: 2040 A. Building permit fees shall be based on the total valuation of the proposed project 2041 as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2042 B. Plan review fees shall be sixty five percent (65%) of the building permit fees. 2043 C. Fees to expedite building plan review as governed by section 18.20.050 of this 2044 title shall be two (2) times the standard building plan review fee. 2045 D. Penalties for not obtaining permanent certificate of occupancy will be three 2046 hundred dollars ($300.00) for each month, after the initial thirty (30) day temporary certificate of 2047 occupancy, which has no additional cost associated with it; due before the first of the month and 2048 only allowed for up to three (3) renewals after the initial free thirty (30) day period. Partial 2049 months will not be refunded. 2050 E. Fees for renewing expired plan review after one hundred eighty (180) days as 2051 governed by section 18.20.110 of this title shall be shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 2052 schedule. 2053 F. A fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be charged for 2054 each permit for fencing. 2055 G. Other fees shall consist of electrical, mechanical and plumbing, and fire 2056 suppression and monitoring equipment inspection fees as shown on the Salt Lake City 2057 consolidated fee schedule. 57 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2058 18.32.050: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 3 DIVISION V ADDED; NONCONFORMING 2059 BUILDING CONVERSION: 2060 Appendix chapter 3 of the uniform building code be, and the same hereby is, amended by adding 2061 chapter 3 division V to create a group R division 5 occupancy classification and requirements 2062 applicable to change in occupancy when nonconforming group R divisions 1 and 3 occupancies 2063 undergo conversion, which shall read as follows: 2064 Chapter 3 Division V 2065 Requirements For Group R Division 5 Occupancies 2066 Sec. 344. Group R, Division 5 Occupancies Defined. Group R, division 5 occupancies shall be: 2067 nonconforming group R divisions 1 and 3 structures undergoing conversion. 2068 Sec. 345. General Provisions. Because conversion changes the original anticipated ownership 2069 plan for a multi-family dwelling unit project from a single ownership into a hybrid mixture of 2070 separate ownership of dwelling units combined with collective ownership of common areas 2071 through association, etc., each nonconforming group R division 1 or division 3 structure being 2072 converted into a condominium project or other type of ownership arrangement involving separate 2073 ownership of individual units combined with joint or collective ownership of common areas shall 2074 constitute a change in classification of occupancy to that of a group R division 5 and shall 2075 comply with basic requirements of this code and the specific requirements listed below. All work 2076 on such structures in the form of additions, alterations, or repairs shall conform to applicable 2077 standards as required by section 3403 of this code. Where said provisions require conformity to 2078 requirements governing new buildings, the applicable requirements of group R division 1 or 3 2079 new construction shall apply. 2080 Special Provisions And Minimum Standards. 2081 Sec. 346. Property Report. Each conversion project to obtain approval shall submit two copies of 2082 a property report prepared by a licensed engineer or architect which discloses and describes: 2083 (1) The age of the building or buildings, 2084 (2) The general condition, useful life, and capacity of the building's structural elements 2085 including the roof, foundations, mechanical system, electrical system, plumbing 2086 system, boiler, and other structural elements; 2087 (3) All known conditions constituting deficiencies requiring repair to meet existing 2088 building codes; and 2089 (4) All known conditions which may require repair or replacement within the next 2090 succeeding five year period. 2091 (5) The existing conditions meet the standards of the Salt Lake City existing residential 2092 housing code sections 18.50.140, Exterior Standards; 18.50.150, Interior Standards; 2093 18.50.180, Space And Occupancy Standards; 18.50.190, Light And Ventilation; 2094 18.50.200 Fire Safety-Egress. The building report, as required in section 20.56.060 of 2095 the city code, shall note all deficiencies; appeals of noted deficiencies may be 2096 addressed to the housing advisory and appeals board. 58 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2097 Said report shall certify the structure currently conforms to applicable codes or the owner shall 2098 present plans to bring the structures into conformity with applicable building codes prior to 2099 issuance of certificates of occupancy. 2100 Sec. 347. Electrical Service Minimum Standards. Each converted dwelling unit shall have an 2101 electrical service which provides: 2102 (1) A minimum service of 60 amps. 2103 (2) Receptacle outlets are required to meet standards of the national electrical code, 2104 section 210-21(b). Each habitable room shall have no less than two such receptacles. 2105 (3) Where a kitchen is provided, or required by this code, each kitchen shall be installed 2106 on a separate circuit. 2107 (4) If, as an option, dishwashers or garbage disposals are to be installed or provided for, 2108 each must be located on a separate circuit. If such appliances or optional capacity are 2109 not provided, the limitation must be disclosed to buyers and in the property report. 2110 (5) All bathrooms are to be equipped with GFIC outlet. 2111 (6) Lights and fixtures in all storage and equipment facilities over 84 sq. ft. in size. 2112 (7) Installation of a smoke detector conforming to manufacturer's recommendations shall 2113 be installed in each dwelling unit as a local detection unit. If the building has a 2114 common exit hall or corridor then a general automatic detection system shall be 2115 installed with the capability of sending a signal to a remote station. 2116 (8) Installation of at least one wall switch controlled lighting outlet in every habitable 2117 room, bathrooms, hallways, stairways, attached garages, and outdoor entrances. 2118 All electrical work and repair must be completed under permit and comply with applicable codes 2119 and ordinances. 2120 Sec. 348. Plumbing And Water Systems. 2121 (a) Plumbing System. A mechanical engineer, licensed plumbing contractor, or a 2122 licensed general contractor shall calculate and determine the capacity of the current 2123 plumbing system, including the existing and potential load in fixture units (as 2124 determined by the uniform plumbing code) as part of the property report required 2125 above. All new installations or repairs must be completed under permit and shall 2126 conform to applicable plumbing codes. The entire system shall be brought up to 2127 applicable standards of this code when required by section 3403. The impact of new 2128 installations upon the existing system shall be calculated and stated in the property 2129 report. 2130 (b) Water Supply. Water piping shall be so arranged that the water supply can be turned 2131 on or off to any individual fixture; provided, however, that supply piping to a single 2132 unit and building accessory thereto may be controlled by one valve. 2133 Sec. 349. Mechanical System. The mechanical system for each converted dwelling unit shall: 59 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2134 (1) Equip each unit with its own heating system, except where a central water or steam 2135 system is present. 2136 (2) Provide each unit with its own means of controlling temperature when the building 2137 utilizes a central heating plant. All mechanical work and repair shall be completed 2138 under permit and comply with applicable codes. 2139 Sec. 350. Discretion Of Building Official To Waive Minor Deviations. The foregoing minimum 2140 standards are intended to be fully complied with prior to the building official's approval of 2141 permits, record of survey maps, plans or certificates. However, the building official may waive 2142 literal compliance with said standards for minor deviations and non-dangerous conditions, if the 2143 official determines that strict compliance with the requirements of this chapter would be 2144 impractical due to the unique condition of the property, or result in an unnecessary and extreme 2145 hardship for the owner of the property. The building official may in such cases impose additional 2146 reasonable and equivalent conditions upon the project. 2147 Sec. 351. All condominiums shall meet the requirements as listed in 18.96.050 (fit premises) of 2148 the city ordinance. 2149 2150 18.32.060: UBC SECTION 109.1 AMENDED; CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: 2151 Section 109.1 of the uniform building code is amended to read as follows: 2152 Section 109.1 Use Or Occupancy. No building or structure of groups A, B, E, F, H, I, M, R and S 2153 occupancy shall be used or occupied, and no change in the existing occupancy classification of a 2154 building or structure or portion thereof shall be made until the building official has issued a 2155 certificate of occupancy therefor as provided herein. 2156 2157 18.32.090: UBC SECTION 204 AMENDED; DEFINITIONS: 2158 Section 204 of the uniform building code, adopted by section 18.32.020 of this chapter, or its 2159 successor, is amended by adding definitions of condominiums and conversions which shall read 2160 as follows: 2161 Condominium, Condominium Project, Condominium Unit. For purposes of this code, 2162 "condominium," "condominium project," and "condominium units" or "units" means property or 2163 portions thereof conforming to the definitions set forth in section 57-8-3 of Utah Code 2164 Annotated, 1953, as amended. 2165 Conversion. "Conversion" means a proposed change in the type of ownership in a parcel or 2166 parcels of land, together with existing attached structures, from single ownership of said parcel 2167 such as an apartment house or multi-family dwelling into a condominium project or other 2168 ownership arrangements involving separate ownership of individual units combined with joint or 2169 collective ownership of common areas, facilities, or elements. 60 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2170 18.32.120: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 35 ADDED; FLOOD HAZARD AREAS: 2171 The uniform building code is amended by adding a new appendix chapter 35, which reads as 2172 follows: 2173 Sec. 3501. Floodplain Hazard Area. For the purpose of this chapter "floodplain hazard area" shall 2174 mean those lands lying within the corporate limits of Salt Lake City as defined in section 2175 18.68.020 of the Salt Lake City code, as being located within the boundaries of flood hazard 2176 boundary map as defined in said section 18.68.020 and adopted by section 18.68.030 of the Salt 2177 Lake City code. A copy of said map and amendments is on file for public examination in the 2178 offices of the city recorder and city engineer. 2179 Sec. 3502. Floodplain Protection Requirements. All plans involving development, repair, 2180 substantial improvements to, or construction of building or structures within the floodplain 2181 hazard area shall comply with the standards set forth in chapter 18.68 of the Salt Lake City code 2182 relating to floodplain hazard regulations. 2183 2184 18.32.130: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 33 AMENDED; EXCAVATION AND 2185 GRADING: 2186 Appendix chapter 33 of the uniform building code, relating to excavation and grading, is hereby 2187 amended by deleting the text of sections 3304 through 3318 and amending by adding a cross 2188 reference, so appendix chapter 33 shall read as follows: 2189 Appendix Chapter 33 2190 Excavation And Grading 2191 Sec. 3304-3318. Said sections and their revised text are hereby deleted, having been incorporated 2192 within the text of chapter 18.28 of the Salt Lake City code relating to site development 2193 regulations, drawing particular reference to provisions within chapters 4 and 5 of said 2194 development regulations. 2195 2196 18.32.140: SENIOR CITIZEN APARTMENT FEE ABATEMENT: 2197 Qualified multi-family apartment projects may apply to, and receive from, the building official 2198 an abatement of the normal building permit fees. In order for the building official to approve the 2199 discount, the applicant must submit necessary documentation in order for the building official to 2200 certify that the apartment project qualifies under the following criteria: 2201 A. The project is owned and/or operated as a bona fide organization for providing 2202 housing for senior citizens; 2203 B. The project operators and/or property owners stipulate that all units shall be 2204 rented by persons over age sixty two (62) years of age; 2205 C. Operators and/or property owners agree to verify ages of tenants as part of their 2206 annual application for an apartment house license; 61 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2207 A. Project operators and property owners execute an agreement, binding upon 2208 successors in interest and secured by the real property, to reimburse the city the amount of the 2209 abated fees plus interest from the date of the permit at the rate applicable to judgment, should the 2210 rate of occupancy by qualified senior citizens drop below ninety five percent (95%) during the 2211 next thirty (30) years. This occupancy rate shall be determined annually as of the date the annual 2212 license application is submitted to the city; and 2213 B. The amount of the fees abated, plus interest at the then established rate applicable 2214 to judgments from date of the abated fees, shall be repaid to the city upon a subsequent 2215 application to convert the project to condominium or other ownership arrangements involving 2216 sale of separate units, if submitted within thirty (30) years of such abatement. 2217 2218 18.32.150: UBC SECTION 103 AMENDED; VIOLATIONS AND PENALTIES: 2219 Section 103 of the uniform building code is amended to read as follows: 2220 It shall be unlawful for any person, firm, or corporation to erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, 2221 move, improve, remove, convert, or demolish, equip, use, occupy, or maintain any building or 2222 structure in the city, or cause the same to be done contrary to or in violation of any of the 2223 provisions of this code. 2224 Any person, firm, or corporation violating any of the provisions of this code shall be deemed 2225 guilty of a misdemeanor and each such person shall be deemed guilty of a separate offense for 2226 each and every day or portion thereof during which any violation of any of the provisions of this 2227 code is committed, continued, or permitted and upon conviction of any such violation such 2228 persons shall be punishable by a fine as provided by section 1.12.050, or its successor, of the Salt 2229 Lake City code. 2230 2231 SECTION 9. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.36. That Chapter 2232 18.36 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Electrical Regulations) is 2233 hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: 2234 CHAPTER 18.36 2235 ELECTRICAL REGULATIONS 2236 2237 18.36.010: ELECTRICAL CODE ADOPTED BY REFERENCE: 2238 The edition of the national electrical code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code 2239 commission, is adopted by Salt Lake City as the ordinances, rules and regulations of the city, 2240 subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set forth in this chapter, one 2241 copy of which code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city 62 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2242 recorder. Hereafter, all references in this code to the national electrical code shall mean the 2243 edition of the national electrical code adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. 2244 2245 18.36.100: PERMIT FEES; RESIDENTIAL WORK: 2246 The following fees for a permit for the installation of electrical materials in residences, including 2247 multiapartment buildings, shall be paid to the city treasurer before any permit is valid. The basic 2248 fee for each permit requiring inspection is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 2249 schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City 2250 consolidated fee schedule. 2251 2252 18.36.110: FEE FOR TEMPORARY METERING: 2253 The fee for permit for temporary metering and service facilities shall be as shown on the Salt 2254 Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2255 2256 18.36.120: COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL FEES: 2257 The fees to be paid to the city treasurer for electrical permits covering work in industrial or 2258 commercial properties shall be computed as follows: 2259 A. Minimum Fee: Minimum fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City 2260 consolidated fee schedule. 2261 B.New Service Or Change Of Service: For new service, change of service, 2262 alterations or repairs of six hundred (600) volt or less capacity service entrance equipment, the 2263 fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2264 C. Subfeeders: Fee for installation, alteration or repair of subfeeders, including 2265 supply taps from subfeeders, shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2266 D. Transformers: The installation of transformers shall be subject to inspection fee 2267 when such transformers are an integral part of the consumer's distribution system. Such fee shall 2268 be in addition to the regular system inspection fee and shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City 2269 consolidated fee schedule. 2270 E. Motor Generator: The fee for installation of a motor generator for emergency or 2271 standby shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2272 F. Alternate Fee Schedule: Electrical permit fees shall be computed on the schedules 2273 set forth on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule and shall be paid prior to work being 2274 started. When a fee cannot be computed on the standard schedules, it shall be computed based on 2275 the alternate schedule shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 63 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2276 18.36.130: ELECTRICAL WORK EXCEEDING ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND 2277 DOLLARS: 2278 When the cost of electrical work exceeds one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00), electrical 2279 permit fees shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 2280 2281 18.36.170: POWER TO PANEL PERMITS; REQUIRED WHEN: 2282 All new construction shall require a power to panel permit in accordance with section 18.36.180 2283 of this chapter, or its successor section, to be issued in conjunction with the required electrical 2284 permit. 2285 2286 18.36.180: POWER TO PANEL PERMIT; FOR CONSTRUCTION PURPOSES ONLY: 2287 A. Temporary Basis: A power to panel permit shall authorize power for construction 2288 purposes on a temporary basis only; permanent power must be authorized separately. 2289 B. Permit: At the time power to panel is required to complete construction, the owner 2290 or contractor shall apply for and obtain a separate power to panel construction permit. Said 2291 permit shall be valid for a sixty (60) day period. 2292 C. Extensions: Thirty (30) day extensions for such permit may be issued upon the 2293 approval of building and housing services and upon payment of one-half (1/2) of the original 2294 permit fee for each extension. 2295 D. Certificate Of Occupancy: Final electrical approval for permanent power shall be 2296 withheld until a certificate of occupancy is issued. Occupancy occurring prior to the issuance of a 2297 certificate of occupancy shall result in a discontinuance of all power until occupancy is approved 2298 or until occupancy ceases. 2299 E. Expiration: Upon expiration of a power to panel construction permit, all power to 2300 the electrical panel shall be discontinued. 2301 F. Fees: 2302 60 day, no issue fee $20.00 30 day extension 7.00 2303 2304 18.36.210: VIOLATION; PENALTY: 2305 Any person, firm or corporation, whether acting as owner or occupant of the premises involved, 2306 or contractor, or otherwise, who violates or refuses to comply with any provisions of this title, or 2307 the national electrical code, as amended, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor. A separate offense 2308 shall be deemed to be committed on each day an offense occurs or continues. 64 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2309 SECTION 10. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.48. That Chapter 2310 18.48 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Dangerous Buildings) is 2311 hereby amended as follows: 2312 CHAPTER 18.48 2313 DANGEROUS BUILDINGS 2314 ARTICLE I. REPAIR, ORAND VACATION, OR BOARDING OF DANGEROUS 2315 BUILDINGS 2316 2317 18.48.010: TITLE: 2318 This chapter and the provisions included herein constitute Salt Lake City's Dangerous Building 2319 Code, and will be referred to hereinafter as "the Dangerous Building Code" or "this Code." This 2320 Code chapter shall implementis modeled after the Uniform Code for the Abatement of 2321 Dangerous Buildings, 1997 Edition, and has only been adopted as stated herein. 2322 2323 18.48.020: PURPOSE AND SCOPE: 2324 It is the purpose of this chapterthe Dangerous Building Code to provide just, equitable, and 2325 practicable methods to require the repair (including temporary boarding) and, vacation, or 2326 temporary boarding of buildings or structures that endanger the life, limb, health, morals, 2327 property, safety, or welfare of the general public or their occupants. The provisions of this 2328 Dangerous Building Code are cumulative and in addition to any other remedy provided by law. 2329 2330 18.48.030: DEFINITIONS: 2331 BUILDING CODE: The International Building Code, or its successor, promulgated by the 2332 International Code Council, as adopted by the state. 2333 BOARDED BUILDING: A building in which accessible openings, such as windows and doors, 2334 are secured by a secondary means against entry. Examples of securing a building by a secondary 2335 means includes, but is not limited to, boarding and fencing. 2336 DANGEROUS BUILDINGS: For the purpose of this Dangerous Building Code, aAny building 2337 or structure that has any or all of the conditions or defects hereinafter described may be deemed 2338 to be a dangerous building, provided that such conditions or defects exist to the extent that the 2339 life, health, property, or safety of the public or its occupants are endangered. 2340 A. Whenever any door, aisle, passageway, stairway or other means of exit is not of sufficient 2341 width or size or is not so arranged as to provide safe and adequate means of exit in case 2342 of fire or panic. 65 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2343 B. Whenever the walking surface of any aisle, passageway, stairway or other means of exit 2344 is so warped, worn, loose, torn or otherwise unsafe as to not provide safe and adequate 2345 means of exit in case of fire or panic. 2346 C. Whenever the stress in any materials, member or portion thereof, due to all dead and live 2347 loads, is more than one and one half 1.5 times the working stress or stresses allowed in 2348 the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose or location. 2349 D. Whenever any portion thereof has been damaged by fire, earthquake, wind, flood, or by 2350 any other cause, to such an extent that the structural strength or stability thereof is 2351 materially less than it was before such catastrophe and is less than the minimum 2352 requirements of the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose, or 2353 location. 2354 E. Whenever any portion or member or appurtenance thereof is likely to fail, or to become 2355 detached or dislodged, or to collapse and thereby injure persons or damage property. 2356 F. Whenever any portion of a building, or any member, appurtenance, or ornamentation on 2357 the exterior thereof is not of sufficient strength or stability, or is not so anchored, 2358 attached, or fastened in place so as to be capable of resisting a wind pressure of one half 2359 of that specified in the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose or 2360 location without exceeding the working stresses permitted in the Building Code for such 2361 buildings. 2362 G. Whenever any portion of a building or structure has wracked, warped, buckled, or settled 2363 to such an extent that walls or other structural portions have materially less resistance to 2364 winds or earthquakes than is required in the case of similar new construction. 2365 H. Whenever the building or structure, or any portion thereof, because of (i) dilapidation, 2366 deterioration or decay; (ii) faulty construction; (iii) the removal, movement or instability 2367 of any portion of the ground necessary for the purpose of supporting such building; (iv) 2368 the deterioration, decay or inadequacy of its foundation; or (v) any other cause, is likely 2369 to partially or completely collapse. 2370 I. Whenever, for any reason, the building or structure, or any portion thereof, is manifestly 2371 unsafe for the purpose for which it is being used. 2372 J. Whenever the exterior walls or other vertical structural members list, lean, or buckle to 2373 such an extent that a plumb line passing through the center of gravity does not fall inside 2374 the middle one third of the base. 2375 K. Whenever the building or structure, exclusive of the foundation, shows thirty three 2376 percent (33%) or more damage or deterioration of its supporting member or members, or 2377 fifty percent (50%) damage or deterioration of its non-supporting members, enclosing or 2378 outside walls or coverings. 2379 L. Whenever the building or structure has been so damaged by fire, wind, earthquake, or 2380 flood, or has become so dilapidated or deteriorated as to become an attractive nuisance to 2381 children or as to enable persons to resort thereto for the purpose of committing unlawful 2382 acts. 66 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2383 M. Whenever any building or structure has been constructed, exists, or is maintained in 2384 violation of any specific requirement or prohibition applicable to such building or 2385 structure provided by the building regulations of this jurisdiction, as specified in the 2386 Building Code or Housing Code, or of any law or ordinance of this state or jurisdiction 2387 relating to the condition, location, or structure of buildings. 2388 N. Whenever any building or structure which, whether or not erected in accordance with all 2389 applicable laws and ordinances, has in any non-supporting part, member or portion less 2390 than fifty percent (50%), or in any supporting part, member or portion less than sixty six 2391 percent (66%) of the (i) strength, (ii) fire-resisting qualities or characteristics, or (iii) 2392 weather-resisting qualities or characteristics required by law in the case of a newly 2393 constructed building of like area, height and occupancy in the same location. 2394 O. Whenever a building or structure, used or intended to be used for dwelling purposes, 2395 because of inadequate maintenance, dilapidation, decay, damage, faulty construction or 2396 arrangement, inadequate light, air or sanitation facilities, or otherwise, is determined by 2397 the health officer to be unsanitary, unfit for human habitation, or in such a condition that 2398 is likely to cause sickness or disease. 2399 P. Whenever any building or structure, because of obsolescence, dilapidated condition, 2400 deterioration, damage, inadequate exits, lack of sufficient fire-resistive construction, 2401 faulty electric wiring, gas connections or heating apparatus, or other cause, is determined 2402 by the fire marshal to be a fire hazard. 2403 Q. Whenever any building or structure is in such a condition as to constitute a public 2404 nuisance known to the common law or in equity jurisprudence. 2405 R. Whenever any portion of a building or structure remains on a site after the demolition or 2406 destruction of the building or structure or whenever any building or structure is 2407 abandoned for a period in excess of six months so as to constitute such building or 2408 portion thereof an attractive nuisance or hazard to the public. 2409 DIVISION: Salt Lake City's Division of Building Services, or the successor Salt Lake City 2410 division authorized to perform the repair, vacation, or boarding of a building under this chapter. 2411 HOUSING CODE: The Salt Lake City Existing Residential Housing Ordinance as promulgated 2412 in Chapter 18.50 of the City Code. 2413 VACANT/SECURE BUILDING: An unoccupied building having all openings, such as windows 2414 and doors, secured against entry, where windows are fully glazed and the doors are secured by 2415 means of a lock. 2416 2417 18.48.040: AUTHORITY TO ENFORCE: 2418 A. Authority Tto Enforce: The building official or designee is hereby authorized to 2419 enforce the provisions of this chapterDangerous Building Code. The building official shall have 2420 the power to render interpretations of this Dangerous Building Code and to adopt and enforce 2421 rules and supplemental regulations to clarify the application of its provisions. Such 67 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2422 interpretations, rules, and regulations shall be in conformity with the intent and purpose of this 2423 Dangerous Building Code. 2424 B. Authority Tto Inspect: The building official or their designee is hereby authorized 2425 to make inspections and take such actions as may be required to enforce the provisions of this 2426 chapterDangerous Building Code. 2427 C. Buildings Oor Structures Subject Tto Inspection: Any building or structure, where 2428 there is reasonable cause to believe a condition exists that renders the building or structure 2429 endangering the life, limb, health, morals, property, safety, or welfare of the general public or the 2430 structure’s occupants in violation of the provisions of this code, is subject to inspection by the 2431 building official or their designee in the manner provided by this Dangerous Building Code. 2432 D. Inspection When Permit Required: All construction or work for which a permit is 2433 required is subject to inspection by the building official or their designee in accordance with and 2434 in the manner provided by this Dangerous Building Code. 2435 E. Inspections: The building official or their designee may enter a building or 2436 structure at reasonable times to inspect or to perform the duties imposed by this 2437 chapterDangerous Building Code. 2438 1. If the building or structure is occupied, the building official or designee 2439 shall present credentials to the occupant and request entry. 2440 2. If the building or structure is unoccupied, the building official or their 2441 designee shall make reasonable efforts to locate the owner or other persons having charge 2442 or control of the building or premises and request entry. 2443 3. If entry is refused, the building official or their designee shall have 2444 recourse to the remedies provided by law to secure entry. 2445 2446 18.48.050: PROCEDURES UPON DETERMINATION OF A VIOLATION: 2447 A. Initiation Of Action: When the building official has inspected or caused to be 2448 inspected any building and has found and determined that such building is a dangerous building, 2449 the building official shall follow the enforcement procedures set forth in the 1997 Uniform Code 2450 for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildingscommence proceedings to cause the repair , vacation, 2451 or boarding of the building. 2452 B. Form Of Notice And Order: The building official shall issue a written notice and 2453 order directed to the record owner of the building. 2454 1. The notice and order shall: 2455 a. Identify the property owner of record according to the records of 2456 the Salt Lake County Recorder; 2457 b. Describe the property and contain a statement that the building 2458 official has found the building to be dangerous with a brief and concise 68 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2459 description of the conditions found to render the building dangerous under the 2460 provisions of this code; and 2461 c. Require the property owner to take action as determined by the 2462 building official. 2463 (1) If the building official has determined that the building or 2464 structure must be repaired or boarded, the order shall require that all 2465 required permits be secured and the work physically commenced within 2466 such time as the building official shall determine is reasonable under all of 2467 the circumstances, which time shall not be less than ten (10) days from the 2468 date after the day the notice is delivered in person or postmarked. 2469 (2) If the building official has determined that the building or 2470 structure must be vacated, the order shall require that the building or 2471 structure shall be vacated within a time certain from the date of the order 2472 as determined by the building official to be reasonable, which time shall 2473 not be less than ten (10) days from the date after the day the notice is 2474 delivered in person or postmarked. 2475 d. A statement that, if any required repair work not also requiring the 2476 vacation of property is not commenced within the time specified in Subsection 2477 18.48.050.B.1.c.(1), the building official will order the building vacated and 2478 posted to prevent further occupancy until the work is completed and may proceed 2479 to cause the work to be done and recover the costs as set forth in Section 2480 18.48.100. 2481 e. A statement that (i) any person having any record title or legal interest in the 2482 building may appeal from the notice and order of the building official , except for an objection 2483 from an itemized statement of costs, to the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board as established 2484 in this chapter, provided the appeal is made in writing as provided in this code and filed with the 2485 building official within thirty (30) days from the date of service of such notice and order; and (ii) 2486 failure to appeal will constitute a waiver of all right to an administrative hearing and 2487 determination of the matter. 2488 C. Service: The written notice and order, and any amended or supplemental notice 2489 and order, shall be served on the property owner of record according to the records of the county 2490 recorder. Service shall be made in person or by certified or commercial courier service. The 2491 failure of any such person to receive such notice shall not affect the validity of any proceedings 2492 taken under this section. Service by certified mail in the manner herein provided shall be 2493 effective on the date the notice and order are postmarked. 2494 D. Proof Of Service: Proof of service of the notice and order shall be certified at the 2495 time of service by a written declaration under penalty of perjury executed by the persons 2496 effecting service, declaring the time, date, and manner in which service was made. The 2497 declaration, together with any receipt card returned in acknowledgment of receipt by certified 2498 mail or commercial courier service shall be affixed to the copy of the notice and order retained 2499 by the building official. 69 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2500 E. Recording Of Certificate: If compliance is not had with the order within the time 2501 specified therein, and no appeal has been properly and timely filed, the building official shall file 2502 in the office of the county recorder a certificate describing the property and certifying (i) that the 2503 building is a dangerous building and (ii) that the owner has been so notified. If the actions 2504 ordered are completed after filing of this certificate or the building is demolished so that it no 2505 longer exists as a dangerous building on the property, the building official shall file a new 2506 certificate with the county recorder certifying that the building has been demolished or all 2507 required corrections have been made so that the building is no longer dangerous, whichever is 2508 appropriate. 2509 2510 18.48.060: NOTICE TO VACATE: RESERVED 2511 A. Form Of Notice: Every notice to vacate shall, in addition to being served as 2512 provided in Section 18.48.050, be posted on the exterior of the building and shall be in 2513 substantially the following form: 2514 DO NOT ENTER 2515 UNSAFE TO OCCUPY 2516 It is a misdemeanor to occupy this building, or to remove or deface this notice. 2517 Building Official 2518 ……of…… 2519 Salt Lake City 2520 B.Compliance With Notice To Vacate: No person shall remain or enter any building 2521 which has been so posted, except that entry may be made to repair or board. No person shall 2522 remove or deface any such notice after it is posted. 2523 2524 18.48.070: RESERVEDEXTENSION OF TIME TO PERFORM WORK: 2525 Upon a timely written request by the owner setting forth the requested reasons for an extension 2526 of time, the building official or designee may grant an extension of time, not to exceed one 2527 hundred twenty (120) days from the deadline set forth in the original notice and order, within 2528 which to complete said repair, vacation, or boarding, if the building official determines that such 2529 an extension of time will not create or perpetuate a situation imminently dangerous to life or 2530 property. The building official's authority to extend time is limited to the physical repair, 2531 vacation, or boarding of the premises and will not in any way affect the time to appeal the notice 2532 and order. 2533 2534 18.48.080: APPEALS: 70 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2535 A. Hearing Appeals: Appeals of a notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter 2536 shall be taken in accordance with Chapter 18.12Timely written appeals of notice and orders or 2537 any action of the building official, except for an objection from an itemized statement of costs, 2538 shall be heard and decided by the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board. 2539 B. Form Of Notice: Any person entitled to service under Section 18.48.050 may 2540 appeal from any notice and order or any action of the building official under this code by filing at 2541 the office of the building official a written appeal containing: 2542 1. A heading containing the words: "Before the housing advisory and appeals 2543 board ______"; 2544 2. A caption reading: "Appeal of _______," giving the names of all 2545 appellants participating in the appeal; 2546 3. A brief statement setting forth the legal interest of each of the appellants in 2547 the building or the land involved in the notice and order; 2548 4. A brief statement in ordinary and concise language of the specific order or 2549 action protested, together with any material facts claimed to support the contentions of 2550 the appellant; 2551 5. A brief statement in ordinary and concise language of the relief sought and 2552 the reasons why it is claimed the protested order or action should be reversed, modified 2553 or otherwise set aside; 2554 6. The signatures of all parties named as appellants and their official mailing 2555 addresses; and 2556 7. The verification (by declaration under penalty of perjury) of at least one 2557 appellant as to the truth of the matters stated in the appeal. 2558 C. Time To File An Appeal: The appeal must be filed within thirty (30) days from 2559 the date of the issuance of the notice and order described herein, except as provided in 2560 Subsection D. 2561 D. Time To File An Appeal For An Imminently Dangerous Building: If the building 2562 or structure is in such condition as to make it immediately dangerous to the life, limb, property or 2563 safety of the public or adjacent property and is ordered vacated and is posted in accordance with 2564 Section 18.48.060, such appeal shall be filed as soon as reasonably practical from the date of the 2565 issuance of the notice and order of the building official. 2566 E. Transmittal Of Appeal: Upon receipt of any appeal filed pursuant to this section, 2567 the building official shall transmit the appeal to the members of the Housing Advisory and 2568 Appeals Board for scheduling of a meeting within thirty (30) days of receipt of a timely appeal. 2569 F. Scheduling Hearing: As soon as practicable after receiving the written appeal, the 2570 Housing Advisory and Appeals board shall fix a date, time and place for the hearing of the 2571 appeal by the board. Such date shall not be less than ten (10) days nor more than thirty (30) days 2572 from the date the appeal was filed with the building official, unless extraordinary circumstances 2573 are present. Written notice of the time and place of the hearing shall be given at least ten (10) 71 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2574 days prior to the date of the hearing to each appellant by the secretary of the board either by 2575 causing a copy of such notice to be delivered to the appellant personally or by mailing a copy 2576 thereof, postage prepaid, addressed to the appellant at the address shown on the appeal. 2577 G. Failure To Timely Appeal: Failure of any person to file a timely appeal in 2578 accordance with the provisions of this code shall constitute a waiver of the right to an 2579 administrative hearing and adjudication of the notice and order or any portion thereof. 2580 H. Issues Considered On Appeal: Only those matters or issues specifically raised by 2581 the appellant shall be considered in the hearing of the appeal. 2582 I. Stays Pending Appeal: Except for vacation or boarding orders made pursuant to 2583 Section 18.48.050, enforcement of any notice and order of the building official issued under this 2584 Dangerous Building Code shall be stayed during the pendency of an appeal therefrom which is 2585 properly and timely filed. 2586 J. Authority To Hear And Evaluate Appeal: The Housing Advisory and Appeals 2587 Board shall have the authority to hear and evaluate evidence related to the building official's 2588 decision and determine whether the decision was arbitrary and capricious or illegal. The Housing 2589 Advisory and Appeals Board has no authority relative to interpretation of the administrative 2590 provisions of this code nor is the board empowered to waive requirements of this code. After the 2591 Housing Advisory and Appeals Board makes a final determination, they shall issue a written 2592 determination. 2593 K. Appeal To Utah District Court: After issuance of a final written determination by 2594 the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board, the decision may be appealed to the Utah District 2595 Court, Third Judicial District within thirty (30) days from the issuance of the decision. 2596 2597 18.48.090: CITY'S ABATEMENT OF PROPERTY: 2598 If the property owner does not comply with the notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter 2599 within the time specified in the notice and order and no appeal has been properly and timely 2600 filed, the building official or designees may cause the building to be repaired, vacated, or 2601 temporarily boarded to the extent necessary to correct the conditions which render the building 2602 dangerous as set forth in the notice and order. Any such repair, vacation, or boarding shall be 2603 completed and the cost thereof paid and recovered as set forth in this chaptercode. 2604 2605 18.48.100: RECOVERY OF COSTS: 2606 A. Permitted Recovery Oof Costs: If the building official or designee causes the 2607 repair, vacation, or boarding of a building pursuant to a notice issued under this chapterSection 2608 18.48.050, and after the property owner received at least 10 days’ notice in which to complete 2609 the repair, vacation or boarding and failed to do so, the division may collect the cost of that 2610 abatement, by filing a property tax lien, as set forth in this section. 2611 B. Itemized Statement Oof Costs: Upon completion of the repair, vacation, or 2612 boarding work, the building official or designee shall prepare an itemized statement of costs and 72 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2613 mail it to the property owner by certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable 2614 of confirming delivery, demanding payment within thirty (30) days of the date the statement is 2615 post marked. The administrative fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule to 2616 cover the city's administrative expenses in contracting for the repair, boarding, or other 2617 abatement costs shall be included in the statement of costs. 2618 C. Form Oof Itemized Statement Oof Costs: The itemized statement of costs shall 2619 include: 2620 1. Include: 2621 a. The address of the property at issue; 2622 2.b. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the division, including 2623 administrative costs; 2624 3.c. A demand for payment; and 2625 4.d. The address where payment is to be made; 2626 5.2. NotifyNotification t the property owner: 2627 a. That failure to timely pay the expenses described in the itemized statement 2628 may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter and Utah Code 2629 Section 10-11-4 or its successor; 2630 6.b. Notification tThat the property owner may file a written objection to all or 2631 part of the statement within twenty (20) days of the date the statement is postmarked; and 2632 7.c. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the name of 2633 the office and the mailing address. 2634 D. Delivery Oof Statement Oof Costs: The itemized statement of costs described in 2635 Subsection C shall be deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or reputable mail tracking 2636 service that is capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the property 2637 owner, according to the records of the county recorder. 2638 E. Objection Tto Statement Oof Costs: A property owner may appeal the statement 2639 of costs to the fines hearing officer, only as to the issue of whether the costs were actually 2640 incurred, pursuant to Section 18.12.050.If the property owner files a timely written objection, the 2641 division will schedule a hearing and will mail or deliver to the property owner prior to the 2642 hearing a notice stating the date, time, and location of the hearing. A fines hearing officer, 2643 appointed pursuant to Section 21A.06.090, shall preside at the hearing and consider the property 2644 owner's objection as set forth in Subsection F. 2645 F. Objection Hearing: At the hearing described in Subsection E, after the property 2646 owner presents the objection to the hearing officer, the fines hearing officer shall review and 2647 determine the cost of abatement incurred by the division in abating the property, including 2648 administrative costs. The property owner must pay any amount the fines hearing officer 2649 determines is due and owing to the Salt Lake City Treasurer at the address provided in the 2650 statement of costs within thirty (30) days of the date of the hearing. 73 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2651 F.G. Failure Tto Object Oor Pay: If the property owner fails to make payment of the 2652 amount set forth in the itemized statement within thirty (30) days of the date of the mailing of 2653 that statement, or to file a timely objection, then the division may certify the past due costs and 2654 expenses to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. 2655 G.H. Failure Tto Pay Aafter Objection Hearing: If the property owner files a timely 2656 objection but fails to make payment of any amount ordered by the fines hearing officerfound due 2657 and owing under Subsection F within thirty (30) days of the date of the hearing, the inspector 2658 may certify the past due costs and expense to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. 2659 H.I. Lien Oon Property: After entry by the Salt Lake County Treasurertreasurer of the 2660 county, as set forth in Subsections FG and GH, the amount entered shall have the force and 2661 effect of a valid judgment of the district court, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by 2662 the Salt Lake County Ttreasurer of the county in which the property is located at the time of the 2663 payment of general taxes. 2664 I.J. Release Oof Lien: Upon payment of the amount set forth in the itemized 2665 statement of costs or otherwise determined due and owing by the fines hearing officer in 2666 Subsections E and F, the judgment is satisfied, the lien is released from the property, and receipt 2667 shall be acknowledged upon the general tax receipt issued by the treasurer. 2668 2669 18.48.110: APPLICABILITY OF BUILDING CODE: 2670 All buildings or structures which are required to be repaired under the provisions of this 2671 chaptercode shall be subject to the provisions of the applicable construction codes adopted 2672 pursuant to Section 18.04.040International Building Code, or its successor section. 2673 2674 18.48.120: PUBLIC NUISANCES: 2675 A. Declaration Aand Abatement Oof Public Nuisances: All buildings or structures or 2676 portions thereof which are determined after inspection by the building official to be dangerous as 2677 defined in this code are hereby declared to be public nuisances and shall be abated by repair, 2678 vacation, or boarding in accordance with the procedures specified herein. 2679 B. Boarded or Vacant Building Aas Public Nuisance: Any structure that is vacant or 2680 which has been boarded for over two (2) years may be declared to be a public nuisance upon a 2681 determination that the structure isas detrimental to the safety orand public welfare of the 2682 residents and property values of this city. 2683 2684 ARTICLE II. BOARDING OR TEMPORARILY SECURING BUILDINGS 2685 2686 18.48.200: SCOPE AND APPLICABILITY: 74 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2687 The provisions of this article apply to any person or entity who is ordered to board a building 2688 under Article I and any person or entity who voluntarily boards a building. 2689 2690 18.48.205: BOARDING PERMITREGISTRATION: 2691 A. PermitRegistration Required: A permit Registration is required to board a 2692 building. In the case where the city causes the boarding work to be done pursuant to Section 2693 18.48.245, the city will register the property on which the building is located and will bill the 2694 record owner the yearly registration fee pursuant to Section 18.48.215is not required to obtain a 2695 boarding permit. In the case where the building official causes temporary boarding work to be 2696 done pursuant to Section 18.48.090 and the building is boarded for more than 45 days, the 2697 provisions of this Article II shall apply. 2698 B. Form Of PermitRegistration Process: Registration of a property on which a 2699 boarded structure shall be located must be donePermits for boarding a building must be applied 2700 for on a form provided by the building official or designee. The form shall specify the following: 2701 1. The address of the structure to be boarded or temporarily secured; 2702 2. The type of building; 2703 3. For residential structures, the number of dwelling units; 2704 4. For nonresidential buildings, the number of square feet of all building 2705 faces at ground level; 2706 5. The name, address, and telephone number of a person authorized to act as 2707 an agent for the owner for performing the owner's obligations under this article, who lives 2708 within forty (40) miles of Salt Lake City; and 2709 6. Whether the property has the required external water source for 2710 landscaping, if landscaping is required. 2711 2712 18.48.210: INITIAL FEESNOTICE OF REGISTRATION: 2713 For the first year of any boarding, at the time of filing the application, the applicant shall pay the 2714 fees shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule for each structure. Upon registration 2715 the city may record with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of registration. The 2716 recordation of a notice of registration shall not be deemed an encumbrance on the property but 2717 shall merely place interested parties on notice that the cost of City abatement activities conducted 2718 pursuant to Section 18.48.245 may be outstanding and recoverable as a lien on the property in 2719 accordance with Section 18.48.100. Once the building official determines that the property is no 2720 longer subject to registration then a notice of deregistration shall be recorded. Recordation of the 2721 notice of deregistration shall have the effect of canceling the recorded notice of registration. 2722 2723 18.48.215: YEARLY REGISTRATION FEES: 75 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2724 A. Annual Fee: Upon registration and onOn or before each yearly anniversary of the 2725 date the property was registered pursuant to this articleissuance of a boarding permit, a property 2726 owner desiring to maintain a boarded building shall pay the annual boarding registration fee 2727 shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. Properties that are defined as a 2728 “contributing structure” or “landmark site” pursuant to Section 21A.34.020 shall be subject to a 2729 higher registration fee. A change in ownership shall not restart the yearly amount of registration 2730 fees, but such fees shall increase as set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule in 2731 accordance with the amount of time that the property has been registered. 2732 B. Late Penalty and InterestFee: If annual registration fees are not timely paid, an 2733 accounts receivable fee and interest shall accrue pursuant to Section 3.16.040.A late fee of 2734 twenty five dollars ($25.00) shall be assessed by the city for each thirty (30) days, or any portion 2735 thereof, in which the annual fees have not been paid up to amounts allowed by state law. 2736 C. Failure Tto RegisterObtain Permit: Boarding a building before 2737 registeringobtaining a permit pursuant to this article shall result in a fine of up to twenty five 2738 percent (25%) of the boarding registrationapplication fee specified in the Salt Lake City 2739 consolidated fee schedule. 2740 D. Collection Oof Fees: If the property owner fails to pay either the initial boarding 2741 fees or the annual boarding registration fees, the city may take legal action to collect any 2742 amounts owed. 2743 2744 18.48.220: POSTING OF BOARDED OR CLOSED TO OCCUPANCY BUILDINGS: 2745 Whenever a building is boarded or closed to occupancy, the city shall be authorized to install a 2746 sign to be mounted on the exterior of the building. The sign shall state that the building is closed 2747 to occupancy and that it is unlawful for any unauthorized person to enter the building. The sign 2748 shall also provide phone numbers to call if people are seen on the property or if doors or 2749 windows are unsecured. 2750 2751 18.48.225: METHOD OF SECURING BUILDINGS: 2752 All buildings shall be boarded in the following manner: 2753 A. Securing Opening: All openings in the structure on the first floor, other openings 2754 easily accessible from the ground, and openings with broken glass, shall be secured either by 2755 erecting a single one-half 1/2 inch (1/2") thick layer of plywood sheathing or similar material, 2756 not to include chipboard/OSB, covering over all exterior openings, overlapping the opening on 2757 every edge by three3 inches (3"), affixed along the edges by nails or screws spaced every six6 2758 inches (6"). 2759 B. Alternatives to Securing Openings: Alternately, the openings may be secured by 2760 conventional wood frame construction. The frames shall use wood studs of a size not less than 2761 two2 inches by four4 inches (2" x 4") (nominal dimension) placed not more than 24twenty four 2762 inches (24") apart on center. The frame stud shall have the four4 inch (4") sides or the wide 76 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2763 dimension perpendicular to the face of the wall. Each side of the frame shall be covered with 2764 plywood sheathing or similar material of at least one-half1/2 inch (1/2") thickness or equivalent 2765 lumber nailed over the opening by using nails or screws spaced every six6 inches (6") on the 2766 outside edges and every twelve12 inches (12") along intermediate stud supports; and 2767 C. Exterior Doors: Exterior doors shall be secured by a strong non-glass door 2768 adequately locked to preclude entry of unauthorized persons, or shall be covered as an opening 2769 described in Subsection A or B of this section or successor sections. 2770 2771 18.48.230: LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE: 2772 Existing landscaping and lawn on the property shall be maintained in the manner otherwise 2773 required by Chapters 9.16 and 21A.48. 2774 2775 18.48.235: EXTERIOR MAINTENANCE: 2776 A. Exterior Oof Building: The exterior of a boarded building shall be maintained as 2777 required by relevant requirements set forth in Section 18.50.140 of this title. In particular, 2778 exterior walls and surfaces shall be properly maintained and severely weathered, peeling, or 2779 unpainted wood and damaged siding and roofing shall be replaced or repaired with similar 2780 materials and colors. 2781 B. Salvage Permit Required: Doors, windows, special glass, fixtures, fittings, pipes, 2782 railings, posts, panels, boards, lumber, stones, bricks, marble, or similar materials within the 2783 interior of a boarded building shall not be salvaged except upon the issuance of a permit as 2784 provided in Section 18.64.070 of this title. 2785 C. Enforcement of Exterior Maintenance Requirements: If the owner of a boarded 2786 building fails to maintain the building and its premises as required by this section and Section 2787 18.64.045 of this title, the city may take appropriate legal action to enforce such requirements. 2788 2789 18.48.240: SNOW AND ICE REMOVAL: 2790 Snow and ice must be removed from public sidewalk areas surrounding the boarded property in 2791 the manner indicated in Section 14.20.070 of this code. 2792 2793 18.48.245: CITY MAINTENANCE OF PROPERTY: 2794 A. Notice: If the building official or the building official's designee determines that a 2795 boarded building and/or property is not being maintained, the building official or the building 2796 official's designee shall issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 18.24.040send a notice to the 2797 property owner and/or the property owner's agent requiring compliance with the building 2798 maintenance standards as required in city code. 77 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2799 B. Failure to Comply with Notice: If the building official or designee determines that 2800 the property owner has failed to comply with the notice and order, the city may cause the work to 2801 be done by a contractor hired by the city and the city may recover its abatement costs in 2802 accordance with the process set forth in Section 18.48.100. 2803 C. City's Recovery Of Costs: The city shall bill the property owner: 2804 1. The administrative fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 2805 schedule to cover the city's administrative expenses in contracting for the building 2806 maintenance; and 2807 2. The actual cost of building maintenance billed to the city by the city's 2808 contractor. 2809 2810 18.48.250: CITY MAINTENANCE OF LANDSCAPING: 2811 If the building official or the building official's designee determines that the landscaping on the 2812 property surrounding a boarded building is not being maintained as required by city code, the 2813 building official or the building official's designee shall follow the notice of violation and 2814 corrective measures procedures as detailed in Sections 9.16.050 and 9.16.060. 2815 2816 18.48.255: VIOLATIONS: 2817 A. It is unlawful for the building owner to fail to maintain the boarded building or 2818 ensure the building remains vacated after the property has been abated by either the city or the 2819 building owner. Each day a violation occurs shall be a separate offense. 2820 B. Violations of the provisions of this chapter are punishable in accordance with 2821 Chapter 18.24by imposing a civil penalty as provided in Section 21A.20.010 et seq., of this code. 2822 2823 18.48.260: BUILDING INSPECTIONS REQUIRED: 2824 Whenever a property owner, manager, or tenant intends to clean, repair, renovate, reopen or 2825 reoccupy a building that has been boarded, the building is to be inspected by the building official 2826 or designee and a permit must be issued by building services or its successor prior to the building 2827 owner, manager, or tenant initiating any of the above actions. Any person conducting any work 2828 on a building that has been boarded or closed to occupancy must have a valid building permit at 2829 all times. 2830 2831 SECTION 11. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.50. That Chapter 2832 18.50 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Existing Residential 2833 Housing) is hereby amended as follows: 78 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2834 2835 CHAPTER 18.50 2836 EXISTING RESIDENTIAL HOUSING 2837 2838 18.50.010: TITLE: 2839 This chapter shall be known as the SALT LAKE CITY EXISTING RESIDENTIAL HOUSING 2840 ORDINANCE and is referred to herein as "this chapter". 2841 2842 18.50.020: PURPOSE AND SCOPE: 2843 A. Purpose: The purpose of this chapter is to provide for the health, safety, comfort, 2844 convenience and aesthetics of Salt Lake City and its present and future inhabitants and 2845 businesses, to protect the tax base, and to protect property values within the city, as provided by 2846 sSection 10-9a-102, of the Utah Code Annotated, or its successor section, and other applicable 2847 state statutes. This purpose shall be accomplished by regulating the maintenance, repair and 2848 remodeling of residential buildings specified in this chapter existing as of the date of enactment 2849 hereof by: 2850 1. Establishing minimum housing standards for all buildings or portions 2851 thereof used, or designed or intended to be used, for human habitation; 2852 2. Establishing minimum standards for safety from fire and other hazards; 2853 3. Promoting maintenance and improvement of structures by applying 2854 standards of this chapter to renovations. This chapter allows distinctions in the 2855 application of standards based on the year a structure was built, as long as a reasonable 2856 level of safety is achieved; 2857 4. Avoiding the closure or abandonment of housing and the displacement of 2858 occupants where such can be done without sacrificing the public health, safety and 2859 welfare; 2860 5. Providing for the administration, enforcement and penalties for this 2861 chapter. 2862 B. Scope: 2863 1. Application Tto Existing Buildings: This chapter encompasses fire safety 2864 and structural integrity of existing residential buildings. Within the structures, the scope 2865 includes equipment and facilities for light, ventilation, heating, sanitation, protection 2866 from the elements, space requirements, and for safe and sanitary maintenance. 2867 2. Owner Occupied Versus Rental Properties: Except as specified in 2868 subsection B3 of this section, the standards of this chapter apply to the interior and 2869 exterior of all buildings, dwelling units and premises which are occupied on a rental 2870 basis. For buildings or dwelling units which are occupied solely by the owner and the 79 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2871 owner's family, all the requirements defined as imminent danger or hazardous condition 2872 situations, and those affecting the exterior of the building and premises shall apply. Other 2873 interior standards do not apply to owner occupied dwelling units. 2874 3. Condominiums: Repealed. 2875 2.4. Application Tto Remodeling Oof Existing Residential Buildings: This 2876 chapter shall apply to remodeling or renovation of all residential buildings existing as of 2877 the date of enactment hereof as follows: 2878 a. This chapter applies regardless of tenancy, regardless of the 2879 valuation of the renovations, and regardless of the date of such remodeling or 2880 renovation, unless otherwise noted in this chapter. 2881 b. Those buildings or portions thereof which conform with all 2882 applicable laws in effect at the time of their construction or whose fire resistive 2883 integrity and fire extinguishing systems have been adequately maintained and 2884 improved to accommodate any increase in occupant load, alteration or addition, or 2885 any change in occupancy may continue in accordance with the standards in effect 2886 at that time. This chapter shall not lessen such requirements for residential 2887 buildings which were constructed in compliance with the code in effect at the 2888 time of construction. 2889 bc. The requirements of this chapter are minimums. During a 2890 renovation or remodeling project, whenever conditions exist which allow such 2891 work to comply with the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, such codesstandard 2892 of the UBC, UPC or UMC these codes shall apply. 2893 cd. When a construction standard is omitted from this chapter, the 2894 applicable standard shall be the state construction codes adopted andUBC, UMC 2895 or UPC in effect at the time the building was constructed or at the time the 2896 relevant electrical, mechanical, or plumbing element was installed, whichever is 2897 later. 2898 de. When the purpose of the renovation is to create new dwelling 2899 units, the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040UBC rather than this chapter shall 2900 apply. 2901 3.5. Application Tto New Construction: From the date of adoption hereof, 2902 newly constructed buildings must comply with the codes adopted pursuant to Section 2903 18.04.040currently adopted UBC. All additions to an existing building envelope shall 2904 comply with the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040most recently adopted 2905 edition of the UBC. 2906 6. Dangerous Buildings: Residential buildings subject to section 302 of the 2907 UCADB shall be governed by the UCADB and not by this chapter. If any conflict exists 2908 between this chapter and the UCADB, the UCADB shall control. 80 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2909 4.7. Change Oof Use: Any building undergoing a change which intensifies the 2910 use, as defined in the UBC and the uniform code for building conservation, shall comply 2911 with the provisions of the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040UBC. 2912 5.8. Permits Required: Except as provided in this subsection, no building or 2913 structure regulated by this chapter shall be erected, constructed, enlarged, altered, moved, 2914 removed, converted, or demolished unless a separate permit for each building or structure 2915 has first been obtained from the building official. Except where required by state law, 2916 permits are not required for those items identified in Section 105.2 of the International 2917 Building Code and International Residential Code, or as otherwise directed by the 2918 building official.the following: 2919 a. Floor covering installation; 2920 b. Interior and exterior painting; 2921 c. Attaching interior finish wall coverings and similar interior finish work; 2922 d. Replacement of glazing except where safety glazing is required by the 2923 UBC; 2924 e. Patching wall surfaces; 2925 f. Installation of countertops and cabinets; 2926 g. Replacement of interior and exterior light fixtures; 2927 h. Replacement of electrical wall outlets and switches; 2928 i. Replacement of kitchen or bathroom sinks, toilets or bidets where the trap 2929 and trap arm are not replaced or extended; 2930 j. Replacement of faucets, washers and traps (when the trap is replaced with 2931 like installation and the trap arm and the existing vents and drain lines are not disturbed); 2932 k. Repair of irrigation pipelines where the backflow preventers exist or are 2933 not being replaced; 2934 l. Replacement of filters, belts and motors in mechanical systems; 2935 m. Installation of battery operated smoke detectors or one 120-volt smoke 2936 detector; 2937 n. Replacement of sidewalks on private property; 2938 o. Replacement of ventilation fans; 2939 p. Seasonal weatherization, as long as it does not prevent emergency egress. 2940 C. Violations: It is unlawful for any person to: 81 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2941 1. Erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, improve, remove, convert, or 2942 demolish, equip, use, occupy or maintain any building or structure or cause or permit the 2943 same to be done in violation of this chapter; 2944 2. Fail to obey a notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter; 2945 3. Occupy, or rent for occupancy, a building that has been closed to 2946 occupancy; or 2947 4. Fail to obey an interpretation, decision or requirement of the board of 2948 appeals and examinershousing advisory and appeals board within thirty (30) days, unless 2949 otherwise noted. 2950 2951 18.50.030: DEFINITIONS: 2952 A. Construction Oof Terms: For the purpose of this chapter, certain terms, phrases, 2953 words, and their derivations shall be construed as specified in this section. Words used in the 2954 singular include the plural, and words used in the plural include the singular. 2955 B. Whole Includes Part: Whenever the words "apartment house", "building", 2956 "dormitory", "dwelling unit", "habitable room", "hotel", "housing unit" or "structure" are used in 2957 this chapter such words shall be construed as if followed by the words "or any portion thereof", 2958 except for owner occupied areas as specified in subsection 18.50.020B2 of this chapter. 2959 C. Referenced Documents: References to codes, ordinances, chapters, sections, or 2960 subsections shall include any successor to such code, ordinance, chapter, section, or subsection 2961 that has been adopted by the city. 2962 D. Defined Terms: 2963 ADDITION: An increase in floor area or height of a building or structure outside of the existing 2964 building envelope. 2965 ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING OFFICER: A member of the building services and licensing 2966 staff who has been authorized by HAAB to conduct administrative hearings to establish a repair 2967 agreement between the property owner and the building official to resolve the property's 2968 deficiencies as defined by this code. 2969 AGENT: Any person, firm, partnership, association, joint venture, corporation, or other entity 2970 who acts for or on behalf of others. 2971 APARTMENT HOUSE: Any building which contains three (3) or more dwelling units otherwise 2972 subject to this code. 2973 APPROVED: As to a given material, mode of construction or repair, piece of equipment or 2974 device means approved by the building official as the result of investigation and/or tests 2975 conducted by the building official, or by reason of accepted principles or tests by recognized 2976 authorities or technical or scientific organizations. 82 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 2977 ATTIC: That portion of a building included between the upper surface of the topmost floor and 2978 the ceiling or roof above. 2979 BASEMENT: A floor level, any part of which is more than four4 feet (4') below grade for more 2980 than fifty percent (50%) of the total perimeter or more than eight8 feet (8') below grade at any 2981 point as floor and grade are defined in the UBC. 2982 BATHROOM: A room containing at least one of each of the following fixtures: sink, toilet, and 2983 tub or shower. It may also include a bidet. 2984 BEDROOM: Any space designed or used for sleeping. 2985 BOARDING HOUSE (or ROOMING HOUSE): A building other than a hotel or motel, with 2986 three (3) or more bedrooms where direct or indirect compensation for lodging and/or kitchen 2987 facilities, not located in guestrooms, or meals are provided for boarders and/or roomers not 2988 related to the head of the household by marriage, adoption or blood. Rentals must be on at least a 2989 monthly basis.The same as defined in Title 21A. 2990 BUILDING: Any structure which is used, designed or intended to be used for human habitation. 2991 BUILDING CLOSURE, CLOSED TO ENTRY, OR CLOSED TO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY: 2992 A building which has been closed to occupancy. 2993 BUILDING ENVELOPE: The space defined by existing floors, exterior walls, roof, basement 2994 and attic, but not including attached garages. 2995 BUILDING INSPECTOR: A person designated by the building official to make inspections of 2996 buildings and properties covered by this chapter. 2997 BUILDING OFFICIAL: The officer or other designated authority charged with the 2998 administration and enforcement of this chapter, or the officer's designee. 2999 BUILDING SERVICES AND LICENSING: The office of the city charged with the 3000 administration of the city's building and housing ordinances. 3001 CEILING HEIGHT: The vertical distance from the finished floor to finished ceiling or to the 3002 lowest point of the ceiling framing members. Where projectionsobstructions other than lighting 3003 fixtures exist below the ceiling, the height shall be measured from the projectionobstruction to 3004 the finished floor. 3005 CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: A certificate issued by the building official authorizing 3006 occupancy of a building. 3007 CITATION DEADLINE: The date identified in the second notice of violation, including any 3008 authorized extension of time. 3009 COMMON ROOM: A room available in congregate housing for the shared use of occupants of 3010 two (2) or more housing units. This does not include common corridors and exit passages, but 3011 does include kitchens and game rooms. 3012 CONDOMINIUM: Property or portions thereof conforming to the definition set forth in section 3013 57-8-3, of the Utah Code Annotated, 1953, as amended, or its successor. 83 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3014 CONGREGATE HOUSING: Any building which contains facilities for living, sleeping and 3015 sanitation, as required by this chapter, and may include facilities for eating and cooking, for 3016 occupancy by other than a family. Congregate housing includes SROs, convents, monasteries, 3017 dormitories, boarding and rooming houses, hostels, fraternity and sorority houses, but does not 3018 include shelters, jails, hospitals, nursing homes, hotels or lodging houses. 3019 COOKING FACILITY: At a minimum, a range with stove top and oven, or alternatively, a 3020 nonportable cooktop and oven, and a sink. 3021 CORRIDOR: A hallway that serves more than one dwelling unit. 3022 COURT: A space, open and unobstructed to the sky, located at or above grade level and bounded 3023 on three (3) or more sides by walls of a building. 3024 CROSS CONNECTION: Any connection or arrangement, physical or otherwise, between a 3025 potable water supply system and any plumbing fixture or any tank, receptacle, equipment or 3026 device, through which unclean or polluted water or other substances may contaminate such 3027 potable water supply system. 3028 DWELLING UNIT: Any building or a portion thereof which contains living facilities, including 3029 provisions for sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation, as required by this chapter. 3030 EFFICIENCY DWELLING UNIT: A dwelling unit containing only one habitable room with a 3031 bath and/or kitchen in the unit. 3032 EXISTING: In existence prior to adoption hereof. 3033 EXITWAY: A continuous and unobstructed means of egress to a public way and includes any 3034 intervening aisles, doorways, gates, corridors, exterior exit balconies, ramps, stairways, 3035 smokeproof enclosures, horizontal exits, exit passageways, and exit access rampscourts and 3036 yards as these terms are defined in the International Building CodeUBC. 3037 FAMILY: The same as defined in tTitle 21A of this code. 3038 FIRE RESISTANCE OR FIRE RESISTIVE CONSTRUCTION: Construction that resists the 3039 spread of fire, as specified in the UBC. 3040 FIRST NOTICE: The initial notice informing the person cited that a housing violation exists. 3041 FLOOR AREA COMPUTATION: The floor area of a habitable room excluding closets, 3042 cabinets, bathrooms, and kitchens when such kitchens are separated from the habitable room by 3043 walls or other partitions. 3044 GARAGE: A building or portion thereof designed, used, or intended to be used for parking or 3045 storage of a motor vehicle containing flammable or combustible liquids or gas in its tank. 3046 GLAZING: Light transmitting glass or plastic installed in windows, doors and skylights, 3047 including safety glass, but not including glass block. 3048 HAAB: The city's housing advisory and appeals board created pursuant to title 2, chapter 2.21 of 3049 this code. 84 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3050 HABITABLE ROOM: A room in a building for living, sleeping, eating or cooking. Bathrooms, 3051 toilet rooms, closets, halls, storage or utility space, and similar areas are not habitable rooms. 3052 HALL: A space used for circulating between the rooms of a building within an individual 3053 dwelling unit. 3054 HAZARDOUS CONDITION: A condition in a residential building or dwelling unit where 3055 failure of a structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing component system or systems is likely 3056 to occur reasonably soonwithin the next ninety six (96) hours but which has not yet occurred or 3057 which is not serious enough to be considered an "imminent danger". "Hazardous conditions" 3058 consist of any of the following: 3059 1. All of the conditions listed under the definition of "imminent danger" if 3060 those conditions can be repaired with safelyty while all or the affected part of the 3061 building or unit remains occupied; or 3062 2. "Imminent danger" conditions which have been partially secured pursuant 3063 to Section 18.24.030.Esubsection 18.50.060B2b of this chapter; 3064 3. Improper, missing, misused or malfunctioning electrical service or 3065 disconnect devices; 3066 4. Cracked, displaced or missing foundations resulting in settlement and 3067 structural damage; 3068 5. Defective or deteriorated flooring or floor supports; 3069 6. Flooring or floor supports of insufficient size to carry imposed loads with 3070 safety; 3071 7. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that crack, split, 3072 lean, list or buckle due to defective material or deterioration where failure is likely to 3073 occur reasonably soonwithin the next ninety six (96) hours but is not likely to occur 3074 immediately; 3075 8. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that are of 3076 insufficient size to carry imposed loads with safety; 3077 9. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other horizontal 3078 or vertical members which sag, split or buckle due to defective material or deterioration; 3079 10. Inoperable toilet, bathroom sink, or bathtub or shower in a dwelling unit or 3080 congregate housing unit; 3081 11. Lack of or inoperable kitchen sink in a dwelling unit or congregate 3082 housing unit; 3083 12. Fireplaces or chimneys which are of insufficient size or strength to carry 3084 imposed loads with safety such that failure is likely to occur reasonably soonwithin the 3085 next ninety six (96) hours but is not likely to occur immediately; 85 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3086 13. Except as defined under "imminent danger" below, conditions that reduce 3087 the width, height or area of a required emergency exitway or required escape window; 3088 14. All buildings or portions thereof which are not provided with the operable 3089 fire extinguishing systems or equipment required by city codes; 3090 15. Buildings or portions thereof occupied for living, sleeping, cooking or 3091 dining purposes which were not designed or intended to be used for such occupancies; 3092 16. Lack of a kitchen area equipped with a working stove, oven, sink and 3093 refrigerator unless specified otherwise by this code. 3094 HISTORIC BUILDING: Any building or structure which has been designated for preservation 3095 by Salt Lake City pursuant to tTitle 21A of this code or its successor, or has been listed on the 3096 National Register of Historic Places or on the Utah State Register of Historic Places, or is a 3097 contributory structure located in an historic district designated pursuant to tTitle 21A of this 3098 code. 3099 HOTEL: Any building containing guestrooms intended or designed to be used, rented, or hired 3100 out to be occupied, or which are occupied for sleeping purposes by guests on a daily basis. 3101 HOTEL/MOTEL ROOM: A room or combination of rooms (suite) offered as a single unit for 3102 lodging on a daily or weekly basis. 3103 IMMINENT DANGER: A condition in a building or dwelling unit subject to this chapter where 3104 structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing systems have failed so that they may cause 3105 immediate death or serious injury to the building's occupants or the public. Conditions of 3106 "imminent danger" are those that are so severe and dangerous that either repairs cannot be 3107 completed immediately or it is appropriate to have the residents or other occupants leave the 3108 building or unit before the repairs have begun. "Imminent danger" consists of any of the 3109 following and other similarly serious conditions: 3110 1. Failed or missing foundations, beams, columns, floor systems; 3111 2. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other horizontal 3112 members which sag, split or buckle and failure is likely to occur at any moment; 3113 3. Broken water lines causing flooding which is undermining structural 3114 supports or otherwise endangering the building's integrity; 3115 4. Leaking gas; 3116 5. Missing flues or vent connectors resulting in exhaust gases entering the 3117 building; 3118 6. Lack of adequate heating facilities during the months of October through 3119 April; 3120 7. Overload of main and branch electrical distribution systems; 3121 8. Exposed electrical wires, fuses and electrical current breakers capable of 3122 producing electrical shock or fire and readily accessible to the occupants or the public; 86 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3123 9. Stairs and stair components that cannot carry the loads intended and which 3124 may collapse if so loaded; 3125 10. Contaminated water systems; 3126 11. A complete absence of toilet facilities; 3127 12. A complete lack of water supply or sewage disposal facilities, as a result 3128 of a failure of a building's or dwelling unit's system and not a city system failure; 3129 13. Blocked emergency egress halls, corridors and/or doors, including 3130 accumulation or storage of materials in stairways, corridors, doors or windows, or other 3131 condition which blocks the means of egress. 3132 INFESTATION: The presence of insects, rodents or other pests in or around a building in 3133 numbers that are or may be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of the occupants. 3134 KITCHEN: A space or room used, designed or intended to be used for the preparation of food, 3135 which includes permanently installed cooking facilities. 3136 LISTED AND LISTING: Terms referring to equipment and materials which are shown in a list 3137 published by an approved testing agency qualified and equipped for experimental testing and 3138 maintaining an adequate periodic inspection of current productions. The listing states that the 3139 material or equipment complies with accepted national standards which are approved, or 3140 standards which have been evaluated for conformity with approved standards. 3141 MAINTENANCE: The repair, replacement and refinishing of any component of an existing 3142 structure, but does not include alteration or modification to the existing weight bearing structural 3143 components. 3144 MINOR DEFICIENCIES: A structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing code violation that is 3145 minor in nature and is less severe or dangerous than a "substandard condition". "Minor 3146 deficiencies" include the following, and other similarly minor conditions: 3147 1. Interior finish wall coverings missing or in disrepair; 3148 2. Lack of paint; 3149 3. Dripping or leaking kitchen or bathroom faucets; 3150 4. Soffit and fascia trim of which no more than twenty percent (20%) is 3151 weathered, missing, or loose. 3152 MONUMENTAL STAIRS: A stairway, exceeding four4 feet (4') in width, at the main entrance 3153 on the exterior of a building. 3154 MULTIPLE-FAMILY STRUCTURE: A residential building containing three (3) or more 3155 dwelling units. 3156 NEC: The edition of the national electrical code currently adopted by the city. 3157 NOTICE AND ORDER: A document which: 87 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3158 1. Provides notice of the existence of a condition covered by this chapter; 3159 2. Orders certain actions by the owner or owner's designee; and 3160 3. Specifies subsequent processes. 3161 NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE: A written notice informing the person cited that the violation has 3162 been cured. 3163 NOTIFIED PARTY: The person or persons to whom a notice and order is issued. 3164 OCCUPANT: A person occupying or having possession of a dwelling unit. 3165 OPENING: An exterior glazed opening capable of being closed to the weather, consisting of a 3166 window, a glazed door, or an openable glazed skylight, which opens upon a roof, yard, court, 3167 street, alley or recess from a court. 3168 OWNER: Any person, individual, firm, corporation, associate, joint venture or partnership and 3169 its agents or assigns who has title or interest in any building, with or without accompanying 3170 actual possession, and including any person who as agent or executor, administrator, trustee or 3171 guardian of an estate has charge, care or control of any building. 3172 PATTERN OF CIRCULATION: Any area in a room or group of rooms where the occupant is 3173 likely to walk because of the location of doors, fixtures or furniture placement when size of room 3174 restricts furniture placement. Fixtures, pipes and ducts projecting from the ceiling which are 3175 located near the middle of the room are within the pattern of circulation. 3176 PERSON: Any individual, firm, corporation, association, joint venture or partnership and its 3177 agents or assigns. 3178 PERSON CITED: The owner, owner's agent, tenant or occupant of any building or land or part 3179 thereof and any architect, builder, contractor, agent or other person who participates in, assists, 3180 directs or creates any situation that is contrary to the requirements of this chapter, and who 3181 received the notice of violation and is being held responsible for the violation. 3182 PLUMBING SYSTEM: Any potable water distribution piping, and any drainage piping within 3183 or below any building, including all plumbing fixtures, traps, vents and devices appurtenant to 3184 such water distribution or drainage piping and including potable water treating or using 3185 equipment, and any lawn sprinkling system. 3186 PREMISES: A lot, plot or parcel of land including the buildings or structures thereon. 3187 PUBLIC WAY: Any street, alley or similar parcel of land essentially unobstructed from the 3188 ground to the sky which is deeded, dedicated, or otherwise permanently appropriated to the 3189 public for public use and which has a clear width of not less than ten feet (10'). 3190 RESIDENTIAL BUILDING: The portions of a building that contain dwelling units. 3191 RISE: The vertical portion of a stair step. 3192 ROOMING HOUSE: A building or group of attached or detached buildings containing in 3193 combination at least three (3) lodging units for occupancy on at least a monthly basis, with or 88 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3194 without board, as distinguished from hotels and motels in which rentals are generally for a daily 3195 or weekly period and occupancy is by transients. 3196 RUN: The horizontal portion of a stair step, measured from the leading edge of the stair tread to 3197 a point directly beneath the leading edge of the step directly above. 3198 SRO (SINGLE ROOM OCCUPANCY): A congregate housing where the dwelling units have 3199 one combined sleeping and living room and may include a kitchen and/or a separate private 3200 bathroom. 3201 SAFETY: The condition of being safe from causing harm, injury or loss. 3202 SECOND NOTICE: The notice informing the person cited of the date that civil fines will begin 3203 to accrue if the housing violation is not corrected. 3204 SECURED BUILDING: A building where all windows and doors are intact and lockable against 3205 unauthorized entry. 3206 SLOPING CEILING: Any ceiling with a slope greater than one- half1/2 inch (1/2") per foot. 3207 SMOKE DETECTOR: An approved device which senses visible or invisible particles of 3208 combustion. 3209 SPACE, COMMON: "Common space" means shared areas available for use by the occupants of 3210 the building. 3211 SPACE, PRIVATE: "Private space" means the portion of a dwelling unit which is for the 3212 exclusive use of the occupants of the unit. 3213 STORY: That portion of a building included between the upper surface of any floor and the 3214 upper surface of the floor next above or the bottom surface of the roof structure. 3215 STRUCTURE: Anything that is built or constructed for residential occupancy, or attached to a 3216 building for residential occupancy. 3217 SUBSTANDARD CONDITION: A structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing system 3218 condition in a residential building or dwelling unit which violates applicable codes but with 3219 maintenance or repair can be made fully safe and which does not amount to an "imminent 3220 danger" or a "hazardous condition". "Substandard conditions" include the following as well as 3221 any violations of the standards in this chapter which have not been included in the categories of 3222 "imminent danger", "hazardous condition" or "minor deficiency": 3223 1. Deteriorated or inadequate foundations with cracking and evidence of 3224 settlement; 3225 2. Defective or deteriorated flooring or floor supports; 3226 3. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that split, lean, list 3227 or buckle due to defective material or deterioration; 3228 4. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other members 3229 that are of insufficient size to carry live and dead loads with safety; 89 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3230 5. Soffit and fascia trim more than twenty percent (20%) of which is 3231 weathered, missing or loose; 3232 6. Missing, decayed, buckling or worn out roof covering; 3233 7. Roof having more than two (2) layers of shingle type roof covering; 3234 8. Fireplaces or chimneys which list, bulge or settle, due to defective 3235 material or deterioration; 3236 9. Parapet wall or parapet cap bricks that are loose or missing; 3237 10. Stair risers, treads, jacks, stringers or supports that are cracked or 3238 otherwise deteriorated or missing; 3239 11. Plumbing which was not installed in accordance with the adopted 3240 plumbing code in effect at the time of installation or with generally accepted construction 3241 practices, has not been maintained in good condition, or is not free of cross connections 3242 or siphonage; 3243 12. Continuous running water in a toilet, bathroom sink or kitchen sink; 3244 13. Lack of hot or cold running water to plumbing fixtures in a dwelling unit 3245 or congregate housing structure; 3246 14. Mechanical equipment which was not installed in accordance with codes 3247 in effect at the time of installation, or with generally accepted construction practices, or 3248 which has not been maintained in good and safe condition; 3249 15. Inoperable heating systems during the months of May through September; 3250 16. Inoperable air conditioning systems, when the building is supplied with 3251 such a system and lacks other adequate forms of ventilation and the air conditioning 3252 system fails to keep the air temperature below eighty five degrees Fahrenheit (85°F); 3253 17. Damaged or missing heat ducts or missing heat duct registers; 3254 18. Electrical wiring which was not installed in accordance with codes in 3255 effect at the time of installation or with generally accepted construction practices, has not 3256 been maintained in good condition, or is not being used in a safe manner; 3257 19. Missing light fixtures, switches and outlet and switch cover plates; 3258 20. Overcurrent situations such as those caused by the use of electrical 3259 extension cords and multiple light fixtures; 3260 21. Lack of the minimum natural light and ventilation required by this 3261 chapter; 3262 22. Room and space dimensions less than that required by this chapter; 3263 23. Dampness of habitable rooms as evidenced by water damage or excess 3264 moisturecondensation or mold on ceilings, walls or floors; 90 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3265 24. Deteriorated, crumbling or loose plaster or stucco; 3266 25. Deteriorated or ineffective waterproofing of exterior walls, roof, 3267 foundation or floors, including broken windows or doors; 3268 26. Deteriorated or lack of weather protection for exterior wall coverings; 3269 27. Broken, rotted, split or buckled exterior wall coverings or roof coverings; 3270 28. Wood has been installed within six6 inches (6") of earth which is not 3271 naturally decay resistant, treated wood or wood protected by an approved barrier; 3272 29. Infestation of insects, vermin or rodents as determined by the Salt Lake 3273 CountyValley health department, or its succcessor; 3274 30. Lack of garbage and rubbish storage and removal facilities as determined 3275 by the Salt Lake ValleyCounty health department regulations; 3276 31. Those premises on which an accumulation of weeds, vegetation, junk, 3277 dead organic matter, debris, garbage, offal, rat harborages, stagnant water, and similar 3278 materials or conditions constitute a violation of the Salt Lake CountyValley health 3279 department regulations; 3280 32. Any building, device, apparatus, equipment, combustible materials or 3281 vegetation which, in the opinion of the chief of fire department or building official, is in 3282 such a condition as to cause a fire or explosion or provide a ready fuel to augment the 3283 spread and intensity of fire or explosion arising from any cause; 3284 33. Any fire resistive requirement of this chapter which is not met; 3285 34. Drainage of water from roofs or yards in a manner that creates flooding or 3286 damage to a structure; 3287 35. Any equipment or apparatus that causes excessive noise, pollution, odor or 3288 light as defined by the Salt Lake City code or Salt Lake ValleyCounty health regulations; 3289 36. Guardrails or handrails in common areas that are missing or cannot 3290 support required loads. 3291 TOILET ROOM: A room which contains a toilet. It may also contain a sink, but does not contain 3292 a tub or shower. 3293 UBC: The edition of the uniform building code currently adopted by the city. 3294 UCADB: The edition of the uniform code for the abatement of dangerous buildings currently 3295 adopted by the city. 3296 UFC: The edition of the uniform fire code currently adopted by the city. 3297 UMC: The edition of the uniform mechanical code currently adopted by the city. 3298 UPC: The edition of the uniform plumbing code currently adopted by the city. 91 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3299 UNFIT FOR HUMAN OCCUPANCY: A condition of premises which has been found by the 3300 building official to be an "imminent danger" or "hazardous condition" situation as defined by this 3301 chapter, or which fails to meet the sanitation requirements of the Salt Lake ValleyCounty health 3302 department. 3303 VENTILATION, NATURAL: "Natural ventilation" means any openable exterior door, window 3304 or skylight which opens upon a roof, yard, court, street or alley. 3305 YARD: As defined in Title 21AAn open space, other than a court, unoccupied by any structure 3306 on the lot on which a building is situated, unobstructed from the ground to the sky. 3307 3308 18.50.040: AUTHORITY: 3309 A. Enforcement: The building official is authorized to enforce all the provisions of 3310 this chapter. The building official may issue and deliver enforcement orderscitations under 3311 authority provided by state law. 3312 B. Interpretation: The building official may render interpretations of this chapter and 3313 adopt and enforce rules and supplemental regulations pursuant to adopted state construction 3314 codes to clarify the application of its provisions. Such interpretations, rules and regulations shall 3315 conform to the intent and purpose of this chapter, and shall be made available in writing for 3316 public inspection upon request. 3317 C. Alternate Materials Aand Methods Oof Construction: This chapter is not intended 3318 to exclude any method of structural design or repair not specifically provided for in this chapter 3319 or applicable adopted state construction codesthe UBC. The building official may approve any 3320 alternate material or method of construction conforming to the applicable adopted state 3321 construction codesalternate design and methods of construction section of the UBC. 3322 3323 18.50.050: RIGHT OF ENTRY: 3324 A. Inspection: Whenever it is necessary to make an inspection to enforce any 3325 provisions of this chapter, or whenever the building official has reasonable cause to believe a 3326 code violation exists in any building or upon any premises which makes such building or 3327 premises unsafe, dangerous or hazardous, the building official may, upon obtaining permission 3328 of the owner or other person having charge or control of the premises or dwelling unit, or upon 3329 obtaining a warrant, enter a residential property or premises to inspect it or to perform the duties 3330 imposed by this chapter. If such building or premises is occupied, the building official shall first 3331 present proper credentials and request entry. If such building or premises is unoccupied, the 3332 building official shall first make a reasonable effort to locate the owner or other persons having 3333 charge or control of the building or premises and request entry. If such entry is refused, the 3334 building official shall have recourse to every remedy provided by law to secure entry. The 3335 building official shall establish written policies which outline owner notification procedures for 3336 regular inspections and establish handling of owner notification for tenant reports of unsafe, 3337 dangerous and hazardous conditions. 92 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3338 B. Unoccupied Dwelling Unit: If an unoccupied dwelling unit is open and 3339 unattended and the owner or other person having charge or control of the building or premises 3340 cannot be located after reasonable effort, the building official or building official's designee may 3341 enter the building. The building official shall issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 3342 18.24.040 that the dwelling unit be immediately secured or boarded against the entry of 3343 unauthorized persons. 3344 C. Inspection Notification: In imminent danger or hazardous condition situations, or 3345 when authorization to enter has not previously been granted by a tenant, the owner shall give the 3346 tenant a minimum of twenty four (24) hours' notification of an inspection of the tenant's premises 3347 by the building official. 3348 D. Violations: Whenever the building official has inspected a building and found 3349 violations of this chapter, the building official has the authority to commence action to cause the 3350 repair, rehabilitation or vacation of the building. The building official shall issue a notice and 3351 order to the owner(s) of the building, which shall list all violations, giving the section number 3352 and a detailed description of each, and classified by severity according to the following 3353 categories: imminent danger, hazardous condition, substandard condition, and minor deficiency 3354 situations. For each violation, or category of violation, the notice and order shall state the 3355 following, described in sections 18.50.060 through 18.50.090 of this chapter: 3356 1. The corrective action necessary for the violation(s); 3357 2. A time frame for compliance; 3358 3. The appeals and administrative hearing officer process; and 3359 4. Specific remedies the city may reasonably expect to take if the violations 3360 are not corrected. 3361 3362 18.50.060: RESERVEDIMMINENT DANGER SITUATIONS: 3363 A. Determination: If the building official determines that an imminent danger exists, 3364 the building official shall take the actions specified in this section. 3365 B. Notice And Order: The building official shall issue a notice and order containing 3366 the following: 3367 1. A notice listing the building's or unit's violations and the reason(s) that the 3368 building official determines that such conditions constitute an imminent danger; 3369 2. An order requiring: 3370 a. Immediate vacation of the building or dwelling unit, or 3371 b. The closure of that portion or system if the building official 3372 determines that a portion or system of the building or unit can be closed or 3373 otherwise secured so that the rest of the building or unit remains occupiable; and 93 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3374 3. An explanation of the appeal rights and processes specified in subsection 3375 E of this section. 3376 C. Delivery Of Notice And Order: Notices and orders issued pursuant to this section 3377 shall be posted on the building entrance doors and on the entrance doors of all dwelling units 3378 affected by the notice and order. The notice and order shall also be mailed to the owner or the 3379 owner's designated agent by both certified mail, return receipt requested, and ordinary first class 3380 mail, postage prepaid, or shall be delivered by hand. 3381 D. Notified Party Actions: Within twenty four (24) hours after the issuance of the 3382 notice and order, the notified party shall take out all required permits and cause the building or 3383 dwelling unit to be either repaired or, if repairs cannot be or are not completed within twenty 3384 four (24) hours, secured from entry as required by other portions of this code. 3385 E. Expedited Appeal: 3386 1. If the notified party disagrees with the notice and order and files an appeal 3387 in writing within seven (7) days of the issuance of the notice and order, the appeal shall 3388 be heard before an HAAB panel within two (2) days of receipt of the appeal. 3389 2. The HAAB panel shall issue a written decision within two (2) days of the 3390 hearing. 3391 3. If the notified party is dissatisfied with the HAAB panel decision, the 3392 notified party may appeal by filing a written notice with the mayor within seven (7) days 3393 of the HAAB decision. 3394 4. The mayor or the mayor's designee shall consider the appeal on the record 3395 made before HAAB and the written appeal. The mayor or the mayor's designee may 3396 accept additional evidence only if the evidence was improperly rejected by HAAB. The 3397 mayor or the mayor's designee may, at their discretion, consider the appeal based solely 3398 on the written materials or materials presented at a publicly conducted hearing. 3399 5. The appeal shall be considered, and the mayor or the mayor's designee 3400 shall issue a final decision within twelve (12) days of the receipt of the appeal. 3401 6. The filing of an appeal shall not stay the requirements of the notice and 3402 order. 3403 F. City Remedies: If the notified party fails to repair or secure the property, 3404 the city may take all appropriate remedies authorized by law including, the imposition of 3405 civil fines, obtaining any necessary authorization to enter the property to secure it from 3406 occupancy or, if the property conditions represent a threat to the public, abating the 3407 deficiency as a public nuisance or taking other appropriate actions. 3408 3409 18.50.070: RESERVEDHAZARDOUS CONDITION SITUATIONS: 3410 A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a hazardous condition 3411 exists, the building inspector shall take the actions specified in this section. 94 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3412 B. Notice And Order: The building inspector shall issue a notice and order 3413 containing the following: 3414 1. A notice listing the building's or unit's violations and the reason(s) that the 3415 building inspector determines that such conditions constitute a hazardous condition; 3416 2. An order requiring the notified party to: 3417 a. Take out all necessary permits and repair the hazardous condition 3418 within three (3) days, or 3419 b. Close the building or required portions thereof to occupancy within 3420 three (3) days; 3421 3. An explanation of the appeal rights and processes specified in subsection 3422 E of this section. 3423 C. Delivery Of Notice And Order: Notices and orders issued pursuant to this section 3424 shall be posted on the building entrance doors and on the entrance doors of all dwelling units 3425 affected by the notice and order. The notice and order shall also be mailed to the owner or the 3426 owner's designated agent by both certified mail, return receipt requested, and ordinary first class 3427 mail, postage prepaid, or shall be delivered by hand. 3428 D. Notified Party Actions: Within three (3) days after the issuance of the notice and 3429 order, the notified party shall take out all required permits and cause the building or dwelling 3430 unit to be either repaired or vacated and secured from entry as required by other portions of this 3431 code. The building official may extend the time for completing the required work to six (6) days 3432 from the date of issuance of the notice and order provided the required permits are taken out 3433 within three (3) days of the date of issuance of said notice and order. 3434 E. Appeal: 3435 1. If the notified party disagrees with the notice and order, the notified party 3436 may appeal in writing within fourteen (14) days of the issuance of the notice and order. 3437 The appeal shall be heard before an HAAB panel within thirty (30) days of receipt of the 3438 appeal. 3439 2. Appeals under this subsection shall stay the enforcement of those items 3440 appealed on the notice and order. 3441 3. The HAAB panel shall issue a written decision within seven (7) days of 3442 the hearing. 3443 4. If the notified party is dissatisfied with the HAAB panel decision, the 3444 notified party may appeal by filing a written notice with the mayor within seven (7) days 3445 of the HAAB decision. 3446 5. The mayor or the mayor's designee shall consider the appeal on the record 3447 made before HAAB and the written appeal. The mayor or the mayor's designee may 3448 accept additional evidence only if the evidence was improperly rejected by HAAB. The 95 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3449 mayor or the mayor's designee may, at their discretion, consider the appeal based solely 3450 on the written materials or materials presented at a publicly conducted hearing. 3451 6. The appeal shall be considered, and the mayor or the mayor's designee 3452 shall issue a final decision within twelve (12) days of the receipt of the appeal. 3453 F. City Remedies: If the notified party fails to repair or secure the property as 3454 required, the city may take all appropriate remedies authorized by law including, the imposition 3455 of civil fines, closing all or a portion of the building, obtaining any necessary authorization to 3456 enter the property to secure it from occupancy or, if the property conditions represent a threat to 3457 the public, abating the deficiency as a public nuisance or taking other appropriate actions. 3458 3459 18.50.080: RESERVEDSUBSTANDARD CONDITION SITUATIONS: 3460 A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a substandard condition 3461 exists, the building inspector may take the actions specified in this section. 3462 B. Notice And Order: The building inspector may issue a notice and order containing 3463 the following: 3464 1. A notice listing the building's or unit's violations and the reason(s) that the 3465 building inspector determines that such conditions constitute a substandard condition; 3466 2. An order requiring the notified party to: 3467 a. Take out all necessary permits and repair the substandard condition 3468 within the times specified, or 3469 b. Close the building or required portions thereof to occupancy within 3470 thirty (30) days; 3471 3. An explanation of the appeal rights and processes specified in subsection 3472 E of this section. 3473 C. Delivery Of Notice And Order: Notices and orders issued pursuant to this 3474 subsection shall be posted on the building entrance doors and in the common areas of the 3475 building. Notices and orders issued to vacate the premises shall be posted on all building 3476 entrance doors, common areas and on individual dwelling units. The notice and order shall also 3477 be mailed to the owner or the owner's designated agent by both certified mail, return receipt 3478 requested, and ordinary first class mail, postage prepaid, or may be delivered by hand. 3479 D. Notified Party Actions: The notified party shall take out all required permits and 3480 cause the building or dwelling unit to be either repaired or secured from entry as required by 3481 other portions of this code within the times specified in the notice and order. If the building 3482 official determines that work is progressing appropriately and an extension is necessary, the 3483 building official may extend the times for completion of any work. 3484 E. Appeal And Administrative Hearing: 96 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3485 1. If the notified party disagrees with the notice and order, the notified party 3486 may appeal in writing within thirty (30) days of the issuance of the notice and order. The 3487 appeal shall be heard before an HAAB panel within forty five (45) days of receipt of the 3488 appeal. 3489 2. Appeals of notice and order for substandard conditions shall be first 3490 considered by an administrative hearing officer pursuant to section 18.50.120 of this 3491 chapter. 3492 3. The HAAB panel shall issue a written decision within fourteen (14) days 3493 of the hearing. 3494 4. If the notified party is dissatisfied with the HAAB panel decision, the 3495 notified party may appeal by filing a written notice with the mayor within fourteen (14) 3496 days of the HAAB decision. 3497 5. The mayor or the mayor's designee shall consider the appeal on the record 3498 made before HAAB and the written appeal. The mayor or the mayor's designee may 3499 accept additional evidence only if the evidence was improperly rejected by HAAB. The 3500 mayor or the mayor's designee may, at their discretion, consider the appeal based solely 3501 on the written materials or materials presented at a publicly conducted hearing. 3502 6. The appeal shall be considered, and the mayor or the mayor's designee 3503 shall issue a final decision within thirty (30) days of the receipt of the appeal. 3504 7. Appeals under this subsection shall stay the enforcement of those items 3505 appealed on the notice and order. 3506 F. City Remedies: If the notified party fails to repair or secure the property as 3507 required, the city may take all appropriate remedies authorized by law including, the 3508 imposition of civil fines, closing all or a portion of the building or securing any necessary 3509 authorization to enter the property to make repairs. 3510 3511 18.50.090: MINOR DEFICIENCY NOTIFICATIONSITUATIONS: 3512 A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a minor deficiency exists, 3513 the building inspector may take the actions specified in this section. 3514 B. Citations: Citations may be issued for minor deficiencies. However, such citations 3515 shall be for the owner's information only and shall have no further legal force or effect. When a 3516 notice and order is issued pursuant to Section 18.50.100, minor deficiencies may be included 3517 under "for owner's information only". If a property inspection reveals only minor deficiencies, 3518 the building inspector may mail a letter to the owner informing the owner of such minor 3519 deficiencies. 3520 C. Delivery Of Notice And Order: The notice and order shall be mailed to the owner 3521 or the owner's designated agent by both certified mail, return receipt requested, and ordinary first 3522 class mail, postage prepaid, or shall be delivered by hand. If delivery of the notice and order by 97 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3523 mail or hand delivery is not made, the notice and order shall be posted on the building entrance 3524 doors and on the entrance doors of all dwelling units affected by the notice and order. 3525 D. Notified Party Actions: The notified party shall take out all required permits and 3526 cause the building or dwelling unit to be either repaired or secured from entry as required by 3527 other portions of this code within the times specified in the notice and order. If the building 3528 official determines that work is progressing appropriately and an extension is necessary, the 3529 building official may extend the times for completion of any work. 3530 E. Appeal And Administrative Consideration: The appeal and administrative hearing 3531 officer processes shall be as specified in subsections 18.50.080E and F of this chapter. 3532 F. City Remedies: If the notified party fails to make the repairs required, or fails to 3533 reach an agreement acceptable to the city for remediation, the city may record a notice of 3534 deficiency with the Salt Lake County recorder's office specifying the deficiencies. 3535 3536 18.50.100: ENFORCEMENT: 3537 A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a violation of this chapter 3538 exists, the building inspector may take the actions specified in this section.In addition to any 3539 other remedies authorized by law or in this chapter, if the notified party fails to repair or secure 3540 the property in question, the city may pursue any one or more of the following additional 3541 remedies: 3542 1. Notice Of Deficiency: The supervisor of housing enforcement may record 3543 with the Salt Lake County recorder's office a notice of any condition provided in sections 3544 18.50.060 through 18.50.090 of this chapter. The notice shall be mailed to all notified 3545 parties. 3546 2. Criminal Action: Violations of the provisions of sections 18.50.060 3547 through 18.50.080 of this chapter may be punishable as a class B misdemeanor upon 3548 conviction. 3549 3. Civil Action: Violations of sections 18.50.060 through 18.50.080 of this 3550 chapter may also be enforced by injunction, mandamus, abatement, civil fines or any 3551 other appropriate action in law or equity. 3552 B. Civil fines may be imposed according to the following procedures:Warning 3553 Notice 3554 1. Notice: 3555 a. If the housing building inspector finds that any provision of this chapter is being 3556 violated, the housing inspector shall provide a written notice to the responsible partyproperty 3557 owner and to any other person determined to be responsible for such violation. The written 3558 notice shall indicate the nature of the violation and order the action necessary to correct it. 3559 Additional written notices may be provided at the housing inspector's discretion. 98 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3560 b. The written notice shall state what action the housing inspector intends to take if 3561 the violation is not corrected. The written notice shall include information regarding the 3562 established warning period for the indicated violations and shall serve to start any warning 3563 periods provided in this chapterthe time period in which the violations must be corrected, which 3564 will be based on their severity. 3565 2. Delivery of Notice: 3566 c. Such written notice issued by the housing inspector shall be deemed sufficient and 3567 complete when served upon the responsible party as followsperson cited: 3568 a.(1) Personally by the inspector or his or her representative; or by 3569 mailing, postage prepaid, by certified mail, return receipt requested or any 3570 reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, addressed 3571 to the responsible partyperson cited at the last known address appearing on the 3572 records of the county recorder; and 3573 b.(2) By posting notice on the property where said violation(s) occurs. 3574 3.d. In cases when delay in enforcement would seriously threaten the effective 3575 enforcement of this chapter, or pose a danger to the public health, safety or welfare, the 3576 housing inspector need not issue a warning noticemay seek enforcement without prior 3577 written notice by invoking any of the fines or remedies authorized in this chapter. 3578 e. If the violation remains uncured within five (5) days after the 3579 expiration of the warning period, a second notice of violation shall be delivered 3580 by mail, postage prepaid, addressed to the person cited at the last known address 3581 appearing on the records of the county recorder. The second notice shall identify 3582 the date on which the civil fines shall begin to accrue. 3583 C. Notice and Order: If, after issuance of the warning notice (if required), the 3584 violations have not been corrected by the time period stated in the notice, the building inspector 3585 may issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 18.24.040. The notice and order need not 3586 provide any additional correction period and may impose fines beginning on the date it is issued. 3587 D.2. RemediesAmount Of Fine: Upon issuance of a notice and order, the building 3588 inspector may pursue any remedies allowed by Sections 18.24.030 and 18.24.050, except that 3589 cCivil fines shall accrue as set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule specific to 3590 the violations of this chapter.follows: 3591 a. Substandard condition violations: Twenty five dollars ($25.00) per 3592 day. If more than ten (10) substandard condition violations exist, the daily fines 3593 shall double. 3594 b. Hazardous condition violations: Fifty dollars ($50.00) each per 3595 day. 3596 c. Imminent danger violations: Seventy five dollars ($75.00) each per 3597 day. 99 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3598 d. Failure to obey an interpretation, decision or requirement of the 3599 housing advisory and appeals board: Twenty five dollars ($25.00) per day. 3600 E.3. Daily Violations: Each day a violation continues after the issuance of the notice 3601 and order (or cure deadline stated therein, if applicable)citation deadline shall give rise to a 3602 separate civil fine. 3603 F.4. Compliance: Accumulation of fines for violations, but not the obligation for 3604 payment of fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed 3605 through an inspection requested pursuant to Subsection 18.24.040.A.3. 3606 G.5. Recurring Violations: In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, 3607 reoccurs at the property within six (6) months of the initial correction and is due to the actions or 3608 inactions of the same responsible party as the prior violation, the city maywill begin enforcement 3609 of said recurring violation and impose fines will begin accruing after a ten (10) day warning 3610 period. 3611 6. Appearance Before A Hearing Officer: 3612 a. Right To Appear: Any person cited may appear before a hearing 3613 officer to appeal the amount of the fine imposed. However, no party may appear 3614 before a hearing officer until violations identified have been corrected and a 3615 notice of compliance has been issued. Appeals to the hearing officer contesting 3616 the amount of the fine imposed must be filed within thirty (30) days from the date 3617 of the notice of compliance. 3618 b. Defense: The burden to prove any defense shall be upon the person 3619 raising such defense. 3620 c. Responsibility: Commencement of any action to remove or reduce 3621 fines shall not relieve the responsibility of any person cited to cure the violation or 3622 to make payment of subsequently accrued civil fines nor shall it require the city to 3623 reissue any of the notices required by this chapter. 3624 7. Appeal Of Administrative Decision: The decision of the housing inspector 3625 regarding the existence of the housing violation shall be deemed an administrative 3626 decision which may be appealed to the housing advisory and appeals board within thirty 3627 (30) days of the date of the first notice. 3628 8. Hearing Officer Duties: 3629 a. The mayor, or his/her designee, shall appoint such hearing officer 3630 as the mayor, or his/her designee, deems appropriate to consider matters relating 3631 to the violation of this chapter. The hearing officer shall have the authority to hear 3632 evidence relating to mitigating circumstances and to make such equitable 3633 adjustments as he/she deems appropriate, as set forth below: 3634 (1) The hearing officer may adjust, reduce or eliminate fines or 3635 create payment plans relating to fines accrued by the person cited. In the 3636 administration of this duty, the hearing officer may reduce or eliminate 100 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3637 fines based upon any circumstance or other equitable consideration the 3638 hearing officer finds to be applicable. In cases where the administrative 3639 process has not been followed by the division, the hearing officer has the 3640 authority to reduce or eliminate fines. 3641 (2) Payment plans may be created by the hearing officer. 3642 Although the hearing officer has the ultimate authority in establishing the 3643 payment schedule, the minimum payment schedule provided by the 3644 department of community and neighborhoods should be followed. 3645 9. Dismissal Criteria: 3646 a. If the hearing officer finds that no violation occurred and/or a 3647 violation occurred but one or more of the defenses set forth in this section is 3648 applicable, the hearing officer may dismiss the notice of violation. Such defenses 3649 include: 3650 (1) At the time of the receipt of the notice of violation, 3651 compliance would have violated the criminal laws of the state of Utah; 3652 (2) Compliance with the subject ordinances would have 3653 presented an imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property. 3654 10. Acceptance Of Hearing Officer Decision: If the hearing officer finds that a 3655 violation of this chapter occurred and no applicable defense exists, the hearing officer 3656 may, in the interest of justice and on behalf of the city, enter into an agreement for the 3657 timely or periodic payment of the applicable fine. The person cited has fourteen (14) days 3658 in which to accept the decision of the hearing officer. If the person cited does not accept 3659 the decision of the hearing officer, an agreement to modify the fine, or set up a payment 3660 schedule, the decision of the hearing officer is void and the city will attempt to collect the 3661 original amount of the fine. 3662 11. Abatement For Correction And Payment: 3663 a. Civil fines may be partially abated after the violation is cured and 3664 at the discretion of the hearing officer if any of the following conditions exist: 3665 (1) Strict compliance with the notice and order would have 3666 caused an imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property. 3667 (2) The violation and inability to cure were both caused by a 3668 force majeure event such as war, act of nature, strike or civil disturbance. 3669 (3) A change in the actual ownership of the property was 3670 recorded with the Salt Lake County recorder's office after the first or 3671 second notice was issued and the new owner is not related by blood, 3672 marriage or common ownership to the prior owner. 3673 (4) Such other mitigating circumstances as may be approved 3674 by the city attorney or designee. 101 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3675 b. If the hearing officer finds that the noticed violation occurred and 3676 no applicable defense applies, the hearing officer may, in the interest of justice 3677 and on behalf of the city, enter into an agreement for the delayed or periodic 3678 payment of the applicable fine. 3679 c. Once a payment schedule has been developed by the hearing 3680 officer, and agreed to by the person cited, failure to submit any two (2) payments 3681 as scheduled will require payment of the entire amount of the original fine 3682 immediately. 3683 3684 18.50.110: APPEALSLATE PROCESS DETAILS: 3685 A. Filing Oof Appeals: Appeals of enforcement of this chapter shall be taken in 3686 accordance with Chapter 18.12.submitted on an appeal form provided by the building official. 3687 The appellant shall state the specific order or action protested and a statement of the relief 3688 sought, along with the reasons why the order or action should be reversed, modified or otherwise 3689 set aside. 3690 B. Failure To Appeal: Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the 3691 provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. 3692 B.C. Inspection Oof Tthe Premises: Before any hearing is held by the board of appeals 3693 and examiners the board maya HAAB panel, the panel shall inspect the building or premises 3694 involved. Prior notice of such inspection shall be given to the responsiblenotified party filing the 3695 appeal, who may be present at such inspection. Upon completion of the inspection, the 3696 chairperson of the panel shall state for the record the material facts observed at the inspection, 3697 which facts shall be read at the initiation of the hearing. Failure of the responsiblenotified party 3698 to provide access without good cause as determined by the building official shall not constitute a 3699 reason for the hearing to be postponed and the appeal denied. 3700 D. Written Notice: Written notice of the time and place of panel hearings shall be 3701 mailed to the appellant in accordance with procedures adopted by HAAB. 3702 E. Appeals Hearing: Any notified party may appear personally or authorize a 3703 designee to act in their behalf. The city and any notified party may call and examine witnesses on 3704 any relevant matter, introduce documentary and physical evidence, and cross examine opposing 3705 witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted. 3706 F. Record: A record of the entire proceeding of all appellate hearings under this 3707 section shall be made by tape recording, or by any other means of permanent recording 3708 determined to be appropriate by HAAB. The record shall be retained on file in accordance with 3709 the city's record retention schedule. 3710 3711 18.50.120: RESERVEDADMINISTRATIVE HEARING OFFICER PROCEDURES: 102 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3712 A. The administrative hearing officer shall hear cases deemed to be of substandard 3713 condition or minor deficiency situations. Review by the administrative hearing officer is not a 3714 provision of hazardous condition appeals, which go directly before a HAAB panel. 3715 B. Each appeal shall first be reviewed by the administrative hearing officer no later 3716 than thirty (30) days from the date of filing of a written appeal. 3717 C. The administrative hearing officer shall inspect the property and review the notice 3718 and order to determine if it is accurate and attempt to develop, in consultation with the appellant, 3719 possible methods of complying with the code consistent with the purposes of this chapter. The 3720 administrative hearing officer may prepare a stipulated agreement for signature by the appellant 3721 and the city. 3722 D. The administrative hearing officer shall maintain complete and permanent records 3723 of all inspections and decisions. Resolutions of disputed issues, agreeable to the administrative 3724 hearing officer and the property owner, shall be presented at the next meeting of HAAB for its 3725 consent or modification. 3726 3727 18.50.130: APPROVAL FOR OCCUPANCY: 3728 Following the correction of the deficiencies and prior to persons reoccupying any residential 3729 building or dwelling unit after it has been closed to occupancy, the building 3730 officialhousing/zoning officer shall issue an approval for occupancy. If a notice of deficiency has 3731 been filed with the Salt Lake County recorder's office pursuant to section 18.50.100 of this 3732 chapter, a release of the notice shall be recorded with that office. 3733 3734 18.50.140: EXTERIOR STANDARDS: 3735 A. Structural Repair: All roofs, floors, walls, chimneys, foundations, and other 3736 structural components shall be repaired when they no longer retain their structural integrity. 3737 Loose bricks in chimneys shall be repaired and missing chimney caps shall be replaced. 3738 B. Exterior Surfaces: Exposed materials that require weather protection and exterior 3739 surfaces that are deteriorating shall be repaired to the extent necessary to stop damage from cold, 3740 wind, water, or dampness. The roof covering and flashing shall form an impervious membrane. 3741 C. Drainage: All surface water shall drain away from the structure andunless any 3742 potential adverse effect of the runoff shall beis mitigated to the reasonable satisfaction of the 3743 building official. 3744 D. Windows Aand Doors: Windows that are required by this chapter for light and 3745 ventilation shall be fully glazed. Window openings not required to meet light, ventilation, and 3746 egress standards may be sealed with opaque materials or removed. Broken or missing doors, 3747 door frames, windows, and window sashes shall be replaced or repaired. 3748 E. Appendages: All awnings, fire escapes, exhaust ducts and similar appendages 3749 shall be maintained in good repair and be properly anchored. 103 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3750 F. House Addressing: All residential buildings shall display a street number in a 3751 prominent location on the street side of the building in such a position that the number is easily 3752 visible to approaching emergency vehicles. The numerals shall be in accordance with the codes 3753 adopted in Section 18.04.040no less than three inches (3") in height and shall be of a contrasting 3754 color to the background to which they are attached. Each individual unit within any multiple- 3755 family structure shall display a prominent identification number, not less than two inches (2") in 3756 height, which is easily visible. 3757 G. Exterior Walkways: All sidewalks, walkways, stairs, driveways, parking spaces 3758 and similar areas shall be kept in a proper state of repair, and maintained free from hazardous 3759 conditions. 3760 3761 18.50.150: INTERIOR STANDARDS: 3762 A. Showers/Tubs: Showers shall be finished to a height of seventy70 inches (70") 3763 above the fixture drain outlet with nonabsorbent material. Freestanding tubs with shower risers 3764 may utilize a shower curtain that totally encloses all sides of the tub. 3765 B. Floor Coverings: All floor and stair coverings shall be maintained in a secure and 3766 substantially intact manner. This standard does not apply to area or throw rugs within dwelling 3767 units. 3768 C. Walls And Ceilings: All walls and ceilings shall be maintained so that they are 3769 secure and intact. Surfaces shall be painted or covered with wallpaper or panelling. 3770 D. Finishes, Washable Surfaces: In kitchens and bathrooms of congregate housing 3771 and SROs, floors and walls within fifteen15 inches (15") of sinks, bidets, showers, toilets, and 3772 tubs shall be finished with a nonporous material that is not adversely affected by moisture. 3773 E. Operable Fixtures Aand Equipment: All fixtures, appliances, and equipment 3774 required by this code shall be maintained in safe and operable condition. 3775 3776 18.50.160: DOORS, TRIM AND HARDWARE: 3777 A. All doors, trim and hardware shall be kept in good working condition. 3778 B. Exterior doors which are required for ingress and egress shall have locks which 3779 are keyed from the exterior and are operable from the interior without the use of a key or other 3780 special equipment or knowledge. Original locks in historic buildings are not required to be 3781 replaced if in good working condition. 3782 C. Hinges for out swinging doors shall be equipped with nonremovable hinge pins or 3783 a mechanical interlock to preclude removal of the door from the exterior by removing the hinge 3784 pins. 3785 3786 18.50.170: ENVIRONMENTAL OR SANITARY STANDARDS: 104 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3787 A. All premises shall be maintained clean, safe, sanitary and free from an 3788 accumulation of rubbish. Every occupant of a structure shall keep that part of the structure and 3789 exterior property which such occupant occupies, controls or uses in a clean and sanitary 3790 condition. Every owner of a structure containing a boarding and rooming house, fraternity and 3791 sorority house, dormitory, SRO or multiple-family dwelling units shall maintain, in a clean and 3792 sanitary condition, the shared or public areas of the structure and exterior property. 3793 B. Garbage and refuse storage and removal shall meet the requirements of the Salt 3794 Lake CountyValley health department regulations. 3795 C. There shall be no insect or rodent infestation in violation of the Salt Lake 3796 CountyValley health department regulations. 3797 D. Asbestos, regardless of the date of installation, shall meet the requirements of the 3798 Salt Lake CountyValley health department regulations. 3799 E. A room in which a toilet is located shall be separated from food preparation or 3800 storage rooms by a tightfitting door. 3801 3802 18.50.180: SPACE AND OCCUPANCY STANDARDS: 3803 A. Ceiling Heights: 3804 1. Habitable Rooms: The minimum ceiling height for all habitable rooms 3805 shall be as set forth in the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040seven feet six 3806 inches (7'6"), except for kitchens, which may be seven feet zero inches (7'0"). This height 3807 may be six6 feet four4 inches (6'4") when the requirements of this chapter for emergency 3808 egress, light and ventilation are met and a one hundred twenty (120) volt electrical 3809 powered smoke detector and carbon monoxide detector areis installed pursuant to the 3810 construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040in the room. The only exception is that a 3811 smoke detector is not required in a kitchen. ProjectionsObstructions shall be allowed to 3812 six5 feet 10zero inches (6'0") when the projectionobstruction is not in the pattern of 3813 circulation and projectionsobstructions are not greater than twenty percent (20%) of the 3814 floor area of the room. 3815 2. Nonhabitable Rooms Except Bathrooms: All nonhabitable rooms, except 3816 bathrooms, shall have no minimum ceiling height requirement. 3817 3. Bathrooms Aand Toilet Rooms: Bathrooms and toilet rooms shall have a 3818 minimum ceiling height of six6 feet 0zero inches (6'0") with no projections below the six 3819 foot (6') minimum. Obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches. The bathroom 3820 ceiling height at the back of a sink, toilet or tub without shower may be sloped to a 3821 minimum height of 5five feet 0zero inches (5'0") at the wall when the ceiling height is no 3822 less than 6six feet 0zero inches (6'0") at a point 2two feet 0zero inches (2'0") from the 3823 wall adjacent to the bathroom plumbing fixture. 3824 4. Sloping Ceilings: In any room with a sloping ceiling, at least one-half 3825 (1/2) the floor area shall have a minimum ceiling height as required by this section. No 105 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3826 portion of the room with a ceiling height below 5five feet 0zero inches (5'0") may be 3827 used in the floor area computation. 3828 5. Corridors: A minimum ceiling height of six6 feet 4 inches (6'4") shall be 3829 required in corridors so long as there are a smoke detector and carbon monoxide detector 3830 installed pursuant to the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. Obstructions 3831 shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of 3832 circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the corridor. 3833 B. Room Aand Corridor Size: 3834 1. Floor Area Aand Room Dimensions: Floor area and room dimensions 3835 shall be as set forth in the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040.Dwelling 3836 units shall have at least one habitable room with not less than one hundred twenty (120) 3837 square feet of floor area. Habitable rooms other than a kitchen shall have an area not less 3838 than seventy (70) square feet and shall not be less than seven feet (7') in length or width. 3839 2. Sleeping Room Dimensions: Every room used for sleeping shall have at 3840 least seventy (70) square feet of floor area equal to the amounts required by the 3841 construction codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. Where more than two (2) 3842 persons occupy a room used for sleeping, the required floor area shall be increased at the 3843 rate of fifty (50) square feet for each occupant in excess of two (2). 3844 3. Corridors: The minimum width of corridors shall be 36thirty six inches 3845 (36"). In dwelling units constructed prior to 1983, a minimum corridor width of 28thirty 3846 inches (30") shall be permitted. 3847 C. Special Dwellings: 3848 1. Efficiency Dwelling Units: An efficiency dwelling unit shall: 3849 a. Have a living room of at least one hundred ninety (190) square feet 3850 of floor area equal to the amounts required by the construction codes adopted 3851 pursuant to Section 18.04.040. An additional one hundred (100) square feet of 3852 floor area shall be provided for each occupant in excess of two (2); 3853 b. Have a closet; 3854 c. Have a kitchen sink and cooking and refrigeration facilities, each 3855 having a clear working space of at least thirty30 inches (30") in front of the 3856 fixture or appliance; 3857 d. Have a bathroom containing a toilet, sink and bathtub or shower. 3858 2. Congregate Housing: Except for Shared Housing as defined in Title 21A, 3859 Iindividual units in congregate housing shall have at least one room with not less than 3860 seventy (70) square feet of floor area per occupant. When individual rooms are less than 3861 one hundred twenty (120) square feet, a separate common room shall be provided of at 3862 least one hundred twenty (120) square feet for each ten (10) units, with a minimum of 3863 one common room per floor. When separate rooms are not provided with cooking 106 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3864 facilities, the common room may be a common kitchen with a floor area as defined by the 3865 floor area computation. 3866 D. Cooking Facilities: 3867 1. Cooking Facilities Iin Dwelling Units: Each dwelling unit shall have a 3868 kitchen that supplies: 3869 a. A range with stove top and oven, or in the alternative, a 3870 nonportable cooktop and oven. Hot plates, pans, and similar units shall not be 3871 considered as cooking facilities. All cooking appliances shall be maintained in 3872 good working condition. 3873 b. An approved sink, with a minimum dimension of twelve12 inches 3874 by twelve12 inches by four4 inches (12" x 12" x 4") deep. 3875 c. A minimum of four (4) square feet of counter space. 3876 d. A refrigerator. 3877 2. Cooking Facilities Ffor Individual Units Iin Congregate Housing: As long 3878 as such cooking facilities do not encroach into the required floor area, required cooking 3879 facilities may be supplied in individual units, provided all of the following items are 3880 supplied: 3881 a. A range with stove top and oven, or in the alternative, a 3882 nonportable cooktop and oven. Hot plates, pans, and similar units shall not be 3883 considered as cooking facilities and are not allowed. Portable cooking devices are 3884 not allowed in individual rooms; 3885 b. An approved sink, with a minimum dimension of twelve12 inches 3886 by twelve12 inches by four4 inches (12" x 12" x 4") deep; 3887 c. A minimum of four (4) square feet of counter space; 3888 d. A refrigerator. 3889 3. Common Kitchens Iin Congregate Housing: When cooking facilities are 3890 not provided within individual units, congregate housing shall have a common kitchen 3891 area which shall contain the following minimum facilities: a sink for each twenty (20) 3892 tenants or portion thereof, a range for each twenty (20) tenants or portion thereof, and a 3893 refrigerator for each ten (10) tenants or portion thereof. The minimum kitchen area shall 3894 be one hundred twenty (120) square feet based on the floor area computation for the first 3895 ten (10) occupants or portion thereof, and an additional thirty (30) square feet for each 3896 additional ten (10) persons or portion thereof. 3897 E. Window Size Alterations: When window size modifications are necessary to meet 3898 light, ventilation or emergency egress, the window shall meet the most currently adopted 3899 uniform building code standard. 107 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3900 18.50.190: LIGHT AND VENTILATION: 3901 A. Natural Light Iin Habitable Rooms: 3902 1. Every habitable room shall have at least one window facing directly to the 3903 outdoors to provide natural light. The minimum total window area shall equal one- 3904 twentieth (1/20th) or more of the floor area of the room, with a minimum of three and 3905 one-half (3 and 1/2) square feet. Special purpose rooms such as home theaters and film 3906 processing rooms shall not be subject to this requirement. Kitchens may be provided with 3907 artificial light, which shall be a minimum of 1.5 watts incandescent or 0.8 watts 3908 fluorescent per square foot of the room. 3909 2. The glazed area of an exterior door may be used for purposes of 3910 computing window size for natural light. 3911 3. For the purpose of meeting light or ventilation requirements, as well as 3912 emergency egress, a room may be considered as a portion of an adjoining room when 3913 one-half (1/2) of the area of the common wall is open and unobstructed and provides an 3914 opening of not less than one-tenth (1/10) of the floor area of the interior room or twenty 3915 five (25) square feet, whichever is greater. 3916 B. Ventilation: 3917 1. Habitable Rooms: 3918 a. Except as provided in subsection B1b of this section, all habitable 3919 rooms shall be provided with natural ventilation by means of openings to the 3920 exterior which have the capability of being closed to the weather. Total openings 3921 shall have an area at least one-twentieth (1/20) of the floor area of the room or 3922 three and one-half (3 and 1/2) square feet, whichever is greater. 3923 b. A mechanical ventilation system shall be allowed in lieu of 3924 openings for natural ventilation. Such system shall create a positive pressure in 3925 the room and the air intake shall be connected directly to the outside and be 3926 capable of two (2) air exchanges per hour. In kitchens, the ventilation system may 3927 create negative pressure. The air intake/exhaust source shall be located at least 3928 three3 feet (3') above any opening which is within ten10 feet (10') of the air 3929 intake/exhaust. 3930 c. Exterior doors may be used to meet natural ventilation 3931 requirements. 3932 2. Bathrooms, Laundry Rooms, Aand Oother Nonhabitable Areas: 3933 a. Except as provided in subsection B2b of this section, all bathrooms 3934 and laundry rooms shall be provided with natural ventilation by means of 3935 openings to the exterior which have the capability of being closed to the weather. 3936 Such openings shall have a total area not less than one-twentieth (1/20) of the 3937 floor area of the room, with a minimum of one and one-half (1 and 1/2) square 3938 feet. 108 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3939 b. A mechanical exhaust system connected directly to the outside 3940 shall be allowed in lieu of natural ventilation. The system shall be capable of 3941 providing five (5) air exchanges per hour. The exhaust air shall discharge at least 3942 three3 feet (3') above or ten10 feet (10') away from any air intake source. Toilet 3943 rooms may be ventilated with an approved recirculation fan or similar device 3944 designed to remove odors from the air. 3945 c. Mechanical or convection venting of bathrooms into the attic shall 3946 be acceptable. Recirculating fans may be used in toilet rooms only. Bathrooms 3947 with tubs or showers shall have a convection or mechanical exhaust system. 3948 d. Bathrooms constructed prior to 1970, which are vented with 3949 convection vent openings extending to the outside shall meet the ventilation 3950 requirement as long as the walls, ceiling and floor are not adversely affected by 3951 moisture. 3952 3953 18.50.200: FIRE SAFETY; EGRESS: 3954 A. Fire Safety: No hazard of fire or explosion shall be created or allowed to exist in 3955 any building, premises, equipment or apparatus. 3956 B. Exit Aand Emergency Egress: 3957 1. Every existing dwelling unit shall have a safe, continuous and 3958 unobstructed means of egress of a minimum ceiling height of six6 feet four4 inches (6'4") 3959 and a minimum egress width of 28 inches as per this code. Obstructions shall be allowed 3960 to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and 3961 obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the exitway. The exitway shall 3962 be kept in a proper state of repair and maintained free of hazardous conditions and 3963 obstructions. 3964 2. Every sleeping room located below the fourth story shall have at least one 3965 openable window or exterior door approved for emergency egress or rescue. Every egress 3966 window shall comply with the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, unless 3967 the size of the opening under such codes is not feasible then tThe opening shall have a 3968 minimum of three and one-half (3 and 1/2) square feet of openable space and clear 3969 opening dimensions of at least twenty20 inches (20") in one dimension and twenty four 3970 24 inches (24") in the other dimension. The escape window must open directly into a 3971 yard or exit court, or into a public street or alley. When windows are provided as a means 3972 of emergency egress or rescue, they shall have a finished sill height of not more than 3973 forty eight48 inches (48"). If the distance from the floor to the windowsill is more than 3974 forty eight48 inches (48"), a permanent ladder or platform attached to the wall or floor 3975 may be installed to meet the maximum height requirement. The ladder or platform must 3976 be approved by the city. 3977 a. Exception 1. Where two (2) approved emergency exit doors 3978 leading from the sleeping room to separate exitways exist and minimum light and 3979 ventilation requirements are met, this subsection does not apply. Emergency exit 109 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 3980 doors shall open directly to a yard or court, or may exit through no more than one 3981 adjoining room which has a door that leads directly to a yard or court. 3982 b. Exception 2. Where minimum light and ventilation and emergency 3983 egress requirements are met, there is no minimum sill height requirement in 3984 sleeping rooms of dwelling units constructed before 1968, which has not been 3985 altered from the original construction. 3986 c. Exception 3. Sleeping rooms that fail to meet the sill height, 3987 window size or net openable area for the emergency egress provisions of this code 3988 may have their emergency egress deficiencies remedied, provided the rooms meet 3989 the required natural light and ventilation requirements of the housing code, by the 3990 installation of a smoke detector in each of the deficient sleeping rooms and in the 3991 hall or space immediately adjacent to and leading into the sleeping room or area. 3992 The smoke detectors shall be wired directly to the house electrical system and be 3993 provided with a battery backup. 3994 3. For windows that are below grade, a window well shall run parallel to the 3995 width of the window and extend at least eighteen18 inches (18") out from the exterior 3996 face of the building. When the distance from the top of the window well to its bottom 3997 exceeds forty eight48 inches (48"), it shall be equipped with an approved permanently 3998 affixed ladder or stairs that are accessible with the window in the fully open position. 3999 Grates are permitted over window wells when hinged away from the structure and not 4000 weighing over fifteen (15) pounds per section of the grate. 4001 4. Bars, grills, grates or similar devices may be installed on emergency 4002 escapes or rescue windows or doors, provided such devices are equipped with approved 4003 release mechanisms which are operable from the inside of the grate without the use of a 4004 key or special knowledge or effort. 4005 C. Stairs Aand Handrails: Stairs and rails shall meet the requirements of the means 4006 of egress section of the applicable adopted state construction codeUBC or its successor with the 4007 following modifications: 4008 1. If there are four (4) or more risers, a handrail shall be required. Two (2) 4009 handrails shall be required when the width of the stairs is forty eight48 inches (48") or 4010 more. Stairways less than forty eight48 inches (48") in width or stairways serving one 4011 individual dwelling unit in group R, division 1 or 3 occupancy, or a group R, division 3 4012 congregate residence may have one handrail. Handrails are not required for monumental 4013 stairs. 4014 2. Handrails shall be placed not less than thirty30 inches (30") nor more than 4015 thirty eight38 inches (38") above the outermost edge of the tread. Handrails for existing 4016 stairs are not required to extend beyond the top or bottom stair tread. 4017 3. Stairs shall have a maximum riser height of eight9 inches (8") and a 4018 minimum step run of 8nine inches (9"). Existing stair flights may have a maximum 4019 variation in rise and run of two2 inches (2") at the top and bottom of the flight. A 4020 maximum of one1 inch (1") variation of rise and run shall be allowed for all intermediate 110 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4021 risers and treads. Stairs shall be level and shall comply with life safety standards as 4022 defined herein. 4023 4. Windinger, circular and spiral stairs may run to narrow to a point. The run 4024 shall measure 8 inches (12 inches from the narrow point)shall comply with the UBC. 4025 5. There shall be no minimum rise or run requirement nor maximum 4026 variation in the rise and run for stairs leading only to mechanical, storage, utility, and 4027 nonhabitable rooms in any residential structure and laundry rooms in individual dwelling 4028 units provided the stairs are structurally sound. 4029 6. Steps shall be maintained in a safe manner. Missing steps, steps which are 4030 deteriorated to the point that a foothold is difficult to maintain, staircases which have 4031 missing boards, and/or staircases which contain boards that have lost their structural 4032 integrity shall be repaired to a safe condition. 4033 7. Interior and exterior stairs shall have a minimum headroom height of six6 4034 feet four4 inches (6'4") so long as there are electrical powered smoke detectors installed 4035 pursuant to the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, except for stairs to 4036 mechanical or storage rooms, utility and nonhabitable rooms in any residential structure 4037 and laundry rooms in individual dwelling units, which have no minimum headroom 4038 height. Within stairways obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the 4039 obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% 4040 of the floor area of the stairway. 4041 8. Stairs in the interior or exterior of an existing building where stair jacks 4042 are replaced or more than fifty percent (50%) of the tread or risers are replaced shall meet 4043 the requirements of the applicable adopted state construction codeUBC, except that the 4044 minimum stair width shall be thirty inches (30") and the minimum headroom height shall 4045 be fivesix feet four inches (6'4"). 4046 9. If because of the configuration of the horizontal and vertical distances an 4047 alternate stair configuration is more practical than the UBC requirement, or if HAAB 4048 finds that the stair rhythm is safe, HAAB may allow other configurations which are less 4049 uniform but achieve comparable safety, regardless of subsections C3 and C4 of this 4050 section. 4051 9.10. A stair tread, stair support, stair riser, landing or railing which is either 4052 missing or so severely in disrepair or damaged that it cannot support its intended live and 4053 dead loads shall be repaired. 4054 10.11. Interior stair landings shall have a minimum width of 28thirty inches (30") 4055 and a minimum length in the direction of travel of thirty30 inches (30"). 4056 D. Guardrails: 4057 1. Guardrails shall be required for all balconies, porches, patios and open 4058 stairs more than thirty30 inches (30") above or below grade. Guardrails shall also be 4059 required for any grade change more than thirty30 inches (30") next to a walking surface. 4060 Guardrails shall not be less than forty two42 inches (42") in height, except for guardrails 111 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4061 serving private dwelling units, which shall have a minimum height of thirty six36 inches 4062 (36"). Guardrails may have a minimum height of thirty six36 inches (36") if the building 4063 was built before 1970. Guardrails having a height less than thirty six36 inches (36") shall 4064 be allowed if they were installed as part of the building's original construction and are not 4065 a replacement. For structures which are on the historic register or are contributory 4066 structures located within one of the city's historic districts, height of existing and 4067 replacement guardrails may be determined based upon standards adopted by the city's 4068 historic landmark committee. 4069 2. Guardrails shall have intermediate rails or an ornamental pattern such that 4070 there is no open area in excess of four4 inches (4") in diameter. The diameter of such 4071 open space may be nine9 inches (9") for buildings built before 1985, and six6 inches (6") 4072 for those built between 1985 and 1991. 4073 E. Smoke Detector Requirements: 4074 1. When smoke detectors are required in dwelling units by the applicable 4075 adopted state construction codeUBC, the detectors shall be mounted on the ceiling or 4076 wall at a point centrally located in the hallway or area giving access to rooms used for 4077 sleeping. In efficiency dwelling units, the detector shall be centrally located on the ceiling 4078 or wall of the main room or sleeping room. 4079 2. Where sleeping rooms are on an upper level, the detector shall be placed at 4080 the ceiling or wall directly above the stairway immediately outside the bedrooms. Wall 4081 mounted detectors shall be a minimum of four4 inches (4") and maximum of twelve12 4082 inches (12") from the ceiling, but no detector shall be mounted within twelve12 inches 4083 (12") of any corner formed by the meeting of walls, ceilings or beams unless 4084 manufacturer's listing specifies otherwise. When activated, the detector shall provide an 4085 alarm in the dwelling unit. 4086 3. When one or more sleeping rooms are added to or created within a 4087 structure, smoke detectors shall be installed in compliance with the manufacturer's listing 4088 and shall receive their primary power from the building wiring in compliance with the 4089 applicable adopted state construction codeUBC. 4090 4. All habitable rooms having a ceiling height of less than seven7 feet six6 4091 inches (7'6") shall have installed a one hundred twenty (120) volt electrical powered 4092 smoke detector. 4093 F. Fire Resistive Separations: Walls or ceilings separating dwelling units from each 4094 other and from hazardous uses shall be maintained in their original condition with all 4095 penetrations sealed or covered with an approved material. These separations include walls and 4096 ceilings separating a garage from a dwelling unit or common area and walls and ceilings 4097 separating furnace rooms in structures containing three (3) or more dwelling units. When fifty 4098 percent (50%) or more of a wall or ceiling is removed for any reason, the entire wall or ceiling 4099 shall be reconstructed to meet the requirements of the applicable adopted state construction 4100 codeUBC for one hour occupancy separation. 112 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4101 18.50.210: PLUMBING: 4102 A. Minimum Requirements: 4103 1. Unless provided otherwise in this chapter, plumbing, piping and fixtures 4104 shall be in accordance with the code in effect at the time of installation. 4105 2. Plumbing, piping and fixtures shall have no leaks and shall be maintained 4106 in good condition. All waste lines shall be connected to an approved sewer system. 4107 3. The minimum plumbing fixtures required for dwelling units are a 4108 bathroom sink, toilet, tub or shower, and kitchen sink. 4109 4. Cold running water shall be plumbed to each toilet. Hot water shall be 4110 supplied to plumbing fixtures and plumbing appliances intended for bathing, washing or 4111 culinary purposesand cold running water plumbed to each bathroom sink, tub, shower 4112 and kitchen sink. 4113 5. Every sink, tub and shower shall be provided with hot water of at least one 4114 hundred ten degrees Fahrenheit (110°F) and with cold water. 4115 65. A space without obstruction from floor to ceiling of not less than twelve12 4116 inches (12") shall be in front of all toilets. Toilets shall be located in a space without 4117 obstruction from floor to ceiling of not less than twenty two22 inches (22") in width. No 4118 encroachments of these dimensions are permitted. 4119 76. Where vents do not exist for plumbing fixtures meeting the applicable 4120 codes in effect at the time of their installation, vents need not be installed when the 4121 plumbing fixture or trap and trap arm is replaced providing the sewer line is not altered. 4122 B. Water Heaters: Water heaters shall comply with the construction codes adopted in 4123 Section 18.04.040 or the construction code in effect at the time of installationand boilers shall 4124 have a listed combination temperature and pressure relief valve and relief valve discharge pipe. 4125 All new installations of water heaters and boilers, when located above a finished space, shall 4126 include a safe pan with an UPC approved drain piped to an approved drainage system. Existing 4127 water heaters and boilers shall have a temperature and pressure relief valve. The valve shall have 4128 a listed discharge pipe which discharges no nearer than six inches (6") to the floor and no further 4129 than two feet (2') from the floor. A temperature and pressure relief valve shall be required for 4130 water heaters only when a water heater was designed for such valve. 4131 C. Cross Connections: In order to protect against contamination of the water supply 4132 through cross connections, all water inlets for plumbing fixtures shall be located above the flood 4133 level rim of the fixture as defined in the UPC. Hoses or handheld shower heads shall not be 4134 attached in any manner that would permit water contamination during reverse pressure. Water 4135 supply pipes provided with an approved backflow preventer or antisiphon device as regulated in 4136 the UPC shall be permitted. Handheld shower heads shall be permitted when provided with a 4137 permanently mounted holder attached to the wall or shower pipe, or when an antisiphon device is 4138 installed. Water faucet outlets below the overflow rim of the fixture shall be permitted until the 4139 faucet is replaced. A new fixture shall not be installed where it would create a cross connection. 113 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4140 D. Drains: 4141 1. Drain traps shall meet standards of the applicable adopted state 4142 construction codeUPC. Existing traps shall be allowed as originally designed. If the trap 4143 has been modified it shall be replaced with an approved trap, and a vent shall be added as 4144 required by the applicable adopted state construction codeUPC. 4145 2. All open entrapped sewer lines and outlets shall be capped with an 4146 approved cap. 4147 E. Fixture Requirements: Every kitchen sink, tub, shower and toilet shall be 4148 provided with the minimum water pressure and quantities required by the codes adopted 4149 pursuant to Section 18.04.040a minimum of fifteen (15) psi of water pressure. 4150 F. Bathrooms Iin Rental Dwelling Units: Each rental dwelling unit shall have a 4151 bathroom within the dwelling unit. Every toilet and bathtub or shower required by this code shall 4152 be in a room which will afford privacy to the occupant. 4153 G. Congregate Housing: 4154 1. The minimum plumbing fixtures required for congregate housing are a 4155 sink, toilet, and tub or shower for each ten (10) occupants or portion thereof and a kitchen 4156 sink. Bathrooms shall have installed a door with privacy lock. 4157 2. Congregate housing that does not provide private toilets, sinks, bathtubs or 4158 showers shall have on each floor, accessible from a public corridor, at least one toilet, one 4159 sink, and one bathtub with shower or one separate shower for each ten (10) occupants or 4160 portion thereof. For each additional ten (10) occupants, or portion thereof, an additional 4161 one toilet, one sink and one bathtub or shower accessible from a public corridor shall be 4162 provided. 4163 4164 18.50.220: MECHANICAL: 4165 A. Mechanical Equipment: 4166 1. Existing Installations: Mechanical systems lawfully in existence at the 4167 time of the adoption of this code may have their use, maintenance or repair continued if 4168 the use, maintenance or repair is in accordance with the original design and location and 4169 no hazard to life, health or property has been created by such mechanical system. 4170 2. Compliance: All mechanical equipment shall be in accordance with the 4171 code in effect at the time of installation. 4172 3. Maintenance: All mechanical equipment shall be properly maintained and 4173 shall be operated in a safe manner. 4174 B. Heating: 4175 1. Temperature: Heating shall be provided by a permanently installed heating 4176 system capable of heating all habitable rooms and bathrooms to a minimum of sixty eight 114 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4177 degrees (68°), which shall be measured in the center of the room at a height of three3 feet 4178 (3') from the floor. 4179 2. Air Return: A return air duct which serves more than one dwelling unit 4180 shall not be permitted. A duplex or multiple dwelling unit legally constructed before 1970 4181 may have an existing common air return continued if the furnace was original 4182 installation. Existing common air return installations shall be allowed to continue when a 4183 listed smoke detector fan shutoff is installed in the return air duct of units constructed 4184 before 1985. Common air returns shall not be allowed in buildings constructed after 4185 1985. 4186 3. Fuel Burning Appliances: 4187 a. Except for direct vented appliances, gas furnaces and gas water 4188 heaters shall not be permitted in bedrooms, in bathrooms or in closets accessed 4189 only from a bedroom or a bathroom. Existing furnace rooms with access only 4190 through an existing bedroom may continue to exist when a one hundred twenty 4191 (120) volt smoke detector is installed in the bedroom and relayed to a smoke 4192 detector installed in the furnace room. All combustion air is to be supplied from 4193 outside air. 4194 b. Gas shutoff valves are required on all gas appliances. Shutoff 4195 valves shall be installed in accordance with the applicable adopted state 4196 construction codeUMC. 4197 c. All fireplaces, wood burning stoves, and all other appliances 4198 producing combustible gas byproducts shall be connected to an operating 4199 chimney or approved flue. All flues and vents shall be installed in compliance 4200 with EPA requirements and the requirements of the applicable adopted state 4201 construction codeUMC in effect at the time of installation. 4202 d. All fuel burning appliances shall be provided with combustion air 4203 per the requirements of their listing and with the applicable adopted state 4204 construction codeUPC and UMC in effect at the time of their installation. 4205 e. All fuel burning appliances shall be provided with listed clearances 4206 and maintained in good working condition and in accordance with their listing. 4207 f. All ventilation fans shall be installed according to their listing and 4208 maintained in good working condition. 4209 g. All ducts and vents shall be maintained according to original 4210 installation requirements. 4211 4212 18.50.230: ELECTRICAL: 4213 A. Safety: All electrical equipment, wiring and appliances shall be properly installed, 4214 maintained and used in a safe manner. Unless provided otherwise in this chapter, all electrical 4215 wiring and equipment shall be in accordance with the electrical code in effect at the time of 115 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4216 installation. All conductors shall be protected by fuses or circuit breakers that are adequately 4217 sized. 4218 B. Electrical Equipment: Electrical equipment shall not exceed the load capacity of 4219 the service and branch circuits shall have adequately sized circuit breakers or fuses. 4220 C. Facilities Required: The following electric facilities must be furnished at a 4221 minimum and must be operable: 4222 1. Service: The minimum main service to any dwelling unit shall be sixty 4223 (60) amperes. Existing dwelling units with electrical services less than sixty (60) amps 4224 per dwelling unit which have no special electrical service loads, such as air conditioners, 4225 ranges, heating units and clothes dryers may continue to be operated without upgrading 4226 the service. 4227 2. Branch Circuits: Circuits supplying air conditioners, ranges, cooktops, 4228 stoves and heating appliances shall meet the requirements of the NEC. Branch circuits 4229 shall not be overfused. 4230 3. Receptacles: Every habitable room shall contain at least two (2) electrical 4231 receptacles or one electrical light fixture and one electrical receptacle. Grounding type 4232 receptacles shall only be used when connected to a grounding system. Existing 4233 nongrounding type receptacles may be replaced with grounding type receptacles where 4234 protected by a ground fault circuit interrupter. 4235 D. Upgrading Facilities: 4236 1. Service: When remodeling work is done, the service must be upgraded if 4237 required by the NEC. 4238 2. Circuits: When new circuits, outlets, switches, wiring and service panels 4239 are being installed, the installation shall meet the requirements of the NEC. 4240 3. Receptacles: Wiring, receptacles and switches may be replaced without 4241 upgrading so long as circuits are not overloaded. 4242 E. Lighting: 4243 1. Dwelling Units: Every toilet room, bathroom, laundry room, furnace 4244 room, interior stairway and hall shall contain at least one permanently mounted electric 4245 light fixture. 4246 2. Apartments, SROs Aand Congregate Housing: 4247 a. Lighting in the common areas shall be as follows: Aisles, 4248 passageways, stairwells, corridors, exitways and recesses related to and within the 4249 building complex shall be illuminated with a minimum of a forty (40) watt light 4250 bulb or equivalent for each two hundred (200) square feet of floor area; provided, 4251 that the spacing between lights shall not be greater than thirty30 feet (30'). 4252 Structures containing three (3) dwelling units or less shall not be required to 4253 provide exit lighting when no lighting outlet has been previously provided. 116 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4254 b. Every furnace room shall contain at least one electric lighting 4255 fixture. 4256 c. Open parking lots and carports shall be provided with a minimum 4257 of one foot-candle of light on the parking surface during the hours of darkness. 4258 Lighting devices shall be protected by weather resistant covers and shall not cast 4259 glare on neighboring properties. 4260 F. General: 4261 1. All electrical panels, boxes, outlets and lighting fixtures shall have proper 4262 covers. 4263 2. Flexible cords, as defined in the NEC, shall be used only according to 4264 their listing and shall not be installed as permanent wiring or strung across exitways. 4265 4266 18.50.240: ENERGY CONSERVATION REQUIREMENTS: 4267 A. Upgrading: Existing residential units shall be upgraded whenever any of the 4268 following events occur: 4269 1. Whenever wallboard, plaster or other finish material is removed which 4270 exposes wall cavities of foundations, exterior walls, floors or ceilings, these spaces shall 4271 be insulated to the degree it is practical. Where attic and crawl space areas are insulated, 4272 the space shall be ventilated as per the currently adopted applicable state construction 4273 codeUBC. 4274 2. Where insulation increases the accumulation of snow, and the snow load 4275 capacity of the roof structure is exceeded, the roof members shall be upgraded to 4276 withstand the additional loads. 4277 3. When access is available to foundations of existing structures, foundations 4278 shall be insulated to the standard required by the applicable Utah energy code when 4279 remodeling of the structure is initiated. 4280 4. When boarded structures are renovated for reoccupancy, the structure shall 4281 be insulated to the following standards when wall, ceiling, roof or floor cavities are open 4282 or accessible: wall, R-11; ceilings and roofs, R-32; floors, R-7. Thermal resistance "R" 4283 shall have the meaning as defined in the Utah energy code. 4284 5. When new habitable space is created within an existing building envelope, 4285 all such spaces shall be insulated to the current Utah energy code standards. 4286 6. All replacement windows shall be double pane. Replacement glass for 4287 structures which are on the historic register or are contributory structures located within 4288 one of the city's historic districts may be determined based upon standards adopted by the 4289 city's historic landmark committee. Replacement metal windows shall have a thermal 4290 break. Single pane replacement glass may be installed on windows not designed to accept 4291 double pane glass. 117 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4292 7. All exterior door replacements shall be weather stripped. 4293 8. New mechanical equipment installed shall meet a minimum of eighty 4294 percent (80%) efficiency. 4295 9. Except for the other applicable requirements of this chapter, when a new 4296 addition is made to an existing residential structure, only the addition shall be made to 4297 comply with current Utah energy code standards. 4298 B. Exterior Door Aand Window Seals: 4299 1. Exterior doors and windows shall be weathertight. If broken, all panes 4300 shall be replaced with glazing in compliance with the applicable adopted state 4301 construction codesUBC. 4302 2. All doors and windows shall be properly caulked and weatherproofed. 4303 4304 SECTION 12. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.52. That Chapter 4305 18.52 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Mechanical Regulations) is 4306 hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: 4307 CHAPTER 18.52 4308 MECHANICAL REGULATIONS 4309 4310 18.52.010: DEFINITIONS: 4311 For the purpose of this title: 4312 ENERGY USING EQUIPMENT: That which is designed, constructed, erected or altered to 4313 operate by the use of fuel and/or power and shall include any devices and appurtenances or 4314 appliances, materials, ducts, pipes, piping, venting, gas piping, valves, fittings, fans, blowers and 4315 burners necessary to the performance of such functions that shall create comfort heating and/or 4316 cooling or power for work services. 4317 MECHANICAL SYSTEM: Means and shall include, but not be limited to, any heating, comfort 4318 cooling, ventilation and refrigeration systems, or energy using equipment. 4319 4320 18.52.020: UNIFORM MECHANICAL CODE ADOPTED: 4321 The edition of the uniform mechanical code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code 4322 commission, is adopted by Salt Lake City as an ordinance, rules and regulations of Salt Lake 4323 City subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set out, one copy of which 4324 code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. 118 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4325 Hereafter all references in this code to the uniform mechanical code shall mean the said edition 4326 adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. 4327 4328 18.52.040: MANUAL ON RECOMMENDED GOOD PRACTICES ADOPTED: 4329 "Recommended Good Practices For Gas Piping Appliance Installation, And Venting", Mountain 4330 Fuel Supply Company, revision of June 1980, is adopted by Salt Lake City as an ordinance, rules 4331 and regulations of the city, subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set 4332 out, three (3) copies of which code have been filed for use and examination by the public in the 4333 office of the city recorder. 4334 4335 18.52.050: MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES: 4336 A. Any person desiring a permit required by this code shall, at the time of filing an 4337 application therefor, pay the fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule to the 4338 city treasurer before the permit is valid. The basic fee for each permit requiring inspection is 4339 shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual 4340 specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 4341 4342 SECTION 13. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.56. That Chapter 4343 18.56 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Plumbing Regulations) is 4344 hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: 4345 CHAPTER 18.56 4346 PLUMBING REGULATIONS 4347 4348 18.56.010: UNIFORM PLUMBING CODE ADOPTED: 4349 The uniform plumbing code, 1988 edition, published by the International Association Of 4350 Plumbing And Mechanical Officials as a code in book form, three (3) copies of which have been 4351 filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder, is hereby adopted, 4352 except as such code may be altered or modified by the provisions of the ordinances of Salt Lake 4353 City. 4354 4355 18.56.020: PLUMBING SYSTEM DEFINED: 4356 "Plumbing system" means all potable water supply and distribution pipes, all plumbing fixtures 4357 and traps, all drainage and vent pipes, and all building drains and appurtenances within the 4358 property lines of the premises except: a) fixed lawn sprinkler systems beyond backflow 119 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4359 prevention devices, and b) building sewers and private wastewater disposal systems three feet 4360 (3') or more beyond the outside walls of buildings. Included also are potable water treating or 4361 using equipment and water heaters. 4362 4363 18.56.030: WATER SUPPLY PORTION OF PLUMBING SYSTEM: 4364 The water supply portion of the plumbing system shall be considered to extend from the meter 4365 box (or the property line in the absence of a meter) to and throughout the building, terminating at 4366 an approved backflow prevention device or devices serving fixed lawn sprinklers. Included also 4367 are fire prevention and firefighting piping and equipment. 4368 4369 18.56.040: PLUMBING PERMIT FEES: 4370 A. Before a permit shall be valid, permit fees shall be paid to the city treasurer. The 4371 basic fee for each permit requiring inspection is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 4372 schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City 4373 consolidated fee schedule. 4374 B. Fees for fire extinguishing systems shall be paid to the city treasurer as shown on 4375 the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 4376 4377 18.56.050: HOT WATER CAPACITY FOR RESIDENTIAL UNITS: 4378 All single-family residences which have central water heating units shall deliver a minimum 4379 capacity of thirty (30) gallons of one hundred forty degree Fahrenheit (140°F) water. Multiple 4380 units shall have a central water heating unit which shall deliver a minimum capacity of thirty 4381 (30) gallons of one hundred forty degree Fahrenheit (140°F) water per residential unit, when a 4382 central water heating unit is installed. 4383 4384 18.56.060: LOW FLUSH TOILETS; REQUIRED FOR BUILDING PERMIT: 4385 After the effective date hereof, no building permits shall be issued for new construction or 4386 remodeling of hotels, motels, apartment houses, dwellings or other structures which have toilets 4387 or water closets which use more than four (4) gallons of water per flush. Any toilets or water 4388 closets installed prior to said effective date shall meet the standards of this section when 4389 replaced. All fixtures installed pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall be of a design such 4390 that the walls of the toilet or water closet bowl are thoroughly washed and contents discharged 4391 with each flush. 4392 4393 18.56.070: LOW FLUSH TOILETS; ON WATERSHED PROPERTY: 120 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4394 After January 1, 1982, any toilets installed prior to the effective date hereof which are located on 4395 watersheds in Salt Lake County, or canyons contiguous to these watersheds, shall be replaced 4396 with toilets or water closets which meet the standards for new construction or remodeling 4397 specified in section 2-5-29 of the revised ordinances of Salt Lake County, 1965, or its successor, 4398 as amended. 4399 4400 18.56.080: FLOOR DRAINS; DUAL FLANGE AND SAFE PANS REQUIRED: 4401 All floor drains, area drains and indirect waste receptors installed on any floor level other than 4402 slab on grade shall have a dual flange and safe pans installed, with a minimum of thirty six 4403 inches (36") square of approved material, unless they are part of an original pour of concrete. 4404 4405 18.56.100: SOVENT PLUMBING SYSTEMS: 4406 "Sovent" is an engineered drainage plumbing system that does not meet conventional code 4407 requirements as found in the uniform plumbing code, 1988 edition, as adopted by section 4408 18.56.010 of this chapter, or its successor section. The system is based on the combined 4409 hydraulic/pneumatic flow and performance characteristics of drainage plumbing products, and 4410 will be allowed for use in the city under the following provisions: 4411 A. Certification: The proprietor(s) of the engineered system shall certify that the 4412 plans meet the design requirements and shall also certify at the completion of the installation that 4413 they have inspected the system and that the system complies with the approved plans; 4414 B. Submittal Of Calculations: Submit hydraulic and pneumatic calculations for the 4415 proposed system before a permit is obtained; 4416 C. Offsets: A double offset shall be installed in the stack on floor levels where no 4417 fixture or branch connections are made; 4418 D. Deaerator Fitting: A deaerator fitting shall be located as close as possible to the 4419 base of the stack. No branch or fixture connections are permitted on this system downstream 4420 from the deaerator fitting. A full size bottom pressure relief line shall connect the deaerator 4421 fitting to the building drain at least ten (10) pipe diameters downstream from the base of the 4422 stack through a wye fitting rolled above the centerline. The full size bottom pressure relief line 4423 shall be provided with an accessible upper terminal cleanout; 4424 E. Prohibited Attachments: Pumpout, blowout, garbage disposal, clothes washing 4425 machine, or outlets from grease traps are prohibited in this system; 4426 F. Cleanouts: Accessible cleanouts shall be provided in all horizontal drains. 4427 Cleanouts shall be provided for each aggregate change of direction exceeding one hundred thirty 4428 five degrees (135°); 4429 G. Conventional Plumbing: Vents from conventional plumbing and pressure 4430 equalizing line vents from a sovent system shall not connect to the sovent stack below other 4431 drainage fittings; 121 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4432 H. Future Alterations: No alteration may be made without prior written permission 4433 from the division of building and housing services, and no provisions for future openings will be 4434 permitted on this system. This system shall be properly identified on each installation site. All 4435 buildings of B-2 occupancies with more than eight thousand (8,000) square feet per floor shall 4436 provide at least one 4-inch waste stack and one 4-inch vent stack for any alteration or additions. 4437 4438 18.56.105: MISCELLANEOUS PLUMBING REQUIREMENTS: 4439 A. Overflow roof drains shall not be connected to the primary roof drain lines. 4440 B. Overflow roof drains shall drain to a point where they can be easily seen for early 4441 problem detection. 4442 C. Fill valves for fire sprinkler storage tanks shall be equipped with an approved air 4443 gap on reduced pressure backflow preventer. 4444 D. Safe pan drains shall be no smaller than one and one-half inches (11/2") unless 4445 first approved by the administrative authority. 4446 E. Trough drains are prohibited unless first approved by the administrative authority. 4447 F. Drainage for gravity dump washers shall be by direct hookup to the building drain 4448 or to a sealed sump connected to the building drain. There shall be a floor drain immediately 4449 downstream of each gravity dump washer hookup. 4450 4451 18.56.110: UNSANITARY CONSTRUCTION AND CONDITIONS: 4452 Any portion of a plumbing system or any construction or work regulated by this title found or 4453 determined to be unsanitary, as defined in this title, or otherwise a menace to life, health or 4454 property, is hereby declared to be a public nuisance. 4455 4456 SECTION 14. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.64. That Chapter 4457 18.64 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Demolition) shall be, and hereby is 4458 amended as follows: 4459 CHAPTER 18.64 4460 DEMOLITION 4461 4462 18.64.005: PURPOSE AND INTENT: 4463 A. The purpose of the provisions in this chapter is to: 122 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4464 1. Promote the public welfare by maintaining the integrity and continuity of 4465 the urban fabric and economic vitality; 4466 2. Provide an orderly and predictable process for demolition of buildings and 4467 structures when appropriate; 4468 3. Ensure demolition occurs safely; 4469 4. Protect utilities and other infrastructure from damage during demolition; 4470 5. Provide for enforcement of timely completion of demolition and for 4471 improvement of property following demolition to ensure the site is not detrimental to the 4472 use and enjoyment of surrounding property; 4473 6. Provide for enforcement and maintenance of property to avoid purposeful 4474 demolition by neglect; and 4475 7. Encourage preservation of the city's housing stock where appropriate. 4476 B. A primary intent of the city council with respect to this chapter is to promote 4477 responsible re-use of existing housing stock where practical and provide an orderly process for 4478 demolition where it is not practical or cost efficient to rebuild/reuse. Accordingly, the council 4479 finds that it is in the public interest to require existing buildings to be maintained in a manner 4480 that does not constitute a public nuisance until replaced by new construction, except as otherwise 4481 permitted by this code. 4482 4483 18.64.010: PERMIT REQUIRED: 4484 It is unlawful to demolish any building or structure in the city, or cause the same to be 4485 demolished, without first obtaining a permit for demolition of each such building or structure 4486 from the city building official as provided in this chapter. 4487 4488 18.64.020: APPLICATION FOR PERMIT: 4489 To obtain a permit for demolition, an applicant shall submit an application in writing on a form 4490 furnished by the building official for that purpose. Each application shall: 4491 A. Identify and describe the type of work to be performed under the permit; 4492 B. State the address of the structure or building to be demolished; 4493 C. Describe the building or structure to be demolished including the type of use, type 4494 of building construction, size and square footage, number of stories, and number of residential 4495 dwelling units (if any); 4496 D. Indicate the method and location of demolished material disposal; 4497 E. Identify the approximate date of commencement and completion of demolition; 123 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4498 F. Indicate if fences, barricades, scaffolds or other protections are required by any 4499 city code for the demolition and, if so, their proposed location and compliance; 4500 G. State whether fill material will be required to restore the site to level grade after 4501 demolition and, if required, the approximate amount of fill material; 4502 H. If the building or structure to be demolished contains any dwelling units, state 4503 whether any of the dwelling units are presently occupied; and 4504 I. State the proposed use of the premises following demolition. If new construction 4505 is proposed following demolition, state the anticipated start date and whether any development 4506 applications have been submitted to and/or approved by the city. 4507 J. Affirm that the property will comply with the landscaping requirements for the 4508 zoning district that the property is located in as required under the provisions of Chapter 21A.48. 4509 4510 18.64.030: FEES AND SIGNATURE: 4511 A. The permit application shall be signed by the party or the party's authorized agent 4512 requesting the permit. A signature on the permit application constitutes a certification by the 4513 signee that the information contained in the application is true and correct. 4514 B. The fee for a demolition permit application shall be as shown on the Salt Lake 4515 City consolidated fee schedule. 4516 C. An additional fee for the cost of inspecting the property to determine compliance 4517 with the requirements of this chapter and to assure the property is kept free of weeds and junk 4518 materials shall be collected in the amount shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 4519 4520 18.64.040: ISSUANCE OF DEMOLITION PERMIT: 4521 A. A demolition permit may be issued only upon completion of an application in 4522 accordance with Section 18.64.020 herein; or the chief building official or fire marshal orders 4523 immediate demolition: 4524 1. Due to an emergency as provided in Chapter 18.64, Article II of this title; 4525 or 4526 2. Because the premises have been damaged beyond repair because of a 4527 natural disaster, fire, or other similar event; or 4528 3. The chief building official or fire marshal authorizes immediate 4529 demolition because clearing of land is necessary to remove a nuisance as defined in this 4530 code or Section 76-10-801 et seq., Utah Code or its successor. 4531 B. If proposed demolition involves a landmark site, a contributing structure, or a 4532 structure located in the H Historic Preservation Overlay District, as provided in Section 124 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4533 21A.34.020 of this code, or its successor, a demolition permit shall be issued only upon 4534 compliance with applicable provisions of that section or its successor. 4535 4536 18.64.045: DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT: 4537 The owner of a boarded building shall maintain the exterior of the building as provided in 4538 Sections 18.48.2535 and 18.50.140, "Exterior Maintenance", of this title or its successor. 4539 4540 18.64.050: RESIDENTIAL DEMOLITION NOTICE 4541 A. If the structure for which a demolition permit is sought contains one or more 4542 dwelling units, whether or not occupied, upon issuance of a demolition permit, the building 4543 official shall cause to be recorded against title to such real property in the official records of Salt 4544 Lake County a notice that contains the following information: 4545 1. Information about the demolished property as required by the city, 4546 including the number of dwelling units and respective number of bedrooms, and the amount of 4547 rent charged in the year prior to the demolition, and the level of affordability if the rent is a 4548 below market rate. 4549 2. Notice that the future development of the property may have specific 4550 development requirements under the City code, including without limitation the city’s 4551 community benefit policies in chapters 19 and 21A.50.050. 4552 4553 18.64.070: PREDEMOLITION SALVAGE PERMITS: 4554 A. A predemolition salvage permit shall be required for removal of doors, windows, 4555 special glass, fixtures, fittings, pipes, railings, posts, panels, boards, lumber, stones, bricks, 4556 marble, or similar materials on the exterior or interior of any building prior to demolition of the 4557 structure. A predemolition salvage permit may be issued only contemporaneously with, or after, 4558 city approval of: 4559 1. A building permit for new construction on the premises following 4560 demolition, or 4561 2. A demolition permit. 4562 B. A predemolition salvage permit fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City 4563 consolidated fee schedule. 4564 4565 18.64.080: EXPIRATION; DILIGENCE: 4566 A demolition permit shall expire forty five (45) calendar days from the date of issuance, unless a 4567 completion date allowing more time is requested and approved by the building official at the 125 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4568 time of application. A demolition permit may be renewed upon request prior to expiration with 4569 approval of the building official for one-half (1/2) of the original permit fee, provided continuous 4570 progress is being made. If a permit is allowed to expire without prior renewal, any subsequent 4571 request for reinstatement shall be accompanied by a reinstatement fee equal to the original 4572 demolition permit fee. 4573 4574 18.64.090: QUALIFICATIONS TO DO WORK: 4575 A. It shall be unlawful for demolition work permitted under this chapter to be 4576 performed except by a wrecking and demolition contractor having a general contractor or 4577 demolition license in good standing issued by the Division of Occupational and Professional 4578 Licensing in the Utah Department of Commerce. 4579 B. Salvage work under a predemolition salvage permit may be done without a 4580 contractor's license provided all other applicable conditions of this chapter are met. 4581 4582 18.64.100: DEMOLITION REQUIREMENTS: 4583 A. Prior to the commencement of any demolition or moving, the permittee shall plug 4584 all sewer laterals at or near sidewalk lines as staked out by the department of public utilities. No 4585 excavation shall be covered until such plugging is approved by the department or by the building 4586 official. The permittee shall further ensure all utility services to the structure and/or premises 4587 have been shut off and meters removed prior to commencement of demolition work. 4588 B. When the applicant indicates the demolition will require more than thirty (30) 4589 days to complete, and where required by the building official for the safety of the public, the 4590 applicant shall also provide plans to fence the demolition site so that it is inaccessible to 4591 unauthorized persons in a manner acceptable to the building official. The building official may 4592 waive the fencing requirement if it is determined that fencing would be inappropriate or 4593 unnecessary to protect safety or health. 4594 C. A permit for demolition shall require that all materials comprising part of the 4595 existing structure(s), including the foundation and footings, be removed from the site. Unless 4596 otherwise approved under a building permit for redevelopment of the site, the depression caused 4597 by the removal of such debris shall be filled back and compacted to the original grade, as 4598 approved by the building official, with fill material excluding detrimental amounts of organic 4599 material or large dimension nonorganic material. 4600 D. Permitted demolition work, including filling and leveling back to grade and 4601 removal of required pedestrian walkways and fences, shall be completed within the permit period 4602 unless the building official finds that any part of the foundation of building or site will form an 4603 integral part of a new structure to be erected on the same site for which plans have already been 4604 approved by the building services and licensing division. In such event, the building official may 4605 approve plans for appropriate adjustments to the completion time and may impose reasonable 4606 conditions including the posting of a bond, erection of fences, securing, or similar preventions to 4607 ensure the site does not create a hazard after the demolition is completed. 126 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4608 4609 18.64.110: RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER ORDINANCE: 4610 Provisions of this chapter shall be subordinate to any contrary specific provisions of Title 21A, 4611 Chapter 21A.34 of this code, dealing with demolition in historic districts, or its successor. 4612 4613 18.64.120: VIOLATIONS: 4614 A. It is unlawful for the owner of a building or structure to violate the provisions of 4615 this chapter. Each day a violation occurs shall be a separate offense. 4616 B. Violation of the provisions of this chapter shall be punishable in accordance with 4617 Chapter 18.24is punishable as a class B misdemeanor or by imposing a civil penalty as provided 4618 in Section 21A.20.010 et seq., of this code. 4619 4620 ARTICLE II. EMERGENCY DEMOLITION 4621 4622 18.64.130: PURPOSE: 4623 Notwithstanding the other provisions of this chapter, the process for demolishing buildings in an 4624 emergency situation shall be as provided by this article. 4625 4626 18.64.140: EMERGENCY DEMOLITIONS APPLICABILITY: 4627 A. If the building official determines that the walls or roof of a building or structure 4628 are collapsing, either in whole or in part, or in imminent danger of collapsing in such a way as to 4629 fall on other structures, property, or public rights of way, are a public nuisance, or create a 4630 danger to persons who may enter the property, or create a danger of fire, the building official 4631 may issue an order that the building should be demolished pursuant to this article. A notice and 4632 order reflecting this determination shall be issued and delivered in accordance with Section 4633 18.24.040. 4634 B. If the city’s fire marshal determines that a building or structure that has been 4635 affected by fire presents an impermissible danger to persons who may enter the property, then 4636 the fire marshal may issue an order that the building should be demolished pursuant to this 4637 article. A notice and order reflecting this determination shall be issued and delivered in 4638 accordance with Section 18.24.040. 4639 C. If the building official or fire marshal declares an emergency demolition the 4640 requirements of Section 21A.34.020.F, or its successor, shall not apply. 4641 4642 18.64.150: RESERVEDEMERGENCY DEMOLITION: 127 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4643 If the chief building official declares an emergency, the notification and hearing provisions of 4644 section this chapter, or its successor, shall be waived and the building official may authorize 4645 immediate demolition of any structure that meets the standards of Section 18.64.140 of this 4646 chapter or its successor. The chief building official must make an emergency declaration in 4647 writing. 4648 4649 18.64.160: BILL FOR COSTS; COLLECTION: 4650 A. Permitted Recovery of Costs: If the building official or designee causes the 4651 emergency demolition of a building pursuant to a notice issued under Section 18.64.140, after 4652 the property owner received at least 10 days’ notice in which to complete demolition and failed 4653 to do so, the division may collect the city’s abatement costs which shall include the cost of the 4654 demolition contractor, costs of any environmental testing or environmental controls over 4655 demolition materials, and a reasonable amount to pay the costs of city personnel involved in the 4656 demolition, by filing a property tax lien, as set forth in this section.Upon the completion of any 4657 city demolition pursuant to this article, the city shall mail a bill to the property owner for the 4658 city's costs of demolition which shall include the cost of the demolition contractor and a 4659 reasonable amount to pay the costs of city personnel involved in the demolition. 4660 B. Itemized Statement of Costs: Upon completion of the demolition work, the 4661 building official or designee shall prepare an itemized statement of costs and mail it to the 4662 property owner by certified mail or using any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of 4663 confirming delivery, demanding payment within 30 days of the date the statement is post 4664 marked.If the bill is not paid within thirty (30) days, the city may take legal action to collect the 4665 bill. 4666 C. Form of Itemized Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs shall 4667 include: 4668 1. The address of the property at issue; 4669 2. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the division, including 4670 administrative costs; 4671 3. A demand for payment; 4672 4. The address where payment is to be made; 4673 5. Notification that failure to timely pay the expenses described in the 4674 itemized statement may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter 4675 and Utah Code Section 10-11-4 or its successor; 4676 6. Notification that the property owner may file a written objection to all or 4677 part of the statement within 20 days of the date the statement is postmarked; and 4678 7. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the name of 4679 the office and the mailing address. 4680 D. Delivery of Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs described in 4681 Subsection C shall be deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or by any reputable mail 4682 tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the 4683 property owner, according to the records of the county recorder. 128 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4684 E. Objection to Statement of Costs: A property owner may appeal the statement of 4685 costs to the fines hearing officer pursuant to Section 18.12.050. 4686 F. Failure to Object or Pay: If the property owner fails to make payment of the 4687 amount set forth in the itemized statement within 30 days of the date of the mailing of that 4688 statement, or to file a timely objection, then the division may certify the past due costs and 4689 expenses to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. 4690 G. Failure to Pay After Objection Hearing: If the property owner files a timely 4691 objection but fails to make payment of any amount ordered by the fines hearing officer, the 4692 inspector may certify the past due costs and expense to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. 4693 H. Lien on Property: After entry by the Salt Lake County Treasurer, as set forth in 4694 Subsections F and G, the amount entered shall have the force and effect of a valid judgment of 4695 the district court, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by the Salt Lake County 4696 Treasurer at the time of the payment of general taxes. 4697 I. Release of Lien: Upon payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement 4698 of costs or otherwise determined due and owing by the fines hearing officer, the judgment is 4699 satisfied, the lien is released from the property, and receipt shall be acknowledged upon the 4700 general tax receipt issued by the county. 4701 4702 SECTION 15. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 18.68.160. That Section 4703 18.68.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Floodplain Hazard Protection: 4704 Mandatory and Prohibitionary Nature of Chapter) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 4705 18.68.160: MANDATORY AND PROHIBITIONARY NATURE OF CHAPTER: 4706 A. Violations: It is unlawful for any person, firm or corporation to intentionally 4707 perform any act prohibited by this chapter or to intentionally fail to perform any act or comply 4708 with any requirement of this chapter or to aid or abet therein, or to fail or refuse to comply with 4709 any valid order called by the specified officials responsible to administer the provisions of this 4710 chapter. No permits shall be issued to any applicant during the time he/she shall fail to correct 4711 defective work or noncomplying work or violation exists after written notice by the official 4712 responsible for the permit or their designee. Any person, firm or corporation violating any of the 4713 provisions of this chapter shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor. 4714 B. Fines And Penalties: Upon conviction for such violations of this chapter, such 4715 party, if a person, shall be punishable as provided in section 1.12.050 of this code, or its 4716 successor. If such party is a corporation, association, partnership or governmental 4717 instrumentality, such party may be subject to a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars 4718 ($2,000.00) and/or imprisonment of not more than six (6) months. 129 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4719 SECTION 15. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.76. That Chapter 4720 18.76 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Mobile Home Parks) shall be, and 4721 hereby is amended as follows: 4722 CHAPTER 18.76 4723 MOBILE HOME PARKS 4724 4725 18.76.010: DEFINITIONS: 4726 For the purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply: 4727 CABANA: A room enclosure erected or constructed adjacent to a mobile home for residential 4728 use by the occupant of the mobile home. 4729 DEPENDENT RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A unit other than a self- contained unit. 4730 HOOKUP: The arrangement and connection of parts, circuits and materials employed in the 4731 connections required between the mobile home or recreational vehicle utility outlets and inlets 4732 and the park service connections that make the mobile home or recreational vehicle operational. 4733 MOBILE HOME: A factory assembled structure or structures equipped with the necessary 4734 service connections and constructed to be readily mobile as a unit or units on its own running 4735 gear, and designed to be used as a dwelling unit without a permanent foundation. 4736 MOBILE HOME PARK: A contiguous parcel of land which, after having the approval of the 4737 city planning commission, is used for the accommodation of occupied mobile homes. 4738 MOBILE HOME SPACE OR LOT: A designated portion of a mobile home park designed for 4739 the accommodation of one mobile home and its accessory buildings or structures for the 4740 exclusive use of the occupants. 4741 MOBILE HOME STAND OR PAD: That part of the mobile home space which has been 4742 prepared and reserved for the placement of one mobile home. 4743 MOTOR HOME: A self-propelled vehicular unit primarily designed as a temporary dwelling for 4744 travel, recreational and vacation use. 4745 PARK DRAINAGE SYSTEM: The entire system of drainage piping used to convey sewage and 4746 other wastes from the mobile home or recreational vehicle drainage outlet connection, at the 4747 mobile home or recreational vehicle site, to the property line connection with the sewer lateral 4748 from the main line sewer. 4749 PARK PLUMBING SYSTEM: Means and includes, but is not limited to, the park drainage and 4750 water supply systems within the park property lines. 4751 PARK WATER SUPPLY SYSTEM: All of the water supply piping within the park, and shall 4752 extend from the water meter to the mobile home or recreational vehicle water supply system, and 130 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4753 shall include main and branch service lines, fixtures, devices, piping in service buildings, and 4754 appurtenances thereto. 4755 RAMADA: Any freestanding roof or shade structure installed or erected above an occupied 4756 mobile home or any portion thereof. 4757 RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A vehicular unit, other than a mobile home, primarily designed 4758 as a temporary dwelling for travel, recreational and vacational use, which is either self-propelled 4759 or is mounted on or pulled by another vehicle, including, but not limited to, a travel trailer, a 4760 camp trailer, a truck camper, or a motor home. 4761 RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK: A site, lot, tract or parcel of land upon which one or more 4762 recreational vehicles are parked for temporary use as living quarters. 4763 RECREATIONAL VEHICLE SPACE: A plot of ground within a recreational vehicle park to 4764 accommodate one recreational vehicle. 4765 RECREATIONAL VEHICLE STAND OR PAD: That part of the recreational vehicle space 4766 which has been prepared and reserved for the placement of one recreational vehicle. 4767 SELF-CONTAINED RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A unit which: 4768 A. Can operate independent of connections to external sewer, water and electrical 4769 systems; and 4770 B. Has a toilet and holding tank for liquid waste; and 4771 C. Contains water storage facilities and may contain a lavatory, kitchen sink and/or 4772 bath facilities connected to the holding tank; provided, however, that all facilities shall be in 4773 sound operating condition, and further provided that it may be connected to external electric, 4774 water and sewer systems. 4775 SERVICE BUILDING: A building housing separate toilet and bathing facilities for men and 4776 women and which may also have laundry facilities, flushing rim sink, and other facilities as may 4777 be required by this title, and which shall be apart from the facilities within the mobile home or 4778 recreational vehicle. 4779 SEWER CONNECTION: All pipes, fittings and appurtenances installed to carry sewage from 4780 the mobile home or recreational vehicle drain outlet to the inlet provided in the park drainage 4781 system. 4782 SEWER RISER PIPE: That portion of the park sewer lateral which extends vertically to the 4783 ground elevation and terminates at each mobile or recreational vehicle space. 4784 TRAVEL TRAILER: A vehicular, portable unit, mounted on wheels, not requiring a special 4785 highway movement permit when drawn by a motorized vehicle, and: 4786 A. Designed as a temporary dwelling for travel, recreational and vacation use; and 4787 B. When factory equipped for the road, having a body width of not more than eight8 4788 feet (8') and a body length of not more than thirty two32 feet (32'). 131 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4789 WATER CONNECTION: All pipes, fittings and appurtenances from the water riser pipe 4790 connection to the water inlet connection of the mobile home or recreational vehicle. 4791 WATER RISER PIPE: That portion of the park water supply system which extends vertically to 4792 the ground elevation and terminates at a designated point at each mobile home or recreational 4793 vehicle space. 4794 4795 18.76.020: RESERVEDCOMPLIANCE WITH ZONING PROVISIONS: 4796 The appeals hearing officer may permit the use of land in any district for a mobile home park 4797 provided that in all cases there is compliance with the conditions in title 21A of this code. (Ord. 4798 8-12, 2012) 4799 4800 18.76.030: PERMITS, LICENSE AND COMPLIANCE REQUIRED: 4801 It is unlawful for any person to construct, maintain or operate a mobile home or recreational 4802 vehicle park within the limits of the city unless such person complies with this title and all other 4803 pertinent provisions of this code, and first obtains approval, permits and licenses as required. 4804 4805 18.76.040: RESERVEDEXISTING PARKS: 4806 Mobile home and recreational vehicle parks legally existing at the time of the effective date of 4807 the ordinance codified herein may continue to operate on the same basis as under nonconforming 4808 uses, as set forth in the current Salt Lake City zoning ordinance. 4809 4810 18.76.050: CONSTRUCTION PERMITS REQUIRED; FEES: 4811 Mobile home park construction permits required by the division shall be issued to properly 4812 licensed contractors as follows: 4813 A. A general building permit fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 4814 schedule, to be issued for pads, patio slabs, metal sheds (sheds to be installed by mobile home 4815 occupant), curb, gutter, drives, piers, sidewalks, fence or wall, per mobile home space; 4816 B. Electric meter stands or pedestals at the rate shown on the Salt Lake City 4817 consolidated fee schedule; 4818 C. The park plumbing system, including sewer and water risers, shall require the fee 4819 shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule, for each space; 4820 D. All permanent buildings, swimming pools, etc., shall have permit fees assessed at 4821 the regular and normal fee schedule; 4822 E. Fire hydrants within the property lines shall require a permit fee shown on the Salt 4823 Lake City consolidated fee schedule, for each hydrant. 132 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4824 4825 18.76.060: RESERVEDPERMIT REQUIRED BEFORE COMMENCING WORK: 4826 Application for required permits shall be made by a duly licensed contractor and fees paid to the 4827 city treasurer before any work commences. A double fee permit shall be assessed if any work 4828 commences without first obtaining the required permit or permits. 4829 4830 18.76.070: RESERVEDPLANS AND LOT PLACEMENT: 4831 The location of the mobile home lot limits on the grounds shall be the same as shown on the 4832 approved plans. The degree of accuracy obtained by working with a scale on the plan and then a 4833 tape on the ground is acceptable. Mobile home lot markers shall be the responsibility of the 4834 mobile home park operator. 4835 4836 18.76.080: LOT MARKERS: 4837 The limits of each mobile home lot in a mobile home park shall be clearly marked on the ground 4838 by permanent flush stakes, markers, or other suitable means. 4839 4840 18.76.090: RESERVEDPERMANENT BUILDING DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION: 4841 Every building, except a mobile home accessory building, shall be designed and constructed in 4842 accordance with this title. 4843 4844 18.76.100: ADDITIONS AND REMODELING OF PARKS: 4845 Existing mobile home and recreational vehicle parks may be enlarged or remodeled provided the 4846 addition or remodel conforms to all the provisions of this title. 4847 4848 18.76.110: RESERVEDACCESSORY BUILDINGS; PERMIT AND PLAN 4849 REQUIREMENTS: 4850 Prior to the installation of accessory buildings or structures in a mobile home lot, within a mobile 4851 home park, two (2) copies of a completely dimensioned plot plan drawn to scale and in 4852 accordance with the approved development plan shall be submitted to the division and a permit 4853 obtained. The plot plan shall show the size and location of the mobile home, the identification 4854 number, and the dimensions of the approved lot space, the dimension and location of the 4855 proposed structure, and its dimensional relation to immediate mobile homes and/or structures. 4856 4857 18.76.120: RESERVEDACCESSORY BUILDINGS; CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS: 133 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4858 A. Standards Applicable: Every accessory building or structure, including, but not 4859 limited to, cabanas, ramadas, awnings, patio covers and carports, shall be constructed in 4860 accordance with the provisions of the latest ANSI standard A119.3. No building nor any portion 4861 of any building shall be supported in any manner by a mobile home. 4862 B. Exception: Roof structures such as patio covers and awnings used as temporary 4863 shelter adjacent to a mobile home may be attached to the side of a mobile home, provided they 4864 project not more than ten feet (10') from the side of the mobile home and have at least the upper 4865 one-half (1/2) of the perimeter open or screened, with the remaining construction of nonbearing 4866 enclosing walls. 4867 4868 18.76.130: RESERVEDCARPORTS, RAMADAS AND COVERED PATIOS: 4869 Attached carports or ramadas shall be completely open except for necessary structural supports. 4870 Covered patios and similar structures may be enclosed, provided the construction conforms to 4871 the requirements of the latest ANSI standard A119.3, except as provided in this title. 4872 4873 18.76.140: RESERVEDRECREATIONAL VEHICLE AREA APPROVED WHEN: 4874 Where the mobile home park has direct access to a major highway, the appeals hearing officer 4875 may approve the use of a portion of the park as a recreational vehicle park, provided the same 4876 design standards are maintained. 4877 4878 18.76.150: UNDERGROUNDING OF UTILITIES: 4879 The complete distribution system or collection system of any utility shall be underground. 4880 4881 18.76.160: SEWER CONNECTIONS AND FEES: 4882 All present and normally assessed applicable fees set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee 4883 schedule shall be paid prior to occupancy of any mobile home, including those fees due to the 4884 engineering department for sewer lateral connection from the property line to the sewer main line 4885 in the street. 4886 4887 18.76.170: STREET SURFACING REQUIREMENTS: 4888 All streets shall be provided with a smooth, hard and dense surface which shall be durable and 4889 well drained under normal use and weather conditions. The surface shall be maintained free of 4890 cracks and holes, and its edges shall be protected by suitable means to prevent traveling and 4891 shifting of the base. 134 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4892 18.76.180: STREETLIGHTS: 4893 Lighting shall be designed to produce a minimum of 0.1 foot- candle throughout the street 4894 system. Potentially hazardous locations, such as major street intersections and steps or stepped 4895 ramps, shall be individually illuminated with a minimum of 0.3 foot-candle. 4896 4897 18.76.190: LANDSCAPING: 4898 Portions of a mobile home lot or recreational vehicle space not occupied by a mobile home or 4899 recreational vehicle or accessory buildings or structures shall be landscaped or treated in such a 4900 manner as to eliminate dust, weeds, debris and accumulation of rubbish. 4901 4902 18.76.200: UNLAWFUL AND HAZARDOUS USES: 4903 No person shall use, permit, or cause to be used for occupancy or storage purposes in a mobile 4904 home park a mobile home which is structurally unsound, which constitutes a hazard, or which 4905 does not protect its occupants against the elements. All mobile homes are subject to Chapter 4906 18.50. 4907 4908 18.76.210: VIOLATION; NOTICE TO DISCONTINUE: 4909 Whenever any mobile home is being used contrary to the provisions of this chapter, the division 4910 may pursue such enforcement methods as permitted by this titleorder such use discontinued and 4911 the mobile home to be removed, relocated, or otherwise made to conform with the provisions of 4912 this title by notice served on any person responsible for the illegal use. 4913 4914 18.76.220: ENFORCEMENT OF PROVISIONS: 4915 The division is hereby designated and authorized as the officers charged with the enforcement of 4916 this chapter. 4917 4918 SECTION 16. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.80. That Chapter 4919 18.80 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Parking Lot Construction) shall be, 4920 and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 4921 4922 CHAPTER 18.80 4923 PARKING LOT CONSTRUCTION 135 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4924 4925 18.80.010: PARKING LOT DEFINED: 4926 "Parking lot" means an open area other than a street used for the parking of more than four (4) 4927 automobiles, and available for public use, whether free, for compensation, or as an 4928 accommodation for clients or customers. 4929 4930 18.80.020: PERMIT; REQUIRED FOR CONSTRUCTION; ISSUANCE CONDITIONS: 4931 No parking lot or parking area shall be constructed without first obtaining a permit authorizing 4932 such construction. No permit shall be issued without first securing the recommendations of the 4933 city transportation engineer and no permit shall be issued until the applicant has complied with 4934 the provisions of this chapter. 4935 4936 18.80.030: WALLS, SCREENING AND BUMPER CURB REQUIREMENTS: 4937 The parking lot shall be provided with attractive walls, guardrails or screening shrubbery, at least 4938 along the street side, to limit points of ingress and egress, to prevent encroachment of parked 4939 vehicles on any sidewalk, and to improve the general appearance and, where necessary, with a 4940 bumper curb parallel with the inside of the wall or guardrail at such distance that the wheels of 4941 the motor vehicles in the parking lot are stopped prior to the motor vehicle's contact with the wall 4942 or guardrail. 4943 4944 18.80.040: DRIVEWAY RESTRICTIONS: 4945 Driveways must not exceed thirty feet (30') in width where they cross the sidewalk; adjacent 4946 driveways must be separated by an island at least twelve feet (12') in width; and driveways must 4947 be at least ten feet (10') from the property line of any intersecting street. 4948 4949 18.80.050: BUILDINGS FOR ATTENDANTS: 4950 Attendant buildings must be located far enough from the entrance to prevent congestion at the 4951 sidewalk, and must be constructed so as not to detract from the appearance of the surrounding 4952 neighborhood. Every operator of a parking lot, before constructing or reconstructing, or locating 4953 or relocating an attendant building, shall secure the approval of the city transportation engineer 4954 and the city planning director. 4955 4956 18.80.060: SURFACING OF PARKING AREA: 4957 Ground surfaces of the parking area shall be paved or hard surfaced. 136 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4958 18.80.070: LIGHTING FACILITIES; REQUIRED WHEN: 4959 Parking lots which are operated and open to use during the hours of darkness after one hour after 4960 sunset shall be provided with lights and lighting facilities that will provide 0.03 watt per square 4961 foot with incandescent light source, or 0.01 watt per square foot with either mercury vapor or 4962 fluorescent light source, but in no event less than 0.2 foot-candle average maintained 4963 illumination on the entire parking lot surface and an average ratio of six to one (6:1). 4964 4965 18.80.080: LIGHTING FACILITIES; PERMIT AND PLAN REQUIRED: 4966 Before installing the lighting facilities required by section 18.80.070 of this chapter, or its 4967 successor, and before altering or adding to any lighting facilities presently existing, the operator 4968 of a parking lot shall first make application to the building official for a permit, and shall submit 4969 with such application a detailed plan for such facilities. If it shall be found that the installation 4970 will conform to the requirements of this chapter and the electrical code, a permit shall be issued 4971 upon payment of the fee required by the electrical code covering work in commercial and 4972 industrial property. 4973 4974 18.80.090: CAR CAPACITY AND MANEUVERING: 4975 The maximum car capacity indicated on the application shall be reasonable, and the arrangement 4976 of parking facilities shall not necessitate the backing of cars onto adjoining public sidewalks, 4977 parkways, roadways or thoroughfares in conducting parking and unparking operations. 4978 4979 18.80.100: CLEANUP OF WASTE AND LITTER: 4980 Every operator of a "parking lot", as defined in this chapter, whether such operator is owner, 4981 lessee, representative or agent, shall keep such parking lot in a clean condition at all times, free 4982 from all kinds of refuse and waste material. It shall be sufficient compliance with this section to 4983 clear the parking lot from refuse and waste material once each day. 4984 4985 18.80.110: ENFORCEMENT OF PROVISIONS: 4986 It shall be the duty of the building official to enforce the provisions of this chapter with respect to 4987 lighting facilities. It shall be the duty of the board of health to enforce the provisions of this 4988 chapter as to keeping the premises in a clean condition. 4989 4990 18.80.120: FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER PROVISIONS: 4991 It is unlawful for any operator of a "parking lot", as defined in this chapter, whether such person 4992 is owner, lessee, representative or agent, to fail to comply with, or to violate any provision of this 4993 chapter. 137 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4994 4995 SECTION 17. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.92. That Chapter 4996 18.92 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Building Conservation Code) shall be, 4997 and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 4998 4999 CHAPTER 18.92 5000 BUILDING CONSERVATION CODE 5001 5002 18.92.010: UNIFORM CODE FOR BUILDING CONSERVATION ADOPTED BY 5003 REFERENCE: 5004 The uniform code for building conservation, 1988 edition, is adopted by the city as the 5005 ordinances, rules and regulations of the city, subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as 5006 hereinafter set out. Three (3) copies of the code shall be filed for use and examination by the 5007 public in the office of the city recorder. 5008 5009 18.92.020: EXCEPTION TO SECTION 402(d) AMENDED: 5010 The exception to section 402(d) of the code is amended to read as follows: 5011 Exception: Existing corridor walls, ceilings and opening protection not in compliance with the 5012 above may be continued when the corridors and common areas are protected with an approved 5013 automatic sprinkler system. Such sprinkler system may be supplied from the domestic water 5014 supply system, provided the system is of adequate pressure, capacity and sizing for the combined 5015 domestic and sprinkler requirements. When the building or floor changes occupancy, the entire 5016 floor or building must be protected with an approved automatic sprinkler system throughout. 5017 5018 18.92.030: SECTION 403 AMENDED: 5019 Section 403 of the code is amended by deleting the following sentence: 5020 Roofs, floors, walls, foundations and all structural components of buildings or structures shall be 5021 capable of resisting the forces and loads specified in chapter 23 of the building code. 5022 5023 18.92.040: EXCEPTION ADDED TO SECTION 606(1): 5024 An exception to section 606(1) is enacted to read as follows: 138 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5025 Exception: Existing nonconforming materials do not need to be surfaced with an approved fire 5026 retardant paint or finish when an automatic fire extinguishing system is installed throughout and 5027 the nonconforming materials can be substantiated as historic in character. 5028 5029 SECTION 18. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.94. That Chapter 5030 18.94 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Commercial Building Benchmarking 5031 and Market Transparency) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 5032 CHAPTER 18.94 5033 COMMERCIAL BUILDING BENCHMARKING AND MARKET TRANSPARENCY 5034 5035 18.94.010: PURPOSE: 5036 The purpose of this chapter is to promote long-term economic development in Salt Lake City 5037 through the enhanced energy efficiency of existing commercial buildings, and to reduce local air 5038 pollution and greenhouse gas emissions resulting from energy consumption in such buildings 5039 through increased energy efficiency, by requiring certain non-residential buildings to benchmark 5040 and report energy consumption and investigate opportunities to implement cost-effective 5041 building energy tune- ups. Promoting and recognizing efficient buildings will contribute to a 5042 cleaner environment and a more efficient use of energy resources. 5043 5044 18.94.020: SCOPE: 5045 The provisions of this chapter apply to buildings and building owners as follows: 5046 A. All buildings owned by the City, that are not used for residential purposes, 5047 wastewater reclamation plants, or for heavy manufacturing purposes as defined in section 5048 21A.62.040 of this Code, with three thousand (3,000) square feet or more of gross floor area; 5049 provided, however, no building with less than twenty two thousand (22,000) square feet of gross 5050 floor area shall be subject to the provisions of section 18.94.080 of this chapter. 5051 B. All other governed buildings or campuses of buildings that are not used for 5052 residential purposes within Salt Lake City's geographic boundaries, where at least one of the 5053 buildings is comprised of at least twenty five thousand (25,000) square feet of gross floor area. 5054 To the extent a governed building contains elements or uses that are not included within the 5055 definition of a governed building under this chapter, the square footage of gross floor area of 5056 such elements or uses shall be excluded from the square footage of gross floor area of such 5057 building and shall not be considered a part of the governed building for purposes of this chapter. 5058 C. Exemptions: 139 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5059 1. Governed buildings that are new construction and the Certificate of 5060 Occupation was issued less than two (2) years prior to the applicable deadlines; or 5061 2. Governed buildings that do not have a Certificate of Occupation or 5062 temporary Certificate of Occupation for all twelve (12) months of the calendar year being 5063 benchmarked; or 5064 3. Governed buildings where a full demolition permit has been issued for the 5065 prior calendar year, provided that demolition work has commenced, some energy-related 5066 systems have been compromised, and legal occupancy is no longer possible at some point 5067 during the calendar year being benchmarked; or 5068 4. Governed buildings, including individual buildings or structures, that do 5069 not receive utility services; or 5070 5. Any of the following: a property or building that is not assessed ad 5071 valorem real property taxes by Salt Lake County, houses of worship, apartments, 5072 agricultural storage facilities and greenhouses, buildings used for heavy manufacturing 5073 purposes as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code, oil and gas production facilities, 5074 buildings that contain movie/television/radio production studios, soundstages, broadcast 5075 antennae, data center, or trading floor that together exceed ten percent (10%) of gross 5076 floor area. 5077 D. Governed buildings do not include properties owned by State or Federal 5078 government. 5079 5080 18.94.030: DEFINITIONS: 5081 BASE BUILDING SYSTEMS: A building assembly made up of various components that serve 5082 a specific function and that are controlled and operated by the owner or designee, including: 5083 A. The building envelope; 5084 B. The HVAC (heating ventilating and air conditioning) systems; 5085 C. Conveying systems; 5086 D. Electrical and lighting systems; 5087 E. Domestic hot water systems. 5088 BENCHMARK: To track and report the total energy consumed for a governed building for the 5089 previous calendar year and other descriptive information for such building as captured by the 5090 benchmarking tool. Total energy consumption may not include separately metered uses that are 5091 not integral to building operations, such as broadcast antennas and electric vehicle charging 5092 stations. 5093 BENCHMARKING SUBMISSION: A subset of: 5094 A. Information input into the benchmarking tool; and 140 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5095 B. Benchmarking information generated by the benchmarking tool. 5096 BENCHMARKING TOOL: The Energy Star portfolio manager or any replacement tool adopted 5097 by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and any substantially similar tool approved by the 5098 Director. 5099 BUILDING ID NUMBER: The identification number that is unique to a governed building. 5100 BUILDING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM: A computer-based system that monitors and controls a 5101 building's mechanical and electrical equipment, such as HVAC, lighting, power, fire, and 5102 security systems, including an energy management system, incorporating interior temperature 5103 sensors and a central processing unit and controls, which are used to monitor and control gas, 5104 steam and oil usage, as applicable. 5105 CAMPUS: A collection of two (2) or more buildings where at least one of the buildings has at 5106 least twenty five thousand (25,000) square feet of gross floor area or more and that act as a single 5107 cohesive property with a single shared primary function, and are generally owned and operated 5108 by the same party. 5109 CITY PROPERTY: All buildings owned by the City, that are not used for residential purposes, 5110 wastewater reclamation plants, or for heavy manufacturing purposes as defined in section 5111 21A.62.040 of this Code. 5112 DEPARTMENT: The Salt Lake City Department of Sustainability. 5113 DIRECTOR: The Director of the Salt Lake City Department of Sustainability. 5114 ENERGY STAR PORTFOLIO MANAGER: The tool developed and maintained by the U.S. 5115 Environmental Protection Agency to track and assess the relative energy performance of 5116 buildings nationwide. 5117 ENERGY STAR SCORE: The 1 - 100 numeric rating generated by the Energy Star portfolio 5118 manager tool. 5119 FINANCIAL HARDSHIP: A property that: 5120 A. Had arrears of property taxes or water or wastewater charges that resulted in the 5121 property's inclusion, within the prior two (2) years, on the City's annual tax lien sale list; or 5122 B. Has a court appointed receiver in control of the property due to financial distress; 5123 or 5124 C. Is owned by a financial institution through default by the borrower; or 5125 D. Has been acquired by a deed in lieu of foreclosure; or 5126 E. Has a senior mortgage subject to a notice of default. 5127 GOVERNED BUILDING: All stand-alone and enclosed buildings used or occupied for a 5128 commercial use, including: 5129 A. Banking/financial services; 141 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5130 B. Stand-alone data centers; 5131 C. Education (including K - 12, daycare, pre- school, vocational school); 5132 D. Entertainment/public assembly (including convention centers, gyms, movie 5133 theaters, performing arts, meeting halls, recreation centers); 5134 E. Food sales and services (including restaurants, supermarkets, grocery stores, 5135 convenience stores); 5136 F. Healthcare (including hospitals, medical offices, senior care communities, 5137 assisted living and nursing care); 5138 G. Lodging (including hotels, motels); 5139 H. Mixed use; 5140 I. Offices; 5141 J. Retail (including retail goods establishments, retail service establishments, 5142 department stores, mass merchandising stores, specialty stores, enclosed retail malls and 5143 shopping centers); 5144 K. Technology/science (including data centers and research facilities); 5145 L. Warehouses, distribution, and package delivery facilities. 5146 GROSS FLOOR AREA: All gross floor area, which is the area included within the exterior walls 5147 of a building or portion thereof, including mezzanines, enclosed interior balconies, enclosed 5148 porches, basement floor area, penthouses, attic space having headroom of seven feet (7') or more, 5149 and interior connected floor area devoted to accessory uses. Gross floor area does not include 5150 balconies, patios, crawl spaces, courts, convertible indoor/outdoor space, parking or loading 5151 areas, and covered walkways. 5152 HEAVY MANUFACTURING: The same as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code. 5153 OCCUPANCY: The physical occupancy of a unit or space by an occupant or a tenant. 5154 OWNER: Any of the following: 5155 A. An individual or entity possessing title to a governed property; 5156 B. The net lessee in the case of a property subject to a triple net lease with a single 5157 tenant; 5158 C. The Board of Managers in the case of a nonresidential condominium; 5159 D. An agent or party duly authorized to act on behalf of the owner. 5160 PERSISTENT COMMISSIONING: An ongoing process of comparing data obtained through the 5161 building management system with analytic models; identifying problematic sensors, controls and 5162 equipment; and resolving operating problems, optimizing energy use and identifying retrofits for 5163 existing buildings. 142 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5164 SHARED BENCHMARKING INFORMATION: Any descriptive information identifying 5165 governed buildings with Energy Star scores above 50, and any portions of the submitted 5166 benchmarking information that owner elects to be posted publicly on the department's website. 5167 SUBMITTED BENCHMARKING INFORMATION: Whole-building information generated by 5168 the benchmarking tool and descriptive information about the governed building and its 5169 operational characteristics, which is submitted to the department. The information shall be 5170 limited to: 5171 A. Descriptive information: 5172 1. Property address; 5173 2. Primary use type; 5174 3. Gross floor area; 5175 B. Output information: 5176 1. Site electricity consumption (kWh); 5177 2. Site natural gas consumption (therms); 5178 3. Site energy use intensity (site EUI); 5179 4. Weather normalized source energy use intensity (source EUI); 5180 5. Total annual greenhouse gas emissions; 5181 6. Water use per gross square foot (if available); 5182 7. The Energy Star score, where available; and 5183 C. Comparable information based on updates/revisions to Energy Star portfolio 5184 manager. 5185 TENANT: A person or entity occupying or holding possession of all or a portion of real 5186 property, or all or a portion of a governed building pursuant to a rental or lease agreement. 5187 TUNE-UP EVALUATION: A utility sponsored retro-commissioning process that systematically 5188 evaluates base building systems and identifies improvements to achieve optimal building 5189 performance. This includes planning, investigation, and documentation to optimize operation, 5190 maintenance and performance of the facility and/or its base building systems and assemblies. 5191 TUNE-UP EVALUATION REPORT: A report certified by the tune-up professional 5192 demonstrating that a tune-up evaluation was conducted through a utility-sponsored tune-up 5193 incentive program. 5194 TUNE-UP PROFESSIONAL: An individual or entity approved or utilized by local utilities to 5195 provide tune-up evaluation services or who possesses other substantially similar credential to 5196 perform a tune-up evaluation required by this chapter. 143 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5197 18.94.040: SUMMARY OF BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS 5198 AND INITIAL COMPLIANCE DATES: 5199 Properties Submitted Benchmarking Information Due Shared Benchmarking Information Made Publicly Available Date When First Tune-Up Evaluation Report Must Be Filed Frequency Of Tune-Up Evaluation City property May 1, 2018 Sept. 1, 2018 May 1, 2020 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year Governed building (50,000 sq. ft. of gross floor area or larger) May 1, 2019 Sept. 1, 2020 May 1, 2021 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year Governed building (25,000 to 49,999 sq. ft. of gross floor area) May 1, 2020 Sept. 1, 2021 May 1, 2022 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year 5200 5201 18.94.050: BENCHMARKING AND BENCHMARKING SUBMISSION REQUIRED: 5202 A. Governed buildings and City properties shall be benchmarked annually for the 5203 previous calendar year according to the following schedule: 5204 1. Each City property shall be benchmarked no later than May 1, 2018, and 5205 every May 1 thereafter. 5206 2. Each governed building with a gross floor area of fifty thousand (50,000) 5207 square feet or more shall be benchmarked no later than May 1, 2019, and every May 1 5208 thereafter. 5209 3. Each governed building with a gross floor area of twenty five thousand 5210 (25,000) to forty nine thousand nine hundred ninety nine (49,999) square feet shall be 5211 benchmarked no later than May 1, 2020, and every May 1 thereafter. 5212 B. Below is a summary table of the first benchmarking submission compliance dates: 5213 Properties Benchmarking Submission By Building Owner City property May 1, 2018 144 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT Governed building (50,000 square feet of gross floor area or larger)May 1, 2019 Governed building (25,000 to 49,999 square feet of gross floor area)May 1, 2020 5215 5216 C. Benchmarking shall be performed and/or verified by the owner. 5217 D. Before making a benchmarking submission the owner shall run all automated data 5218 quality checker functions available within the benchmarking tool, and shall correct all missing or 5219 incorrect information identified. 5220 E. If the current owner receives notification from the City that any information 5221 reported as part of the benchmarking submission is inaccurate or incomplete, the information so 5222 reported shall be amended in the benchmarking tool by the owner and the owner shall provide an 5223 updated benchmarking submission to the Director within sixty (60) days of the notification. 5224 F. Exceptions: 5225 1. Governed buildings whose average occupancy throughout the calendar 5226 year for which benchmarking is required is less than sixty percent (60%); or 5227 2. Governed buildings under financial hardship; or 5228 3. Due to special circumstances unique to the applicant's facility and not 5229 based on a condition caused by actions of the applicant, strict compliance with provisions 5230 of this chapter would cause undue hardship or would not be in the public interest; or 5231 4. An owner is unable to benchmark due to the failure of either a utility 5232 provider or a tenant (or both) to report the information necessary for the owner to 5233 complete any benchmarking submittal requirement. 5234 G. For properties qualifying for these exceptions, the owner shall file documentation, 5235 in such form and with such certifications as required by the Director, with the department in the 5236 year prior to the due date for the benchmarking submission, establishing that the governed 5237 building qualifies for such an exception. 5238 H. A randomly-selected subset of benchmarking submission not to exceed ten 5239 percent (10%) of the total benchmarking submissions completed in a given year may be subject 5240 to verification by the City. Such reviews shall be conducted in a way so as to preserve the 5241 anonymity of individual properties and shall be conducted at no cost to the owner. 5242 I. An owner may make a claim of confidentiality for any submitted benchmarking 5243 information pursuant to the limitations under State law. 5244 5245 18.94.060: BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE TRANSPARENCY: 145 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5246 A. The City shall make accessible to the public the shared benchmarking information 5247 for the previous calendar year. 5248 1. For each governed building with a gross floor area of fifty thousand 5249 (50,000) square feet or more, on or about September 1, 2020, and on or about each 5250 September 1 thereafter. 5251 2. For each governed building with a gross floor area of twenty five thousand 5252 (25,000) to forty nine thousand nine hundred ninety nine (49,999) square feet, on or 5253 about September 1, 2021, and each September 1 thereafter. 5254 B. The department may, upon request, make available the submitted benchmarking 5255 information for the previous calendar year for an individual City property or governed building. 5256 5257 18.94.070: PROVIDING BENCHMARKING INFORMATION TO THE PROPERTY 5258 OWNER: 5259 A. Each tenant occupying a governed building shall, within sixty (60) days of a 5260 request by the owner and in a form to be determined by the Director, provide all information that 5261 cannot otherwise be acquired by the owner and that is needed by the owner to comply with the 5262 requirements of this chapter. 5263 5264 18.94.080: TUNE-UP EVALUATIONS REQUIRED: 5265 A. Required: Tune-up evaluations are required for governed buildings and City 5266 properties that are eligible for participation in a utility-sponsored tune-up incentive program, as 5267 determined by the utility offering the incentive program and that have an Energy Star score of 49 5268 and below. Implementation of tune-up measures in addition to evaluations is encouraged but not 5269 required. 5270 B. Report: The owner shall conduct a tune-up evaluation of the base building 5271 systems of a qualifying governed building and file a tune-up evaluation report prior to December 5272 31 of the year in which the tune-up evaluation is being performed. The initial reporting year shall 5273 be determined by the last digit of the property's tax ID number as illustrated below, and 5274 subsequent tune-up evaluation shall be completed and tune-up evaluation reports filed every fifth 5275 year thereafter: Last Digit Of Tax ID Number 50,000 Square Feet And Above Of Gross Floor Area 25,000 To 49,999 Square Feet Of Gross Floor Area Last Digit Of Tax ID Number 50,000 Square Feet And Above Of Gross Floor Area 25,000 To 49,999 Square Feet Of Gross Floor Area 0 2021 2022 1 2021 2022 2 2022 2023 3 2022 2023 146 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 4 2023 2024 5 2023 2024 6 2024 2025 7 2024 2025 8 2025 2026 9 2025 2026 5277 5278 C. Report Submission: The owner shall submit the tune-up evaluation report to the 5279 City. 5280 D. Exceptions: Tune-up evaluations are not required if any of the following are met: 5281 1. If the governed building is less than five (5) years old; or 5282 2. If a registered design professional or tune-up professional certifies that: 5283 a. The governed building has an Energy Star score of 50 or above for 5284 the year prior to the first tune-up due date or for at least two (2) of the three (3) 5285 years preceding the due date of the governed building's tune-up evaluation report. 5286 b. There is no Energy Star rating for the building type and owner 5287 submits documentation that the property's energy performance is better than the 5288 energy performance of an average building of its type for two (2) of the three (3) 5289 years preceding the due date of the governed building's tune-up report. 5290 c. The governed building has received certification under the most 5291 recent LEED 2009 rating system for existing buildings or operation and 5292 maintenance, or existing buildings version 4 rating system or future iterations of 5293 LEED published by the U.S. Green Building Council or other substantially 5294 similar rating systems for existing buildings, for at least two (2) of the three (3) 5295 years preceding the due date for the governed building's tune-up evaluation 5296 reports. 5297 d. The governed building has performed a tune-up evaluation within 5298 the past five (5) years prior to the tune-up evaluation due date. 5299 3. If the governed building has a persistent commissioning program in place. 5300 For properties qualifying for these exceptions, the owner shall file documentation, 5301 in such form and with such certifications as required by the Director, with the 5302 department in the year prior to the due date for the tune-up report, establishing 5303 that the governed building qualifies for such an exception. 5304 E. Verification: A randomly-selected subset of tune-up evaluation reports not to 5305 exceed ten percent (10%) of the total tune-up evaluation reports completed in a given year may 147 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5306 be subject to verification by the City. Such reviews shall be conducted in a way so as to preserve 5307 the anonymity of individual properties and shall be conducted at no cost to the owner. 5308 5309 18.94.090: NOTIFICATION: 5310 A. Between January 1 and March 1 of each year during which an owner is required 5311 to provide a benchmarking submission, the Director shall notify these owners of their obligation 5312 to benchmark performance for the previous calendar year through whatever means the Director 5313 so chooses. 5314 5315 18.94.100: VIOLATIONS AND ENFORCEMENT: 5316 A. If the Director determines that an owner has failed to comply with the 5317 requirements of this chapter or the owner submits incomplete or false information, the Director 5318 may issue up to three (3) written notices of noncompliance to the owner, allowing owner to cure 5319 such noncompliance within ninety (90) days after each notice of violation. After the third written 5320 notice of violation, the Director may impose a fine of up to five hundred dollars ($500.00) per 5321 violation thereafter not exceeding a total of one thousand dollars ($1,000.00) annually. 5322 5323 18.94.110: APPEALS PROCESS: 5324 A. Any owner affected by the Director's determination related to that owner's 5325 property regarding enforcement of this chapter may request, within thirty (30) days of owner's 5326 written notification of the Director's determination, in writing filed with the department, an 5327 appeal hearing before the Board of Appeals and Examiners, established under this title. 5328 5329 SECTION 18. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.95. That Chapter 5330 18.95 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Use of LEED Standards in City 5331 Funded Construction) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 5332 CHAPTER 18.95 5333 USE OF LEED STANDARDS IN CITY FUNDED CONSTRUCTION 5334 5335 18.95.010: PURPOSE: 5336 The purpose of this chapter is to promote development consistent with sound environmental 5337 practices by requiring, subject to sSections 18.95.040, 18.95.050, and 18.95.120 of this chapter, 5338 that applicable building projects constructed with city construction funds obtain, at a minimum: 148 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5339 a) "silver" for city owned and operated buildings, or b) "certified" for private building projects 5340 that receive city funds. These designations shall be from the "USGBC" as defined herein. 5341 5342 18.95.020: DEFINITIONS: 5343 As used in this chapter: 5344 APPLICABLE BUILDING PROJECT: The construction or major renovation of a commercial, 5345 multi-family residential, or municipal building that will contain more than ten thousand (10,000) 5346 square feet of occupied space when the design contract for such project commences on or after 5347 November 17, 2006. 5348 BOARD: The board of appeals and examiners created under chapter 18.12 of this title, 5349 hereinafter called "board". 5350 BUILDING OFFICIAL: The director of the division of building services or the designee of the 5351 director. 5352 CERTIFIED: The level of compliance with the leadership in energy and environmental design 5353 (LEED) standards designated as "certified" by the United States Green Building Council 5354 (USGBC). 5355 CHIEF PROCUREMENT OFFICER: The city employee designated pursuant to sSubsection 5356 3.24.040A of this code or that employee's designee pursuant to sSection 3.24.050 of this code, or 5357 any successor to those sections. 5358 CITY CONSTRUCTION FUNDS: Funds that are authorized to be used for construction by the 5359 city council for use by any person or city department in order to construct an applicable building 5360 project, including, without limitation, loans, grants, and tax rebates. However, this term shall not 5361 apply to the funds of the library or redevelopment agency. 5362 CITY ENGINEER: The city employee designated pursuant to sSection 2.08.080 of this code or 5363 that employee's designee pursuant to sSection 3.24.050 of this code, or any successor to those 5364 sections. 5365 LEED STANDARD: The leadership in energy and environmental design (LEED) green building 5366 rating system for new construction and major renovations (LEED-NC) as adopted in November 5367 2002 and revised in November 2005, the LEED green building rating system for commercial 5368 interiors (LEED-CI) as adopted in November 2002, or the LEED green building rating system 5369 for existing buildings upgrades, operations and maintenance (LEED-EB) as adopted in October 5370 2004 and updated in July 2005. 5371 MAJOR RENOVATION: Work that demolishes space down to the shell structure and rebuilds it 5372 with new walls, ceilings, floors and systems, when such work affects more than twenty five 5373 percent (25%) of the building's square footage, and the affected space is at least ten thousand 5374 (10,000) square feet or larger. 5375 SILVER: The level of compliance with LEED standards designated as "silver" by the USGBC. 149 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5376 SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: A determination of good faith efforts to comply as further 5377 described in sSection 18.95.110 of this chapter. 5378 TEMPORARY STRUCTURE: Any proposed building that is intended to be in existence for five 5379 (5) years or less or any existing building that at the time it was constructed was intended to be in 5380 existence for five (5) years or less. 5381 USGBC: The organization known as the United States green building council. 5382 5383 18.95.030: APPLICATION: 5384 Whenever city construction funds are used for an applicable building project, such project shall 5385 at a minimum obtain a silver certification by the USGBC in the case of a city owned building 5386 project or certified certification in the case of all other projects, subject to the exceptions, 5387 waivers, and determinations of substantial compliance provided for in this chapter. 5388 5389 18.95.040: EXCEPTIONS: 5390 The provisions of this chapter shall not apply if the building official and either the chief 5391 procurement officer or the city engineer jointly determine in writing that any of the following 5392 circumstances exist: 5393 A. The applicable building project will serve a specialized, limited function, such as 5394 a pump station, garage, storage building, equipment area, or other similar area, or a single- 5395 family residence; 5396 B. The applicable building project is intended to be a temporary structure; 5397 C. The useful life of the applicable building project does not justify whatever 5398 additional expense would be incurred to increase the building's long term efficiency; 5399 D. The application of LEED standard factors will increase construction costs beyond 5400 the funding capacity for the project, or will require that the project's scope of work or 5401 programmatic needs be diminished to meet budget constraints; 5402 E. The use of LEED standard factors will create an impediment to construction due 5403 to conflicts of laws, building code requirements, federal or state grant funding requirements, or 5404 other similar requirements; 5405 F. LEED factors are not reasonably attainable due to the nature of the facilities or the 5406 schedule for construction; or 5407 G. LEED certification will violate any other federal, state or local law, including, 5408 without limitation, other sections of this code. 5409 If an exception is granted, the developer must agree to integrate green building practices into the 5410 design and construction of the project to the maximum extent possible and feasible. A 5411 determination that an exception does not apply may be appealed in accordance with Chapter 150 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5412 18.12to the board. Such appeal must be submitted in writing to the board within thirty (30) days 5413 of the determination. 5414 5415 18.95.050: WAIVERS: 5416 The denial of an exception pursuant to sSection 18.95.040 of this chapter does not preclude an 5417 application for waiver pursuant to this section. The board shall have the authority to grant a 5418 waiver from the requirements of this chapter only if it makes the following findings in writing: 5419 A. Literal enforcement of this chapter would cause unreasonable hardship for the 5420 applicant that is not necessary to carry out the general purpose of this chapter; 5421 B. There are special circumstances attached to the project that do not generally apply 5422 to other projects that are subject to this chapter; 5423 C. The waiver would not have a substantially negative effect on the master plans, 5424 policies, and resolutions of the city and would not be contrary to the purposes of this chapter; 5425 D. Any asserted economic hardship is not self-imposed; and 5426 E. The spirit of this chapter will be observed and substantial justice done. 5427 5428 18.95.060: APPEAL OF CITY DECISIONS: 5429 Appeals of decisions by the building official or enforcement officials pursuant to this chapter 5430 shall be taken in accordance with Chapter 18.12.Any private sector developer who is denied an 5431 exception, or a determination of substantial compliance, or who is assessed a penalty by the 5432 building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer, may appeal such 5433 decision in writing to the board within thirty (30) days of the decision and shall state the basis to 5434 support the relief sought. The board shall review the circumstances of the appeal and shall issue 5435 a written determination of the receipt of the appeal within thirty (30) days consistent with the 5436 requirements of this section. 5437 5438 18.95.070: RESERVEDAPPEAL OF BOARD DECISIONS: 5439 Any private sector developer denied a waiver by the board or denied an exception, or 5440 determination of substantial compliance, or who has had financial penalties imposed on appeal to 5441 the board under this chapter may appeal such decision by the board in writing to the mayor or the 5442 mayor's designee within thirty (30) days of the decision and shall state the basis to support the 5443 relief sought. The mayor or the mayor's designee shall review the circumstances of the appeal 5444 and shall issue a written determination within thirty (30) days of the receipt of the appeal 5445 consistent with the requirements of this section. 5446 5447 18.95.080: REQUIRED DEPOSIT: 151 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5448 All private sector developers, excluding nonprofit developers, who receive city funds for 5449 applicable building projects shall submit a ten thousand dollar ($10,000.00) "good faith" deposit 5450 with the city which shall be refunded upon the building project receiving the applicable level of 5451 LEED certification or after a determination of substantial compliance. 5452 5453 18.95.090: PROOF OF REGISTRATION: 5454 Within thirty (30) days from receiving notice that the city will fund an applicable building 5455 project, all private sector developers shall submit written proof that said project is registered with 5456 the USGBC. City funds will not be dispersed until the required deposit under sSection 18.95.080 5457 of this chapter and the proof of registration under this section are received by the city. 5458 5459 18.95.100: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION: 5460 If a project is not LEED certified or has not been granted a determination of substantial 5461 compliance within one year after a temporary certificate of occupancy is issued by the city, then 5462 a private sector developer must file a written application with the city for an extension to obtain 5463 LEED certification. Said application must be filed with the city no later than three hundred 5464 ninety five (395) days after the date on which the certificate of occupancy was issued by the city. 5465 The city may grant a one year extension pursuant to this section and any additional extensions as 5466 may be necessary so long as a private sector developer is actively pursuing LEED certification. 5467 Extensions pursuant to this section shall begin on the date granted by the city. 5468 5469 18.95.110: REQUEST FOR SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: 5470 Receipt of LEED certification from the USGBC shall be conclusive evidence of the level of 5471 certification stated therein. If certification is not received from the USGBC or is not at the level 5472 required by this chapter, a private sector developer may request that the city issue a 5473 determination that the project has substantially complied with this chapter upon a reasonable 5474 demonstration that such project as constructed is consistent with the intent of this chapter and 5475 that strict enforcement of this chapter would create an unreasonable burden in light of the needs 5476 of such project, the ability of the project owner to control cost increases, and other relevant 5477 circumstances. The request for determination of substantial compliance must contain the 5478 following information: 5479 A. Final LEED certification application, documentation, and response from the 5480 USGBC; 5481 B. An explanation of the efforts and accomplishments made by the private sector 5482 developer to achieve compliance with this chapter; 5483 C. An explanation of the practical or economic infeasibility of implementing certain 5484 high performance building design or construction techniques that, if implemented, would 5485 otherwise have likely resulted in certification; and 152 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5486 D. Any other supporting documents the private sector developer wishes to submit. 5487 5488 18.95.120: DETERMINATION OF SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: 5489 The building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer shall review 5490 within sixty (60) days of receipt of a request for determination of substantial compliance and 5491 shall approve or deny the request based on the good faith efforts of the private sector developer 5492 to comply with this chapter. In making a determination of the good faith efforts, review of the 5493 request shall include whether the private sector developer has established the following: 5494 A. That reasonable, appropriate, and ongoing efforts to comply with this chapter 5495 were taken; and 5496 B. That compliance would otherwise have been obtained but for the practical or 5497 economic infeasibility of implementing high performance building design or construction 5498 techniques. 5499 In making any such determination, cost increases due solely to aesthetic elements shall not 5500 constitute any part of a demonstration of unreasonable burden. A determination of substantial 5501 compliance pursuant to this section shall satisfy sSection 18.95.030 of this chapter. 5502 If the request for determination of substantial compliance is denied, the private sector developer 5503 will be deemed to have not satisfied sSection 18.95.030 of this chapter and shall forfeit the "good 5504 faith" deposit under sSection 18.95.080 of this chapter and may be assessed an additional penalty 5505 up to the amount originally funded by the city. Any penalty assessed shall be offset by the "good 5506 faith" deposit. 5507 5508 18.95.130: PENALTY: 5509 Any private sector developer who fails to: a) comply with this chapter, b) apply for an extension 5510 pursuant to sSection 18.95.100 of this chapter, or c) receive a determination of substantial 5511 compliance, shall forfeit the "good faith" deposit to the city to cover the cost and inconvenience 5512 to the city. An additional penalty may be assessed based on a direct analysis of possible LEED 5513 design credits. Given that a total of twenty six (26) LEED design credits are required for 5514 certification, the additional penalty shall be based on the following considerations: 5515 A. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 21-25 LEED 5516 credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to twenty five percent (25%) of the 5517 amount originally funded. 5518 B. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 16-20 LEED 5519 credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to fifty percent (50%) of the 5520 amount originally funded. 5521 C. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 6-15 LEED 5522 credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to seventy five percent (75%) of 5523 the amount originally funded. 153 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5524 D. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 0-5 LEED 5525 credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to one hundred percent (100%) of 5526 the amount originally funded. 5527 Failure to pay a penalty within ninety (90) days of written notice from the city shall result in a 5528 lien against the project. 5529 5530 18.95.140: RULE MAKING AUTHORIZATION: 5531 The building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer are authorized 5532 to issue administrative rules under this chapter. 5533 5534 18.95.150: ADMINISTRATIVE INTERPRETATIONS: 5535 Pursuant to the authority granted under sSubsection 18.0850.040KB of this title, the building 5536 official may render interpretations of this chapter. Such interpretations shall conform with the 5537 intent and purpose of this chapter, and shall be made available in writing for public inspection 5538 upon request. 5539 5540 18.95.160: LIMITATIONS: 5541 Nothing required under this chapter shall supersede any federal, state or local law, including, 5542 without limitation, other provisions of this code; or any contract, grant, or other funding 5543 requirement; or other standards or restrictions that may otherwise apply to an applicable building 5544 project. This chapter shall not apply whenever its application would disadvantage the city in 5545 obtaining federal funds. 5546 5547 SECTION 19. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.96. That Chapter 5548 18.96 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Fit Premises) shall be, and hereby is 5549 amended as follows: 5550 5551 CHAPTER 18.96 5552 FIT PREMISES 5553 5554 18.96.010: TITLE: 5555 This chapter may be referred to as the SALT LAKE CITY FIT PREMISES ORDINANCE. 154 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5556 5557 18.96.020: EXCLUSIONS FROM APPLICATION OF CHAPTER: 5558 The following arrangements are not governed by this chapter: 5559 A. Residence at a detention, medical, geriatric, educational, counseling, or religious 5560 institution; 5561 B. Occupancy under a contract of sale of a dwelling unit if the occupant is the 5562 purchaser; 5563 C. Occupancy by a member of a fraternal or social organization in a building 5564 operated for the benefit of the organization; 5565 D. Transient occupancy in a hotel, or motel (or lodgings subject to Utah code section 5566 59-12-301); except that single room occupancy units ("SRO") shall be governed by this chapter. 5567 "SRO" means an existing housing unit with one combined sleeping and living room of at least 5568 seventy (70) square feet, but of not more than two hundred twenty (220) square feet, where the 5569 usual tenancy or occupancy of the same unit by the same person or persons is for a period of 5570 longer than one week. Such units may include a kitchen and a private bath; and 5571 E. Occupancy by an owner of a condominium unit. 5572 5573 18.96.030: IDENTIFICATION OF OWNER AND AGENTS: 5574 A. A property owner, or any person authorized to enter into an oral or written rental 5575 agreement on the property owner's behalf, shall disclose to the tenant in writing at or before the 5576 commencement of the tenancy the name, address and telephone number of: 5577 1. The owner or person authorized to manage the premises; and 5578 2. A local person authorized to act for and on behalf of the owner for the 5579 purpose of receiving notices and demands, and performing the property owner's 5580 obligations under this chapter and the rental agreement if the owner or manager reside 5581 outside of Salt Lake City. 5582 B. A person who enters into a rental agreement as “landlord”, “property manager” or 5583 the like, and fails to comply with the requirements of this section becomes an agent of the 5584 property owner for the purposes of: 5585 1. Receipt of notices under this chapter; and 5586 2. Performing the obligations of the property owner under this chapter and 5587 under the rental agreement. 5588 C. The information required to be furnished by this section shall be kept current. 5589 This section is enforceable against any successor property owner, owner, or manager. 155 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5590 D. Every rental property with more than one unit rented without a written agreement 5591 shall have a notice posted in a conspicuous place with the name, address and telephone number 5592 of the owner or manager and local agent as required by subsection A of this section. 5593 5594 18.96.040: PROPERTY OWNER TO DELIVER POSSESSION OF DWELLING UNIT: 5595 A. A copy of the lease or rental agreement, rules and regulations, an inventory of the 5596 condition of the premises, a list of all appliances and furnishings and a summary of this chapter 5597 shall be given to each tenant at the time the rental agreement is entered into. The summary shall 5598 be prepared by the city for the purpose of fairly setting forth the material provisions of this 5599 chapter and shall include information about mediation resources in the Salt Lake City area and 5600 shall encourage property owners and tenants to take advantage of mediation services. The 5601 property owner shall secure and retain the tenant's signed acknowledgment that the foregoing 5602 documents have been provided to the tenant. Such acknowledgment shall be returned to the 5603 property owner no later than three (3) days after the tenant takes possession of the dwelling unit. 5604 Before entering into a rental agreement, the property owner shall disclose to the tenant any 5605 current notice by a utility provider to terminate water, gas, electrical or other utility service to the 5606 dwelling unit or to common areas of the building, the proposed date of termination, and any 5607 current uncorrected building or health code violation included in a deficiency list or notice from 5608 the Salt Lake City building and housing servicesdivision or any other government entity. 5609 B. By explicit written agreement, a property owner and a tenant may establish a 5610 procedure whereby the tenant notifies the property owner of needed repairs, makes those repairs 5611 and deducts the cost of the repairs from the rent due and owing. 5612 C. A property owner may allocate any duties to the tenant by explicit written 5613 agreement. Such agreement must be clear and specific, boxed, in bold type or underlined. 5614 5615 18.96.050: PROPERTY OWNER TO MAINTAIN THE PREMISES AND EACH 5616 DWELLING UNIT: 5617 A property owner shall: 5618 A. Comply with the requirements of applicable building, housing and health codes 5619 and city ordinances and not rent the premises unless they are safe, sanitary, and fit for human 5620 occupancy; 5621 B. Maintain the structural integrity of the building; 5622 C. Maintain floors in compliance with safe load bearing requirements; 5623 D. Provide exits, emergency egress, and light and ventilation in compliance with 5624 applicable codes; 5625 E. Maintain stairways, porches, walkways and fire escapes in sound condition; 5626 F. Provide smoke detectors and fire extinguisher as required by code; 156 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5627 G. Provide operable sinks, toilets, tubs and/or showers; 5628 H. Provide heating facilities as required by code; 5629 I. Provide kitchen facilities as required; 5630 J. Provide running water; 5631 K. Provide adequate hall and stairway lighting; 5632 L. Maintain floors, walls and ceilings in good condition; 5633 M. Supply window screens where required by code; 5634 N. Maintain foundation, masonry, chimneys, water heater and furnace in good 5635 working condition; 5636 O. Prevent the accumulation of stagnant water in the interior of any premises; 5637 P. Maintain in good and safe working order and condition all electrical, plumbing, 5638 sanitary, heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and other facilities and appliances supplied by the 5639 property owner as required by applicable codes; 5640 Q. Provide and maintain appropriate garbage receptacles and arrange for timely 5641 garbage removal as required by code; 5642 R. Supply electricity, and hot water at all times and heat during at least the months of 5643 October through April and as weather conditions might otherwise reasonably warrant, except 5644 where the dwelling unit is so constructed that electricity, heat or hot water is within the exclusive 5645 control of the tenant and supplied by a direct public utility connection; 5646 S. Once proof of pest infestation has been established, be responsible for initiation of 5647 pest control measures. In no instance shall a property owner be required to apply pesticides 5648 contrary to label directions; 5649 T. Not interrupt or disconnect utility service; 5650 U. Provide adequate locks to exterior doors and furnish keys to tenants as required 5651 by applicable codes; 5652 V. Maintain the dwelling unit in a reasonably insulated and weather tight condition 5653 as required by the building and housing and Utah state energy conservation codes; 5654 W. Provide for and protect each tenant's peaceful enjoyment of the premises; 5655 X. Ensure that repairs, decorations, alterations, or improvements, or exhibiting the 5656 dwelling unit shall not unreasonably interfere with the tenants' right to quiet enjoyment of the 5657 premises; 5658 Y. Provide a mailbox; and 5659 Z. Provide separate meters for each tenant for gas and electricity or include charges 5660 for utility services in the rent. 157 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5661 5662 18.96.060: TENANT TO MAINTAIN DWELLING UNIT: 5663 A tenant shall: 5664 A. Comply with all appropriate requirements of the rental agreement and applicable 5665 provisions of building, housing and health codes; 5666 B. Maintain the premises occupied in a clean and safe condition and not 5667 unreasonably burden any common area; 5668 C. Dispose of all garbage and other waste in a clean and safe manner and avoid 5669 leaving garbage or litter in hallways, porches, patios and other common areas; 5670 D. Maintain all plumbing fixtures in as sanitary a condition as the fixtures permit and 5671 avoid obstructing sinks, toilets, tubs, showers and other plumbing drains; 5672 E. Use all electrical, plumbing, sanitary, heating, and other facilities and appliances 5673 in a reasonable manner; 5674 F. Not destroy, deface, damage, impair or remove any part of the premises or 5675 knowingly permit any person to do so; 5676 G. Promptly inform the property owner of any defective conditions or problems at 5677 the premises; 5678 H. Not interfere with the peaceful enjoyment of the residential rental unit of another 5679 renter; 5680 I. Upon vacation, restore the premises to their initial condition except for reasonable 5681 wear and tear or conditions caused by the property owner; 5682 J. Be current on all payments required by the rental agreement and this chapter; 5683 K. Not increase the number of occupants above that specified in the rental agreement 5684 without written permission of the owners; 5685 L. Not modify or paint the premises without the express written permission of the 5686 property owner/agent; 5687 M. Dispose of oil, car batteries, and other hazardous waste materials away from the 5688 rental premises, and in a manner prescribed by federal and local laws; and 5689 N. Not require the owner to correct or remedy any condition caused by the renter, the 5690 renter's family or the renter's guests or invites by inappropriate use of the property during the 5691 rental term or any extension of it. 5692 5693 18.96.070: RULES AND REGULATIONS: 158 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5694 A property owner may adopt rules or regulations concerning the tenant's use and occupancy of 5695 the premises which become a part of the rental agreement if they apply to all tenants in the 5696 premises in a nondiscriminatory manner, do not conflict with the lease, state law or city 5697 ordinance, and are provided to the tenant before the tenant enters into the rental agreement. 5698 Rules, regulations or lease terms can, by agreement between the parties, be more favorable to the 5699 tenant than allowed by state law or city ordinance but cannot be more restrictive. Rules may be 5700 modified from time to time by the property owner. However, no rule adopted after the 5701 commencement of any rental agreement shall substantially modify the existing terms, conditions 5702 or rules without written consent of the tenant. 5703 5704 18.96.080: ACCESS: 5705 A. A tenant shall not unreasonably withhold consent to the property owner to enter 5706 into the dwelling unit in order to make necessary or agreed repairs, decorations, alterations, or 5707 improvements; or exhibit the dwelling unit to prospective purchasers, tenants, or work people. 5708 B. A property owner may enter the dwelling unit without consent of the tenant in 5709 case of emergency. 5710 C. Except in case of emergency the property owner shall give the tenant at least 5711 twenty four (24) hours' notice of plans to enter and may enter only between eight o'clock (8:00) 5712 A.M. and ten o'clock (10:00) P.M. 5713 D. A property owner has no other right of access except: 5714 1. Pursuant to court order; 5715 2. To make repairs requested by the tenant pursuant to sSections 18.96.110 5716 and 18.96.120 of this chapter; 5717 3. To make repairs ordered by the division pursuant to this title; or 5718 4.3. If the tenant has abandoned the premises as defined in sSection 78B-36- 5719 81412(3), Utah Code Annotated, or any successor provision. 5720 5721 18.96.090: RESERVEDPROPERTY OWNER AND TENANT REMEDIES FOR ABUSE 5722 OF ACCESS: 5723 A. If the tenant refuses to allow lawful access, the property owner may obtain 5724 injunctive relief to compel access, or terminate the rental agreement and commence an eviction 5725 action. In either case, the property owner may recover actual damages and reasonable attorney 5726 fees. 5727 B. If the property owner makes an unlawful entry or makes repeated demands for 5728 entry which harass the tenant, the tenant may obtain injunctive relief to prevent the recurrence of 5729 the conduct or terminate the rental agreement and vacate the premises. In either case, the tenant 159 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5730 may recover the lesser of the actual damages or damages equal to one month's rent and 5731 reasonable attorney fees. 5732 5733 18.96.100: RESERVEDFAILURE TO DELIVER POSSESSION: 5734 If the property owner fails to deliver possession of the dwelling unit to the tenant as promised in 5735 the rental agreement, rent abates until possession is delivered. Alternatively, the tenant may 5736 terminate the rental agreement by written notice to the property owner and recover all prepaid 5737 rent and security deposits and actual damages. 5738 5739 18.96.110: REPAIR OF SPECIFIED FAILURES: 5740 In the event of the failures specified below, which are not due to the unavailability of utility 5741 service, the property owner shall take reasonable steps to begin repairing the failures 5742 promptlywithin the following specified time periods after receipt of written notice of the failure 5743 delivered in accordance with Section 18.50.100to the person identified in subsection 5744 18.96.030A2 of this chapter, and shall remedy such failurecomplete the repairs within the period 5745 set forth in the notice and order issued by the inspector reasonable diligence: A.Inoperable toilet 24 hours B.Tub, shower or kitchen and bathroom sink with inoperable drain or no hot or cold water 48 hours C.Inoperable refrigerator or cooking range or stove 48 hours D.Nonfunctioning heating (during a period where heat is reasonably necessary) or electrical system 24 hours E.Inoperable electric fixture 72 hours F.Broken exterior door or inoperable or missing exterior door lock 48 hours G.Broken window with missing glass 96 hours H.Inoperable exterior lighting 96 hours I.Broken stair or balustrade 24 hours J.Inoperable or missing smoke detector required by code 24 hours K.Inoperable required fire sprinkler system (if smoke detectors are not present or operating) 24 hours 160 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT L.Inoperable required fire sprinkler system (if smoke detectors are installed and operable) 96 hours M.Broken or leaking water pipes causing an imminent threat to life, safety or health 24 hours N.Other broken or leaking water pipes 72 hours O.Disconnection of electrical, water or natural gas service caused by property owner 24 hours 5747 5748 The division shall establish repair period standards based on the severity of the failures identified 5749 above. The tenant shall grant the property owner reasonable access to perform the repairs 5750 required in this section. 5751 5752 18.96.120: VIOLATIONSTENANT REPAIR AND DEDUCT: 5753 Violations of this chapter shall be enforced pursuant to Sections 18.50.100 and 18.50.110.If the 5754 property owner fails to begin making the repairs required by section 18.96.110 of this chapter, 5755 within the specified times, and the tenant is current on all rent and other payments to the property 5756 owner, the tenant may cause the repairs to be made subject to the following provisions: 5757 A. Critical Repairs: If the repairs involve an inoperable toilet, lack of heat during a 5758 period for which heat is required, broken or leaking water pipes posing an immediate threat to 5759 life, safety or health or a complete lack of running water or disconnected gas, electric or water 5760 service, the tenant may, upon the expiration of the notice period specified in section 18.96.110 of 5761 this chapter, cause the necessary repairs to be made. 5762 1. In making such repairs the tenant must use a licensed contractor if such a 5763 licensed contractor is required by applicable building or housing codes. 5764 2. If a licensed contractor is required for the work, the tenant shall make 5765 reasonable efforts to obtain two (2) bids for the work and, if bids are obtained, shall 5766 contract for the work to be done by the lowest bidder. 5767 B. Noncritical Repairs: If the required repairs are not critical repairs subject to the 5768 provisions of subsection A of this section, the tenant, after the expiration of the notice time 5769 required by section 18.96.110 of this chapter, shall give the property owner or property owner's 5770 agent identified in section 18.96.030 of this chapter a second written notice of intent to repair and 5771 deduct. This second notice shall be either delivered and served personally upon the property 5772 owner or agent or sent by both certified and regular mail. 5773 1. The second notice shall state the nature of the problem, the date the tenant 5774 sent the first notice required by section 18.96.110 of this chapter, and the intention of the 161 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5775 tenant to cause the repairs to be done and to deduct the cost from the rent if the property 5776 owner does not make the repairs. 5777 2. The property owner shall begin making the required repairs within forty 5778 eight (48) hours after the hand delivery of the second notice or by the end of the second 5779 calendar day after the date of mailing of the second notice and complete the repairs with 5780 reasonable diligence. 5781 3. If the property owner has not begun the required repairs within the time 5782 specified in subsection B2 of this section, the tenant may cause the repairs to be made. 5783 4. In making such repairs the tenant must use a licensed contractor if such a 5784 licensed contractor is required by applicable building or housing codes. 5785 5. If a licensed contractor is required for the work, the tenant shall make 5786 reasonable efforts to obtain two (2) bids for the work, and, if bids are obtained, shall 5787 contract for the work with the low bidder. 5788 6. If a licensed contractor is not required for the work, the tenant may do the 5789 work on his or her own or contract for the work to be done at a reasonable cost. 5790 C. Deductible Amount: For any repairs made pursuant to this section, the tenant may 5791 deduct from future rent the actual and reasonable cost of the repairs performed up to a maximum 5792 deduction of four hundred dollars ($400.00); provided however, tenant shall furnish all original 5793 paid receipts to the property owner. 5794 D. Nontermination: The property owner may not terminate the tenant's tenancy for 5795 the tenant's deduction of rent for repairs made pursuant to this section nor may the property 5796 owner terminate the tenancy until the tenant's costs, not to exceed four hundred dollars 5797 ($400.00), for repairs made under this section have been offset by deducted rent. 5798 E. Tenant Caused Damages: The repair and deduct provisions of this section shall 5799 not be applicable to any damages caused or repairs necessitated by actions of the tenant or the 5800 tenant's invited guests or other occupants of the dwelling unit. 5801 5802 18.96.130: RETALIATORY CONDUCT PROHIBITED: 5803 A. Except as provided in this section and section 57-22-4, Utah Code Annotated, a 5804 property owner may not terminate a rental agreement or bring or threaten to bring an eviction 5805 action because the tenant has in good faith: 5806 1. Complained of code violations at the premises to a governmental agency, 5807 elected representative or public official charged with responsibility for enforcement of a 5808 building, housing, health or similar code; 5809 2. Complained of a building, housing, health or similar code violation or an 5810 illegal property owner practice to a community organization or the news media; 162 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5811 3. Sought the assistance of a community organization or the news media to 5812 remedy code violation or illegal property owner practice; 5813 4. Requested the property owner to make repairs to the premises as required 5814 by this chapter, a building or health code, other regulation, or the residential rental 5815 agreement; 5816 5. Become a member of a tenants' union or similar organization; 5817 6. Testified in any court or administrative proceeding concerning the 5818 condition of the premises; or 5819 7. Exercised any right or remedy provided by law. 5820 5821 SECTION 20. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 21A.20. That Chapter 5822 21A.20 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Enforcement) shall be, and hereby is amended as 5823 follows: 5824 21A.20.010: RESERVEDDEFINED TERMS: 5825 In this chapter, the words, terms, phrases and their derivatives shall have the meanings as stated 5826 and defined in this chapter. 5827 CITATION DEADLINE: The date identified in the second notice of violation described in 5828 subsection 21A.20.030E of this chapter. 5829 CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER: An employee of Salt Lake City's Division of Building 5830 Services, or of the successor Salt Lake City division authorized to perform civil enforcement 5831 functions, or any duly authorized agent, representative or designee. 5832 DIVISION: Salt Lake City's Division of Building Services, or the successor Salt Lake City 5833 division authorized to perform civil enforcement functions. 5834 FIRST NOTICE: The initial notice informing the person cited that a zoning violation exists. 5835 NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE: A written notice informing the person cited that the violation has 5836 been cured. 5837 PERSON CITED: The property owner, property owner's agent, tenant or occupant of any 5838 building or land or part thereof and any architect, builder, contractor, agent or other person who 5839 participates in, assists, directs or creates any situation that is contrary to the requirements of this 5840 title, and who received the notice of violation and is being held responsible for the violation. 5841 PROPERTY OWNER: Any person who, alone or jointly or severally with others, holds legal 5842 title to the property at issue. 163 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5843 SECOND NOTICE: The notice informing the person cited of the date that civil fines will begin 5844 to accrue if the zoning violation is not corrected. 5845 5846 21A.20.020: COMPLAINTS REGARDING VIOLATIONS: 5847 A Ccivil Eenforcement Oofficer may investigate any complaint alleging a violation of this title 5848 and take such action as is warranted in accordance with the procedures set forth in this chapter. 5849 5850 21A.20.030: PROCEDURES UPON DISCOVERY OF VIOLATIONS: 5851 A. If the Ccivil Eenforcement Oofficer finds that any provision of this title is being 5852 violated, the Ccivil Eenforcement Oofficer may provide a written warning notice to the property 5853 owner and any other person determined to be responsible for such violation. The written notice 5854 shall indicate the nature of the violation and order the action necessary to correct it. Additional 5855 written notices may be provided at the Ccivil Eenforcement Oofficer's discretion. 5856 B. The written warning notice shall state what action the building services division 5857 intends to take if the violation is not corrected. The written notice shall include information 5858 regarding the established warning period for the indicated violations and shall serve to start any 5859 warning periods provided in this chapter. 5860 C. Such written warning notice issued by the Ccivil Eenforcement Oofficer, if 5861 issued, shall be deemed sufficient and complete delivered when: 5862 1. A copy of the written notice is posted on the property where said violation(s) 5863 occur, and 5864 2. The written notice is either: 5865 a. Mailed certified mail or using any reputable mail tracking service that is 5866 capable of confirming delivery commercial courier service to the property owner at the 5867 last known address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder and any 5868 other person determined to be responsible for such violation, at their last known address, 5869 or 5870 b. Personally served upon the property owner and any other person 5871 determined to be responsible for such violation. 5872 D. In cases when delay in enforcement would seriously threaten the effective 5873 enforcement of this title, or pose a danger to the public health, safety or welfare, the Ccivil 5874 Eenforcement Oofficer may seek enforcement without issuing a warning notice and may proceed 5875 directly to issuing a notice and order as set forth in Subpart Eprior written notice by invoking any 5876 of the civil fines or remedies authorized in section 21A.20.060 of this chapter. 5877 E. Upon discovery of a violation of this title, or iIf the violation remains 5878 uncorrecteduncured within five (5) business days of theafter expiration of the warning period set 5879 forth in the warning notice, if issued, described in subsections A through C of this section, a 164 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5880 second notice of violation shall be delivered by mailing, postage prepaid, addressed to the person 5881 cited at the last known address appearing on the records of the County Recorder. The second 5882 notice shall identify the citation deadline and state that the civil fines set forth in section 5883 21A.20.040 of this chapter will begin to accrue if the violations are not remedied by that date. the 5884 civil enforcement officer may issue a notice and order. 5885 1. The written notice and order shall state: 5886 a. The name and address, if known, of the responsible party; 5887 b. The date and location of each violation; 5888 c. The code sections violated; 5889 d. That the violations must be corrected; 5890 e. Provide a specific date by which the enforcement official orders 5891 that the violations be corrected by; 5892 f. The amount of the civil fine to accrue for each violation, or other 5893 enforcement action that the enforcement official intends to pursue, if the violation 5894 is not corrected by the date specified; 5895 g. Identification of the right to and procedure to appeal; and 5896 h. The signature of the enforcement official. 5897 5898 2. The enforcement official shall serve the notice and order on the 5899 responsible party by: 5900 a. Posting a copy of the written notice and order on the noncompliant 5901 property, and 5902 b. By mailing the notice and order through certified mail or reputable 5903 mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery. If the responsible 5904 party is the property owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known 5905 address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. If the 5906 responsible party is any other person or entity other than the owner of record, then 5907 mailing shall be to the last known address of the responsible party on file with the 5908 city. 5909 c. Notwithstanding the foregoing, personal service upon the 5910 responsible party shall be sufficient to meet the notice and order service 5911 requirements of this Subsection 21A.20.030.E.2.b. 5912 5913 F. Following the issuance of a notice and order, any responsible party shall correct 5914 the violations specified in the notice and order. Upon correction of the violations specified in the 5915 notice and order, the responsible party shall contact the enforcement official identified in the 5916 notice and order to request an inspection of the property. 5917 5918 G. If one or more violations are not corrected by the deadline specified in the notice 5919 and order, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set forth in Section 21A.20.040. Accumulation of 5920 civil fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of civil fines already accrued, shall 5921 stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed through an inspection requested pursuant 5922 to Subsection E. 165 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5923 5924 H. The responsible party shall have the right to contest the notice and order at an 5925 administrative hearing in accordance with Chapter 21A.16. Failure to timely request an 5926 administrative hearing and pay the administrative hearing fee set forth in the Salt Lake City 5927 consolidated fee schedule shall constitute a waiver of the right to a hearing and a waiver of the 5928 right to appeal. 5929 5930 I. Upon expiration of the citation period set forth in a notice and order, and where 5931 the violation(s) remain uncorrected, the city may record on the noncompliant property with the 5932 Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of noncompliance. The recordation of a notice of 5933 noncompliance shall not be deemed an encumbrance on the noncompliant property but shall 5934 merely place interested parties on notice of any continuing violation of this title at the 5935 noncompliant property. If a notice of noncompliance has been recorded and the enforcement 5936 official later determines that all violations identified in the notice of noncompliance have been 5937 corrected, the enforcement official shall issue a notice of compliance by recording the notice of 5938 compliance on the property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office. Recordation of the 5939 notice of compliance shall have the effect of canceling the recorded notice of noncompliance. 5940 5941 J. If the city files an action for injunctive relief seeking abatement of one or more 5942 violations and the district court authorizes the abatement of one or more violations and the city 5943 incurs costs and the costs are not paid, a lien or garnishment may be placed to recover the costs 5944 and may be considered an encumbrance on the property. 5945 5946 21A.20.040: CIVIL FINES: 5947 A. General: If the violations are not corrected by the citation deadline, civil fines shall 5948 accrue at twenty five dollars ($25.00) $50 a day per violation for those properties legally 5949 used for purposes that are solely residential uses, and one hundred dollars ($2100.00) a 5950 day per violation for those properties used for purposes that are not residential uses. Fines 5951 for violations pertaining to use of a dwelling unit shall be per dwelling unit. 5952 B. Affordable housing incentives per 21A.52.050: If the violation(s) are not corrected by the 5953 citation deadline, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set in the Consolidated Fee Schedule 5954 per day per violation. If the violation(s) include renting an affordable rental unit in excess 5955 of the approved rental rate then an additional monthly fine shall accrue that is the 5956 difference between the market rate of the unit and the approved rental rate that is agreed 5957 to by the applicant at the time of approval for a project using the incentives. 5958 C. Failure to obtain certificate of appropriateness per 21A.34.020: For development or any 5959 building activity on properties subject to Section 21A.34.020 without a certificate of 5960 appropriateness, if such violation is not corrected by the citation deadline, civil fines shall 5961 accrue at $50 per day, except that the fine shall be $250 per day for full or partial 5962 demolition of a contributing structure without a certificate of appropriateness and $500 5963 per day for full or partial demolition of a landmark site without a certificate of 5964 appropriateness. 166 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 5965 21A.20.050: DAILY VIOLATIONS: 5966 Each day a violation continues after the citation deadline shall be considered a separate offense 5967 and give rise to a separate civil fine. Accumulation of civil fines for violations, but not the 5968 obligation for payment of civil fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation. 5969 5970 21A.20.060: COMPLIANCE: 5971 The Ccity may use such lawful means as are available to obtain compliance with the provisions 5972 of this title and to collect the civil fines that accrue as a result of the violation of the provisions of 5973 this title, including a legal action to obtain one or more of the following: an injunction, an order 5974 of mandamus, an order requiring the property owner or occupant to abate the violations, an order 5975 permitting the Ccity to enter the property to abate the violations, and a judgment in the amount of 5976 the civil fines accrued for the violation, including costs and attorney fees. The city has sole 5977 discretion over which remedy or combination of remedies it may choose to pursue. 5978 Violations of the provisions of this title or failure to comply with any of its requirements are 5979 punishable as a Class BC misdemeanor upon conviction. 5980 5981 21A.20.070: RECURRING VIOLATIONS: 5982 In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, reoccurs at the same property within six 5983 (6) months of the initial correction and is due to the actions or inactions of the same person or 5984 property owner as the prior violation(s), the building services division may begin enforcement of 5985 said recurring violation by sending by certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is 5986 capable of confirming delivery a Nnotice and Oorder in the form described in sSubsection 5987 21A.20.030.EB of this chapter. Civil fines set forth in sSection 21A.020.040 of this chapter will 5988 begin accruing, if the violation is not remedied within ten (10) calendar days of the citation 5989 deadline contained in that notice. 5990 5991 21A.20.080: APPEALING CIVIL FINES TO A FINES HEARING OFFICER: 5992 A. Powers Aand Duties Oof Fines Hearing Officer: The Ffines Hhearing Oofficer, 5993 appointed pursuant to sSection 21A.06.090 of this title, may hear and decide appeals of civil 5994 fines imposed pursuant to this chapter. As set forth in this section, the Ffines Hhearing Oofficer 5995 may reduce civil fines and approve civil fine payment schedules. 5996 B. Right Tto Appear: Any person receiving a notice of violation may appear before a 5997 Ffines Hhearing Oofficer to appeal the amount of the civil fine imposed by submitting a civil 5998 fine appeal on a form provided by the building services division. However, no party may appear 5999 before a Ffines Hhearing Oofficer until violations from which the civil fines stemmedidentified 6000 have been corrected and a notice of compliance has been issued. Appeals to a Ffines Hhearing 6001 Oofficer contesting the amount of the civil fine imposed, must be filed within thirty (30) days 6002 from the date of the notice of compliance. 167 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6003 C. Responsibility: Commencement of any action to remove or reduce civil fines shall 6004 not relieve the responsibility of any person cited to correctcure the violation or make payment of 6005 subsequently accrued civil fines nor shall it require the Ccity to reissue any of the notices 6006 required by this chapter. 6007 D. Reduction Oof Civil Fine: Civil fines may be reduced at the discretion of the 6008 Ffines Hhearing Oofficer after the violation is correctedcured from which the civil fines 6009 stemmed and if any of the following conditions exist: 6010 1. The violation pertains to landscaping, in which case the time for payment 6011 and correction of landscaping violations may be abated from October 15 through the next 6012 April 1, or such other times as caused by weather conditions adverse to successful 6013 landscaping; 6014 2. Strict compliance with the notice and order would have caused an 6015 imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property; 6016 3. The violation and inability to curecorrect the same were both caused by a 6017 force majeure event such as war, act of nature, strike or civil disturbance; 6018 4. A change in the actual ownership of the property was recorded with the 6019 Salt Lake County Recorder's Office after the first or second notice was issued and the 6020 new property owner is not related by blood, marriage or common ownership to the prior 6021 owner; or 6022 5. Such other mitigating circumstances as determined by the Ffines Hhearing 6023 Oofficer. 6024 E. Payment Schedule: At the request of a person subject to civil fines governed by 6025 this chapter, the Ffines Hhearing Oofficer may approve a payment schedule for the delayed or 6026 periodic payment of the applicable civil fine to accommodate the person's unique circumstances 6027 or ability to pay. 6028 F. Failure Tto Submit Payment Oon Payment Schedule: If a payment schedule has 6029 been developed by the Ffines Hhearing Oofficer, the failure by a person owing civil fines to 6030 submit any two (2) payments as scheduled shall cause the entire amount of the original civil fine 6031 to become immediately due. 6032 6033 21A.20.090: NOTICE OF CITY'S INTENT TO ABATE ZONING VIOLATIONS: 6034 A. If the Ccity obtains a court order permitting entry on the property for the purpose 6035 of abating zoning violations, the building services division shall provide written notice of that 6036 order to the property owner of record at the address on file with the Salt Lake County Recorder. 6037 B. The notice shall: 1) identify the property owner of record according to the records 6038 of the Salt Lake County Recorder, 2) describe the property and the violations the court order 6039 permits the building services division to enter the property to abate, 3) attach a copy of the court 6040 order, and (4) inform the property owner when the abatement is scheduled to occur, and 4) 168 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6041 provide the property owner thirty (30) days from the date the notice is served to abate the 6042 violations the court order permits the division to enter the property to abate. 6043 C. Notice may be delivered in person, or by certified mail, or by reputable mail 6044 tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery commercial courier service, if mailed to 6045 the last known address of the property owner according to the records of the Salt Lake County 6046 Recorder. 6047 D. If the zoning violations are not corrected by the property owner within thirty (30) 6048 days of the date the notice is served, then the division may employ any necessary assistance to 6049 enter the property and abate the zoning violations, as permitted by the court order. 6050 6051 21A.20.100: COLLECTION OF THE COSTS OF ABATEMENT: 6052 A. If the building services division or an agent thereof the division enters a property 6053 to abate a violation pursuant to a court order, as set forth in sSection 21A.20.090 of this chapter, 6054 the building services division may collect the cost of that abatement, by filing a Pproperty Ttax 6055 lien, as set forth in this section. 6056 B. Upon completion of abatement work, the building services division shall prepare 6057 an itemized statement of costs and mail it to the property owner by certified mail or by any 6058 reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, demanding payment 6059 within thirty (30) days of the date the statement is post marked. 6060 C. The itemized statement of costs shall: 6061 1. Include: 6062 a. The address of the property at issue; 6063 b. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the building services 6064 division, including administrative costs; 6065 c. A demand for payment; and 6066 d. The address where payment is to be made; 6067 2. Notify the property owner: 6068 a. That failure to timely pay the expenses described in the itemized 6069 statement may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter and 6070 Utah Code section 10-11-4 or its successor; 6071 b. That the property owner may file a written objection to all or part 6072 of the statement within twenty (20) days of the date the statement is postmarked; 6073 and 6074 c. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the 6075 name of the office and the mailing address. 169 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6076 D. The itemized statement of costs described in subsection C of this section shall be 6077 deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or by any reputable mail tracking service that is 6078 capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the property owner, 6079 according to the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. 6080 E. If the property owner files a timely objection, the building services division will 6081 schedule a hearing in accordance with title 52, chapter 4 of the Utah Code (Open and Public 6082 Meetings Act), and will mail or deliver to the property owner prior to the hearing a notice stating 6083 the date, time, and location of the hearing. 6084 F. At the hearing described in subsection E of this section, a Ffines Hhearing 6085 Oofficer shall review and determine the actual cost of abatement incurred by the building 6086 services division in abating the property, including administrative costs. The property owner 6087 must pay any amount the Ffines Hhearing Oofficer determines is due and owing to the Salt Lake 6088 City Treasurer at the address provided in the statement of costs within thirty (30) days of the date 6089 of the hearing. 6090 G. If the property owner fails to make payment of the amount set forth in the 6091 itemized statement within thirty (30) days of the date of the mailing of that statement, or to file a 6092 timely objection, then the building services division may certify the past due costs and expenses 6093 to the Salt Lake County Treasurer and the Treasurer will proceed as set forth in Utah Code 6094 section 10-11-4 or its successor. 6095 H. If the property owner files a timely objection but fails to make payment of any 6096 amount found due and owing under subsection F of this section within thirty (30) days of the 6097 date of the hearing, the building services division may certify the past due costs and expense to 6098 the Salt Lake County Treasurer and the Treasurer will proceed as set forth in Utah Code section 6099 10-11-4. 6100 I. After entry by the Treasurer of the County, as set forth in subsections G and H of 6101 this section the amount entered shall be a nonrecurring notice charge as defined in Utah Code 11- 6102 60-102, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by the Salt Lake County Treasurer at the 6103 time of the payment of general taxes. 6104 J. Notwithstanding any other provision in this chapter to the contrary, where the 6105 property owner presents evidence demonstrating financial hardship to the satisfaction of the 6106 building services division, the building services division may waive some or all administrative 6107 fees and the actual costs incurred in abating the property if the property abated is the property 6108 owner's principal place of residence. 6109 6110 SECTION 21. Amending the Text of Salt Lake City Code Section 21A.62.040. That Section 6111 21A.62.040 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Definitions: Definitions of Terms), shall be and 6112 hereby is amended as follows: 170 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6113 a. Adding the definition of “CITATION DEADLINE.” That the definition of 6114 “CITATION DEADLINE” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in 6115 alphabetical order to read as follows: 6116 CITATION DEADLINE: the date identified in the notice and order to correct the 6117 violation(s) identified therein. 6118 b. Adding the definition of “CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.” That the definition 6119 of “CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER” be added and inserted into the list of 6120 definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: 6121 CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER: an employee of Salt Lake City’s Division of 6122 Building Services, or successor division, authorized to perform civil enforcement 6123 functions, or any duly authorized agent, representative, or designee. 6124 c. Adding the definition of “NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE.” That the definition of 6125 “NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in 6126 alphabetical order to read as follows: 6127 NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE: a written notice informing the person cited that the 6128 violation has been corrected. 6129 d. Adding the definition of “PERSON CITED.” That the definition of “PERSON 6130 CITED” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read 6131 as follows: 6132 PERSON CITED: the property owner, property owner's agent, tenant or occupant of any 6133 building or land or part thereof and any architect, builder, contractor, agent or other 6134 person who participates in, assists, directs or creates any situation that is contrary to the 6135 requirements of this title, and who received the notice of violation and is being held 6136 responsible for the violation. 6137 e. Adding the definition of “PROPERTY OWNER.” That the definition of 6138 “PROPERTY OWNER” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in 6139 alphabetical order to read as follows: 171 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6140 PROPERTTY OWNER: any person who, alone or jointly or severally with others, holds 6141 legal title to the property at issue. 6142 6143 SECTION 22. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 2.07.020. That Section 6144 2.07.020 of the Salt Lake City Code is hereby amended to eliminate the “Housing advisory and 6145 appeals board” therefrom as follows: 6146 2.07.020: CITY BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS NAMED: 6147 For the purpose of this chapter the term "city board" or "board" means the following city boards, 6148 commissions, councils, and committees: 6149 Accessibility and disability commission 6150 Airport board 6151 Board of appeals and examiners 6152 Business advisory board 6153 Citizens' compensation advisory committee 6154 City and county building conservancy and use committee 6155 Community development and capital improvement programs advisory board 6156 Community recovery committee 6157 Fire code board of appeals 6158 Golf enterprise fund advisory board 6159 Historic landmark commission 6160 Housing advisory and appeals board 6161 Housing trust fund advisory board 6162 Human rights commission 6163 Library board 6164 Parks, natural lands, trails, and urban forestry advisory board 6165 Planning commission 6166 Public utilities advisory committee 6167 Racial equity in policing commission 172 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6168 Salt Lake art design board 6169 Salt Lake City arts council board 6170 Salt Lake City sister cities board 6171 Transportation advisory board 6172 6173 SECTION 23. Repealing Salt Lake City Code Chapter 2.21. That Chapter 2.21 of the Salt 6174 Lake City Code (Housing Advisory and Appeals Board) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its 6175 entirety as follows: 6176 2.21.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: 6177 The provisions of chapter 2.07 of this title shall apply to the housing advisory and appeals board 6178 except as otherwise set forth in this chapter. 6179 6180 2.21.020: CREATION AND MEMBERSHIP: 6181 A. The city creates a housing advisory and appeals board ("HAAB"). 6182 B. HAAB shall be comprised of ten (10) members from among the qualified electors of the 6183 city in a manner providing balanced geographical, professional, neighborhood and 6184 community representation. 6185 C. The HAAB chair or vice chair may not be elected to serve consecutive terms in the same 6186 office. The secretary of HAAB shall be designated by the building official. 6187 D. The expiration of terms shall be staggered with no more than three (3) terms expiring in 6188 any one year. Expiration of terms shall be on December 31. 6189 6190 2.21.030: POWERS AND AUTHORITY: 6191 HAAB shall have the power and authority to: 6192 A. Apply the provisions of Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 18.50 of this code; 6193 B. Hear and decide appeals as specified in Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 18.50 6194 of this code; 6195 C. Modify the impact of specific provisions of Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 6196 18.50 of this code, where strict compliance with the provisions is economically or 6197 structurally impracticable and any approved alternative substantially accomplishes the 6198 purpose and intent of the requirement deviated from; 173 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6199 D. Conduct housing impact hearings pursuant to Title 18, Chapter 18.64 of this code; 6200 E. Recommend new procedures to the building official and new ordinances regarding 6201 housing to the city council; and 6202 F. Hear and decide appeals as specified in Title 18, Chapter 18.48 of this code. 6203 6204 2.21.040: HAAB PANELS: 6205 Unless otherwise determined appropriate by the chair, HAAB may exercise any of its 6206 responsibilities under title 5, chapter 5.14, or title 18, chapter 18.50 of this code in panels of five 6207 (5) voting members appointed by the chair. 6208 6209 SECTION 24. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 2.80.040. That Section 6210 2.80.040 of the Salt Lake City Code (Housing Trust Fund Advisory Board: Fund Created) shall 6211 be, and hereby is amended as follows: 6212 2.80.040: FUND CREATED: 6213 6214 There is created a restricted account within the general fund, to be designated as the "Salt Lake 6215 City housing trust fund" (the "fund"). The fund shall be accounted for separately within the 6216 general fund, and the fund shall be used exclusively to assist with affordable and special 6217 needs housing in the city. No expenditures shall be made from the fund without approval of the 6218 city council. 6219 A. There shall be deposited into the fund all monies received by the city, regardless 6220 of source, which are dedicated to affordable housing and special needs housing including, but not 6221 limited to, the following: 6222 1. Grants, loan repayments, bonuses, entitlements, mitigation fees, 6223 forfeitures, donations, redevelopment tax increment income, and all other monies 6224 dedicated to affordable and special needs housing received by the city from federal, state, 6225 or local governments; 6226 2. Real property contributed to or acquired by the city under other ordinances 6227 for the purposes of preserving, developing, or restoring affordable housing; 6228 3. Monies appropriated to the fund by the council; and 6229 4. Contributions made specifically for this purpose from other public or 6230 private sources. 6231 5. CDBG, ESG, and HOPWA monies only as designated by the city's 6232 community development advisory board and approved by the mayor and city 174 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6233 council, and HOME monies only as designated by the city's housing trust fund advisory 6234 and appeals board and approved by the mayor and city council. 6235 B. The monies in the fund shall be invested by the city treasurer in accordance with 6236 the usual procedures for such special accounts. All interest or other earnings derived from fund 6237 monies shall be deposited in the fund. 6238 6239 SECTION 25. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Subsection 5.14.120.B.2. That 6240 Subsection 5.14.120.B.2 of the Salt Lake City Code (Rental Dwellings: Enforcement: Civil 6241 Penalties: Amount of Penalty) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 6242 2. Amount Oof Penalty: Civil penalties shall accrue as follows: 6243 a. Violations of the self-certification standards established by the City: Fifty 6244 dollars ($50.00) per violation per day. If more than ten (10) violations exist, 6245 the daily penalties shall double. 6246 b. Failure to obey an interpretation, decision or requirement of the Housing 6247 Advisory and Appeals Board: Twenty five dollars ($25.00) per violation per 6248 day. 6249 6250 SECTION 26. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Subsection 5.14.120.B.6. That 6251 Subsection 5.14.120.B.6 of the Salt Lake City Code (Rental Dwellings: Enforcement: Civil 6252 Penalties: Appeals) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 6253 6. Appeals: 6254 a. Appeals Contesting Tthe Existence Oof Aa Violation: 6255 (1) Appeals contesting the existence of the violation must be done in 6256 accordance with Section 18.12.030filed with the Housing Advisory and 6257 Appeals Board pursuant to section 5.14.125 of this chapter within thirty 6258 (30) days from the date the original notice of violation was issued. 6259 b. Appeals Contesting Tthe Amount Oof Tthe Penalties Imposed: any person 6260 receiving a notice of violation may appeal the civil fines imposed, but not the 6261 basis therefor (which must be done pursuant to Subsection 5.14.120.B.6.a), in 6262 accordance with Section 18.12.050. 6263 (1) The Mayor, or his/her designee, shall appoint such Hearing Officer as the 6264 Mayor, or his/her designee, deems appropriate to consider matters relating 175 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6265 to the violation of this chapter. The Hearing Officer shall have the 6266 authority to hear evidence, reduce or eliminate penalty amounts, and to 6267 make such equitable adjustments as he/she deems appropriate. 6268 (2) Any person receiving a notice of violation may appear before a Hearing 6269 Officer to appeal the amount of the penalty imposed. However, no party 6270 may appear before a Hearing Officer until violations identified have been 6271 corrected and a notice of compliance has been issued. 6272 (3) The Hearing Officer shall maintain complete and permanent records of all 6273 inspections and decisions. 6274 (4) The burden to prove any defense shall be upon the person raising such 6275 defense. 6276 (5) Commencement of any action to remove or reduce penalties shall not 6277 relieve the responsibility of any person cited to make payment of 6278 subsequently accrued civil penalties nor shall it require the City to reissue 6279 any of the notices required by this chapter. 6280 (6) The Hearing Officer may adjust, reduce or eliminate penalties or create 6281 payment plans relating to penalties accrued by the person cited. In the 6282 administration of this duty, the Hearing Officer may reduce or eliminate 6283 penalties based upon any circumstance or other equitable consideration the 6284 Hearing Officer finds to be applicable. In cases where the administrative 6285 process has not been followed by the division, the Hearing Officer has the 6286 authority to reduce or eliminate penalties. 6287 (7) Payment plans may be created by the Hearing Officer. Although the 6288 Hearing Officer has the ultimate authority in establishing the payment 6289 schedule, the minimum payment schedule provided by the Department of 6290 Community and Neighborhoods should be followed. Once a payment 6291 schedule has been developed by the Hearing Officer, and agreed to by the 6292 person cited, failure to submit any two (2) payments as scheduled will 6293 require payment of the entire amount of the original penalty immediately. 6294 6295 SECTION 27. Repealing Salt Lake City Code Section 5.14.125. That Section 5.14.125 of 6296 the Salt Lake City Code (Housing Advisory and Appeals Board Appellate Process Details) shall 6297 be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 6298 5.14.125: HOUSING ADVISORY AND APPEALS BOARD APPELLATE PROCESS 6299 DETAILS: 6300 A. Filing Of Appeals: Appeals shall be submitted on an appeal form provided by the 6301 building official. The appellant shall state the specific order or action protested and a statement 176 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6302 of the relief sought, along with the reasons why the order or action should be reversed, modified 6303 or otherwise set aside. 6304 B. Failure To Appeal: Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the 6305 provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. 6306 C. Inspection Of The Premises: Before any hearing is held by a Housing Advisory 6307 and Appeals Board panel, the panel shall inspect the building or premises involved. Prior notice 6308 of such inspection shall be given to the notified party filing the appeal, who may be present at 6309 such inspection. Upon completion of the inspection, the Chairperson of the panel shall state for 6310 the record the material facts observed at the inspection, which facts shall be read at the initiation 6311 of the hearing. Failure of the notified party to provide access without good cause as determined 6312 by the building official shall not constitute a reason for the hearing to be postponed and the 6313 appeal may be denied. 6314 D. Written Notice: Written notice of the time and place of panel hearings shall be 6315 mailed to the appellant in accordance with procedures adopted by the Housing Advisory and 6316 Appeals Board. 6317 E. Appeals Hearing: Any notified party may appear personally or authorize a 6318 designee to act in their behalf. The City and any notified party may call and examine witnesses 6319 on any relevant matter, introduce documentary and physical evidence, and cross examine 6320 opposing witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted. 6321 F. Record: A record of the entire proceeding of all appellate hearings under this 6322 section shall be made by tape recording, or by any other means of permanent recording 6323 determined to be appropriate by the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board. The record shall be 6324 retained on file in accordance with the City's record retention schedule. 6325 6326 SECTION 28. Amending the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. That the Salt 6327 Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be, and hereby is, amended, in pertinent part, to reflect 6328 the fees set forth in the attached Exhibit A, and that a copy of the amended Salt Lake City 6329 consolidated fee schedule shall be published on the official Salt Lake City website. 6330 6331 SECTION 29. Effective Date. That this ordinance shall become effective on the date of 6332 its first publication. 6333 177 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6334 Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah this ___ day of ____________ 202__. 6335 6336 ______________________________________ 6337 CHAIRPERSON 6338 6339 ATTEST: 6340 6341 _________________________ 6342 CITY RECORDER 6343 6344 6345 Transmitted to Mayor on ____________________________. 6346 6347 Mayor’s Action: _________ Approved. ____________ Vetoed. 6348 6349 6350 _______________________________________ 6351 MAYOR 6352 6353 6354 6355 6356 (SEAL) 6357 6358 Bill No. _______ of 202__. 6359 Published: __________________ 63606361 Ordinance amending Title 18 administration_v6 178 LEGISLATIVE DRAFT 6362 6363 EXHIBIT A 6364 6365 COMMUNITY AND NEIGHBORHOODS (CAN) Service Fee Additional Information Section Boarding or Securing of Buildings Boarding administrative costs $129500 Plus actual costs, see Section 18.48.100 18.48.100 Boarding registration fee Residential Years 1&2 Non-Residential Years 1&2 Residential Years 3-5 Non-Residential Years 3-5 Residential Years 6 or more Non-Residential Years 6 or more $1,546 $3,000 $6,000 $6,000 $9,000 $9,000 $14,000 Per parcel 18.48.215 Boarding registration fee for a contributing structure or landmark site $14,000 Per parcel 18.48.215 Late penalty for registration fee nonpayment $25 Per 30 days (or any partial month) until paid 18.48.215 Other abatement administrative cost $129 Plus actual costs for weed abatement and other adatement work 18.48, 9.36, 21A.20 City maintenance of building $219 Annual, plus actual costs, see Section 18.48.2570 18.48.2570 Building Code Enforcement Violation of Title 18 (except Ch. 18.50 or Stop Work Order) $100 18.24.030 Violation of Stop Work Order $250 18.24.040.B Violation of Ch. 18.50 Substandard condition $2550 18.50.100.D Hazardous condition $50100 18.50.100.D Imminent danger condition $75250 18.50.100.D Appeal of a decision to the board of appeals and examiners $285 Add’l fee for required public notices 18.12.020 6366 6367 __________________ ERIN MENDENHALL DEPARTMENT of COMMUNITY Mayor and NEIGHBORHOODS Blake Thomas Director CITY COUNCIL TRANSMITTAL Jill Love 05/09/2024 Jill Love (May 9, 2024 09:14 MDT)Date Received: Jill Love, Chief Administrative Officer Date sent to Council: 05/09/2024 TO:Salt Lake City Council DATE: 05/07/24 Victoria Petro-Eschler, Chair FROM:Blake Thomas, Director of Community & Neighborhoods _ SUBJECT:Proposed Text Amendments to Title 18 STAFF CONTACTS: Troy Anderson t.anderson@slcgov.com; Craig Weinheimer craig.weingheimer@slcgov.com DOCUMENT TYPE: Ordinance RECOMMENDATION: Consider and adopt the attached ordinance BUDGET IMPACT: None BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: The City Council is being asked to adopt a text amendment to an existing ordinance. This city-initiated petition is proposing changes to Title 18 Buildings and Construction. Title 18 has not received a comprehensive update to keep pace with state law and administrative practices in decades. The changes are necessary to bring the city's building regulations into compliance with state law by adopting certain uniform building codes as well as modernizing administrative procedures. This proposal increases fees associated with the boarded building program to reflect the city’s actual cost of regulation, eliminates code that is duplicative or irreconcilable with state-wide adopted building codes, creates an administrative enforcement mechanism for building code violations, updates existing residential housing standards based on precedent from the housing advisory appeals board, and creates one standard appeal process to a streamlined board of appeals and examiners for any violation of Title 18. The proposal also updates portions of Title 21A related to zoning enforcement to reflect existing city administrative practices and increases daily fines associated with uncorrected zoning violations. SALT LAKE CITY CORPORATION 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 404 WWW.SLC.GOV P.O. BOX 145486, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84114-5486 TEL 801.535.6230 FAX 801.535.6005 PUBLIC PROCESS: October 26, 2023 - The Early Notice Letter was sent to recognized community organizations and all boarded building property owners of record. October 27, 2023 – The city website for the proposal was posted to the Planning webpage. January 11, 2024 – Planning Commission agenda was posted on the Planning webpage. January 24, 2024 – Planning Commission recommends City Council approve the proposal. EXHIBITS: 1.Memorandum Updates 2.Planning Commission Staff report 3.Proposed Ordinance 1. Memorandum Updates To: City Council Members From: Craig Weinheimer Date: March 14, 2024 Re: Title 18 changes proposal DEPARTMENT of COMMUNITY and NEIGHBORHOODS A Planning Commission meeting was held on January 24, 2024 in which Building Services provided a presentation outlining proposed changes to Title 18. The Planning Commission voted to recommend approval to the City Council. Since this time, Staff have identified a few changes to the proposal: 1.Boarded Buildings Fee Study The Finance Department conducted a cost analysis and found that each boarded building permit cost the City a total of $22,537 annually between Civil Enforcement and emergency services (i.e., Police and Fire). Upon further investigation the Finance Department has corrected the fee study reporting a total of $15,551 for each boarded building annually. 2.Boarding Registration Late Fee and Interest. The Title 18 proposal provided to the Planning Commission identified in section 18.48.125 a late penalty and interest provision that was not in accordance with Finance Department procedures as found in Title 3.16.040. This has been corrected in the most recent proposal. 3.Boarded Building Registration Fee Amount The Fee Study cited in the proposal has identified an operating cost of $15,551 and a maximum proposed fee increase to be $14,000 due to small claims collections requirements. The current renewal fee is $1,546. Building services is recommending potential boarding registration fee increases in the range of $3,000, $6,000, or $14,000 per year. MEMORANDUM BUILDING SERVICES DIVISION 2. Planning Commission Staff Report ATTACHMENTS: To: Salt Lake City Planning Commission From:Craig Weinheimer, Civil Enforcement Legal Investigator, craig.weinheimer@slcgov.com , 801-535-6682 Date:January 24,2023 Re:PLNPCM2023-00868, Building Code Administration and Enforcement Building Code Administration & Enforcement REQUEST: This city-initiated petition is proposing changes to Title 18 Buildings and Construction. Title 18 has not received a comprehensive update to keep pace with state law and administrative practices in decades. The changes are necessary to bring the city's building regulations into compliance with state law adopting certain uniform building codes as well as modernizing administrative procedures. This proposal increases fees associated with the boarded building program to reflect the city’s actual cost of regulation, eliminates code that is duplicative or irreconcilable with state- adopted building codes, creates an administrative enforcement mechanism for building code violations, updates existing residential housing standards based on precedent from the housing advisory appeals board, and creates one standard appeal process to a streamlined board of appeals and examiners for any violation of Title 18. The proposal also updates portions of Title 21A related to zoning enforcement to reflect existing city administrative practices and increases daily fines associated with uncorrected zoning violations. RECOMMENDATION: That the planning commission recommends that the city council adopt the proposal. ATTACHMENT A: Proposed Ordinance Amending Title 18 ATTACHMENT B: Public Process & Comments This proposal is a comprehensive update to Title 18, with related updates to enforcement and appeal mechanisms for zoning violations (which are found in Title 21A and that are enforced by building services). The four substantive changes fall into the following categories: Boarded and Vacant Building Program; Building Code Enforcement Process; Housing Code Updates; Removal of Duplicative or Overlapping Codes; and Zoning Code Enforcement Updates. Boarded and Vacant Building Program (Sections 18.48.200-260) Staff Report BUILDING SERVICES DIVISION PROJECT DESCRIPTION: In 2022, the city council requested that the administration propose a change in boarded building fees to capture the full city cost of both monitoring/boarding and emergency services at those properties. The intent was to increase boarding permit fees to recuperate the city costs related to administering the inspection and monitoring of dangerous/boarded buildings. The finance department conducted a cost analysis, and the findings were that each boarded building permit costs the city a total of $22,537 annually between building services and emergency services (police and fire). The city currently charges $902 for the initial year permit fee and $1,546 for subsequent years. Updates to this program reflected in this proposal are as follows: Changing the program from an annual boarding permit to an annual registration. This type of boarded or vacant building registry was instituted in other cities during the Great Recession. A registry more accurately reflects the nature of the city’s monitoring and regulation, since boarding does not necessarily occur every year (as a permit suggests). Recording notices against the title on properties on the registry to let any interested buyer know that (1) the property is subject to the registry with annual registration fees, and (2) that boarding costs actually incurred by the city may be outstanding (which fees could be a lien against the title once sent to the Salt Lake County Treasurer). Incorporates a standard citation and appeal process, which will be the same for any Title 18 violation (found in Chapters 18.24 and 18.12). Increase the annual fee to $14,000 or less. This would result in the recuperation of 62% of the actual city costs. The current fee structure has an initial year fee and an annual fee for subsequent years. The proposal is to amend the initial year fee and make it the same amount as the subsequent yearly fee. The main reason is to simplify the process of tracking and collecting unpaid fees. Increase the administrative cost fee and the late penalty fee. The administrative cost fee is only charged when a city contractor performs boarding on private property, and it’s an excellent way to penalize those property owners who are not involved in the boarding and maintenance of their property. The current fee is $129. This proposal would increase the fee to $2,000 for each instance of boarding. The late penalty fee is currently $25 for every thirty days in which the annual fees are not paid. We propose an increase to $100 for this fee. Building Code Enforcement Process (Chapters 18.12, 18.24, and 2.21, and Section 5.14.125) Building services has experienced a number of recent impediments to an effective enforcement and citation appeal process. First, state-adopted building code requires that the city have a board of appeals and examiners, but this five-member board was difficult to keep staffed by qualified persons. Second, the Housing Advisory Appeals Board is a separate ten member board that required additional staff to administer and sometimes reached conclusions that were difficult to justify. Third, Title 18 did not have a general civil citation and appeal process (except that a stop work order could be issued pursuant to state adopted building codes). Fourth, subject-specific portions of Title 18 had specific citation and appeal processes, which were not consistent with one another, making any enforcement process unduly difficult. And finally, recent construction problems have resulted in building services revisiting the current tools and fines available in the event contractors and owners refuse to correct violations. The current general Title 18 enforcement process relied on criminal proceedings and only a couple of discrete violations (such as building without a permit) could be enforced through Title 21A, which is the zoning ordinance. In order to address these issues Titles 18, 2, and 5 have been revised as follows: The board of appeals and examiners has been streamlined to require only one appeal hearing officer, along with the building official as an ex-officio member (this building official status on the board is consistent with state-adopted building code). The Housing Advisory Appeals Board is being eliminated in favor of one appeal body – the board of appeals and examiners (which the city must have according to state-adopted building code) – to reduce administrative burden and keep appeal processes consistent. A standard appeal process for any violation of Title 18 has been added to Chapter 18.12. This process is nearly identical to an appeal of an administrative decision made pursuant to Title 21A. A fines-only appeal process for any violation of Title 18 has been added to Chapter 18.12. This process is identical to the fines-only appeal process for a zoning code violation. Significant changes to Chapter 18.24 were made to describe the city’s remedies in the event of a violation of Title 18, which will now include a civil citation and civil fines process. This process is nearly identical to the process for citing and fining individuals and businesses for zoning violations. New fines are being adopted now that a civil citation process has been created within Title 18. General violations will be $100 per day; violation of a stop work order will be $250 per day; housing code (Chapter 18.50) violations will be between $50 and $200 per day depending on the severity of the violation. Currently Title 18 only permits enforcement by stop work order and criminal proceedings. With these new standardized enforcement and appeal processes, in addition to the criminal proceedings, we will have a more effective tool to get properties and construction projects into compliance. The current cost for criminal violations of the building code is a $1,000 fine, double permit fees, a stop work order, or a re-inspection fee of $75.00. This process works well in the majority of the enforcement cases we have. However, like most cities, pursuing criminal citations for these type of municipal ordinance violations are rare. The other remedies and fines are low enough to be completely ignored by some property owners and builders. If we can implement the assessment of daily fines for civil violations it will make the fines high enough that they will not be ignored by the property owner or contractor. This will give us a better enforcement tool for future construction violations and decrease the number of violations not rectified. Housing Code Updates (Chapters 18.50 and 18.96) The Existing Residential Housing Code in Chapter 18.50, originally enacted in 1995, made reference to building, plumbing, mechanical, and electrical codes that were adopted at the time under the umbrella of the Uniform Building Codes. These UBC codes have since been replaced in Utah with the International Construction Codes. This proposal will update code references in Chapter 18.50 to conform with the Utah adopted ICC codes. The Fit Premises codes in Chapter 18.96 set forth certain rental housing standards. Some of these codes have been preempted by state law, and therefore needed to be removed. These chapters were also revised to incorporate APPROVAL PROCESS AND COMMISSION AUTHORITY the standard citation and appeal process for any Title 18 violation, though residential rental housing owners will have the right to a warning notice before a citation is issued. In addition to removing old references to the UBC and replacing them with current state-adopted building codes, some standards have also been revised to incorporate standards unofficially implemented for many years in Salt Lake City by the HAAB board. Removal of Duplicative or Overlapping Codes Since Title 18 has not been comprehensively updated in decades there are many chapters that are no longer being used because the subject matter is already comprehensively covered in the state- adopted building codes, or in Title 21A. In order to streamline the code and eliminate such duplication or overlap, Section 18.28.050 and Chapters 18.32, 18.36, 18.48 article 1, 18.56, and 18.92 are being removed. Zoning Code Enforcement Updates (Chapter 21A.20) As part of implementing a civil citation and fine process within Title 18, certain amendments to the zoning enforcement chapter (Chapter 21A.20) are necessary to reflect building services’ current enforcement procedures. These amendments reflect the following changes: Consistent with other revisions to Title 21A, definitions are being moved to the general zoning definitions chapter (21A.62). Building services current citation process is now reflected, including when a notice and order can be issued, what it needs to include, how it needs to be sent, and a recipient’s ability to appeal the notice and order. Zoning violations fines are being increased from $25 to $50 per day for residential properties and from $100 to $200 per day for commercial properties. Zoning fines have not been increased since approximately 1999 (and some zoning violations pre-1999 were subject to fine amounts that are identical to the amounts being proposed in the current amendments). A new fine amount for failing to have a certificate of appropriateness for work on the exterior of historic district properties is proposed at $50 per day, but if the work that was done is a full or partial demolition of a contributing or landmark structure, then the fine would be $250 per day. Clarifying that citation notices can be sent by any reputable mail tracking service that confirms delivery, as opposed to just by “certified mail” or “commercial courier service.” The planning commission is a recommending body for code amendments pertaining to land use regulation. Because some of the amendments impact land use, the building services division is bringing all of the amendments to the planning commission for review and recommendation. The planning commission can consider forwarding the proposal to the city council for adoption as is, with modification as to any land use related aspect of the proposal provided the modification complies with applicable state and federal laws or recommend that the proposal not be adopted. If considering KEY CONSIDERATIONS STAFF RECOMMENDATION modifications, the commission can provide clear direction to building services staff regarding the changes and ask that the changes be made prior to sending the proposal to the council for consideration, provide staff with exact wording (or deletions) that are desired, or table the matter with clear direction to staff to make specific changes that will be reviewed by the commission at a later date. The commission should note that this item is time-sensitive because the council has directed that the building code enforcement updates reflected in the proposed ordinance be sent to the council before the affordable housing incentives ordinance is set to take effect on April 30, 2024. Tabling the matter may create a risk in complying with the council’s request. If a commissioner has an issue with any aspect of the code, it is recommended to contact staff as soon as possible so we are prepared for the public hearing. The key considerations listed below were identified through the analysis of the project: 1.How the proposal helps implement city goals and policies. 2.Compliance with Utah Code. 3.Impact on zoning code. Consideration 1: How the proposal helps implement city goals and policies This proposal accomplishes city goals by pursuing administrative efficiency, administrative transparency, and charging fees commensurate with the city’s actual regulation costs. Consideration 2: Compliance with Utah Code This proposal is necessary to bring the city’s building and construction code title into conformance with state- adopted building codes. Consideration 3: Impact on the zoning code This proposal does not negatively impact the zoning code. Definitions in Title 18 were reconciled with existing definitions in Title 21A. Overlapping regulations were also eliminated (to maintain such regulations within Title 21A that are not appropriate for construction regulation under Title 18). No substantive zoning standards are being amended in Title 21A through this proposal. Rather, the enforcement portions of Title 21A are being updated to reflect building services’ existing zoning enforcement processes, as well as increase or create fines for violations that previously had no fine attached. The planning commission should recommend that the city council adopt the proposed changes to Title 18 and the relevant portions of Title 2, 5, and 21A based on the information presented in this staff report This proposal will be presented to the City Council regardless of the recommendation of the commission because it is a code amendment, and the city council has final approval authority for all city code amendments. To eliminate inconsistencies with state-adopted building codes and reflect the city’s current zoning enforcement procedures Title 18 should be updated. The division of building services expects the city council to adopt this proposal. However, there may be aspects of the proposal that are modified by the city council. The council can modify any aspect of the proposal because the entire title of code is under consideration. NEXT STEPS 3. Proposed Ordinance 1 1 SALT LAKE CITY ORDINANCE No. of 2024 (An ordinance amending the text of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code to modernize the administration, enforcement, and appeals procedures applicable to the state construction codes) An ordinance amending the text of Titles 2, 5, 18, and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code to modernize the administration, enforcement, and appeals procedures applicable to the state construction codes pursuant to Petition No. PLNPM2023-00868. WHEREAS, the Salt Lake City Planning Commission (“Planning Commission”) held a public hearing on January 24, 2024 to consider a petition by the Salt Lake City Council (“City Council”) to amend various provisions of Titles 2, 5, 18 and 21A of the Salt Lake City Code pursuant to Petition No. PLNPM2023-00868; and WHEREAS, at its January 24, 2024 meeting, the Planning Commission voted in favor of transmitting a positive recommendation to the City Council on said petition; and WHEREAS, after a public hearing on this matter the City Council has determined that adopting this ordinance is in the city’s best interests. NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah: SECTION 1. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.04. That Chapter 18.04 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Administration and General Provisions) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.04 ADMINISTRATION AND GENERAL PROVISIONS 18.04.010: DIVISION OF BUILDING SERVICES: This title establishes the duties of the division of building services. 2 18.04.020: DEFINITIONS: A. Where undefined terms are used in this title, the definitions of "Webster's Collegiate Dictionary" shall apply. B. All words and phrases defined in this section shall be given such defined meanings wherever used in this title, including the following: BUILDING OFFICIAL: Means and refers to the director of the division of building services, or his/her designee. DEVELOPMENT: any building activity or clearing of land as an adjunct of construction. DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITY: shall have the same meaning as defined in Utah Code §10-9a- 103 or its successor provisions. DIVISION: Means and refers to the division of building services of the city. ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL: any person employed by and authorized by the city to enforce violations of state law or this title, including, but not limited to, building inspectors, the building official, fire marshals, and civil enforcement officers. NONCOMPLIANT PROPERTY: property where one or more violations of this title have occurred or are currently occurring. NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE: a document, in any form, giving notice to interested parties that one or more violations of city code exist on the noncompliant property. PERSON: any individual, receiver, assignee, trustee in bankruptcy, trust, estate firm, co- partnership, joint venture, club, company, joint stock company, business trust, limited liability company, corporation, association, legal entity, society or other group of individuals acting as a unit, whether mutual, cooperative, fraternal, nonprofit or otherwise. RESPONSIBLE PARTY: means the person(s) determined by the city who is responsible for causing, maintaining, or allowing the continuation of a violation of this title. This may include, but is not limited to, a property owner, agent, tenant, lessee, occupant, architect, builder, contractor, business owner, or other person who individually or together with another person is responsible for causing, maintaining, or allowing the continuation or a violation of any provision of the code. 18.04.030: RESERVED 18.04.040: BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION CODES ADOPTED: The following codes, as adopted by the State of Utah, along with any adopted appendices are hereby adopted as part of the code of Salt Lake City: 3 The International Building Code, as promulgated by Title 15A of the Utah State Code; The International Residential Code, as promulgated by Title 15A of the Utah State Code; The International Fire Code; International Existing Building Code; International Energy Conservation Code; International Fuel Gas Code; National Electrical Code; The International Mechanical Code; The International Plumbing Code; The International Swimming Pool and Spa Code; Rule R156-56 of the Utah Administrative Code; ICC/MBI 1205-2021 Standard for Off-Site Construction: Inspection and Regulatory Compliance, or its successor, and 1997 Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings 18.04.050: RESERVED 18.04.060: RESOLUTION OF CONFLICTING PROVISIONS: Wherever conflicting provisions or requirements of the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040 or the provision of this title occur, the most restrictive provisions or requirements shall govern. In the event a provision of this title conflicts with an is more restrictive than the codes adopted in Utah Code Title 15A, the provisions of Title 15A shall govern. 18.04.070: LIABILITY LIMITATIONS: Nothing in this title shall be construed to relieve or lessen the responsibility of any contractor, owner, or any other persons involved, for apparatus, construction or equipment installed by or for them, for damages to anyone injured or damaged either in person or property by any defect therein, nor shall the city or any employee thereof be held to assume any liability by reason of the inspections authorized herein, or the certificate of occupancy issued by the building official. SECTION 2. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.08. That Chapter 18.08 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Organization) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.08 ORGANIZATION 18.08.010: DIVISION ESTABLISHED: 4 There is established, in the department of community and neighborhoods, a subordinate division of building services, to be under the supervision of the building official. The function of the division shall be the implementation, administration and enforcement of the provisions of this title. 18.08.020: POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE DIVISION: The functions of the division of building services shall be: A. To enforce the zoning laws of Salt Lake City; B. To carry out, enforce and perform all duties, provisions and mandates designated, made and set forth in the ordinances of the city concerning building, plumbing, electrical and mechanical construction, and construction related fire suppression; C. To examine and approve all plans and specifications before building permits shall be issued, and to inspect or cause to be inspected all buildings and structures erected in the city; and D. To perform all of the functions and have all of the powers required of and conferred on the building official by the ordinances of the city. 18.08.030: BUILDING OFFICIAL; EMPLOYMENT: The mayor shall employ a qualified building official and such other employees of the division that may from time to time be required to perform the functions of this title, at such compensation and for such periods of time as the mayor may deem proper. 18.08.040: BUILDING OFFICIAL; POWERS AND DUTIES: The building official shall maintain public office hours necessary to efficiently administer the following duties: A. Maintain an official register of all persons, firms or corporations lawfully entitled to carry on or engage in the businesses regulated by this title to whom a current license has been issued by the department of contractors of the state; B. Issue building permits to properly licensed persons, firms or corporations for work to be done within the scope of this title; C. Administer and enforce the provisions of this title in a manner consistent with the intent thereof, and inspect all work authorized by any permit, to assure compliance with provisions of this title or amendments thereto, approving or condemning such work in whole or in part, as conditions require; 5 D. Issue a certificate of approval or certificate of occupancy for all work approved by him/her; E. Require correction or reject all work done or being done, or materials used or being used which do not in all respects comply with the provisions of this title and amendments thereto; F. Order changes in workmanship and/or materials essential to obtain compliance with all provisions of this title; G. Investigate any construction or work regulated by this title and issue such notices and/or stop work orders which are necessary to prevent or to correct dangerous or unsanitary conditions; H. Recommend revocation of contractor licenses to the state department of business regulation for cause; I. Authorize any utility to make necessary connections for power, water or gas to all applicants for such power or water in the city, when the installation and all facets of the construction or remodel project conform to this title J. Verify that buildings not built on site in Salt Lake City (Factory Built Buildings) are built, inspected, and installed in accordance with the "ICC/MBI Standard for Off-Site Construction: Planning, Design, Fabrication and Assembly", or its successor document. In order for the building official to allow occupancy of qualifying structures, units delivered on site must be provided with a permanently affixed tag identifying the technical code versions, with Utah State Amendments, under which they were built. Individuals making the inspections must be certified and licensed building inspectors in the State of Utah; and K. The building official may render interpretations of this title and adopt and enforce rules and supplemental regulations pursuant to adopted state construction codes to clarify the application of its provisions. Such interpretations, rules and regulations shall conform to the intent and purpose of this title, and shall be made available in writing for public inspection upon request. 18.08.050: BUILDING OFFICIAL; DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY: The building official may delegate any of his/her powers and duties. 18.08.060: BUILDING OFFICIAL; UTILITY DISCONNECTION AUTHORITY: The building official, or the building official's authorized representative, shall have the authority to disconnect or order discontinuance of any utility service or energy supply to buildings, structures or equipment therein regulated by this code, in cases of emergency or where necessary to protect life and property. Such utility service shall be discontinued until the emergency or threat to life or property has ceased. 6 18.08.070: BUILDING OFFICIAL; LIABILITY LIMITATIONS: The building official, appeals hearing officer, fines hearing officer, or enforcement officials, when acting for the city in good faith and without malice in the discharge of his/her duties, shall not thereby render himself/herself liable personally, and the same are hereby relieved from all personal liability for any damage that may accrue to persons or property as a result of any act required or by reason of any act or omission in the discharge of such official's duties. 18.08.080: BUILDING OFFICIAL; RIGHT OF ENTRY FOR INSPECTIONS: The building official and any enforcement official shall have the right of entry, within reasonable hours, to any building or premises for the purpose of inspection, or to investigate any work or conditions governed by this title. 18.08.090: BUILDING OFFICIAL; CONFLICT OF INTEREST PROHIBITED: The building official and his/her assistants shall not in any way engage in the sale or installation of equipment or supplies upon which they are required to make inspection under this code. SECTION 3. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.12. That Chapter 18.12 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Board of Appeals and Examiners) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.12 BOARD OF APPEALS AND EXAMINERS 18.12.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: The provisions of chapter 2.07 of this title shall apply to the board of appeals and examiners except as otherwise set forth in this chapter. 18.12.020: BOARD OF APPEALS CREATED; PURPOSE AND AUTHORITY: In order to (1) hear and decide appeals of orders, decisions or determinations made by the building official relative to the application and interpretation of this title, including any state construction code adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040, or (2) hear and decide appeals of orders by enforcement officials, there shall be and is hereby created a board of appeals and 7 examiners comprised of an appeals hearing officer and the building official. The building official shall be an ex officio member of said board but shall not have a vote on any matter before the board. The mayor may appoint more than one appeals hearing officer, but only one appeals hearing officer shall consider and decide upon any matter before the board. The appeals hearing officer may serve consecutive four year terms upon the advice of the mayor and consent of the city council. The appeals hearing officer need not be a resident of Salt Lake City. The board shall provide for reasonable interpretations of the provisions of this title and the appeals hearing officer shall be qualified by experience and training to pass upon matters pertaining to building construction, housing, and abatement codes and technical disciplines set forth in this title. The board shall hear and decide appeals where it is alleged there is an error in any order, requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of this title. 18.12.030: PROCEDURE FOR APPEALS TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS & EXAMINERS: Appeals of decisions by the building official or enforcement officials shall be taken in accordance with the following procedures: A. Form: The appeal shall be filed using an application form provided by the building official. To be considered complete, the application must include all information required on the application, including but not limited to identification of the order, decision or determination being appealed, the alleged error made by stating each fact and every theory of relief on appeal and one or more reasons the appellant claims the administrative decision is in error. Incomplete applications will not be accepted. B. Filing: The application must be submitted as indicated on the form by the applicable deadline, together with all applicable fees as set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. The applicant shall also be responsible for payment of all fees established for providing the public notice required by the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, in accordance with the consolidated fee schedule, including costs of mailing, preparation of mailing labels and all other costs relating to notification. All fees are due at the time of filing the appeal. An appeal will not be considered complete until all applicable fees are paid. C. Parties Entitled to Appeal. An applicant, a board or officer of the city, or an adversely affected party, as that term is defined by Utah Code 10-9a-103, or its successor, may appeal. D. Time for Filing an Appeal; Time for Hearing: The deadline for filing a complete application for appeal is 10 days from the date of the decision, determination or order. Each appeal shall be reviewed informally by the board no later than 45 days from the date of filing of a written appeal, unless a later date is agreed to by the parties. Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. 8 A. Notice Required. Upon receipt of an appeal the board of appeals and examiners shall schedule and hold a public hearing in accordance with the standards and procedures for conducting public hearings set forth in Chapter 21A.10. B. Standard of Review. The board shall conduct each appeal de novo. The appellant has the burden of proving the decision appealed is incorrect. The board shall render a decision based upon the applicable law. The board shall afford due process to the parties on appeal. Each party may call such witnesses and present such evidence as it deems appropriate, provided such evidence is not unduly cumulative or irrelevant as determined by the board. Hearings shall be conducted informally. After hearing all evidence and legal arguments presented by the parties, the board shall apply the plain language of the applicable law and issue a written decision on the merits of all theories of relief the appellant raised in the appeal. C. Effect of Decision. The decision of the board is a final decision of the city, appealable to district court. No person may challenge in district court any order, decision, or enforcement action taken pursuant to this title unless and until that person has exhausted the administrative remedies provided by this chapter. D. Procedures. The proceedings of each appeal hearing shall be recorded and such recordings shall be retained for a period that is consistent with city retention policies and any applicable retention requirements set forth in state law. The building official shall adopt policies and procedures, consistent with the provisions of this chapter, for processing appeals, the conduct of an appeal hearing, and for any other purpose considered necessary to properly consider an appeal. E. No Automatic Stay: Filing an appeal does not stay the decision appealed, unless a provision of this title specifically states otherwise. F. Requesting a Stay: The board may grant a request submitted by any party to the appeal to stay a decision of the building official or enforcement official for a specified period of time or until the board issues a decision, if the requesting party can show a stay is necessary to prevent substantial harm to the requesting party. No request is required if a provision of this title imposes an automatic stay upon the filing of an appeal with the board. If a stay is requested, the board shall make reasonable efforts to determine whether a stay is appropriate within 10 days of the appeal being deemed complete. If the board does not decide a request for a stay within 10 days of the appeal being deemed complete, the request shall be presumed denied. No stay will be authorized for incomplete appeals or appeals filed after the appeal deadline. 18.12.040: BOARD DECISIONS: The board of appeals shall render all decisions and findings in writing to the parties within 14 days of the hearing on the appeal. 18.12.050: APPEALS OF CIVIL FINES & ABATEMENT COSTS: 9 A. Powers and Duties of Fines Hearing Officer: The fines hearing officer, appointed pursuant to Section 21A.06.090, may hear and decide appeals of civil fines and abatement costs imposed pursuant to this title. As set forth in this section, the fines hearing officer may affirm civil fines, reduce civil fines, and approve civil fine payment schedules. The fines hearing officer may affirm or reduce an abatement statement of costs and may approve abatement cost payment schedules. B. Right to Appear: Any responsible party receiving a notice and order or statement of abatement costs may appear before a fines hearing officer to appeal the amount of the civil fine or abatement cost imposed by submitting a statement of appeal on a form provided by the division of building services. However, in the case of civil fines, no party may appear before a fines hearing officer until violations for which the fines have accrued have been corrected. Appeals to a fines hearing officer contesting the amount of the civil fine imposed must be filed within 30 days from the date of compliance. Appeals to a fines hearing officer contesting the statement of abatement costs must be filed within 20 days from the date the statement of costs is delivered, but the only issue on such appeal is the amount of such costs and not the city’s determination to incur abatement costs. Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. C. Responsibility: Commencement of any action to remove or reduce civil fines shall not relieve the responsibility of any responsible party to correct the violation or make payment of accrued civil fines nor shall it require the city to reissue any of the notices required by this chapter. D. Reduction of Civil Fine: Civil fines may be reduced at the discretion of the fines hearing officer after the violation is corrected and if any of the following conditions exist: 1. Strict compliance with the notice and order would have caused an imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property; 2. The violation and inability to correct the same were both caused by a force majeure event such as war, act of nature, strike or civil disturbance; 3. A change in the actual ownership of the property was recorded with the Salt Lake County Recorder's Office after a notice of violation was issued and the new property owner is not related by blood, marriage or common ownership to the prior owner; or 4. Such other mitigating circumstances as determined by the fines hearing officer. E. Notice Required. Upon receipt of an appeal of a statement of abatement costs the fines hearing officer shall schedule and hold a public hearing in accordance with the standards and procedures for conducting public hearings set forth in Chapter 21A.10. F. Payment Schedule: At the request of a responsible party subject to civil fines or abatement costs governed by this title, the fines hearing officer may approve a payment schedule for the delayed or periodic payment of the applicable civil fine or abatement costs to accommodate the person's unique circumstances or ability to pay. 10 G. Failure to Comply with Payment Schedule: If a payment schedule has been developed by the fines hearing officer, the failure by a person to submit any 2 payments as scheduled shall cause the entire amount of the original civil fine or abatement cost to become immediately due, less any payments actually made. 18.12.060: JUDICIAL REVIEW OF BOARD'S DECISIONS: The city, or any person aggrieved by any decision of the board or fines hearing officer as to abatement costs, may appeal to district court so long as the petition for such relief is filed with the court within 30 days of the board’s or fines hearing officer’s decision. SECTION 4. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.16. That Chapter 18.16 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Registration and Licenses) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.16 LICENSES 18.16.010: STATE CONTRACTOR LICENSE REQUIRED: Except as provided in Section 18.20.070, every applicant for a permit issued pursuant to this title shall furnish evidence that such applicant is currently licensed under the provisions of the Utah contractor's license law as it presently exists or hereafter may be amended, giving the classification and number of the license, and shall have secured all licenses required by the ordinances of Salt Lake City. 18.16.020: EXCAVATION BOND REQUIRED: Any person, firm or corporation properly licensed to do business in accordance with this title who in the course of their work has occasion to excavate in the city streets, alleys or rights of way shall file an additional bond with the city in the amount of $10,000.00, or such larger amount as the city engineer may require. 18.16.030: LICENSE NOT TRANSFERABLE: 11 It is unlawful for any contractor to use such contractor's license or to allow his/her license to be used in any way for the purpose of procuring a bond or permit for any person other than such contractor. 18.16.040: SALE OF UNAPPROVED MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT PROHIBITED: It is unlawful for any dealer or person to sell, deliver or offer for sale any mechanical equipment or apparatus that has not been approved by a recognized listing agency. SECTION 5. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.20. That Chapter 18.20 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Permits and Inspections) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.20 PERMITS AND INSPECTIONS 18.20.010: WORK REQUIRING PERMIT: No person, firm or corporation shall erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, improve, remove, convert or demolish any building, structure or premises, or make any installation, alteration or improvement to the electrical, fire, plumbing or mechanical system in a building, structure or premises, or cause the same to be done, without first obtaining the prescribed permits for each such building or structure or premises from the building official. 18.20.020: FEES: A. Building permit fees shall be based on the total valuation of the proposed project as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. B. Plan review fees shall be 65% of the building permit fees. C. Fees to expedite building plan review as governed by Section 18.20.050 shall be 2 times the standard building plan review fee. D. Penalties for not obtaining permanent certificate of occupancy will be $300.00 for each month, after the initial 30 day temporary certificate of occupancy, which has no additional cost associated with it; due before the first of the month and only allowed for up to 3 renewals after the initial free 30 day period. Partial months will not be refunded. E. Fees for renewing expired plan review after 180 days as governed by Section 18.20.110 shall be shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 12 A. A fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be charged for each permit for fencing. B. Other fees shall consist of electrical, mechanical and plumbing, and fire suppression and monitoring equipment inspection fees as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.20.030: APPLICATION; FORM AND FILING: To apply for a building permit the applicant shall first file an application on a form furnished by the building official and pay the requisite fee therefor as established in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.20.040: APPLICATION; PLANS AND OTHER DATA: Each application for a permit shall be accompanied by all required plans, diagrams and other data required by the building official. The building official may require the plans and other data to be prepared and designed by an engineer or architect licensed by the state to practice as such. 18.20.050: APPLICATION; REVIEW; PERMIT ISSUANCE CONDITIONS: A. Application Review: Except as provided in subsection B of this section, the application plans and data filed by an applicant for a building permit shall be checked by the building official. Said application may be reviewed by other government agencies or departments to check compliance with the laws and ordinances under their jurisdiction. No building permit shall be issued unless and until the plans and specifications comply with all applicable land use regulations, including but not limited to Title 21A. The building official may issue a permit for the construction of part of a building or structure before the entire plans and specifications for the whole building or structure have been submitted or approved, provided adequate information and detailed statements have been filed complying with all pertinent requirements of this title. The holder of such permit shall proceed at his or her own risk without assurance that the permit for the entire building or structure will be granted. B. Expedited Plan Review: A building permit applicant may seek an expedited building plan review, provided that the applicant pay the expedited plan review fee set forth in Section 18.20.020 of this title. The expedited building plan review may be conducted by a qualified third party with significant experience conducting building plan reviews, as selected and approved by the building official. The person(s) assigned to conduct the expedited building plan review shall provide initial comments, including corrections to be made to the building plans, within 10 business days of the date the application was filed and all fees paid. C. Plan Review Expiration: If a building permit applicant fails to submit corrected building plans in accordance with the comments and requirements of the building services division or its authorized representative within 180 days of the division transmitting such comments and requirements to the applicant, or if the applicant fails to pay the required building permit fee within 180 days of the division informing the applicant that its building plans are 13 approved and the building permit fee is due, the plan review shall expire at the end of such period and the review become null and void. An expired plan review may be renewed, provided that the applicant pay the plan review renewal fee established in Section 18.20.020 of this title, however, no plan review may be renewed after 3 years from the original submission date or if new versions of the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040 have come into effect since the prior plan review was conducted. 18.20.060: PERMIT; ISSUED TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS ONLY: Except as otherwise provided by this title, no building permit shall be issued to any person other than a duly licensed contractor licensed by the State of Utah Division of Professional Licensing or its successor. 18.20.070: HOMEOWNER PERMITS: Any permit required by this title may be issued to any person to do any work regulated by this title in a single-family dwelling used exclusively for such person's living purposes, including the usual accessory buildings and quarters in connection with such buildings, provided that any such person is a bona fide owner of any such dwelling and accessory buildings and quarters, and that the same are occupied or designed to be occupied by such owner, and further provided that the owner shall furnish the building official with a complete layout drawing of the proposed work, satisfy the building official that he or she has a working knowledge of the code requirements, performs the work himself or herself, pays the necessary inspection fees, and calls for all inspections required by this title. 18.20.080: PERMIT; EFFECT OF ISSUANCE: The issuance of a permit or approval of plans or other data shall not be construed to be a permit for or an approval of any violation of any of the provisions of this title, Title 21A, or any rights of third parties. The issuance of a permit based upon plans and other data shall not prevent the building official from thereafter requiring the correction of errors in said plans and data or from stopping construction activity being carried on thereunder when in violation of this title or any other law. The city shall have no obligation to enforce the rights of third parties or recover damages to third parties due to the acts or omissions of permit holders. 18.20.090: START OF WORK WITHOUT PERMIT; PENALTY FEES; EMERGENCIES: A. Whenever any work requiring a permit under this title is commenced without a permit first having been obtained the building official may pursue enforcement of this title pursuant to Chapter 18.24. 14 A. Fee Increase When: Whenever any construction or work for which a permit is required by this title is started or commenced without obtaining the prescribed permit, the fees specified in this title may be increased by the building official up to a fee of 10% of the valuation of the proposed construction as determined by the building official, or $1,000.00, whichever is greater, but the payment of such increased fees shall not relieve any persons from fully complying with the requirements of this title in the execution of the work nor from any other penalties prescribed herein. B. Exception; Emergency Work: This section shall not apply to emergency work when it shall be proved to the satisfaction of the building official that such work was urgently necessary and that it was not practical to obtain a permit therefor before the commencement of the work. In all such cases, a permit must be obtained as soon as it is practical to do so, and if there be an unreasonable delay in obtaining a permit, a double fee, as herein provided, shall be charged. 18.20.100: PERMIT; DENIAL CONDITIONS: The building official may refuse to issue any permit for work governed by this title to any person who has a permit revoked in accordance with this title, or during such time as such person fails to comply with any provision of this title or Title 21A. No permit shall be issued to the responsible party for a property actively subject to enforcement proceedings by the city for violations of this title or Title 21A, except for permits required to correct the violations. 18.20.110: PERMIT; EXPIRATION AND RENEWAL: Every permit issued by the building official under the provisions of this title shall expire by limitation and become null and void if the building or work authorized by such permit is not commenced within 180 days from the date of such permit or if the building or work authorized by such permit is suspended or abandoned at any time after the work is commenced for a period of 180 days. Before such work can be recommenced, the permittee must request that the permit be renewed by the building official and the fee therefor shall be 1/2 the amount required for a new permit for such work. Such renewal may be granted if such request is made prior to the permit expiring upon the permittee demonstrating justifiable cause for the renewal, and provided no changes have been made or will be made in the original plans or scope of such work. Such renewal shall be denied if such request is made after the permit has expired and (1) municipal regulations impacting the use, size, yard, space or other requirements concerning the proposed structure or development have changed since the permit was issued, (2) material changes have been made or will be made in the original plans or scope of work, or (3) justifiable cause does not exist to allow the project to be renewed. In connection with renewing a permit that pertains to construction of a new structure or substantial exterior alteration of a site the building official may impose reasonable conditions regarding a deadline to complete the work, posting of a bond, erection of fences, securing methods, and similar conditions to mitigate the hazards of and limit the nuisances of ongoing construction. 15 18.20.120: PERMIT; NOT TRANSFERABLE: Building permits are non-transferable without completion of a permit transfer document approved by the building official. When any construction activity regulated by this title is not completed by the permittee identified in the permit and is instead completed by any other person, such person shall procure a permit to cover the work he or she performs. 18.20.130: PERMIT; SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION: The building official may, in writing, suspend or revoke a permit issued under provisions of this title whenever the permit is issued in error, or on the basis of inaccurate information supplied, or upon a finding of a violation of any ordinance or regulation of any of the provisions of this title or Title 21A. 18.20.140: HEARING ON DENIAL OR REVOCATION OF PERMIT: Any person adversely affected by the action of the building official made pursuant to Section 18.20.130 may appeal pursuant to Chapter 18.12, except that an appeal of a revocation or suspension of a building permit based upon a finding of a violation of Title 21A shall be made to the appeals hearing officer as set forth in Chapter 21A.16. 18.20.150: INSPECTION OF WORK: A. All construction, work and equipment for which a permit is required shall be subject to inspections by the building official. The building official may make or require any inspection of any construction work to ascertain compliance with the provisions of this title and other laws which are enforced by the division. B. No construction, work or equipment regulated by this title shall be connected to any energy, fuel or power supply or water system or sewer system until authorized by the building official. C. Prior to issuance of a building permit or during construction a survey of any lot or parcel may be required by the building official to verify compliance with approved plans. D. The building official shall not be liable for any expense entailed in the removal or replacement of any material required to allow an inspection. 18.20.160: APPROVALS REQUIRED FOR ONGOING CONSTRUCTION: No work shall be done on any part of the building or structure beyond the point indicated in each successive inspection without first obtaining the written approval of the building official. Such written approval shall be given only after an inspection shall have been made of each successive step in the construction as indicated by each of the inspections required by the building official. 16 18.20.170: REQUESTS FOR INSPECTIONS: The building official may require that every request for inspection be made at least one day before such inspection is required and in such method as prescribed by the building official. It shall be the duty of the person requesting any inspections required by this title to provide access to and means for proper inspection of such work. Nothing in this section shall be construed to require the building official to perform an inspection within the notice period provided herein. 18.20.180: RESERVED 18.20.190: FINAL INSPECTION AND CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: A final inspection and building official approval are required on all buildings and structures requiring a building permit prior to occupancy. Final inspection approval shall be issued in the form of a certificate of occupancy. A building or structure shall not be used or occupied in whole or in part, and a change in occupancy of a building or structure or portion thereof shall not be, until the building official has issued a certificate of occupancy therefor. A certificate of occupancy may, upon notice, be revoked by the building official if the building official finds that elements of the property for which a certificate was issued have been changed or modified, including a change in occupancy classification, without obtaining the requisite permits required by this title. 18.20.200: REINSPECTIONS AND FEES: A. A reinspection fee may be assessed: 1. When the approved plans are not readily available to the inspector; 2. For failure to provide access on the date for which the inspection is required; 3. For deviating from plans requiring the approval of the building official. B. In instances where reinspection fees have been assessed or reinspection is necessary, no additional inspection of the work will be performed until the required fees have been paid and the permittee calls for a reinspection. The reinspection charge shall be shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule and not exceed the amount shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule for each additional inspection required. 18.20.210: CLEANUP AND PROTECTION OF PUBLIC RIGHTS OF WAY: 17 A. Each permit holder shall be responsible to see that vehicles used in the process of carrying out the work authorized by the permit shall not track any mud, dirt or debris of any kind upon any streets or sidewalks within the corporate limits of Salt Lake City Corporation unless a permit has been obtained from the city engineer for use of a designated portion of the right of way with provisions made to keep that portion of the right of way and adjacent areas cleared of mud, dirt or debris of any kind. The permittee shall install a suitable process to clean the wheels of the equipment prior to its leaving the job site and entering the streets of Salt Lake City Corporation. The suitable process shall consist of: 1. A cleaning area and crew to clean mud and dirt off the wheels and exterior body surface of the trucks, or its equivalent; 2. The cleaning area shall be arranged to furnish adequate draining to prevent puddling; the cleaning area shall be kept mud free and may be on a macadam or concrete slab; 3. The cleaning area shall be located on private property and arranged in such a way that there is no blocking of vehicular or pedestrian traffic on city rights of way except where permission has been granted by the city engineer; 4. The cleaning water or solution used for cleaning shall not be allowed to enter the city streets, gutter, or storm drain or sanitary sewer system. B. All trucks and equipment leaving the site with earthen materials or loose debris shall be loaded and/or covered in such a manner as to prevent dropping of materials on city streets and/or sidewalks. C. Ramps constructed over curbs and gutters shall not interfere with or block the passage of water along the gutter and shall be constructed of asphalt material that will not erode or deteriorate under adverse weather conditions. D. The permit holder shall install erosion and water runoff controls sufficient to ensure that no stormwater, surface water, sediments or debris from the construction site shall drain or wash or be tracked into any public right of way or other adjacent properties, including curb and gutter, unless permission has been granted through the erosion control plan. These controls shall be sufficient to cover any contingency, including, but not limited to, seasonal storms, unseasonal storms, or methods of construction. The building official or the city engineer may require, when in his/her discretion he/she deems necessary, an erosion control plan to be submitted for approval. Such plan may be required any time during construction and must be submitted within 5 days of the request. The building official or the city engineer may suspend all work until the plan requested is approved. The permit holder will maintain all erosion control facilities throughout the life of the construction project. He/she will monitor their effectiveness after storms and make the necessary adjustments to ensure they function correctly. E. The sidewalk and/or curb and gutter shall not be used for storage of debris, dirt or excavated materials. In addition, the sidewalks shall not be removed, blocked or otherwise rendered unusable by either the storage of construction equipment or materials or the construction procedures used, unless a safe, usable alternate walkway along the same side of the street is provided by the contractor unless a permit has been issued by the city engineer. All 18 alternate walkways shall be ramped in accordance with handicap ramp requirements and so constructed as to provide an all weather walking surface 4 feet wide as sound and smooth as the normal concrete sidewalk. F. The permit holder shall be responsible for the immediate removal of mud, dirt or debris deposited on city streets, sidewalks and/or curb and gutters by equipment leaving the site or by the permit holder's construction procedures. G. If it becomes necessary for the city street crews to remove any mud, dirt, or debris which has been deposited upon a street or sidewalk of Salt Lake City Corporation, the total cost to the city of such removal will be charged to the property owner or permit holder, including legal fees, if any. Payment of such charges will be made to the city prior to certification of final inspections, utility clearances, and issuance of a certificate of occupancy. H. The building official or the city engineer is empowered to suspend any permit until the permit holder installs the necessary cleaning equipment and/or erosion control facilities to ensure that no dust or debris is deposited upon the streets and sidewalks of Salt Lake City Corporation. Such device shall operate in a manner satisfactory to the building official or the city engineer. 18.20.220: WAIVER OR DEFERRAL OF FEES: Nonprofit organizations may petition the city for the waiver or deferral of any or all fees required by this title on an annual or project by project basis as provided below: A. Petitions shall be filed with the division of housing stability. B. Waivers shall not be granted for projects that are receiving 75% or more of their funding directly or indirectly from state or federal agencies, except for projects that upgrade or construct owner occupied housing or multiple dwelling units used for very low income housing as provided by the guidelines established by the United States department of housing and urban development. C. Waiver requests shall be heard informally before the director of the department of community and neighborhoods after notice of the hearing has been posted for 7 days in the office of the city recorder. D. The director of the department of community and neighborhoods may recommend granting the waiver or deferral if he/she finds that the project or projects, and the sponsoring nonprofit organization furthers the city's established low income housing goals to provide housing for persons or families under 80% of the city's median income, as defined by the United States department of housing and urban development, and also meets all applicable guidelines established for any such programs by the United States department of housing and urban development. The director may recommend that waivers may be granted for remodeling or construction of offices for nonprofit housing corporations if he/she finds that such remodeling or construction will save the corporation money and that such savings will be applied to a specific housing project. 19 E. The director’s recommendation will be made to the city council and considered at a public meeting. The property owner of any project(s) for which a waiver or deferral of fees is granted shall enter into, as applicable, (1) a restrictive covenant, in a form approved by the city attorney, against the applicable property pertaining to the affordable housing that shall be provided at the property, or (2) a binding agreement regarding the method in which the fee savings shall be applied to a specific housing project. F. Fee waivers or deferrals shall not be granted to any organization which owns, operates, manages or is related by common ownership or management to any other such organization which owns, operates or manages buildings for which existing notices of code violations have not been corrected. SECTION 6. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.24. That Chapter 18.24 of the Salt Lake City Code (Administration and Enforcement: Enforcement and Penalties) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.24 ENFORCEMENT AND PENALTIES 18.24.010: ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY: Unless otherwise provided by this title, the building official is authorized and responsible for enforcement of this title. The fire marshal or designee shall be the principal enforcement officer on post construction activity with respect to the fire codes. Whenever one or more violations of this title exist, any enforcement official has the authority to obtain compliance subject to the provisions of this code. Unless otherwise provided, any violation of this title shall be subject to the enforcement processes and penalties as set forth in this chapter. 18.24.020: CRIMINAL PENALTIES: Unless otherwise provided, it shall be a misdemeanor for any person, firm, or corporation to violate the provisions of this title, either by failing to do those acts required or by doing an act prohibited by this title or the codes referred to herein, or by aiding or abetting in a violation of this title or the codes referred to herein. Each day that any violation of this title is permitted to continue shall constitute a separate offense. The class of misdemeanor shall be as dictated by state law. 18.24.030: CHOICE OF REMEDIES: 20 A. In addition to any criminal prosecution, this title may be enforced through administrative or civil actions. The city may pursue any legal remedy to ensure compliance with this title including, but not limited to, injunctive relief. The city has sole discretion over which remedy or combination of remedies it may choose to pursue. B. If the city elects to pursue through administrative or civil actions one or more violations of the provisions of this title, a civil penalty shall be assessed for each violation in the amount set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. Each day a violation continues after notice of the same shall give rise to a separate civil fine. C. The possibility of an administrative or civil remedy does not interfere with the city’s right to prosecute violations of this title as criminal offenses. If the city chooses to file both civil and criminal actions for the same violation, no civil penalties in the form of fines shall be assessed, but other remedies, such as orders to correct the violations or other declaratory or injunctive relief, is available to the city. D. The city may use such lawful means as are available to obtain compliance with the provisions of this title and to collect the civil fines that accrue as a result of the violation of the provisions of this title, including but not limited to a legal action to obtain one or more of the following: an injunction, an order of mandamus, an order requiring the property owner or occupant or permittee to abate the violations, an order permitting the city to enter the property and abate the violations, and a judgment in the amount of the civil fines accrued for the violation, including costs and attorney fees, and a judgment in the amount of any actual costs incurred by the city. E. In addition to the other remedies provided by this title, upon the finding of a violation of this title the building official may evacuate or close a building to occupancy when necessary to protect the public or neighboring property from a risk to health or safety. The building shall thereafter remain unoccupied until the appropriate certificate of occupancy has been issued. F. Recurring Violations: In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, reoccurs at the same property within 6 months of the initial correction and is due the actions or inactions of the same responsible party as the prior violation, the city may begin enforcement of said recurring violation and impose fines after a 10 day warning period. 18.24.040: NOTICE & ORDER; STOP WORK ORDER: A. Notice and Order. 1. Upon a determination that there is a violation of this title an enforcement official may provide a written notice and order to any responsible party. The written notice and order shall state: a. The name and address, if known, of the responsible party; b. the date and location of each violation; c. the code sections violated; 21 • that the violations must be corrected; • provide a specific date by which the enforcement official orders that the violations be corrected by; • the amount of the civil fine to accrue for each violation, or other enforcement action that the enforcement official intends to pursue, if the violation is not corrected by the date specified; • identification of the right to and procedure to appeal; and • the signature of the enforcement official. 2. The enforcement official shall serve the notice and order on the responsible party by: a. Posting a copy of the written notice and order on the noncompliant property, and b. By mailing the notice and order through certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery. If the responsible party is the property owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. If the responsible party is any other person or entity other than the owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known address of the responsible party on file with the city. c. Notwithstanding the foregoing, personal service upon the responsible party shall be sufficient to meet the notice and order mailing requirements of Subsection 18.24.040.A.2.b. 3. Following the issuance of a notice and order, any responsible party shall correct the violations specified in the notice and order. Upon correction of the violations specified in the notice and order, the responsible party shall request an inspection of the property. 4. Following a request for an inspection as set forth in Subsection 18.24.040.A.3, an enforcement official shall conduct an inspection of the property to determine whether the violations alleged in the notice and order have been corrected, including, if applicable, all necessary permits have been issued and all final inspections have been performed as required by applicable city codes. 5. If one or more violations are not corrected by the deadline specified in the notice and order, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set forth in Subsection 18.24.030.B. Accumulation of civil fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of civil fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed through an inspection requested pursuant to Subsection 18.24.040.A.3. 6. The responsible party shall have the right to contest the notice and order at an administrative hearing in accordance with Chapter 18.12. Failure to timely request an administrative hearing and pay the administrative hearing fee set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall constitute a waiver of the right to a hearing and a waiver of the right to appeal. B. Stop Work Order. Upon a determination that there is a violation of this title an enforcement official may issue a stop work order prior to issuance of a notice and order. If, after issuance of a notice and order pursuant to subsection A, the violations cited remain uncorrected 22 after the correction period set forth in the notice and order, then a daily civil fine in the amount set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be imposed. 18.24.050: NOTICE OF NONCOMPLIANCE; ABATEMENT LIEN: A. Upon expiration of the correction period set forth in a notice and order or stop work order, and where the violation(s) remain uncorrected, the city may record on the noncompliant property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of noncompliance. B. The recordation of a notice of noncompliance shall not be deemed an encumbrance on the noncompliant property but shall merely place interested parties on notice of any continuing violation of this title at the noncompliant property. C. If a notice of noncompliance has been recorded pursuant to Section A and the enforcement official determines that all violations have been corrected, the enforcement official shall issue a notice of compliance by recording the notice of compliance on the property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office. Recordation of the notice of compliance shall have the effect of canceling the recorded notice of noncompliance. D. If the city files an action for injunctive relief seeking abatement of one or more violations and the district court authorizes the abatement of one or more violations and the city incurs costs and the costs are not paid, a lien or garnishment may be placed to recover the costs and may be considered an encumbrance on the property. SECTION 7. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.28. That Chapter 18.28 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Site Development Regulations) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.28 SITE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS 18.28.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: A. Authority: This chapter is enacted pursuant to title 10 of the Utah Code as amended. This chapter is further enacted as an element of the Salt Lake City master plan. B. Applicability: The provisions of this chapter shall apply to all site development within Salt Lake City. C. Purpose: This chapter is adopted: to promote public safety and the general public welfare; to protect property against loss from erosion, earth movement, earthquake hazard, and 23 flooding; to maintain a superior community environment; to provide for the continued orderly growth of the city to ensure maximum preservation of the natural scenic character of major portions of the city by establishing minimum standards and requirements relating to land grading, excavations, and fills; and to establish procedures by which these standards and requirements may be enforced. It is intended that this chapter be administered with the foregoing purposes in mind and specifically to: 1. Ensure that the development of each site occurs in a manner harmonious with adjacent lands so as to minimize problems of drainage, erosion, earth movement, and similar hazards; 2. Ensure that public lands and places, watercourses, streets, and all other lands in the city are protected from erosion, earth movement, and drainage hazards; 3. Ensure that the planning, design, and construction of all development will be done in a manner which provides maximum safety and human enjoyment, and, except where specifically intended otherwise, makes it as unobtrusive in the natural terrain as possible; 4. Ensure, insofar as practicable, the retention of natural vegetation to aid in protection against erosion, earth movement, and other hazards and to aid in preservation of the natural scenic qualities of the city; and 5. Ensure, insofar as Salt Lake City is located in an active seismic zone, that appropriate earthquake hazard mitigation measures are incorporated into the planning and execution of site development. D. Identification of Fault Hazards: Pending the completion by the Utah geological survey (UGS) of a fault hazard map for Salt Lake City, the planning director may rely upon the existing information available from UGS or other publicly or privately prepared geological reports to identify fault hazards. 18.28.020: DEFINITIONS: A. Definition Of Terms: For the purposes of this chapter, certain terms used herein are defined as set forth below: AS GRADED: The surface conditions existent upon completion of grading. BEDROCK: In place, solid, rock. BENCH: A relatively level step excavated into earth material on which fill is to be placed. BORROW: Earth material acquired from an off site location for use in grading a site. BUILDING PERMIT: A permit issued by Salt Lake City for the construction, erection, or alteration of a structure or building. 24 CERTIFY OR CERTIFICATION: Means that the specific reports, inspections, and tests that are required have been performed by the person or under their supervision, and that the results of such reports, inspections, and tests comply with the applicable requirements of this chapter. CITY ENGINEER: The city engineer of Salt Lake City. CIVIL ENGINEER: A professional engineer registered in the state of Utah to practice in the field of civil works. CIVIL ENGINEERING: The application of the knowledge to the forces of nature, principals of mechanics, and the properties of materials to the evaluation, design, and construction of civil works for the beneficial uses of mankind. COMPACTION: The densification of fill by mechanical means. CUBIC YARDS: The volume of material in an excavation and/or fill. CUL-DE-SAC: A street closed at one end. CUT: See definition of Excavation. DRIVEWAY: A way or route for use by vehicle traffic leading from a parking area or from a house, garage, or other structure, to a road or street. EARTH MATERIAL: Any rock, natural soil, or any combination thereof. ENGINEERING GEOLOGIST: A graduate in geology or engineering geology of an accredited university, with 5 or more full years of professional postgraduate experience in the application of the geological sciences, of which 3 full years shall be in the field of engineering geology that has required the application of geological data, techniques, and principles to engineering problems dealing with groundwater, naturally occurring rock and soil, and geologic hazards for the purpose of assuring that geological factors are recognized and adequately interpreted and presented. EROSION: The wearing away of the ground surface as a result of the movement of wind, water, and/or ice. EXCAVATION: Any act by which vegetation, earth, sand, gravel, rock, or any other similar material is cut into, dug, quarried, uncovered, removed, displaced, relocated, or bulldozed, and shall include the conditions resulting therefrom. EXISTING GRADE: The actual elevation (in relation to mean sea level) of the ground surface before excavation or filling. FILL: Any earth, sand, gravel, rock, or any other material which is deposited, placed, replaced, pushed, dumped, pulled, transported, or moved by man to a new location and shall include the conditions resulting therefrom. FILL MATERIAL: Earth material free from rock or similar irreducible material exceeding 12 inches in diameter, metal, and organic material except that topsoil spread on cut and fill surfaces may incorporate humus for desirable moisture retention properties. 25 GRADING: Excavation or fill or any combination thereof that alters the elevation of the terrain and shall include the conditions resulting from any excavation or fill. LICENSED ARCHITECT: An architect who is registered with the division of occupational and professional licensing of the state of Utah. NATURAL DRAINAGE: Water which flows by gravity in channels formed by the surface topography of the earth prior to changes made by the efforts of man. ONE STREET ACCESS: A street that provides the sole access to one or more other streets. PARCEL: All contiguous land in one ownership, provided, however, each lot conforming to the zoning ordinances of Salt Lake City in a subdivision may be considered to be a separate parcel. PERCENT OF SLOPE: The slope of a designated area of land determined by dividing the horizontal run of the slope into the vertical rise of the same slope, measured between contour lines on the referenced contour map and converting the resulting figure into a percentage value. This calculation is described by the following formula: S = V/H Where "S" is the percent of slope; "V" is the vertical distance; and "H" is the horizontal distance. PERMITTEE: Any person to which a site development permit has been issued. PLANNING DIRECTOR: The planning director of Salt Lake City. QUARRY: An open excavation for the extraction of resources. REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER: A civil engineer who is registered with the division of occupational and professional licensing of the state of Utah. REMOVAL: Killing vegetation by spraying, complete extraction, or excavation, or cutting vegetation to the ground, trunks, or stumps. SEISMIC: Characteristic of, or produced by, earthquakes or earth vibration. SITE: A lot or parcel of land, or a contiguous combination thereof, where grading work is performed as a single unified operation. 26 SITE DEVELOPMENT: Grading and underground utility installation in preparation for an approved, pending development or use for the subject site. SLOPE CLASSIFICATION MAP: A map prepared as a colored exhibit by a registered professional engineer or land surveyor based upon a contour map of the specified scale and contour interval, upon which the measured and calculated percent of slope (measured between every contour interval on the map) is classified or grouped into percentage of slope data in 10% slope groupings as follows: Slope Classification Percent Of Slope Mapped Color Level 0 - 9.9%Uncolored Slight 10 - 19.9%Yellow Moderate 20 - 29.9%Orange Severe 30% and greater Red SOILS ENGINEER: A registered civil engineer of the state of Utah, specializing in soil mechanics and foundation engineering, familiar with the application of principles of soil mechanics in the investigation and analysis of the engineering properties of earth materials. SURCHARGE: The temporary placement of fill material on a site in order to compress or compact the natural soil mass. TESTING LABORATORY: A testing laboratory that requires supervisory personnel to be professional engineers registered with the division of occupational and professional licensing of the state of Utah. VACANT: Land on which there are no structures or only structures which are secondary to the use or maintenance of the land itself. 18.28.030: RESERVED 18.28.040: LAND DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS: A. General Application: No person or party shall cause any excavation or grading to be done in excess of the limits set forth below without first having obtained a site development permit. 1. Work Requiring Separate Approval/Permit: A site development permit shall be required in all cases where development comes under any one or more of the following provisions: 27 yards;a. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding 1,000 cubic b. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding 5 feet in vertical depth at its deepest point measured from the adjacent, undisturbed, ground surface; c. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof exceeding an area of a 1/2 acre; d. Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof of 10% or more of a building site including the excavation for foundations and footings; e. Removal of vegetation from an area in excess of a 1/2 acre for purposes other than agricultural; f. Engineered interior fills or surcharges. g. Commercial quarries or mining activities operating in permitted zoning districts as provided in Title 21A. 4.Work Not Requiring Separate Approval/Permit: A separate site development permit shall not be required in the following cases: • Excavation below finished grade for basements and footings of buildings or other structures authorized by a valid building permit. This shall not exempt any fill made with material from such excavation, or exempt any excavation having an unsupported height greater than 5 feet after the completion of such structure. • Removal of vegetation as part of work authorized by a valid building permit. A. Permits Required: Except as exempted in Subsection A of this section, a separate approval or permit shall be required for each site, and may cover both excavation and fill. 1. Application: To obtain a permit the applicant shall first file an application therefor in writing on a form furnished by the building department for that purpose. Every such application shall: a. Identify and describe the work to be covered by the permit for which application is made; b. Describe the land on which the proposed work is to be done by legal description, street address, or similar description that will readily identify and definitely locate the proposed work and identify lots of any platted subdivision included within the proposed building site; c. Indicate the use or occupancy for which the proposed work is intended; 28 • Be accompanied by plans, diagrams, computations, and specifications and other data as required; • Be signed by property owner or permittee, or his authorized agent, who may be required to submit evidence to indicate such authority; • Show the location of existing and proposed buildings or structures on the applicant's property, and the location of buildings or structures on adjacent properties which are within 15 feet of the applicant's property, or which may be affected by the proposed site development activities; • Show the location of property lines and all existing and proposed streets, roadways, driveways, easements, and rights of way on, contiguous, or adjacent to the proposed development site; • Show the present contours of the site in dashed lines and the proposed contours in solid lines. Contour intervals shall be not greater than 2 feet where slopes are predominately 5% or less, and 5 feet where slopes are predominately steeper than 5%. The source of all topographical information shall be indicated; • Show the location of all drainage to, from, and across the site, the location of intermittent and permanent streams, springs, culverts, and other drainage structures, and size and location of any precipitation catchment areas in, above, or within 100 feet of the site; • Include detailed plans and location of all surface and subsurface drainage devices, walls, dams, sediment basins, storage reservoirs, and other protective devices to be constructed with, or as a part of, the proposed work, together with a map showing drainage areas, and the complete drainage network including outfall lines and natural drainageways which may be affected by the proposed project. Include the estimated runoff of the areas served by the proposed drainage system; • Present a plan showing temporary erosion control measures to prevent erosion during the course of construction; • All grading in excess of 5,000 cubic yards shall require professional engineering and shall be designated as "engineered grading". Any application including engineered grading shall contain a grading plan prepared by a registered professional engineer or licensed architect; • Include a revegetation plan including: • A survey of existing trees, shrubs, and ground covers, • A plan for the proposed revegetation of the site detailing existing vegetation to be preserved, new vegetation to be planned and any modification to existing vegetation, and 29 • A plan for the preservation of existing vegetation during construction activity; a. Make a statement of the estimated starting and completion dates for the grading work proposed and any revegetation work that may be required; b. Identify the type of surcharging fill material to be used on the building site; c. Estimate the amount of time surcharging fill material will be in place, and show consideration by a soils engineer of the potential for vertical and lateral soil movements on properties adjacent to the surcharge; d. Submit a copy of the recorded subdivision plat showing developable area limitations, if applicable; e. Describe the method to be employed in disposing of soil and other material that is removed from the site, including the location of the disposal site; f. Describe the method to be used in obtaining fill to be used on the site and the site of acquisition of such fill; g. Include an engineering geology report described in Section 18.28.040.C.2 if the proposed development lies within 500 feet of an identified fault. Said report may be submitted for review to the Utah geological survey by the building official. h. Applications related to commercial quarriers shall contain an acceptable plan for the eventual rehabilitation and use of the quarry site after the resources have been removed. Such a plan, at a scale of not less than one inch equals 100 feet with contour intervals not greater than 5 feet, shall be compatible with its surroundings and in general agreement with the city’s master plan. The plan shall show the proposed treatment of any stream channel adjacent to the resource deposits during extraction operations. Limits of excavation shall be determined to protect any natural or improved channel and any nearby wooded areas considered vital to the function of the rehabilitated area. Included the estimated time period during which quarrying and land rehabilitation operations will be conducted. i. Such other information as may be required by the building official or city engineer such as slope classification map and analysis, profiles or cross sections, additional drainage calculations, soils data including a report from a registered soils engineer or other qualified person. B. Soil Engineering Report or Engineering Geology Required: 1. Soil Engineering Report: The soil engineering report required shall include data regarding the nature, distribution, and strength of existing soils, conclusions and recommendations for grading procedures, design criteria for corrective measures 30 when necessary, and opinions and recommendations addressing the adequacy of the site under the proposed grading plan to support the proposed development. 2. Engineering Geology Report: The engineering geology report required shall include an adequate description of the geology of the site, conclusions and recommendations regarding the effect of geologic conditions on the proposed development, and opinions and recommendations addressing the adequacy of the site under the proposed grading plan to support the proposed development. This requirement may be waived by written recommendation of the building official if it is deemed unwarranted. C. Issuance: The application, plans, specifications, and other data submitted by an applicant for permit shall be reviewed by the building official. Such plans may be reviewed by other departments or agencies to verify compliance with any applicable laws under their jurisdiction. If the building official finds that the work described in an application for a permit and the plans, specifications, and other data filed therewith conform to the requirements of this title and other pertinent laws and ordinances, and that the fees specified have been paid, he shall issue a permit therefor to the property owner or his authorized agent. When the building official issues the permit where plans are required, he shall endorse in writing or stamp the plans and specifications "APPROVED". Such approved plans and specifications shall not be changed, modified, or altered without authorization from the building official, and all work shall be done in accordance with the approved plans. The building official may require that the site development activities and project designs or specifications be modified if delays occur which may create weather generated problems not considered at the time the permit was issued. D. Fees: City fees associated with reviewing and processing site development permits shall be those listed on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. E. Grading and Erosion Control Standards and Regulations: All site development work shall be accomplished in conformance to the following grading and erosion control design standards and regulations: 1. Hours of Operation: All grading operations within 660 feet of residential land uses shall be carried on between the hours of 7:00 A.M. and 5:30 P.M. The building official may waive this requirement if it is shown that by restricting the hours of operation it would unduly interfere with the development of the property and it is shown that the neighboring properties would not be adversely affected. 2. Dust and Dirt Control: All graded surfaces of any nature shall be dampened or suitably contained to prevent dust or spillage on city streets or adjacent properties. Equipment, materials, and roadways on the site shall be used or treated so as to cause the least possible annoyance due to dirt, mud, or dust conditions. 3. Undevelopable Slopes: Any (1) slope identified on a subdivision plat as undevelopable, (2) slope that has been altered without permits or prior approval to 30% or greater, or (3) natural slopes of 30% or greater (as measured pursuant to a “ten-foot averaging” method as defined in Section 20.50.020), shall be designated undevelopable area. In no event shall streets traverse such slopes. 31 5.Finished Cuts and Slopes: Limitations shall be applied to the extent of cut and fill slopes to minimize the amount of excavated surface or ground area exposed to potential erosion and settlement. • The exposed or finished cuts or slopes of any fill or excavation shall be smoothly graded. • All cut and fill slopes shall be recontoured and revegetated by the permittee in accordance with an approved plan. • Cut or fill slopes shall normally be limited to 15 feet in vertical height. However, upon review and favorable recommendation of the city engineer and public utilities director the building official may approve cut and fill slopes exceeding 15 feet provided that such variations be allowed on a limited basis after thorough review of each request and only when balanced by offsetting improvements to the overall aesthetic, environmental, and engineering quality of the development. • No excavation creating a cut face and no fill creating an exposed surface shall have a slope ratio exceeding one and one- half horizontal to one vertical (11/2:1). • Exceptions: • No slopes shall cut steeper than the bedding plane, fracture, fault, or joint in any formation where the cut slope will lie on the dip of the strike line of the bedding plane, fracture, fault, or joint. • No slopes shall be cut in an existing landslide, mudflow, or other form of naturally unstable slope except as recommended by a qualified geological engineer. • Where the formation is exposed above the top of the cut which will permit the entry of water along bedding planes, this area shall be sealed with a compacted soil blanket having a minimum thickness of 2 feet. The soil for this blanket shall be relatively impervious and shall be approved by the soils engineer or engineering geologist. • If the material of a slope is of such composition and character as to be unstable under the anticipated maximum moisture content, the slope angle shall be reduced to a stable value or retained by a method approved by the city engineer and certified as to its stability by a soils engineer or geologist. Said retaining method shall include design provisions which are: • Conducive to revegetation for soil stability and visual impact; • Used for selected areas of the site and not as a general application; and 32 • Limited to tiers each of which is no higher than 6 feet, separated by plantable terraces a minimum of 2 feet in width; j. Any retaining system shall remain and be maintained on the lots until plans for construction are approved and a building permit is issued. The plans shall include provisions to integrate driveway access to the lot while maintaining the structural integrity of the retaining system. k. The building official may require the slope of a cut or fill to be made more level if at any time it is found that the material being, or the fill, is unusually subject to erosion, static or dynamic instability, or if other conditions make such requirements necessary for stability. l. Driveways leaving public rights of way shall not exceed a maximum change in grade angle of 6% transition over an 11 foot run. The slope should be transitioned beyond property line no more than an average 16% grade. Parking structures may allow a maximum change in grade angle of 10% with a minimum 10 foot run. Maximum sight distance should be encouraged with blind entrances or other sight obstructions complying with the Sight Distance Triangle Requirements as defined and illustrated in Chapter 21A.62. 5. Abatement of Hazardous Conditions: a. If, at any stage of grading, the building official or city engineer determines by inspection that the nature of the formation is such that further work as authorized by an existing permit is likely to imperil any property, public way, watercourse, or drainage structure, the building official or city engineer shall require, as condition to allowing the work to proceed, that reasonable safety precautions be taken as are considered advisable to avoid likelihood of such peril. Such precautions may include, but shall not be limited to, any of the following: (1) Specification of a more level exposed slope; (2) Construction of additional drainage facilities, berms, or terraces; (3) Compaction or cribbing; (4) Installation of plants for erosion control; and/or (5) Reports from a registered soils engineer and/or engineering geologist whose recommendations may be made requirements for further work. Such requirements by the building official or city engineer shall constitute a required change order in the work to be performed under permit. Said changes may be required to be reflected in amended plans. b. Where it appears that damage from storm drainage may result from work performed hereunder, such work may be stopped and the permittee required to take such measures as may be necessary to protect adjoining property or the 33 public safety. On large operations, or where unusual site conditions exist, the building official or city engineer may specify the time at which grading may proceed and the time of completion or may require that the operation be conducted in specific stages so as to ensure completion of protective measures or devices prior to the advent of seasonal rains. 6.Fill Material and Compaction: • Fill Material: All fill shall be earth, rock, or inert material free from organic material and free of metal, except that topsoil spread on cut and fill surfaces may incorporate humus for desirable moisture retention properties. Fill not meeting the definition above shall be placed only in an approved public or private landfill or other approved deposit site. • Backfillings: Any pipe trench or trenching, or excavation made in any slope of any excavated or filled site, shall be backfilled and compacted to the level of the surrounding grade. • Compaction of Fills: Unless otherwise directed by the building official, all fills governed by this title, intended to support building, structures, or where otherwise required to be compacted for stability, shall be compacted, inspected, and tested in accordance with the following provisions: • The natural ground surface shall be prepared by removal of topsoil and vegetation, and, if necessary, shall be graded to a series of terraces. If fill material unacceptable under subsection F6a of this section is placed on the site, or the fill is not placed according to procedures of this title, then it must be removed. • The fill shall be spread and compacted in accordance with the city engineer's approved standards. • The moisture content of the fill material shall be controlled at the time of spreading and compaction to obtain required maximum density. • A written report of the completed compaction, showing location and depth of test holes, materials used, moisture conditions, recommended soil bearing pressures, and relative density obtained from all tests, prepared by a civil engineer or soils engineer licensed by the state of Utah, or testing laboratory shall be submitted to the building official, who shall rely on the expertise of the city engineer for review. • The building official or city engineer may require additional tests or information if, in his opinion, the conditions or materials are such that additional information is necessary, and may modify or delete any of the above listed requirements that, in his opinion, are unnecessary to further the purpose of this title. 34 7.Surcharging: Surcharges shall consist of earth material and shall be applied in such a manner as to have no effect on soil stability on adjacent or neighboring properties. F. Erosion Control and Revegetation: All cut and fill surfaces created by grading shall be planted with a ground cover that is a drought resistant variety. Topsoils are to be stockpiled during rough grading and used on cut and fill slopes. Cuts and fills along public roads are required to be landscaped according to a revegetation plan approved by the city. All plant selections must be approved by the parks department and building official prior to approval. G. Drainage: 1. Adequate provisions shall be made to prevent any surface waters from damaging the cut face of an excavation or any portion of a fill. All drainage ways and structures shall carry surface waters, without producing erosion, to the nearest practical street, storm drain, or natural watercourse as approved by the city engineer. The city engineer may also require drainage structures to be constructed, or installed as necessary to prevent erosion damage or to prevent saturation of the fill or material behind cut slopes. 2. An excess stormwater passage shall be provided for all stormwater storage areas. Such passage shall have capacity to convey through the proposed development the excess stormwater from the tributary watershed. The capacity of such excess stormwater passages shall be constructed in such a manner as to transport the peak rate of runoff from a 100-year return frequency storm assuming all storm sewers are inoperative, all upstream areas are fully developed in accordance with the city's current land use plan, and that antecedent rainfall has saturated the tributary watershed. 3. No buildings or structures shall be constructed within such passage, however, streets, parking lots, playgrounds, park areas, pedestrian walkways, utility easements, and other open space uses shall be considered compatible uses. In the event such passageway is reshaped or its capacity to transport excess stormwater is otherwise restricted during or after construction, the building official or city engineer shall notify the agency, party, or parties causing said restriction to remove the same and set a reasonable time for its removal. If said parties refuse to, or are unable to, comply with said order, the building official or city engineer shall cause said restrictions to be removed at the expense of said parties. Where a proposed development contains existing natural drainage, appropriate planning measures shall be undertaken or required to preserve and maintain said natural drainage as part of the excess stormwater passage. 4. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this title, whenever, in the judgment of the building official or city engineer, a condition occurs in a stormwater storage area or passageway that creates a dangerous and imminent health and safety hazard, the building official or city engineer shall order such action as shall be effective immediately or in the time manner prescribed in the order itself. H. Setbacks: The setback and other restrictions specified in this section are minimum and may be increased by the building official or by the recommendation of a civil engineer, soils engineer, or engineering geologist, if necessary for safety and stability, to prevent damage of 35 adjacent properties from deposition or erosion, or to provide access for slope maintenance and drainage. Setbacks deal with distance from property lines, structures, or faults, and must satisfy the requirements of subsections I1 through I3 of this section. Retaining walls may be used to reduce the required setbacks when approved by the building official. 1. Setbacks from Property Lines: The toes and tops of cut and fill slopes where no structures are located shall be set back from the outer boundaries of a "permit area" (PA = lot area excluding any undevelopable areas) including yard setbacks, slope- right areas, and easements, in accordance with the table and figure 2 of this section. SETBACKS FROM PERMIT AREA BOUNDARY a = Setback distance at toe b = Setback at top H = Height from toe to top of cut/fill slope H a b1 Less than 5'0 1' 5' to 30'H/2 H/5 Over 30'15'6' Note: 1. Additional width may be required for interceptor drain. FIGURE 2 2. Setback from Structures: Setback from cut or fill slopes and structures shall be provided in accordance with figure 3 of this section. 36 FIGURE 3 3. Setbacks from Faults: No structure shall be located over a fault. Determinations of the appropriate setback distance from the fault shall be made based on recommendations contained in the geological report required by subsection C of this section. I. Site Development Inspections: 1. Special Inspections: All site development activities for which a permit or approval is required shall be subject to inspection by the building official. Special inspections of grading operations and special testing shall be performed to ensure conformity with approved plans and specifications. The following special inspections and testing are required: a. Fills: (1) The site is to be inspected prior to placement of fill material. (2) The fill material is to be inspected prior to placement on the site. (3) Final compaction of fill is to be tested. (4) The final grade is to be inspected. (5) Revegetation will be inspected during planting, upon planting completion, and again prior to bond release where applicable. b. Cuts: (1) The site is to be inspected prior to cutting or removing material. (2) The grade is to be inspected after cutting. 37 • Revegetation will be inspected during planting, upon planting completion, and again prior to bond release where applicable. 7. Inspection Schedule and Enforcement: At the time the site development permit or approval is issued, the building official shall establish the stage of development at which required inspections shall be made. In order to obtain inspections, the permittee shall notify the city of readiness at least 24 hours before said inspection is to be made. Where it is found by inspection that conditions are not substantially as stated or shown on the approved plans, the building official or his inspectors may stop further work until approval is obtained for amended plans. J. Completion of Work: 1. Final Reports: Upon completion of the rough grading work and again at the final completion of the work, reports, drawings, and supplements thereto will be required as follows: a. An "as graded" grading plan, prepared by a civil engineer, including original ground surface elevations, lot drainage patterns, and locations and elevations of all surface and subsurface drainage facilities. The engineer shall verify that the work was done in accordance with the final approved site development plan. b. A soil grading report, prepared by a soils engineer, including location and elevations of field density tests, summaries of field and laboratory tests and other substantiating data, and comments on any changes made during grading and their effect on the recommendations made in the soil engineering investigation report. The soils engineer shall verify the adequacy of the site for the intended use. c. A geologic grading report, prepared by an engineering geologist, including a final description of the geology of the site including any new information disclosed during the grading and the effect of the same on recommendations incorporated in the approved site development plan. The engineering geologist shall verify the adequacy of the site for the intended use as affected by geologic factors. This requirement may be modified or waived in writing by the building official if circumstances warrant. 2. Notification of Completion: The permittee, or his authorized agent, shall notify the building official when the grading operation is ready for final inspection. Final approval shall not be given until all work, including installation of all drainage facilities and their protective devices and all erosion control measures including revegetation, have been completed in accordance with the final approved site development plan and the required reports have been submitted. 18.28.050: RESERVED 38 18.28.060: INTERPRETATION, PERMIT PROCEDURE, APPEALS, GROUNDS FOR DENIAL, AND ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS: A. Interpretation; Conflicts: 1. Minimum Requirements: In their interpretation and application, provisions of this chapter shall be held to be minimum requirements, except where expressly stated to be maximum requirements. No intent is made to impair, or interfere with, any private restrictions placed upon any property by covenant or deed; provided, however, that where this chapter imposes higher standards or greater restrictions the provisions of this chapter shall govern. 2. Application of Most Restrictive Standard: Whenever any provision of this chapter or any other provision of law, whether set forth in this chapter or in any other law, ordinance, or resolution of any kind, imposes overlapping or contradictory regulations over the development of land, the most restrictive standards or requirements shall govern. B. Retention of Plans: Plans, specifications, and reports for all site development submitted to Salt Lake City for approval shall be retained by Salt Lake City. C. Expiration, Renewals, and Extensions of Permit: Every site development permit or approval shall expire by limitation and become null and void if the work authorized by such permit or approvals has not been commenced within 180 days, or if the work is suspended or abandoned for a period of 180 days at any time after the work is commenced. Before such work can recommence, the permit shall first be renewed by the building official and the renewal fee shall be 1/2 the amount required for a new permit for such work, provided no changes have been made or will be made in the original plans or scope of such work, otherwise a full fee may be required as determined by the building official. Any modifications to the original approved work that is related to a development for which the Salt Lake City planning commission granted approval, may require subsequent review and decision by the planning commission as determined by the planning director. D. Appeals: 1. Filing: Any applicant aggrieved by a determination of any administrative official in relation to this chapter may appeal such determination to the board of appeals and examiners pursuant to Chapter 18.12. 2. Effect of Administrative Appeal: In the event of an appeal pursuant to the provisions above, the effect of such filing shall act to stay any and all further action and work pending the determination of the matter on appeal. E. General Grounds for Denial: Factors, in addition to deviation from provisions of this chapter, which may be grounds for denial of a site development permit or approval shall include, but not be limited to: 1. Possible or potential saturation of fill and/or unsupported cuts by water (both natural and/or domestic); 39 8.Runoff surface waters that produce unreasonable erosion and/or silting of drainageways; 9.Subsurface conditions (such as rock strata and faults, soil or rock materials, types of formations, etc.) which when disturbed by the proposed site development activity, may create earth movement and/or produce slopes that cannot be landscaped; 10.Result in excessive and unnecessary scarring of the natural landscape through grading or removal of vegetation. A. Prohibited Activities: 1. Removal of Topsoil: It shall be unlawful to remove topsoil for purposes of resale when unrelated to a bona fide purpose of site development contemplated under this chapter. The provisions of this chapter shall not be construed as permitting the removal of topsoil solely for resale. 2. Nuisance: It shall be unlawful to create or maintain a condition which creates a public or private nuisance. After notice by the city, owners shall be strictly responsible to take any necessary action to correct or abate such nuisance. Further, this chapter shall not be construed to authorize any person or owner to create or maintain a private or public nuisance upon real property and compliance with the provisions of this chapter shall not be a defense in any action to abate such nuisance. B. Permit or Approval Revocation: In the event the building official or city engineer revokes a site development permit any aggrieved party may appeal such decision pursuant to Chapter 18.12. C. Property Owner Responsibility: Property owners are responsible to maintain their property in a safe, nonhazardous, condition and to otherwise comply with the provisions of this chapter and other applicable ordinances. Failure of city officials to observe or to recognize hazardous or unsightly conditions, or to recommend denial of the site development permit, shall not relieve the permittee, or property owner, from responsibility for the condition or damages resulting therefrom. Nor shall such action result in the city, its officers, or agents, becoming responsible or liable for conditions and damages resulting therefrom. D. Obstruction Prohibited: It shall be unlawful for any person to willfully or carelessly obstruct or injure any public right of way by causing or permitting earth or rock to slump, slough, or erode off private property onto the public right of way. E. Flooding: It shall be unlawful for any person to willfully or carelessly obstruct or injure any public right of way by causing or permitting flow or seepage of water, or by willfully or carelessly causing or permitting water under his/her control, possession, or supervision to escape in any manner so as to injure any street or public improvement. F. Violation And Penalties: It shall be unlawful for any person to construct, enlarge, alter, repair, or maintain any grading, excavation or fill or cause the same to be done, contrary to or in violation of any provision of this chapter. 40 SECTION 8. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.32. That Chapter 18.32 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Building Regulations) is hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.32 BUILDING REGULATIONS 18.32.020: BUILDING CODE AND STANDARDS ADOPTED: The edition of the uniform building code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission as the construction standard to be adhered to by subdivisions of the state (section 58-56-4, Utah Code Annotated, or its successor section) is adopted by Salt Lake City, together with the following chapters of the appendix to the uniform building code: Chapter 3 Division IV - Requirements For Group R, Division 4 Occupancies; Chapter 11 Division I - Site Accessibility; Chapter 11 Division II - Accessibility For Existing Buildings; Chapter 15 Reroofing; Chapter 16 Division I - Snow Load Design; Chapter 16 Division III - Earthquake Regulations For Seismic Isolated Structures; Chapter 31 Division II - Membrane Structure; Chapter 33 Excavation And Grading. ICC/MBI Standard for Off-Site Construction: Planning, Design, Fabrication and Assembly, or its successor document. Hereafter, all references in this code to the uniform building code shall mean the said edition adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. One copy of the uniform building code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. 18.32.035: FEES: A.Building permit fees shall be based on the total valuation of the proposed project as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. B.Plan review fees shall be sixty five percent (65%) of the building permit fees. C.Fees to expedite building plan review as governed by section 18.20.050 of this title shall be two (2) times the standard building plan review fee. 41 A.Penalties for not obtaining permanent certificate of occupancy will be three hundred dollars ($300.00) for each month, after the initial thirty (30) day temporary certificate of occupancy, which has no additional cost associated with it; due before the first of the month and only allowed for up to three (3) renewals after the initial free thirty (30) day period. Partial months will not be refunded. B.Fees for renewing expired plan review after one hundred eighty (180) days as governed by section 18.20.110 of this title shall be shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. C.A fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be charged for each permit for fencing. D. Other fees shall consist of electrical, mechanical and plumbing, and fire suppression and monitoring equipment inspection fees as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.32.050: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 3 DIVISION V ADDED; NONCONFORMING BUILDING CONVERSION: Appendix chapter 3 of the uniform building code be, and the same hereby is, amended by adding chapter 3 division V to create a group R division 5 occupancy classification and requirements applicable to change in occupancy when nonconforming group R divisions 1 and 3 occupancies undergo conversion, which shall read as follows: Chapter 3 Division V Requirements For Group R Division 5 Occupancies Sec. 344. Group R, Division 5 Occupancies Defined. Group R, division 5 occupancies shall be: nonconforming group R divisions 1 and 3 structures undergoing conversion. Sec. 345. General Provisions. Because conversion changes the original anticipated ownership plan for a multi-family dwelling unit project from a single ownership into a hybrid mixture of separate ownership of dwelling units combined with collective ownership of common areas through association, etc., each nonconforming group R division 1 or division 3 structure being converted into a condominium project or other type of ownership arrangement involving separate ownership of individual units combined with joint or collective ownership of common areas shall constitute a change in classification of occupancy to that of a group R division 5 and shall comply with basic requirements of this code and the specific requirements listed below. All work on such structures in the form of additions, alterations, or repairs shall conform to applicable standards as required by section 3403 of this code. Where said provisions require conformity to requirements governing new buildings, the applicable requirements of group R division 1 or 3 new construction shall apply. Special Provisions And Minimum Standards. Sec. 346. Property Report. Each conversion project to obtain approval shall submit two copies of a property report prepared by a licensed engineer or architect which discloses and describes: 42 (1) The age of the building or buildings, (2) The general condition, useful life, and capacity of the building's structural elements including the roof, foundations, mechanical system, electrical system, plumbing system, boiler, and other structural elements; (3) All known conditions constituting deficiencies requiring repair to meet existing building codes; and (4) All known conditions which may require repair or replacement within the next succeeding five year period. (5) The existing conditions meet the standards of the Salt Lake City existing residential housing code sections 18.50.140, Exterior Standards; 18.50.150, Interior Standards; 18.50.180, Space And Occupancy Standards; 18.50.190, Light And Ventilation; 18.50.200 Fire Safety-Egress. The building report, as required in section 20.56.060 of the city code, shall note all deficiencies; appeals of noted deficiencies may be addressed to the housing advisory and appeals board. Said report shall certify the structure currently conforms to applicable codes or the owner shall present plans to bring the structures into conformity with applicable building codes prior to issuance of certificates of occupancy. Sec. 347. Electrical Service Minimum Standards. Each converted dwelling unit shall have an electrical service which provides: (1) A minimum service of 60 amps. (2) Receptacle outlets are required to meet standards of the national electrical code, section 210-21(b). Each habitable room shall have no less than two such receptacles. (3) Where a kitchen is provided, or required by this code, each kitchen shall be installed on a separate circuit. (4) If, as an option, dishwashers or garbage disposals are to be installed or provided for, each must be located on a separate circuit. If such appliances or optional capacity are not provided, the limitation must be disclosed to buyers and in the property report. (5) All bathrooms are to be equipped with GFIC outlet. (6) Lights and fixtures in all storage and equipment facilities over 84 sq. ft. in size. (7) Installation of a smoke detector conforming to manufacturer's recommendations shall be installed in each dwelling unit as a local detection unit. If the building has a common exit hall or corridor then a general automatic detection system shall be installed with the capability of sending a signal to a remote station. (8) Installation of at least one wall switch controlled lighting outlet in every habitable room, bathrooms, hallways, stairways, attached garages, and outdoor entrances. All electrical work and repair must be completed under permit and comply with applicable codes and ordinances. 43 Sec. 348. Plumbing And Water Systems. (a) Plumbing System. A mechanical engineer, licensed plumbing contractor, or a licensed general contractor shall calculate and determine the capacity of the current plumbing system, including the existing and potential load in fixture units (as determined by the uniform plumbing code) as part of the property report required above. All new installations or repairs must be completed under permit and shall conform to applicable plumbing codes. The entire system shall be brought up to applicable standards of this code when required by section 3403. The impact of new installations upon the existing system shall be calculated and stated in the property report. (b) Water Supply. Water piping shall be so arranged that the water supply can be turned on or off to any individual fixture; provided, however, that supply piping to a single unit and building accessory thereto may be controlled by one valve. Sec. 349. Mechanical System. The mechanical system for each converted dwelling unit shall: (1) Equip each unit with its own heating system, except where a central water or steam system is present. (2) Provide each unit with its own means of controlling temperature when the building utilizes a central heating plant. All mechanical work and repair shall be completed under permit and comply with applicable codes. Sec. 350. Discretion Of Building Official To Waive Minor Deviations. The foregoing minimum standards are intended to be fully complied with prior to the building official's approval of permits, record of survey maps, plans or certificates. However, the building official may waive literal compliance with said standards for minor deviations and non-dangerous conditions, if the official determines that strict compliance with the requirements of this chapter would be impractical due to the unique condition of the property, or result in an unnecessary and extreme hardship for the owner of the property. The building official may in such cases impose additional reasonable and equivalent conditions upon the project. Sec. 351. All condominiums shall meet the requirements as listed in 18.96.050 (fit premises) of the city ordinance. 18.32.060: UBC SECTION 109.1 AMENDED; CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: Section 109.1 of the uniform building code is amended to read as follows: Section 109.1 Use Or Occupancy. No building or structure of groups A, B, E, F, H, I, M, R and S occupancy shall be used or occupied, and no change in the existing occupancy classification of a building or structure or portion thereof shall be made until the building official has issued a certificate of occupancy therefor as provided herein. 18.32.090: UBC SECTION 204 AMENDED; DEFINITIONS: 44 Section 204 of the uniform building code, adopted by section 18.32.020 of this chapter, or its successor, is amended by adding definitions of condominiums and conversions which shall read as follows: Condominium, Condominium Project, Condominium Unit. For purposes of this code, "condominium," "condominium project," and "condominium units" or "units" means property or portions thereof conforming to the definitions set forth in section 57-8-3 of Utah Code Annotated, 1953, as amended. Conversion. "Conversion" means a proposed change in the type of ownership in a parcel or parcels of land, together with existing attached structures, from single ownership of said parcel such as an apartment house or multi-family dwelling into a condominium project or other ownership arrangements involving separate ownership of individual units combined with joint or collective ownership of common areas, facilities, or elements. 18.32.120: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 35 ADDED; FLOOD HAZARD AREAS: The uniform building code is amended by adding a new appendix chapter 35, which reads as follows: Sec. 3501. Floodplain Hazard Area. For the purpose of this chapter "floodplain hazard area" shall mean those lands lying within the corporate limits of Salt Lake City as defined in section 18.68.020 of the Salt Lake City code, as being located within the boundaries of flood hazard boundary map as defined in said section 18.68.020 and adopted by section 18.68.030 of the Salt Lake City code. A copy of said map and amendments is on file for public examination in the offices of the city recorder and city engineer. Sec. 3502. Floodplain Protection Requirements. All plans involving development, repair, substantial improvements to, or construction of building or structures within the floodplain hazard area shall comply with the standards set forth in chapter 18.68 of the Salt Lake City code relating to floodplain hazard regulations. 18.32.130: UBC APPENDIX CHAPTER 33 AMENDED; EXCAVATION AND GRADING: Appendix chapter 33 of the uniform building code, relating to excavation and grading, is hereby amended by deleting the text of sections 3304 through 3318 and amending by adding a cross reference, so appendix chapter 33 shall read as follows: Appendix Chapter 33 Excavation And Grading Sec. 3304-3318. Said sections and their revised text are hereby deleted, having been incorporated within the text of chapter 18.28 of the Salt Lake City code relating to site development regulations, drawing particular reference to provisions within chapters 4 and 5 of said development regulations. 45 18.32.140: SENIOR CITIZEN APARTMENT FEE ABATEMENT: Qualified multi-family apartment projects may apply to, and receive from, the building official an abatement of the normal building permit fees. In order for the building official to approve the discount, the applicant must submit necessary documentation in order for the building official to certify that the apartment project qualifies under the following criteria: A. The project is owned and/or operated as a bona fide organization for providing housing for senior citizens; B. The project operators and/or property owners stipulate that all units shall be rented by persons over age sixty two (62) years of age; C. Operators and/or property owners agree to verify ages of tenants as part of their annual application for an apartment house license; D.Project operators and property owners execute an agreement, binding upon successors in interest and secured by the real property, to reimburse the city the amount of the abated fees plus interest from the date of the permit at the rate applicable to judgment, should the rate of occupancy by qualified senior citizens drop below ninety five percent (95%) during the next thirty (30) years. This occupancy rate shall be determined annually as of the date the annual license application is submitted to the city; and E.The amount of the fees abated, plus interest at the then established rate applicable to judgments from date of the abated fees, shall be repaid to the city upon a subsequent application to convert the project to condominium or other ownership arrangements involving sale of separate units, if submitted within thirty (30) years of such abatement. 18.32.150: UBC SECTION 103 AMENDED; VIOLATIONS AND PENALTIES: Section 103 of the uniform building code is amended to read as follows: It shall be unlawful for any person, firm, or corporation to erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, improve, remove, convert, or demolish, equip, use, occupy, or maintain any building or structure in the city, or cause the same to be done contrary to or in violation of any of the provisions of this code. Any person, firm, or corporation violating any of the provisions of this code shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and each such person shall be deemed guilty of a separate offense for each and every day or portion thereof during which any violation of any of the provisions of this code is committed, continued, or permitted and upon conviction of any such violation such persons shall be punishable by a fine as provided by section 1.12.050, or its successor, of the Salt Lake City code. 46 SECTION 9. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.36. That Chapter 18.36 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Electrical Regulations) is hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.36 ELECTRICAL REGULATIONS 18.36.010: ELECTRICAL CODE ADOPTED BY REFERENCE: The edition of the national electrical code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission, is adopted by Salt Lake City as the ordinances, rules and regulations of the city, subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set forth in this chapter, one copy of which code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. Hereafter, all references in this code to the national electrical code shall mean the edition of the national electrical code adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. 18.36.100: PERMIT FEES; RESIDENTIAL WORK: The following fees for a permit for the installation of electrical materials in residences, including multiapartment buildings, shall be paid to the city treasurer before any permit is valid. The basic fee for each permit requiring inspection is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.36.110: FEE FOR TEMPORARY METERING: The fee for permit for temporary metering and service facilities shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.36.120: COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL FEES: The fees to be paid to the city treasurer for electrical permits covering work in industrial or commercial properties shall be computed as follows: A. Minimum Fee: Minimum fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. B. New Service Or Change Of Service: For new service, change of service, alterations or repairs of six hundred (600) volt or less capacity service entrance equipment, the fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 47 A. Subfeeders: Fee for installation, alteration or repair of subfeeders, including supply taps from subfeeders, shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. B. Transformers: The installation of transformers shall be subject to inspection fee when such transformers are an integral part of the consumer's distribution system. Such fee shall be in addition to the regular system inspection fee and shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. C. Motor Generator: The fee for installation of a motor generator for emergency or standby shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. D. Alternate Fee Schedule: Electrical permit fees shall be computed on the schedules set forth on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule and shall be paid prior to work being started. When a fee cannot be computed on the standard schedules, it shall be computed based on the alternate schedule shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.36.130: ELECTRICAL WORK EXCEEDING ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS: When the cost of electrical work exceeds one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00), electrical permit fees shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.36.170: POWER TO PANEL PERMITS; REQUIRED WHEN: All new construction shall require a power to panel permit in accordance with section 18.36.180 of this chapter, or its successor section, to be issued in conjunction with the required electrical permit. 18.36.180: POWER TO PANEL PERMIT; FOR CONSTRUCTION PURPOSES ONLY: A. Temporary Basis: A power to panel permit shall authorize power for construction purposes on a temporary basis only; permanent power must be authorized separately. B. Permit: At the time power to panel is required to complete construction, the owner or contractor shall apply for and obtain a separate power to panel construction permit. Said permit shall be valid for a sixty (60) day period. C. Extensions: Thirty (30) day extensions for such permit may be issued upon the approval of building and housing services and upon payment of one-half (1/2) of the original permit fee for each extension. D. Certificate Of Occupancy: Final electrical approval for permanent power shall be withheld until a certificate of occupancy is issued. Occupancy occurring prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy shall result in a discontinuance of all power until occupancy is approved or until occupancy ceases. 48 E. Expiration: Upon expiration of a power to panel construction permit, all power to the electrical panel shall be discontinued. F. Fees: 60 day, no issue fee $20.00 30 day extension 7.00 18.36.210: VIOLATION; PENALTY: Any person, firm or corporation, whether acting as owner or occupant of the premises involved, or contractor, or otherwise, who violates or refuses to comply with any provisions of this title, or the national electrical code, as amended, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor. A separate offense shall be deemed to be committed on each day an offense occurs or continues. SECTION 10. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.48. That Chapter 18.48 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Dangerous Buildings) is hereby amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.48 DANGEROUS BUILDINGS ARTICLE I. REPAIR AND VACATION OF DANGEROUS BUILDINGS 18.48.010: TITLE: This chapter shall implement the Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings, 1997 Edition. 18.48.020: PURPOSE AND SCOPE: It is the purpose of this chapter to provide just, equitable, and practicable methods to require the repair (including temporary boarding) and vacation of buildings or structures that endanger the life, limb, health, morals, property, safety, or welfare of the general public or their occupants. 18.48.030: DEFINITIONS: 49 BUILDING CODE: The International Building Code, or its successor, promulgated by the International Code Council, as adopted by the state. BOARDED BUILDING: A building in which accessible openings, such as windows and doors, are secured by a secondary means against entry. Examples of securing a building by a secondary means includes, but is not limited to, boarding and fencing. DANGEROUS BUILDINGS: Any building or structure that has any or all of the conditions or defects hereinafter described may be deemed to be a dangerous building, provided that such conditions or defects exist to the extent that the life, health, property, or safety of the public or its occupants are endangered. A. Whenever any door, aisle, passageway, stairway or other means of exit is not of sufficient width or size or is not so arranged as to provide safe and adequate means of exit in case of fire or panic. B. Whenever the walking surface of any aisle, passageway, stairway or other means of exit is so warped, worn, loose, torn or otherwise unsafe as to not provide safe and adequate means of exit in case of fire or panic. C. Whenever the stress in any materials, member or portion thereof, due to all dead and live loads, is more than 1.5 times the working stress or stresses allowed in the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose or location. D. Whenever any portion thereof has been damaged by fire, earthquake, wind, flood, or by any other cause, to such an extent that the structural strength or stability thereof is materially less than it was before such catastrophe and is less than the minimum requirements of the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose, or location. E. Whenever any portion or member or appurtenance thereof is likely to fail, or to become detached or dislodged, or to collapse and thereby injure persons or damage property. F. Whenever any portion of a building, or any member, appurtenance, or ornamentation on the exterior thereof is not of sufficient strength or stability, or is not so anchored, attached, or fastened in place so as to be capable of resisting a wind pressure of one half of that specified in the Building Code for new buildings of similar structure, purpose or location without exceeding the working stresses permitted in the Building Code for such buildings. G. Whenever any portion of a building or structure has wracked, warped, buckled, or settled to such an extent that walls or other structural portions have materially less resistance to winds or earthquakes than is required in the case of similar new construction. H. Whenever the building or structure, or any portion thereof, because of (i) dilapidation, deterioration or decay; (ii) faulty construction; (iii) the removal, movement or instability of any portion of the ground necessary for the purpose of supporting such building; (iv) the deterioration, decay or inadequacy of its foundation; or (v) any other cause, is likely to partially or completely collapse. 50 A. Whenever, for any reason, the building or structure, or any portion thereof, is manifestly unsafe for the purpose for which it is being used. B. Whenever the exterior walls or other vertical structural members list, lean, or buckle to such an extent that a plumb line passing through the center of gravity does not fall inside the middle one third of the base. C. Whenever the building or structure, exclusive of the foundation, shows 33% or more damage or deterioration of its supporting member or members, or 50% damage or deterioration of its non-supporting members, enclosing or outside walls or coverings. D. Whenever the building or structure has been so damaged by fire, wind, earthquake, or flood, or has become so dilapidated or deteriorated as to become an attractive nuisance to children or as to enable persons to resort thereto for the purpose of committing unlawful acts. E. Whenever any building or structure has been constructed, exists, or is maintained in violation of any specific requirement or prohibition applicable to such building or structure provided by the building regulations of this jurisdiction, as specified in the Building Code or Housing Code, or of any law or ordinance of this state or jurisdiction relating to the condition, location, or structure of buildings. F. Whenever any building or structure which, whether or not erected in accordance with all applicable laws and ordinances, has in any non-supporting part, member or portion less than 50%, or in any supporting part, member or portion less than 66% of the (i) strength, (ii) fire-resisting qualities or characteristics, or (iii) weather-resisting qualities or characteristics required by law in the case of a newly constructed building of like area, height and occupancy in the same location. G. Whenever a building or structure, used or intended to be used for dwelling purposes, because of inadequate maintenance, dilapidation, decay, damage, faulty construction or arrangement, inadequate light, air or sanitation facilities, or otherwise, is determined by the health officer to be unsanitary, unfit for human habitation, or in such a condition that is likely to cause sickness or disease. H. Whenever any building or structure, because of obsolescence, dilapidated condition, deterioration, damage, inadequate exits, lack of sufficient fire-resistive construction, faulty electric wiring, gas connections or heating apparatus, or other cause, is determined by the fire marshal to be a fire hazard. I. Whenever any building or structure is in such a condition as to constitute a public nuisance known to the common law or in equity jurisprudence. J. Whenever any portion of a building or structure remains on a site after the demolition or destruction of the building or structure or whenever any building or structure is abandoned for a period in excess of six months so as to constitute such building or portion thereof an attractive nuisance or hazard to the public. HOUSING CODE: The Salt Lake City Existing Residential Housing Ordinance as promulgated in Chapter 18.50 of the City Code. 51 VACANT/SECURE BUILDING: An unoccupied building having all openings, such as windows and doors, secured against entry, where windows are fully glazed and the doors are secured by means of a lock. 18.48.040: AUTHORITY TO ENFORCE: A. Authority to Enforce: The building official or designee is hereby authorized to enforce the provisions of this chapter. B. Authority to Inspect: The building official or their designee is hereby authorized to make inspections and take such actions as may be required to enforce the provisions of this chapter. C. Buildings or Structures Subject to Inspection: Any building or structure, where there is reasonable cause to believe a condition exists that renders the building or structure endangering the life, limb, health, morals, property, safety, or welfare of the general public or the structure’s occupants, is subject to inspection by the building official or their designee. 18.48.050: PROCEDURES UPON DETERMINATION OF A VIOLATION: When the building official has inspected or caused to be inspected any building and has found and determined that such building is a dangerous building, the building official shall follow the enforcement procedures set forth in the 1997 Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings. 18.48.060: RESERVED 18.48.070: RESERVED 18.48.080: APPEALS: Appeals of a notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter shall be taken in accordance with Chapter 18.12. 18.48.090: CITY'S ABATEMENT OF PROPERTY: If the property owner does not comply with the notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter within the time specified in the notice and order, the building official or designees may cause the building to be repaired, vacated, or temporarily boarded to the extent necessary to correct the conditions which render the building dangerous as set forth in the notice and order. Any such 52 repair, vacation, or boarding shall be completed and the cost thereof paid and recovered as set forth in this chapter. 18.48.100: RECOVERY OF COSTS: A. Permitted Recovery of Costs: If the building official or designee causes the repair, vacation, or boarding of a building pursuant to a notice issued under this chapter, and after the property owner received at least 10 days’ notice in which to complete the repair, vacation or boarding and failed to do so, the division may collect the cost of that abatement, by filing a property tax lien, as set forth in this section. B. Itemized Statement of Costs: Upon completion of the repair, vacation, or boarding work, the building official or designee shall prepare an itemized statement of costs and mail it to the property owner by certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, demanding payment within 30 days of the date the statement is post marked. The administrative fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule to cover the city's administrative expenses in contracting for the repair, boarding, or other abatement costs shall be included in the statement of costs. C. Form of Itemized Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs shall include: 1. The address of the property at issue; 2. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the division, including administrative costs; 3. A demand for payment; 4. The address where payment is to be made; 5. Notification that failure to timely pay the expenses described in the itemized statement may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter and Utah Code Section 10-11-4 or its successor; 6. Notification that the property owner may file a written objection to all or part of the statement within 20 days of the date the statement is postmarked; and 7. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the name of the office and the mailing address. D. Delivery of Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs described in Subsection C shall be deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the property owner, according to the records of the county recorder. E. Objection to Statement of Costs: A property owner may appeal the statement of costs to the fines hearing officer, only as to the issue of whether the costs were actually incurred, pursuant to Section 18.12.050. 53 A. Failure to Object or Pay: If the property owner fails to make payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement within 30 days of the date of the mailing of that statement, or to file a timely objection, then the division may certify the past due costs and expenses to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. B. Failure to Pay after Objection Hearing: If the property owner files a timely objection but fails to make payment of any amount ordered by the fines hearing officer within 30 days of the date of the hearing, the inspector may certify the past due costs and expense to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. C. Lien on Property: After entry by the Salt Lake County Treasurer, as set forth in Subsections F and G, the amount entered shall have the force and effect of a valid judgment of the district court, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by the Salt Lake County Treasurer at the time of the payment of general taxes. D. Release of Lien: Upon payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement of costs or otherwise determined due and owing by the fines hearing officer, the judgment is satisfied, the lien is released from the property, and receipt shall be acknowledged upon the general tax receipt issued by the treasurer. 18.48.110: APPLICABILITY OF BUILDING CODE: All buildings or structures which are required to be repaired under the provisions of this chapter shall be subject to the provisions of the applicable construction codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. 18.48.120: PUBLIC NUISANCES: A. Declaration and Abatement of Public Nuisances: All buildings or structures or portions thereof which are determined after inspection by the building official to be dangerous are hereby declared to be public nuisances and shall be abated by repair, vacation, or boarding in accordance with the procedures specified herein. B. Boarded or Vacant Building as Public Nuisance: Any structure that is vacant or which has been boarded may be declared a public nuisance upon a determination that the structure is detrimental to the safety or public welfare of the residents and property values of this city. ARTICLE II. BOARDING OR TEMPORARILY SECURING BUILDINGS 18.48.200: SCOPE AND APPLICABILITY: 54 The provisions of this article apply to any person or entity who is ordered to board a building under Article I and any person or entity who voluntarily boards a building. 18.48.205: REGISTRATION: A. Registration Required: Registration is required to board a building. In the case where the city causes the boarding work to be done pursuant to Section 18.48.245, the city will register the property on which the building is located and will bill the record owner the yearly registration fee pursuant to Section 18.48.215. In the case where the building official causes temporary boarding work to be done pursuant to Section 18.48.090 and the building is boarded for more than 45 days, the provisions of this Article II shall apply. B. Registration Process: Registration of a property on which a boarded structure shall be located must be done on a form provided by the building official or designee. The form shall specify the following: 1. The address of the structure to be boarded or temporarily secured; 2. The type of building; 3. For residential structures, the number of dwelling units; 4. For nonresidential buildings, the number of square feet of all building faces at ground level; 5. The name, address, and telephone number of a person authorized to act as an agent for the owner for performing the owner's obligations under this article, who lives within 40 miles of Salt Lake City; and 6. Whether the property has the required external water source for landscaping, if landscaping is required. 18.48.210: NOTICE OF REGISTRATION: Upon registration the city may record with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of registration. The recordation of a notice of registration shall not be deemed an encumbrance on the property but shall merely place interested parties on notice that the cost of City abatement activities conducted pursuant to Section 18.48.245 may be outstanding and recoverable as a lien on the property in accordance with Section 18.48.100. Once the building official determines that the property is no longer subject to registration then a notice of deregistration shall be recorded. Recordation of the notice of deregistration shall have the effect of canceling the recorded notice of registration. 18.48.215: YEARLY REGISTRATION FEES: 55 A. Annual Fee: Upon registration and on each yearly anniversary of the date the property was registered pursuant to this article, a property owner desiring to maintain a boarded building shall pay the annual boarding registration fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. Properties that are defined as a “contributing structure” or “landmark site” pursuant to Section 21A.34.020 shall be subject to a higher registration fee. B. Late Penalty and Interest: If annual registration fees are not timely paid, an accounts receivable fee and interest shall accrue pursuant to Section 3.16.040. C. Failure to Register: Boarding a building before registering pursuant to this article shall result in a fine of up to 25% of the boarding registration fee specified in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. D. Collection of Fees: If the property owner fails to pay the boarding registration fees, the city may take legal action to collect any amounts owed. 18.48.220: POSTING OF BOARDED OR CLOSED TO OCCUPANCY BUILDINGS: Whenever a building is boarded or closed to occupancy, the city shall be authorized to install a sign to be mounted on the exterior of the building. The sign shall state that the building is closed to occupancy and that it is unlawful for any unauthorized person to enter the building. The sign shall also provide phone numbers to call if people are seen on the property or if doors or windows are unsecured. 18.48.225: METHOD OF SECURING BUILDINGS: All buildings shall be boarded in the following manner: A. Securing Opening: All openings in the structure on the first floor, other openings easily accessible from the ground, and openings with broken glass, shall be secured either by erecting a single 1/2 inch thick layer of plywood sheathing or similar material, not to include chipboard/OSB, covering over all exterior openings, overlapping the opening on every edge by 3 inches, affixed along the edges by nails or screws spaced every 6 inches. B. Alternatives to Securing Openings: Alternately, the openings may be secured by conventional wood frame construction. The frames shall use wood studs of a size not less than 2 inches by 4 inches (nominal dimension) placed not more than 24 inches apart on center. The frame stud shall have the 4 inch sides or the wide dimension perpendicular to the face of the wall. Each side of the frame shall be covered with plywood sheathing or similar material of at least 1/2 inch thickness or equivalent lumber nailed over the opening by using nails or screws spaced every 6 inches on the outside edges and every 12 inches along intermediate stud supports; and C. Exterior Doors: Exterior doors shall be secured by a strong non-glass door adequately locked to preclude entry of unauthorized persons, or shall be covered as an opening described in Subsection A or B of this section or successor sections. 56 18.48.230: LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE: Existing landscaping and lawn on the property shall be maintained in the manner otherwise required by Chapters 9.16 and 21A.48. 18.48.235: EXTERIOR MAINTENANCE: A. Exterior of Building: The exterior of a boarded building shall be maintained as required by relevant requirements set forth in Section 18.50.140. In particular, exterior walls and surfaces shall be properly maintained and severely weathered, peeling, or unpainted wood and damaged siding and roofing shall be replaced or repaired with similar materials and colors. B. Salvage Permit Required: Doors, windows, special glass, fixtures, fittings, pipes, railings, posts, panels, boards, lumber, stones, bricks, marble, or similar materials within the interior of a boarded building shall not be salvaged except upon the issuance of a permit as provided in Section 18.64.070. 18.48.240: SNOW AND ICE REMOVAL: Snow and ice must be removed from public sidewalk areas surrounding the boarded property in the manner indicated in Section 14.20.070. 18.48.245: CITY MAINTENANCE OF PROPERTY: A. Notice: If the building official or the building official's designee determines that a boarded building and/or property is not being maintained, the building official or the building official's designee shall issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 18.24.040 requiring compliance with the building maintenance standards as required in city code. B. Failure to Comply with Notice: If the building official or designee determines that the property owner has failed to comply with the notice and order, the city may cause the work to be done by a contractor hired by the city and the city may recover its abatement costs in accordance with the process set forth in Section 18.48.100. 18.48.250: CITY MAINTENANCE OF LANDSCAPING: If the building official or the building official's designee determines that the landscaping on the property surrounding a boarded building is not being maintained as required by city code, the building official or the building official's designee shall follow the notice of violation and corrective measures procedures as detailed in Sections 9.16.050 and 9.16.060. 57 18.48.255: VIOLATIONS: A. It is unlawful for the building owner to fail to maintain the boarded building or ensure the building remains vacated after the property has been abated by either the city or the building owner. Each day a violation occurs shall be a separate offense. B. Violations of the provisions of this chapter are punishable in accordance with Chapter 18.24. 18.48.260: BUILDING INSPECTIONS REQUIRED: Whenever a property owner, manager, or tenant intends to clean, repair, renovate, reopen or reoccupy a building that has been boarded, the building is to be inspected by the building official or designee and a permit must be issued by building services or its successor prior to the building owner, manager, or tenant initiating any of the above actions. Any person conducting any work on a building that has been boarded or closed to occupancy must have a valid building permit at all times. SECTION 11. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.50. That Chapter 18.50 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Existing Residential Housing) is hereby amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.50 EXISTING RESIDENTIAL HOUSING 18.50.010: TITLE: This chapter shall be known as the SALT LAKE CITY EXISTING RESIDENTIAL HOUSING ORDINANCE. 18.50.020: PURPOSE AND SCOPE: A. Purpose: The purpose of this chapter is to provide for the health, safety, comfort, convenience and aesthetics of Salt Lake City and its present and future inhabitants and businesses, to protect the tax base, and to protect property values within the city, as provided by Section 10-9a-102 of the Utah Code, or its successor section, and other applicable state statutes. This purpose shall be accomplished by regulating the maintenance, repair and remodeling of residential buildings specified in this chapter existing as of the date of enactment hereof by: 58 11.Establishing minimum housing standards for all buildings or portions thereof used, or designed or intended to be used, for human habitation; 12.Establishing minimum standards for safety from fire and other hazards; 13.Promoting maintenance and improvement of structures by applying standards of this chapter to renovations. This chapter allows distinctions in the application of standards based on the year a structure was built, as long as a reasonable level of safety is achieved; 14.Avoiding the closure or abandonment of housing and the displacement of occupants where such can be done without sacrificing the public health, safety and welfare; 15.Providing for the administration, enforcement and penalties for this chapter. B. Scope: 1. Application to Existing Buildings: This chapter encompasses fire safety and structural integrity of existing residential buildings. Within the structures, the scope includes equipment and facilities for light, ventilation, heating, sanitation, protection from the elements, space requirements, and for safe and sanitary maintenance. 2. Application to Remodeling of Existing Residential Buildings: This chapter shall apply to remodeling or renovation of all residential buildings existing as of the date of enactment hereof as follows: a. This chapter applies regardless of tenancy, regardless of the valuation of the renovations, and regardless of the date of such remodeling or renovation, unless otherwise noted in this chapter. b. The requirements of this chapter are minimums. During a renovation or remodeling project, whenever conditions exist which allow such work to comply with the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, such codes shall apply. c. When a construction standard is omitted from this chapter, the applicable standard shall be the state construction codes adopted and in effect at the time the building was constructed or at the time the relevant electrical, mechanical, or plumbing element was installed, whichever is later. d. When the purpose of the renovation is to create new dwelling units, the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040 shall apply. 3. Application to New Construction: From the date of adoption hereof, newly constructed buildings must comply with the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. All additions to an existing building envelope shall comply with the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. 59 16.Change of Use: Any building undergoing a change which intensifies the use shall comply with the provisions of the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. 17.Permits Required: Except as provided in this subsection, no building or structure regulated by this chapter shall be erected, constructed, enlarged, altered, moved, removed, converted, or demolished unless a separate permit for each building or structure has first been obtained from the building official. Except where required by state law, permits are not required for those items identified in Section 105.2 of the International Building Code and International Residential Code, or as otherwise directed by the building official. C. Violations: It is unlawful for any person to: 1. Erect, construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, improve, remove, convert, or demolish, equip, use, occupy or maintain any building or structure or cause or permit the same to be done in violation of this chapter; 2. Fail to obey a notice and order issued pursuant to this chapter; 3. Occupy, or rent for occupancy, a building that has been closed to occupancy; or 4. Fail to obey an interpretation, decision or requirement of the board of appeals and examiners. 18.50.030: DEFINITIONS: A. Construction of Terms: For the purpose of this chapter, certain terms, phrases, words, and their derivations shall be construed as specified in this section. Words used in the singular include the plural, and words used in the plural include the singular. B. Whole Includes Part: Whenever the words "apartment house", "building", "dormitory", "dwelling unit", "habitable room", "hotel", "housing unit" or "structure" are used in this chapter such words shall be construed as if followed by the words "or any portion thereof". C. Referenced Documents: References to codes, ordinances, chapters, sections, or subsections shall include any successor to such code, ordinance, chapter, section, or subsection that has been adopted by the city. D. Defined Terms: AGENT: Any person, firm, partnership, association, joint venture, corporation, or other entity who acts for or on behalf of others. BASEMENT: A floor level, any part of which is more than 4 feet below grade for more than 50% of the total perimeter or more than 8 feet below grade at any point. BATHROOM: A room containing at least one of each of the following fixtures: sink, toilet, and tub or shower. It may also include a bidet. 60 BEDROOM: Any space designed or used for sleeping. BOARDING HOUSE: The same as defined in Title 21A. BUILDING: Any structure which is used, designed or intended to be used for human habitation. BUILDING CLOSURE, CLOSED TO ENTRY, OR CLOSED TO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY: A building which has been closed to occupancy. BUILDING INSPECTOR: A person designated by the building official to make inspections of buildings and properties covered by this chapter. CEILING HEIGHT: The vertical distance from the finished floor to finished ceiling or to the lowest point of the ceiling framing members. Where obstructions other than lighting fixtures exist below the ceiling, the height shall be measured from the obstruction to the finished floor. CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: A certificate issued by the building official authorizing occupancy of a building. COMMON ROOM: A room available in congregate housing for the shared use of occupants of 2 or more housing units. This does not include common corridors and exit passages, but does include kitchens and game rooms. CONDOMINIUM: Property or portions thereof conforming to the definition set forth in section 57-8-3 of the Utah Code, as amended, or its successor. CONGREGATE HOUSING: Any building which contains facilities for living, sleeping and sanitation, as required by this chapter, and may include facilities for eating and cooking, for occupancy by other than a family. Congregate housing includes SROs, convents, monasteries, dormitories, boarding and rooming houses, hostels, fraternity and sorority houses, but does not include shelters, jails, hospitals, nursing homes, hotels or lodging houses. COOKING FACILITY: At a minimum, a range with stove top and oven, or alternatively, a nonportable cooktop and oven, and a sink. CORRIDOR: A hallway that serves more than one dwelling unit. EFFICIENCY DWELLING UNIT: A dwelling unit containing only one habitable room with a bath and/or kitchen in the unit. EXISTING: In existence prior to adoption hereof. EXITWAY: A continuous and unobstructed means of egress to a public way and includes any intervening aisles, doorways, gates, corridors, exterior exit ramps, stairways, smokeproof enclosures, horizontal exits, exit passageways, and exit access ramps as these terms are defined in the International Building Code. FAMILY: The same as defined in Title 21A. FIRE RESISTANCE OR FIRE RESISTIVE CONSTRUCTION: Construction that resists the spread of fire. 61 FLOOR AREA COMPUTATION: The floor area of a habitable room excluding closets, cabinets, bathrooms, and kitchens when such kitchens are separated from the habitable room by walls or other partitions. GARAGE: A building or portion thereof designed, used, or intended to be used for parking or storage of a motor vehicle containing flammable or combustible liquids or gas in its tank. GLAZING: Light transmitting glass or plastic installed in windows, doors and skylights, including safety glass, but not including glass block. HABITABLE ROOM: A room in a building for living, sleeping, eating or cooking. Bathrooms, toilet rooms, closets, halls, storage or utility space, and similar areas are not habitable rooms. HALL: A space used for circulating between the rooms of a building within an individual dwelling unit. HAZARDOUS CONDITION: A condition in a residential building or dwelling unit where failure of a structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing component system or systems is likely to occur reasonably soon but which has not yet occurred or which is not serious enough to be considered an "imminent danger". "Hazardous conditions" consist of any of the following: 1. All of the conditions listed under the definition of "imminent danger" if those conditions can be repaired safely while all or the affected part of the building or unit remains occupied; or 2. "Imminent danger" conditions which have been partially secured pursuant to Section 18.24.030.E; 3. Improper, missing, misused or malfunctioning electrical service or disconnect devices; 4. Cracked, displaced or missing foundations resulting in settlement and structural damage; 5. Defective or deteriorated flooring or floor supports; 6. Flooring or floor supports of insufficient size to carry imposed loads with safety; 7. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that crack, split, lean, list or buckle due to defective material or deterioration where failure is likely to occur reasonably soon but is not likely to occur immediately; 8. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that are of insufficient size to carry imposed loads with safety; 9. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other horizontal or vertical members which sag, split or buckle due to defective material or deterioration; 10. Inoperable toilet, bathroom sink, or bathtub or shower in a dwelling unit or congregate housing unit; 62 18.Lack of or inoperable kitchen sink in a dwelling unit or congregate housing unit; 19.Fireplaces or chimneys which are of insufficient size or strength to carry imposed loads with safety such that failure is likely to occur reasonably soon but is not likely to occur immediately; 20.Except as defined under "imminent danger" below, conditions that reduce the width, height or area of a required emergency exitway or required escape window; 21.All buildings or portions thereof which are not provided with the operable fire extinguishing systems or equipment required by city codes; 22.Buildings or portions thereof occupied for living, sleeping, cooking or dining purposes which were not designed or intended to be used for such occupancies; 23.Lack of a kitchen area equipped with a working stove, oven, sink and refrigerator unless specified otherwise by this code. HISTORIC BUILDING: Any building or structure which has been designated for preservation by Salt Lake City pursuant to Title 21A or its successor, or is a contributory structure located in an historic district designated pursuant to Title 21A. HOTEL: Any building containing guestrooms intended or designed to be used, rented, or hired out to be occupied, or which are occupied for sleeping purposes by guests on a daily basis. HOTEL/MOTEL ROOM: A room or combination of rooms (suite) offered as a single unit for lodging on a daily or weekly basis. IMMINENT DANGER: A condition in a building or dwelling unit subject to this chapter where structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing systems have failed so that they may cause immediate death or serious injury to the building's occupants or the public. Conditions of "imminent danger" are those that are so severe and dangerous that either repairs cannot be completed immediately or it is appropriate to have the residents or other occupants leave the building or unit before the repairs have begun. "Imminent danger" consists of any of the following and other similarly serious conditions: 1. Failed or missing foundations, beams, columns, floor systems; 2. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other horizontal members which sag, split or buckle and failure is likely to occur at any moment; 3. Broken water lines causing flooding which is undermining structural supports or otherwise endangering the building's integrity; 4. Leaking gas; 5. Missing flues or vent connectors resulting in exhaust gases entering the building; 63 6. Lack of adequate heating facilities during the months of October through April; 63 7. Overload of main and branch electrical distribution systems; 8. Exposed electrical wires, fuses and electrical current breakers capable of producing electrical shock or fire and readily accessible to the occupants or the public; 9. Stairs and stair components that cannot carry the loads intended and which may collapse if so loaded; 10. Contaminated water systems; 11. A complete absence of toilet facilities; 12. A complete lack of water supply or sewage disposal facilities, as a result of a failure of a building's or dwelling unit's system and not a city system failure; 13. Blocked emergency egress halls, corridors and/or doors, including accumulation or storage of materials in stairways, corridors, doors or windows, or other condition which blocks the means of egress. INFESTATION: The presence of insects, rodents or other pests in or around a building in numbers that are or may be detrimental to the health, safety or general welfare of the occupants. KITCHEN: A space or room used, designed or intended to be used for the preparation of food, which includes permanently installed cooking facilities. MAINTENANCE: The repair, replacement and refinishing of any component of an existing structure, but does not include alteration or modification to the existing weight bearing structural components. MINOR DEFICIENCIES: A structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing code violation that is minor in nature and is less severe or dangerous than a "substandard condition". "Minor deficiencies" include the following, and other similarly minor conditions: 1. Interior finish wall coverings missing or in disrepair; 2. Lack of paint; 3. Dripping or leaking kitchen or bathroom faucets; 4. Soffit and fascia trim of which no more than 20% is weathered, missing, or loose. MONUMENTAL STAIRS: A stairway, exceeding 4 feet in width, at the main entrance on the exterior of a building. MULTIPLE-FAMILY STRUCTURE: A residential building containing 3 or more dwelling units. NEC: The edition of the national electrical code currently adopted by the city. OCCUPANT: A person occupying or having possession of a dwelling unit. 64 OPENING: An exterior glazed opening capable of being closed to the weather, consisting of a window, a glazed door, or an openable glazed skylight, which opens upon a roof, yard, court, street, alley or recess from a court. PATTERN OF CIRCULATION: Any area in a room or group of rooms where the occupant is likely to walk because of the location of doors, fixtures or furniture placement when size of room restricts furniture placement. Fixtures, pipes and ducts projecting from the ceiling which are located near the middle of the room are within the pattern of circulation. PLUMBING SYSTEM: Any potable water distribution piping, and any drainage piping within or below any building, including all plumbing fixtures, traps, vents and devices appurtenant to such water distribution or drainage piping and including potable water treating or using equipment, and any lawn sprinkling system. PREMISES: A lot, plot or parcel of land including the buildings or structures thereon. RESIDENTIAL BUILDING: The portions of a building that contain dwelling units. SRO (SINGLE ROOM OCCUPANCY): A congregate housing where the dwelling units have one combined sleeping and living room and may include a kitchen and/or a separate private bathroom. SAFETY: The condition of being safe from causing harm, injury or loss. SECURED BUILDING: A building where all windows and doors are intact and lockable against unauthorized entry. SLOPING CEILING: Any ceiling with a slope greater than 1/2 inch per foot. SMOKE DETECTOR: An approved device which senses visible or invisible particles of combustion. SPACE, COMMON: "Common space" means shared areas available for use by the occupants of the building. SPACE, PRIVATE: "Private space" means the portion of a dwelling unit which is for the exclusive use of the occupants of the unit. SUBSTANDARD CONDITION: A structural, electrical, mechanical or plumbing system condition in a residential building or dwelling unit which violates applicable codes but with maintenance or repair can be made fully safe and which does not amount to an "imminent danger" or a "hazardous condition". "Substandard conditions" include the following as well as any violations of the standards in this chapter which have not been included in the categories of "imminent danger", "hazardous condition" or "minor deficiency": 1. Deteriorated or inadequate foundations with cracking and evidence of settlement; 2. Defective or deteriorated flooring or floor supports; 3. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports that split, lean, list or buckle due to defective material or deterioration; 65 1. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports, or other members that are of insufficient size to carry live and dead loads with safety; 2. Soffit and fascia trim more than 20% of which is weathered, missing or loose; 3. Missing, decayed, buckling or worn out roof covering; 4. Roof having more than 2 layers of shingle type roof covering; 5. Fireplaces or chimneys which list, bulge or settle, due to defective material or deterioration; 6. Parapet wall or parapet cap bricks that are loose or missing; 7. Stair risers, treads, jacks, stringers or supports that are cracked or otherwise deteriorated or missing; 8. Plumbing which was not installed in accordance with the adopted plumbing code in effect at the time of installation or with generally accepted construction practices, has not been maintained in good condition, or is not free of cross connections or siphonage; 9. Continuous running water in a toilet, bathroom sink or kitchen sink; 10. Lack of hot or cold running water to plumbing fixtures in a dwelling unit or congregate housing structure; 11. Mechanical equipment which was not installed in accordance with codes in effect at the time of installation, or with generally accepted construction practices, or which has not been maintained in good and safe condition; 12. Inoperable heating systems during the months of May through September; 13. Inoperable air conditioning systems, when the building is supplied with such a system and lacks other adequate forms of ventilation and the air conditioning system fails to keep the air temperature below 85°F; 14. Damaged or missing heat ducts or missing heat duct registers; 15. Electrical wiring which was not installed in accordance with codes in effect at the time of installation or with generally accepted construction practices, has not been maintained in good condition, or is not being used in a safe manner; 16. Missing light fixtures, switches and outlet and switch cover plates; 17. Overcurrent situations such as those caused by the use of electrical extension cords and multiple light fixtures; 18. Lack of the minimum natural light and ventilation required by this chapter; 19. Room and space dimensions less than that required by this chapter; 66 20. Dampness of habitable rooms as evidenced by water damage or excess moisture on ceilings, walls or floors; 21. Deteriorated, crumbling or loose plaster or stucco; 22. Deteriorated or ineffective waterproofing of exterior walls, roof, foundation or floors, including broken windows or doors; 23. Deteriorated or lack of weather protection for exterior wall coverings; 24. Broken, rotted, split or buckled exterior wall coverings or roof coverings; 25. Wood has been installed within 6 inches of earth which is not naturally decay resistant, treated wood or wood protected by an approved barrier; 26. Infestation of insects, vermin or rodents as determined by the Salt Lake County health department, or its succcessor; 27. Lack of garbage and rubbish storage and removal facilities as determined by the Salt Lake County health department regulations; 28. Those premises on which an accumulation of weeds, vegetation, junk, dead organic matter, debris, garbage, offal, rat harborages, stagnant water, and similar materials or conditions constitute a violation of the Salt Lake County health department regulations; 29. Any building, device, apparatus, equipment, combustible materials or vegetation which, in the opinion of the chief of fire department or building official, is in such a condition as to cause a fire or explosion or provide a ready fuel to augment the spread and intensity of fire or explosion arising from any cause; 30. Any fire resistive requirement of this chapter which is not met; 31. Drainage of water from roofs or yards in a manner that creates flooding or damage to a structure; 32. Any equipment or apparatus that causes excessive noise, pollution, odor or light as defined by the Salt Lake City code or Salt Lake County health regulations; 33. Guardrails or handrails in common areas that are missing or cannot support required loads. TOILET ROOM: A room which contains a toilet. It may also contain a sink, but does not contain a tub or shower. UNFIT FOR HUMAN OCCUPANCY: A condition of premises which has been found by the building official to be an "imminent danger" or "hazardous condition" situation as defined by this chapter, or which fails to meet the sanitation requirements of the Salt Lake County health department. VENTILATION, NATURAL: "Natural ventilation" means any openable exterior door, window or skylight which opens upon a roof, yard, court, street or alley. 67 YARD: As defined in Title 21A. 18.50.040: AUTHORITY: A. Enforcement: The building official is authorized to enforce all the provisions of this chapter. The building official may issue and deliver enforcement orders under authority provided by state law. B. Interpretation: The building official may render interpretations of this chapter and adopt and enforce rules and supplemental regulations pursuant to adopted state construction codes to clarify the application of its provisions. Such interpretations, rules and regulations shall conform to the intent and purpose of this chapter, and shall be made available in writing for public inspection upon request. C. Alternate Materials and Methods of Construction: This chapter is not intended to exclude any method of structural design or repair not specifically provided for in this chapter or applicable adopted state construction codes. The building official may approve any alternate material or method of construction conforming to the applicable adopted state construction codes. 18.50.050: RIGHT OF ENTRY: A. Inspection: Whenever it is necessary to make an inspection to enforce any provisions of this chapter, or whenever the building official has reasonable cause to believe a code violation exists in any building or upon any premises which makes such building or premises unsafe, dangerous or hazardous, the building official may, upon obtaining permission of the owner or other person having charge or control of the premises or dwelling unit, or upon obtaining a warrant, enter a residential property or premises to inspect it or to perform the duties imposed by this chapter. If such building or premises is occupied, the building official shall first present proper credentials and request entry. If such building or premises is unoccupied, the building official shall first make a reasonable effort to locate the owner or other persons having charge or control of the building or premises and request entry. If such entry is refused, the building official shall have recourse to every remedy provided by law to secure entry. The building official shall establish written policies which outline owner notification procedures for regular inspections and establish handling of owner notification for tenant reports of unsafe, dangerous and hazardous conditions. B. Unoccupied Dwelling Unit: If an unoccupied dwelling unit is open and unattended and the owner or other person having charge or control of the building or premises cannot be located after reasonable effort, the building official or building official's designee may enter the building. The building official shall issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 18.24.040 that the dwelling unit be immediately secured or boarded against the entry of unauthorized persons. C. Inspection Notification: In imminent danger or hazardous condition situations, or when authorization to enter has not previously been granted by a tenant, the owner shall give the 68 tenant a minimum of 24 hours' notification of an inspection of the tenant's premises by the building official. 18.50.060: RESERVED 18.50.070: RESERVED 18.50.080: RESERVED 18.50.090: MINOR DEFICIENCY NOTIFICATION: A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a minor deficiency exists, the building inspector may take the actions specified in this section. B. Citations: Citations may be issued for minor deficiencies. However, such citations shall be for the owner's information only and shall have no further legal force or effect. When a notice and order is issued pursuant to Section 18.50.100, minor deficiencies may be included under "for owner's information only". If a property inspection reveals only minor deficiencies, the building inspector may mail a letter to the owner informing the owner of such minor deficiencies. 18.50.100: ENFORCEMENT: A. Determination: If the building inspector determines that a violation of this chapter exists, the building inspector may take the actions specified in this section. B. Warning Notice 1. Notice: If the building inspector finds that any provision of this chapter is being violated, the inspector shall provide a written notice to the responsible party. The written notice shall indicate the nature of the violation and order the action necessary to correct it. The written notice shall state what action the inspector intends to take if the violation is not corrected. The written notice shall include the time period in which the violations must be corrected, which will be based on their severity. 2. Delivery of Notice: Such written notice issued by the inspector shall be deemed sufficient and complete when served upon the responsible party as follows: a. Personally by the inspector or his or her representative; or by mailing, postage prepaid, by certified mail, return receipt requested or any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, addressed 69 to the responsible party at the last known address appearing on the records of the county recorder; and b. By posting notice on the property where said violation(s) occurs. 8. In cases when delay in enforcement would seriously threaten the effective enforcement of this chapter, or pose a danger to the public health, safety or welfare, the inspector need not issue a warning notice. C. Notice and Order: If, after issuance of the warning notice (if required), the violations have not been corrected by the time period stated in the notice, the building inspector may issue a notice and order pursuant to Section 18.24.040. The notice and order need not provide any additional correction period and may impose fines beginning on the date it is issued. D. Remedies: Upon issuance of a notice and order, the building inspector may pursue any remedies allowed by Sections 18.24.030 and 18.24.050, except that civil fines shall accrue as set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule specific to the violations of this chapter. E. Daily Violations: Each day a violation continues after the issuance of the notice and order (or cure deadline stated therein, if applicable) shall give rise to a separate civil fine. F. Compliance: Accumulation of fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed through an inspection requested pursuant to Subsection 18.24.040.A.3. G. Recurring Violations: In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, reoccurs at the property within 6 months of the initial correction and is due to the actions or inactions of the same responsible party as the prior violation, the city may begin enforcement of said recurring violation and impose fines after a 10 day warning period. 18.50.110: APPEALS: A. Filing of Appeals: Appeals of enforcement of this chapter shall be taken in accordance with Chapter 18.12. B. Inspection of the Premises: Before any hearing is held by the board of appeals and examiners the board may inspect the building or premises involved. Prior notice of such inspection shall be given to the responsible party filing the appeal, who may be present at such inspection. Failure of the responsible party to provide access without good cause as determined by the building official shall not constitute a reason for the hearing to be postponed and the appeal denied. 18.50.120: RESERVED 18.50.130: APPROVAL FOR OCCUPANCY: 70 Following the correction of the deficiencies and prior to persons reoccupying any residential building or dwelling unit after it has been closed to occupancy, the building official shall issue an approval for occupancy. 18.50.140: EXTERIOR STANDARDS: A. Structural Repair: All roofs, floors, walls, chimneys, foundations, and other structural components shall be repaired when they no longer retain their structural integrity. Loose bricks in chimneys shall be repaired and missing chimney caps shall be replaced. B. Exterior Surfaces: Exposed materials that require weather protection and exterior surfaces that are deteriorating shall be repaired to the extent necessary to stop damage from cold, wind, water, or dampness. The roof covering and flashing shall form an impervious membrane. C. Drainage: All surface water shall drain away from the structure and any potential adverse effect of the runoff shall be mitigated to the reasonable satisfaction of the building official. D. Windows and Doors: Windows that are required by this chapter for light and ventilation shall be fully glazed. Window openings not required to meet light, ventilation, and egress standards may be sealed with opaque materials or removed. Broken or missing doors, door frames, windows, and window sashes shall be replaced or repaired. E. Appendages: All awnings, fire escapes, exhaust ducts and similar appendages shall be maintained in good repair and be properly anchored. F. House Addressing: All residential buildings shall display a street number in a prominent location on the street side of the building in such a position that the number is easily visible to approaching emergency vehicles. The numerals shall be in accordance with the codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. Each individual unit within any multiple-family structure shall display a prominent identification number. G. Exterior Walkways: All sidewalks, walkways, stairs, driveways, parking spaces and similar areas shall be kept in a proper state of repair, and maintained free from hazardous conditions. 18.50.150: INTERIOR STANDARDS: A. Showers/Tubs: Showers shall be finished to a height of 70 inches above the fixture drain outlet with nonabsorbent material. Freestanding tubs with shower risers may utilize a shower curtain that totally encloses all sides of the tub. B. Floor Coverings: All floor and stair coverings shall be maintained in a secure and substantially intact manner. This standard does not apply to area or throw rugs within dwelling units. 71 C. Walls And Ceilings: All walls and ceilings shall be maintained so that they are secure and intact. Surfaces shall be painted or covered with wallpaper or paneling. D. Finishes, Washable Surfaces: In kitchens and bathrooms of congregate housing and SROs, floors and walls within 15 inches of sinks, bidets, showers, toilets, and tubs shall be finished with a nonporous material that is not adversely affected by moisture. E. Operable Fixtures and Equipment: All fixtures, appliances, and equipment required by this code shall be maintained in safe and operable condition. 18.50.160: DOORS, TRIM AND HARDWARE: A. All doors, trim and hardware shall be kept in good working condition. B. Exterior doors which are required for ingress and egress shall have locks which are keyed from the exterior and are operable from the interior without the use of a key or other special equipment or knowledge. Original locks in historic buildings are not required to be replaced if in good working condition. C. Hinges for out swinging doors shall be equipped with nonremovable hinge pins or a mechanical interlock to preclude removal of the door from the exterior by removing the hinge pins. 18.50.170: ENVIRONMENTAL OR SANITARY STANDARDS: A. All premises shall be maintained clean, safe, sanitary and free from an accumulation of rubbish. Every occupant of a structure shall keep that part of the structure and exterior property which such occupant occupies, controls or uses in a clean and sanitary condition. Every owner of a structure containing a boarding and rooming house, fraternity and sorority house, dormitory, SRO or multiple-family dwelling units shall maintain, in a clean and sanitary condition, the shared or public areas of the structure and exterior property. B. Garbage and refuse storage and removal shall meet the requirements of the Salt Lake County health department regulations. C. There shall be no insect or rodent infestation in violation of the Salt Lake County health department regulations. D. Asbestos, regardless of the date of installation, shall meet the requirements of the Salt Lake County health department regulations. E. A room in which a toilet is located shall be separated from food preparation or storage rooms by a tightfitting door. 18.50.180: SPACE AND OCCUPANCY STANDARDS: 72 A. Ceiling Heights: 1. Habitable Rooms: The minimum ceiling height for all habitable rooms shall be as set forth in the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. This height may be 6 feet 4 inches when the requirements of this chapter for emergency egress, light and ventilation are met and a smoke detector and carbon monoxide detector are installed pursuant to the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. The only exception is that a smoke detector is not required in a kitchen. Obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the room. 2. Nonhabitable Rooms Except Bathrooms: All nonhabitable rooms, except bathrooms, shall have no minimum ceiling height requirement. 3. Bathrooms and Toilet Rooms: Bathrooms and toilet rooms shall have a minimum ceiling height of 6 feet 0 inches. Obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches. The bathroom ceiling height at the back of a sink, toilet or tub without shower may be sloped to a minimum height of 5 feet 0 inches at the wall when the ceiling height is no less than 6 feet 0 inches at a point 2 feet 0 inches from the wall adjacent to the bathroom plumbing fixture. 4. Sloping Ceilings: In any room with a sloping ceiling, at least one-half (1/2) the floor area shall have a minimum ceiling height as required by this section. No portion of the room with a ceiling height below 5 feet 0 inches may be used in the floor area computation. 5. Corridors: A minimum ceiling height of 6 feet 4 inches shall be required in corridors so long as there are a smoke detector and carbon monoxide detector installed pursuant to the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. Obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the corridor. B. Room and Corridor Size: 1. Floor Area and Room Dimensions: Floor area and room dimensions shall be as set forth in the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040. 2. Sleeping Room Dimensions: Every room used for sleeping shall have floor area equal to the amounts required by the construction codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. Where more than 2 persons occupy a room used for sleeping, the required floor area shall be increased at the rate of 50 square feet for each occupant in excess of 2. 3. Corridors: The minimum width of corridors shall be 36 inches. In dwelling units constructed prior to 1983, a minimum corridor width of 28 inches shall be permitted. C. Special Dwellings: 1. Efficiency Dwelling Units: An efficiency dwelling unit shall: 73 • Have a living room floor area equal to the amounts required by the construction codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. An additional 100 square feet of floor area shall be provided for each occupant in excess of two; • Have a closet; • Have a kitchen sink and cooking and refrigeration facilities, each having a clear working space of at least 30 inches in front of the fixture or appliance; • Have a bathroom containing a toilet, sink and bathtub or shower. 9. Congregate Housing: Except for Shared Housing as defined in Title 21A, individual units in congregate housing shall have at least one room with not less than 70 square feet of floor area per occupant. When individual rooms are less than 120 square feet, a separate common room shall be provided of at least 120 square feet for each 10 units, with a minimum of one common room per floor. When separate rooms are not provided with cooking facilities, the common room may be a common kitchen with a floor area as defined by the floor area computation. D. Cooking Facilities: 1. Cooking Facilities in Dwelling Units: Each dwelling unit shall have a kitchen that supplies: a. A range with stove top and oven, or in the alternative, a nonportable cooktop and oven. Hot plates, pans, and similar units shall not be considered as cooking facilities. All cooking appliances shall be maintained in good working condition. b. An approved sink, with a minimum dimension of 12 inches by 12 inches by 4 inches deep. c. A minimum of 4 square feet of counter space. d. A refrigerator. 2. Cooking Facilities for Individual Units in Congregate Housing: As long as such cooking facilities do not encroach into the required floor area, required cooking facilities may be supplied in individual units, provided all of the following items are supplied: a. A range with stove top and oven, or in the alternative, a nonportable cooktop and oven. Hot plates, pans, and similar units shall not be considered as cooking facilities and are not allowed. Portable cooking devices are not allowed in individual rooms; b. An approved sink, with a minimum dimension of 12 inches by 12 inches by 4 inches deep; c. A minimum of 4 square feet of counter space; 74 • A refrigerator. 10. Common Kitchens in Congregate Housing: When cooking facilities are not provided within individual units, congregate housing shall have a common kitchen area which shall contain the following minimum facilities: a sink for each 20 tenants or portion thereof, a range for each 20 tenants or portion thereof, and a refrigerator for each 10 tenants or portion thereof. The minimum kitchen area shall be 120 square feet based on the floor area computation for the first 10 occupants or portion thereof, and an additional 30 square feet for each additional 10 persons or portion thereof. 18.50.190: LIGHT AND VENTILATION: A. Natural Light in Habitable Rooms: 1. Every habitable room shall have at least one window facing directly to the outdoors to provide natural light. The minimum total window area shall equal 1/20th or more of the floor area of the room, with a minimum of 3 and 1/2 square feet. Special purpose rooms such as home theaters and film processing rooms shall not be subject to this requirement. Kitchens may be provided with artificial light, which shall be a minimum of 1.5 watts incandescent or 0.8 watts fluorescent per square foot of the room. 2. The glazed area of an exterior door may be used for purposes of computing window size for natural light. 3. For the purpose of meeting light or ventilation requirements, as well as emergency egress, a room may be considered as a portion of an adjoining room when 1/2 of the area of the common wall is open and unobstructed and provides an opening of not less than 1/10 of the floor area of the interior room or 25 square feet, whichever is greater. B. Ventilation: 1. Habitable Rooms: a. Except as provided in subsection B1b of this section, all habitable rooms shall be provided with natural ventilation by means of openings to the exterior which have the capability of being closed to the weather. Total openings shall have an area at least 1/20 of the floor area of the room or 3 and 1/2 square feet, whichever is greater. b. A mechanical ventilation system shall be allowed in lieu of openings for natural ventilation. Such system shall create a positive pressure in the room and the air intake shall be connected directly to the outside and be capable of 2 air exchanges per hour. In kitchens, the ventilation system may create negative pressure. The air intake/exhaust source shall be located at least 3 feet above any opening which is within 10 feet of the air intake/exhaust. c. Exterior doors may be used to meet natural ventilation requirements. 75 24.Bathrooms, Laundry Rooms, and other Nonhabitable Areas: • Except as provided in subsection B2b of this section, all bathrooms and laundry rooms shall be provided with natural ventilation by means of openings to the exterior which have the capability of being closed to the weather. Such openings shall have a total area not less than 1/20 of the floor area of the room, with a minimum of 1 and 1/2 square feet. • A mechanical exhaust system connected directly to the outside shall be allowed in lieu of natural ventilation. The system shall be capable of providing 5 air exchanges per hour. The exhaust air shall discharge at least 3 feet above or 10 feet away from any air intake source. Toilet rooms may be ventilated with an approved recirculation fan or similar device designed to remove odors from the air. • Mechanical or convection venting of bathrooms into the attic shall be acceptable. Recirculating fans may be used in toilet rooms only. Bathrooms with tubs or showers shall have a convection or mechanical exhaust system. • Bathrooms constructed prior to 1970, which are vented with convection vent openings extending to the outside shall meet the ventilation requirement as long as the walls, ceiling and floor are not adversely affected by moisture. 18.50.200: FIRE SAFETY; EGRESS: A. Fire Safety: No hazard of fire or explosion shall be created or allowed to exist in any building, premises, equipment or apparatus. B. Exit and Emergency Egress: 1. Every existing dwelling unit shall have a safe, continuous and unobstructed means of egress of a minimum ceiling height of 6 feet 4 inches and a minimum egress width of 28 inches. Obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the exitway. The exitway shall be kept in a proper state of repair and maintained free of hazardous conditions and obstructions. 2. Every sleeping room located below the fourth story shall have at least one openable window or exterior door approved for emergency egress or rescue. Every egress window shall comply with the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, unless the size of the opening under such codes is not feasible then the opening shall have a minimum of 3 and 1/2 square feet of openable space and clear opening dimensions of at least 20 inches in one dimension and 24 inches in the other dimension. The escape window must open directly into a yard or exit court, or into a public street or alley. When windows are provided as a means of emergency egress or rescue, they shall have a finished sill height of not more than 48 inches. If the distance from the floor to the windowsill is more than 48 inches, a permanent ladder or platform attached to the wall or 76 floor may be installed to meet the maximum height requirement. The ladder or platform must be approved by the city. 3. For windows that are below grade, a window well shall run parallel to the width of the window and extend at least 18 inches out from the exterior face of the building. When the distance from the top of the window well to its bottom exceeds 48 inches, it shall be equipped with an approved permanently affixed ladder or stairs that are accessible with the window in the fully open position. Grates are permitted over window wells when hinged away from the structure and not weighing over 15 pounds per section of the grate. 4. Bars, grills, grates or similar devices may be installed on emergency escapes or rescue windows or doors, provided such devices are equipped with approved release mechanisms which are operable from the inside of the grate without the use of a key or special knowledge or effort. C. Stairs and Handrails: Stairs and rails shall meet the requirements of the means of egress section of the applicable adopted state construction code with the following modifications: 1. If there are 4 or more risers, a handrail shall be required. Two handrails shall be required when the width of the stairs is 48 inches or more. Stairways less than 48 inches in width or stairways serving one individual dwelling unit in group R, division 1 or 3 occupancy, or a group R, division 3 congregate residence may have one handrail. Handrails are not required for monumental stairs. 2. Handrails shall be placed not less than 30 inches nor more than 38 inches above the outermost edge of the tread. Handrails for existing stairs are not required to extend beyond the top or bottom stair tread. 3. Stairs shall have a maximum riser height of 9 inches and a minimum step run of 8 inches. Existing stair flights may have a maximum variation in rise and run of 2 inches at the top and bottom of the flight. A maximum of 1 inch variation of rise and run shall be allowed for all intermediate risers and treads. Stairs shall be level and shall comply with life safety standards as defined herein. 4. Winding, circular and spiral stairs may run to narrow to a point. The run shall measure 8 inches (12 inches from the narrow point). 5. There shall be no minimum rise or run requirement nor maximum variation in the rise and run for stairs leading only to mechanical, storage, utility, and nonhabitable rooms in any residential structure and laundry rooms in individual dwelling units provided the stairs are structurally sound. 6. Steps shall be maintained in a safe manner. Missing steps, steps which are deteriorated to the point that a foothold is difficult to maintain, staircases which have missing boards, and/or staircases which contain boards that have lost their structural integrity shall be repaired to a safe condition. 7. Interior and exterior stairs shall have a minimum headroom height of 6 feet 4 inches so long as there are electrical powered smoke detectors installed pursuant to 77 the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040, except for stairs to mechanical or storage rooms, utility and nonhabitable rooms in any residential structure and laundry rooms in individual dwelling units, which have no minimum headroom height. Within stairways obstructions shall be allowed to 5 feet 10 inches when the obstruction is not in the pattern of circulation and obstructions are not greater than 20% of the floor area of the stairway. 8. Stairs in the interior or exterior of an existing building where stair jacks are replaced or more than 50% of the tread or risers are replaced shall meet the requirements of the applicable adopted state construction code. 9. A stair tread, stair support, stair riser, landing or railing which is either missing or so severely in disrepair or damaged that it cannot support its intended live and dead loads shall be repaired. 10. Interior stair landings shall have a minimum width of 28 inches and a minimum length in the direction of travel of 30 inches. D. Guardrails: 1. Guardrails shall be required for all balconies, porches, patios and open stairs more than 30 inches above or below grade. Guardrails shall also be required for any grade change more than 30 inches next to a walking surface. Guardrails shall not be less than 42 inches in height, except for guardrails serving private dwelling units, which shall have a minimum height of 36 inches. Guardrails may have a minimum height of 36 inches if the building was built before 1970. Guardrails having a height less than 36 inches shall be allowed if they were installed as part of the building's original construction and are not a replacement. For structures which are on the historic register or are contributory structures located within one of the city's historic districts, height of existing and replacement guardrails may be determined based upon standards adopted by the city's historic landmark committee. 2. Guardrails shall have intermediate rails or an ornamental pattern such that there is no open area in excess of 4 inches in diameter. The diameter of such open space may be 9 inches for buildings built before 1985, and 6 inches for those built between 1985 and 1991. E. Smoke Detector Requirements: 1. When smoke detectors are required in dwelling units by the applicable adopted state construction code, the detectors shall be mounted on the ceiling or wall at a point centrally located in the hallway or area giving access to rooms used for sleeping. In efficiency dwelling units, the detector shall be centrally located on the ceiling or wall of the main room or sleeping room. 2. Where sleeping rooms are on an upper level, the detector shall be placed at the ceiling or wall directly above the stairway immediately outside the bedrooms. Wall mounted detectors shall be a minimum of 4 inches and maximum of 12 inches from the ceiling, but no detector shall be mounted within 12 inches of any corner formed by the 78 meeting of walls, ceilings or beams unless manufacturer's listing specifies otherwise. When activated, the detector shall provide an alarm in the dwelling unit. 3. When one or more sleeping rooms are added to or created within a structure, smoke detectors shall be installed in compliance with the manufacturer's listing and shall receive their primary power from the building wiring in compliance with the applicable adopted state construction code. 4. All habitable rooms having a ceiling height of less than 7 feet 6 inches shall have installed a 120 volt electrical powered smoke detector. F. Fire Resistive Separations: Walls or ceilings separating dwelling units from each other and from hazardous uses shall be maintained in their original condition with all penetrations sealed or covered with an approved material. These separations include walls and ceilings separating a garage from a dwelling unit or common area and walls and ceilings separating furnace rooms in structures containing 3 or more dwelling units. When 50% or more of a wall or ceiling is removed for any reason, the entire wall or ceiling shall be reconstructed to meet the requirements of the applicable adopted state construction code for one hour occupancy separation. 18.50.210: PLUMBING: A. Minimum Requirements: 1. Unless provided otherwise in this chapter, plumbing, piping and fixtures shall be in accordance with the code in effect at the time of installation. 2. Plumbing, piping and fixtures shall have no leaks and shall be maintained in good condition. All waste lines shall be connected to an approved sewer system. 3. The minimum plumbing fixtures required for dwelling units are a bathroom sink, toilet, tub or shower, and kitchen sink. 4. Cold running water shall be plumbed to each toilet. Hot water shall be supplied to plumbing fixtures and plumbing appliances intended for bathing, washing or culinary purposes. 5. A space without obstruction from floor to ceiling of not less than 12 inches shall be in front of all toilets. Toilets shall be located in a space without obstruction from floor to ceiling of not less than 22 inches in width. No encroachments of these dimensions are permitted. 6. Where vents do not exist for plumbing fixtures meeting the applicable codes in effect at the time of their installation, vents need not be installed when the plumbing fixture or trap and trap arm is replaced providing the sewer line is not altered. B. Water Heaters: Water heaters shall comply with the construction codes adopted in Section 18.04.040 or the construction code in effect at the time of installation. 79 C. Cross Connections: In order to protect against contamination of the water supply through cross connections, all water inlets for plumbing fixtures shall be located above the flood level rim of the fixture. Hoses or handheld shower heads shall not be attached in any manner that would permit water contamination during reverse pressure. Water supply pipes provided with an approved backflow preventer or antisiphon device shall be permitted. Handheld shower heads shall be permitted when provided with a permanently mounted holder attached to the wall or shower pipe, or when an antisiphon device is installed. Water faucet outlets below the overflow rim of the fixture shall be permitted until the faucet is replaced. A new fixture shall not be installed where it would create a cross connection. D. Drains: 1. Drain traps shall meet standards of the applicable adopted state construction code. Existing traps shall be allowed as originally designed. If the trap has been modified it shall be replaced with an approved trap, and a vent shall be added as required by the applicable adopted state construction code. 2. All open entrapped sewer lines and outlets shall be capped with an approved cap. E. Fixture Requirements: Every kitchen sink, tub, shower and toilet shall be provided with the minimum water pressure and quantities required by the codes adopted pursuant to Section 18.04.040. F. Bathrooms in Rental Dwelling Units: Each rental dwelling unit shall have a bathroom within the dwelling unit. Every toilet and bathtub or shower required by this code shall be in a room which will afford privacy to the occupant. G. Congregate Housing: 1. The minimum plumbing fixtures required for congregate housing are a sink, toilet, and tub or shower for each 10 occupants or portion thereof and a kitchen sink. Bathrooms shall have installed a door with privacy lock. 2. Congregate housing that does not provide private toilets, sinks, bathtubs or showers shall have on each floor, accessible from a public corridor, at least one toilet, one sink, and one bathtub with shower or one separate shower for each 10 occupants or portion thereof. For each additional 10 occupants, or portion thereof, an additional one toilet, one sink and one bathtub or shower accessible from a public corridor shall be provided. 18.50.220: MECHANICAL: A. Mechanical Equipment: 1. Existing Installations: Mechanical systems lawfully in existence at the time of the adoption of this code may have their use, maintenance or repair continued if the use, maintenance or repair is in accordance with the original design and location and no hazard to life, health or property has been created by such mechanical system. 80 25.Compliance: All mechanical equipment shall be in accordance with the code in effect at the time of installation. 26.Maintenance: All mechanical equipment shall be properly maintained and shall be operated in a safe manner. B. Heating: 1. Temperature: Heating shall be provided by a permanently installed heating system capable of heating all habitable rooms and bathrooms to a minimum of 68°, which shall be measured in the center of the room at a height of 3 feet from the floor. 2. Air Return: A return air duct which serves more than one dwelling unit shall not be permitted. A duplex or multiple dwelling unit legally constructed before 1970 may have an existing common air return continued if a listed smoke detector fan shutoff is installed in the return air duct. 3. Fuel Burning Appliances: a. Except for direct vented appliances, gas furnaces and gas water heaters shall not be permitted in bedrooms, in bathrooms or in closets accessed only from a bedroom or a bathroom. Existing furnace rooms with access only through an existing bedroom may continue to exist when a 120 volt smoke detector is installed in the bedroom and relayed to a smoke detector installed in the furnace room. All combustion air is to be supplied from outside air. b. Gas shutoff valves are required on all gas appliances. Shutoff valves shall be installed in accordance with the applicable adopted state construction code. c. All fireplaces, wood burning stoves, and all other appliances producing combustible gas byproducts shall be connected to an operating chimney or approved flue. All flues and vents shall be installed in compliance with EPA requirements and the requirements of the applicable adopted state construction code in effect at the time of installation. d. All fuel burning appliances shall be provided with combustion air per the requirements of their listing and with the applicable adopted state construction code in effect at the time of their installation. e. All fuel burning appliances shall be provided with listed clearances and maintained in good working condition and in accordance with their listing. f. All ventilation fans shall be installed according to their listing and maintained in good working condition. g. All ducts and vents shall be maintained according to original installation requirements. 81 18.50.230: ELECTRICAL: A. Safety: All electrical equipment, wiring and appliances shall be properly installed, maintained and used in a safe manner. Unless provided otherwise in this chapter, all electrical wiring and equipment shall be in accordance with the electrical code in effect at the time of installation. All conductors shall be protected by fuses or circuit breakers that are adequately sized. B. Electrical Equipment: Electrical equipment shall not exceed the load capacity of the service and branch circuits shall have adequately sized circuit breakers or fuses. C. Facilities Required: The following electric facilities must be furnished at a minimum and must be operable: 1. Service: The minimum main service to any dwelling unit shall be 60 amperes. Existing dwelling units with electrical services less than 60 amps per dwelling unit which have no special electrical service loads, such as air conditioners, ranges, heating units and clothes dryers may continue to be operated without upgrading the service. 2. Branch Circuits: Circuits supplying air conditioners, ranges, cooktops, stoves and heating appliances shall meet the requirements of the NEC. Branch circuits shall not be overfused. 3. Receptacles: Every habitable room shall contain at least two electrical receptacles or one electrical light fixture and one electrical receptacle. Grounding type receptacles shall only be used when connected to a grounding system. Existing nongrounding type receptacles may be replaced with grounding type receptacles where protected by a ground fault circuit interrupter. D. Upgrading Facilities: 1. Service: When remodeling work is done, the service must be upgraded if required by the NEC. 2. Circuits: When new circuits, outlets, switches, wiring and service panels are being installed, the installation shall meet the requirements of the NEC. 3. Receptacles: Wiring, receptacles and switches may be replaced without upgrading so long as circuits are not overloaded. E. Lighting: 1. Dwelling Units: Every toilet room, bathroom, laundry room, furnace room, interior stairway and hall shall contain at least one permanently mounted electric light fixture. 2. Apartments, SROs and Congregate Housing: a. Lighting in the common areas shall be as follows: Aisles, passageways, stairwells, corridors, exitways and recesses related to and within the 82 building complex shall be illuminated with a minimum of a 40 watt light bulb or equivalent for each 200 square feet of floor area; provided, that the spacing between lights shall not be greater than 30 feet. Structures containing three dwelling units or less shall not be required to provide exit lighting when no lighting outlet has been previously provided. b. Every furnace room shall contain at least one electric lighting fixture. c. Open parking lots and carports shall be provided with a minimum of one foot-candle of light on the parking surface during the hours of darkness. Lighting devices shall be protected by weather resistant covers and shall not cast glare on neighboring properties. A. General: 1. All electrical panels, boxes, outlets and lighting fixtures shall have proper covers. 2. Flexible cords, as defined in the NEC, shall be used only according to their listing and shall not be installed as permanent wiring or strung across exitways. 18.50.240: ENERGY CONSERVATION REQUIREMENTS: A. Upgrading: Existing residential units shall be upgraded whenever any of the following events occur: 1. Whenever wallboard, plaster or other finish material is removed which exposes wall cavities of foundations, exterior walls, floors or ceilings, these spaces shall be insulated to the degree it is practical. Where attic and crawl space areas are insulated, the space shall be ventilated as per the currently adopted applicable state construction code. 2. Where insulation increases the accumulation of snow, and the snow load capacity of the roof structure is exceeded, the roof members shall be upgraded to withstand the additional loads. 3. When access is available to foundations of existing structures, foundations shall be insulated to the standard required by the applicable Utah energy code when remodeling of the structure is initiated. 4. When boarded structures are renovated for reoccupancy, the structure shall be insulated to the following standards when wall, ceiling, roof or floor cavities are open or accessible: wall, R-11; ceilings and roofs, R-32; floors, R-7. Thermal resistance "R" shall have the meaning as defined in the Utah energy code. 5. When new habitable space is created within an existing building envelope, all such spaces shall be insulated to the current Utah energy code standards. 83 27.All replacement windows shall be double pane. Replacement glass for structures which are on the historic register or are contributory structures located within one of the city's historic districts may be determined based upon standards adopted by the city's historic landmark committee. Replacement metal windows shall have a thermal break. Single pane replacement glass may be installed on windows not designed to accept double pane glass. 28.All exterior door replacements shall be weather stripped. 29.New mechanical equipment installed shall meet a minimum of 80% efficiency. 30.Except for the other applicable requirements of this chapter, when a new addition is made to an existing residential structure, only the addition shall be made to comply with current Utah energy code standards. B. Exterior Door and Window Seals: 1. Exterior doors and windows shall be weathertight. If broken, all panes shall be replaced with glazing in compliance with the applicable adopted state construction codes. 2. All doors and windows shall be properly caulked and weatherproofed. SECTION 12. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.52. That Chapter 18.52 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Mechanical Regulations) is hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.52 MECHANICAL REGULATIONS 18.52.010: DEFINITIONS: For the purpose of this title: ENERGY USING EQUIPMENT: That which is designed, constructed, erected or altered to operate by the use of fuel and/or power and shall include any devices and appurtenances or appliances, materials, ducts, pipes, piping, venting, gas piping, valves, fittings, fans, blowers and burners necessary to the performance of such functions that shall create comfort heating and/or cooling or power for work services. MECHANICAL SYSTEM: Means and shall include, but not be limited to, any heating, comfort cooling, ventilation and refrigeration systems, or energy using equipment. 84 18.52.020: UNIFORM MECHANICAL CODE ADOPTED: The edition of the uniform mechanical code, as adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission, is adopted by Salt Lake City as an ordinance, rules and regulations of Salt Lake City subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set out, one copy of which code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. Hereafter all references in this code to the uniform mechanical code shall mean the said edition adopted by the Utah uniform building code commission. 18.52.040: MANUAL ON RECOMMENDED GOOD PRACTICES ADOPTED: "Recommended Good Practices For Gas Piping Appliance Installation, And Venting", Mountain Fuel Supply Company, revision of June 1980, is adopted by Salt Lake City as an ordinance, rules and regulations of the city, subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set out, three (3) copies of which code have been filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. 18.52.050: MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES: A. Any person desiring a permit required by this code shall, at the time of filing an application therefor, pay the fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule to the city treasurer before the permit is valid. The basic fee for each permit requiring inspection is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. SECTION 13. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.56. That Chapter 18.56 of the Salt Lake City Code (Technical Building Specifications: Plumbing Regulations) is hereby repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.56 PLUMBING REGULATIONS 18.56.010: UNIFORM PLUMBING CODE ADOPTED: The uniform plumbing code, 1988 edition, published by the International Association Of Plumbing And Mechanical Officials as a code in book form, three (3) copies of which have been filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder, is hereby adopted, except as such code may be altered or modified by the provisions of the ordinances of Salt Lake City. 85 18.56.020: PLUMBING SYSTEM DEFINED: "Plumbing system" means all potable water supply and distribution pipes, all plumbing fixtures and traps, all drainage and vent pipes, and all building drains and appurtenances within the property lines of the premises except: a) fixed lawn sprinkler systems beyond backflow prevention devices, and b) building sewers and private wastewater disposal systems three feet (3') or more beyond the outside walls of buildings. Included also are potable water treating or using equipment and water heaters. 18.56.030: WATER SUPPLY PORTION OF PLUMBING SYSTEM: The water supply portion of the plumbing system shall be considered to extend from the meter box (or the property line in the absence of a meter) to and throughout the building, terminating at an approved backflow prevention device or devices serving fixed lawn sprinklers. Included also are fire prevention and firefighting piping and equipment. 18.56.040: PLUMBING PERMIT FEES: A.Before a permit shall be valid, permit fees shall be paid to the city treasurer. The basic fee for each permit requiring inspection is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. In addition, the fee for each individual specialty item is shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. B. Fees for fire extinguishing systems shall be paid to the city treasurer as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.56.050: HOT WATER CAPACITY FOR RESIDENTIAL UNITS: All single-family residences which have central water heating units shall deliver a minimum capacity of thirty (30) gallons of one hundred forty degree Fahrenheit (140°F) water. Multiple units shall have a central water heating unit which shall deliver a minimum capacity of thirty (30) gallons of one hundred forty degree Fahrenheit (140°F) water per residential unit, when a central water heating unit is installed. 18.56.060: LOW FLUSH TOILETS; REQUIRED FOR BUILDING PERMIT: After the effective date hereof, no building permits shall be issued for new construction or remodeling of hotels, motels, apartment houses, dwellings or other structures which have toilets or water closets which use more than four (4) gallons of water per flush. Any toilets or water closets installed prior to said effective date shall meet the standards of this section when replaced. All fixtures installed pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall be of a design such 86 that the walls of the toilet or water closet bowl are thoroughly washed and contents discharged with each flush. 18.56.070: LOW FLUSH TOILETS; ON WATERSHED PROPERTY: After January 1, 1982, any toilets installed prior to the effective date hereof which are located on watersheds in Salt Lake County, or canyons contiguous to these watersheds, shall be replaced with toilets or water closets which meet the standards for new construction or remodeling specified in section 2-5-29 of the revised ordinances of Salt Lake County, 1965, or its successor, as amended. 18.56.080: FLOOR DRAINS; DUAL FLANGE AND SAFE PANS REQUIRED: All floor drains, area drains and indirect waste receptors installed on any floor level other than slab on grade shall have a dual flange and safe pans installed, with a minimum of thirty six inches (36") square of approved material, unless they are part of an original pour of concrete. 18.56.100: SOVENT PLUMBING SYSTEMS: "Sovent" is an engineered drainage plumbing system that does not meet conventional code requirements as found in the uniform plumbing code, 1988 edition, as adopted by section 18.56.010 of this chapter, or its successor section. The system is based on the combined hydraulic/pneumatic flow and performance characteristics of drainage plumbing products, and will be allowed for use in the city under the following provisions: A. Certification: The proprietor(s) of the engineered system shall certify that the plans meet the design requirements and shall also certify at the completion of the installation that they have inspected the system and that the system complies with the approved plans; B. Submittal Of Calculations: Submit hydraulic and pneumatic calculations for the proposed system before a permit is obtained; C. Offsets: A double offset shall be installed in the stack on floor levels where no fixture or branch connections are made; D. Deaerator Fitting: A deaerator fitting shall be located as close as possible to the base of the stack. No branch or fixture connections are permitted on this system downstream from the deaerator fitting. A full size bottom pressure relief line shall connect the deaerator fitting to the building drain at least ten (10) pipe diameters downstream from the base of the stack through a wye fitting rolled above the centerline. The full size bottom pressure relief line shall be provided with an accessible upper terminal cleanout; E. Prohibited Attachments: Pumpout, blowout, garbage disposal, clothes washing machine, or outlets from grease traps are prohibited in this system; 87 A. Cleanouts: Accessible cleanouts shall be provided in all horizontal drains. Cleanouts shall be provided for each aggregate change of direction exceeding one hundred thirty five degrees (135°); B. Conventional Plumbing: Vents from conventional plumbing and pressure equalizing line vents from a sovent system shall not connect to the sovent stack below other drainage fittings; C. Future Alterations: No alteration may be made without prior written permission from the division of building and housing services, and no provisions for future openings will be permitted on this system. This system shall be properly identified on each installation site. All buildings of B-2 occupancies with more than eight thousand (8,000) square feet per floor shall provide at least one 4-inch waste stack and one 4-inch vent stack for any alteration or additions. 18.56.105: MISCELLANEOUS PLUMBING REQUIREMENTS: A. Overflow roof drains shall not be connected to the primary roof drain lines. B. Overflow roof drains shall drain to a point where they can be easily seen for early problem detection. C. Fill valves for fire sprinkler storage tanks shall be equipped with an approved air gap on reduced pressure backflow preventer. D. Safe pan drains shall be no smaller than one and one-half inches (11/2") unless first approved by the administrative authority. E. Trough drains are prohibited unless first approved by the administrative authority. F. Drainage for gravity dump washers shall be by direct hookup to the building drain or to a sealed sump connected to the building drain. There shall be a floor drain immediately downstream of each gravity dump washer hookup. 18.56.110: UNSANITARY CONSTRUCTION AND CONDITIONS: Any portion of a plumbing system or any construction or work regulated by this title found or determined to be unsanitary, as defined in this title, or otherwise a menace to life, health or property, is hereby declared to be a public nuisance. SECTION 14. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.64. That Chapter 18.64 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Demolition) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 88 CHAPTER 18.64 DEMOLITION 18.64.005: PURPOSE AND INTENT: A. The purpose of the provisions in this chapter is to: 1. Promote the public welfare by maintaining the integrity and continuity of the urban fabric and economic vitality; 2. Provide an orderly and predictable process for demolition of buildings and structures when appropriate; 3. Ensure demolition occurs safely; 4. Protect utilities and other infrastructure from damage during demolition; 5. Provide for enforcement of timely completion of demolition and for improvement of property following demolition to ensure the site is not detrimental to the use and enjoyment of surrounding property; 6. Provide for enforcement and maintenance of property to avoid purposeful demolition by neglect; and 7. Encourage preservation of the city's housing stock where appropriate. B. A primary intent of the city council with respect to this chapter is to promote responsible re-use of existing housing stock where practical and provide an orderly process for demolition where it is not practical or cost efficient to rebuild/reuse. Accordingly, the council finds that it is in the public interest to require existing buildings to be maintained in a manner that does not constitute a public nuisance until replaced by new construction, except as otherwise permitted by this code. 18.64.010: PERMIT REQUIRED: It is unlawful to demolish any building or structure in the city, or cause the same to be demolished, without first obtaining a permit for demolition of each such building or structure from the city building official as provided in this chapter. 18.64.020: APPLICATION FOR PERMIT: To obtain a permit for demolition, an applicant shall submit an application in writing on a form furnished by the building official for that purpose. Each application shall: A. Identify and describe the type of work to be performed under the permit; B. State the address of the structure or building to be demolished; 89 C. Describe the building or structure to be demolished including the type of use, type of building construction, size and square footage, number of stories, and number of residential dwelling units (if any); D. Indicate the method and location of demolished material disposal; E. Identify the approximate date of commencement and completion of demolition; F. Indicate if fences, barricades, scaffolds or other protections are required by any city code for the demolition and, if so, their proposed location and compliance; G. State whether fill material will be required to restore the site to level grade after demolition and, if required, the approximate amount of fill material; H. If the building or structure to be demolished contains any dwelling units, state whether any of the dwelling units are presently occupied; and I. State the proposed use of the premises following demolition. If new construction is proposed following demolition, state the anticipated start date and whether any development applications have been submitted to and/or approved by the city. J. Affirm that the property will comply with the landscaping requirements for the zoning district that the property is located in as required under the provisions of Chapter 21A.48. 18.64.030: FEES AND SIGNATURE: A. The permit application shall be signed by the party or the party's authorized agent requesting the permit. A signature on the permit application constitutes a certification by the signee that the information contained in the application is true and correct. B. The fee for a demolition permit application shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. C. An additional fee for the cost of inspecting the property to determine compliance with the requirements of this chapter and to assure the property is kept free of weeds and junk materials shall be collected in the amount shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 18.64.040: ISSUANCE OF DEMOLITION PERMIT: A. A demolition permit may be issued only upon completion of an application in accordance with Section 18.64.020 herein; or the building official or fire marshal orders immediate demolition: 1. Due to an emergency as provided in Chapter 18.64; or 2. Because the premises have been damaged beyond repair because of a natural disaster, fire, or other similar event; or 90 31.The building official or fire marshal authorizes immediate demolition because clearing of land is necessary to remove a nuisance as defined in this code or Section 76-10-801 et seq., Utah Code or its successor. B. If proposed demolition involves a landmark site, a contributing structure, or a structure located in the H Historic Preservation Overlay District, as provided in Section 21A.34.020 of this code, or its successor, a demolition permit shall be issued only upon compliance with applicable provisions of that section or its successor. 18.64.045: DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT: The owner of a boarded building shall maintain the exterior of the building as provided in Sections 18.48.235 and 18.50.140. 18.64.050: RESIDENTIAL DEMOLITION NOTICE A. If the structure for which a demolition permit is sought contains one or more dwelling units, whether or not occupied, upon issuance of a demolition permit, the building official shall cause to be recorded against title to such real property in the official records of Salt Lake County a notice that contains the following information: 1. Information about the demolished property as required by the city, including the number of dwelling units and respective number of bedrooms, and the amount of rent charged in the year prior to the demolition, and the level of affordability if the rent is a below market rate. 2. Notice that the future development of the property may have specific development requirements under the City code, including without limitation the city’s community benefit policies in chapters 19 and 21A.50.050. 18.64.070: PREDEMOLITION SALVAGE PERMITS: A. A predemolition salvage permit shall be required for removal of doors, windows, special glass, fixtures, fittings, pipes, railings, posts, panels, boards, lumber, stones, bricks, marble, or similar materials on the exterior or interior of any building prior to demolition of the structure. A predemolition salvage permit may be issued only contemporaneously with, or after, city approval of: 1. A building permit for new construction on the premises following demolition, or 2. A demolition permit. B. A predemolition salvage permit fee shall be as shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. 91 18.64.080: EXPIRATION; DILIGENCE: A demolition permit shall expire 45 calendar days from the date of issuance, unless a completion date allowing more time is requested and approved by the building official at the time of application. A demolition permit may be renewed upon request prior to expiration with approval of the building official for 1/2 of the original permit fee, provided continuous progress is being made. If a permit is allowed to expire without prior renewal, any subsequent request for reinstatement shall be accompanied by a reinstatement fee equal to the original demolition permit fee. 18.64.090: QUALIFICATIONS TO DO WORK: A. It shall be unlawful for demolition work permitted under this chapter to be performed except by a contractor having a general contractor or demolition license in good standing issued by the Division of Occupational and Professional Licensing in the Utah Department of Commerce. B. Salvage work under a predemolition salvage permit may be done without a contractor's license provided all other applicable conditions of this chapter are met. 18.64.100: DEMOLITION REQUIREMENTS: A. Prior to the commencement of any demolition or moving, the permittee shall plug all sewer laterals at or near sidewalk lines as staked out by the department of public utilities. No excavation shall be covered until such plugging is approved by the department or by the building official. The permittee shall further ensure all utility services to the structure and/or premises have been shut off and meters removed prior to commencement of demolition work. B. When the applicant indicates the demolition will require more than 30 days to complete, and where required by the building official for the safety of the public, the applicant shall also provide plans to fence the demolition site so that it is inaccessible to unauthorized persons in a manner acceptable to the building official. The building official may waive the fencing requirement if it is determined that fencing would be inappropriate or unnecessary to protect safety or health. C. A permit for demolition shall require that all materials comprising part of the existing structure(s), including the foundation and footings, be removed from the site. Unless otherwise approved under a building permit for redevelopment of the site, the depression caused by the removal of such debris shall be filled back and compacted to the original grade, as approved by the building official, with fill material excluding detrimental amounts of organic material or large dimension nonorganic material. D. Permitted demolition work, including filling and leveling back to grade and removal of required pedestrian walkways and fences, shall be completed within the permit period unless the building official finds that any part of the foundation of building or site will form an 92 integral part of a new structure to be erected on the same site for which plans have already been approved by the division. In such event, the building official may approve plans for appropriate adjustments to the completion time and may impose reasonable conditions including the posting of a bond, erection of fences, securing, or similar preventions to ensure the site does not create a hazard after the demolition is completed. 18.64.110: RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER ORDINANCE: Provisions of this chapter shall be subordinate to any contrary specific provisions of Title 21A, Chapter 21A.34 of this code, dealing with demolition in historic districts, or its successor. 18.64.120: VIOLATIONS: A. It is unlawful for the owner of a building or structure to violate the provisions of this chapter. Each day a violation occurs shall be a separate offense. B. Violation of the provisions of this chapter shall be punishable in accordance with Chapter 18.24. ARTICLE II. EMERGENCY DEMOLITION 18.64.130: PURPOSE: Notwithstanding the other provisions of this chapter, the process for demolishing buildings in an emergency situation shall be as provided by this article. 18.64.140: EMERGENCY DEMOLITIONS APPLICABILITY: A. If the building official determines that the walls or roof of a building or structure are collapsing, either in whole or in part, or in imminent danger of collapsing in such a way as to fall on other structures, property, or public rights of way, are a public nuisance, create a danger to persons who may enter the property, or create a danger of fire, the building official may issue an order that the building should be demolished pursuant to this article. A notice and order reflecting this determination shall be issued and delivered in accordance with Section 18.24.040. B. If the city’s fire marshal determines that a building or structure that has been affected by fire presents an impermissible danger to persons who may enter the property, then the fire marshal may issue an order that the building should be demolished pursuant to this article. A notice and order reflecting this determination shall be issued and delivered in accordance with Section 18.24.040. 93 C. If the building official or fire marshal declares an emergency demolition the requirements of Section 21A.34.020.F, or its successor, shall not apply. 18.64.150: RESERVED 18.64.160: BILL FOR COSTS; COLLECTION: A. Permitted Recovery of Costs: If the building official or designee causes the emergency demolition of a building pursuant to a notice issued under Section 18.64.140, after the property owner received at least 10 days’ notice in which to complete demolition and failed to do so, the division may collect the city’s abatement costs which shall include the cost of the demolition contractor, costs of any environmental testing or environmental controls over demolition materials, and a reasonable amount to pay the costs of city personnel involved in the demolition, by filing a property tax lien, as set forth in this section. B. Itemized Statement of Costs: Upon completion of the demolition work, the building official or designee shall prepare an itemized statement of costs and mail it to the property owner by certified mail or using any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, demanding payment within 30 days of the date the statement is post marked. C. Form of Itemized Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs shall include: 1. The address of the property at issue; 2. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the division, including administrative costs; 3. A demand for payment; 4. The address where payment is to be made; 5. Notification that failure to timely pay the expenses described in the itemized statement may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter and Utah Code Section 10-11-4 or its successor; 6. Notification that the property owner may file a written objection to all or part of the statement within 20 days of the date the statement is postmarked; and 7. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the name of the office and the mailing address. D. Delivery of Statement of Costs: The itemized statement of costs described in Subsection C shall be deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or by any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the property owner, according to the records of the county recorder. E. Objection to Statement of Costs: A property owner may appeal the statement of costs to the fines hearing officer pursuant to Section 18.12.050. 94 F. Failure to Object or Pay: If the property owner fails to make payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement within 30 days of the date of the mailing of that statement, or to file a timely objection, then the division may certify the past due costs and expenses to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. G. Failure to Pay After Objection Hearing: If the property owner files a timely objection but fails to make payment of any amount ordered by the fines hearing officer, the inspector may certify the past due costs and expense to the Salt Lake County Treasurer. H. Lien on Property: After entry by the Salt Lake County Treasurer, as set forth in Subsections F and G, the amount entered shall have the force and effect of a valid judgment of the district court, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by the Salt Lake County Treasurer at the time of the payment of general taxes. I. Release of Lien: Upon payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement of costs or otherwise determined due and owing by the fines hearing officer, the judgment is satisfied, the lien is released from the property, and receipt shall be acknowledged upon the general tax receipt issued by the county. SECTION 15. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 18.68.160. That Section 18.68.160 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Floodplain Hazard Protection: Mandatory and Prohibitionary Nature of Chapter) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 18.68.160: MANDATORY AND PROHIBITIONARY NATURE OF CHAPTER: It is unlawful for any person, firm or corporation to perform any act prohibited by this chapter or to fail to perform any act or comply with any requirement of this chapter or to aid or abet therein, or to fail or refuse to comply with any valid order called by the specified officials responsible to administer the provisions of this chapter. No permits shall be issued to any applicant during the time he/she shall fail to correct defective work or noncomplying work or violation exists after written notice by the official responsible for the permit or their designee. SECTION 15. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.76. That Chapter 18.76 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Mobile Home Parks) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 95 CHAPTER 18.76 MOBILE HOME PARKS 18.76.010: DEFINITIONS: For the purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply: CABANA: A room enclosure erected or constructed adjacent to a mobile home for residential use by the occupant of the mobile home. DEPENDENT RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A unit other than a self- contained unit. HOOKUP: The arrangement and connection of parts, circuits and materials employed in the connections required between the mobile home or recreational vehicle utility outlets and inlets and the park service connections that make the mobile home or recreational vehicle operational. MOBILE HOME: A factory assembled structure or structures equipped with the necessary service connections and constructed to be readily mobile as a unit or units on its own running gear, and designed to be used as a dwelling unit without a permanent foundation. MOBILE HOME PARK: A contiguous parcel of land which, after having the approval of the city planning commission, is used for the accommodation of occupied mobile homes. MOBILE HOME SPACE OR LOT: A designated portion of a mobile home park designed for the accommodation of one mobile home and its accessory buildings or structures for the exclusive use of the occupants. MOBILE HOME STAND OR PAD: That part of the mobile home space which has been prepared and reserved for the placement of one mobile home. MOTOR HOME: A self-propelled vehicular unit primarily designed as a temporary dwelling for travel, recreational and vacation use. PARK DRAINAGE SYSTEM: The entire system of drainage piping used to convey sewage and other wastes from the mobile home or recreational vehicle drainage outlet connection, at the mobile home or recreational vehicle site, to the property line connection with the sewer lateral from the main line sewer. PARK PLUMBING SYSTEM: Means and includes, but is not limited to, the park drainage and water supply systems within the park property lines. PARK WATER SUPPLY SYSTEM: All of the water supply piping within the park, and shall extend from the water meter to the mobile home or recreational vehicle water supply system, and shall include main and branch service lines, fixtures, devices, piping in service buildings, and appurtenances thereto. RAMADA: Any freestanding roof or shade structure installed or erected above an occupied mobile home or any portion thereof. 96 RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A vehicular unit, other than a mobile home, primarily designed as a temporary dwelling for travel, recreational and vacational use, which is either self-propelled or is mounted on or pulled by another vehicle, including, but not limited to, a travel trailer, a camp trailer, a truck camper, or a motor home. RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK: A site, lot, tract or parcel of land upon which one or more recreational vehicles are parked for temporary use as living quarters. RECREATIONAL VEHICLE SPACE: A plot of ground within a recreational vehicle park to accommodate one recreational vehicle. RECREATIONAL VEHICLE STAND OR PAD: That part of the recreational vehicle space which has been prepared and reserved for the placement of one recreational vehicle. SELF-CONTAINED RECREATIONAL VEHICLE: A unit which: A. Can operate independent of connections to external sewer, water and electrical systems; and B. Has a toilet and holding tank for liquid waste; and C. Contains water storage facilities and may contain a lavatory, kitchen sink and/or bath facilities connected to the holding tank; provided, however, that all facilities shall be in sound operating condition, and further provided that it may be connected to external electric, water and sewer systems. SERVICE BUILDING: A building housing separate toilet and bathing facilities for men and women and which may also have laundry facilities, flushing rim sink, and other facilities as may be required by this title, and which shall be apart from the facilities within the mobile home or recreational vehicle. SEWER CONNECTION: All pipes, fittings and appurtenances installed to carry sewage from the mobile home or recreational vehicle drain outlet to the inlet provided in the park drainage system. SEWER RISER PIPE: That portion of the park sewer lateral which extends vertically to the ground elevation and terminates at each mobile or recreational vehicle space. TRAVEL TRAILER: A vehicular, portable unit, mounted on wheels, not requiring a special highway movement permit when drawn by a motorized vehicle, and: A. Designed as a temporary dwelling for travel, recreational and vacation use; and B. When factory equipped for the road, having a body width of not more than 8 feet and a body length of not more than 32 feet. WATER CONNECTION: All pipes, fittings and appurtenances from the water riser pipe connection to the water inlet connection of the mobile home or recreational vehicle. WATER RISER PIPE: That portion of the park water supply system which extends vertically to the ground elevation and terminates at a designated point at each mobile home or recreational vehicle space. 97 18.76.020: RESERVED 18.76.030: PERMITS, LICENSE AND COMPLIANCE REQUIRED: It is unlawful for any person to construct, maintain or operate a mobile home or recreational vehicle park within the limits of the city unless such person complies with this title and all other pertinent provisions of this code, and first obtains approval, permits and licenses as required. 18.76.040: RESERVED 18.76.050: CONSTRUCTION PERMITS REQUIRED; FEES: Mobile home park construction permits required by the division shall be issued to properly licensed contractors as follows: A. A general building permit fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule, to be issued for pads, patio slabs, metal sheds (sheds to be installed by mobile home occupant), curb, gutter, drives, piers, sidewalks, fence or wall, per mobile home space; B. Electric meter stands or pedestals at the rate shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule; C. The park plumbing system, including sewer and water risers, shall require the fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule, for each space; D. All permanent buildings, swimming pools, etc., shall have permit fees assessed at the regular and normal fee schedule; E. Fire hydrants within the property lines shall require a permit fee shown on the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule, for each hydrant. 18.76.060: RESERVED 18.76.070: RESERVED 18.76.080: LOT MARKERS: The limits of each mobile home lot in a mobile home park shall be clearly marked on the ground by permanent flush stakes, markers, or other suitable means. 98 18.76.090: RESERVED 18.76.100: ADDITIONS AND REMODELING OF PARKS: Existing mobile home and recreational vehicle parks may be enlarged or remodeled provided the addition or remodel conforms to all the provisions of this title. 18.76.110: RESERVED 18.76.120: RESERVED 18.76.130: RESERVED 18.76.140: RESERVED 18.76.150: UNDERGROUNDING OF UTILITIES: The complete distribution system or collection system of any utility shall be underground. 18.76.160: SEWER CONNECTIONS AND FEES: All applicable fees set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be paid prior to occupancy of any mobile home, including those fees due to the engineering department for sewer lateral connection from the property line to the sewer main line in the street. 18.76.170: STREET SURFACING REQUIREMENTS: All streets shall be provided with a smooth, hard and dense surface which shall be durable and well drained under normal use and weather conditions. The surface shall be maintained free of cracks and holes, and its edges shall be protected by suitable means to prevent traveling and shifting of the base. 18.76.180: STREETLIGHTS: 99 Lighting shall be designed to produce a minimum of 0.1 foot- candle throughout the street system. Potentially hazardous locations, such as major street intersections and steps or stepped ramps, shall be individually illuminated with a minimum of 0.3 foot-candle. 18.76.190: LANDSCAPING: Portions of a mobile home lot or recreational vehicle space not occupied by a mobile home or recreational vehicle or accessory buildings or structures shall be landscaped or treated in such a manner as to eliminate dust, weeds, debris and accumulation of rubbish. 18.76.200: UNLAWFUL AND HAZARDOUS USES: No person shall use, permit, or cause to be used for occupancy or storage purposes in a mobile home park a mobile home which is structurally unsound, which constitutes a hazard, or which does not protect its occupants against the elements. All mobile homes are subject to Chapter 18.50. 18.76.210: VIOLATION; NOTICE TO DISCONTINUE: Whenever any mobile home is being used contrary to the provisions of this chapter, the division may pursue such enforcement methods as permitted by this title. 18.76.220: ENFORCEMENT OF PROVISIONS: The division is hereby designated and authorized as the officers charged with the enforcement of this chapter. SECTION 16. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.80. That Chapter 18.80 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Parking Lot Construction) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.80 PARKING LOT CONSTRUCTION 18.80.010: PARKING LOT DEFINED: 100 "Parking lot" means an open area other than a street used for the parking of more than four (4) automobiles, and available for public use, whether free, for compensation, or as an accommodation for clients or customers. 18.80.020: PERMIT; REQUIRED FOR CONSTRUCTION; ISSUANCE CONDITIONS: No parking lot or parking area shall be constructed without first obtaining a permit authorizing such construction. No permit shall be issued without first securing the recommendations of the city transportation engineer and no permit shall be issued until the applicant has complied with the provisions of this chapter. 18.80.030: WALLS, SCREENING AND BUMPER CURB REQUIREMENTS: The parking lot shall be provided with attractive walls, guardrails or screening shrubbery, at least along the street side, to limit points of ingress and egress, to prevent encroachment of parked vehicles on any sidewalk, and to improve the general appearance and, where necessary, with a bumper curb parallel with the inside of the wall or guardrail at such distance that the wheels of the motor vehicles in the parking lot are stopped prior to the motor vehicle's contact with the wall or guardrail. 18.80.040: DRIVEWAY RESTRICTIONS: Driveways must not exceed thirty feet (30') in width where they cross the sidewalk; adjacent driveways must be separated by an island at least twelve feet (12') in width; and driveways must be at least ten feet (10') from the property line of any intersecting street. 18.80.050: BUILDINGS FOR ATTENDANTS: Attendant buildings must be located far enough from the entrance to prevent congestion at the sidewalk, and must be constructed so as not to detract from the appearance of the surrounding neighborhood. Every operator of a parking lot, before constructing or reconstructing, or locating or relocating an attendant building, shall secure the approval of the city transportation engineer and the city planning director. 18.80.060: SURFACING OF PARKING AREA: Ground surfaces of the parking area shall be paved or hard surfaced. 18.80.070: LIGHTING FACILITIES; REQUIRED WHEN: 101 Parking lots which are operated and open to use during the hours of darkness after one hour after sunset shall be provided with lights and lighting facilities that will provide 0.03 watt per square foot with incandescent light source, or 0.01 watt per square foot with either mercury vapor or fluorescent light source, but in no event less than 0.2 foot-candle average maintained illumination on the entire parking lot surface and an average ratio of six to one (6:1). 18.80.080: LIGHTING FACILITIES; PERMIT AND PLAN REQUIRED: Before installing the lighting facilities required by section 18.80.070 of this chapter, or its successor, and before altering or adding to any lighting facilities presently existing, the operator of a parking lot shall first make application to the building official for a permit, and shall submit with such application a detailed plan for such facilities. If it shall be found that the installation will conform to the requirements of this chapter and the electrical code, a permit shall be issued upon payment of the fee required by the electrical code covering work in commercial and industrial property. 18.80.090: CAR CAPACITY AND MANEUVERING: The maximum car capacity indicated on the application shall be reasonable, and the arrangement of parking facilities shall not necessitate the backing of cars onto adjoining public sidewalks, parkways, roadways or thoroughfares in conducting parking and unparking operations. 18.80.100: CLEANUP OF WASTE AND LITTER: Every operator of a "parking lot", as defined in this chapter, whether such operator is owner, lessee, representative or agent, shall keep such parking lot in a clean condition at all times, free from all kinds of refuse and waste material. It shall be sufficient compliance with this section to clear the parking lot from refuse and waste material once each day. 18.80.110: ENFORCEMENT OF PROVISIONS: It shall be the duty of the building official to enforce the provisions of this chapter with respect to lighting facilities. It shall be the duty of the board of health to enforce the provisions of this chapter as to keeping the premises in a clean condition. 18.80.120: FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH CHAPTER PROVISIONS: It is unlawful for any operator of a "parking lot", as defined in this chapter, whether such person is owner, lessee, representative or agent, to fail to comply with, or to violate any provision of this chapter. 102 SECTION 17. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.92. That Chapter 18.92 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Building Conservation Code) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.92 BUILDING CONSERVATION CODE 18.92.010: UNIFORM CODE FOR BUILDING CONSERVATION ADOPTED BY REFERENCE: The uniform code for building conservation, 1988 edition, is adopted by the city as the ordinances, rules and regulations of the city, subject to the amendments and exceptions thereto as hereinafter set out. Three (3) copies of the code shall be filed for use and examination by the public in the office of the city recorder. 18.92.020: EXCEPTION TO SECTION 402(d) AMENDED: The exception to section 402(d) of the code is amended to read as follows: Exception: Existing corridor walls, ceilings and opening protection not in compliance with the above may be continued when the corridors and common areas are protected with an approved automatic sprinkler system. Such sprinkler system may be supplied from the domestic water supply system, provided the system is of adequate pressure, capacity and sizing for the combined domestic and sprinkler requirements. When the building or floor changes occupancy, the entire floor or building must be protected with an approved automatic sprinkler system throughout. 18.92.030: SECTION 403 AMENDED: Section 403 of the code is amended by deleting the following sentence: Roofs, floors, walls, foundations and all structural components of buildings or structures shall be capable of resisting the forces and loads specified in chapter 23 of the building code. 18.92.040: EXCEPTION ADDED TO SECTION 606(1): An exception to section 606(1) is enacted to read as follows: 103 Exception: Existing nonconforming materials do not need to be surfaced with an approved fire retardant paint or finish when an automatic fire extinguishing system is installed throughout and the nonconforming materials can be substantiated as historic in character. SECTION 18. Repealing the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.94. That Chapter 18.94 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Commercial Building Benchmarking and Market Transparency) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: CHAPTER 18.94 COMMERCIAL BUILDING BENCHMARKING AND MARKET TRANSPARENCY 18.94.10 : PURPOSE: The purpose of this chapter is to promote long-term economic development in Salt Lake City through the enhanced energy efficiency of existing commercial buildings, and to reduce local air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions resulting from energy consumption in such buildings through increased energy efficiency, by requiring certain non-residential buildings to benchmark and report energy consumption and investigate opportunities to implement cost-effective building energy tune- ups. Promoting and recognizing efficient buildings will contribute to a cleaner environment and a more efficient use of energy resources. 18.94.020: SCOPE: The provisions of this chapter apply to buildings and building owners as follows: A.All buildings owned by the City, that are not used for residential purposes, wastewater reclamation plants, or for heavy manufacturing purposes as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code, with three thousand (3,000) square feet or more of gross floor area; provided, however, no building with less than twenty two thousand (22,000) square feet of gross floor area shall be subject to the provisions of section 18.94.080 of this chapter. B.All other governed buildings or campuses of buildings that are not used for residential purposes within Salt Lake City's geographic boundaries, where at least one of the buildings is comprised of at least twenty five thousand (25,000) square feet of gross floor area. To the extent a governed building contains elements or uses that are not included within the definition of a governed building under this chapter, the square footage of gross floor area of such elements or uses shall be excluded from the square footage of gross floor area of such building and shall not be considered a part of the governed building for purposes of this chapter. C. Exemptions: 104 32.Governed buildings that are new construction and the Certificate of Occupation was issued less than two (2) years prior to the applicable deadlines; or 33.Governed buildings that do not have a Certificate of Occupation or temporary Certificate of Occupation for all twelve (12) months of the calendar year being benchmarked; or 34. Governed buildings where a full demolition permit has been issued for the prior calendar year, provided that demolition work has commenced, some energy- related systems have been compromised, and legal occupancy is no longer possible at some point during the calendar year being benchmarked; or 35.Governed buildings, including individual buildings or structures, that do not receive utility services; or 36.Any of the following: a property or building that is not assessed ad valorem real property taxes by Salt Lake County, houses of worship, apartments, agricultural storage facilities and greenhouses, buildings used for heavy manufacturing purposes as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code, oil and gas production facilities, buildings that contain movie/television/radio production studios, soundstages, broadcast antennae, data center, or trading floor that together exceed ten percent (10%) of gross floor area. D. Governed buildings do not include properties owned by State or Federal government. 18.94.030: DEFINITIONS: BASE BUILDING SYSTEMS: A building assembly made up of various components that serve a specific function and that are controlled and operated by the owner or designee, including: A. The building envelope; B. The HVAC (heating ventilating and air conditioning) systems; C. Conveying systems; D. Electrical and lighting systems; E. Domestic hot water systems. BENCHMARK: To track and report the total energy consumed for a governed building for the previous calendar year and other descriptive information for such building as captured by the benchmarking tool. Total energy consumption may not include separately metered uses that are not integral to building operations, such as broadcast antennas and electric vehicle charging stations. BENCHMARKING SUBMISSION: A subset of: 105 A. Information input into the benchmarking tool; and 105 B. Benchmarking information generated by the benchmarking tool. BENCHMARKING TOOL: The Energy Star portfolio manager or any replacement tool adopted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and any substantially similar tool approved by the Director. BUILDING ID NUMBER: The identification number that is unique to a governed building. BUILDING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM: A computer-based system that monitors and controls a building's mechanical and electrical equipment, such as HVAC, lighting, power, fire, and security systems, including an energy management system, incorporating interior temperature sensors and a central processing unit and controls, which are used to monitor and control gas, steam and oil usage, as applicable. CAMPUS: A collection of two (2) or more buildings where at least one of the buildings has at least twenty five thousand (25,000) square feet of gross floor area or more and that act as a single cohesive property with a single shared primary function, and are generally owned and operated by the same party. CITY PROPERTY: All buildings owned by the City, that are not used for residential purposes, wastewater reclamation plants, or for heavy manufacturing purposes as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code. DEPARTMENT: The Salt Lake City Department of Sustainability. DIRECTOR: The Director of the Salt Lake City Department of Sustainability. ENERGY STAR PORTFOLIO MANAGER: The tool developed and maintained by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to track and assess the relative energy performance of buildings nationwide. ENERGY STAR SCORE: The 1 - 100 numeric rating generated by the Energy Star portfolio manager tool. FINANCIAL HARDSHIP: A property that: A. Had arrears of property taxes or water or wastewater charges that resulted in the property's inclusion, within the prior two (2) years, on the City's annual tax lien sale list; or B. Has a court appointed receiver in control of the property due to financial distress; or C. Is owned by a financial institution through default by the borrower; or D. Has been acquired by a deed in lieu of foreclosure; or E. Has a senior mortgage subject to a notice of default. GOVERNED BUILDING: All stand-alone and enclosed buildings used or occupied for a commercial use, including: A. Banking/financial services; 106 B. Stand-alone data centers; C. Education (including K - 12, daycare, pre- school, vocational school); D. Entertainment/public assembly (including convention centers, gyms, movie theaters, performing arts, meeting halls, recreation centers); E. Food sales and services (including restaurants, supermarkets, grocery stores, convenience stores); F. Healthcare (including hospitals, medical offices, senior care communities, assisted living and nursing care); G. Lodging (including hotels, motels); H. Mixed use; I. Offices; J. Retail (including retail goods establishments, retail service establishments, department stores, mass merchandising stores, specialty stores, enclosed retail malls and shopping centers); K. Technology/science (including data centers and research facilities); L. Warehouses, distribution, and package delivery facilities. GROSS FLOOR AREA: All gross floor area, which is the area included within the exterior walls of a building or portion thereof, including mezzanines, enclosed interior balconies, enclosed porches, basement floor area, penthouses, attic space having headroom of seven feet (7') or more, and interior connected floor area devoted to accessory uses. Gross floor area does not include balconies, patios, crawl spaces, courts, convertible indoor/outdoor space, parking or loading areas, and covered walkways. HEAVY MANUFACTURING: The same as defined in section 21A.62.040 of this Code. OCCUPANCY: The physical occupancy of a unit or space by an occupant or a tenant. OWNER: Any of the following: A. An individual or entity possessing title to a governed property; B. The net lessee in the case of a property subject to a triple net lease with a single tenant; C. The Board of Managers in the case of a nonresidential condominium; D. An agent or party duly authorized to act on behalf of the owner. PERSISTENT COMMISSIONING: An ongoing process of comparing data obtained through the building management system with analytic models; identifying problematic sensors, controls and equipment; and resolving operating problems, optimizing energy use and identifying retrofits for existing buildings. 107 SHARED BENCHMARKING INFORMATION: Any descriptive information identifying governed buildings with Energy Star scores above 50, and any portions of the submitted benchmarking information that owner elects to be posted publicly on the department's website. SUBMITTED BENCHMARKING INFORMATION: Whole-building information generated by the benchmarking tool and descriptive information about the governed building and its operational characteristics, which is submitted to the department. The information shall be limited to: 37.Descriptive information: • Property address; • Primary use type; • Gross floor area; 38.Output information: • Site electricity consumption (kWh); • Site natural gas consumption (therms); • Site energy use intensity (site EUI); • Weather normalized source energy use intensity (source EUI); • Total annual greenhouse gas emissions; • Water use per gross square foot (if available); • The Energy Star score, where available; and 39.Comparable information based on updates/revisions to Energy Star portfolio manager. TENANT: A person or entity occupying or holding possession of all or a portion of real property, or all or a portion of a governed building pursuant to a rental or lease agreement. TUNE-UP EVALUATION: A utility sponsored retro-commissioning process that systematically evaluates base building systems and identifies improvements to achieve optimal building performance. This includes planning, investigation, and documentation to optimize operation, maintenance and performance of the facility and/or its base building systems and assemblies. TUNE-UP EVALUATION REPORT: A report certified by the tune-up professional demonstrating that a tune-up evaluation was conducted through a utility-sponsored tune-up incentive program. TUNE-UP PROFESSIONAL: An individual or entity approved or utilized by local utilities to provide tune-up evaluation services or who possesses other substantially similar credential to perform a tune-up evaluation required by this chapter. 108 18.94.040: SUMMARY OF BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS AND INITIAL COMPLIANCE DATES: Properties Submitted Benchmarking Information Due Shared Benchmarking Information Made Publicly Available Date When First Tune-Up Evaluation Report Must Be Filed Frequency Of Tune-Up Evaluation City property May 1, 2018 Sept. 1, 2018 May 1, 2020 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year Governed building (50,000 sq. ft. of gross floor area or larger) Governed building (25,000 to 49,999 sq. ft. of gross floor area) May 1, 2019 Sept. 1, 2020 May 1, 2021 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year May 1, 2020 Sept. 1, 2021 May 1, 2022 Prior to Dec. 31 of every fifth year 18.94.050: BENCHMARKING AND BENCHMARKING SUBMISSION REQUIRED: A.Governed buildings and City properties shall be benchmarked annually for the previous calendar year according to the following schedule: 1.Each City property shall be benchmarked no later than May 1, 2018, and every May 1 thereafter. 2.Each governed building with a gross floor area of fifty thousand (50,000) square feet or more shall be benchmarked no later than May 1, 2019, and every May 1 thereafter. 3. Each governed building with a gross floor area of twenty five thousand (25,000) to forty nine thousand nine hundred ninety nine (49,999) square feet shall be benchmarked no later than May 1, 2020, and every May 1 thereafter. B.Below is a summary table of the first benchmarking submission compliance dates: Properties Benchmarking Submission By Building Owner City property May 1, 2018 109 Governed building (50,000 square feet of gross floor area or larger) Governed building (25,000 to 49,999 square feet of gross floor area) May 1, 2019 May 1, 2020 A.Benchmarking shall be performed and/or verified by the owner. B. Before making a benchmarking submission the owner shall run all automated data quality checker functions available within the benchmarking tool, and shall correct all missing or incorrect information identified. C.If the current owner receives notification from the City that any information reported as part of the benchmarking submission is inaccurate or incomplete, the information so reported shall be amended in the benchmarking tool by the owner and the owner shall provide an updated benchmarking submission to the Director within sixty (60) days of the notification. D.Exceptions: 1.Governed buildings whose average occupancy throughout the calendar year for which benchmarking is required is less than sixty percent (60%); or 2.Governed buildings under financial hardship; or 3.Due to special circumstances unique to the applicant's facility and not based on a condition caused by actions of the applicant, strict compliance with provisions of this chapter would cause undue hardship or would not be in the public interest; or 4.An owner is unable to benchmark due to the failure of either a utility provider or a tenant (or both) to report the information necessary for the owner to complete any benchmarking submittal requirement. E.For properties qualifying for these exceptions, the owner shall file documentation, in such form and with such certifications as required by the Director, with the department in the year prior to the due date for the benchmarking submission, establishing that the governed building qualifies for such an exception. F.A randomly-selected subset of benchmarking submission not to exceed ten percent (10%) of the total benchmarking submissions completed in a given year may be subject to verification by the City. Such reviews shall be conducted in a way so as to preserve the anonymity of individual properties and shall be conducted at no cost to the owner. G.An owner may make a claim of confidentiality for any submitted benchmarking information pursuant to the limitations under State law. 18.94.060: BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE TRANSPARENCY: 110 A. The City shall make accessible to the public the shared benchmarking information for the previous calendar year. 1. For each governed building with a gross floor area of fifty thousand (50,000) square feet or more, on or about September 1, 2020, and on or about each September 1 thereafter. 2.For each governed building with a gross floor area of twenty five thousand (25,000) to forty nine thousand nine hundred ninety nine (49,999) square feet, on or about September 1, 2021, and each September 1 thereafter. B. The department may, upon request, make available the submitted benchmarking information for the previous calendar year for an individual City property or governed building. 18.94.070: PROVIDING BENCHMARKING INFORMATION TO THE PROPERTY OWNER: A. Each tenant occupying a governed building shall, within sixty (60) days of a request by the owner and in a form to be determined by the Director, provide all information that cannot otherwise be acquired by the owner and that is needed by the owner to comply with the requirements of this chapter. 18.94.080: TUNE-UP EVALUATIONS REQUIRED: A.Required: Tune-up evaluations are required for governed buildings and City properties that are eligible for participation in a utility-sponsored tune-up incentive program, as determined by the utility offering the incentive program and that have an Energy Star score of 49 and below. Implementation of tune-up measures in addition to evaluations is encouraged but not required. B.Report: The owner shall conduct a tune-up evaluation of the base building systems of a qualifying governed building and file a tune-up evaluation report prior to December 31 of the year in which the tune-up evaluation is being performed. The initial reporting year shall be determined by the last digit of the property's tax ID number as illustrated below, and subsequent tune-up evaluation shall be completed and tune-up evaluation reports filed every fifth year thereafter: Last Digit Of Tax ID 50,000 Square Feet And Above Of 25,000 To 49,999 Square Feet Of Number Gross Floor Area Gross Floor Area Last Digit Of Tax ID 50,000 Square Feet And Above Of 25,000 To 49,999 Square Feet Of Number Gross Floor Area Gross Floor Area 0 2021 2022 1 2021 2022 2 2022 2023 3 2022 2023 111 4 2023 2024 5 2023 2024 6 2024 2025 7 2024 2025 8 2025 2026 9 2025 2026 City.C. Report Submission: The owner shall submit the tune-up evaluation report to the D. Exceptions: Tune-up evaluations are not required if any of the following are met: 1. If the governed building is less than five (5) years old; or 2.If a registered design professional or tune-up professional certifies that: a.The governed building has an Energy Star score of 50 or above for the year prior to the first tune-up due date or for at least two (2) of the three (3) years preceding the due date of the governed building's tune-up evaluation report. b. There is no Energy Star rating for the building type and owner submits documentation that the property's energy performance is better than the energy performance of an average building of its type for two (2) of the three (3) years preceding the due date of the governed building's tune-up report. c.The governed building has received certification under the most recent LEED 2009 rating system for existing buildings or operation and maintenance, or existing buildings version 4 rating system or future iterations of LEED published by the U.S. Green Building Council or other substantially similar rating systems for existing buildings, for at least two (2) of the three (3) years preceding the due date for the governed building's tune-up evaluation reports. d.The governed building has performed a tune-up evaluation within the past five (5) years prior to the tune-up evaluation due date. 3. If the governed building has a persistent commissioning program in place. For properties qualifying for these exceptions, the owner shall file documentation, in such form and with such certifications as required by the Director, with the department in the year prior to the due date for the tune-up report, establishing that the governed building qualifies for such an exception. E. Verification: A randomly-selected subset of tune-up evaluation reports not to exceed ten percent (10%) of the total tune-up evaluation reports completed in a given year may 112 be subject to verification by the City. Such reviews shall be conducted in a way so as to preserve the anonymity of individual properties and shall be conducted at no cost to the owner. 18.94.090: NOTIFICATION: A. Between January 1 and March 1 of each year during which an owner is required to provide a benchmarking submission, the Director shall notify these owners of their obligation to benchmark performance for the previous calendar year through whatever means the Director so chooses. 18.94.100: VIOLATIONS AND ENFORCEMENT: A. If the Director determines that an owner has failed to comply with the requirements of this chapter or the owner submits incomplete or false information, the Director may issue up to three (3) written notices of noncompliance to the owner, allowing owner to cure such noncompliance within ninety (90) days after each notice of violation. After the third written notice of violation, the Director may impose a fine of up to five hundred dollars ($500.00) per violation thereafter not exceeding a total of one thousand dollars ($1,000.00) annually. 18.94.110: APPEALS PROCESS: A. Any owner affected by the Director's determination related to that owner's property regarding enforcement of this chapter may request, within thirty (30) days of owner's written notification of the Director's determination, in writing filed with the department, an appeal hearing before the Board of Appeals and Examiners, established under this title. SECTION 18. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.95. That Chapter 18.95 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Use of LEED Standards in City Funded Construction) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.95 USE OF LEED STANDARDS IN CITY FUNDED CONSTRUCTION 18.95.10 : PURPOSE: The purpose of this chapter is to promote development consistent with sound environmental practices by requiring, subject to Sections 18.95.040, 18.95.050, and 18.95.120 of this chapter, that applicable building projects constructed with city construction funds obtain, at a minimum: 113 a) "silver" for city owned and operated buildings, or b) "certified" for private building projects that receive city funds. These designations shall be from the "USGBC" as defined herein. 18.95.020: DEFINITIONS: As used in this chapter: APPLICABLE BUILDING PROJECT: The construction or major renovation of a commercial, multi-family residential, or municipal building that will contain more than 10,000 square feet of occupied space when the design contract for such project commences on or after November 17, 2006. CERTIFIED: The level of compliance with the leadership in energy and environmental design (LEED) standards designated as "certified" by the United States Green Building Council (USGBC). CHIEF PROCUREMENT OFFICER: The city employee designated pursuant to Subsection 3.24.040A or that employee's designee pursuant to Section 3.24.050. CITY CONSTRUCTION FUNDS: Funds that are authorized to be used for construction by the city council for use by any person or city department in order to construct an applicable building project, including, without limitation, loans, grants, and tax rebates. However, this term shall not apply to the funds of the library or redevelopment agency. CITY ENGINEER: The city employee designated pursuant to Section 2.08.080 of this code or that employee's designee pursuant to Section 3.24.050. LEED STANDARD: The leadership in energy and environmental design (LEED) green building rating system for new construction and major renovations (LEED-NC) as adopted in November 2002 and revised in November 2005, the LEED green building rating system for commercial interiors (LEED-CI) as adopted in November 2002, or the LEED green building rating system for existing buildings upgrades, operations and maintenance (LEED-EB) as adopted in October 2004 and updated in July 2005. MAJOR RENOVATION: Work that demolishes space down to the shell structure and rebuilds it with new walls, ceilings, floors and systems, when such work affects more than 25% of the building's square footage, and the affected space is at least 10,000 square feet or larger. SILVER: The level of compliance with LEED standards designated as "silver" by the USGBC. SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: A determination of good faith efforts to comply as further described in Section 18.95.110. TEMPORARY STRUCTURE: Any proposed building that is intended to be in existence for 5 years or less or any existing building that at the time it was constructed was intended to be in existence for 5 years or less. USGBC: The organization known as the United States green building council. 114 18.95.030: APPLICATION: Whenever city construction funds are used for an applicable building project, such project shall at a minimum obtain a silver certification by the USGBC in the case of a city owned building project or certified certification in the case of all other projects, subject to the exceptions, waivers, and determinations of substantial compliance provided for in this chapter. 18.95.040: EXCEPTIONS: The provisions of this chapter shall not apply if the building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer jointly determine in writing that any of the following circumstances exist: A. The applicable building project will serve a specialized, limited function, such as a pump station, garage, storage building, equipment area, or other similar area, or a single- family residence; B. The applicable building project is intended to be a temporary structure; C. The useful life of the applicable building project does not justify whatever additional expense would be incurred to increase the building's long term efficiency; D. The application of LEED standard factors will increase construction costs beyond the funding capacity for the project, or will require that the project's scope of work or programmatic needs be diminished to meet budget constraints; E. The use of LEED standard factors will create an impediment to construction due to conflicts of laws, building code requirements, federal or state grant funding requirements, or other similar requirements; F. LEED factors are not reasonably attainable due to the nature of the facilities or the schedule for construction; or G. LEED certification will violate any other federal, state or local law, including, without limitation, other sections of this code. If an exception is granted, the developer must agree to integrate green building practices into the design and construction of the project to the maximum extent possible and feasible. A determination that an exception does not apply may be appealed in accordance with Chapter 18.12. 18.95.050: WAIVERS: The denial of an exception pursuant to Section 18.95.040 of this chapter does not preclude an application for waiver pursuant to this section. The board shall have the authority to grant a waiver from the requirements of this chapter only if it makes the following findings in writing: 115 A. Literal enforcement of this chapter would cause unreasonable hardship for the applicant that is not necessary to carry out the general purpose of this chapter; B. There are special circumstances attached to the project that do not generally apply to other projects that are subject to this chapter; C. The waiver would not have a substantially negative effect on the master plans, policies, and resolutions of the city and would not be contrary to the purposes of this chapter; D. Any asserted economic hardship is not self-imposed; and E. The spirit of this chapter will be observed and substantial justice done. 18.95.060: APPEAL OF CITY DECISIONS: Appeals of decisions by the building official or enforcement officials pursuant to this chapter shall be taken in accordance with Chapter 18.12. 18.95.070: RESERVED 18.95.080: REQUIRED DEPOSIT: All private sector developers, excluding nonprofit developers, who receive city funds for applicable building projects shall submit a $10,000.00 "good faith" deposit with the city which shall be refunded upon the building project receiving the applicable level of LEED certification or after a determination of substantial compliance. 18.95.090: PROOF OF REGISTRATION: Within 30 days from receiving notice that the city will fund an applicable building project, all private sector developers shall submit written proof that said project is registered with the USGBC. City funds will not be dispersed until the required deposit under Section 18.95.080 and the proof of registration under this section are received by the city. 18.95.100: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION: If a project is not LEED certified or has not been granted a determination of substantial compliance within one year after a temporary certificate of occupancy is issued by the city, then a private sector developer must file a written application with the city for an extension to obtain LEED certification. Said application must be filed with the city no later than 395 days after the date on which the certificate of occupancy was issued by the city. The city may grant a one year extension pursuant to this section and any additional extensions as may be necessary so long as a 116 private sector developer is actively pursuing LEED certification. Extensions pursuant to this section shall begin on the date granted by the city. 18.95.110: REQUEST FOR SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: Receipt of LEED certification from the USGBC shall be conclusive evidence of the level of certification stated therein. If certification is not received from the USGBC or is not at the level required by this chapter, a private sector developer may request that the city issue a determination that the project has substantially complied with this chapter upon a reasonable demonstration that such project as constructed is consistent with the intent of this chapter and that strict enforcement of this chapter would create an unreasonable burden in light of the needs of such project, the ability of the project owner to control cost increases, and other relevant circumstances. The request for determination of substantial compliance must contain the following information: A. Final LEED certification application, documentation, and response from the USGBC; B. An explanation of the efforts and accomplishments made by the private sector developer to achieve compliance with this chapter; C. An explanation of the practical or economic infeasibility of implementing certain high performance building design or construction techniques that, if implemented, would otherwise have likely resulted in certification; and D. Any other supporting documents the private sector developer wishes to submit. 18.95.120: DETERMINATION OF SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: The building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer shall review within 60 days of receipt of a request for determination of substantial compliance and shall approve or deny the request based on the good faith efforts of the private sector developer to comply with this chapter. In making a determination of the good faith efforts, review of the request shall include whether the private sector developer has established the following: A. That reasonable, appropriate, and ongoing efforts to comply with this chapter were taken; and B. That compliance would otherwise have been obtained but for the practical or economic infeasibility of implementing high performance building design or construction techniques. In making any such determination, cost increases due solely to aesthetic elements shall not constitute any part of a demonstration of unreasonable burden. A determination of substantial compliance pursuant to this section shall satisfy Section 18.95.030. 117 If the request for determination of substantial compliance is denied, the private sector developer will be deemed to have not satisfied Section 18.95.030 and shall forfeit the "good faith" deposit under Section 18.95.080 and may be assessed an additional penalty up to the amount originally funded by the city. Any penalty assessed shall be offset by the "good faith" deposit. 18.95.130: PENALTY: Any private sector developer who fails to: a) comply with this chapter, b) apply for an extension pursuant to Section 18.95.100 of this chapter, or c) receive a determination of substantial compliance, shall forfeit the "good faith" deposit to the city to cover the cost and inconvenience to the city. An additional penalty may be assessed based on a direct analysis of possible LEED design credits. Given that a total of 26 LEED design credits are required for certification, the additional penalty shall be based on the following considerations: A. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 21-25 LEED credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to 25% of the amount originally funded. B. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 16-20 LEED credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to 50% of the amount originally funded. C. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 6-15 LEED credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to 75% of the amount originally funded. D. If the city determines that a project could have reasonably received 0-5 LEED credits, then the private sector developer shall pay the city up to 100% of the amount originally funded. Failure to pay a penalty within 90 days of written notice from the city shall result in a lien against the project. 18.95.140: RULE MAKING AUTHORIZATION: The building official and either the chief procurement officer or the city engineer are authorized to issue administrative rules under this chapter. 18.95.150: ADMINISTRATIVE INTERPRETATIONS: Pursuant to the authority granted under Subsection 18.08.040K, the building official may render interpretations of this chapter. Such interpretations shall conform with the intent and purpose of this chapter, and shall be made available in writing for public inspection upon request. 118 18.95.160: LIMITATIONS: Nothing required under this chapter shall supersede any federal, state or local law, including, without limitation, other provisions of this code; or any contract, grant, or other funding requirement; or other standards or restrictions that may otherwise apply to an applicable building project. This chapter shall not apply whenever its application would disadvantage the city in obtaining federal funds. SECTION 19. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 18.96. That Chapter 18.96 of the Salt Lake City Code (Additional Regulations: Fit Premises) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: CHAPTER 18.96 FIT PREMISES 18.96.10 : TITLE: This chapter may be referred to as the SALT LAKE CITY FIT PREMISES ORDINANCE. 18.96.020: EXCLUSIONS FROM APPLICATION OF CHAPTER: The following arrangements are not governed by this chapter: A. Residence at a detention, medical, geriatric, educational, counseling, or religious institution; B. Occupancy under a contract of sale of a dwelling unit if the occupant is the purchaser; C. Occupancy by a member of a fraternal or social organization in a building operated for the benefit of the organization; D. Transient occupancy in a hotel, or motel (or lodgings subject to Utah code section 59-12-301); except that single room occupancy units ("SRO") shall be governed by this chapter. "SRO" means an existing housing unit with one combined sleeping and living room of at least 70 square feet, but of not more than 220 square feet, where the usual tenancy or occupancy of the same unit by the same person or persons is for a period of longer than one week. Such units may include a kitchen and a private bath; and E. Occupancy by an owner of a condominium unit. 119 18.96.030: IDENTIFICATION OF OWNER AND AGENTS: A. A property owner, or any person authorized to enter into an oral or written rental agreement on the property owner's behalf, shall disclose to the tenant in writing at or before the commencement of the tenancy the name, address and telephone number of: 1. The owner or person authorized to manage the premises; and 2. A local person authorized to act for and on behalf of the owner for the purpose of receiving notices and demands, and performing the property owner's obligations under this chapter and the rental agreement if the owner or manager reside outside of Salt Lake City. B. A person who enters into a rental agreement as “landlord”, “property manager” or the like, and fails to comply with the requirements of this section becomes an agent of the property owner for the purposes of: 1. Receipt of notices under this chapter; and 2. Performing the obligations of the property owner under this chapter and under the rental agreement. C. The information required to be furnished by this section shall be kept current. This section is enforceable against any successor property owner, owner, or manager. D. Every rental property with more than one unit rented without a written agreement shall have a notice posted in a conspicuous place with the name, address and telephone number of the owner or manager and local agent as required by subsection A of this section. 18.96.040: PROPERTY OWNER TO DELIVER POSSESSION OF DWELLING UNIT: A. A copy of the lease or rental agreement, rules and regulations, an inventory of the condition of the premises, a list of all appliances and furnishings and a summary of this chapter shall be given to each tenant at the time the rental agreement is entered into. The summary shall be prepared by the city for the purpose of fairly setting forth the material provisions of this chapter and shall include information about mediation resources in the Salt Lake City area and shall encourage property owners and tenants to take advantage of mediation services. The property owner shall secure and retain the tenant's signed acknowledgment that the foregoing documents have been provided to the tenant. Such acknowledgment shall be returned to the property owner no later than 3 days after the tenant takes possession of the dwelling unit. Before entering into a rental agreement, the property owner shall disclose to the tenant any current notice by a utility provider to terminate water, gas, electrical or other utility service to the dwelling unit or to common areas of the building, the proposed date of termination, and any current uncorrected building or health code violation included in a deficiency list or notice from the division or any other government entity. 120 B. By explicit written agreement, a property owner and a tenant may establish a procedure whereby the tenant notifies the property owner of needed repairs, makes those repairs and deducts the cost of the repairs from the rent due and owing. C. A property owner may allocate any duties to the tenant by explicit written agreement. Such agreement must be clear and specific, boxed, in bold type or underlined. 18.96.050: PROPERTY OWNER TO MAINTAIN THE PREMISES AND EACH DWELLING UNIT: A property owner shall: A. Comply with the requirements of applicable building, housing and health codes and city ordinances and not rent the premises unless they are safe, sanitary, and fit for human occupancy; B. Maintain the structural integrity of the building; C. Maintain floors in compliance with safe load bearing requirements; D. Provide exits, emergency egress, and light and ventilation in compliance with applicable codes; E. Maintain stairways, porches, walkways and fire escapes in sound condition; F. Provide smoke detectors and fire extinguisher as required by code; G. Provide operable sinks, toilets, tubs and/or showers; H. Provide heating facilities as required by code; I. Provide kitchen facilities as required; J. Provide running water; K. Provide adequate hall and stairway lighting; L. Maintain floors, walls and ceilings in good condition; M. Supply window screens where required by code; N. Maintain foundation, masonry, chimneys, water heater and furnace in good working condition; O. Prevent the accumulation of stagnant water in the interior of any premises; P. Maintain in good and safe working order and condition all electrical, plumbing, sanitary, heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and other facilities and appliances supplied by the property owner as required by applicable codes; Q. Provide and maintain appropriate garbage receptacles and arrange for timely garbage removal as required by code; 121 R. Supply electricity, and hot water at all times and heat during at least the months of October through April and as weather conditions might otherwise reasonably warrant, except where the dwelling unit is so constructed that electricity, heat or hot water is within the exclusive control of the tenant and supplied by a direct public utility connection; S. Once proof of pest infestation has been established, be responsible for initiation of pest control measures. In no instance shall a property owner be required to apply pesticides contrary to label directions; T. Not interrupt or disconnect utility service; U. Provide adequate locks to exterior doors and furnish keys to tenants as required by applicable codes; V. Maintain the dwelling unit in a reasonably insulated and weather tight condition as required by the building and housing and Utah state energy conservation codes; W. Provide for and protect each tenant's peaceful enjoyment of the premises; X. Ensure that repairs, decorations, alterations, or improvements, or exhibiting the dwelling unit shall not unreasonably interfere with the tenants' right to quiet enjoyment of the premises; Y. Provide a mailbox; and Z. Provide separate meters for each tenant for gas and electricity or include charges for utility services in the rent. 18.96.060: TENANT TO MAINTAIN DWELLING UNIT: A tenant shall: A. Comply with all appropriate requirements of the rental agreement and applicable provisions of building, housing and health codes; B. Maintain the premises occupied in a clean and safe condition and not unreasonably burden any common area; C. Dispose of all garbage and other waste in a clean and safe manner and avoid leaving garbage or litter in hallways, porches, patios and other common areas; D. Maintain all plumbing fixtures in as sanitary a condition as the fixtures permit and avoid obstructing sinks, toilets, tubs, showers and other plumbing drains; E. Use all electrical, plumbing, sanitary, heating, and other facilities and appliances in a reasonable manner; F. Not destroy, deface, damage, impair or remove any part of the premises or knowingly permit any person to do so; 122 G. Promptly inform the property owner of any defective conditions or problems at the premises; H. Not interfere with the peaceful enjoyment of the residential rental unit of another renter; I. Upon vacation, restore the premises to their initial condition except for reasonable wear and tear or conditions caused by the property owner; J. Be current on all payments required by the rental agreement and this chapter; K. Not increase the number of occupants above that specified in the rental agreement without written permission of the owners; L. Not modify or paint the premises without the express written permission of the property owner/agent; M. Dispose of oil, car batteries, and other hazardous waste materials away from the rental premises, and in a manner prescribed by federal and local laws; and N. Not require the owner to correct or remedy any condition caused by the renter, the renter's family or the renter's guests or invites by inappropriate use of the property during the rental term or any extension of it. 18.96.070: RULES AND REGULATIONS: A property owner may adopt rules or regulations concerning the tenant's use and occupancy of the premises which become a part of the rental agreement if they apply to all tenants in the premises in a nondiscriminatory manner, do not conflict with the lease, state law or city ordinance, and are provided to the tenant before the tenant enters into the rental agreement. Rules, regulations or lease terms can, by agreement between the parties, be more favorable to the tenant than allowed by state law or city ordinance but cannot be more restrictive. Rules may be modified from time to time by the property owner. However, no rule adopted after the commencement of any rental agreement shall substantially modify the existing terms, conditions or rules without written consent of the tenant. 18.96.080: ACCESS: A. A tenant shall not unreasonably withhold consent to the property owner to enter into the dwelling unit in order to make necessary or agreed repairs, decorations, alterations, or improvements; or exhibit the dwelling unit to prospective purchasers, tenants, or work people. B. A property owner may enter the dwelling unit without consent of the tenant in case of emergency. C. Except in case of emergency the property owner shall give the tenant at least 24 hours' notice of plans to enter and may enter only between 8:00 A.M. and 10:00 P.M. 123 D. A property owner has no other right of access except: 1. Pursuant to court order; 2. To make repairs requested by the tenant pursuant to Sections 18.96.110 and 18.96.120 of this chapter; 3. To make repairs ordered by the division pursuant to this title; or 4. If the tenant has abandoned the premises as defined in Section 78B-6-814, Utah Code, or any successor provision. 18.96.090: RESERVED 18.96.100: RESERVED 18.96.110: REPAIR OF SPECIFIED FAILURES: In the event of the failures specified below, which are not due to the unavailability of utility service, the property owner shall take reasonable steps to begin repairing the failures promptly after receipt of written notice of the failure delivered in accordance with Section 18.50.100, and shall remedy such failure within the period set forth in the notice and order issued by the inspector: A. Inoperable toilet B. Tub, shower or kitchen and bathroom sink with inoperable drain or no hot or cold water C. Inoperable refrigerator or cooking range or stove D. Nonfunctioning heating (during a period where heat is reasonably necessary) or electrical system E. Inoperable electric fixture F. Broken exterior door or inoperable or missing exterior door lock G. Broken window with missing glass H. Inoperable exterior lighting I. Broken stair or balustrade J. Inoperable or missing smoke detector required by code K. Inoperable required fire sprinkler system (if smoke detectors are not present or operating) L. Inoperable required fire sprinkler system (if smoke detectors are installed and operable) 124 M. Broken or leaking water pipes causing an imminent threat to life, safety or health N. Other broken or leaking water pipes O. Disconnection of electrical, water or natural gas service caused by property owner The division shall establish repair period standards based on the severity of the failures identified above. The tenant shall grant the property owner reasonable access to perform the repairs required in this section. 18.96.120: VIOLATIONS Violations of this chapter shall be enforced pursuant to Sections 18.50.100 and 18.50.110. 18.96.130: RETALIATORY CONDUCT PROHIBITED: A. Except as provided in this section and section 57-22-4, Utah Code Annotated, a property owner may not terminate a rental agreement or bring or threaten to bring an eviction action because the tenant has in good faith: 1. Complained of code violations at the premises to a governmental agency, elected representative or public official charged with responsibility for enforcement of a building, housing, health or similar code; 2. Complained of a building, housing, health or similar code violation or an illegal property owner practice to a community organization or the news media; 3. Sought the assistance of a community organization or the news media to remedy code violation or illegal property owner practice; 4. Requested the property owner to make repairs to the premises as required by this chapter, a building or health code, other regulation, or the residential rental agreement; 5. Become a member of a tenants' union or similar organization; 6. Testified in any court or administrative proceeding concerning the condition of the premises; or 7. Exercised any right or remedy provided by law. 125 SECTION 20. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Chapter 21A.20. That Chapter 21A.20 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Enforcement) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 21A.20.010: RESERVED 21A.20.020: COMPLAINTS REGARDING VIOLATIONS: A civil enforcement officer may investigate any complaint alleging a violation of this title and take such action as is warranted in accordance with the procedures set forth in this chapter. 21A.20.030: PROCEDURES UPON DISCOVERY OF VIOLATIONS: A. If the civil enforcement officer finds that any provision of this title is being violated, the civil enforcement officer may provide a written warning notice to the property owner and any other person determined to be responsible for such violation. The written notice shall indicate the nature of the violation and order the action necessary to correct it. Additional written notices may be provided at the civil enforcement officer's discretion. B. The written warning notice shall state what action the building services division intends to take if the violation is not corrected. The written notice shall include information regarding the established warning period for the indicated violations and shall serve to start any warning periods provided in this chapter. C. Such written warning notice issued by the civil enforcement officer, if issued, shall be deemed delivered when: 1. A copy of the written notice is posted on the property where said violation(s) occur, and 2. The written notice is either: a. Mailed certified mail or using any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery to the property owner at the last known address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder and any other person determined to be responsible for such violation, at their last known address, or b. Personally served upon the property owner and any other person determined to be responsible for such violation. D. In cases when delay in enforcement would seriously threaten the effective enforcement of this title, or pose a danger to the public health, safety or welfare, the civil enforcement officer may seek enforcement without issuing a warning notice and may proceed directly to issuing a notice and order as set forth in Subpart E. 126 A. Upon discovery of a violation of this title, or if the violation remains uncorrected after expiration of the warning period set forth in the warning notice, if issued, the civil enforcement officer may issue a notice and order. 1. The written notice and order shall state: a. The name and address, if known, of the responsible party; b. The date and location of each violation; c. The code sections violated; d. That the violations must be corrected; e. Provide a specific date by which the enforcement official orders that the violations be corrected by; f. The amount of the civil fine to accrue for each violation, or other enforcement action that the enforcement official intends to pursue, if the violation is not corrected by the date specified; g. Identification of the right to and procedure to appeal; and h. The signature of the enforcement official. 2. The enforcement official shall serve the notice and order on the responsible party by: a. Posting a copy of the written notice and order on the noncompliant property, and b. By mailing the notice and order through certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery. If the responsible party is the property owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known address appearing on the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. If the responsible party is any other person or entity other than the owner of record, then mailing shall be to the last known address of the responsible party on file with the city. c. Notwithstanding the foregoing, personal service upon the responsible party shall be sufficient to meet the notice and order service requirements of this Subsection 21A.20.030.E.2.b. B. Following the issuance of a notice and order, any responsible party shall correct the violations specified in the notice and order. Upon correction of the violations specified in the notice and order, the responsible party shall contact the enforcement official identified in the notice and order to request an inspection of the property. C. If one or more violations are not corrected by the deadline specified in the notice and order, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set forth in Section 21A.20.040. Accumulation of civil fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of civil fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation(s) once confirmed through an inspection requested pursuant to Subsection E. 127 D. The responsible party shall have the right to contest the notice and order at an administrative hearing in accordance with Chapter 21A.16. Failure to timely request an administrative hearing and pay the administrative hearing fee set forth in the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall constitute a waiver of the right to a hearing and a waiver of the right to appeal. E. Upon expiration of the citation period set forth in a notice and order, and where the violation(s) remain uncorrected, the city may record on the noncompliant property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office a notice of noncompliance. The recordation of a notice of noncompliance shall not be deemed an encumbrance on the noncompliant property but shall merely place interested parties on notice of any continuing violation of this title at the noncompliant property. If a notice of noncompliance has been recorded and the enforcement official later determines that all violations identified in the notice of noncompliance have been corrected, the enforcement official shall issue a notice of compliance by recording the notice of compliance on the property with the Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office. Recordation of the notice of compliance shall have the effect of canceling the recorded notice of noncompliance. F. If the city files an action for injunctive relief seeking abatement of one or more violations and the district court authorizes the abatement of one or more violations and the city incurs costs and the costs are not paid, a lien or garnishment may be placed to recover the costs and may be considered an encumbrance on the property. 21A.20.040: CIVIL FINES: A. General: If the violations are not corrected by the citation deadline, civil fines shall accrue at $50 a day per violation for those properties legally used for purposes that are solely residential uses, and $200 a day per violation for those properties used for purposes that are not residential uses. B. Affordable housing incentives per 21A.52.050: If the violation(s) are not corrected by the citation deadline, civil fines shall accrue at the rate set in the Consolidated Fee Schedule per day per violation. If the violation(s) include renting an affordable rental unit in excess of the approved rental rate then an additional monthly fine shall accrue that is the difference between the market rate of the unit and the approved rental rate that is agreed to by the applicant at the time of approval for a project using the incentives. C. Failure to obtain certificate of appropriateness pursuant to Section 21A.34.020: For development or any building activity on properties subject to Section 21A.34.020 without a certificate of appropriateness, if such violation is not corrected by the citation deadline, civil fines shall accrue at $50 per day, except that the fine for full or partial demolition of a contributing structure or landmark site without a certificate of appropriateness shall be $250 per day. 21A.20.050: DAILY VIOLATIONS: 128 Each day a violation continues after the citation deadline shall be considered a separate offense and give rise to a separate civil fine. Accumulation of civil fines for violations, but not the obligation for payment of civil fines already accrued, shall stop upon correction of the violation. 21A.20.060: COMPLIANCE: The city may use such lawful means as are available to obtain compliance with the provisions of this title and to collect the civil fines that accrue as a result of the violation of the provisions of this title, including a legal action to obtain one or more of the following: an injunction, an order of mandamus, an order requiring the property owner or occupant to abate the violations, an order permitting the city to enter the property to abate the violations, and a judgment in the amount of the civil fines accrued for the violation, including costs and attorney fees. The city has sole discretion over which remedy or combination of remedies it may choose to pursue. Violations of the provisions of this title or failure to comply with any of its requirements are punishable as a Class C misdemeanor upon conviction. 21A.20.070: RECURRING VIOLATIONS: In the case where a violation, which had been corrected, reoccurs at the same property within 6 months of the initial correction and is due to the actions or inactions of the same person or property owner as the prior violation(s), the building services division may begin enforcement of said recurring violation by sending by certified mail or reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery a notice and order in the form described in Subsection 21A.20.030.E of this chapter. Civil fines set forth in Section 21A.020.040 of this chapter will begin accruing if the violation is not remedied within 10 calendar days of the citation deadline contained in that notice. 21A.20.080: APPEALING CIVIL FINES TO A FINES HEARING OFFICER: A. Powers and Duties of Fines Hearing Officer: The fines hearing officer, appointed pursuant to Section 21A.06.090 of this title, may hear and decide appeals of civil fines imposed pursuant to this chapter. As set forth in this section, the fines hearing officer may reduce civil fines and approve civil fine payment schedules. B. Right to Appear: Any person receiving a notice of violation may appear before a fines hearing officer to appeal the amount of the civil fine imposed by submitting a civil fine appeal on a form provided by the building services division. However, no party may appear before a fines hearing officer until violations from which the civil fines stemmed have been corrected and a notice of compliance has been issued. Appeals to a fines hearing officer contesting the amount of the civil fine imposed, must be filed within 30 days from the date of the notice of compliance. C. Responsibility: Commencement of any action to remove or reduce civil fines shall not relieve the responsibility of any person cited to correct the violation or make payment of 129 subsequently accrued civil fines nor shall it require the city to reissue any of the notices required by this chapter. D. Reduction of Civil Fine: Civil fines may be reduced at the discretion of the fines hearing officer after the violation is corrected from which the civil fines stemmed and if any of the following conditions exist: 1. The violation pertains to landscaping, in which case the time for payment and correction of landscaping violations may be abated from October 15 through the next April 1, or such other times as caused by weather conditions adverse to successful landscaping; 2. Strict compliance with the notice and order would have caused an imminent and irreparable injury to persons or property; 3. The violation and inability to correct the same were both caused by a force majeure event such as war, act of nature, strike or civil disturbance; 4. A change in the actual ownership of the property was recorded with the Salt Lake County Recorder's Office after the first or second notice was issued and the new property owner is not related by blood, marriage or common ownership to the prior owner; or 5. Such other mitigating circumstances as determined by the fines hearing officer. E. Payment Schedule: At the request of a person subject to civil fines governed by this chapter, the fines hearing officer may approve a payment schedule for the delayed or periodic payment of the applicable civil fine to accommodate the person's unique circumstances or ability to pay. F. Failure to Submit Payment on Payment Schedule: If a payment schedule has been developed by the fines hearing officer, the failure by a person owing civil fines to submit any two (2) payments as scheduled shall cause the entire amount of the original civil fine to become immediately due. 21A.20.090: NOTICE OF CITY'S INTENT TO ABATE ZONING VIOLATIONS: A. If the city obtains a court order permitting entry on the property for the purpose of abating zoning violations, the building services division shall provide written notice of that order to the property owner of record at the address on file with the Salt Lake County Recorder. B. The notice shall: 1) identify the property owner of record according to the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder, 2) describe the property and the violations the court order permits the building services division to enter the property to abate, 3) attach a copy of the court order, and (4) inform the property owner when the abatement is scheduled to occur. 130 C. Notice may be delivered in person, or by certified mail, or by reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, if mailed to the last known address of the property owner according to the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. 21A.20.100: COLLECTION OF THE COSTS OF ABATEMENT: A. If the building services division or an agent thereof enters a property to abate a violation pursuant to a court order, as set forth in Section 21A.20.090 of this chapter, the building services division may collect the cost of that abatement, by filing a property tax lien, as set forth in this section. B. Upon completion of abatement work, the building services division shall prepare an itemized statement of costs and mail it to the property owner by certified mail or by any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery, demanding payment within 30 days of the date the statement is post marked. C. The itemized statement of costs shall: 1. Include: a. The address of the property at issue; b. An itemized list of all expenses incurred by the building services division, including administrative costs; c. A demand for payment; and d. The address where payment is to be made; 2. Notify the property owner: a. That failure to timely pay the expenses described in the itemized statement may result in a lien on the property in accordance with this chapter and Utah Code section 10-11-4 or its successor; b. That the property owner may file a written objection to all or part of the statement within 20 days of the date the statement is postmarked; and c. Where the property owner may file the objection, including the name of the office and the mailing address. D. The itemized statement of costs described in subsection C of this section shall be deemed delivered when mailed by certified mail or by any reputable mail tracking service that is capable of confirming delivery addressed to the last known address of the property owner, according to the records of the Salt Lake County Recorder. E. If the property owner files a timely objection, the building services division will schedule a hearing in accordance with title 52, chapter 4 of the Utah Code (Open and Public Meetings Act), and will mail or deliver to the property owner prior to the hearing a notice stating the date, time, and location of the hearing. 131 F. At the hearing described in subsection E of this section, a fines hearing officer shall review and determine the actual cost of abatement incurred by the building services division in abating the property, including administrative costs. The property owner must pay any amount the fines hearing officer determines is due and owing to the Salt Lake City Treasurer at the address provided in the statement of costs within 30 days of the date of the hearing. G. If the property owner fails to make payment of the amount set forth in the itemized statement within 30 days of the date of the mailing of that statement, or to file a timely objection, then the building services division may certify the past due costs and expenses to the Salt Lake County Treasurer and the Treasurer will proceed as set forth in Utah Code section 10- 11-4 or its successor. H. If the property owner files a timely objection but fails to make payment of any amount found due and owing under subsection F of this section within 30 days of the date of the hearing, the building services division may certify the past due costs and expense to the Salt Lake County Treasurer and the Treasurer will proceed as set forth in Utah Code section 10-11-4. I. After entry by the Treasurer of the County, as set forth in subsections G and H of this section the amount entered shall be a nonrecurring notice charge as defined in Utah Code 11- 60-102, is a lien on the property, and shall be collected by the Salt Lake County Treasurer at the time of the payment of general taxes. J. Notwithstanding any other provision in this chapter to the contrary, where the property owner presents evidence demonstrating financial hardship to the satisfaction of the building services division, the building services division may waive some or all administrative fees and the actual costs incurred in abating the property if the property abated is the property owner's principal place of residence. SECTION 21. Amending the Text of Salt Lake City Code Section 21A.62.040. That Section 21A.62.040 of the Salt Lake City Code (Zoning: Definitions: Definitions of Terms), shall be and hereby is amended as follows: a. Adding the definition of “CITATION DEADLINE.” That the definition of “CITATION DEADLINE” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: CITATION DEADLINE: the date identified in the notice and order to correct the violation(s) identified therein. 132 b. Adding the definition of “CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.” That the definition of “CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: CIVIL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER: an employee of Salt Lake City’s Division of Building Services, or successor division, authorized to perform civil enforcement functions, or any duly authorized agent, representative, or designee. c. Adding the definition of “NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE.” That the definition of “NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE: a written notice informing the person cited that the violation has been corrected. d. Adding the definition of “PERSON CITED.” That the definition of “PERSON CITED” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: PERSON CITED: the property owner, property owner's agent, tenant or occupant of any building or land or part thereof and any architect, builder, contractor, agent or other person who participates in, assists, directs or creates any situation that is contrary to the requirements of this title, and who received the notice of violation and is being held responsible for the violation. e. Adding the definition of “PROPERTY OWNER.” That the definition of “PROPERTY OWNER” be added and inserted into the list of definitions in alphabetical order to read as follows: PROPERTTY OWNER: any person who, alone or jointly or severally with others, holds legal title to the property at issue. 133 SECTION 22. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 2.07.020. That Section 2.07.020 of the Salt Lake City Code is hereby amended to eliminate the “Housing advisory and appeals board” therefrom as follows: 2.07.020: CITY BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS NAMED: For the purpose of this chapter the term "city board" or "board" means the following city boards, commissions, councils, and committees: Accessibility and disability commission Airport board Board of appeals and examiners Business advisory board Citizens' compensation advisory committee City and county building conservancy and use committee Community development and capital improvement programs advisory board Community recovery committee Fire code board of appeals Golf enterprise fund advisory board Historic landmark commission Housing trust fund advisory board Human rights commission Library board Parks, natural lands, trails, and urban forestry advisory board Planning commission Public utilities advisory committee Racial equity in policing commission Salt Lake art design board Salt Lake City arts council board Salt Lake City sister cities board Transportation advisory board 134 SECTION 23. Repealing Salt Lake City Code Chapter 2.21. That Chapter 2.21 of the Salt Lake City Code (Housing Advisory and Appeals Board) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 2.21.010: GENERAL PROVISIONS: The provisions of chapter 2.07 of this title shall apply to the housing advisory and appeals board except as otherwise set forth in this chapter. (Ord. 67-13, 2013) 2.21.020: CREATION AND MEMBERSHIP: A. The city creates a housing advisory and appeals board ("HAAB"). B. HAAB shall be comprised of ten (10) members from among the qualified electors of the city in a manner providing balanced geographical, professional, neighborhood and community representation. C. The HAAB chair or vice chair may not be elected to serve consecutive terms in the same office. The secretary of HAAB shall be designated by the building official. D. The expiration of terms shall be staggered with no more than three (3) terms expiring in any one year. Expiration of terms shall be on December 31. 2.21.030: POWERS AND AUTHORITY: HAAB shall have the power and authority to: A. Apply the provisions of Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 18.50 of this code; B. Hear and decide appeals as specified in Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 18.50 of this code; C. Modify the impact of specific provisions of Title 5, Chapter 5.14 and Title 18, Chapter 18.50 of this code, where strict compliance with the provisions is economically or structurally impracticable and any approved alternative substantially accomplishes the purpose and intent of the requirement deviated from; D. Conduct housing impact hearings pursuant to Title 18, Chapter 18.64 of this code; E. Recommend new procedures to the building official and new ordinances regarding housing to the city council; and F. Hear and decide appeals as specified in Title 18, Chapter 18.48 of this code. 135 2.21.040: HAAB PANELS: Unless otherwise determined appropriate by the chair, HAAB may exercise any of its responsibilities under title 5, chapter 5.14, or title 18, chapter 18.50 of this code in panels of five (5) voting members appointed by the chair. (Ord. 65-15, 2015) SECTION 24. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Section 2.80.040. That Section 2.80.040 of the Salt Lake City Code (Housing Trust Fund Advisory Board: Fund Created) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 2.80.040: FUND CREATED: There is created a restricted account within the general fund, to be designated as the "Salt Lake City housing trust fund" (the "fund"). The fund shall be accounted for separately within the general fund, and the fund shall be used exclusively to assist with affordable and special needs housing in the city. No expenditures shall be made from the fund without approval of the city council. A. There shall be deposited into the fund all monies received by the city, regardless of source, which are dedicated to affordable housing and special needs housing including, but not limited to, the following: 1. Grants, loan repayments, bonuses, entitlements, mitigation fees, forfeitures, donations, redevelopment tax increment income, and all other monies dedicated to affordable and special needs housing received by the city from federal, state, or local governments; 2. Real property contributed to or acquired by the city under other ordinances for the purposes of preserving, developing, or restoring affordable housing; 3. Monies appropriated to the fund by the council; and 4. Contributions made specifically for this purpose from other public or private sources. 5. CDBG, ESG, and HOPWA monies only as designated by the city's community development advisory board and approved by the mayor and city council, and HOME monies only as designated by the city's housing trust fund advisory board and approved by the mayor and city council. B. The monies in the fund shall be invested by the city treasurer in accordance with the usual procedures for such special accounts. All interest or other earnings derived from fund monies shall be deposited in the fund. 136 SECTION 25. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Subsection 5.14.120.B.2. That Subsection 5.14.120.B.2 of the Salt Lake City Code (Rental Dwellings: Enforcement: Civil Penalties: Amount of Penalty) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 2. Amount of Penalty: Civil penalties shall accrue as follows: a. Violations of the self-certification standards established by the City: $50.00 per violation per day. If more than 10 violations exist, the daily penalties shall double. SECTION 26. Amending the text of Salt Lake City Code Subsection 5.14.120.B.6. That Subsection 5.14.120.B.6 of the Salt Lake City Code (Rental Dwellings: Enforcement: Civil Penalties: Appeals) shall be, and hereby is amended as follows: 6. Appeals: a. Appeals Contesting the Existence of a Violation: (1) Appeals contesting the existence of the violation must be done in accordance with Section 18.12.030. b. Appeals Contesting the Amount of the Penalties Imposed: any person receiving a notice of violation may appeal the civil fines imposed, but not the basis therefor (which must be done pursuant to Subsection 5.14.120.B.6.a), in accordance with Section 18.12.050. SECTION 27. Repealing Salt Lake City Code Section 5.14.125. That Section 5.14.125 of the Salt Lake City Code (Housing Advisory and Appeals Board Appellate Process Details) shall be, and hereby is repealed in its entirety as follows: 5.14.125: HOUSING ADVISORY AND APPEALS BOARD APPELLATE PROCESS DETAILS: A. Filing Of Appeals: Appeals shall be submitted on an appeal form provided by the building official. The appellant shall state the specific order or action protested and a statement 137 of the relief sought, along with the reasons why the order or action should be reversed, modified or otherwise set aside. B. Failure To Appeal: Failure of any person to file an appeal in accordance with the provisions of this section shall constitute a waiver of the person's right to an appeal. C.Inspection Of The Premises: Before any hearing is held by a Housing Advisory and Appeals Board panel, the panel shall inspect the building or premises involved. Prior notice of such inspection shall be given to the notified party filing the appeal, who may be present at such inspection. Upon completion of the inspection, the Chairperson of the panel shall state for the record the material facts observed at the inspection, which facts shall be read at the initiation of the hearing. Failure of the notified party to provide access without good cause as determined by the building official shall not constitute a reason for the hearing to be postponed and the appeal may be denied. D. Written Notice: Written notice of the time and place of panel hearings shall be mailed to the appellant in accordance with procedures adopted by the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board. E.Appeals Hearing: Any notified party may appear personally or authorize a designee to act in their behalf. The City and any notified party may call and examine witnesses on any relevant matter, introduce documentary and physical evidence, and cross examine opposing witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted. F.Record: A record of the entire proceeding of all appellate hearings under this section shall be made by tape recording, or by any other means of permanent recording determined to be appropriate by the Housing Advisory and Appeals Board. The record shall be retained on file in accordance with the City's record retention schedule. SECTION 28. Amending the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule. That the Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be, and hereby is, amended, in pertinent part, to reflect the fees set forth in the attached Exhibit A, and that a copy of the amended Salt Lake City consolidated fee schedule shall be published on the official Salt Lake City website. SECTION 29. Effective Date. That this ordinance shall become effective on the date of its first publication. 138 ___________________________ atherine D. Pasker, Senior City Att Passed by the City Council of Salt Lake City, Utah this day of 2024. CHAIRPERSON ATTEST: CITY RECORDER Transmitted to Mayor on . Mayor’s Action: Approved. Vetoed. MAYOR (SEAL) Bill No. of 2024. Published: Ordinance amending Title 18 administration_v2 APPROVED AS TO FORM Salt Lake City Attorney’s Office Date:March 11, 2024 By: _ K orney 139 EXHIBIT A COMMUNITY AND NEIGHBORHOODS (CAN) Service Fee Additional Information Section Boarding or Securing of Buildings Boarding administrative costs $500 Plus actual costs, see Section 18.48.100 18.48.100 Boarding registration fee $14,000 Per parcel 18.48.215 Boarding registration fee for a contributing structure or landmark site $14,850 Per parcel 18.48.215 Other abatement administrative cost $129 Plus actual costs 18.48, 9.36, 21A.20 City maintenance of building $219 Annual, plus actual costs, see Section 18.48.250 18.48.250 Building Code Enforcement Violation of Title 18 (except Ch. 18.50 or Stop Work Order) $100 18.24.030 Violation of Stop Work Order $250 18.24.040.B Violation of Ch. 18.50 Substandard condition $50 18.50.100.D Hazardous condition $100 18.50.100.D Imminent danger condition $250 18.50.100.D Appeal of a decision to the board of appeals and examiners $285 Add’l fee for required public notices 18.12.020 Page | 1 COUNCIL STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY TO:City Council Members FROM:Vili Lolohea, District Liaison / Policy Specialist DATE:December 3, 2024 RE: Salt Lake City ADA Self-Evaluation & Transition Plan ISSUE AT A GLANCE This memorandum summarizes the findings and recommendations from Salt Lake City’s ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan. This work assesses the City’s compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and identifies key steps to eliminate accessibility barriers in City programs, facilities, and public spaces. This plan is to meet the goals of the Department of Justice (DOJ), which urges local governments to establish procedures for an ongoing assessment of their compliance with the ADA's barrier removal requirements. The last plan was in place in 1993. Key Findings: 1.City Buildings: 15 facilities assessed, with barriers like inadequate signage, inaccessible entrances, and non-compliant restrooms. 2.Public Rights of Way: o 40.1% of sidewalks require grinding. o 24.44% of curb ramps need upgrading to meet ADA standards. 3.Parks and Golf Courses: Accessibility barriers in 79 parks and 6 golf courses include non-compliant play structures and ground surfacing. 4.Communication: Citywide need for improved, ADA-compliant signage and digital accessibility. Recommendations: To address these barriers, the following actions are proposed: 1.Administrative Actions: o Regularly evaluate ADA compliance in programs and policies. o Adopt Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) for all digital content. o Train staff and provide timely updates on ADA initiatives. 2.Collaborative Actions: o Work with disability stakeholders, including the Accessibility and Disability Commission. Item Schedule: Briefing: December 3, 2024 Action: December 10, 2024 Public Hearing: January 7, 2025 Potential Action: TBD Page | 2 o Develop a data dashboard to monitor Transition Plan progress. o Create evidence-based design guides for long-term accessibility improvements. 3.Legislative and Budgetary Actions: o Allocate funding for high-priority barrier removal. o Increase budgets for sidewalk, curb ramp, and pathway upgrades. o Implement ADA standards and best practices for all new construction and renovations. o Fund citywide signage assessments and improvements. Attachments: 1 - Full ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan 2 - Appendix A: ADA Liaison List Salt Lake City ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan Executive Summary Background The 1990 ADA regulations required local governments to: evaluate all their services, policies, practices, and facilities, modify any that did not meet ADA requirements, and develop a transition plan detailing barrier removal to achieve program access that specified a completion time (entities with 50+ employees). A self-evaluation is a comprehensive report of the assessment of a city’s programs, services, activities; facilities; and current policies, practices and procedures. The self-evaluation identifies and corrects barriers to program access that are inconsistent with its Title II requirements. Per regulations, this was to be completed by January 26, 1993. Salt Lake City Corporation completed a self-evaluation on July 1, 1992. A transition plan identifies architectural barriers found in the self-evaluation. It outlines how and when in the following three years (from the time of the self-evaluation) programmatic barriers will be eliminated. This was to be initiated and accomplished by July 26, 1995. No historical files were found showing this was initiated or accomplished by Salt Lake City Corporation, with the exception being a Transition Plan for City public way assets by Engineering every 2 years. The Department of Justice (DOJ) urges local governments to establish procedures for an ongoing assessment of their compliance with the ADA's barrier removal requirements. If a complaint is filed with the DOJ, any consent decree initiated by the DOJ will require a self-evaluation to be done within a certain timeframe. It is the first document the DOJ asks for during an investigation. Methodology The evaluation of the City's services, programs, and activities required participation by every City department. Departments, through their ADA liaison, completed the evaluation process under the ADA Coordinator’s guidance. Appendix A lists all participating ADA liaisons. To complete the Existing Facilities evaluation for priority buildings, parks, and golf courses, an ArcGIS survey was created using the ADA Checklist for Existing Facilities based on the 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design. For each location, the survey evaluated: Priority 1: Accessible approach and entrance o Parking, Exterior Accessible Route, Curb Ramps, Exterior Ramps, Entrance Priority 2: Access to goods and services o Interior Accessible Route, Interior Ramps, Elevators, Signs, Interior Doors (to conference rooms, etc.), Rooms and Spaces, Seating (Assembly Areas, Non-employee work surfaces, General), Sales and Service Counters Priority 3: Access to public toilet rooms o Accessible Route, Signs, Entrance, Lavatories (The 2010 Standards refer to sinks in toilet rooms as lavatories.), Soap Dispensers and Hand Dryers, Toilet Stalls Priority 4: Access to other items such as water fountains and public telephones o Drinking Fountains, Telephones, Fire Alarm Systems For each park location, the survey also evaluated: Play Areas, Sports Courts and Athletic Fields, and Other Available Amenities Key Findings 1.Building Facilities: 15 City-owned buildings were evaluated, and barriers found include: inadequate signage, non-compliant restrooms, inaccessible entrances, and pathways. 2.Public Rights of Way (PROW): An inventory of sidewalks and curb ramps revealed significant areas that do not meet ADA standards. Approximately 40.1% of sidewalks require grinding, and 24.44% of curb ramps need upgrades to meet current ADA criteria. 3.City Parks and Golf Courses: The evaluation of all City-owned parks (79) and golf courses (6) identified numerous areas requiring improvements. These include the need for accessible play structures, compliant ground surfacing, and proper signage. 4.Communications and Signage: There is a need for improved signage and communication aids to ensure that individuals with disabilities can easily access information and navigate City facilities. Recommendations To address the identified issues, the following recommendations are proposed for the City Council’s consideration and support. Some recommendations are administrative in nature, while some are legislative or require the cooperation of both branches of government: Continually evaluating all programs, services, and policies. The implementation of WCAG standards to all digital content on websites, social media, and apps. Communicating the City’s ADA compliance initiatives through timely updates and staff training. Working with disability stakeholders, including the City’s Accessibility and Disability Commission, to improve or implement accessibility measures. The development of a robust Transition Plan management dashboard for data collection. The development of an evidence-based Design Best Practices Guide for the public right of way, facilities, signage, and parks to improve long-term accessibility outcomes. The development of a city-wide policy that mandates all new construction and major renovations to comply with the latest ADA standards and the City’s best practices. The allocation of funding for the removal of high-priority barriers in buildings and parks. Increasing budget allocations for the repair and upgrade of sidewalks, curb ramps, and pedestrian pathways. Funding an assessment and design plan for signage citywide to ensure all City facilities have clear, compliant, and unified signage that aligns with the City’s branding. Conclusion Salt Lake City's commitment to ADA compliance is crucial for fostering an inclusive community. By supporting these recommendations, the City can ensure that all individuals, regardless of their abilities, have equal access to public services and facilities. The City Council’s support and action are vital in driving accessibility initiatives forward, ensuring a more accessible and equitable city for all. This executive summary provides a strategic overview and actionable policy recommendations aimed at enhancing Salt Lake City's compliance with ADA standards. For further details and specific findings, please refer to the complete ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan. Item B4 CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 304 P.O. BOX 145476, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84114-5476 SLCCOUNCIL.COM TEL 801-535-7600 FAX 801-535-7651 MOTION SHEET CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY TO:City Council Members FROM: Nick Tarbet Policy Analyst DATE:December 3, 2024 RE: MOTION SHEET – Jordan River Fairpark District Rezone & Text Amendment and Development Agreement Petition No PLNPCM2024-00982 MOTION 1 I move the Council close the public hearing and defer action to a future council meeting. MOTION 2 I move that the Council continue the public hearing to a future council meeting. MUNICIPAL SERVICES INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT This Municipal Services Interlocal Agreement (Agreement) is entered into between Salt Lake City Corporation, a Utah municipal corporation (City), and the Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District, a political subdivision of the State of Utah (Fairpark District), to be effective as of January 1, 2025 (Effective Date). A. In 2024, the Utah State legislature passed House Bill 562, the Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District (the Act) and created the Fairpark District. B. As set forth in the Act, the purpose of the Fairpark District is to encourage and facilitate development within the fairpark district boundary, described and depicted on Exhibit A (Fairpark District Boundary). The Fairpark District Boundary shall also mean any land included in the Fairpark District Boundary as permitted by the Act. C. Among other things, the Act establishes that certain taxes, including but not limited to enhanced property tax (defined below) that would have otherwise been received by the City for the City to provide municipal services, largely be redirected to the Fairpark District. D. The Act requires the City to provide the same municipal services to the Fairpark District Boundary as the City provides other areas of the City with similar zoning and development levels. E. The Act provides that the City shall receive 25% of the enhanced property tax from the Fairpark District Boundary, which alone does not cover the City’s costs for services. For example, in 2023, the City’s cost for municipal services in the Fairpark District Boundary was $1.2 million but the property taxes were approximately $45,000. F. In order help address this difference in costs, the Act further provides that the City and Fairpark District enter into this Agreement providing for the Fairpark District to reimburse the City for the cost of services the City is obligated to provide to the growing development within the Fairpark District Boundary. G. With the City receiving a percentage of the City’s property taxes, the City will not be fully reimbursed for the cost for municipal services, and as such, the City depends on on this Agreement to help support the cost of necessary municipal services for the Fairpark District Boundary as it develops, including but not limited to police, fire, transportation, public lands, and homelessness assistance. H. The parties enter into this Agreement setting forth the terms of the Fairpark District’s reimbursement to the City for municipal services. NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the parties agree as follows: (a) Reimbursement. Pursuant to the Act, in addition to the base taxable value and 25% of the enhanced property tax, the City shall be reimbursed by the Fairpark District an additional amount to help compensate the City for the cost of municipal services the City provides. The term “base taxable value” means the taxable value of the land within the Fairpark District Boundary as of January 1, 2024, determined by the Fairpark District Board and the Salt Lake County Assessor. The term “enhanced property tax” means the difference between: i) the amount of property tax revenues generated in a tax year by the City from privately owned land, using the current assessed value of the Property; and ii) the amount of property tax revenues that would be generated in the same tax year by the City from that same area using the base taxable value of the property. The additional percentage of enhanced property tax the City shall be paid to reimburse the City for municipal services (Enhanced Property Tax Payment), shall be: (a) Beginning January 1, 2025, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 10%; (b) Beginning January 1, 2030, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 20%; (c) Beginning January 1, 2035, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 35%; (d) Beginning January 1, 2040, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 50%; (e) Beginning January 1, 2045, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 65%; (f) Beginning January 1, 2050, and for a period of 5 years, shall be 80%; and (g) Beginning January 1, 2055, and for the remainder of the Fairpark District, the City shall receive 100% of the enhanced property tax. 1. Adjustment. The City and Fairpark District may exercise the option to reevaluate the City’s cost for municipal services for the Fairpark District Boundary and determine if the Enhaced Property Tax Payment is sufficient to cover the City’s actual costs. If the amount the City receives through the Enhanced Property Tax Payment is not the same as the actual cost for municipal services, the parties shall adjust the percentages in Section 1 accordingly through an amendment to this Agreement. This adjustment cannot be exercised by either party more than once every three years and may not be exercised after January 1, 2055. Until an amendment is finalized, the adjustment shall not impact the Fairpark District’s obligation to make the required Enhanced Property Tax payment to the City. 2. Term. The term of this Agreement shall be from January 1, 2025, until the earlier of when: i) the Fairpark District terminates the collection of all taxes (including enhanced property tax), that, if collected by the Fairpark District, preempts the City’s collection of the same tax; or ii) the Fairpark District dissolves. 3. Enhanced Property Tax Reimbursement and Procedures. The Fairpark District shall make each annual Enhanced Property Tax Payment by the later of (a) April 30 following the applicable tax year or (b) 60 days following Fairpark District’s receipt of the enhanced property tax from Salt Lake County if the Fairpark District does not receive the enhanced property tax until after March 1. The Fairpark District assumes all risk that the Fairpark District Boundary may not generate sufficient enhanced property tax to fulfill its objectives. 4. Default. Neither party shall be in default under this Agreement unless such party fails to perform an obligation required under this Agreement within 30 days after written notice is given to the defaulting party by the other party, reasonably setting forth the reasons in which the defaulting party has failed to perform such obligation. If the nature of the defaulting party’s obligation is such that more than 30 days are reasonably required for performance or cure, the defaulting party shall not be in default if such party commences performance within such 30-day period and after such commencement diligently prosecutes such cure to completion, provided that the maximum additional time to complete such cure is 90 days (or, 120 days in total). In the event a default under this Agreement remains uncured after the above-described cure period, the non- defaulting party retains all rights under law and equity. In the event the Fairpark District default is caused by its failure to pay the annual Enhanced Property Tax Payment and fails to cure such default as provided in this section, City shall charge Fairpark District a late fee of 10% per annum of the amount of enhanced property tax due and not received by the City until the outstanding amount is paid in full. 5. Miscellaneous (a)Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding between the parties regarding the subject matter of this Agreement. There are no terms, obligations, covenants, statements, representations, warranties or conditions relating to the subject matters other than those specifically contained in this Agreement. This Agreement supersedes all prior oral or written negotiations, agreements and covenants relative to the subject matters of this Agreement. (b) Notices. All notices, demands, requests, and other communications required or permitted hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to be delivered, whether received or not, three (3) days after deposit by United States mail, registered or certified (or another commercially acceptable means requiring a return receipt), postage prepaid, addressed as follows: If to Fairpark District: Fairpark District Attn: [Address] [Address] Email: If to City: Salt Lake City Corporation Attn: Room [number], City & County Building 451 South State Street Salt Lake City, UT 84111 Email: With a copy to: Salt Lake City Attorney’s Office Attn: City Attorney 451 South State Street, Suite 505A Salt Lake City, UT 84111 Email: Such communications may also be given by email, provided any such communication is concurrently given by one of the above methods. Notices shall be deemed effective upon the receipt, or upon attempted delivery if the delivery is refused by the intended recipient or if delivery is impossible because the intended recipient has failed to provide a reasonable means of accomplishing delivery. (c) Governing Law. This Agreement is intended to be performed in the State of Utah, and the laws of Utah shall govern the validity, construction, enforcement and interpretation of this Agreement. (d) Amendments. This Agreement may be amended or supplemented only by an instrument in writing executed by both parties and pursuant to the Interlocal Cooperation Act. (e)Waiver. No waiver of any of the provisions of this Agreement shall be deemed, or shall constitute, a waiver of any other provision, whether or not similar, nor shall any waiver constitute a continuing waiver. No waiver of any of the terms of this Agreement shall be binding unless reduced to writing and signed by the party or parties sought to be charged with such waiver. 6. Interlocal Cooperation Act Requirements. In satisfaction of the requirements of the Interlocal Cooperation Act, §§ 11-13-101 et seq., and in connection with this Agreement, the parties agree as follows: (a) This Agreement shall be approved by each party pursuant to § 11-13- 202.5; (b) This Agreement shall be reviewed as to the proper form and compliance with applicable law by an authorized attorney on behalf of each party pursuant to § 11-13-202.5; (c) An executed original counterpart shall be filed with the keeper of records for each party pursuant to § 11-13-209; (d) The Term of this Agreement does not exceed fifty (50) years pursuant to § 11-13- 216 of the Interlocal Cooperation Act; (e) No separate legal entity is created by the terms of this Agreement. No real or personal property shall be acquired jointly by the parties as a result of this Agreement. To the extent that a party acquires, holds, or disposes of any real or personal property for use in the joint or cooperative undertaking contemplated by this Agreement, such party shall do so in the same manner that it deals with other property of such party; and (f) Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, each party shall be responsible for its own costs of any action taken pursuant to this Agreement, and for any financing of such costs. [SIGNATURE PAGES FOLLOW] (f) IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement to be effective as of the Effective Date. Salt Lake City Corporation: Erin Mendenhall, Mayor Approved as to form: Salt Lake City Attorney’s Office ____________________________ Attest and countersign: Salt Lake City Recorder Utah Fairpark Area Investment and Restoration District: Benn Buys, Executive Director EXHIBIT A TO MUNICIPAL SERVICES INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT COUNCIL STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY TO:City Council Members FROM: Nick Tarbet, Policy Analyst DATE: December 3, 2024 RE:Text Amendment: Northpoint Light Industrial (M-1A) Zoning District Petition PLMPCM2024- 00333 PROJECT TIMELINE: Briefing 1: Sept 3, 2024 Briefing 2: Oct 15, 2024 Briefing 3: Dec 3, 2024 Set Date: Sept 3, 2024 Public Hearing: Oct 1, 2024 Potential Action: Dec. 10. 2024 NEW INFORMATION At the October 15 work session briefing, the Council did not support removing the 300’ buffer from the code to be addressed in future development agreements. However, the Council did instruct staff to work with the administration to come up with potential options for the council to consider about potential additional allowed uses within the 300’ buffer. Based on that direction, Planning worked with Public Utilities on the following option for the Council to consider. The buffer from the River would be divided up into three sections from the annual high-water mark. The permitted uses are outlined in the tables linked below or in Attachment A. No Disturbance Area: 0-100 ft. o No development at all o Permitted uses are outlined in Area A of Table 21A.34.130-3 (Undeveloped lots) Structure Limit Area: 100-200 ft o Very minimal development, like trails, patios, and fencing, allowed. o Permitted uses are outlined in Area B of Table 21A.34.130-2 (Developed lots) Buffer Transition Area: 200-300 ft Page | 3 o Changes to Area C of Riparian Corridor Overlay (RCO), which allows most uses in the underlying zone as long as they follow all other requirements in the RCO zone o Permitted uses are outlined in Area C of table 21A.34.130-2 (Developed lots) Attachment C is the draft ordinance with the potential edits highlighted so they can easily be identified. It shows the draft language for the buffer changes as well as the edits the Council previously approved: adding painted texture concrete to the list of allowable building materials and clarifying maximum building height in relation to the loading dock. If the Council supports these changes, they will be included in the final draft for potential adoption on December 10. PUBLIC COMMENTS Some have raised a concern with the city’s ability to limit large distributors from building in this area. Staff believes the design standards, such as maximum lot size and maximum length of blank walls, will disincentivize the large-scale distributors from building within this zoning district. Additionally, M-1A zoning permits Wholesale Distribution but not Distribution Centers. Both definitions, see below, clarify that businesses can allocate part of their building for storage and distribution to businesses or customers. However, this accessory distribution use must comply with specific requirements in the code, including the stipulation that it be subordinate in area—meaning the space dedicated to this use cannot exceed 50% of the total structure. Wholesale Distribution (permitted in M-1A): A business that maintains an inventory of materials, supplies and goods related to one or more industries and sells bulk quantities of materials, supplies and goods from its inventory to companies within the industry. A wholesale distributor is not a retail goods establishment. The term "wholesale distribution" does not include accessory distribution that is subordinate and incidental to a primary land use (e.g., manufacturing, industrial assembly, or other type of primary commercial or industrial use). Distribution Center (not permitted in M-1A): A facility that is used for the receipt of products and the storage, separation, and distribution of those products on an individual basis to individual end-user consumers. This includes e-commerce activities. A distribution center is not a retail goods establishment. The term "distribution center" does not include accessory distribution that is subordinate and incidental to a primary land use (e.g., manufacturing, industrial assembly, or other type of primary commercial or industrial use). The following information was provided for the October 15 work session briefing. WORK SESSION SUMMARY -OCTOBER 15 During the October 1 public hearing a few people spoke. Two individuals who live along 2200 West spoke about the significant negative impacts they are experiencing due to the warehouse construction going on west of 2200 West. They said the new zone would ruin agricultural land. Another individual spoke about how the city can limit distribution and wholesale uses. Page | 4 The Council closed the public hearing and deferred action to a future meeting. At the September 3 briefing, the Council directed staff to work with Planning and stakeholders on two issues: 1. Maximum building height pertaining to docks at below-grade 2. Buffer requirements from the Jordan River: Consider whether there are alternatives or potential development agreements that can help address the concerns. Updates to the Ordinance 1. Maximum Height in relation to loading docks: The red underlined text is the new language Planning staff recommended and stakeholders supported. Maximum Height: No building shall exceed 40 feet in height. Building height along loading dock areas may exceed the maximum height limit by 5 feet. The additional height shall only be allowed below the average elevation of finished grade and the area shall be excluded from the calculation of the average elevation of finished grade. 2. Included painted texture concrete in the list of allowable building materials Items for further discussion Jordan River Buffer The Council adopted the Northpoint Small Area Plan in November 2023. A development buffer adjacent to the Jordan River was included in the plan with the following policy direction: Setback and Buffer Table: 300 ft buffer from the Jordan River in both the Light Industrial and Transitional areas. (Northpoint Small Area Plan, page 18) Implementation Items: Require a buffer of 300 feet between wetlands/uplands and any site development (e.g. buildings, parking, site features, and amenities) within the Northpoint Plan Area. The Great Salt Lake is a complex and delicate ecosystem, and impact on this habitat area by new development must be carefully mitigated. A critical part of this mitigation is ensuring an adequate buffer between development and the wetland/upland ecosystem. Wetlands include both jurisdictional and non-jurisdictional wetlands. The Plan identifies a 300-foot buffer from wetland areas. This should be implemented through either an update to the City’s existing Riparian Overlay Zone or a new Northpoint-specific development code. (Northpoint Small Area Plan, page 35) The Council has heard from a couple of stakeholders about the buffer’s impact on their property. During the first briefing, the Council directed staff to work with Planning and stakeholders on concerns expressed about the buffer. Cross E. Ranch owns a substantial amount of property adjacent to the Jordan River, technically within unincorporated Salt Lake County. However, they have expressed interest in annexing into the city and are part of the Northpoint Annexation, a separate petition that is currently being processed. Cross E. Ranch contacted city staff to express their concerns about the buffer requirements from the Jordan River proposed in the zoning amendments. The Northpoint Small Area Plan calls for a 300 ft buffer from the Jordan River. They’ve expressed support for a buffer for the fist 100 ft from the river, but are concerned with the additional 200’. They prefer to address the setback concerns via a development agreement that would allow them to cluster their development area together and then place the traditional open space, buffer, and landscaping near the river. They recommend the section about buffer yards be Page | 5 removed and replaced with a development agreement which includes buffers specifically negotiated by the city and property owner. See Attachment A for their recommended changes to the ordinance. Based on the feedback from stakeholders and direction from the Council, Planning has provided the following options for the Council to consider to address concerns about the buffer: 1. Reduce the buffer width to 150' total if the 150' is put into a conservation easement or has a public access easement. There would have to be a minimum public access easement width of at 50 feet. 2. Remove the transitional buffer (the area between 100’ and 300’) and require development agreements to negotiate the development of the land while still ensuring community and environmental benefit goals are met. 3. Modify the allowed uses in the buffer area to generate some financial benefit. Evaluate which uses could be compatible with the buffer while still providing income. Options might include agriculture, outdoor recreation, and necessary support buildings. The following information was provided for the October 1 work session briefing. During the September 3 briefing, the Council provided direction to staff on the following policy questions. 1. Max height 40 feet. Concern this wouldn't allow for the parapet/screening. o Response: Current city code (21A.36.020.C) already gives an allowance to do 5' parapet walls for screening mechanical equipment. o Council Direction: Yes to keeping as is. 2. Painted vs Tinted concrete. Is it possible to add “painted” in addition to tinted/textured as allowed types of concrete. o Response: Planning staff confirmed they would be ok with adding painted concrete. o Council Direction: Yes to adding “painted concrete” to the ordinance. 3. Blank Wall Standard – request to change from 12” to 8”. o Proposed Language: The maximum length of any blank wall uninterrupted by windows, doors, art, or architectural detailing along any ground level street facing facade is 25’. Changes in plane, texture, materials, scale of materials, patterns, art, or other architectural detailing are acceptable methods to comply with this standard. The architectural feature shall be either recessed a minimum of twelve inches (12") or projected a minimum of twelve inches (12"). o Response: 12" is the City standard that is used in all other districts no matter the building size. As of now, Planning staff would prefer to keeping it at 12" for consistency in applying the code for our building services and zoning reviewers, and because 12" will better break up the wall than 8". o Council Direction: Yes to keeping at 12 inches. 4. Exclude dock areas from maximum building height since they go below grade. Page | 6 o The Constituent is concerned that without this accommodation, the buildings will not match standard market buildings for interested tenants. o Response: If the Council is supportive, staff will work with the constituent and planning staff to develop recommendations for the Council to consider that would address this concern. o Council Direction: Yes to working with stakeholder on language. *See below for additional information. 5. Amend the wetland buffers in this ordinance to be consistent with language that applies to the Jordan River buffer: “Land within the Jordan River Transitional Buffer Area may count as natural open space.” o Response: Planning staff recommends that request is better addressed in the Riparian Corridor overlay amendments Public Utilities will bring forward. o Council Direction: Yes to NO change at this time. 6. Remove the buffer requirements from the Jordan River, and work with Cross E Ranch on alternatives that work for them via a potential development agreement. Cross E Ranch doesn’t want to create the open areas along the Jordan River in their area because the banks are very high and potentially dangerous. Cross E Ranch would prefer to cluster the traditional open space, buffer, and landscaping in their area o Response - Does the Council want staff to work with planning staff to review and come back with options for consideration. o Council Direction: Yes to further discussions with the constituent and come back to the Council with more information. *See below for additional information. Additional information Per Council direction Council and Planning staff reached out with stakeholders who requested changes to the ordinance for items 4 and 6 above. Those discussions are still ongoing; therefore, staff recommends the Council continue the public hearing to a future meeting so that if any changes to the ordinance are proposed, the public will have the opportunity to weigh in on them. Once staff has the potential new information ready for the Council to review, it will be brought back for discussion in a work session. The following information was provided for the September 3 work session briefing. ISSUE AT-A-GLANCE The Council will receive a briefing about a proposal that would amend various sections of the Salt Lake City Code creating a new section 21A.28.040 Northpoint Light Industrial (M-1A) Zoning District. This Council initiated petition would create a new zoning district that would help implement the vision and goals of the Northpoint Small Area plan adopted by the Council in November 2023. The new zoning district would provide an environment for light industrial, office, and research uses, while reducing the impact on adjacent agricultural and residential properties and native habitats. The Planning Commission reviewed the petition and forwarded a positive recommendation. In the motion, the Planning Commission requested that any land use involving hazardous waste or medical waste be prohibited. As noted in the Transmittal letter, Planning Staff reviewed the land use tables and confirmed that such uses are not proposed in the current draft ordinance. Page | 7 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Purpose Statement - The purpose of the Northpoint District is to protect sensitive lands and wildlife habitat surrounding the Great Salt Lake shore lands and the Jordan River while providing an environment for light industrial, office, and research uses that produce minimal impact on adjacent residential and agricultural properties. This district is appropriate within the Northpoint Small Area Plan boundaries. The district promotes a high standard of building design quality, open space preservation, and protection of sensitive lands and waterways Land Uses The following summary of uses is outlined on page 4 of the Planning Commission staff report. The land use table is significantly pared down from the M-1 Light Industrial Zoning District, excluding many uses that would be inappropriate for the area. Prohibited uses include kennels/pounds, raising of furbearing animals, bottling plants, check/payday loan businesses, community correctional facilities, commercial laundry facilities, outdoor recycling processing centers, rock and gravel storage and distribution, and vehicle auctions, package delivery service and distribution centers. Allowed Uses include primarily agriculture, light industrial, office, manufacturing uses, and some retail services. Development and Design Standards The following table outlines the Development and Design standards as well as Modification standards outlined on pages 4-7 of the Planning Commission staff report Summary of Development Standards Max lot size Maximum lot size is 10 acres, but larger lots may be approved if 20% of the area of the lot to be modified is preserved as natural open space on the development site. See the section below titled Allowed Modifications for more information on modifications to the standards. Max Height Buildings cannot exceed 40 feet in height. Building Size Limitations Maximum building footprint is 100,000 square feet, with potential for increased size if the property owner incorporates sustainability measures such as additional open space preservation, a green roof, or Page | 8 electric vehicle parking. See the section below titled Allowed Modifications for more information on modifications to the standards. Setbacks and Buffers Additional Setback: Jordan River Buffer Building setback requirements for the front and corner side yard is 20’, and the rear and interior side yards is 15’, with additional setbacks from residential structures and specific buffer requirements along the Jordan River. New development must be 65’ from principal residential structures on neighboring properties, and vehicle laneways used to access a development site must be setback 30’ from principal residential structures on neighboring properties. The Jordan River has a 300’ buffer from the annual highwater line. The first 100’ is a strict no-disturbance buffer and no construction or development activities will be permitted in this area. The remaining 200’ of the buffer area (the area between 100’ and 300’) is designated as the Transitional Buffer Area. This allows the buffer width to be reduced in some areas if a greater buffer is provided elsewhere. The modified buffer must maintain the total required buffer area, foot for foot, and must be contiguous with the No-Disturbance Buffer. Landscaping Requirements include water wise landscaping and prevention of noxious weeds to protect adjacent sensitive lands. Trees Trees are required along all property lines at a rate of 1 tree per 30 feet of property line, however, due to concerns with the unique drainage conditions in the area, trees can be spaced irregularly or clustered. When abutting a residential use, the amount of trees required is increased to 1 tree for every 15 feet of property line and must be placed every 15 feet for the length of the residential use and within 30 feet of the residential use. Design Standards Building Façade Length Limiting building facade length along 2200 West to 250 feet. Maximum Length of Blank Walls The maximum length of any blank wall uninterrupted by windows, doors, art, or architectural detailing along any ground level street facing facade is 25’. Page | 9 Building Materials Specifying building materials to ensure they are compatible with the natural environment. Brick, natural stone, wood, and tinted/textured concrete are appropriate materials. Stucco, including EIFS, is limited to architectural detailing surfaces and articulation. Exterior plastic vinyl siding or any reflective or polished materials are prohibited. Roofs Implementing roof specifications to mitigate the heat island effect. Light reflective roofing material with a minimum solar reflective index (SRI) of 82 is required for all roofs. Bird-safe Glass Treatments For any building elevation with more than 10% glass, a minimum of 90% of all glass shall be treated with applied films, coatings, tints, exterior screens, netting, fritting, frosted glass, or other means to reduce the number of birds that may collide with the glazing. Any treatment must create a grid pattern that is equal to or smaller than 2 inches wide by 4 inches tall. Mirrored or highly reflective glass is prohibited. Dark Sky Lighting Standards All lighting on the property, including lighting on the buildings, parking areas, and for signs shall be shielded to direct light down and away from the edges of the property to eliminate glare or light into adjacent properties and have cutoffs so that no light is emitted and/or reflected above the horizontal plane of the fixture. Fence Guidelines To minimize impacts on wildlife, fences shall have a visually open design with at least 50% of the fence open for the continuous length of the fence. Stormwater Retention Retention of the 80th percentile storm is required for all new and redevelopment projects greater than 1 acre. Detention shall be provided to ensure stormwater discharge does not exceed 0.2 cfs per acre, or less, to match pre-development flows, as identified in the area stormwater master plan. Modification of Standards Maximum Lot Area Approval for lots larger than 10 acres may be granted, provided the buildings and structures are grouped and a minimum of 20% of the area to be modified is designated as natural open spaced on the development site. Required setback yards and disconnected small areas of open space scattered throughout the site do not count toward the 20%, but any required wetland, canal, or other riparian buffers may be included. Maximum Building Façade Length The maximum building façade length of 250 feet along 2200 West may be increased if more natural open space is provided on the development site. The maximum building façade length may increase at a ratio of 20 feet per 5% of the total site dedicated as natural open space. The natural open space dedicated and permanently protected on site shall be no less than 7,000 SF, and to the greatest extent possible, shall be contiguous. Page | 10 Maximum Building Footprint Electric Vehicle Parking Sustainable Roof Designation of Natural Open Space Public Amenities: Stormwater All electric property The maximum footprint of a new building (100,000 SF) may be increased by complying with one or more of the options below. No more than an additional 100,000 square feet in building footprint will be permitted for an overall maximum building size of 200,000 SF. Provide a minimum of 10 electric vehicle parking spaces with a rate of 10,000 SF of additional footprint per 10 EV stalls. At least 30% of the roof area shall be devoted to either solar panels or a green roof, or a combination of the two in exchange for 40,000 SF of additional footprint. Additional open space designation on the development site at a rate of 1 square foot of building square footage for 1 square foot of open space preserved. Inclusion of a privately-owned public pathway, trail, or greenway connecting to or through natural open space areas with a rate of 10,000 SF per 1,000 SF of linear feet of trail, or 25,000 SF per trailhead. Providing full retention of stormwater with no release to the public storm drain system for 50,000 SF of additional footprint, or providing stormwater detention to the effect that no more than 0.1 cfs/acre is discharged from the 100- year 3-hour storm for 35,000 SF of additional footprint. The site is developed as an all-electric property for an additional 50,000 SF of additional footprint. Key Considerations Planning staff discusses in depth two key considerations on pages 7 -10 of the planning commission staff report. Below is a short summary of the discussion, Please see those pages for full analysis. 1. How the Proposal Helps Implement City Goals & Policies Identified in Adopted Plans Staff found the text amendment was consistent with the goals and policies outlined in Plan Salt Lake such as Economy, Natural Environment and Growth. Additionally, they found text amendment aligns with the goals and vision of the newly adopted Northpoint Small Area plan. Page | 11 1. Public Input and Code Changes Staff made many substantive changes to the draft ordinance based on feedback from the public. These include changes to the land use table, maximum lot size, vehicle laneways and location of trees. Potential Amendments After the Planning Commission forwarded their recommendation, some stakeholders reached out to Council Member Petro and staff to raise concerns and questions they have about the proposed ordinance. Staff was able to review and respond to some of the questions. For the others which do not yet have a response, staff is asking if the Council supports working with the constituent and planning staff to come up with potential changes that would address their concerns. Questions with Responses 1.Max height 40 feet. Concern this wouldn't allow for the parapet/screening. o Response: Current city code (21A.36.020.C) already gives an allowance to do 5' parapet walls for screening mechanical equipment. 2.Painted vs Tinted concrete. Is it possible to add painted in addition to tinted/textured concrete. o Response: Planning staff confirmed they would be ok with adding painted. 3.Blank Wall Standard – change to 8’ instead of 12’. o The maximum length of any blank wall uninterrupted by windows, doors, art, or architectural detailing along any ground level street facing facade is 25’. Changes in plane, texture, materials, scale of materials, patterns, art, or other architectural detailing are acceptable methods to comply with this standard. The architectural feature shall be either recessed a minimum of twelve inches (12") or projected a minimum of twelve inches (12"). o Response: 12" is the City standard that is used in all other districts no matter the building size. As of now, Planning staff would prefer to keeping it at 12" for consistency in applying the code for our building services and zoning reviewers, and because 12" will better break up the wall than 8". Questions for further discussion 1.Exclude dock areas from maximum building height since they go below grade. o The Constituent is concerned that without this accommodation, the buildings will not match standard market buildings for interested tenants. o Response: If the Council is supportive, staff will work with the constituent and planning staff to develop recommendations for the Council to consider that would address this concern. 2.Amend the wetland buffers in this ordinance to be consistent with language that applies to the Jordan River buffer: “Land within the Jordan River Transitional Buffer Area may count as natural open space.” o Response: Planning staff recommends that request is better addressed in the Riparian Corridor overlay amendments Public Utilities will bring forward. V4 1 Project Title: Northpoint Light Industrial (M-1A) Zoning District Petition No.: PLMPCM2024-00333 Version: 4 Date Prepared: November 19, 2024 Planning Commission Action: Recommended 6/12/2024 This proposed ordinance makes the following amendments to Title 21A (for summary purposes only): Creates a new section 21A.28.040 Northpoint Light Industrial (M-1A) Zoning District. Makes changes to associated code sections (parking, landscaping, etc.) to implement the proposed zone. Underlined text is new; text with strikethrough is proposed to be deleted. Modifications made after the Planning Commission recommendation are highlighted in yellow. All other text is existing with no proposed change. 1 1. Adopts a new Section 21A.28.040 to create the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning District 2 (M-1A) as follows: 3 4 21A.28.040 NORTHPOINT LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ZONING DISTRICT (M-1A) 5 6 A. Purpose Statement: The purpose of the Northpoint District is to protect sensitive lands 7 and wildlife habitat surrounding the Great Salt Lake shore lands and the Jordan River 8 while providing an environment for light industrial, office, and research uses that 9 produce minimal impact on adjacent residential and agricultural properties. This 10 district is appropriate within the Northpoint Small Area Plan boundaries and other 11 areas with similar attributes. The district promotes a high standard of building design 12 quality, open space preservation, and protection of sensitive lands and waterways. 13 B. Uses: Uses in the Northpoint District as specified in Section 21A.33.040, "Table Of 14 Permitted And Conditional Uses For Manufacturing Districts", of this title are 15 permitted subject to the general provisions set forth in Section 21A.28.010. 16 C. Maximum Lot Area: The maximum allowable lot size is 10 acres. Approval for lots 17 larger than 10 acres may be granted per Subsection 21A.28.040.I. 18 D. Minimum Yard and Setback Requirements: 19 1. Front Yard: 20' 20 2. Corner Side Yard: 20' APPROVED AS TO FORM Salt Lake City Attorney’s Office Date: ___________________________ By: ____________________________ Katherine D. Pasker, Senior City Attorney V4 2 21 3. Interior Side Yard: 15’ 22 4. Rear Yard: 15’ 23 5. Additional Setback: 24 a. Principal structures must be a minimum of 65’ from principal residential 25 structures on abutting properties. 26 b. Vehicle laneways used to access a development site must be a minimum of 27 30’ from principal residential structures on abutting properties. 28 6. Buffer Yards: 29 a. The Jordan River shall have a 300’ buffer from the annual high-water level 30 (AHWL), as defined in Section 21A.34.130, to preserve the natural habitat 31 and water quality of the Jordan River. Except as modified in this subsection, 32 the Jordan River buffer is subject to all rules and regulations in 21A.34.130: 33 Riparian Corridor Overlay District. 34 i. No-Disturbance Area: The first 100’ of the buffer from the AHWL, 35 nearest to the river shall be designated as a no-disturbance area. Permitted 36 uses in the no-disturbance area shall be subject to the uses in Area A in 37 Table 21A.34.130-3: USES ALLOWED ON UNDEVELOPED LAND. 38 ii. Structure Limit Area: The area between 100’ and 200’ from the AHWL 39 shall be designated as a structure limit area. Permitted uses in the structure 40 limit area shall be subject to the uses in Area B in Table 21A.34.120-2: 41 USES ALLOWED ON DEVELOPED LOTS. 42 iii. Buffer Transition Area: The area between 200’ and 300’ from the AHWL 43 shall be designated as the buffer transition area. Permitted uses in the 44 buffer transition area shall be subject to the uses in Area C in Table 45 21A.34.130-2: USES ALLOWED BY AREA ON DEVELOPED LOTS. 46 E. Maximum Height: No building shall exceed 40 feet in height. Building height along 47 loading dock areas may exceed the maximum height limit by 5 feet. The additional 48 height shall only be allowed below the average elevation of finished grade and the 49 area shall be excluded from the calculation of the average elevation of finished grade. V4 3 50 51 F. Building Size Limits: Building footprints are limited to a maximum of 100,000 52 square feet. The maximum footprint of a building may be increased per Subsection 53 21A.28.040.I. 54 G. Landscaping Requirements: The purpose of the landscaping in the Northpoint area is 55 to provide appropriate native landscaping that prevents noxious weeds and to provide 56 landscaping that will not negatively impact the adjacent sensitive lands. 57 1. All landscaping shall consist of native plants as identified in the “Salt Lake City 58 Plant List and Hydrozone Schedule” on file with the planning division. 59 2. All required front, corner side, side, and rear yards shall be maintained as 60 landscape yards in conformance with the requirements of Section 21A.48.060.C. 61 3. Trees are required along all property lines in the following yards: 62 a. Front and Corner Side Yards: One tree for every 30 linear feet of lot frontage. 63 Trees may be spaced irregularly or clustered to form a natural grouping. 64 b. Interior Side and Rear Yards: One tree is required for every 30 linear feet of 65 yard length. Trees may be spaced irregularly or clustered to form a natural 66 grouping. 67 c. Interior Side and Rear Yards When Abutting a Residential Use: One tree is 68 required for every 15 linear feet of the property line abutting the residential V4 4 69 use. The zoning administrator may approve alternate planting locations for 70 required trees to allow for clustering under the following conditions: 71 i. No trees may be removed from any areas abutting or within 30 feet of a 72 primary residential use; and 73 ii. The total number of required trees may not be reduced. 74 4. Noxious weed species as identified by the Utah Department of Agriculture and 75 Food (or its successor) in the State of Utah Noxious Weed List (or its successor) 76 shall be removed from landscaped areas and areas disturbed by construction 77 activity. Noxious weeds shall be controlled for a period of two years and methods 78 of control shall be identified on the landscape plan. 79 5. All other requirements in Chapter 21A.48 apply. This section shall take 80 precedence in the case of a conflict with Chapter 21A.48. 81 H. Design Standards: 82 1. Maximum Building Façade Length along 2200 West: The maximum building 83 façade length along 2200 West is limited to 250 feet. The maximum building 84 façade length may be increased per Subsection 21A.28.040.I. 85 2. Blank Walls: The maximum length of any blank wall uninterrupted by windows, 86 doors, art, or architectural detailing along any ground level street facing facade is 87 25’. Changes in plane, texture, materials, scale of materials, patterns, art, or other 88 architectural detailing are acceptable methods to comply with this standard. The 89 architectural feature shall be either recessed a minimum of twelve inches (12") or 90 projected a minimum of twelve inches (12"). 91 3. Building Materials: To mitigate the contrast of the built and natural environment, 92 the following building materials are permitted: brick, natural stone, wood, and 93 painted, tinted, or textured concrete. Stucco, including EIFS, is limited to 94 architectural detailing surfaces and articulation. Exterior plastic vinyl siding or 95 any reflective or polished materials are prohibited. Other materials not 96 specifically mentioned may be permitted, on a case-by-case basis, with approval 97 from the planning director, provided they meet the intent to mitigate the contrast 98 and impact of the materials on the natural environment. Windows and doors are 99 not subject to the building material restrictions. 100 4. Roofs: Light reflective roofing material with a minimum solar reflective index 101 (SRI) of 82 shall be used for all roofs. 102 5. Glass: For any building elevation with more than 10% glass, a minimum of 90% 103 of all glass shall be treated with applied films, coatings, tints, exterior screens, 104 netting, fritting, frosted glass, or other means to reduce the number of birds that 105 may collide with the glazing. Any treatment must create a grid pattern that is V4 5 106 equal to or smaller than 2 inches wide by 4 inches tall. Mirrored or highly 107 reflective glass is prohibited. 108 6. Lighting: 109 b. All lighting, including lighting on buildings, parking areas, and signs shall be 110 shielded to direct light down and away from the edges of the property to 111 eliminate glare or light encroaching onto adjacent properties and have cutoffs 112 so that no light is emitted and/or reflected above the horizontal plane of the 113 fixture. When a light manufacturer provides a BUG rating, the uplight rating 114 (U) shall equal zero (0). 115 c. Uplighting and event searchlights are prohibited. 116 d. Total site illumination shall not exceed 100,000 lumens per net acre. 117 e. Outdoor lighting shall be a color temperature of 3,000 Kelvin or less. 118 7. Fencing: To minimize impacts on wildlife, fences shall have a visually open 119 design with at least 50% of the fence open for the continuous length of the fence. 120 Fencing that is less than 50% open is permitted when solid screening is otherwise 121 required by this title. 122 b. Prohibited Decorative Features: 123 i. Pointed extensions at the top of fences are prohibited to prevent injury to 124 wildlife attempting to traverse the fence. 125 ii. Woven wire fencing and incorporating loose wires that may entangle 126 animals is prohibited to avoid harm to wildlife. 127 iii. Hollow fence posts that are open at the top, where birds or other small 128 animals may become entrapped, are prohibited. All fence posts must be 129 solid or have caps securely attached. 130 8. Stormwater Management: 131 a. This subsection shall be enforced by the Salt Lake City Public Utilities 132 Department. 133 b. Drainage: Site stormwater shall be collected on site and routed to the public 134 storm drain system or gutter. Stormwater may not discharge across property 135 lines or across public sidewalks without legal authorization to do so. A 136 technical drainage study is required for the development of all lots detailing 137 compliance with the requirements of this section to be reviewed with any site 138 development or building permit. 139 c. Stormwater Quality: Stormwater treatment is required prior to discharge to the 140 public storm drain. Sites shall utilize stormwater best management practices 141 (BMP's) to remove solids, oils, and other pollutants. Green infrastructure V4 6 142 should be used whenever possible. Options for green infrastructure and low 143 impact development include bioretention systems, harvest/reuse, permeable 144 surfaces, green roofs, and site design. 145 d. Retention: Retention of the 80th percentile storm is required for all new and 146 redevelopment projects greater than 1 acre. 147 e. Detention: Detention shall be provided to ensure stormwater discharge does 148 not exceed 0.2 cfs per acre, or less, to match pre-development flows, as 149 identified in the area stormwater master plan. Detention systems shall be 150 designed using the 100-year 3-hour storm using the Farmer-Fletcher rainfall 151 distribution. 152 I. Modifications of Standards: Modifications to the standards of this section are allowed 153 as identified in this subsection: 154 1. Applicability. All development sites within the M-1A (Northpoint Light 155 Industrial) zoning district. Development site includes all land under the same 156 ownership that is proposed to be developed as one development area. 157 Development sites can include land that contains multiple parcels or lots. 158 2. Restrictive Covenants: Development limitations elected in connection with 159 modifying a development standard as set forth in this subsection shall be 160 documented by a restrictive covenant in favor of the city recorded on the title of 161 the development site that describes the area that is being voluntarily restricted to 162 modify a zoning standard. 163 3. Land used to allow one modification may not be counted toward allowing another 164 modification. 165 4. Allowed modifications: 166 a. Maximum Lot Area: Approval for lots larger than 10 acres may be granted, 167 provided the buildings and structures are grouped and comply with the 168 following standards: 169 i. The cluster development shall be a minimum of 10 acres. 170 ii. A minimum separation of 15 feet shall be provided between all principal 171 buildings. 172 iii. A minimum of 20% of the area of the lot to be modified is designated as 173 natural open space on the development site, as defined in Section 174 21A.62.040. Natural open space shall, to the greatest extent possible, be 175 contiguous. Fragmented and disconnected small areas scattered 176 throughout the development site including required building separations, 177 and required setback yards, shall not count toward the 20%. Any V4 7 178 required wetland, canal, or riparian buffers may be counted toward the 20%, 179 b. Maximum Building Façade Length: The maximum building façade length 180 along 2200 West may be increased if natural open space in excess of any 181 required buffer is provided on the development site. The maximum building 182 façade length may increase by 20 feet if 5% of the total non-buffer area of the 183 site is dedicated as natural open space, as defined in Section 21A.62.040, and 184 may increase by an additional 20 feet for every additional 5%. The natural 185 open space dedicated and permanently protected on site shall be no less than 186 7,000 SF and shall, to the greatest extent possible, be contiguous. Fragmented 187 and disconnected small areas scattered throughout the development site, and 188 required setback yards, shall not be counted. 189 c. Maximum Building Footprint Size: The maximum footprint of a building may 190 be increased by complying with one or more of the options below. No more 191 than an additional 100,000 square feet in building footprint will be permitted: Option Amount of additional building square footage 1.Electric Vehicle Parking: Provide a minimum of 10 electric vehicle parking spaces on the development site. 1 ADA electric vehicle stall shall be provided for every 25 electric vehicle stalls Electric vehicle parking spaces shall count toward the minimum required number of parking spaces. The electric vehicle parking space shall be: a. Located in the same lot as the principal use; b. Signed in a clear and conspicuous manner, such as special pavement marking or signage, indicating exclusive availability to electric vehicles; and c. Outfitted with a standard electric vehicle charging station. 10,000 SF per 10 parking stalls 2.At least 30% of the roof area of the building seeking an increase in 40,000 SF V4 8 footprint shall be devoted to either solar panels or a vegetated green roof, or a combination of the two. 3.Designation of natural open space within the development site, as defined in Section 21A.62.040. Natural open space shall, to the greatest extent possible, be contiguous. Fragmented and disconnected small areas scattered throughout the development, and required setback yards, shall not count towards the designated open space. Jordan River Transitional Buffer Area and Wetland Buffers: Land within the Transitional Buffer Area or any required wetland buffers may count as natural open space. The square footage increase shall be for a building outside of the required buffer area on the same development site and shall include item #4 below (Inclusion of a privately-owned public pathway, trail, or greenway connecting to or through natural open space areas). 1 SF per 1 SF of natural open space 4.Inclusion of a privately-owned public pathway, trail, or greenway connecting to or through natural open space areas. 10,000 SF per 1,000 linear feet of trail 25,000 SF per trailhead. The trailhead must include amenities such as directional signage, benches, etc. 5.Providing full retention of site stormwater with no release to the public storm drain system and providing enhanced stormwater quality practices. 50,000 SF V4 9 System design to be approved by the Salt Lake City Public Utilities Department. 5.Providing detention to the effect that no more than 0.1 cfs/acre is discharged for the 100-year 3-hour storm with the Farmer Fletcher Rainfall Distribution and providing enhanced stormwater quality practices. System design to be approved by the Salt Lake City Public Utilities Department. 35,000 SF 7.The site is developed as an all- electric property. All-electric property means a property that contains no permanently installed equipment or appliances that utilize combustion, plumbing for fuel gas or fuel oil or fuel gas utility connection, installed within the building(s) or site, except for emergency power systems and standby power systems. 50,000 SF 194 195 1. Amends Section 21A.33.040 Table of Permitted and Conditional Uses for Manufacturing 196 Districts to add the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning District (M-1A) to the table, with no 197 other revisions, as follows: 198 199 21A.33.040: TABLE OF PERMITTED AND CONDITIONAL USES FOR 200 MANUFACTURING DISTRICTS: 201 Permitted And Conditional Uses By District Use M-1 M-2 M-1A Accessory use, except those that are otherwise specifically regulated elsewhere in this title P Agricultural use P V4 10 Alcohol: Bar establishment C6,10 Brewpub C6,10 Distillery C19 Tavern C6,10 Winery C19 Ambulance services (indoor and/or outdoor)P Animal: Cremation service P Pet cemetery P2 Stockyard C12 Veterinary office P Antenna, communication tower P Antenna, communication tower, exceeding the maximum building height C Artisan food production P19 Bakery, commercial P19 Bio-medical facility P18,19 Blacksmith shop P19 Brewery P19 Building materials distribution P Bus line station/terminal P Bus line yard and repair facility P12 Cannabis production establishment P V4 11 Commercial food preparation P19 Community garden P Contractor's yard/office C Crematorium C Data center P19,21 Daycare center, adult P Daycare center, child P Dwelling, living quarters for caretaker or security guard, limited to uses on lots 1 acre in size or larger and is accessory to a principal use allowed by the zoning district P Equipment, heavy (rental, sales, service)P Equipment rental (indoor and/or outdoor)P Financial institution with or without drive-through facility P Food processing P19 Gas station C Government facility P Government facility requiring special design features for security purposes P Grain elevator C12 Greenhouse P Home occupation P15 Hotel/motel P Impound lot P12 Industrial assembly P19 Laboratory, medical related P19 V4 13 Light manufacturing P19 Limousine service P Mobile business P Municipal services uses including City utility uses and police and fire stations P Office P Office, publishing company P Open space P Park P Parking: Commercial P Off site P Park and ride lot shared with existing use P Photo finishing lab P19 Printing plant C19 Radio, television station P Recreation (indoor)P Recreation (outdoor)P Recycling: Collection station P Processing center (indoor)C19 Research and development facility P19 Restaurant with or without drive-through facilities P11 Retail goods establishment with or without drive- through facility P11 V4 14 Retail service establishment: Electronic repair shop P Furniture repair shop P Upholstery shop P School: Professional and vocational (with outdoor activities)P Professional and vocational (without outdoor activities)P Seminary and religious institute P Seasonal farm stand P Small brewery P19 Solar array P17,19 Storage and display (outdoor)P Storage, public (outdoor)P Storage, self P Store, convenience P Studio, motion picture P Taxicab facility P Technology facility P19 Tire distribution retail/wholesale P Urban farm P Utility: Building or structure P Solid waste transfer station C12 V4 15 Transmission wire, line, pipe or pole P1 Automobile and truck repair P Automobile and truck sales and rental (including large truck) P Automobile part sales P Automobile salvage and recycling (indoor)P19 Recreational vehicle (RV) sales and service C Truck repair (large)P Vending cart, private property P Warehouse P19 Welding shop P19 Wholesale distribution P19 Woodworking mill P19 207 Qualifying provisions: 208 1. See Subsection 21A.02.050.B of this title for utility regulations. 209 2. Subject to Salt Lake Valley Health Department approval. 210 3. Electric generating facilities shall be located within 2,640 feet of an existing 138 kV or 211 larger electric power transmission line. 212 4. No railroad freight terminal facility shall be located within 1 mile of a Residential 213 Zoning District. 214 5. Pursuant to the requirements set forth in Section 21A.36.140 of this title. 215 1. If a place of worship is proposed to be located within 600 feet of a tavern, bar 216 establishment, or brewpub, the place of worship must submit a written waiver of 217 spacing requirement as a condition of approval. 218 2. Building additions on lots less than 20,000 square feet for office uses may not exceed 219 50 percent of the building's footprint. Building additions greater than 50 percent of the 220 building's footprint or new office building construction are subject to a design review. V4 16 221 3. A community correctional facility is considered an institutional use and any such 222 facility located within the AFPP Airport Flight Path Protection Overlay District is 223 subject to the land use and sound attenuation standards for institutional uses of the 224 applicable Airport Influence Zone within Section 21A.34.040 of this title. 225 4. No check cashing/payday loan business shall be located closer than 1/2 mile of other 226 check cashing/payday loan businesses. 227 5. Subject to conformance with the provisions in Section 21A.36.300, "Alcohol Related 228 Establishments", of this title. 229 6. Subject to conformance to the provisions in Section 21A.40.060 of this title for drive- 230 through use regulations. 231 7. Prohibited within 1,000 feet of a Single- or Two-Family Zoning District. 232 8. Prohibited within the Eco-Industrial Buffer Area of the Northwest Quadrant Overlay 233 District. 234 9. Prohibited within the Development Area of the Northwest Quadrant Overlay District. 235 10. Allowed only within legal conforming single-family, duplex, and multi-family 236 dwellings and subject to Section 21A.36.030 of this title. 237 11.Prohibited within 1/2 mile of any Residential Zoning District boundary and subject to 238 Section 21A.36.110 of this title. 239 12.Prior to issuance of a building permit in the M-1A District, Development Area and the 240 Eco-Industrial Buffer Area of the Northwest Quadrant Overlay, consultation with the 241 Utah Division of Wildlife Resources is required to obtain recommendations on siting 242 and equipment types for all solar arrays on a particular property to mitigate impacts to 243 wildlife. 244 13. Prohibited within 1/2 mile of a residential use if the facility produces hazardous or 245 radioactive waste as defined by the Utah Department of Environmental Quality 246 administrative rules. 247 14. Consult the water use and/or consumption limitations of Subsection 21A.33.010.D.1. 248 15. Prohibited in the IP Inland Port Overlay District. See Subsection 21A.34.150.B.2.f. 249 16. Prohibited on the North Temple Landfill site as identified in the Northwest Quadrant 250 Master Plan. 251 17.Data centers may be permitted provided they utilize a closed-loop cooling system. 252 253 2. Amends Subsection 21A.36.010.B.2, as follows: 254 V4 17 255 1. Lots in the RP, BP, M-1, M-2, M-1A, AG, AG-2, AG-5, AG-20, A, OS, NOS, and EI 256 Districts may have multiple buildings on a single lot regardless of street frontage and 257 subject to meeting all other zoning regulations. 258 259 4. Amends Subsection 21A.36.010.E, as follows: 260 261 E. Flag Lots Iin Nonresidential Districts: In the CG, BP, RP, M-1, and M-2, and M-1A 262 Districts, flag lots shall be permitted, subject to subdivision regulations; provided, that: 263 1. As part of new subdivisions or through the planned development process only when 264 the flag lot is proposed at the rear of an existing parcel; 265 2. The flag lot access strip shall have a minimum of twenty four feet (24') of frontage on 266 a public street; and 267 3. The City subdivision review process determines the following: that 268 a. Iit is not desirable or necessary to extend a public street to access the parcel., and 269 b. The existing lot and site layout is not conducive to private street development. 270 271 5. Amends the table in Subsection 21A.37.060.C to add the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning 272 District (M-1A) to the table as follows: 273 C. Manufacturing Districts: DistrictStandard (Code Section) M-1 M-2 M-1A Ground floor use (%) (21A.37.050A1) Ground floor use + visual interest (%) (21A.37.050A2) Building materials: ground floor (%) (21A.37.050B1) Building materials: upper floors (%) (21A.37.050B2) Glass: ground floor (%) (21A.37.050C1) Glass: upper floors (%) (21A.37.050C2) Building entrances (feet) (21A.37.050D) Blank wall: maximum length (feet) (21A.37.050E) Street facing facade: maximum length (feet) (21A.37.050F) V4 18 Upper floor step back (feet) (21A.37.050G) Lighting: exterior (21A.37.050H)X X X Lighting: parking lot (21A.37.050I)X X X Screening of mechanical equipment (21A.37.050J) Screening of service areas (21A.37.050K) Ground floor residential entrances (21A.37.050L) Parking garages or structures (21A.37.050M) 275 276 6. Amends Table 21A.40.090.E to add the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning District (M- 277 1A) to the table under “Commercial/manufacturing districts” with no other revisions to the 278 table, as follows: V4 18 279 280 TABLE 21A.40.090E 281 WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES Monopole With Antennas And Antenna Support Structure Less Than 2' Wide 3 Monopole With Antennas And Antenna Support Structure Greater Than 2' Wide 3 Wall Mount 3 Roof Mount 3 District Height Limit But Not To Exceed 60' (Whichever Is Less) 60' Or Exceeding The Maximum Height Limit Of The Zone District Height Limit But Not To Exceed 60' (Whichever Is Less) 60' Or Exceeding The Maximum Height Limit Of The Zone Lattice Tower Commercial/manufa cturing districts: M-1A P P P C P C C 282 V4 19 283 284 7. Amends Subsection 21A.44.040.A.4 as follows: 285 4. The maximum parking limit does not apply to properties in the M-1, M-2, M-1A, BP, or 286 Airport zoning districts that are located west of the centerline of Redwood Road. 287 288 8. Amends Table 21A.44.060-A to add the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning District (M- 289 1A) to the table under “GENERAL CONTEXT” and “Commercial and Manufacturing (CC, CS, 290 CG, M-1, M-2, SNB)” with no other revisions to the table, as follows: TABLE 21A.44.060-A: PARKING LOCATION AND SETBACK REQUIREMENTS: N = parking prohibited between lot line and front line of the principal building Zoning District Front Lot Line Corner Side Lot Line Interior Side Lot Line Rear Lot Line GENERAL CONTEXT Commercial and Manufacturing (CC, CS, CG, M-1, M-2, SNB) CC 0 ft.; or 7 ft. when abutting any residential district CS 15 ft. CG N. See also Subsection 21A.26.070 .I M-1 0 ft.; or 15 ft. when abutting any residential district M-2 M-1A 15 ft. 0 ft.; or 50 ft. when abutting any residential district 291 292 9. Amends Table 21A.44.060-C as follows: TABLE 21A.44.060-C: MINIMUM AND MAXIMUM DRIVE APPROACH WIDTH: Zoning District Minimum Drive Approach Width (in front and corner side yard) Maximum Drive Approach Width* (in front and corner side yard) SR-1, SR-2 and SR-3 8 ft.22 ft. MH 8 ft.16 ft. Other Residential Zoning Districts 8 ft.24 ft. M-1 and M-2 Manufacturing Districts 12 ft. single lane and 24 ft. for two- way 30 ft. V4 20 Other Non-Residential Zoning Districts 12 ft. single lane and 24 ft. for two- way 30 ft. * All drive approaches serving residential uses shall be a minimum eight feet (8’) wide. 294 295 10. Amends Subsection 21A.44.090.A.4.a as follows: 296 a. The property is located in a CG, M-1, M-2, M-1A, or EI zoning district. 297 298 11. Amends Section 21A.44.100.B.2 as follows: 299 2. Except in the M-1, M-2, M-1A, CG, and D districts, no cleaning or maintenance of 300 loading areas using motorized equipment may be performed between ten o'clock (10:00) 301 P.M. and seven o'clock (7:00) A.M. each day, except for snow removal. 302 303 12. Amends the preamble to Section 21A.46.055 as follows: 304 Pursuant to the terms and conditions set forth in this section, attended portable signs shall be 305 allowed on public property in Residential/Business (RB), Residential/Mixed Use (R-MU), 306 Neighborhood Commercial (CN), Community Business (CB), Community Shopping (CS), 307 Corridor Commercial (CC), Sugar House Business (CSHBD), General Commercial (CG), 308 Light Manufacturing (M-1), Heavy Manufacturing (M-2), Northpoint Light Manufacturing 309 (M-1A), Central Business (D-1), Downtown Support (D-2), Downtown 310 Warehouse/Residential (D-3), Downtown Secondary Central Business (D-4), Gateway- 311 Mixed Use (G-MU) and Business Park (BP) Zoning Districts. 312 313 13. Amends Section 21A.46.100 as follows: 314 21A.46.100: SIGN REGULATIONS FOR MANUFACTURING DISTRICTS: 315 The following regulations shall apply to signs permitted in the manufacturing districts. Any 316 sign not expressly permitted by these district regulations is prohibited. 317 A. Sign Regulations Ffor Tthe M-1 And M-2 Manufacturing Districts: 318 1. Purpose: Sign regulations for the M-1 and M-2 manufacturing districts are 319 intended to provide for appropriate identification of industrial and manufacturing 320 uses. Signage should enhance the aesthetics of the districts, rather than clutter the 321 area. Supportive commercial signage should be in scale with industrial signage. 322 2. Applicability: Regulations in subsection A3 of this section shall apply to all lots 323 within the M-1, and M-2, and M-1A districts. 324 3. Sign Type, Size Aand Height Standards: V4 21 325 326 STANDARDS FOR THE M-1 AND M-2 MANUFACTURING DISTRICTS 327 [Note to codifier: aside from the title, there are no changes to the table or any of the notes 328 thereto.] 329 4. Supplementalry Regulations: 330 a. Lot Frontage Requirements: A minimum lot frontage of one hundred feet 331 (100’) shall be required for pole signs or monument signs. 332 333 14. Amends Subsection 21A.48.060.D as follows: 334 D. Landscape Buffer Standards: District When Abutting 1 Required Landscape / Freeway Buffer Widths All districts (except Single- and Two- Family, Foothill, Special Development Pattern, SNB, FB-UN1, and those districts listed below that require a greater buffer width) Single- and Two- Family, Foothill, & Special Development 10’ All districts Freeway 2 20’ All other non-residential districts (except SNB, FB- UN1, and those districts listed below that require a greater buffer width) RMF-30, RMF-35, RMF-45, & RMF-75 10’ M-1 & M-1A Any district that allows residential uses, AG districts, & OS 15’ Any district that allows residential uses 50’ M-2 AG districts & OS 30’ BP & RP All residential districts (in Chapter 21A.24)30’ EI All districts 30’ MH All districts 20’ 1. Or when required elsewhere by this title. V4 22 2. The zoning administrator may approve a reduced freeway buffer if there’s an existing sound wall or required off-street parking cannot be met. If such a reduction is necessary, the buffer may not be less than 10’ in width. Landscape Buffer Standards 1 tree for every 30 linear feet of landscape buffer. 1 shrub every 3 feet, with a mature height of no less than 4’, along the entire length of the buffer. A 6-foot solid fence along the length of the required landscape buffer unless modified by the zoning administrator to better meet the fence height provisions in Section 21A.40.120. Turf is limited to active recreation areas. Freeway Landscape Buffer Standards (buffer standards for those properties abutting a freeway) 1 tree for every 15 linear feet of required freeway landscape buffer. Trees shall be staggered along the length of the buffer. 100% coverage required, may include adaptive or native grasses, wildflower, and shrubs. Turf is prohibited. 336 337 338 15. Amends Table 21A.55.060 to add the Northpoint Light Industrial Zoning District (M-1A) 339 to the table under “Manufacturing districts” with no other revisions to the table, as follows: 340 TABLE 21A.55.060 341 PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS District Minimum Planned Development Size Manufacturing districts: M-1 Light Manufacturing District No minimum required M-2 Heavy Manufacturing District No minimum required M-1A Northpoint Light Manufacturing District No minimum required 342 CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 304 P.O. BOX 145476, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84114-5476 SLCCOUNCIL.COM TEL 801-535-7600 FAX 801-535-7651 COUNCIL STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY TO:City Council Members FROM:Brian Fullmer Policy Analyst DATE:December 3, 2024 RE: Sugar House Master Plan, Zoning Map, and Text Amendment at 1095 East 2100 South (Former Wells Fargo Bank) PLNPCM2023-00960/00961 The Council will be briefed about a request to create a new zoning district, the MU-15 (Form-Based Mixed- Use 15 Subdistrict) and the applicant’s request that would apply the new zone to the property at 1095 East 2100 South. The requested new zone would increase the property’s development potential and allow a maximum height of 155 feet. A former Wells Fargo bank branch building is currently located on the approximately 1.2-acre parcel which, under the proposal, would be redeveloped into a mixed-use residential project. Alternatively, Planning staff has pointed out that the property could be redeveloped under its current zoning which would allow a mixed-use building up to 105 feet tall (approximately 9-10 stories). The redevelopment could also occur under the MU-11 zoning, which is currently being developed by the Administration, and would allow buildings up to 125 feet tall plus additional height with certain conditions. These are summarized in the table below. Zoning District Maximum Building Height CSHBD1 (Current)105 feet MU-11 (Administration’s proposal currently being processed in separate petition) 125 feet (design review above 85 feet) MU-15 (Applicant’s proposal)155 feet (design review above 75 feet) Item Schedule: Briefing: December 3, 2024 Set Date: December 10, 2024 Public Hearing: January 7, 2025 Potential Action: TBD Page | 2 In addition to the proposed rezone, the applicant proposes amending the 2005 Sugar House Community Master Plan to enable higher density development in the Sugar House Business District than the two- to four-story height limits discussed in the “High-Intensity Mixed Use” section of the Plan. Maximum residential density called for in the Plan is 20-50 dwelling units per acre. The applicant is proposing buildings up to 15 stories and density between 50-270 dwelling units per acre. Planning staff noted the Sugar House Community Master Plan generally supports increased residential density within the Sugar House Business District and stated, “The most intense development in this community should be located within the Town Center Scale subdistrict where the project site is located.” It is important to note that this is a private petition and not part of the City-initiated commercial and mixed-use zoning district consolidation. The petitioner’s proposed MU-15 zone would add a seventh mixed-use zoning district to the six MU zoning districts the Administration is recommending. A building constructed under the proposed MU-11 zoning could add three additional stories and get to the applicant’s proposed 155 feet of height if they utilize the affordable housing incentives as a public benefit. They would still have the option to construct with mass timber. Planning staff also noted “The MU-15 zone (Form Based Mixed-Use 15 Subdistrict) is based on the proposed MU zones that are part of the zoning consolidation project, but because that proposal is still in the draft form, the MU-15 proposal has some differences in content and structure that would have to be reconciled based on whichever district is adopted first.” According to Planning staff, the proposals generally met standards for approval and recommended the Planning Commission forward a positive recommendation to the Council. The Commission reviewed the proposals at its September 11, 2024 meeting and held a public hearing at which 17 people spoke or had their comments read. All but one commenter was opposed to the proposal. Commenters expressed concerns about the proposed building’s height being inappropriate for the location, its proximity to single-family residences to the north without a sufficient transition between, increased density and traffic, parking issues, needed infrastructure upgrades, and construction fatigue. The Commission voted unanimously to forward a negative recommendation to the City Council. Goal of the briefing: Review the proposed master plan and zoning map amendments, determine if the Council supports moving forward with the proposal. POLICY QUESTIONS 1. The Council may want to discuss whether to add this MU-15 zoning district to those proposed by the Administration’s zoning consolidation petition. 2. The Council may want to discuss whether the MU-11 zoning district is the right option for this development. 3. The Council may want to discuss utilizing affordable housing incentives with the applicant to get their desired height. 4. The Council may want to discuss community benefits with the applicant that have potential to achieve the proposed building’s height. 5. The Council may want to ask about compatibility issues with the adjacent single-family and lower impact commercial properties. 6.The applicant submitted a proposed modification to the text amendment that would add sustainability standards that, if met, would allow additional height for the building. Meeting the Page | 3 sustainability standards would provide up to three additional stories in the MU-11 zoning district and achieve the applicant’s desired building height. See further discussion about this proposed addition on page 4 below. The Council want to discuss the applicant’s proposed sustainable building incentives with Planning staff and ask for their review and recommendation on the proposed language. Staff note: legally it would not be appropriate for the applicant to suggest changes to a different petition, but if the Council is interested in this path, that is an option for them to request. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Because zoning of a property can outlast the life of a building, any rezoning application should be considered on the merits of changing the zoning of that property, not simply based on a potential project. In the area zoning map below, CSHBD1 properties (proposed to be zoned MU-11 under the Administration’s proposal) are shaded pink, and CSHBD2 (proposed to be zoned MU-6 under the Administration’s proposal) are pink with white hash marks. R-1/5,000 and R-1/7,000 single-family zoned properties are respectively shaded tan and yellow. Area zoning map with the subject property outlined in blue. The subject petitions were submitted in November 2023, prior to the enactment of the Community Benefit Policy. The applicant submitted a draft community benefit checklist which was reviewed by Planning staff Page | 5 who believe it does not meet the new policy requirements. Even though this petition is not subject to the City's formal Community Benefit Policy, the City Council is free to consider community benefits as part of any legislative decision on this rezone petition. The proposed MU-15 zone would permit residential units on 1100 East/Highland Drive, which Planning staff opposes. Current CSHBD1 zoning and the Administration’s proposed MU-11 zoning district call for ground floor retail uses on 1100 East and 2100 South frontages to support the Sugar House Business District. Original Proposal The applicant initially proposed creating a new CSHBD-SUS (Sustainability Zone) that would allow buildings up to 305 feet. Portions of the proposal were not supported by City staff, and the developer changed their proposal and submitted the text amendment under the MU-15 name which the Council is currently reviewing. Supplemental Information from the Applicant In addition to building heights discussed above, the MU-15 district as proposed by the petitioner would require the following: Sustainable construction methods and a Whole Building, Life Cycle Assessment (WBLCA) o To achieve additional height, projects must cut upfront embodied carbon by at least 60%. o A preliminary WBLCA is required when applying for a building permit, and a final WBLCA indicating at least 60% reduction in embodied carbon would be required before a certificate of occupancy is issued. Planning noted the City does not have in-house reviewers for these assessments, so a third-party review at the applicant’s expense would be required. The applicant did not provide a remediation plan if the building failed its final WBLCA. Planning staff recommended an enforcement policy for non-compliance and suggested including language in City code stating that a certificate of occupancy may not be issued until the owner takes necessary actions to receive the final assessment verifying the embodied carbon reduction. Mass timber building construction. MU-15 zoning initially applies to property at 1095 East 2100 South but may be applied elsewhere in the future. After the Planning Commission forwarded their recommendation, the applicant submitted additional changes for the Council to consider. These include sustainable building incentives in the code that if met, would allow the applicant to increase their building height. Under the applicant’s sustainable building incentives proposal, additional height would be allowed for buildings that meet green emission standards, have a least a LEED Gold rating, and use building technologies that allow capture of embodied carbon. Planning staff is aware of this additional language but has not officially reviewed or provided a recommendation. The Council may wish to ask Planning staff to review the language and make a formal recommendation to the Council. Public Input The Planning Division received significant public input on the proposal, the vast majority of which is in opposition. The Sugar House Community Council submitted letters in opposition to the original CSHBD- Page | 6 SUS, and current MU-15 proposal. Email comments can be found on pages 154-303 of the Planning Commission staff report. It is worth noting that many of these comments in the staff report were referencing the initial proposed CSHBD-SUS zoning district. Additional comments are found on pages 81-113 of the transmittal and were received after the MU-15 zoning district proposal was submitted on July 11, 2024. KEY CONSIDERATIONS Planning staff identified three key considerations related to the proposal which are found on pages 14-22 of the Planning Commission staff report and summarized below. For the complete analysis, please see the staff report. Consideration 1 – How the Proposal Helps Implement City Goals & Policies Identified in Adopted Plans Planning staff reviewed how the proposal aligns with Plan Salt Lake (2015), Housing SLC (2023-2027), Thriving in Place (2023), and the Sugar House Community Master Plan (2001). They found the proposal generally supports the plans and stated: “Redeveloping this underutilized parcel, in close proximity to transit options and neighborhood amenities, aligns with overall city support for higher density development. Amending the general plan would ensure newer Sugar House developments comply with the Sugar House Plan and support both the city-initiated zoning consolidation and the privately initiated MU-15 zoning text amendment.” Consideration 2 – Review of MU-15 Zoning District & its Compatibility with Adjacent Properties Under current zoning, and in the Administration’s proposal, there are properties with less intense development potential to help transition between the subject property and single-family residential properties to the north and west, though that transition buffer would be small for some nearby single- family homes. Planning staff found that the design standards proposed for both the MU-11 and MU-15 zones were similar, which would help ensure high quality design that is compatible with the scale and character of the existing neighborhood. Consideration 3 – Departmental Reviews Public Utilities noted concerns with the following: Utility Impact-water, sewer, and storm drain systems at the property and downstream could be significantly impacted. Detailed development plans would be required to assess increased demand on these systems. Increased Costs-higher density development could increase construction costs due to needed upgrades to offsite utilities and may affect areas outside the property. Sewer Capacity-Upgrades to the area’s sewer system are planned but won’t accommodate capacity for new developments. Public Utilities said additional infrastructure improvements will be necessary. Water Infrastructure-Upgrades to existing water mains are planned but additional work may be needed, particularly for fire hydrant demands and connections. Canal Proximity-The subject property is near the Jordan & Salt Lake Canal. Any development would need to be outside of the existing easement or potential additional easements for canal maintenance. Page | 7 The Transportation Division will require a traffic study to determine the impacts a large development would have on area traffic flow. ANALYSIS OF STANDARDS Attachment F (pages 139-143) of the Planning Commission staff report outlines zoning text and zoning map amendment standards that should be considered as the Council reviews this proposal. The standards and findings are summarized below. Please see the Planning Commission staff report for additional information. Zoning Text Amendment Factor Finding Whether a proposed map amendment is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives, and policies of the city as stated through its various adopted planning documents. Generally complies Whether a proposed map amendment furthers the specific purpose statements of the zoning ordinance. Complies Whether a proposed map amendment is consistent with the purposes and provisions of any applicable overlay zoning districts which may impose additional standards. N/A The extent to which a proposed text amendment implements best current, professional practices of urban planning and design. Complies The impact that the proposed text amendment may have on city resources necessary to carry out the provisions and processes required by this title. Would require significant public facility upgrades. Seven-year moratorium on street reconstruction likely to cause issues for site redevelopment. The impact that the proposed text amendment may have on other properties that would be subject to the proposal and properties adjacent to subject properties. Proposed MU-15 zoning intended for subject property but may be applied in other areas of the city. It is unknown if other property owners may use renewable construction methods. Impacts to adjacent properties would be similar to those under current or City proposed zoning. Design standards would ensure high level of design. The community benefits that would result from the proposed text amendment, as identified in 21A.50.050.C. Planning staff reviewed a community benefit checklist provided by the Page | 8 applicant and does not believe proposed benefits meet policy requirements. (As noted above, the petitions were vested before community benefit policy adoption.) Zoning Map Amendment Factor Finding Whether a proposed map amendment is consistent with and helps implement the purposes, goals, objectives, and policies of the city as stated through its various adopted planning documents. Generally complies Whether a proposed map amendment furthers the specific purpose statements of the zoning ordinance. Complies The extent to which a proposed map amendment will affect adjacent and nearby properties due to the change in development potential and allowed uses that do not current apply to the property. No proposed uses currently not allowed within existing zoning. Proposal is consistent with uses in proposed MU-11 zone except MU- 15 would not permit single-family attached. Whether a proposed map amendment is consistent with the purposes and provisions of any applicable overlay zoning districts which may impose additional standards. N/A The potential impacts on the city to provide safe drinking water, storm water, and sewer to the property and other properties based on the additional development potential of future development including any impact that may result in exceeding existing or planned capacities that may be located further away from the subject property. Would require significant public facility upgrades. The status of existing transportation facilities, any planned changes to the transportation facilities, and the impact that the proposed amendment may have on the city’s ability, need, and timing of future transportation improvements. Would impact area transportation facilities. Property owner would be required to meet conditions from Engineering and Transportation Divisions. The proximity of necessary amenities such as parks, open space, schools, fresh food, entertainment, cultural facilities, and the ability of current and future residents Sugar House is well connected to these amenities. S-Line ridership would likely to access these amenities without having to rely on a personal vehicle. increase with additional area residents. Page | 9 The potential impacts to public safety resources created by the increase in development potential that may result from the proposed amendment. Police did not have concerns with the proposal. Fire said construction would need to meet International Building and International Fire Codes. The potential for displacement of people who reside in any housing that is within the boundary of the proposed amendment and the plan offered by the petitioner to mitigate displacement. Property has been a commercial development. The potential for displacement of any business that is located within the boundary of the proposed amendment and the plan offered by the petitioner to mitigate displacement. No current businesses would be displaced. The community benefits that would result from the proposed map amendment, as identified in Section 21A.50.050.C. Planning staff reviewed a community benefit checklist provided by the applicant and does not believe proposed benefits meet policy requirements. (As noted above, the petitions were vested before community benefit policy adoption.) PROJECT CHRONOLOGY • November 29, 2023 – Applications submitted. • December 19, 2023 – Petitions assigned to Planning staff. • December 22, 2023 – o Applications deemed complete. o 45-day comment period notice sent to Sugar House Community Council. o Early notice sent to neighbors within 300 feet of the site. • December 26, 2023 – Online open house posted to Planning Division website. • February 27, 2024 – Sugar House Community Council Chair submitted letter of opposition to initial CSHBD-SUS zoning. • July 11, 2024 – o Proposed CSHBD-SUS zoning district withdrawn and new MU-15 zoning district proposal submitted. o Open house webpage updated with information on applicant’s new MU-15 proposal. • August 29, 2024 – Public hearing notice mailed, posted on City and State websites, and posted on Planning Division listserv. • August 30, 2024 – Public hearing notice sign posted on the property. Page | 10 • September 10, 2024 – Sugar House Community Council sent letter in opposition to the proposed MU-15 zoning. • September 11, 2024 – Planning Commission review and public hearing. The Commission voted to forward a unanimous negative recommendation to the City Council. • November 1, 2024 – Transmittal received in City Council Office. Item B3 CITY COUNCIL OF SALT LAKE CITY 451 SOUTH STATE STREET, ROOM 304 P.O. BOX 145476, SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84114-5476 SLCCOUNCIL.COM TEL 801-535-7600 FAX 801-535-7651 MOTION SHEET CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY tinyurl.com/SLCFY25 TO:City Council Members FROM: Ben Luedtke and Sylvia Richards DATE:December 3, 2024 RE: Budget Amendment Number Two of FY2025 MOTION 1 – CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING I move that the Council close the public hearing and refer the item to a future date for action. MOTION 2 – CONTINUE PUBLIC HEARING I move that the Council continue the public hearing to a future date. MOTION 3 – CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING AND ADOPT ALL ITEMS I move that the Council close the public hearing and adopt an ordinance amending the Fiscal Year 2025 final budget of Salt Lake City including the employment staffing document only for items as shown on the motion sheet. Staff note: Council Members do not need to read the individual items being approved below; they are listed for reference. A-1: Purchase Additional City Fleet Vehicles ($3.9 Million one-time from the Fleet Maintenance Fund Balance) A-2: Enhanced Security Improvements at the Justice Court ($200,000 from General Fund Balance then ongoing) A-3: Community Oriented Policing Services or COPS Hiring Grant from the U.S. Department of Justice for Two New Sergeants and 10 New Police Officers ($1 Million from Nondepartmental Holding Account and $617,673 from General Fund Balance of which $689,953 is ongoing) A-4: Vehicles, Equipment, and Related Police Officer Costs Not Covered by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant ($877,832 one-time from General Fund Balance of which $498,692 is ongoing) A-5: Downtown Capital City Revitalization Zone 0.5% Sales Tax Budget $25,982,860 ongoing in a new dedicated fund) A-6: 3200 West Complete Street Additions ($100,000 one-time from the Quarter-cent Sales Tax for Transportation Fund Balance) D-1: City Hall Earthquake Repair Insurance Funds Rescope ($3,488,282 rescope in the CIP Fund) D-2: Fleet Encumbrance Reappropriation ($10,580,117 from Fleet Fund) D-4: Landfill Projects ($7 Million one-time in the CIP Fund ; Budget Neutral from County Reimbursements) D-5: Additional Funding for Kensington Neighborhood Byway (Rescope $103,182 of CIP funds and $42,833 of transportation impact fees both from a cancelled project) D-6: Racial Equity in Policing Commission Recommended Trainings for the Police Department ($240,950 one-time from the Nondepartmental Public Safety Reform Holding Account) D-7: Prosecutor’s Office Changes since Budget Amendment #1 ($280,269 back to General Fund Balance; removing City Prosecutor FTE; and Rescope $50,000 in the CIP Fund for Fifth Floor of City Hall feasibility and structural study) D-8: 911 Department Reclassifying Two Positions (Budget Neutral) D-9: University of Utah Donation for Sunnyside Park Improvements ($4,200,000 one-time) D-10: Expense Budget Transfer from Non-departmental to the Police Department and Fire Department for Wages ($2,131,513 from Non-departmental; $1,047,521 to the Fire Department and $1,083,992 to the Police Department) E-1: TTIF 200 South Transit Corridor Project ($1,800,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) E-2: TTIF 400 South Multi-Use Trail ($6,356,000,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) E-3: TTIF West Temple Bike Transit Connections ($1,326,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) E-4: TTIF Westpointe/Jordan Meadows Neighborhood Byway ($900,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) E-5: FY24 COPS Law Enforcement Mental Health and Wellness Act ($98,786 from Misc. Grants Fund) E-6: FY 24 COPS Hiring Program ($1,500,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) F-2: University of Utah Sunnyside Donation ($4,200,000 from Donations Fund) G-1: Mental Health Services to First Responders ($47,556 from Misc. Grants Fund) G-2: Utah State Board of Education Snack Grant ($6,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) G-3: State of Utah, Department of Public Safety, Bureau of Emergency Medical Services (BEMS) ($9,642 from Misc. Grants Fund) G-4: Emergency Management Performance Grant ($18,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) I-1: City Hall Physical Security Improvements Holding Account Release ($123,133 one-time) I-2: Request to Reappropriate Funds for Reconnecting Communities Federal Grant for Local Match ($1.24 Million – Funding Our Future’s Fund Balance) I-3: Ivory University House Student Housing Project ($330,000 from FOF for Year One / FOF Housing Allocation to CAN for Years Two through Five) I-4: Informal Public Benefits Analysis: Utility Rate Stabilization Fee Waiver I-5: Aligning Appointed Pay Plan with the Council Office Staffing Document MOTION 4 – CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING AND NOT ADOPT I move that the Council close the public hearing and proceed to the next agenda item. COUNCIL STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL of SALT LAKE CITY tinyurl.com/SLCFY25 TO:City Council Members FROM: Ben Luedtke, Sylvia Richards Budget and Policy Analysts DATE: December 3, 2024 RE: Budget Amendment Number 2 of Fiscal Year (FY) 2025 NEW INFORMATION At the November 19 briefing, the Council passed three straw polls support of A-1, A-3, and A-4. The straw polls are for initiating paperwork to purchase police vehicles while the manufacturer is still accepting orders, and early job advertising for the 12 new police officers partially funded by the COPS hiring grant to help ensure they can participate in the January academy instead of waiting for the next academy in May. Straw polls indicate the Council’s informal position on an item but are nonbinding and do not guarantee how the Council will vote. Below are new write-ups for items D-5, I-4, and I-5, and an updated vacancy report. The Council may consider closing the public hearing and adopting some or all items at the December formal meetings. D-6: Racial Equity in Policing Commission Recommended Trainings for the Police Department ($240,950 one-time from the Nondepartmental Public Safety Reform Holding Account) The Commission on Racial Equality in Policing (CREP) has recommended that the City initiate training for members of the Police Department on the history of policing in marginalized communities. This item would fund three new one-time trainings. If the Council approved this funding request, then $1,290,439 would remain available in the public safety reform holding account for future uses. The trainings are intended to be developed and delivered, if possible, by local community-based trainers. A request for proposal would be developed to select the trainings. I-4: Informal Public Benefits Analysis: Utility Rate Stabilization Fee Waiver At the November 12th meeting, the Council approved an amendment to the Consolidate Fee Schedule to allow for a waiver of the stabilization fee on water and sewer accounts if the line was unused for longer than 18-months. In accordance with Utah State Code 10-8-2, Council will include this item as part of the budget amendment to establish the minimal budget impact to the Utility. The waiver of fees will constitute less than a 1 percent impact to the Utility budget for the fiscal year. (10-8-2 (2)(b)) I-5: Aligning Appointed Pay Plan with the Council Office Staffing Document See Attachment 4 for the red lined version of the Appointed Pay Plan. Several changes are shown in the Council Office section including removing positions that no longer exist and adjusting titles and pay grades. All the changes are to bring the Appointed Pay Plan into alignment with the FY2025 staffing document the Council adopted as part of the last annual budget. There are no budget impacts from updating the Appointed Pay Plan. Project Timeline: 1st Briefing: November 19, 2024 2nd Briefing & Public Hearing: Dec. 3, 2024 Potential Adoption Vote: December 10, 2024 Updated Vacancy Report The Finance Department provided a vacancy report dated October 25, 2024, which is summarized in the table to the right. It’s organized from most to least year-to-date (YTD) savings. This is a snapshot of current full- time positions that are unfilled by the department. The report found 193 vacant positions in the City. This report excludes several types of positions if they are grant funded, seasonal or part-time, and some FTEs in the 911, Fire, and Police Departments that are authorized but unfunded to help with turnover (such as hiring entry level positions shortly before expected retirements / terminations). This report only reflects the current fiscal year so covering the period of July 1 – October 25. It does not reflect positions that have been vacant across multiple fiscal years. During the annual budget the Council requested that the Administration include vacancy analyses as part of the hybrid zero-based budgeting / program-based budgeting effort. Note the table shows both General Fund departments and enterprise fund departments. The 193 vacant positions are approximately 5.5% of all FTEs in the City. Policy Question: Regular Vacancy Reports – The Council may wish to request that the Administration include regularly updated vacancy reports with budget amendments similar to how impact fees tracking reports are regularly provided. The Council could also request that departments provide updates on plans to address significant staffing issues such as a high number of vacancies, or key leadership positions that are vacant. Information below this line was provided at earlier briefings Budget Amendment Number Two includes 31 proposed amendments with $54,211,296 in revenues and $73,124,104 in expenditures of which $3,477,524 is from General Fund Balance. The amendments are across seven funds with twelve proposed general fund positions for new police officers and one position (City Prosecutor) being removed that was previously added in Budget Amendment #1. Most expenses in this budget amendment are housekeeping items found in section D. One of these funds will be a new fund associated with the Downtown Capital City Revitalization Zone 0.5% sales tax. The amendments also include six new initiatives in section A and additional housekeeping and grant related items, and one donation-related item. There are also four Council-added items. Fund Balance If all the items are adopted as proposed, including all the Council-added items, then the General Fund Balance would be projected at 13.9% which is $4,627,100 above the 13% minimum target. Tracking New Ongoing General Fund Costs for the Next Annual Budget The table of potential new ongoing General Fund costs for the FY2026 annual budget is available as Attachment 1 at the end of this document. If all the items in Budget Amendment #2 are adopted as proposed by the Administration, then the FY2026 annual budget could have $1,704,055 of new ongoing costs. The total new ongoing costs from Budget Amendments 1 through 2 would be $6,207,570. Note that of the total cost, $4.1 million would be needed if the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation grant is not available for FY2026. Straw Poll Requests The Administration is requesting straw polls for three items listed below. Note that straw polls are an informal indication of the Council’s support and are not legally binding. All three of the straw polls are being requested to allow Fleet to begin paperwork to help meet the ordering window for purchasing police vehicles. There is no closing Department Estimated Salary Savings YTD # of Vacant Positions % of Department's Total FTEs Airport 578,011$ 38 5.7% 911 450,896$ 24 24.0% Police 412,169$ 35 4.6% Public Utilities 359,453$ 28 5.9% Fire 216,582$ 18 4.4% Community & Neighborhoods 185,406$ 11 5.6% City Council 112,464$ 4 10.3% Attorneys Office 107,715$ 4 6.0% Public Lands 97,007$ 9 5.4% Finance 77,819$ 3 3.5% Public Services 66,333$ 9 3.3% RDA 64,222$ 2 5.7% Economic Development 56,477$ 3 12.8% HR 35,448$ 2 6.0% Sustainability 13,984$ 2 3.1% IMS 7,906$ 1 1.0% Grand Total 2,841,892$ 193 5.5% date, however, the manufacturer will stop accepting orders once available builds are filled, which is unpredictable. Item A-1: Purchase Additional City Fleet Vehicles by using $3.9 million from the Fleet Maintenance Fund Balance Item A-3: FY 24-25 COPS Hiring Program Grant to allow early job advertising to help ensure recruits can participate in the January training academy Item A-4: FY 24-25 Vehicles, Equipment, and Related Police Officer Costs Not Covered by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: No adjustments to the revenue budget are anticipated at this time. Fund Balance Chart The Administration’s chart below shows the current General Fund Balance figures. Fund balance has been updated to include proposed changes for BA#1. Note that some Council-added items are proposed to use more from Fund Balance that shown in the table below. FUND BALANCE CHART Based on those projections adjusted fund balance is projected to be at 14.29%. The additional Council-added items would result in a Fund Balance projected to be at 13.9%. A summary spreadsheet outlining proposed budget changes is attached. The Administration requests this document be modified based on the decisions of the Council. The budget opening is separated in eight different categories: A.New Budget Items B.Grants for Existing Staff Resources C.Grants for New Staff Resources D.Housekeeping Items E.Grants Requiring No New Staff Resources F.Donations G.Council Consent Agenda Grant Awards I.Council Added Items PUBLIC PROCESS: Public Hearing Vacancy Report (193 Vacant Positions) The Finance Department provided a vacancy report dated October 25, 2024 which is summarized in the table to the right. This is a snapshot in time of current full-time positions that are unfilled by department. The report found 193 vacant positions in the City. This report excludes several types of positions if they are grant funded, seasonal or part-time, and some FTEs in the 911, Fire, and Police Departments that are authorized but unfunded to help with turnover (such as hiring entry level positions shortly before expected retirements / terminations). This report only reflects the current fiscal year so covering the period of July 1 – October 25. It does not reflect positions that have been vacant across multiple fiscal years. During the annual budget the Council requested that the Administration include vacancy analyses as part of the hybrid zero-based budgeting / program-based budgeting effort. Impact Fee Unallocated “Available to Spend” Balances and Refund Tracking Updated balances of impact fees are anticipated to be available later this month. There is one item (D-5) in this budget amendment that would rescope transportation impact fees from one project to another. There are no proposed new appropriations of impact fees at the time of publishing this staff report. Section A: New Items Note: to expedite the processing of this staff report, staff has included the Administration’s descriptions from the transmittal for some of these items. A-1: Purchase Additional City Fleet Vehicles ($3.9 Million one-time from the Fleet Maintenance Fund Balance) The Administration is requesting $3.9 million of one-time previously appropriated but unspent Fleet funding for the purchase of vehicles as follows: Department Current Acquire & Capital Cost Number Of Assets CED $147,980.46 4 Fire $1,900,000.00 1 Police $464,625.75 5 Streets $1,381,834.61 5 Grand Total $3,894,440.82 15 If this item is approved by the Council, the Administration estimates the amount remaining in the Fleet Fund will be $1.5 million, which is historically much lower than previous years. In response to the question as to whether Fleet has a new policy not to maintain a fund balance, Fleet Administration indicated the following: “ Fleet's budget is divided into two funds, Maintenance and Replacement. Internal service funds, in this case Fleet's Maintenance Fund, should never carry a large fund balance as it is an internal operation for departments in the City. The Fleet "new vehicle fund" (aka replacement fund) should carry a minimal fund balance.” A-2: Enhanced Security Improvements at the Justice Court ($200,000 from General Fund Balance then ongoing) In August of 2024, the Justice Court Administration received a Vulnerability Assessment Report which evaluated the Court’s security both inside and outside the Court building. The Administration is requesting $200,000 in ongoing funding for security improvements at the Justice Court. The Court may need to make future funding requests to implement other recommendations but may also satisfy those needs through the Department of Public Service Safety and Security via a CIP application. This budget amendment request addresses the primary and time sensitive need of the Court at this time, according to the report. Policy Question: Potential Efficiencies by Combining Security between City Facilities – Council Members may wish to ask the Administration whether efficiencies could be gained by combining Justice Court security efforts with City Hall, Washington Square, and Library Plaza security. A-3: Community Oriented Policing Services or COPS Hiring Grant from the U.S. Department of Justice for Two New Sergeants and 10 New Police Officers ($1 Million from Nondepartmental Holding Account and $617,673 from General Fund Balance of which $689,953 is ongoing) This item is related to item E-6 later in the staff report which is the budget step to accept the $1.5 million grant from the DOJ. A-3 is the required local match from the City’s General Fund. The City was awarded $1.5 million from the U.S. Department of Justice’s Community Oriented Policing Services or COPS hiring grant. It partially funds 12 new police officer FTEs that will form two squads dedicated to the Jordan River Trail and surrounding neighborhoods. The grant requires the City to maintain employment of the new police officers for at least 12 months after the 36 months that the grant helps pay for. Historically, the City has successfully applied for and received COPS hiring grants multiple times and has retained the officers beyond the required four-years. Over the four-year term, the grant provides $1.5 million and the General Fund will need to budget $5,480,115. The table below breakout these estimated costs by fiscal year. When the grant term ends, $2,071,325 is the fully loaded estimated annual cost for the General Fund to continue employing the 12 new police officer FTEs. In the annual budget, the Council created a $1 million holding account in Nondepartmental for TBD Jordan River trail service level improvements. The funds were intentionally left flexible to respond to different needs along the river and adjacent trail. The Administration is proposing to use the full $1 million to help meet the required $1,617,673 local matching funds for the COPS hiring grant. The remaining $617,673 would come from General Fund Balance. This item would approve ongoing costs that would be covered by the General Fund this fiscal year for: $383,228 for the local match of salaries and benefits, $306,725 for equipment and supplies, and $45,720 for 12 body cameras and associated software licenses One-time costs covered by the General Fund include: $787,800 transfer to the Fleet Fund for new vehicles, and $94,200 transfer to the IMS Fund for computers, software, mobile data terminals, and radios Timing of New Jordan River Trail Police Squads and Police Department Staffing Update The Department reports an academy class is scheduled to begin in January. New recruits typically take 10 months to complete the academy and field training. When the 12 new recruits complete training they will be placed in patrol positions and a corresponding 12 experienced patrol officers will be transferred into the new Jordan River police squads. The public could start seeing the newly created squads in October or November next year. The Department is recommending this approach to avoid creating a shortfall in patrol staffing levels. If this item is approved, then the total staffing of police officers would increase to 630 FTEs (not counting 20 authorized but unfunded positions to help reduce turnover fluctuations). This includes 598 police officers paid by the General Fund, and 32 partially or fully covered by grants: 1 for the DEA Metro Narcotics Task Force, 12 from this new COPS hiring grant, and 19 by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant. The Departments reports 12 police officers are currently unavailable due to being on leave and 46 are in training. STRAW POLL REQUEST: The Administration is requesting a straw poll on the $787,800 for new police vehicles so the Fleet Division may initiate paperwork to place the order while the manufacturer is still accepting new orders. The purchase order could not be finalized until the Council formally votes to adopt this budget item. Vehicle manufacturer ordering windows have become less predictable in recent years. Some Council Members have also proposed including early job advertising of the 12 new positions to help ensure the recruits can be included in the January academy instead of waiting for the next scheduled academy in May. Policy Question: Short-term Resource Needs until New Squads are Deployed – The Council may wish to ask the Administration what additional resources could help address public safety concerns along the Jordan River trail until the new squads are deployed in October / November next year? A-4: Vehicles, Equipment, and Related Police Officer Costs Not Covered by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant ($877,832 one-time from General Fund Balance of which $498,692 is ongoing) This is a follow up item from the annual budget that would shift ongoing costs from the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation to the General Fund and provide one-time funding for police officers’ vehicles, equipment, and related costs. The Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant award this year is $2,945,958 which is (- $161,243) less than last year. Four new police officers were added this year bringing the total to 19 police officers funded by the grant. The police officers are dedicated to the geographic area around the Geraldine E. King and Gail Miller homeless resource centers. The grant also funds four civilian FTEs and a subaward to the Volunteers of America or VOA. The grant would need to be approximately $4.1 million next year to fully cover the 23 FTEs, equipment, supplies, and subaward to the VOA. The grant is subject to annual appropriations by the Legislature and changes to the number of eligible municipalities. Non-personnel costs related to the 19 police officers funded by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant are proposed to shift to the General Fund. This shift better aligns eligible costs with reimbursement deadlines under the grant. For example, the City was unable to receive all reimbursable expenses under the grant in recent years because of difficulty aligning vehicle and equipment expenditures with the grant deadline. The smaller grant award is also insufficient to cover the cost of FTEs and all the vehicles and equipment needed by those FTEs. The reduced grant award created a budget shortfall for ongoing costs would be covered by the General Fund: $273,236 for ongoing supplies and equipment, and $225,456 for ongoing police officer salaries One-time costs covered by the General Fund include: $262,600 transfer to the Fleet Fund for vehicles $72,390 for 19 body cameras and associated software licenses $44,150 transfer to the IMS Fund for computers, software, mobile data terminals, and radios FY 24-25 State Homeless Mitigation Grant Officer Costs ($877,832 STRAW POLL REQUEST: The Administration is requesting a straw poll on the $262,600 for new police vehicles so the Fleet Division may initiate paperwork to place the order while the manufacturer is still accepting new orders. The purchase order could not be finalized until the Council formally votes to adopt this budget item. Vehicle manufacturer ordering windows have become less predictable in recent years. A-5: Downtown Capital City Revitalization Zone 0.5% Sales Tax Budget $25,982,860 ongoing in a new dedicated fund) Following the action by City Council to adopt the participation agreement and project area with the City and Smith Entertainment Group, this item is to address the anticipated 0.5% sales and use tax revenue and expense (budget) for the remainder of Fiscal Year 2025. It is anticipated that this action will result in approximately $25,982,860 in revenues for the remainder of the fiscal year, resulting in expenses of $25,982,860. The annual budget estimate is approximately $56,484,479. As the agreement and notice period become finalized, a new Fund will be established and Finance staff will ensure adequate accounting measures to track, report and monitor the Downtown Revitalization Zone Sales Tax. The Council voted to endorse the proposed participation agreement and project area on July 9, 2024, and submitted notice of the Council’s endorsement to the Revitalization Zone Committee on August 30, 2024. The Revitalization Zone Committee approved the endorsed project area and participation agreement on September 17, 2024. The City Council adopted a resolution on October 1, 2024. Per the Participation Agreement, the Administration plans to bring to the Council in a budget opening later this fiscal year a proposal to create the Public Benefit Account for ticket fee revenue and the 1% of sales tax revenues to cover the City's administrative expenses. A-6: 3200 West Complete Street Additions ($100,000 one-time from the Quarter-cent Sales Tax for Transportation Fund Balance) This request would fund a new opportunity to add sidewalks and bike lanes to bridge a gap in the active transportation network, connecting to West Valley City. 3200 West is a city arterial street which crosses under the 201 Freeway. UDOT is replacing the 201 Freeway bridge over 3200 West, which presents an opportunity for changes under the bridge -- a tricky spot for walking and bicycling due to a lack of bike lanes and disjointed sidewalks. This project would improve sidewalks and crosswalks, as well as add bike lanes under the bridge and through the interchange. UDOT's project is scheduled for 2025 construction. UDOT only recently extended the opportunity for these active transportation improvements to be added to the bridge project and has asked the local municipalities (Salt Lake City and West Valley City) to contribute toward adding these safety improvements. Transportation would like to consider using the County 1/4 cent Transportation fund for this request versus using General Fund balance. In the annual budget, the Council appropriated $2 million one-time for the Livable Streets Traffic Calming Program from the Quarter Cent Sales Tax for Transportation Fund Balance (separate from General Fund Balance). The Council expressed an interest to continue annual funding for that program to reach all high need neighborhood zones. It's estimated that there's $1 million remaining unappropriated in the Quarter Cent Sales Tax for Transportation Fund Balance but this is pending confirmation by the annual financial audit in December / January. Alternatively, there is existing complete streets funding from CIP that is eligible to be used for this project. Section D: Housekeeping Items D-1: City Hall Earthquake Repair Insurance Funds Rescope ($3,488,282 rescope in the CIP Fund) In Fiscal Year 2023 $7,252,300 was accepted by FM Global to pre-load funds for earthquake repairs to City Hall. Of this amount, $3,764,018.74 (pending final invoicing) was spent and $3,488,281.26 is remaining. The project is now being closed out and under warranty. The remaining balance has been approved by the insurer to complete multiple repairs to other facilities that have been deferred thus far. Since the earthquake damage was considered a one ‘loss event,’ all the FM Global funding is coming from one so-called ‘bucket.’ Since the City-County Building repairs are complete, this request is to place remaining funds in a holding account for FM Global-approved earthquake repair expenditures. This amount could change as projects are further along. When all repair projects are closed out, the remaining funds will be returned to FM Global. These funds are all insurance proceeds and will not impact the General Fund. The Administration provided the below list of City buildings with eligible expenses from damage caused by the March 2020 earthquake. The damage to these facilities was less critical than to City Hall. Site/Location Anticipated Completion Date Fire Station #8 March 2025 Fire Station #14 December 2025 Pioneer Police Precinct April 2025 Public Lands Administration Building May 2025 Fleet Shop Building April 2025 Police Training Facility June 2025 Jordan Park Maintenance Bldg June 2025 Rose Park Golf Maintenance Shed June 2025 RAC Athletic Complex North Building June 2025 Compliance Building                         212 E 600 S June 2025 234 E 600 S June 2025 Central Business District               240 E 600 S June 2025 Facilities                                               248 E 600 S June 2025 Justice Court Building                          333 S 200 E June 2025 D-2: Fleet Encumbrance Reappropriation ($10,580,117 from Fleet Fund) This is the Fleet encumbrance rollover for vehicles that were committed to with the funds appropriated in Fiscal Year 2024 or earlier, but that have not been received or completed and put into service. A summary of rollover amounts is included below. An additional small amount of prior-year funding was encumbered for software upgrades, a purchase that was also not fully expended by year-end. Fiscal Year 2023 Orders: $2,863,947.37 Fiscal Year 2024 Orders: $6,502,52616 Upfit costs for all listed vehicles: $1,213,643.47 Total Rollover Request: $10,580,117.00. D-3: WITHDRAWN D-4: Landfill Projects ($7 Million one-time in the CIP Fund; Budget Neutral from County Reimbursements) The landfill CIP account was funded with $1.5M for various landfill projects that have been ongoing. The funds placed in the account are applied to individual projects and then reimbursed by the County back to the General Fund – which are considered as equal expense and revenue. With the Council approved Environmental Engineer position, projects have been moving along at a much quicker timeline. The now-current project module is for the "South Header and methane collection wells" - for capture of methane gas emitting from the landfill which is then used for energy production. The construction start date has now moved up to Spring '25. This $7M project will need funding secured before going out to bid this winter. The accelerated construction timeline is why this item is coming to the Council in a budget amendment. D-5: Additional Funding for Kensington Neighborhood Byway (Rescope $103,182 of CIP funds and $42,833 of transportation impact fees both from a cancelled project) This request is to rescope funds from the existing Appropriation for 1300 S Bicycle Bypass (pedestrian) and the project for the- 1300 S Bicycle Bypass to construct a different bypass route than was originally envisioned at the time of the original CIP application in fiscal year 2015. The original east-west bypass route was to parallel 1300 South to the north; the east-west Kensington Neighborhood Byway parallels 1300 South to the south. The original northern route became unfeasible after a lengthy design process as UDOT declined to permit a new bicycle/pedestrian crossing of State Street at Edith Avenue (1195 S) or Kelsey Avenue (1180 S) due to close proximity to the 1300 South signalized intersection. A portion of the original appropriation was used to make safety improvements to the TRAX rail crossing at Paxton Avenue, which then connects to existing bikeways on Main St. This leaves two funding sources as outlined below, both dedicated to the 1300 South Bicycle Bypass. The East-West Kensington Neighborhood Bypass runs parallel to 1300 South at approximately 1500 South and will serve as a preferred bicycle route and alternative for those traveling East-West in the Ballpark neighborhood. The other funding source, a federal grant from the Wasatch Front Regional Council, has already been rescoped to fund the Kensington Neighborhood Byway. This request seeks to add the City's portion of the 1300 S Bicycle Bypass to resolve a budget gap in the Kensington project, as UDOT has given approval for more significant improvements at State Street and 700 East compared to the budget developed for the original Kensington funding applications. There is also an associated impact fee cost center tied to the original appropriation for 1300 S Bicycle Bypass found in the 1300 S Bicycle Bypass (pedestrian) for $42,832.69. In consulting with the CIP Finance team, these funds will either need to be used on a project or returned to the Street/Transportation impact fee Fund. The Council recently appropriated $970,000 in FY2025 CIP for urban trails most of which is anticipated to go to this project’s expanded scope. The Kensington Neighborhood Byway project has a current budget of $2,472,823. The additional funding proposed in this item would increase the budget to $2,618,838. If this item is approved, then the project’s expanded scope is expected to be fully funded. D-6: Racial Equity in Policing Commission Recommended Trainings for the Police Department ($240,950 one-time from the Nondepartmental Public Safety Reform Holding Account) At the time of publishing this staff report additional information was forthcoming on this item. D-7: Prosecutor’s Office Changes since Budget Amendment #1 ($280,269 back to General Fund Balance; removing City Prosecutor FTE; and Rescope $50,000 in the CIP Fund for Fifth Floor of City Hall feasibility and structural study) This item is in response to a previous item noted on Budget Amendment 1. In Budget Amendment 1 (Item A-1), it was noted that the District Attorney's Office provided the City Attorney's Office notice of intent to termination the interlocal agreement between the city and County. This item was to bring the function and various staff under the City, resulting in termination of the contract effective December 31, 2024. Following ongoing discussions, it was determined that the agreement will remain in place as is for the foreseeable future. As a result, this item is to reverse the budgetary impacts and actions outlined in Budget Amendment 1. It is important to note, however, that two (2) of the positions outlined in BA1 are proposed to remain as new, ongoing FTEs. The two (2) new FTEs are outlined below. The City Prosecutor FTE would be removed and the associated budget returned to General Fund Balance. (1) Senior City Attorney – Class 39. The anticipated cost for 8 months is $157,635.74 in FY25, or $236,452 annually and; (1) Deputy Director of Administration - City Attorney’s Office – Class 40 (New position). The anticipated cost for 9 months is $186,547 in FY25, or $248,729 annually. Additionally, in BA1, the administration proposed $280,000 be rescoped and transferred to the CIP Fund to lease office space, utilities, tenant improvements, furniture, fixtures, and equipment. Following council discussion, the amount was increased to $472,298. This action is also being reversed, however, $50,000 is to remain in the CIP Fund to conduct a feasibility and structural study for the current City Attorney’s (department) office space at City Hall and the remainder of the Fifth Floor. D-8: 911 Department Reclassifying Two Positions (Budget Neutral) The 911 Department is proposing to reclassify an existing appointed executive assistant at pay grade 26 to a merit Business System Analyst at pay grade 28. The change is intended to increase the technical expertise within the Department and improve collaboration with IMS. The second reclassification is an existing appointed deputy director at pay grade 32 to a merit assistant director at pay grade 31. There are currently four merit assistant directors in the 911 Department which would increase to five under this proposal. The assistant directors have been described as like division directors which are typically appointed. There would no longer be a deputy director position in the 911 Department. A job description for the assistant director position is available as Attachment 3. Both reclassifications would change appointed positions to merit positions. The Administration included an update to the Appointed Pay Plan in the transmittal that would require Council approval. The net impact of the pay grade changes is estimated to be budget neutral so no additional funding would be needed. Policy Question: No Deputy Director in the 911 Department – The Council may wish to discuss with the Administration how the 911 Department would function without a deputy director, especially in stances when the director is unavailable. Over the years, some departments have proposed removing deputy directors and the Council approved it but later the departments returned requesting to restore the deputy director positions. This most recently occurred with the HR department. D-9: University of Utah Donation for Sunnyside Park Improvements ($4,200,000 one-time) The City received a donation from the University of Utah for $4,200,000 for improvements at Sunnyside park (See Initiative F-2). This funding has been received through the Donation fund and will be transferred to the CIP fund to facilitate the improvements planned for Sunnyside park. D-10: Expense Budget Transfer from Non-departmental to the Police Department and Fire Department for Wages ($2,131,513 from Non-departmental; $1,047,521 to the Fire Department and $1,083,992 to the Police Department) As part of the Fiscal Year 2025 Adopted Budget, budget was captured in Non-departmental to account for the additional budget necessary to support increased Police and Fire wages because of updated MOUs. This item is to transfer those funds from Non-departmental to the Police and Fire Department budgets, as follows: General Fund: $1,854,416 Funding Our Future: $277,097 Fire Department: $1,047,521 Police Department: $1,083,992 Staff note: Items E-1 through E-4 are capital projects receiving nearly $10.4 million in grants from the State Transit Transportation Investment Fund or TTIF. The City Transportation Division provided a presentation about these four projects which is available as Attachment 2. Section E: Grants Requiring No Staff Resources E-1: TTIF 200 South Transit Corridor Project ($1,800,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability grant award in the amount of $1,800,000 for the purpose of completing the 200 South Transit Corridor project. Project Description: The 200 South Transit Corridor Technology Upgrades will evaluate bus transit operations on 200 South between roughly 600 west and University Street and identify strategies for improvement. The focus of the project will be on improving bus operations through upgrades to intersection controls, which will likely include a combination of transit signal priority (TSP), detection systems, cabinet/controller hardware, fiber optic communication, and connected vehicle (V2X) systems. Salt Lake City has already made significant investments to rebuild the street to establish a Business Access and Transit (BAT) lane and boarding islands; this project follows the initial roadway construction with focus on transit operations and technology upgrades to further enhance the transit capacity and safety of the 200 South Transit Corridor. E-2: TTIF 400 South Multi-Use Trail ($6,356,000,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability grant award in the amount of $6,356,000 for the purpose of completing the 400 South multi-use trail. UDOT and SLC are partnering to create a multi-use trail on the south side of 400 South from 900 West to 200 West, including the viaduct bridge over the railroad tracks. The corridor is an important east/west connector and the project aims to maintain current vehicular capacity while establishing a safe dedicated corridor for people walking, biking and rolling. The trail will feature art to enhance the character of the surrounding area and make traveling along the trail an enjoyable experience. E-3: TTIF West Temple Bike Transit Connections ($1,326,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability grant award in the amount of $1,326,000 for the purpose of completing the West Temple Bike Transit Connections. West Temple Bike Transit Connections-the project will add buffered bike lanes in both directions of West Temple from Market Street to North Temple, improve pedestrian crossings by adding medians and/or bulb outs and HAWK signals at the Market Street, Pierpont Street, and 150 South crosswalks, and improve bus stops including bus boarding islands at a new protected intersection at 300 South. E-4: TTIF Westpointe/Jordan Meadows Neighborhood Byway ($900,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability grant award in the amount of $900,00 for the purpose of completing the Westpointe/Jordan Neighborhood Byway. The Westpointe/Jordan Meadows Neighborhood Byway will integrate active transportation infrastructure into the local street network to create a north- south route through the Westpointe and Jordan Meadows neighborhoods that runs west of and parallel to Redwood Road. This project will improve bicycling and walking along this route and increase neighborhood access to the Green Line TRAX and planned SLC Westside Transit Hub. This route will provide access to transit at several points; notably to TRAX on the south end, along the route itself and on 700 North. Also, it will enhance connectivity to the Northwest middle School, Westpointe Park, Escalante Elementary School and Utah State Office complex at 1950 West North Temple. E-5: FY24 COPS Law Enforcement Mental Health and Wellness Act ($98,786 from Misc. Grants Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability through a grant award in the amount of $98,786 for the purpose of providing wellness and mental health resources to the police department. Project Description: Salt Lake City will receive a grant under the DOJ through the COPS Office. Salt Lake City will use FY24 LEMHWA funding to support training for the Wellness team, peer mentoring training for Peer support team including a mobile wellness app for employees and their families and accompanying training; and overtime for Peer Support Team to expand services in the department. E-6: FY 24 COPS Hiring Program ($1,500,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) Staff note: This item is related to item A-3 earlier in the staff report which is the budget step to authorize 12 new police officer FTEs on the staffing document and provide $1.6 million from the City's General Fund as the required local match to the $1.5 million COPS hiring grant. This budget amendment is to recognize the City's funding availability through a grant award in the amount of $1,500,000 for the purpose of hiring 12 new officers. Project Description: The Police Department will hire 12 new police officers to facilitate deployment of 12 current officers who will be assigned to newly created squads. The squads will focus on crime reduction, community safety, and expansion of services in areas to include the City’s portion of the Jordan River Trail, as well as City parks and other recreational areas and residential and business areas. Section F: Donations F-1: WITHDRAWN F-2: University of Utah Sunnyside Donation ($4,200,000 from Donations Fund) This budget amendment is to recognize the City receiving a donation from the University of Utah for $4,200,000 for improvements at Sunnyside park. Per the donation agreement with the University, the University will provide $1.0 million within 30 days of the effective date of the agreement. The remaining balance will be deposited into a third-party escrow account within 30 days of receipt of the City’s notice that it has completed its public engagement process to determine the improvements. Quarterly progress payments will be released to the City from the escrow based on a construction schedule mutually agreed upon by the City and the University. Per the agreement, these funds must be used for the project determined by the public engagement process. The City may not use these funds for deferred maintenance or repairs except as required to accomplish new, renovated, or upgraded amenities and infrastructure. Per the agreement, the City may also use these funds toward mitigating the loss of the softball fields currently in Sunnyside park to other City parks. The funds from this donation will be deposited in the City’s Donations special revenue fund and transferred to a CIP fund to be used for the Project (see Initiative D-10 for CIP Funding). Section G: Grant Consent Agenda No. 4 G-1: Mental Health Services to First Responders ($47,556 from Misc. Grants Fund) Funding to support a year of a comprehensive and data-driven mental health and wellness platform to enhance the mental well-being of its first responders. A platform of this type will provide essential wellness tools for early detection and intervention, including web-accessible peer support and a wellness resource toolkit accessible through iOS and Android-driven applications offering clinically validated wellness sessions and learning modules specifically tailored for first responders, their families, and retirees. This resource will provide first responders with the tools to build resilience and maintain mental wellness. Additionally, this will cover the cost of two mental health trainings for SLC 911 (Help is on the way for Dispatch Training and an Emotion Intelligence training for SLC 911 managers.).This grant is provided by the Utah State Department of Public Safety. The Public Hearing was held June 11 ,2024. G-2: Utah State Board of Education Snack Grant ($6,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) The Division of Youth and Family Services submitted a renewal application for reimbursement to provide nutritious snacks to Youth City participants during summer of 2024. The Public Hearing was held on July 9, 2024. G-3: State of Utah, Department of Public Safety, Bureau of Emergency Medical Services (BEMS) ($9,642 from Misc. Grants Fund) This is Salt Lake City's annual BEMS grant from the state. Under Utah Code Ann. 53-2d-207, BEMS is allowed to award annual grants to emergency medical services providers from the EMS Per Capita grant funds to assist in providing emergency medical services. The Public Hearing was held March 5,2024. G-4: Emergency Management Performance Grant ($18,000 from Misc. Grants Fund) This is Salt Lake City's annual BEMS grant from the state. Under Utah Code Ann. 53-2d-207, BEMS is allowed to award annual grants to emergency medical services providers from the EMS Per Capita grant funds to assist in providing emergency medical services. The Public Hearing was held June 11, 2024. Section I: Council-Added Items I-1: City Hall Physical Security Improvements Holding Account Release ( On June 26, 2024 the Administration sent a transmittal requesting the Council release $123,133 for two projects described below. In Budget Amendment #5 of FY2023, the Council put $1 million into a CIP Fund holding account for one-time to be determined physical security improvements to City Hall. If the Council approved releasing these funds, then the holding account would have a remaining balance of $586,867. The Council previously approved releasing some funds in January this year:$ $83,733 for Camera System Upgrades (hardware and software): The current camera system in use throughout the City and City Hall, manufactured by Pelco, is outdated and its software license is set to expire at the end of 2024. Due to the outdated technology and expiring license, the cameras and servers they operate on require replacement. The City will be migrating to Milestone's system for use in City Hall. Milestone has already been successfully implemented by the SLC Police Department in the Public Safety Building. Transitioning to Milestone will ensure enhanced security and uniformity across the City infrastructure. $39,400 is needed for Emergency Notification System Upgrades (hardware in three buildings). Emergency Management will be transitioning from the current RAVE emergency notification platform to Titan HST. The Emergency Management Division will cover the subscription cost; however, there is a hardware component associated with this change that needs funding. The necessary hardware will be initially installed at City Hall, Plaza 349, and the Public Safety Building to support this new system. This first phase will inform future deployments of hardware at other buildings. I-2: Request to Reappropriate Funds for Reconnecting Communities Federal Grant for Local Match ($1.24 Million – Funding Our Future’s Fund Balance) This is a reappropriation as the local matching funds for a federal reconnecting communities grant the City was awarded to study and recommend solutions to the east-west transportation divide created by several railroad tracks and Interstate 15. The study has a total budget of $3.74 million. UDOT is acting as the financial administrator for the City. The Federal Highway Administration preferred this arrangement in part because UDOT already has the systems to regularly manage federal transportation funds and meet the compliance requirements. The funding sources are: -$1.97 million from the federal reconnecting communities planning grant -$1.24 million from the General Fund -$500,000 from UTA -$25,000 from the RDA -$5,000 from Public Utilities Staff has communicated to the Administration Council Member interest in submitting federal grant applications for implementation construction funding. Those applications may need to be submitted before the study is finalized which could be in two years. There are limited federal funding opportunities to implement the results of the study but the largest federal grants are scheduled to only be available for two or three more years. Most of these construction grants are authorized by the Inflation Reduction Act and Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. Congressional authorization would be needed to extend most of these grants beyond the next two or three years. Policy Question: Request Local Matching Funds in Annual Budget for Construction Grant Applications – The Council may wish to request that the Administration include local matching funds in the next annual budget in anticipation of the City applying for implementation construction grants from the Federal Government. The U.S. Department of Transportation has previously provided guidance that grant applications are more competitive when there are local matching funds and a coalition of supporting organizations. I-3: Ivory University House Student Housing Project ($350,000 from FOF for Year One / FOF Housing Allocation to CAN for Years Two through Five) Council Member Petro has requested the Council’s consideration on this item. The Ivory Foundation has approached the City about contributing towards the Ivory University House, a student housing project they are building adjacent to the University of Utah campus on land owned by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. The City does not currently have a financing tool to facilitate the development of affordable student housing in the manner that the City has financing tools to facilitate general affordable housing, which is why this is coming through a budget amendment request. Additionally, while tax credit programs like LIHTC are available for income-qualified persons on an Area- Median-Income (AMI) basis, no such tool exists to help facilitate affordable student housing. The following are general aspects of the proposal: -25% of the student housing would be set aside for graduates of Salt Lake City school district high schools who qualify for the highest amount of financial aid as determined through the student’s Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA). This would guarantee that the family of the student is need based and not just the student. Those families would also likely qualify for many of the other affordable housing developments that the City invests in. -This would serve approximately 150 students per year. -The City would allocate $350,000 per year for 5 years to the project, through the City’s Funding our Future housing allocation for a total of $1.75 million. The initial year would come from Funding our Future fund balance. -The term of the deed restriction on the affordable spaces is proposed to be 30 years in exchange for the City’s investment. -The City would require annual reports including the number of students served. The Administration is still working on details that could be included in a potential contract, should the Council approve this funding. Because it would be a contractual obligation for 5 years, it would be included in Funding our Future budget appropriations for the next 4 budget cycles and would be removed from the budget once the term of the contract is complete. Policy Questions: Long-term City Strategy for Affordable Student Housing – The Council may wish to ask the Administration if it would like to consider a longer-term strategy for the City to use its housing dollars to facilitate affordable student housing for all of the universities and community colleges in Salt Lake City. Council Approval of Final Terms – The Council may wish to make the funding contingent on approval of final terms of the agreement. I-4: PLACEHOLDER - Public Utilities Stabilization Fee Waiver for Instances of Non-use At the time of publishing this staff report additional information was forthcoming on this item. ATTACHMENTS 1. Council Request: Tracking New Ongoing Costs to the General Fund 2. Transit Transportation Investment Fund or TTIF presentation from the City’s Transportation Division on four capital projects receiving TTIF funding 3. 911 Division Assistant Director Job Description 4. Appointed Pay Plan Redlined Version ACRONYMS BEMS – Bureau of Emergency Medical Services CAFR – Comprehensive Annual Financial Report CDBG – Community Development Block Grant CREP – Commission on Racial Equity in Policing CIP – Capital Improvement Program COPS – Community Oriented Policing Services DOJ – Department of Justice FOF – Funding Our Future FTE – Full time Employee / Equivalent FY – Fiscal Year GF – General Fund iOS – I-phone Operating Software IMS – Information Management Services RAVE Alert – Mobile Emergency Notification System UDOT – Utah Department of Transportation ATTACHMENT 1 Council Request: Tracking New Ongoing Costs to the General Fund Council staff has provided the following list of potential new ongoing costs to the General Fund. Many of these are new FTE’s approved during this fiscal year’s budget amendments, noting that each new FTE increases the City’s annual budget costs if positions are added to the staffing document. Note that some items in the table below are partially or fully funded by grants. If a grant continues to be awarded to the City in future years, then there may not be a cost to the General Fund but grant funding is not guaranteed year-over-year. Budget Amendment Item Potential Cost to FY2026 Annual Budget Full Time Employee (FTEs)Notes #1 Item A-1 Attorney’s Office Organizational Structure Change $722,888 3 FTEs: 1 City Prosecutor 1 Senior City Attorney 1 Deputy Director of Administration City Prosecutor $178,278 for 9 months/$237,704 annually Senior City Attorney Class 39 - $157,635.74 for 8 months/$236,454 annually Deputy Director of Administration Class 40 - $186,547 for 9 months or $248,730 annually. At the time of publishing this staff report, the cost to lease office space is unknown. The cost could be more or less than the current budget under the soon to be terminated interlocal agreement with the District Attorney’s Office. #1 Item D-8 $171,910 1 FTE: Capital Asset Planning Financial Analyst IV position Inadvertently left out of the Mayor’s Recommended FY2025 Budget. Position would be dedicated to impact fees compliance tracking and reporting for new state requirements. Impact fees fully reimburse the General Fund for the position’s cost. $2,945,957 grant funding* 4 FTEs: 3 Officer positions 1 Sergeant position *Amount of grant funding needed in order to fully cover the ongoing costs including the new FTEs. #1 Item E-1 Homeless Shelter Cities Mitigation Grant FY25 Costs currently paid for by the Homeless Shelter Cities Mitigation Grant in FY2024 that might be shifting to the General Fund in FY2025 $662,760 For ongoing costs related to 15 existing FTEs; the grant funds a total of 23 FTEs $662,760 is needed for ongoing equipment for all 15 officers. The Administration is checking whether existing budgets could absorb some of these costs. #2 Item A-2 Enhanced Security at Justice Court $200,000 A security report identified an issue needing to be addressed immediately. Budget Amendment Item Potential Cost to FY2026 Annual Budget Full Time Employee (FTEs)Notes #2 Item A-3 Community Oriented Policing Svcs or COPS Hiring Grant from U.S. Dept. of Justice for 2 new Sergeants & 10 new Officers FY 24-25 $1,285,642 in FY2026 For ongoing costs related to hiring 2 new Sergeant FTEs and 10 new Officers in the Police Dept. Ongoing costs include grant salary match plus vehicles, supplies & equipment. After the 48 month grant period ends, the estimated annual cost to retain the 12 police officers is $2,071,325. #2 Item A-4 Vehicles, Equip- ment & Related Police Officer costs not covered by the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation Grant FY24-25 $498,692 is ongoing For ongoing costs related to the hiring of new officers Ongoing costs include ongoing salary increases, supplies, body cameras, vehicles, and computers. #1 & #2 D-7 Prosecutor’s Office Changes since Budget Amendment #1 (-$280,279) back to General Fund Balance 1 FTE Removed City Prosecutor FTE removed Reverses a portion of budgetary impacts & actions outlined in BAM#1, Item A-1. TOTAL $6,207,570 38 total FTEs of which 15 are New FTEs Note that of the total cost, $4.1 million would be needed if the Homeless Shelter Cities State Mitigation grant is not available for FY2026 Page | 1 INFORMATIONAL MEMO CITY COUNCIL and REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD of SALT LAKE CITY December 3, 2024 At the request of several Council Members, the Chair has scheduled a discussion on a proposal for a change in leadership structure for the City Council and Redevelopment Agency Board. The proposal would alter the overall leadership structure of the Council/Board, with one Chairperson, and two vice-chairpersons. One of the vice-chairpersons would assist the Chair in their duties with City Council agenda setting and related matters, and the other vice-chairperson would assist the Chair in their duties with RDA agenda setting and related matters. There is no legal requirement for the RDA Board to elect separate persons to serve as RDA Chair/Vice Chair than the Council Chair/Vice Chair, although it has historically been the City’s practice for those to be four different people. Under the proposal, there would be three leadership positions. If the Council is interested in this concept, staff can request the Attorney’s office prepare two resolutions – one that would amend the Bylaws of the Board of the Redevelopment Agency of Salt Lake City, and one that would amend the Council Rules of Procedure. The Board and Council would need to act on both during RDA and Council Meeting on December 10 in order for changes to be effective in time for the first meeting in January, when those positions are selected. If a majority of the Council/Board approve these resolutions, the Council/Board may also wish to consider how this may affect the proposed ordinance adding leadership stipends, which is also slated for consideration on December 10th. By way of reminder, the current draft ordinance sets leadership stipends as follows: Council Chair: $3,000 Council Vice Chair: $2,000 Redevelopment Agency Chair: $1,500 Redevelopment Agency Vice Chair: $1,000 The Council may also wish to discuss some of the logistical implications of this type of change, such as: Who would attend Chair and Vice Chair meetings and how frequently? If three Council Members are in leadership, would meetings be scheduled with all three? How would RDA staff be involved in Chair and Vice Chair meetings? Who would Chair the RDA Meetings? How would City and RDA policy issues be decided? Who would be the official spokesperson for the RDA? How would seniority among Council Members and leadership be handled? 1 A.38 COUNCIL OFFICE TRAVEL, TRAINING, AND CAPACITY BUILDING (11/2024) “Government is a trust, and the officers of the government are trustees; and both the trust and the trustees are created for the benefit of the people.” -Henry Clay, Speech at Ashland, Kentucky, March 1829 The Council Office follows the City’s travel policy found in Title 53, Chapter 23 of the Salt Lake City Policies and Procedures Manual (City Policy). The following policy is specific to the Council Office and Council Members. City Policy is referenced in multiple places throughout this policy. Any updates to the City Policy affecting excerpts quoted here will be incorporated accordingly. Unless otherwise specified here, City Policy applies. This policy supersedes the City policy in cases where the policies may differ. This policy is subject to revision over time. 1. Policy Basis for the City Council’s Travel, Training and Capacity Building Approach: The City Council finds that a well-informed City Council is important to the success of Salt Lake City, and that high quality and readily accessible learning opportunities are essential, due to the complex and significant decisions Council Members face. The Council further finds that participating in local educational and networking opportunities, traveling to conventions where there is an opportunity to hear from and converse with experts and meet peers from other cities, making site visits to see programs being implemented, and participating in national learning opportunities both in person and via the internet are the most efficient ways for Council Members to obtain and expand their store of City-related knowledge. The Council bases its conclusions on the following: i. The Legislative Branch of Salt Lake City government has formal legal responsibilities to the organization of Salt Lake City and directly to the taxpayers. ii. City Council Members are elected from the general population and come to the position with differing sets of expertise that can most effectively benefit the City taxpayers if Council Members have the opportunity to apply their personal knowledge and philosophies to the context of local government. iii. Council Members must make important decisions starting their first week and intensifying within their first six months in office. They could be faced with bonding, zoning, budgeting, policy and oversight decisions within hours of taking office. The State Legislature begins voting on issues that can significantly affect the City approximately two weeks after new Council Members are sworn in. The Council will evaluate, refine and adopt a City budget in the range of $2 billion within the first six months of being office. iv. Local office may be a Council Member's first direct association with a governmental entity. Government service has different transparency, ethical, fiscal and legal obligations from those in the private sector. Council Members must gain and retain a strong working knowledge of those requirements throughout their term in office. v. As the Capital City of Utah and as a business, medical, innovation and educational hub in the Intermountain West, Salt Lake City faces unique opportunities and challenges. vi. Constituents, property owners and business operators rely upon elected officials to be current with best practices and innovative approaches to problem solving. vii. It is more cost-effective to learn from the successes and failures of other cities than to reinvent the wheel. Learning from those with experience increases the odds of successful implementation for Salt Lake City. 2 viii. Just as ‘a picture is worth a thousand words,’ personally observing how a program operates in another City is a valuable learning experience; it allows one to consider how the situation is the same or different than Salt Lake City, and helps identify potential improvements and avoid potential pitfalls. Direct discussions with on-site experts can provide first-hand background information and advice. Travel outside of the City is a cost to taxpayers, and merits close scrutiny by the public. By adoption of this policy, the Council has established accountability standards that tie the expenditure of taxpayer funds to achieving the public purpose the travel is intended to meet. 2.Purpose: City Policy Ch.23 2.4, “Travel will be approved only to transact official business, attend official and professional meetings, and participate in conferences and training sessions necessary to promote the efficient conduct of the City’s affairs.” It is the Salt Lake City Council’s policy that the conferences and meetings it funds: i. Are consistent with legal requirements and Salt Lake City’s missions, objectives, and policies; ii. Represent an efficient and effective use of taxpayer funds; and be able to withstand public scrutiny. Participants in travel funded by City taxpayers must conduct business, including conferences and meetings, consistent with these tenets. Meeting attendance shall be for the purpose of education, information and the exchange of experiences in municipal operations. Council Members traveling to other cities and attending conferences is a benefit to taxpayers, and lessons learned will result in better development and services for residents. 3.Ethics Statement: That public office is a public trust has long been a guiding principle of government. To uphold this trust, the City Council has bound itself to abide by certain standards of conduct. Council Members should: i. Conduct themselves at all times in a manner that reflects creditably on the Council; ii. Abide by the spirit as well as the letter of the City and Council policies; iii. Adhere to the ethical standards expressed here and in the Council’s code of conduct; iv. Adhere to the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act (OPMA) by avoiding policy, budget and issue conversations in contexts that should legally be conducted in Salt Lake City in an open and public meeting. Council Members have a duty to carefully balance the opportunity to learn from other cities with the duty to not hold any discussion in which a majority of the Council Members are present. 4. Definitions. For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply unless the context clearly indicates or requires a different meaning. Definitions set forth in the Salt Lake Policies and Procedures manual also apply here. i. ABBREVIATED TRAVEL. Attendance at a conference or convention where the registrant will not attend all the days offered and must depart early or arrive late. ii. ELIGIBLE EXPENSE. An expense for which the City may provide reimbursement, or a Council Member may use a City travel credit card, as outlined here and in Salt Lake City Policies and Procedures Title 53, Chapter 23, Section 5. 3 iii. ENTERTAINMENT. Excepting entertainment included in the base registration for an event, includes, but is not limited to, shows, amusements, theaters, circuses, sporting events, or any other place of public or private entertainment or amusement. iv. GRATUITY/TIP. Voluntary payment in excess of baseline charge for meals, services or transportation. v. GUEST. A personal companion or relative who is not eligible for taxpayer-funded travel. vi. INCIDENTAL EXPENSES. Include fees and gratuities paid to hospitality workers, baggage handlers, and others. vii. OPEN AND PUBLIC MEETINGS ACT (OPMA). State law Title 52 Chapter 4, governing transparency and noticing requirements for meetings of public bodies. viii. PER DIEM. Meaning “per day,” per diem is provided to travelers as an allowance for meals and incidental expenses and calculated according to federal standards. ix. PUBLIC BUSINESS. A public purpose which is required or useful for the benefit of the city to carry out the responsibilities of city business. x. REASONABLE COST. City Policy Ch. 23 3.12: “Least costly means of accomplishing business objectives, considering the nature and purpose of travel, the value of the traveling employee’s time, and the reputation of the City.” xi. TRAVEL. Any expenditure directly incident to official travel by employees and officers of the city or by wards or charges of the city involving reimbursement to travelers or direct payment to private agencies providing transportation or related services. xii. TRAVEL EXPENSE APPROVING OFFICIAL/AUTHORITY: The City Council Executive Director is the travel expense approving official for City Council staff members who are traveling on City business. The City Council Chair and Vice Chair and, if requested, the full City Council, will serve as the travel expense approving authority for City Council Members who are traveling on City business. xiii. TRAVELER. Any Council or staff member traveling on behalf of the City, using taxpayer funding. 5.Policy: Council Members may travel to conferences and conventions related to City business. When traveling, Council Members are expected to extract maximum value from the conference/trip and will attend as many sessions/tours as practicable, with an eye towards attendance at sessions that directly relate to issues facing Salt Lake City. Council Members represent the City at all times and shall adhere to the code of conduct. i. All travelers must adhere to federal, state, and local laws governing taxpayer-funded travel. ii. City Policy Ch. 23 4.1G: “Any Traveler accepting complimentary trips shall comply with the City’s conflict of interest ordinance.” iii. City Policy Ch. 23 Ch.23 4.2: “A. All employees responsible for traveling decisions and approving travel requests shall make fiscally responsible choices. B. Approving Officials shall exercise due diligence to ensure that expenses associated with travel are reasonable and necessary for the conduct of City business and are within budgetary limits and in compliance with this Policy. C. All travel requests must be screened to limit trips, the number of individuals traveling, places to be visited, itineraries, and durations to those that are essential to the performance of the Department mission. 4 D. Authorization for travel is limited to and shall only be approved for conferences, trainings, conventions, and other functions from which the City derives a specific benefit through attendance by the Traveler. As reasonably and operationally practicable, Travelers and Approving Officials shall consider other means of participation for training-related and other functions such as webinars or conference calls in lieu of traveling. E. Any expenses submitted for reimbursement may be reviewed and rejected by the Finance Department for noncompliance of this Policy. All decisions are final.” xiv. Open and Public Meetings Act (OPMA) Considerations: Council Members’ City- sponsored travel often falls within two broad categories: large, national conferences with attendance ranging from hundreds to thousands, and smaller conventions and fact- finding trips with a few dozen attendees. i. Large professional conferences are widely recognized as allowed under OPMA, because: 1. Council Members are participating with a large group of elected officials from throughout the country, state or region. The conversation is not Salt Lake City specific; 2. It is not likely that a majority of the Salt Lake City Council Members would attend the same workshop, since multiple options are offered at the same time; 3. There is generally no interaction that could be considered lobbying or advocacy from any entity or individuals, particularly any entity or individuals who have been or will be before the City Council with a request for action; and 4. Council Members select sessions to attend from among a variety of sessions. There is no expectation from sponsors for the Council Members to attend a particular session or event. ii. For smaller conferences, the Council has identified criteria to preserve compliance with OPMA and facilitate their attendance at the function in a way that is open and transparent. Council staff can communicate with organizers and hosts to request accommodation for these criteria. Council Members can reasonably attend events that: 1. Are open to participation for a wide range of people, rather than limited to a list of invited participants, either officially or as a result of limited focus and exposure/availability of information about the conference; 2. Are priced within the range of professional conferences, so that the attendance is not prohibitive for all but limited segments of the population to attend; 3. Are publicly announced at least four months in advance, to allow interested parties to make arrangements to attend; 4. Allow news media attendance; and 5. Make outreach efforts to include historically disadvantaged representatives in the travel. iii. Occasions where the Council should seek guidance from legal counsel include invitations from organizations or hosts/sponsors that: 1. have had a request for action before the City Council in the past year 5 2. reasonably expect to have a request for action before the City Council in the next one to two years 3. have representatives in attendance at the function who will participate in the conference and interact with elected officials 4. have an expectation that the Council will engage in conversations that relate directly to City business at the function, outside of an open and public meeting 5. have an expectation that they will have time and communication opportunities with the City Council Members beyond the time that they would have if they were not sponsoring the trip 6. provide one or more informational or educational sessions that align with the position of the sponsors or host and do not include information or education opportunities that provide opposing points of view or pros and cons relating to the subject. v. National Travel: Pre-authorized conventions are: National League of Cities (NLC) – Congressional City Conference; Washington, D.C. National League of Cities – City Summit; Location rotates Utah League of Cities and Towns (ULCT), Mid-Year Conference; St. George Downtown Alliance – Urban Exploration American Planning Association (APA) Annual Conference Mpact Transit + Community Annual Conference i. Any and all Council Members may attend the ULCT conference in St. George and the NLC conference in Washington, D.C. ii. The remaining conferences are limited to three Council Members per trip. This minimizes transparency and open meetings concerns. If more than three wish to attend the same conference, Council Members who have attended fewer conferences in a calendar year or have attended the conference in question least recently shall be given priority to attend the conference. iii. When a Council Member expresses interest in traveling to a conference, convention or seminar, beyond the pre-authorized opportunities, Council staff will prepare information for the briefing session, and a motion for the Formal Meeting, to be considered under “New Business.” iv.If a Council Member has scheduling limitations that preclude them from being in the convention city for the full conference, they are encouraged to weigh the benefits that can be experienced during an abbreviated trip, and travel only if they determine that the taxpayers will still receive value for the investment of the travel funds. The Chair may determine that an abbreviated trip is acceptable if a Council Member is asked to represent Salt Lake City to accept an award when others are not available to represent Salt Lake City. vi. International Travel. International travel is not typically part of the Council's travel, training and capacity-building program. Rare exceptions may be made by the Council, after a public discussion reviewing the benefits of the travel to the City taxpayers. Travel limitations outlined elsewhere in this policy may be waived by the Council when evaluating the benefit to the taxpayers in the case of participation with a board. No international trips are preapproved. Rare occasions where it is appropriate for Council Members to travel internationally in the performance of their duties include, but are not limited to, the list below. If such an occasion arises, Council Members may each be 6 permitted one international trip per elected term. Staff typically does not accompany Council Members on international trips; exceptions may be determined by the Council Staff Executive Director. Sister City Delegations Olympic Host City duties State-sponsored trips vii. Staff: Since the Council is committed to a well-trained professional staff, the Council budgets for one conference approximately every year per professional staff person within existing budgetary constraints, as work schedules allow and with approval of the Executive Director. Special circumstances for professional required education and travel specific to job assignment and Council Member support needs will be considered by the Director. 6.Council Member Travel Expenses i. City Policy Ch. 23 4.2A: “All employees responsible for traveling decisions and approving travel requests shall make fiscally responsible choices.” ii. City Council Members sometimes represent Salt Lake City Corporation, and therefore the City taxpayers, on boards established by the State of Utah or other organizations. To keep the public records abundantly clear that the Council Member represents the interests of the City taxpayers in their service on the board, the Council Member shall not travel at the expense of the State or other organization to which the Board relates. iii. Upon consent of the Council majority, Members may travel to conferences, conventions or seminars at the expense of the Council Office. iv. When traveling on City-related business, the office coordinates and directly pays for registration, flights and hotel arrangements, and advances funds for Meals and Incidental Expenses (M&IE), following federal standards for Per Diem rates. Any other eligible expenses such as transportation may be paid using a City travel credit card, with receipts retained and provided to the Council Office upon the conclusion of the trip. i. Staff will follow the Americans with Disabilities Act and arrange accommodations consistent with formal documentation provided to the City. ii. Gratuities and Incidentals. Guidelines on reimbursable gratuities are below: 1. ADA Assistance: A gratuity paid based upon assistance or an accommodation necessitated by a documented disabling condition is reimbursable. (Airport wheelchair assistance, handling of a wheelchair or other assistive device, etc.) 2. Meals: Tips/gratuities for meals are included in the Federal calculation of the meal expense, so travelers will not be reimbursed for those expenses. 3. Transportation (Taxi, Van, Ride-Hail, Rideshare): Travelers may be reimbursed for a tip/gratuity of up to 20 percent paid to the transportation provider. Tip amounts beyond 20 percent are considered a personal expense and are not reimbursed. a. Additional charges or gratuity for multiple passengers: i. A gratuity or incremental charge for personal guests or transportation with peers while not on official City business is a personal expense and is not reimbursed. ii. A gratuity or incremental charge paid so that others from the City or related organizations can share a ride is reimbursable, so long as the ride destination is specifically tied to a City public purpose. (Airport to and from the hotel, traveling together to a conference on-site seminar or tour, etc.) 7 7. Courtesy Transportation: Tips for courtesy transportation services are reimbursable (hotel shuttle). 8. Hotel Staff: Tips to hotel staff are not reimbursable because the Federal Government includes incidentals in the per diem calculation. (Incidentals are defined as tips/gratuities, hotel business center coping/scanner/printer/ fax charges, baggage services, laundry, etc.) 9. Use of the business center for projects on behalf of the City is reimbursable, and a gratuity for expedited service or assistance would be reimbursable. 10. Package, Shipping Receipt, Mail Service: travelers may need to pick up something that has been shipped to the hotel for official City business. A gratuity is typically paid to the mail room and is reimbursable. 11. Concierge Services: a. A gratuity for advice on a restaurant, entertainment, or direction is a discretionary personal expense that is not reimbursable. b. A gratuity to a concierge whose assistance is urgently needed to achieve a City public purpose may be reimbursable and can be considered for reimbursement on a case-by-case. Examples may include finding a location for experts and a group of City representatives to converse or contacting delivery services to arrange for a last-minute delivery of City materials. Council Members can rely upon Council staff, rather than a concierge, for most situations of this nature. i. City Policy Ch. 23 Section 5 excerpts: “Meals via Per Diem & Cash Advance: A. All meal and incidental expenses will be provided on a per diem basis in the event of overnight travel. Per diem rates are established by the GSA for federal travel conducted in the CONUS and internationally. i. For the first or last day of travel, a Traveler is limited to 75% of the applicable per diem rate for meals and incidental expenses. However, if the Traveler leaves before 9:00 am or the Traveler returns after 6:00 pm on the first or last day, the Traveler is eligible for 100% of per diem for those days. … … E. Personal meals must not to be purchased on a City credit card. … … I. The Traveler shall return the per diem cash advance within ten days after the travel is cancelled or changed. The Traveler must submit a cash receipt showing proof of payment. When cash is not returned immediately, the City may deduct the amount of the per diem cash advance from the Traveler’s wages. J. The Traveler is responsible for any cash per diem that is lost or stolen.” ii. Many factors may affect whether travelers will be available for group mealtimes that are included as part of conference registration or hotel registration. The Council therefore finds that it is cost-effective to provide the full per diem to travelers and not attempt to adjust the dollar amount both before and after the 8 fact based on other provided meals. The time to administer that process exceeds any potential savings to the taxpayers. v. Group Meals: As a gesture of goodwill toward officials from other cities, Council Members may find it appropriate to organize a meal for collaboration. In these cases, the City would pay for the meal and gratuity for all in attendance. 1. A City traveler can pay for the group meal, within the following parameters: a. No liquor can be paid for by the City. Participants can ask for a separate beer and liquor bill and pay the cost personally. b. Occasionally, public officials travel with a guest. If the dinner or lunch is held during a time that would otherwise be free from conference activities, officials are significantly more likely to make themselves available to attend if their guest can join them. It is in the City’s interest to facilitate conversations among officials; therefore, it is also in the City’s interest to cover the dinner costs for the guest. It should be noted that it is rare for the City to cover a cost for a guest; dinner with other officials is an exception. c. Avoid exclusive or high-end specialty venues that could be considered excessive by constituents. As a rule of thumb, a formal restaurant with a quiet group seating area is justified; a grandiose, opulent, or extravagant restaurant or restaurant fare would not be acceptable for the use of taxpayer funds. d. As the meal for city travelers is covered by the daily per diem, the traveler is required to return the amount designated by the formula for the meal. This can be accomplished with the staff when the travel is settled. e. The individual who pays for the meal may use a City Travel Card or may request reimbursement. They shall provide the Council Office with the itemized receipt, a list of all attendees; and a note identifying the public purpose of the function. f. City travelers having a meal together without the above justification of networking benefits with other parties are best protected from criticism if each pays their own meal cost. Although more convenient, charging a group meal to the City and returning the portion of the per diem allocated for that meal may inadvertently result in a City traveler receiving more funding than is permitted. vi. City Policy Ch. 23 5.5 B-C B. “Trips that bundle lodging, meal, and other travel costs are not allowable under this Policy unless approved by the Finance Department upon demonstration by the Traveler that the cost of the bundled trip does not exceed the component costs of the trip as allowed under this Policy. In cases where breakfast is included in the room price, it shall be stated in the per diem worksheet. C. Non-mandatory hotel related fees for bundled services (such as resort fees or health club fees) are not City-approved costs unless at least one of the bundled services related to the fee is essential for conducting City business. Mandatory hotel related fees will be reimbursed with submission of itemized receipt.” vii. Transportation: 9 12. City Policy Ch. 23 2.5: “The Traveler must secure the most reasonable means of travel to balance cost, travel time and work requirements” 13. When considering transportation, the Council Office is to choose and/or reimburse for the fastest practical option for the nature and purpose of the official business, and shall not book a flight without approval by the Council Member. Council Members are encouraged to respond promptly to options provided by the staff to preserve the opportunity to get reasonable fare. Other staff considerations for booking should include: a. Total cost (actual transportation costs, per diem costs, overtime expenses, and lost time from work) b. Number of stops and length of layovers 14. Travelers who do not travel by the transport identified by the Council Office are responsible for any additional expenses. 15. The City will only cover the cost of essential expenses for official City business. 16. Travelers are responsible for the travel expenses over the reimbursement limits, such as personal delays, circuitous routes, luxury lodgings, or services unnecessary or unjustified in the performance of official business. 17. Travelers who travel by an indirect route or interrupt a direct route for personal convenience may only receive reimbursement equivalent to the cost of traveling by the direct, uninterrupted route and must personally pay for any additional expenses. 18. In general, City travelers must fly coach class at government expense on both local and international official travel. Employees may upgrade to first class or business class at personal expense, including by using their frequent flyer miles. 19.City Policy Ch. 23 5.1 D: “Lodging must be evaluated to minimize unnecessary travel at the destination and to reduce the impacts of the lodging itself.” 20.The Council Office follows City policy on allowable taxpayer-funded travel, including (but not limited to) prohibitions on paying for first class, extra bags, or any additional upgrades or convenience fees. 21. Group Transportation: Occasionally City travelers find it more convenient for one person to cover the cost of the group’s transportation to a venue. This can be accommodated if the City travelers provide documentation when they return to Salt Lake City. a. City Policy Ch. 23 5.1 C: “Carpooling, public transit, or shuttle buses must be considered for all group travel. Travelers are strongly encouraged to choose the lowest cost for ground transportation taking into consideration reasonable travel time and other related cost factors such as parking. b. Staff will determine whether the particular transportation expense was anticipated and included in each traveler’s advance, or was an expense eligible for City Credit card use or reimbursement. c. For transportation costs estimated and provided to the City traveler in advance, a corresponding reduction will be applied for those who received the advance but did not incur the expense when the travel settlement is calculated. 10 d. For transportation costs not advanced to travelers, a City traveler who paid the expense personally will be reimbursed once a receipt and list of passengers is submitted and reviewed for public benefit. e. For transportation expenses paid by a City traveler on the City travel card, the City traveler is responsible for providing the receipt and list of passengers when the travel concludes. f. The City can not cover the transportation cost of personal guests. g. The City can only cover the cost of transporting travelers to official functions. Transportation to social or entertainment functions is a personal expense. A dinner hosted by the Utah League of Cities and towns for representatives of all Cities qualifies as an official function. Transportation with a group of convention participants, or with friends, to an informal evening out is a personal expense and does not qualify for City reimbursement. h. As noted elsewhere in this policy, a gratuity of up to 20 percent may be paid by the City for transportation services. 1. Air Transportation: City Policy Ch. 23 5.4 excerpts “A.i Air travel must be by commercial airline. Travelers traveling on City business by scheduled air carrier shall use the Salt Lake City International Airport (“SLC Int’l Airport”) as the point of departure and return. … … A.iii The City will pay only the costs for the most direct route necessary to accomplish the purpose of the City travel on the lowest cost flight(s) available. The City will not pay expenses resulting from indirect travel routes or for arriving earlier and leaving later than necessary to conduct official business. Adjustments will be made for any of these types of expenses to ensure that the City is not incurring additional costs. a. The City will not pay extra fees or upgrade costs of any kind. b. Coach or economy class seating is considered the standard class of travel. The City will not cover the cost of First Class. c. Excess baggage charges will not be reimbursed. The City will cover the cost of one checked bag only. d. Early boarding fees or other upgraded convenience fees will not be covered by the City. e. Costs to change or re-book a flight will be borne solely by the Traveler, unless the change in flight is driven by business necessity as documented in a memo signed by the Traveler’s Department Director. Changes made without written preapproval are at the Traveler’s expense.” o Deviations from approved travel expenses: Council Members may request changes to the travel itinerary or cancellation of all travel plans. Any per diem funds advanced to Council Members for travel will be returned to the City if the travel is canceled. City Policy Ch. 23 5.4 A.v: “When a trip is cancelled and the Traveler receives credit for the value of the airfare, the employee should use that credit for future City travel. If a Traveler receives a credit for any travel purchase, they must use the credit for other City related business travel. The credit may not be used for personal use. If an employee leaves City employment the credit must be paid back to the City.” City Policy Ch. 23 4.1.E: “Any additional costs to the Traveler related to traveling in advance or extending the stay beyond the time necessary to attend the 11 approved conference, training, convention, and other function will not be reimbursed or paid by the City. The Traveler must make separate reservations and may not charge such additional cost to the City credit card.” In the event of such additional costs incurred to the City without written preapproval, the Council Member is responsible for paying these charges or reimbursing the City. iv. If a personal emergency or a matter of pressing private business precludes a registered Council Member’s attendance at the conference, delays the Council Member’s arrival in the convention city, or necessitates leaving before originally scheduled, the Council Member should report the situation immediately to the Council Chair and/or Council Executive Director so that steps can be taken to attempt to mitigate the loss of taxpayer funds. When appropriate, especially if funds spent on travel can not be recovered, best efforts shall be made by staff to offer the opportunity to another Council Member or staff before canceling reservations or flights. 1. If a circumstance arises where the City is charged for expenses that are not used by the Council Member due to late arrival or early departure, the expense will be charged to the Council Member. v. In the event of cancelations or travel costs due to a personal emergency or extenuating circumstance not easily addressed using this policy, it will be referred, through the Council Chair to the full Council for resolution. viii. Reimbursement. If a traveler incurs non-eligible expense incidentals on a City travel card, the traveler shall reimburse the Front Office within five business days of returning from travel. i. For City Council Member reimbursement requests or charges by City Council Members to Salt Lake City accounts that are not routine, Council staff will: 1. Identify the relevant sections of the Council policy and the Salt Lake City policies and procedures, and provide that information to the traveler. 2. If further review is requested by the City Council Member, Council staff will inform the Chair and Vice Chair of the request, and seek Guidance of the City Attorney and Finance Director on legal and fiscal requirements. 3. Provide the legal or fiscal requirements or advice received from the City Attorney and Finance Director to the requesting Council Member and the Chair and Vice Chair. 4. If further review is requested by the Council Member, the Council Member should make a written request to the Chair and Vice Chair, detailing their request in the context of the City Council policy, City policy, legal or fiscal requirements, and advice of the City Attorney and/or Finance Director. 5. The requesting Council Member may appeal the decision of the Chair and Vice Chair to the full Council for a determination by majority vote. ix. Guests. Council Members and Council staff may invite guests to join them on official City travel: i. All associated expenses must be paid with personal funds. ii. Council staff should not be involved in making any arrangements for guests. Options to minimize taxpayer resources spent making guest travel arrangements include: 1. Council Members may book their own travel arrangements and receive reimbursement for eligible expenses upon submitting documentation. 2. The Council Office may make the arrangements for the Council Member and provide Council Members with travel registration information so 12 Council Members may personally contact airlines and other vendors to make additional arrangements. iii. Most conferences have a clear policy about guests; many offer separate registration options to allow participation in meals, tours and special events. City attendees should refer to conference materials for guest registration information. iv. Conferences expect all attendees, including guests, to adhere to standards of conduct. This includes respecting the event’s policies, other attendees, and the venue to ensure a respectful and safe environment for all. v. Any misconduct on the part of a guest can reflect poorly on the City and on the hosting traveler. vi. The presence of guests should not detract from the focus on City business. x. Transparency and documentation: i. All travel documents, receipts, conference agendas and other documentation are publicly accessible records. ii. City Policy Ch. 23 5.5 D: “D. Travelers shall submit an itemized receipt as provided at motel/hotel check-out. Booking receipts for lodging are not acceptable forms of documentation.” iii. City Policy Ch. 23 4.1F-J: “F. A Traveler shall document all allowable and authorized travel-related expenditures with itemized (line-item detail) receipts, invoices, or other supporting documentation. If documentation is missing, the Traveler shall write a letter to the Finance Department approved by the Department Director explaining the reason a receipt is not available. The City shall not reimburse Travelers for unauthorized travel expenditures. Any unauthorized travel charges on a City credit card will require immediate reimbursement to the City and will result in an automatic 30-day suspension of all City credit cards held by that Traveler. G. Any Traveler accepting complimentary trips shall comply with the City’s conflict of interest ordinance. H. For group expenditures incurred by one Traveler, the affected Traveler shall submit with the receipts an itemized breakdown of expenses for each Traveler in the group. I. When actual expenditures exceed 10% of the original estimated expenses, the Traveler shall attach a written explanation within five business days after the end of the travel period. J. All international travel must be approved in writing using the international approval form identified in the travel procedures. 7.Accountability: This Travel Policy is in place to provide accountability to Travelers. Non- compliance may affect future travel opportunities. Elected officials are ultimately accountable to the taxpayers. Because choices made by Council Members reflect upon the full Council and Salt Lake City government, the Council may elect to act in accordance with the Council’s Code of Conduct policy should problems arise. Additional remedies include: i. Charging the Council Member for all or a portion of the travel if the public purpose was not met, ii. Taking other action deemed appropriate by a majority of the Council. 13 8.Implementation: this document must be included in the regular orientations for Council Members and Council staff. Council Members entering office shall sign the attached statement affirming that the Council Member read and understood this policy. This policy is in effect regardless of a Council Member’ s execution of the statement. The Council will receive annual training on this Code in conjunction with either open meetings training or the Council’s annual retreat. Council Members are encouraged to indicate which conferences they plan to attend at that training so staff can monitor travel pricing and take advantage of early registration discounts. Draft for Council Discussion Potential Attachment to Travel Policy December 3, 2024 Guideposts for initial staff review of small-scale conference/meeting/travel opportunities in the context of open meetings, conflict of interest, and gift restriction factors: Yes*No Unknown The function is likely to have fewer than 100 participants. The participation of Salt Lake City officials is a key component of the function. The topics relate directly circumstances, opportunities, or possible improvements in Salt Lake City, and may require action by the Salt Lake City Council to achieve. One or more of the sponsoring organizations, or the hosting organization, is likely to have business related to the topics of the conference before the City Council in the coming year. Conference participants are invited to attend a sponsored function with a value that may exceed the $50 State Statute threshold (sports event, theatre performance, elaborate meal, etc.) Meals, functions, events or sessions at the conference are hosted by specific sponsors The sponsors will participate in panel discussions, tours, or as presenters at the conference, meeting or function. The public is not easily able to participate due to cost, distance, limited attendance, etc. A conference jacket, bag or other item that may exceed the $50 State Statute threshold is provided to participants by one or more sponsors Other – TBD by City Council Process for staff, Chair and Vice Chair, or full City Council to evaluate potential concerns: *Yes answers on the chart should be double checked by Council staff with the Executive Director to determine next steps: 1. Review by the Chair and Vice Chair. Council Chair and Vice Chair may elect to refer any travel item to the full Council for review at any step of this process. Council Members may request full review of the issue by the full City Council once the Chair and Vice Chair have gathered full information. The Council staff will be available to assist with steps as requested. 2. Determination by Chair and Vice Chair whether to request legal review of whether the conference format or substance suggests that precautions may be necessary to enable attending Council Members to assure compliance with State Statutes, Salt Lake City Ordinances and Salt Lake City Council policies. 3. The Chair and Vice Chair, in collaboration with the City Attorney, may elect to identify adjustments that could be suggested to conference organizers to address any potential issues related to the legal requirements. After an effort is made to suggest adjustments, the Chair and Vice Chair will report to the full Council. Potential adjustments to address potential issues with open meetings, conflict of interest, and gift restriction factors: The Chair and Vice Chair could consider suggesting that the hosting organization consider the following, or other measures identified as credible by Council Members: a. Include speakers, panelists and conference participants who have who have an advocacy interest that is not directly aligned with the messaging of the conference hosts and sponsors, so that a variety of views are represented and both pros and cons are identified. b. Assure that the sponsorship program is general in nature and is provided to support the hosting community organization, rather than tied to specific meals, functions or materials; assure that the sponsorship program is not tied to accessing the time of City Council or other Salt Lake City decision makers: i. To avoid any appearance that businesses are providing ‘gifts’ to government-related attendees that could conflict with State Statute or City ordinance. ii. To avoid any appearance that the sponsors are given exclusive access to elected officials that is not available to the public, those business or community members with opposing views, or members of the community who cannot afford the expense or take the time to attend. iii. To avoid any perception by businesses, organizations and the public that a conference sponsorship provides an opportunity to influence a majority of the City Council Members informally to benefit private interests. c. Facilitate the production of audio or video recordings of the sessions and make them publicly available on a web site. d. Announce the conference to the public and the news media and allow news media attendance if requested. e. The conference host organization could collaborate with the City Legislative Branch well before the conference agenda is set to give Council Members the opportunity to: i. Know whether topics scheduled for the conference and sponsors of the conference are likely to come before the Council with directly related budget, taxation, zoning or regulatory requests. ii. Understand whether the conference sponsors will participate in panel discussions, speak at sessions, or have a direct interest in tours or functions made available to conference participants. iii. Seek legal advice to identify any potential conflict of interest, open meeting, or gift restriction situations that could be perceived by the public. iv. Suggest adjustments by the Council Members or the conference host to address any potential concerns. v. Determine as a group whether it is most appropriate to send a small group of Council Members, or whether a majority could attend. City Council Announcements December 3, 2024 Feedback needed: CAN staff is updating the policies for the city's Housing Stability programs. While those are being updated, the Administration has suggested allowing a deferment of loan payments for two homeowners due to economic hardship conditions. The deferment would last for 6 months or until the new policy statements can be considered by the Council early next year. Is the Council supportive of allowing deferment in this specific instance? : SALT LAKE CITY CORPORATION SWORN STATEMENT SUPPORTING CLOSURE OF MEETING I, , acted as the presiding member of the Salt Lake Council, which met on in an electronic meeting pursuant to Salt Lake City Proclamation. Appropriate notice was given of the Council's meeting as required by §52-4-202. A quorum of the Council was present at the meeting and voted by at least a two-thirds vote, as detailed in the minutes of the open meeting, to close a portion of the meeting to discuss the following: §52-4-205(l)(a) discussion of the character, professional competence, or physical or mental health of an individual; §52 -4-205(1)(b) strategy sessions to discuss collective bargaining; §52-4-205(l)(c) strategy sessions to discuss pending or reasonably imminent litigation; §52-4-205(l)(d) strategy sessions to discuss the purchase, exchange, or lease of real property, including any form of a water right or water shares, if public discussion of the transaction would: (i) disclose the appraisal or estimated value of the property under consideration; or (ii) prevent the public body from completing the transaction on the best possible terms; §52-4-205(l)(e) strategy sessions to discuss the sale of real property, including any form of a water right or water shares if: (i) public discussion of the transaction would: (A) disclose the appraisal or estimated value of the property under consideration; or (B) prevent the public body from completing the transaction on the best possible terms; (ii) if the public body previously gave public notice that the property would be offered for sale; and (iii) the terms of the sale are publicly disclosed before the public body approves the sale; §52-4-205(1)(f) discussion regarding deployment of security personnel, devices, or systems; and §52-4-205(1)(g) investigative proceedings regarding allegations of criminal misconduct. A Closed Meeting may also be held for Attorney-Client matters that are privileged pursuant to Utah Code §78B-1-137, and for other lawful purposes that satisfy the pertinent requirements of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act. Other, described as follows: The content of the closed portion of the Council meeting was restricted to a discussion of the matter(s) for which the meeting was closed. With regard to the closed meeting, the following was publicly announced and recorded, and entered on the minutes of the open meeting at which the closed meeting was approved: (a) the reason or reasons for holding the closed meeting; (b) the location where the closed meeting will be held; and (c) the vote of each member of the public body either for or against the motion to hold the closed meeting. The recording and any minutes of the closed meeting will include: (a) the date, time, and place of the meeting; (b) the names of members Present and Absent; and (c) the names of all others present except where such disclosure would infringe on the confidentiality necessary to fulfill the original purpose of closing the meeting. Pursuant to §52-4-206(6), a sworn statement is required to close a meeting under §52-4-205(1)(a) or (f), but a record by electronic recording or detailed minutes is not required; and Pursuant to §52-4-206(1), a record by electronic recording and/or detailed written minutes is required for a meeting closed under §52-4-205(1)(b),(c),(d),(e),and (g): A record was not made. A record was made by: Electronic recording Detailed written minutes I hereby swear or affirm under penalty of perjury that the above information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge. Presiding Member Date of Signature Victoria Petro December 3, 2024 Victoria Petro (Dec 5, 2024 15:51 MST) Sworn Statement WS 12-3-2024 Final Audit Report 2024-12-05 Created:2024-12-04 By:STEPHANIE ELLIOTT (STEPHANIE.ELLIOTT@slc.gov) Status:Signed Transaction ID:CBJCHBCAABAA60gRzFllku14VCbNDI5Ae2fcsf2h8xc_ "Sworn Statement WS 12-3-2024" History Document created by STEPHANIE ELLIOTT (STEPHANIE.ELLIOTT@slc.gov) 2024-12-04 - 9:33:02 PM GMT Document emailed to victoria.petro@slc.gov for signature 2024-12-04 - 9:33:48 PM GMT Email viewed by victoria.petro@slc.gov 2024-12-05 - 5:58:21 AM GMT Signer victoria.petro@slc.gov entered name at signing as Victoria Petro 2024-12-05 - 10:50:58 PM GMT Document e-signed by Victoria Petro (victoria.petro@slc.gov) Signature Date: 2024-12-05 - 10:51:00 PM GMT - Time Source: server Agreement completed. 2024-12-05 - 10:51:00 PM GMT