HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/20/2019 - Meeting Minutes
SALT LAKE CITY DEPARTMENT OF AIRPORTS
MINUTES OF ADVISORY BOARD MEETING
February 20, 2019
Members Present: Cyndy Miller, Chair
Wade Bitner
Arlyn Bradshaw
Roger Boyer
Theresa Foxley
Larry Pinnock
Steve Price
Jim Riding
Mayor’s Office: Patrick Leary
City Council Office: James Rogers
Russell Weeks
Department of Airports: Bill Wyatt, Executive Director
John Buckner, Director of Commercial & Administration Services
Brian Butler, Interim Director of Finance
Ed Cherry, Chief Information Officer
LuJean Christensen, Administrative Assistant
Ed Clayson, Director of Maintenance
Candace Deavila, Operations Manager/Airfield
Brady Fredrickson, Director of Planning & Environmental
Pete Higgins, Director of Operations
Mike Rawson, Business Development Manager
Al Stuart, Assistant Director of Operations
Nancy Volmer, Director of Public Relations
Mike Williams, ARP Program Director
Brad Wolfe, Commercial Manager
Cyndy Miller called the meeting to order at 8:02 am.
AGENDA
A. Minutes
The motion was made by Jim Riding and seconded by Larry Pinnock to approve the minutes of
January 16, 2019. All votes were affirmative; motion passed.
Airport Advisory Board Meeting Minutes
20 February 2019
2
Miller stated that Bill Wyatt had been unforeseeably delayed and asked Mike Williams to give
his presentation before the Director’s Report.
B. Airport Redevelopment Program (ARP) Update – Mike Williams, ARP Director,
SLCDA
Mike Williams, Airport Redevelopment Program (ARP) Director, presented an update on the
ARP (presentation on file). Main points included were:
CGMP #4 – Landside and Airside enabling status
CGMP #5 – Terminal/South Concourse West/Gateway status
CGMP #6 – Roadways/Parking Garage/Central Utility Plant status
CGMP #7 – Baggage Handling System status
CGMP #9 – Apron Paving – Taxilane 20/21
CGMP #9A – SCW Apron Paving and Hydrant Fueling status
CGMP #15 – NCP Phase 1 enabling
CGMP #16 – NCP Phase 1
NCP Baggage Handling System Phase 1/Phase 2
NCP Apron Paving/Hydrant Fueling
Project statistics
Near term schedule
Overall Airport Redevelopment Program budget
Job progress photos
James Rogers arrived at 8:10 a.m.
Arlyn Bradshaw arrived at 8:11 a.m.
Bill Wyatt arrived at 8:16 a.m.
Miller expressed her condolences on behalf of the Board for the recent death of a construction
worker on the project. Miller also acknowledged Williams’ extreme emphasis on safety
throughout the project and the cleanliness of the construction site—a major component of a safe
working environment.
Williams explained that the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) is
investigating the incident along with a separate incident which occurred the previous week on the
North Concourse Project (a fall which required hospitalization for a few days). Williams stated
his belief that the final report from OSHA will not identify any wrongdoing by the project for
these unfortunate events. Safety efforts have been redoubled throughout the program and
refresher training has been provided. In addition, safety personnel on all teams (program
management, construction and subcontracting) are now wearing blue vests which say safety on
them for better visibility to site workers.
Airport Advisory Board Meeting Minutes
20 February 2019
3
C. Director’s Report
Bill Wyatt, Executive Director, updated the Airport Advisory Board regarding current events.
Wyatt updated the Board on yesterday’s discussion with the City Council regarding the
operation of Turo. Turo is an app-based peer-to-peer car sharing company which does
not have an agreement with the Airport to operate legally on our property. This new
technology most closely resembles the operation of an off-site rental car company, but
there is no clear classification. We are collaborating with the City Council to restructure
citations from a misdemeanor to an infraction (similar to a parking citation) with a
substantial fine. As with the early days of Uber and Lyft operations, we believe that once
the fines are high enough, Turo will be willing to finalize an agreement. While Turo does
not have a significant amount of business at SLC, disruptive transportation technologies
in general will be an ongoing challenge. Bond investors and the rating agencies have
repeatedly inquired about the impact of these technologies on future revenues and our
ability to repay debt. Although the full impact is not yet known, the Airport is committed
to finding ways to generate revenue from entities which operate on its property. The
Airport will continue its negotiations with Turo and make proposals which comply with
the fair competition requirements of the FAA and are in line with existing tenant
agreements.
Wyatt made introductory remarks regarding the wildlife program update. The FAA has
proposed a regulation which would radically expand the wildlife mitigation
responsibilities of airports and their sponsors within a five mile radius of airport. A recent
bird strike at SLC hit the aircraft cowling while the plane was still over the runway. Had
the engine been hit, the potential for recovery at that location and elevation is low. This
incident lends a sense of urgency to increased mitigation efforts and underscores the
FAA’s belief that airports and their sponsors should do more. Our wildlife team includes
Airport staff and a biologist contracted by the United States Department of Agriculture
(USDA). Not only does this partnership bring added skills and knowledge, but the
USDA holds the permits which authorize lethal mitigation when the capture and
relocation of wildlife is unsuccessful. By contracting with the USDA, we are immunized
from potential civil litigation in the event of a catastrophic bird strike.
Patrick Leary arrived at 8:33 a.m.
D. Wildlife Management Update – Candace Deavila, Wildlife Manager, SLCDA and
Bobby Boswell, Biologist, USDA
Candace Deavila, Wildlife Manager, and Bobby Boswell, Biologist, USDA, presented an Airport
Wildlife Management update to the Board (presentation on file). Main points included were:
Wildlife management team
2018 strike data
Hazardous wildlife attractants on or near airports
FAA identified land practices which are known wildlife attractants
Synergistic effects of surrounding land uses
Existing and pending regulations
Airport Advisory Board Meeting Minutes
20 February 2019
4
Theresa Foxley asked if there are industry benchmarks or targets for bird strikes. Deavila
answered that there are none and added that the average frequency is three to five strikes per
10,000 aircraft operations.
Wyatt emphasized the unique application of this proposed regulation for Salt Lake City, which is
the Airport’s sponsor. The broad authorities (e.g. permits) of airport sponsors would be expected
to support wildlife mitigation efforts and will be complicated to work through.
Roger Boyer commented on the potential for complications with land use proposals and future
development.
Larry Pinnock expressed concern for the impact of this proposed regulation on nearby duck clubs
and asked if a cooperative mitigation effort had been attempted or discussed. Boswell noted that
there have been internal discussions, although an existing ordinance forbids hunting on airport
property. James Rogers added that any proposed modifications to the ordinance would require
presenting to the City Council for further discussion.
Rogers asked if the development of the Northwest Quadrant would help or hinder adherence to
the proposed regulation. Boswell explained that it depends upon what is incorporated into that
development. For example, a retention pond built by Amazon next to their warehouse, and the
increased presence of deer and antelope due to the prison construction, have both created new
challenges for wildlife mitigation.
Wyatt commented to Pinnock that majority of airports, including SLC, have a primarily non-
lethal wildlife management program. In most cases, capture and relocation of wildlife is
effective. Managing the food chain, to the extent possible, is another standard approach. The
proposed regulation increases the requirements for airports without increasing authority, which
speaks to the FAA’s intent for obligating sponsor support.
Rogers asked if the financial impact to the Airport for this regulation was known. Wyatt
answered that it may include additional staff and other resources.
Foxley inquired about the status of the rulemaking process and if airports and industry
associations had commented on the proposed regulation. Al Stuart indicated that the Airport
would be making comments to the FAA and industry associations once the final version of the
proposed rule has been issued. In spite of the noise generated by airports nationwide, the FAA
appears to be committed to moving forward. Wyatt added that the proposed regulation is
national and not aimed at SLC exclusively.
Jim Riding asked if wildlife mitigation is done at the South Valley Regional and Tooele Valley
Airports. Boswell replied that wildlife staff do visit these airports and we now have enough data
collected to create wildlife hazard assessments for these locations.
Wade Bitner questioned whether the timing bird migratory patterns could be used to adjust flight
schedules and reduce the number of strikes. Boswell answered that military installations are
very proactive about this whereas commercial airports are not. We also have an establishment of
resident Canada geese and other species at SLC which no longer migrate. For example, a pelican
Airport Advisory Board Meeting Minutes
20 February 2019
5
was hazed off of the former Wingpointe golf course yesterday, even though pelicans have
typically moved to Mexico this time of year.
Bitner wondered if the Airport would be required to provide wildlife mitigation on other golf
courses throughout the Salt Lake Valley. Boswell explained that a Canada goose conservation
depredation order is already in effect within a three mile radius of all airports, and the state
performs mitigation efforts in other parts of the valley. The FAA’s proposed regulation only
pertains to a five mile radius of the Airport.
Wyatt asked how the Hudson Incident affected wildlife mitigation at airports. Boswell noted that
it caused a drastic intake in the lethal take of Canada geese because they brought down the
aircraft. It also accelerated the management of that species.
Foxley inquired about technological developments within the aircraft manufacturing industry.
Deavila stated that various types of research have looked at strengthening engine fan blades and
aircraft exteriors, using different spectrums of light (because birds see in the ultraviolet
spectrum), and avian radar. Many approaches to wildlife mitigation are necessary because of the
varying species, a changing environment, and species adaptation. Boswell added that many
species of birds are simply not able to get out of the way of an aircraft which is traveling at
speeds of 200 mph or greater.
E. Concession Program RFP Update – John Buckner, Commercial & Administration
Services Director, SLCDA
John Buckner, Commercial & Administration Services Director, and Brad Wolfe, Commercial
Manager, presented an update on the Concession Program RFP to the Board (presentation on
file). Main points included were:
Timeline
Program Goals and Objectives
Companies Selected
Concepts Selected – Local Participation
Concepts Selected – National Participation
ACDBE Goal and Participation
Arlyn Bradshaw left at 9:25 a.m.
Bill encouraged everyone to join us for the food and beverage media announcement in the plaza
area of the new terminal.
Riding asked which side of the security checkpoint these selected food and beverage concessions
would be on. Buckner responded that most are located on the secure side, with a full-service
restaurant, coffee shop and gift shop on the public side.
Cyndy Miller adjourned the meeting at 9:30 a.m.
Airport Advisory Board Meeting Minutes
20 February 2019
6
The next Board meeting will be held on March 20, 2019.
___________________________ ________________________
Cynthia Miller, Chair Date
___________________________ _________________________
Jacqueline M. Biskupski, Mayor Date